Twelve Tables - Knowledge

1371: 1334:, combining strict and rigorous penalties with equally strict and rigorous procedural forms. In most of the surviving quotations from these texts, the original table that held them is not given. Scholars have guessed where surviving fragments belong by comparing them with the few known attributions and records, many of which do not include the original lines, but paraphrases. It cannot be known with any certainty from what survives that the originals ever were organized this way, or even if they ever were organized by subject at all. 731:. They would threaten to leave the city with the consequence that it would grind to a halt, as the plebeians were Rome's labor force. Tradition held that one of the most important concessions won in this class struggle was the establishment of the Twelve Tables, establishing basic procedural rights for all Roman citizens in relation to each other. The drafting of the Twelve Tables may have been fomented by a desire for self-regulation by the patricians, or for other reasons. 1152: 687: 33: 1301: 1267:

modernisation. It is believed that the process of this interlingual translation began at some point during the third or second century BC when the text of the Twelve Tables was no longer understandable in its entirety. As such, though it cannot be determined whether the quoted fragments accurately preserve the original form of Latin, what is present gives some insight into the grammar of

1011:

and mental diseases must be killed by the father himself. If a husband no longer wants to be married to his wife he can remove her from their household and "order her to mind her own affairs" Not all of the codes of table IV are to the benefit of only the patriarch. If a father attempts to sell his son three times then the son earns his freedom from the father.

1221:, which translates as "common law", but is commonly referred to as "civil law" in English-speaking countries. Some countries including South Africa and San Marino still base their current legal system on aspects of jus commune. In addition, law school students throughout the world are still required to study the Twelve Tables as well as other facets of 1443:, vol. 2 (London, 1996). In this new version, Crawford and the team of specialists reconsidered the conventional arrangement of the laws based on Dirksen and his followers. They concluded that this conventional grouping of the rules was wrong and offered their new arrangement. For instance, the laws relating to 1399:, from which many of the provisions of the Twelve Tables came to us. Godefroy believed that Gaius in his work followed the original order of the Twelve Tables. Since Gaius' work was divided into six books, Godefroy assumed that each book covered two tables and that each table focused on a certain matter. 2203:

Oliviero Diliberto, “Umanesimo giuridico-antiquario e palingenesi delle XII Tavole,” in Annali del Dipartimento di Storia del Diritto della Università degli Studi di Palermo 50 (2005): 1–23; Diliberto, “La palingenesi decemvirale,” 481–501; Pierfranceso Arces, “Apuntti per una storia dei tentativi di

946:

These two tables are concerned with the Roman court proceedings. Table I covers proceedings between the defendant and the plaintiff, with responses to potential situations such as when age or illness prevents the defendant from making appearance, then transportation has to be arranged to assist them.

830:

Some of the provisions are procedural to ensure fairness among all Romans in the courts, while other established legal terms dictating the legality of capital crimes, intentional homicide, treason, perjury, judicial corruption, and writing slanderous poems. The Romans valued keeping peace in the city

1322:

in Latin). In the ancient world, the laws inscribed on bronze were often not easy to read but tended to serve a symbolic and religious purpose. It is likely that the law became literary text at some point during the fourth century BC. It was the time when the Roman civil law began to be administered

1266:

Parts of the text of the Twelve Tables were preserved in the brief excerpts and quotations from the original laws in other ancient authors. All Roman sources quote the Twelve Tables in a modernised form of Latin. It is likely that the extant quotations of the text contain a multiplicity of layers of

1010:

The fourth table of the Twelve Tables deals with the specific rights of Patriarchs of families. One of the first proclamations of the Table IV is that "dreadfully deformed" children must be quickly euthanized. It also explains that sons are born into inheritance of their family. Babies with physical

641:

The Twelve Tables are sufficiently comprehensive that their substance has been described as a 'code', although modern scholars consider this characterization exaggerated. The Tables are a sequence of definitions of various private rights and procedures. They generally took for granted such things as

1096:

are laws dealing with litigating wrongs that occur between citizens. One such situation is that of physical injury, retaliation for which can range from dealing the perpetrator an injury in kind, to monetary compensation to the injured. This table also establishes the legal ramifications for damage

1059:

One of the aspects highlighted in the Twelve Tables is a woman's legal status and standing in society. Women were considered to be under a form of guardianship similar to that of minors, and sections on ownership and possession give the impression that women were considered to be akin to a piece of

650:

There is no scholarly agreement about the exact historical account of the creation and promulgation of the laws of the Twelve Tables. Ancient writers' stories about the Twelve Tables were recorded a couple of centuries later, in the second and first centuries BC. The first known publications of the

1274:

Even in the updated form, certain Latin terms used in the Twelve Tables were difficult to understand in the late Roman Republic. For instance, when Cicero reports that Roman commentators did not understand a particular point in the Twelve Tables, we should expect that his example was not unique.

813:

the Twelve Tables were a way to publicly display rights that each citizen had in the public and private sphere. These Twelve Tables displayed what was previously understood in Roman society as the unwritten laws. The public display of the tablets allowed for a more balanced society between the

986:

3. Unless he (the debtor) discharge the debtor unless someone appear in court (in iure) to guarantee payment for him, he (the creditor) shall take with him. He shall bind either with thong or with fetters, of which the weight shall be not less than fifteen pounds or shall be more if he (the

976:

written by an anonymous source due to its origins being collaborated through a series of translations of tablets and ancient references, P.R. Coleman-Norton arranged and translated many of the significant features of debt that the Twelve Tables enacted into law during the 5th century. The

1317:

inscribed on twelve bronze tablets. It is believed that at some later stage the text of the Twelve Tables became a literary text. Some scholars suggest that the text at this time was rewritten and kept as a small ancient book. For instance, Cicero terms the laws ‘a single booklet’

1191:. At this time, there was extreme tension between the privileged class and the common people resulting in the need for some form of social order. While the existing laws had major flaws that were in need of reform, the Twelve Tables eased the civil tension and violence between the 1342:

In Roman historical and legal sources, ancient writers referenced and discussed the laws of the Twelve Tables in numerous fragments. However, during the Early Middle Ages the knowledge of the Twelve Tables was lost. The reconstruction of the text started with the rediscovery of

2204:

palingenesi della legge delle XII Tavole,” Rivista di Diritto Romano 8 (2008): 1–15; and Jean-Lois Ferrary, “Saggio di storia della palingenesi delle Dodici Tavole,” in Le dodici tavole. Dai decemviri agli umanisti, ed. Michel Humbert (Pavia: Iuss Press, 2005), 503–556.

822:

who had little education or experience in understanding law. By revealing the unwritten rules of society to the public, the Twelve Tables provided a means of safeguard for Plebeians allowing them the opportunity to avoid financial exploitation and added balance to the

638:(106–43 BC) that the "Twelve Tables...seems to me, assuredly to surpass the libraries of all the philosophers, both in weight of authority, and in plenitude of utility". Cicero scarcely exaggerated; the Twelve Tables formed the basis of Roman law for a thousand years. 1275:

According to Cicero, the law of the Twelve Tables introduced limits on the expense of the funeral arrangements. One of those rules, Cicero explains, was subject to various interpretations because of the difficulty to understand the archaic Latin term of

1308:

in Crete (around 450 BC). This Greek lawcode was inscribed in twelve columns on the inner face of a circular wall. Scholars observed that its content and focus on the private law offers striking parallels with the Twelve

1019:

The Twelve Tables have three sections that pertain to women as they concern estates and guardianship, ownership and possession, and religion, which give a basic understanding as to the legal rights of women and girls.

994:

5. Unless they (the debtors) make a compromise, they (the debtors) shall be held in bonds for sixty days. During those days they shall be brought to into the comitia (meeting-place) on three successive markets ”

990:

4. If he (the debtor) chooses, he shall live on his own . If he lives not on his own , who shall hold him in bonds, shall give a pound of bread daily; if he (the creditor) shall so desire, he shall give more.

1355: 779:"...every citizen should quietly consider each point, then talk it over with his friends, and, finally, bring forward for public discussion any additions or subtractions which seemed desirable." (cf. Liv. 702:

According to Livy and Dionysius of Halicarnassus, the laws of the Twelve Tables have come about as a result of the long social struggle between patricians and plebeians, in modern scholarship known as the

1249:

claimed that he learned them by heart as a boy in school but that no one did so any longer. Since the early second century BC, Roman Republican scholars wrote commentaries upon the Twelve Tables, such as

1206:

I. Such laws from The Digest that are derived from the Twelve Tables are the legal recompense for damage caused by an animal, protocol for inheritances, and also laws about structural property damage.

1287:

on the occasion of a funeral’. The old interpreters, Sextus Aelius and Lucius Acilius, said they were not sure what this meant, but suspected it was some kind of funeral garment. Lucius Aelius takes

969:

Featured within the Twelve Tables are five rules about how to execute judgments, in terms of debtors and creditors. These rules show how the ancient Romans maintained peace with financial policy.

1217:. The idea of property was also perpetuated in the Twelve Tables, including the different forms of money, land, and slaves. An additional example, the Twelve Tables are tied into the notion of 1327:. It is likely that state administrators would have found it more convenient to consult the law in book form. Therefore, it is likely that the twelve bronze tables would have become obsolete. 1209:

The influence of the Twelve Tables is still evident in the modern day. The Twelve Tables play a significant role in the basis of the early American legal system. Political theorists, such as

1416: 1045:): “Where a woman, who has not been united to a man in marriage, lives with him for an entire year without interruption of three nights, she shall pass into his power as his legal wife.” 1604: 961:

Table II sets the amount of financial stake for each party depending on the source of litigation, what to do in case of impairment of the judge, and rules of who must present evidence.

1283:

After limiting the expense, then, to three veils, a small purple tunic, and ten pipers, the law goes on to do away with lamentation: ‘Women shall not scratch their cheeks or have a

1410:(Leipzig, 1824). Dirksen's work, based on the principles and discoveries of Godefroy, is now considered to be the most authoritative reconstructions of the Twelve Tables. In 1866 4424: 1360: 1482:

Fragmenta XII. Tabularum, suis nunc primum tabulis restituta: probationibus, notis, & indice munita / Iacobo Gothofredo in Parlamento Parisiensi advocato auctore

1403: 695: 793:(secession of the plebes, a plebeian protest) to force the Senate to consider them, the Law of the Twelve Tables was formally promulgated. According to Livy (AUC 668: 1411: 691: 2592: 1078:

People who live near the road are in charge of maintaining it; if a road is not well maintained then carts and animals can be ridden where the riders wish.

1364: 1291:

to be a mournful wailing, as the word itself suggests. I tend to believe this second explanation, since that is the very thing that Solon’s law forbids.

583: 1055:): “Women shall not during a funeral lacerate their faces, or tear their cheeks with their nails; nor shall they utter loud cries bewailing the dead.” 1350: 663: 2479: 3021: 1112:

This section of the tables makes it illegal for anyone to define what a citizen of Rome is with the exception of the greatest assembly, or

657: 675:

provided the most detailed accounts of the creation of the laws. In addition, different versions of the story are known from the works of

3063: 3051: 2006: 3110: 1237:, they gradually became obsolete, eventually being only of historical interest. The original tablets may have been destroyed when the 1097:

dealt to property by animals and damage dealt to crops by people or animals. The penalty for stealing crops is hanging as sacrifice to

760:

cities. Some scholars deny that the Romans imitated the Greeks in this respect or suggest that they visited only the Greek cities of

794: 780: 3026: 1142:): If a slave shall have committed theft or done damage with his master's knowledge, the action for damages is in the slave's name. 642:

the institutions of the family and various rituals for formal transactions. The provisions were often highly specific and diverse.

1031:): “Female heirs should remain under guardianship even when they have attained the age of majority, but exception is made for the 954:

If there is a failure to appear by either party, then after noon the judge must make judgement in favor of the one who is present.

4398: 3036: 4429: 4343: 3031: 2765: 671:

was another early interpreter of the Twelve Tables in the middle of the second century BC. Meanwhile Roman historians Livy and

576: 180: 2449: 977:

translation of the legal features surrounding debt and derived from the known sources of the Twelve Tables are stated as such

727:. In the context of this unequal status, plebeians would take action to secure concessions for themselves using the threat of 556: 4313: 3138: 2665: 1740: 170: 2377:, Edited by Cairns, John W. and Du Plessis, Paul J. Edinburgh studies in law; 3, 85–104. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Pr. 1420:

followed Dirksen's model. The first full English publication of the Dirksen's reconstruction was prepared and translated by

4403: 4278: 3431: 2350:

Nossalità, falsa nossalità e magia: negli illeciti agricoli e pastorali della codificazione decemvirale al primo principato

2984: 1503:

Die XII Tafeln: Geschichte und System des Civil-und Criminal-Rechtes, wie-Processes der XII Tafeln nebst deren Fragmenten

1408:

A Review of the attempts hitherto made at the criticism and restoration of the text of the fragments of the Twelve Tables

1116:

It also outlaws execution of those who are unconvicted, bribery of judges, and extradition of a citizen to enemy powers.

341: 2655: 1839: 163: 146: 4323: 3083: 2650: 2645: 2621: 2472: 2357: 2322: 1977: 1796: 569: 141: 801:(Pomponius (Dig. 1 tit. 2 s2 §4) alone says on ivory), and posted publicly, so all Romans could read and know them. 4338: 3011: 2660: 2587: 158: 1175:. Although legal reform occurred soon after the implementation of the Twelve Tables, these ancient laws provided 2604: 2537: 2415: 1251: 151: 3358: 3283: 3041: 634:. Something of the regard with which later Romans came to view the Twelve Tables is captured in the remark of 1349:

in the Late Middle Ages. The first attempt of the recovery of the laws was made by the French legal historian

723:

were eligible to become magistrates and this, among other plebeian complaints, was a source of discontent for

3854: 1435:

In the last couple of decades, one of the most prominent reconstructions of the law of the Twelve Tables was

3694: 3298: 2750: 2465: 1436: 1214: 999: 611:. Formally promulgated in 449 BC, the Tables consolidated earlier traditions into an enduring set of laws. 1891: 1402:

The most important modern reconstruction of the Twelve Tables was published by the German legal historian

4439: 4393: 4318: 4077: 3133: 3016: 2562: 2439: 1382:

publication of the law of the Twelve Tables in 1616. Godefroy's reconstruction was based on the order of

980:“1. Of debt acknowledged and for matters judged in court (in iure) thirty days shall be allowed by law . 736: 4353: 4017: 3909: 3679: 3451: 3273: 3181: 3046: 2989: 708: 672: 652: 354: 941: 4373: 3466: 3421: 3348: 3268: 3216: 3206: 3158: 2505: 2429: 419: 121: 2384:, Mnemosyne supplements. History and Archaeology of Classical Antiquity, 336. Leiden; Boston: Brill. 661:

included a version of the laws of the Twelve Tables, his commentary on them and the legal formulas (

3974: 3884: 3393: 3373: 3368: 3353: 3306: 3246: 3201: 3003: 1202:

The Twelve Tables also heavily influenced and are referenced in later Roman Laws texts, especially

1196: 1184: 815: 720: 23: 1489:Übersicht der bisherigen Versuche zur Kritik und Herstellung des Textes der. Zwölf-Tafel-Fragmente 983:

2. After that hand shall be laid on (Manus infection) . He shall be brought into court (in ius).

4383: 4363: 4303: 4293: 4283: 3689: 3378: 3278: 3258: 3173: 3163: 2868: 2808: 2788: 2500: 2241:

Uebersicht der bisherigen Versuche zur Kritik und Hestellung des Textes der Zwölf-Tafel-Fragmente

1168: 1084:

Fruit that falls from a tree onto a neighbor's property still belongs to the original tree owner.

630:. The law had previously been unwritten and exclusively interpreted by upper-class priests, the 457: 2018: 1811:

McCarty, Nick "Rome The Greatest Empire of the Ancient World", The Rosen Publishing Group, 2008

1572:

Crawford, M.H. 'Twelve Tables' in Simon Hornblower, Antony Spawforth, and Esther Eidinow (eds.)

1068:

This table outlines the attitudes towards property. The following are all rules about property:

4388: 4378: 4328: 4308: 4122: 4097: 4062: 3944: 3669: 3316: 3078: 2609: 2368:

The Beginnings of Rome: Italy and Rome from the Bronze Age to the Punic Wars (c. 1000–264 B.C.)

1429: 1255: 1233:

The Twelve Tables are no longer extant: although they remained an important source through the

740:(decemvirate, board of "Ten Men") were appointed to draw up the first ten tables. According to 704: 4358: 4288: 4112: 3864: 3664: 3659: 3456: 3363: 3288: 3251: 3236: 3211: 3191: 3093: 1242: 1132:): A person of a certain class shall not partake in marriage with a person of a lower class. 753: 1911: 1370: 998:

The five mandates of the Twelve Tables encompassing debt created a new understanding within

4444: 4368: 4333: 4022: 3889: 3789: 3714: 3579: 3542: 2918: 2582: 1345: 99: 4012: 1939:. 1st ed., University of California Press, 2005, www.jstor.org/stable/10.1525/j.ctt1ppxrv. 831:

and the Twelve Tables were a mechanism of establishing and continuing peace and equality.

8: 4298: 4147: 3949: 3819: 3769: 3088: 2685: 1002:

that ensured financial exploitation would be limited within legal business transactions.

234: 1519:, septiéme édition par un groupe de romanistes, Paris and Naples: Jovene Editore, 25-73. 4434: 4348: 4072: 3879: 3734: 3674: 3594: 3537: 3401: 2637: 2616: 1586: 1395: 1203: 492: 131: 3987: 2116:, first published 1998, reissued 2008, Oxford, New York: Oxford University Press, 146. 1060:

real estate or property due to the use of terms such as "ownership" and "possession".

3982: 3834: 3589: 3549: 3527: 2735: 2353: 2318: 2014: 1973: 1845: 1835: 1792: 1736: 1324: 1176: 1098: 1081:

Property owners can request removal of trees that have been blown onto their property

411: 404: 207: 2434: 4047: 4007: 3939: 3874: 3799: 3794: 3566: 3489: 3436: 3231: 3226: 3115: 2974: 2923: 2883: 2853: 2848: 2843: 2833: 2755: 2702: 2695: 2680: 2675: 2599: 2527: 1994:

The Ancient City a Study on the Religion, Laws, and Institutions of Greece and Rome

1658:, eds. John W. Cairns and Paul du Plessis, Edinburgh: Edinburgh Studies in Law, 88. 1421: 1379: 1331: 942:

Tables I & II: Procedure for Courts and Judges and Further Enactments on Trials

716: 680: 676: 533: 527: 520: 506: 335: 314: 259: 244: 239: 224: 108: 2164:

Williamson, Callie, 1987, 'Monuments of Bronze: Roman Legal Documents on Bronze',

1773:

Steinberg, S. 'The Twelve Tables and Their Origins: An Eighteenth-Century Debate'

1629:

Steinberg, S. 'The Twelve Tables and Their Origins: An Eighteenth-Century Debate'

4142: 3954: 3934: 3894: 3829: 3779: 3774: 3649: 3599: 3507: 3341: 3321: 3241: 2690: 2515: 2312: 2301: 1163:. The Twelve Tables provided an early understanding of some key concepts such as 789: 728: 249: 2314:

The Early History of Rome: Books I–V of The History of Rome from its Foundations

4197: 3839: 3574: 3522: 3494: 3441: 3426: 3406: 3221: 3196: 3153: 3143: 2969: 2943: 2873: 2858: 2823: 2783: 2544: 1383: 1234: 818:

who were educated and understood the laws of legal transactions, and the Roman

712: 600: 538: 485: 329: 304: 213: 61: 1155:

Roman civilians examining the Twelve Tables after they were first implemented.

4418: 3729: 3699: 3614: 3148: 3125: 2938: 2793: 2778: 2532: 1849: 1531:

Das Zwölftafelgesetz. Leges XII tabularum. Wissenschaftliche Buchgesellschaft

1313:

According to ancient authors initially the Twelve Tables were recorded as an

1210: 1032: 824: 761: 619: 615: 434: 284: 52: 2142:, Berkeley and Los Angeles, London: University of California Press, 227–228. 2086:, Berkeley and Los Angeles, London: University of California Press, 227–228. 1378:

The fundamental work of the reconstruction of the Twelve Tables appeared in

787:

In 449 BC, the second decemvirate completed the last two codes, and after a

4207: 4067: 3512: 3461: 3416: 3411: 3263: 3073: 2959: 2903: 2898: 2670: 2554: 2488: 2129:, Berkeley and Los Angeles, London: University of California Press, 202–203 1359:(1515). His work was followed by more publications on the Twelve Tables by 1180: 1075:

Road widths are eight feet wide on straight parts and double that on turns.

771:

The first decemvirate completed the first ten codes in 450 BC. Here is how

741: 347: 299: 269: 195: 70: 2273:, No.329 edition, Loeb Classical Library, London & Cambridge, 424-515. 1951: 1151: 4002: 3624: 3446: 3336: 2730: 2401:

Westbrook, Raymond. 1988. "The Nature and Origins of the Twelve Tables."

2373:

Harries, Jill. 2007. "Roman Law Codes and the Roman Legal Tradition". In

1654:

Harries, Jill, 2007, “Roman Law Codes and the Roman Legal Tradition,” in

1305: 1218: 390: 2194:, Berkeley and Los Angeles, London: University of California Press, 228. 2192: