Knowledge:Requests for arbitration/Macedonia 2

1559:

serve no use (for example it serves no use to ask Palestinians about Israel's right of existence or to ask Chinese about Tibet independence and so on, there are many national POVs out there) While assuming good faith in Knowledge is a good policy, assuming that national editors will excuse themselves automatically from debates where their POV would influence the result is ludicrous and will only encourage same national(ist) editors to watch over "their" national pages like eagles (again I don't accuse anybody of bad faith, the problem here is POV, national POV at that) I only hope that we can find some way of removing or reducing this kind of POV and have a procedure for deciding this kind of sensible national items, maybe in case of doubt by enforcing the standard used in the rest of the articles or having a more balanced straw-poll that involves more 3rd party nationals, that's all. Now, people will complain about national profiling, I think I made a clear case why the national POV can be a problem in Knowledge, I don't ask for excluding people based on their nationality, I ask for bringing more 3rd party people or using solutions from other articles, or finding different ways to decide content in the case there's suspicion that national POV plays an important role in the debate as it is pretty clear from the simple common sense analysis of the issue. If you can't make this kind of sweeping decision maybe you should decide in this specific naming matter and put it to sleep in a merciful manner, cause otherwise the edit wars and debates will continue endlessly.

2388:

administrators' conducts regarding the issue - Húsönd's ethnic filling and ChrisO's unilateral move of the page - attracted me to take a look at the case. Some say ChrisO and Húsönd's conducts enforced "obvious is obvious, so let's endorse for them to fix it". I have to disagree with this view because of several reasons. First, the dispute in reality is not settled yet, so we have to respect the both side and reflect the current situation without any bias. Second, administrators are supposed to assist editors to resolve disputes, not to inflate them. However see what results have been generated by their conducts; flaring the flame. They mix administrator's roles with their editorial POV and emotions too much. The page move under the protection is not a fair play even considering the fact that he knew the Greek holidays. The pointy and unilateral action based on his firm belief that he is doing right is arguable enough. ChrisO argues that if any administrator move back the title, that would be "wheel war" which can be a ground for de-sysopping. I'm very concerned about his ethics and interpretation of our policies. I feel uneasy that many tend to blame the dispute all to Greek as calling ultra-nationalists. How so? Name accompanies identity matters, so we can not attribute this dispute to just one side. One thing to remind that not every state members of UN recognize Republic of Macedonia, and English is unarguably the current

2067:(now deleted) of the ethnicity of the straw poll participants. Consensus was easily formed at ANI that Greek users had their own walled garden and were creating an obstacle to Knowledge's natural consensus building process. Despite overall agreement, the poll ended, no admin ever closed it, no decision was ever made, and the heated discussion unsurprisingly died out. It is very frustrating to see core values of Knowledge be manipulated by one ethnic group, but even more frustrating to see everybody (expect that ethic group) acknowledge the manipulation and still do nothing about it. On top of that, those who point the obvious fact that the problem lies with one ethnic group still have to bear with the usual accusations of racism and censorship. And then they become "involved" and can take no unilateral actions such as... move an article. Thus, although I do not approve ChrisO's rush, I think that his action attempts to bring rightful attention to a problem that should earn far more disapproval. I am glad that this is finally back at the Arbcom and I do expect that at last we may have some results, and some peace. 5844:

would normally call for individual sanctions, their actions taken together have taken on a collectively disruptive form. The stance of these factions, as represented by a small number of core regular editors and a larger volatile group of occasional supporters, has had the collective effect of permanently blocking regular consensus-seeking mechanisms. Many of these editors have shown a willingness to use Knowledge as a mechanism to pursue their national political interests. The collective net effect of this is to create a bloc whose influence is at times disproportionate to its size and at times has the result of negating Knowledge policies. Knowledge's goal is to create a neutral and factual encyclopedia in a consensus-based environment. Methods used by these factions include: wikilawyering, overt appeals to political considerations, "refusal to get the point", hyperbole, filibustering, assumptions of bad faith, personal attacks, external lobbying, and edit warring. Several outside editors have over time turned away from the dispute exasperated by the immobility of these opinion blocs. Users turning away:

2441:

a point John Carter made about trust. As John Carter so eloquently and diplomatically mentioned the actions of ChrisO damage the trust of established as well as newer editors. Administrators in Knowledge hold a very special place in the community. Their authority is maintained and respected when they excercise their power with measure and discipline and always upholding the policies of the community as well as the trust of the editors. Most admins do this job remarkably well and so even though Knowledge is not a democracy most editors feel as if they are on an equal editorial footing with the administrators because they trust that the administrators will follow due process at all times. In the few instances where administrators undertake to act in a heroic fashion and start using heroic terminology like cutting the Gordian knot, you know instinctively something went wrong. When administrators use their tools as super-powers then Knowledge becomes Smallville, Metropolis or Gotham city. Nice places all but they seem not very suitable models for encyclopedia building. To paraphrase

2461:(italics not mine). As I said before, I know Knowledge is not a democracy but I hope it will not soon become a banana republic either. There are many other issues remaining that I will not address in detail here, such as the use of nationality/ethnicity (or even suspected ethnicity) based statistics to cast a wide pall over a group of editors and other similar anti-intellectual tactics employed by certain admins and which I consider particularly harmful to the project, to logic and to any intellectual pursuit in general. In closing I urge Arbcom to address these points that I raised, as well as many other peripheral issues so capably enunciated by the other participants, for the good of this project. I would also like to take this opportunity to thank Cacharoth for his helpful guidance regarding the background of this controversy and his comments concerning the Easter celebrations. 3423:(WP:DAB), is to resolve "conflicts in Knowledge article titles that occur when a single term can be associated with more than one topic, making that term likely to be the natural title for more than one article." For primary topics, "When there is a well-known primary topic for an ambiguous term, name or phrase ... then that term or phrase should either be used for the title of the article on that topic or redirect to that article." The guideline goes on to state: "If there is extended discussion about which article truly is the primary topic, that may be a sign that there is in fact no primary topic, and that the disambiguation page should be located at the plain title with no "(disambiguation)"." Disambiguation is not a means of promoting, endorsing or rejecting the point of view of any party or parties to a naming or other dispute. 2658:. Would like to suggest here that the opening of the case is delayed until 22nd April, for several reasons: (1) So ArbCom can finish off some other cases that need our attention; (2) To fit in with the original intention to file on 22nd April - mainly, as I understand it, to fit in with the dates of Orthodox Easter; (3) To give those involved time to gather their thoughts; (4) To enable discussion of the case name (request name conflicts with an article of that name), the case scope and who should be the named parties; (5) To enable people to read the megabytes of discussion that has taken place around this topic; (6) For arbitrators and the editors involved at this topic to read the following articles: 2063:: the timing of the move by ChrisO was inadequate. Furthermore, being ChrisO clearly involved in this dispute, he should have refrained from an unilateral move that was guaranteed to produce a very heated outcry. That said, I fully understand the frustration that led to such reaction. The naming issue of the Republic of Macedonia and its application on Knowledge has been a long-lasting dispute, as the Greek POV is fiercely defended by a large group of Greek users that effectively block any consensus from ever occurring. The recent straw poll clearly demonstrated this. Yet, outside attention was only drawn when the straw poll issue was brought to ANI by Greek users, irked by 1423:. I am not sure if my interpretation keeps pace with how ARBCOM itself regards its competence, but I personally tend to see it in the broadest possible sense, because it is a matter of policy application everywhere. If the Committee decides to deal with the naming dispute issue, then it should issue concrete guidelines about how the country should be referred not only in the "Greece" article but throughout the project. Eventually, these guidelines will decide the naming dispute itself. So, directly or indirectly, the ARBCOM will have to deal with the heart of the problem: the naming dispute (and I agree on that with Sept). At least, this is what I believe.-- 1908:)–1) Use the most common English name, and if that isn't available for some reason, 2) Use a self-identification. The policy specifically excludes political, moral, and legal arguments in deciding on a name, but the Greek editors continually cite 1) the political views of Macedonia and Greece, 2) the moral rights of Greece, and 3) the legal name imposed by international organizations as reasons for ignoring Knowledge naming policy. Consensus is impossible when you are talking to a wall. It is my sincere hope that this arbitration will result in a clear and unambiguous interpretation of Knowledge naming policy. ( 3523:("RfC/U") represents a forum in which editors may raise concerns about the conduct of a fellow editor or administrator. Although this procedure can be misused, when utilized in good faith, it presents an editor with the opportunity to learn that concerns exist about his or her conduct, respond to the concerns, and if appropriate adjust his or her conduct. Civility and decorum are especially important in the highly charged atmosphere of a user-conduct RfC. RfCs should not be used abusively, nor should the concerns raised in an RfC be ignored. 1937:

several comments from various parties indicating that it might be an attempt to basically game the system and take advantage of the fact that many or most of the editors from the Greek side would be celebrating the Orthodox Easter before they noticed the change had been made, thus in effect making it a stable page for several days before the Greek editors returned and noticed the move. Several editors have very clearly stated that these actions of ChrisO's undermine their trust in the fairness and effectiveness of the wikipedia.

1380:. I apologize for acting in the way I act before the 22 April, when the Greece article issue was planned to be brought here, but I strongly believe that any delay to bring User:ChrisO's move to your attention would entail irreversible damage to the project (collateral edit-warring already ensued, the title's name may affect many articles where uncontrolled edit-wars most probably will erupt, and a controversial adm action of major importance for many articles cannot remain "on the air" for so many days). Thank you.-- 2531:, I am never surprised when these areas of real world ethnic/political strife come here. As Fut Perf says, this is an area where wiki consensus building regularly fails and we as a community need to find better ways to work with this type of situation. The consensus model regularly fails here because each side, due to long term centuries-old strife in the area/topic, perceives the truth, as they see it, being twisted. Focus should be on admin behavior and conduct of all users, not what the titles should be. 2023:

policy and which we have never tried to impose to anyone. I would challenge anyone to find any of the "Greek nationalists" reverting any article where "Republic of Macedonia" was the established naming. On the contrary, the other side (which mainly comprises of two users who enjoy immunity, ChrisO and Future Perfect at Sunrise) has engaged in extensive edit wars, mass renames and intimidation tactics in order to push their POV and reverse the status quo. Again, diffs will be provided in detail.

3616:

the normal channels (such as a Request for adminship) to regain them. Determining whether an administrator resigned under controversial circumstances is, in most cases, in the discretion of the bureaucrats. However, an administrator who requests desysopping while an arbitration case or a request for arbitration is pending against him or her will be deemed to have left under circumstances of controversy, unless the Arbitration Committee decides otherwise, for purposes of applying this rule.

1419:: I see here that there is a question about what we ask from the arbitrators. As I see things, there are two issues: 1) ChrisO's move which precipitated the filing, and 2) the underlying issue (naming dispute). I believe that both should be dealt by the Committee. As far as (1) is concerned, LessHeard vanU's perspective is interesting (but needs some development and clarifications). As far as (2) is concerned, I've exposed how I personally regard ArbCom's extent of competence 1468:

is occurring daily across Knowledge on this issue. The issue is far wider than just the article move; there will be no resolution of this matter without addressing the underlying policy problems. Note that this doesn't imply solving the naming issue itself - ultimately this dispute comes down to whether policies should in fact be followed (the answer to which should be obvious but is being clouded by wikilawyering and a simple refusal to discuss policy requirements). --

1794:

start of any new "negotiation". The former, stable for so many years, status of the article was accepted by all parties and created no problems. The constitutional name of the country was used, respecting the self identification of the ethnic Macedonians and a disambiguation table was introduced respecting the Greek claims. This formula worked for so many years with minimal protest, so the situation had miraculously been resolved in a way only possible in Knowledge.

1494:, now defunct). The consensus-seeking mechanism has been tried repeatedly but as others have already noted, it has been stymied by an intransigent ethnic-nationalist block of editors. I should also add that a couple of Yannis's claims are misleading - there has been no "collateral edit-warring", merely an unrelated dispute over content in the ancient history section of the article, and I have already stated that I will voluntarily reverse the article move if its 6300:

uninvolved administrator, or group of administrators, including those who made the binding decision, may enforce the decision. Since consensus and policy can change, these binding decisions may be reviewed at appropriate times by that same administrator(s), or other uninvolved administrators. If the community is unable to find an administrator, or group of administrators, to address the situation, it may request that the Arbitration Committee appoint one.

63: 1671:. The traditional methods of counting reverts, uncivil remarks and questionable admin actions is not going produce any answer that meaningfully solves the real problem here; namely, that this article is under siege from a group of nationalists for whom no way save that endorsed by Greek foreign policy is acceptable. We need something new. More of the same will at best leave us where we are now, and at worst may bolster the nationalists. 4705:"...there is an overwhelming project-wide consensus of uninvolved users, versus an equally overwhelming consensus of a small local faction armed only with undefeatable tenacity. There is not the tiniest chance that one side will ever convince the other. So, the solution is not to have more talk. The solution, I'm very much afraid, is to fight it out, until one side wins. And that, unfortunately, will mean: until one side is banned." 1447:

spilled over onto Knowledge. Years of discussions between Wikipedians over what name to use for the country have been largely fruitless, with some Greek editors insisting on adopting the Greek government's preferred terminology across Knowledge or just within a "walled garden" of Greece-related articles. POV vandalism and disruption in support of the Greek position across the whole of Knowledge is endemic on this issue, as an

2489:, primarily to examine the use of administrative tools in this matter—I note that the article was, and remains, move-protected—but also to try and move the broader dispute towards resolution. Yannismarou, please add as parties (and provide appropriate notification to) the editors involved in the naming dispute, as well as any others who have expressed interest in participating in the case that was to be filed on the 22nd. 1642:, not the move at the other article, where I've had no involvement). Attempting to follow traditional methods of dispute resolution has led to roadblock because of a sizable nationalist faction that insists on using a name not used elsewhere in Knowledge. Where two separate consensuses, one consisting almost entirely of people with a vested interest in a certain nationality, the other consisting of more or less everyone 1590:

by gaining at least "no consensus" status in any vote-like procedure through sheer strength of numbers, and by derailing any discussion-based procedure through sheer tenacity of filibustering, until neutral editors are bored away. We need to figure out how to deal with polls dominated by national factions, and we need to figure out where the line is to be drawn between healthy debate and disruptive

1543:. Thus, this case filling has to me a distinct feeling of either scoring points against the opposite party or panic that the real case will be submitted soon and thus this was an attempt to preempt it from being filled (BTW, it was agreed that the case will be filled by a neutral party, this doesn't seem the case here either). Sorry for the meta-comment, but these things had to be mentioned. 3917:(Subsequent discussion about that summary: "The consensus was that there is no consensus, and that's what the body of the guideline text correctly describes. There is an agreement that status quo should remain stable; there most emphatically is no consensus that that status quo currently predominant in most Greece articles (using "fY...") should be mandated as obligatory for new content.") 3227:. In such circumstances, the 'involved' administrator should not take the action but should instead report the issue to the noticeboard, perhaps with a suggestion for appropriate action, to be dealt with by an uninvolved administrator. In limited circumstances, such as blatant vandalism or bad-faith harassment, an involved administrator may act, but such exceptions are likely to be rare. 3477:

act in concert to systematically advocate editorial decisions considered favorable to their shared political views that contravene the application of Knowledge policy or obstruct consensus-building. Mere strength of numbers is not sufficient to contravene Knowledge policy. Defending editorial positions that support political preferences typical of a particular national background is not

1980:. In it, I mentioned that Future Perfect agreed extremely quickly with the rather sudden renaming of the article, within 45 minutes as the records will show, and requested additional information to help eliminate the possibility that he might be acting on a potential POV and COI. The conversation continued until I was called by Future Perfect "idiotic". When I called that into question, 6244:{{Consensus|This article is currently subject to ''']''', as laid out in the final decision of the "Macedonia 2" arbitration case. If you are a new editor, or an editor unfamiliar with the situation, please follow the guidelines laid out in the above link. If you are unsure if your edit is appropriate, discuss it on this talk page first.}} Similar edit notice wording should be used. 1933:

memory the simple name "Macedonia" was never really even spoken about, except to dismiss the article being named that out of hand. Although there were heated voices on both sides, and I am ashamed to admit that I was one of them at times, there did seem to be some real discussion taking place, and there were hopes, at least on my part, that a real solution could be arrived at.

1961:

easier to resolve than the latter. If I am correct in that opinion, and if ArbCom rules allow it, I would request that, if a decision regarding the former issue is resolved before the second issue, any implementation of a decision regarding the former issue not be delayed until the resolution of the second issue, but be carried out as soon as a clear decision is reached.

1581:. To Coren: No this is not a request for the committee to settle the naming dispute (i.e. the content issue) itself. It's a request for guidance in a more general matter of Knowledge governance: how to deal with content decisions where a dispute is overwhelmingly dominated by pre-existing real-world political positions polarised along national lines. 6995:

designate a panel of three uninvolved administrators who will assess the consensus developed during the discussion, and report the results of their assessment within one week of the end of the discussion. The results will then be appended onto this case, and the consensus as assessed by the panel shall be enforceable as if it were a

1882:) by Avg as a reason for reporting Future Perfect to "the authorities" when he changed "former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia" to "Republic of Macedonia". This is a serious problem and further illustrates the nationalistic fervor of this community when anyone tries to treat Macedonia as an equal entity within Knowledge. But 1698:. Macedonia, without any appelations, is the self-identifying term for the country officially known as the Republic of Macedonia. ChrisO's actions are justified as they follow suit behind the practises featured in the English version of Knowledge. The addition of "Republic of" was used to disambiguate it from other 6960:, as currently configured, logs all changes involving the word "Macedonia" but does not block any edits. The community is strongly advised to consider adding a new abuse filter criterion; any instances of changing the word "Macedonia" to "FYROM" (the five-letter acronym, not the full phrase) shall be prevented. 3461:, outing has not occurred if an editor has previously voluntarily self-identified his or her country, language, nationality, or other personal information. Subsequent posting of that information by other users does not constitute outing. If a user has redacted that information, their wishes should be respected. 1805:, which was clearly not respected by ChrisO when he disrupted the article. Should the ArbCom deem this time that stricter guidelines are necessary, I will stand by it, although I understand that such a decision is difficult to take because of the possibility that it will clash with the pillars of Knowledge. 7067:

At the end of the six-month period, the supervising administrator will make a recommendation to the Committee regarding X's readiness to use the tools correctly and to conduct themselves appropriately without supervision. Based on this recommendation, the Committee will either allow X to continue as

6830:

is subject to an editing restriction for one year. Should he make any edits which are judged by an administrator to be uncivil, personal attacks, or assumptions of bad faith, he may be briefly blocked, up to a week in the event of repeated violations. After 5 blocks, the maximum block shall increase

6299:

process have been unsuccessful, the community should designate a neutral uninvolved administrator, or group of administrators, agreeable to all sides of the dispute, which should review the situation and resolve it by applying Knowledge policy. All sides should faithfully adhere to this decision. Any

3013:

of Knowledge that all editors should adhere to. Knowledge users are expected to behave reasonably and calmly in their interactions with other users, to keep their cool when editing, and to avoid acting in a manner that brings the project into disrepute. Administrators are expected to adhere to this

1646:

any vested interest in that country, something is broken. The Knowledge community needs better tools to deal with nationalistic editing if we are to have any hope of truly being a neutral encyclopedia in cases like this. I ask ArbCom to help us with this. At least, point us in the direction we should

1451:

shows. Any article that mentions Macedonia is a target for disruptive editing, which generally involves replacing the term "Republic of Macedonia" with "FYROM" or made-up terms like "Vardarska". This has even extended to anonymous vandalism from the Greek Parliament on an article that appeared on the

7124:

1) Blocks for violation of 1RR related to this arbitration may be issued after 1 warning for up to 1 week for first offense, up to 1 month after the first 1 week block, up to 6 months after the first 1 month block, and then indefinite blocks and ban options may be considered. All blocks and bans are

7059:

For a period of six months after their supervising administrator is approved by the Committee, X is permitted to use their administrative tools only as approved by the supervising administrator. The supervising administrator may place limits on the topic areas in which tool may be used, the type of

7055:

30) An administrator, X, subject to administrative supervision is required to find another administrator in good standing who is willing to supervise their administrative actions. The choice of supervising administrator is subject to approval by the Committee. X is encouraged to seek a supervising

5735:

37) IP editors from both sides have been disruptive by changing articles to a particular POV without a consensus to do so. This is often done on pages which have no direct connection to Greece, Macedonia, or their peoples, languages, or cultures. The effect disrupts Knowledge, overshadows legitimate

3715:

that this was the solution best in line with existing policy, and that in these very exceptional circumstances prior discussion would have been useless because the expected stonewalling from the Greek editors would make consensus-forming impossible. The article had previously been move-protected for

2440:

The plethora of detailed statements and excellent rationales by Yannis, AndreasJS, John Carter and Shadowmorph fully address my concerns. Therefore since these excellent points were made by them as well as others I will avoid repeating many of their arguments here. I would like however to expand on

2420:

Instead, focus on the subjacent reasons that led ChrisO to take such action: the general editing environment around these topics, the existence of a group of Greek editors determined to have our articles reflect their biases (as described by others above). — This is the source of much (most?) of the

1960:

It is I believe clear to everybody that there are two distinct, related, things being considered here. They are ChrisO's behavior and the broader naming question. It seems to me as a comparative outsider to the ongoing dispute who has only recently become involved in it, that the former issue may be

1936:

Then, out of the blue, without any discussion, ChrisO moves the page, locks it in place himself, and says that he is doing this in the interests of following policy, and is forced to justify how his move is in compliance with policy. I and several others called into question the move, and there were

1895:

of this arbitration–how does Knowledge deal with a parochial group of editors (whether nationalistic, as in this case, or religious) that blocks all attempts at productive editing that violates some self-proclaimed interest? In this case, we have a group of editors who refuse to reach any consensus

1808:

Finally, the ArbCom and all editors assisting in this process should keep in mind that although the name problem exists and is a serious issue for both sides, this was not the case in the specific article in question, whose title, name, position and general status quo had been accepted by all sides.

1490:. Samaria appears to be a much more complex issue and the arbitration case is a hopeless mess, frankly. In Ireland, the Committee remanded the issue to the community for further discussion. This stage has already happened for Macedonia - a lengthy attempt to reach agreement failed some time ago (see 1467:

editorial action to cut the Gordian Knot by moving the article to a name that matches policy and real-world usage. What we need now is to obtain a definitive, binding ruling on the policy dispute and preferably to tackle some of the disruptive behaviour - POV-pushing, wikilawyering, vandalism - that

7293:

discussion. The discussion must remain open for at least one month after it is opened, and the consensus must be assessed by a panel of three uninvolved contributors. In assessing the consensus, the panel is instructed to disregard any opinion which does not provide a clear and reasonable rationale

6259:

5) For the purpose of imposing sanctions under the provisions of this case, an administrator will be considered "uninvolved" if he or she has not previously participated in any content disputes on articles in the area of conflict and is not mentioned by name in the Arbitration Committee decision in

5843:

39) Over several years, many editors have represented an identifiable opinion faction with regard to Macedonia-related articles. While many of the editors concerned have undoubtedly acted individually in good faith, and the individual conduct of most of them did not reach a level of disruption that

3615:

28) Users who give up their administrator (or other) privileges and later request the return of those privileges may have them restored upon request, provided they did not give them up under circumstances of controversy. Users who give up privileges under controversial circumstances must go through

2989:

1) The purpose of Knowledge is to create a high-quality, free-content encyclopedia in an atmosphere of camaraderie and mutual respect among contributors. Contributors whose actions are detrimental to that goal may be asked to refrain from them, even when these actions are undertaken in good faith;

2022:

is something that I feel ArbCom should address. Mud is a difficult thing to remove when someone throws it at you. I would ask ArbCom to protect me and anyone else insulted from the continuous abuse and ridicule we get, just because we happen to have a certain opinion, which has always been based on

1940:

I beg the ArbCom to accept this case. The article in question was one of the top 300 in hits for March, and it is thus one of our most important articles. Such radical moves as have taken place on such an important article are at best questionable. That they take place under a cloud such as the one

1932:

page regarding how the Republic of Macedonia was to be named in that article. At the time, the two choices being considered were "Former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia" and "Republic of Macedonia". I and other new arrivals seemed to consistently favor the latter, but to the best of my knowledge and

1800:

This problem exists and is in no way unique in Knowledge. The ArbCom should make its recommendations and I will assist in every step. The only question is how we can expect respect for this decision when there have already been such recommendations and these tend to be disrespected by all sides and

1589:

article, we clearly found that this dispute was between a single, deeply entrenched and extremely determined, national faction of Greek editors, against a consensus of everybody else. However, the Greek faction is strong enough to block all regular consensus mechanisms threatening their POV island:

1534:

First of all I'm confused by this filling. this is not the issue that was supposed to be brought to ArbCom, it's only a tangential issue. Second, it was clearly agreed by all the parties to wait till the end of this weekend for practical reasons. Third, I was named a party in this discussion, but I

1462:

for a summary.) Unfortunately any movement towards a solution that reflects external sources has been blocked by Greek editors, essentially for POV reasons. Policy has been and is still being ignored - all of the editors who have objected to the article's new name have so far refused to discuss the

1446:

article was first created. The dispute centres on the name of the country Macedonia, which shares its name with a Greek region and a wider historical region. The Greek and Macedonian governments have been involved in a fairly bitter diplomatic dispute over the issue for the last 17 years, which has

6207:

3.1) All articles related to Macedonia (defined as any article that could be reasonably construed as being related to Macedonia, Macedonia nationalism, Greece related articles that mention Macedonia, and other articles in which how Macedonia will be referred to is an issue) fall under 1RR whenever

3538:

24) In deciding what sanctions to impose against an administrator or other editor, the Arbitration Committee will consider the editor's overall record of participation, behavioral history, and other relevant circumstances. An editor's positive and valuable contributions in one aspect of his or her

3476:

21) It is potentially harmful to Knowledge when editorial debates become strongly associated with real-world political polarizations and when they become dominated by groups of editors lined up along political lines due to shared national backgrounds. This is particularly harmful when such editors

1793:

at least until the ArbCom reaches a decision. His goal was to create a status quo which would manipulate the opinions of those not directly interested in this matter and it seems he has succeeded, since editors already talk about "not changing things yet", thus accepting that his edits will be the

1782:

which form (or have formed until now) the only firm rules of Knowledge. He intentionally changed the status quo of an article which had been stable for years and was not disputed by any side in this conflict. He did this in a most provocative way, deprived of the editors the right to revert/modify

1558:

and enforce their national POV there. If it's not evident to you that's the case here, please examine the use of the name of "Republic of Macedonia" or "Macedonia" in the majority (or maybe even "all") of the other articles and even in foreign language Wikis. I also made the case that biased polls

1371:

I regard the issue of major importance. It is not only the legitimacy of User:ChrisO's move and its adherence to our policies which is judged here, but also the avoidance of further and collateral damage this action may entail. I thus decided to bring the case in front of you now, although not all

6994:

29.1.1) Within seven days of the closure of this case, a discussion is to be opened to consider the preferred current and historical names for the four entities known as Macedonia. The discussion will end one month after it is opened. Prior to the discussion ending, the Arbitration Committee will

6909:

Upon regaining his administrator access, Future Perfect at Sunrise will not be allowed to use administrative tools in topical areas relating to Greece and Macedonia, or in relation to editors involved in that topical area. Should Future Perfect at Sunrise violate this restriction, the Arbitration

2138:

into a featured article. The map of one of those editors has even found fame beyond wikipedia in (Slav) Macedonian blogs and sites and is happily used. Users came together to agree on a line of conduct over when to use Macedonia, RoM, Fyrom, Greek Macedonia, etc. It worked. Users, such as myself,

2102:

I'm innocent I tells ya, I wuz framed. Seriously, I've noted elsewhere that I thought the move was a bad idea, both in its timing and in its intent: I understand why Chris did what he did, but I see no consensus for the move. Yes, as a potential political tactic it was smart in the sense that a

2031:

strongly advocates that Macedonia should not be used as the name of the country. I will also present my arguments on the naming issue (of course I disagree with the current naming) if the content dispute is discussed, however I very strongly believe the behavioral issue has to be tackled first. I

1832:

There are several layers to the issue before us here. First, there is the real-world conflict over a single word--started by Greece so long ago that it almost seems to date from Alexander's day. This issue is totally irrelevant to Knowledge's policies, but it is mentioned time and time again as

1737:

I originally came across the naming dispute on talk Greece where I disagreed with listing editors nationalities taking part in a straw poll. I have no allegiances to either country, so no matter what decision is made I won't lose any sleep over it. I took some interest in the name change made by

2802:

Noting here that ArbCom won't say what the name(s) should be, but that we will almost certainly be laying out a framework, or urging that a framework be set up, for achieving a lasting resolution to this issue (or at least for a set period to allow editing energies to be productively channelled

1693:

whole issue could wait until the Orthodox Easter, which begins this weekend. As a sort of respect to users from both "sides". But in further reading the comments by Yannismarou and ChrisO, both have vigourously defended their actions. It is true that a walled garden has been established by many

2771:

1) No Macedonia-related article, broadly defined, shall be moved/renamed until after the "Macedonia 2" case closes. If it does occur, any uninvolved administrator can expeditiously revert it. After the case closes, Macedonia-related moves/renames can occur as prescribed in the final decision.

2026:

Regarding the content dispute, never, ever has "Macedonia" been discussed as a choice for naming the country, because it was common ground to everybody even remotely involved with the issue that there is a high degree of ambiguity. Again, I will present as evidence many diffs where even ChrisO

3242:

10) Administrators are required to explain their actions. When an administrator takes an action that is likely to be controversial or to raise questions, he or she should explain the action in advance or at the time, in a location that the affected editors are likely to see, so that they will

3139:

are trusted members of the community, who are expected to follow Knowledge policies and are held to a high standard of conduct. They are expected to pursue their duties to the best of their abilities. Occasional mistakes are entirely compatible with this; administrators are not expected to be

1375:

My filing concerns mainly the User:ChrisO's move, but it is the ArbCom itself which will determine the scope of its competence, and if and how it is going to examine the related issue of the "Greece" article. Although I try to present the case as neutrally as I can, I cannot hide that I am an

3942:

article was challenged by a number of editors, who proposed switching to the "Republic of..." convention. During the ensuing controversy, editors of both sides supported their respected views with great tenacity, and often exhibited inappropriate behavior such as disruption, filibustering,

3274:

12) Edit-warring is harmful. When disagreements arise, users are expected to discuss their differences rationally rather than reverting ad infinitum. Revert rules should not be construed as an entitlement or inalienable right to revert, nor do they endorse reverts as an editing technique.

2387:

I'm not sure as to why I'm called an involved editor, but have an interest in how ArbCom would handle the long-term and tendentious nationalistic dispute. I expect that whatever remedy comes from the case would be a precedant for other heated naming disputes. The recent two ANI reports on

1401:

answers to your question. Yes, one administrator's action precipitated this early filing. Yes, the consensus was to bring the naming issue to ArbCom the earliest on 22 April because of the Orthodox Easter. There seemed to be a consensus the filing to be made by a non-involved user (maybe

6243:

4) As there are hundreds of articles potentially subject to the remedies contained in this decision, it is up to the community to tag the talk pages and edit notices of the articles and to decide how to go about that. Code for a template on talk pages that can be used for that is here:

2013:

the first time he abused the admin tools to settle this dispute in his favour. And finally, it was based in deceit and in an outright lie to the community. I'm prepared to prove my claims with diffs when the arbitration enters the evidence phase. ChrisO has completely lost my trust.

7175:

4) Topic bans and other measures imposed by administrators pursuant to the enforcement provisions of this case are open to community review. The community is free to modify sanctions, such as extending a topic ban or replacing a topic ban with mentoring and editing restrictions.

6176:

2.1) The remedies in this case shall apply to any disagreement among editors concerning the proper use or designation of the names "Macedonia", "Republic of Macedonia", "the former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia", or any similar or related reference in any article in Knowledge.

2004:

I would like to start by expressing my firm belief that this action by ChrisO was not simply a random "bold" move nor a move by a passing-by, uninvolved administrator. It was a carefully planned and premeditated move, by a heavily biased editor, with the objective of acting as a

6260:

this case. Enforcing the provisions of this decision or the earlier decision in the first Macedonia arbitration will not be considered to be participation in a dispute. Any doubt regarding whether an administrator qualifies under this definition is to be treated as any other

3903:(proposed guideline text, as of October 2007: "There is currently no clearly defined consensus about how to refer to the Republic of Macedonia in articles about Greece. when in doubt, it is recommended to leave the status quo in each article as is." This was stable since 3379:

to use a particular name, particularly the name it uses for itself (a self-identifying name). Articles should report the objective fact that such names are used; if another nation or group disputes the right to use that name, then information about that dispute (if it is

1372:

the proper series of "dispution mechanism resolution" actions has been followed. I do think, however, that this case falls under the categories "Sensitive or "drama prone" issues requiring advice on handling" as well as "Unusually divisive disputes among administrators".

6761:

is strongly admonished for displaying a long pattern of incivil, rude, offensive, and insulting behavior towards other editors and failure to address the community's concerns in this regard. This is inappropriate for any editor, but especially for an administrator.

5535:) (Kekrops) has disrupted the project through years-long systematic advocacy editing in issues of Greek national disputes, including the Macedonia naming issue. He has shown a pattern of persistent and excessive wikilawyering, edit-warring and multiple instances of 471:

Please do not edit this page directly unless you are either 1) an Arbitrator, 2) an Arbitration Clerk, or 3) adding yourself to this case. Statements on this page are original comments provided when the Committee was initially requested to Arbitrate this page (at

1457:

The situation outside Knowledge regarding the country's name is straightforward - it's called simply "Macedonia" by the great majority of English-language reference works and media. Knowledge's policy is also clear about how terminology should be used. (See

2570:

Accept, both to look at the recent move but also the underlying issue in the sense that it would have been brought to us anyway next week. As Flo says, we will, as always, not be resolving the content dispute, but we can provide a framework for resolution.

3199:

by using administrative tools. Administrator tools may not be used to further the administrator's own position in a content dispute. Administrators who are unsure whether they should take an action should defer that action to an uninvolved administrator.

7063:

During this time, the supervising administrator is asked to assist X in training to use the tools in a manner that complies with all relevant policies and benefits the project, and to conduct themselves in a manner appropriate for an administrator.

5452: 3403:

17) Protracted naming disputes are not a highly productive form of encyclopedia building and should be avoided if at all possible. Effort spent on actually improving articles as opposed to engaging in disputes over their names is highly encouraged.

7103:

or the approval of this Committee. ChrisO is urged to give careful consideration to the principles expressed in this decision in his future editing, and especially if he reattains adminship at a future date. ChrisO may retain his rollback rights.

3325:. Where different scholarly viewpoints exist on a topic, those views enjoying a reasonable degree of support should be reflected in article content. An article should fairly represent the weight of authority for each such view, and should not give 1601:

normal procedure would simply never lead anywhere. Arbcom needs to deal not so much with the legalities of this move itself, but with the underlying causes: why do we regularly have situations that make such rouge moves look like the only way out?

2990:

and good faith actions, where disruptive, may still be sanctioned. Use of the site for other purposes—including, but not limited to, advocacy, propaganda, furtherance of outside conflicts, and political or ideological struggle—is prohibited.

6294:

6) When the net effect of blocs of editors with a shared agenda disrupts the achievement of consensus over, and/or negates the application of, Knowledge policy to the point that it is harmful to the encyclopedia, and appropriate steps of the

1637:

Looking just at ChrisO's action, a single administrative action, isn't going to make much of a case. What really needs examining here is a complete failure in the wiki model to get us through a problem (here I am talking about the dispute at

2416:

Please, do not dedicate too much of your time to the bold actions by ChrisO that precipitated the filing of this case: whether adequate or not, it is one single, easily reversable action made in good faith. — Little harm can come out of it.

5361:) has disrupted the project through years-long systematic advocacy editing in issues of Greek national disputes, including the Macedonia naming issue. He has a battle ground mentality and has threatened to edit war without compromising. 4003:

8) Articles relating to or simply mentioning Macedonia have been and are being subjected to frequent vandalism and disruptive editing, characterized by ethnic polarization, in an effort to promote one side or the other's particular view.

2674:(a featured article). In general, a way does need to be found to resolve these perennial disputes for set periods of time (say two years) so that in between the periodic debates, work is actually done on other articles instead. Whether by 1783:

his edits and directly threatened other admins not to do so either. He clearly acted in bad faith, choosing the start of a holy day for the Greeks to act and he totally disrupted Knowledge to illustrate a point, whatever this might be.

4248:) was found to have edit-warred and have heavily edited Balkan-related articles in the Kosovo arbitration case of 2006. As a result of that, he was advised not to engage in edit warring and not to use rollback in content disputes. 1828:

How ironic. The Gordian Knot was a tangled Greek mess solved by a Macedonian who bent, if not broke, the rules. (And of course I realize that Alexander was not a Slavic Macedonian, but it's still a beautiful irony, nonetheless.)

6003:

Replacing "Republic of Macedonia" with invented POV or pejorative terms (e.g. "Former Yugoslavic Republic of Macedonia", "Vardarska", "Slavomacedonia", "Republic of FYROM", "Republic of Skopje", "Bananadonia" and "Monkeydonia").

4930: 4548: 4747: 2678:-type resolution or otherwise. But these nationalist naming disputes need to be settled because they are a large drain in time and resources (several recent and current arbitration cases have been disputes over article names). 2050:

the arbitration starts on the 22nd of April. He will then prove to the arbitrators and to the community that his action was not intended to promote a certain POV and trick the arbitrators into upholding the newly changed name.

1941:

cast by ChrisO's actions damages the trust of several experienced editors, and even more so newer editors, and we should all do our best to address ensuring that such damaging behavior not happen any more often than necessary.

1753:. The question for me is, did he use his tools in the proper manner and after using those tools was he right to infer that it would be wheel-warring and possibly frighten off other admins from reverting his preferred version. 3851:

5) Since circa 2006/2007, there was a relatively stable status quo, though not a consensus, that was respected by most regular editors in the field. Part of this status quo was that the "Former Yugoslav" form was used in the

4722: 3258:

11) Users who have been sanctioned for improper conduct are expected to avoid repeating it should they continue to participate in the project. Failure to do so may lead to the imposition of increasingly severe sanctions.

3115:

5) Consensus is not immutable. It is reasonable, and sometimes necessary, for both individual editors and particularly the community as a whole to change its mind. Long-held consensus cannot be used as an excuse against a

3065:. Although the points of view of individual states, international organizations or groups, and their views or conventions supported by official sources may be taken into account, they should not constitute a basis for 3951:

held in parallel ended in a polarized roughly 50/50 result: about half of the respondents, mostly self-identified Greeks, advocated "former Yugoslav..."; the other half, mostly from elsewhere, advocated "Republic of".

2017:

I would also like to draw the attention of the ArbCom to the somewhat established tactics even in the statements of certain involved parties here, in labelling a group of editors as "Greek nationalists". The issue of

6154: 3155:

7) Sustained disruption of Knowledge is incompatible with the status of administrator. Administrators who repeatedly and aggressively engage in inappropriate activity may be desysopped by the Arbitration Committee.

1877:

on four occasions before getting the article protected from anonymous IPs. Staffordshire University is not even within the Greek "sphere of interest", but it was cited (along with other irrelevant articles such as

5312:) is a single-purpose account whose involvement with Knowledge has been almost entirely been focused on editing a handful of Macedonia-related articles and this arbitration case. He has edit-warred disruptively on 1340:

took place but it bore no fruit. No adm closed the poll; the article was protected twice by User:Horologium to avoid ongoing edit-wars, and no solution to the problem was found. After endless discussions, it was

5293: 2133:

Statement forthcoming on Monday, 20 April 2009. Many editors who argue for this article to be called RoM, as it was until a few days ago have outstanding contributions to wikipedia. Many were involved in making

2233:

for the page. The funny part is that there never was in 5 years any talk or reason to move it, Republic of Macedonia was the consensus (in the wiki way). But aside from that, the name issue is important. Why

7260: 6899: 6825: 6756: 4689: 817: 2009:. It is also the culmination of a serial disregard of any sense of the consensus process and it has been accompanied by a host of accusations, insults and threats against an ethnic group of editors. It was 6187: 5460: 2139:

then went on to revert some reference to Fyrom into RoM because we had agreed. Now, those users seem to be vilified for wishing to abide by the status quo as agreed. That seems wrong. Please reconsider.

1738:

Chris0 to the Macedonia article as many of the same editors where involved. My concern is the way he went about it without any prior notice and his comments since making the change. I saw his statement

4486: 6693:. Combined with actions in this case, this is a long-term pattern. ChrisO is desysopped as a result. ChrisO may obtain the tools back via the usual means or by request to the Arbitration Committee. 7324: 6690: 4781: 4617: 4396: 7099:

31) The Committee takes note that ChrisO has resigned his administrator status while this case was pending. Any request by ChrisO for restoration of adminship privileges will require either a new

5606: 3833: 1616: 7387:

Log any block, restriction, ban or extension under any remedy in this decision here. Minimum information includes name of administrator, date and time, what was done and the basis for doing it.

3442:, which ignores the spirit of those policies and serves to obstruct consensus-building processes or cover up an agenda of POV-pushing, is harmful to the project and may be met with sanctions. 1626: 1609: 6979:, shall be moved/renamed until after the community comes to a solution for the naming dispute. If any unauthorized move does occur, any uninvolved administrator may expeditiously revert it. 3298:

such as names are concerned, disputes may arise over whether a particular name should be used. Knowledge takes a descriptive rather than prescriptive approach in such cases, by using the

4392: 4878: 4836: 2493: 1663:

PS: If this case is supposed to include everyone with involvement in the naming dispute, I suppose I should be added, though having that many parties sounds exceedingly unwieldy to me.

5961:

Similarly, but replacing "Republic of Macedonia" with "FYROM", to remove any mention of Macedonia, even if there is no ambiguity or if the term FYROM is inappropriate in that context.

4885:

to the point that the conclusion was moved to an outside view vice placing it in a closing template which was the practice at that time. The closing admin, now an arbitrator, stated "

2703: 2580: 7580: 6904:

is desysopped for three months as a consequence of poor user conduct and misuse of administrative tools. After three months, his administrator access will be automatically restored.

2614: 6682: 4328: 2687: 2597: 2480: 1869:. Third, there is the Greek vandalism that occurs nearly daily throughout Knowledge against Macedonia. The abuse log is cited elsewhere here, but I have personally been watching 5699:) is a single-purpose account whose involvement with Knowledge has been almost entirely been focused on editing a handful of Macedonia-related articles and this arbitration case. 4636: 3539:

participation on Knowledge do not excuse misbehavior or questionable judgment in another aspect of participation, but may be considered in determining the sanction to be imposed.

2803:

elsewhere for that period). Discussions on how to resolve this should still continue, but no moving or renaming (with obvious exceptions such as typos on newly-created articles).

2743: 2726: 2633: 2565: 1026: 562: 488: 3701: 7002:

In assessing the consensus, the panel is instructed to disregard any opinion which does not provide a clear and reasonable rationale explained by reference to the principles of

2757: 2650: 2550: 1083: 5703: 5700: 4906: 4135: 2509: 7908: 7056:

administrator outside their normal areas of editing and administrative tool use. Should X refuse to seek out an administrative supervisor, they will be summarily desysopped.

6845: 6613:

is strongly admonished for changing a protected template and moving a protected article in disputes in which he was heavily involved as an editor without obtaining consensus.

503: 7527: 7522: 7374: 7157: 6128: 5824: 5821: 5818: 5815: 5812: 5809: 5680: 5633: 5456: 4737:

a three-revert rule warning template from his user talk page with the edit summary "LOL, I'm perfectly aware of what I am doing, thank you very much for your kind concern."

3753:

Macedonia (region): A historical/geographical region, today split between Albania, Bulgaria, Greece and the independent Republic of Macedonia (part of Yugoslavia until 1992)

3648:. While focusing specifically on issues related to Macedonia, these issues are part of a broader set of conflicts prevalent over the entire range of articles concerning the 4887:...just because one works in a difficult area does not give a user the right to attack another. As a result, I caution FPS to be more civil and to avoid personal attacks... 4520:

using the summary "consensus at AfD was that this page as it currently stands is not useful. Redirecting again, until somebody writes something better". On April 21, 2009,

3215:

9) In several recent instances, administrators involved in disputes have taken sysop actions relating to that dispute and then referred the actions typically to either the

3042:

are all inconsistent with Knowledge etiquette. Users should not respond to such behavior in kind; concerns regarding the actions of other users should be brought up in the

2670:; (7) For those involved in the naming dispute to consider whether time spent discussing the name of the article might be better spent improving articles, as was done with 1567: 7531: 7060:

tool used, the purpose for which they are used, or any others as they consider necessary. Should X refuse to comply with these limits, they will be summarily desysopped.

284: 1702:, however usage of the full name of a country is not common wiki practise. Although officially "The United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland", the article is 6676: 6608: 5220: 4322: 2111:

have explained. To be more blunt: should the Greece article be a walled garden, one that can ignore the realities and policies and logic? I say "no". Period and EOS.

722: 620: 4877:

during August-November 2008 that primarily focused on concerns about incivility, assuming good faith, how he handled images, and tendentious editing. While he did make

1345:

that the case should be presented on 22 April before the ArbCom for the reasons exposed in the above thread. It was not conclusively decided who will file the request.

7514: 2766: 1572: 321: 153: 4053: 3872: 5243:(see contribs) whose involvement with Knowledge has been almost entirely been focused on editing a handful of Macedonia-related articles and this arbitration case. 3729:

ChrisO did not change "Republic of Macedonia" to "Macedonia" anywhere else. He also acknowledges he is aware of the importance of the timing due to Easter holidays.

2466: 1694:

users, all from a similar POV and ethnic background, whereby the term "Macedonia" has been claimed as an exclusively Greek one, despite the prevalent opinion in the

869: 5187: 2470: 2158:

I'm the proverbial new editor. I was previously anonymous but Macedonia is protected from those for ever. I was trying to improve Macedonia dab page and along with

1993: 7145: 4874: 3348:

of articles by engaging in sustained aggressive point-of-view editing may be banned from the affected articles. In extreme cases they may be banned from the site.

3019: 7747: 7445: 6124:

40) ChrisO resigned his status as an administrator on June 6, 2009, while this arbitration case was pending, and just prior to that gave himself rollback rights.

6970: 5484:), who self-identified as Greek but disagreed with him on the Macedonia question, of lying and calling him "FYROMian" and "leftist", often writing in Greek. See 4854: 3500:

that is or is likely to be controversial should be discussed beforehand on the page's talk page, and/or at any other pertinent location. The methods outlined at

2927: 1216: 484: 477: 86: 6989: 4331:

in the Israeli apartheid case not to use his administrative tools without prior discussion and consensus, nor to use them so as to continue an editing dispute.

2825: 7818: 7673: 5827: 4784:

for block review since he was involved. Most reviewers felt Sadbuttrue92 did deserve a block but felt someone else should have done it. FPAS's response was to

3829: 1981: 1977: 1463:

policy rationale for the move. It is clear that attempts to reach a consensus have failed and are unlikely to succeed without external stimulus. I undertook a

7504: 5505: 5374: 4890: 2812: 5413: 4159: 2901: 2840:

Since there is a delay in opening the case, this proposal seems sensible as there was likely to be a similar injunction proposed soon after the case opened.

1865:). This issue is also totally irrelevant to Knowledge's policies, but is repeatedly used to sidetrack the issue of common English usage as found throughout 1597:

ChrisO's move is just an expression of exasperation with this situation: he tried to cut the gordian knot, by doing the correct edit in a situation where he

315: 7382: 5848: 5845: 5561: 5558: 5555: 5552: 4047: 3912:(ChrisO's attempt at summarising the status quo: "in articles dealing only with the internal affairs of Greece use "former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia") 3866: 3558:

are expected to contribute neutrally instead of following their own agenda and, in particular, should take care to avoid creating the impression that their

2961: 2946: 2883: 2871: 2847: 7029: 5117: 4499: 4014: 3660:. Many of these conflicts are grounded in matters external to Knowledge, including long-standing historical, national, and ethnic disputes in the region. 3577:

26) The recruitment of editors for the purpose of influencing a survey, performing reverts, or otherwise attempting to give the appearance of consensus is

3371:

should prefer what the greatest number of English speakers would most easily recognize." Knowledge determines the recognizability of a name by seeing what

2462: 1554:) as a simple content problem, I see it as a matter of principle, whether Knowledge allows a group of people to "own" their national page and keep them as 865: 2914: 2835: 2399: 6008: 4886: 3953: 2876:

Yes, there will be no need for another vote. This motion covers the situations. We are doing it this way instead of an injunction because of the delay.

2521: 2377: 1950: 1762: 1432: 1411: 1389: 6634: 6566: 5650: 5647: 5630: 5627: 5546: 5543: 5540: 5445: 5368: 5365: 5169: 4382: 4351: 4280: 4239: 4196: 4122: 4094: 4068: 4062: 4059: 4044: 3920: 3910: 3904: 3887: 3881: 3878: 3863: 3783: 3680: 1904:, and other diversionary tactics without addressing the fundamental policy issue. Knowledge's policy is very clear to me concerning naming an entity ( 1520: 1503: 1473: 578: 6686: 5210:

whose involvement with Knowledge has been almost entirely been focused on editing a handful of Macedonia-related articles and this arbitration case.

4717:"...perfectly willing to make this a test case. Either the Knowledge community surrenders to the power of local national factions, or it fights them." 4249: 2505:? I understand that one administrator's action precipitated this early filing of a request, but the intent was to bring this to ArbCom all along? — 1861:

passim). Second, there is the continual attempt by the entrenched nationalists to paint international usage as the standard for Knowledge naming (as

6481: 5299: 1970: 279: 4542: 4341: 4229: 1718:. In this case the term "Macedonia" has been appropriately chosen, acting in line with other developments on Knowledge and accordance with WP:NAME. 1678: 1658: 7585: 7468: 7463: 5718: 5176: 4974: 4968: 4445: 4257: 2103:

move to the center takes us back to Republic of Macedonia, but in this case it wasn't necessarily the best idea. The real issue is precisely what

311: 107: 99: 2123: 499: 7499: 7472: 7440: 7409: 7404: 7224: 6863: 6789: 6720: 4991: 4922: 4870: 4763: 4653: 4562: 4513: 4429: 4413: 4372: 4155: 2501:, I need to understand something here that's of critical importance, I think: is the community requesting that ArbCom settle the naming dispute 781: 3778:

4) The disputes regarding Macedonia related articles go back several years, to at least October 2003. On May 11, 2007, several users, including

2148: 7752: 7518: 7413: 6462: 5668: 5259: 4788:

with an edit summary in Greek that roughly means "fuck off, you wanker", but FPAS thought it meant "go to hell". FPAS was warned by arbitrator

4179: 2797: 1442:

The Macedonia naming issue is one of the oldest and ugliest POV disputes on Knowledge. It has been ongoing since as far back as 2002, when the

5997: 4729:"...s long as Knowledge doesn't find a way to reduce the power of local POV cliques, I will protest and, if necessary, edit-war against them." 2089: 1818: 1524: 1507: 1477: 476:), and serve as opening statements; as such, they should not be altered. Any evidence you wish to provide to the Arbitrators should go on the 7898: 7455: 7236: 6875: 6801: 6732: 6629: 6561: 5838: 5549: 5389: 4665: 4442: 4378: 4347: 4275: 4235: 4192: 4090: 3779: 3698: 3676: 2194:. That way he ridiculed me as a new editor, and showed me the door together with all other potential new editors. He did this on an Orthodox 2039: 1516: 1499: 1469: 793: 573: 253: 4360:) admitted on April 16, 2009 that he is an involved administrator and acknowledged he should not take administrative actions in this topic. 4253: 3720:, including reactions from previously uninvolved outside editors, were mostly critical of the process, but partly supportive of the result. 2296: 2032:

find appalling to be forced to enter into a content dispute with the tables turned to ChrisO favor, just because he abused the admin tools.

1917: 7396: 7254: 7242: 6893: 6881: 6819: 6807: 6750: 6738: 4683: 4671: 3986:", or the name "FYROM" and "Former Yugoslav", being added or removed from articles. It has been triggered over 500 times as of 25 May 2009. 3637: 1583:

This is a situation where the standard Wiki model of consensus procedures regularly fails, and we need to figure out how to deal with that.

811: 799: 461: 6042:" with POV or pejorative terms such as "Fyromians", "Skopjans", "Pseudomacedonians" or "Slavomacedonians". Also replacing mentions of the 1727: 103: 7576: 7230: 6869: 6795: 6726: 5532: 4659: 3653: 3026:(including rude, offensive, derogatory, and insulting terms—whether in English, a language other than English, or using invented terms), 2257:. Is Knowledge just a reference or is it a learning tool? Do the uneducated users learn anything on the historic region, when they go to 1719: 1577:

I request that Arbcom accept this case under the perspective previously agreed by all participants of the sub-dispute that had arisen at

1112: 951: 787: 761: 273: 118: 96: 6681:

has been admonished or made subject to restrictions in the course of three prior arbitration proceedings by the Arbitration Committee:

3762:

Macedonia (Greece): Three Greek provinces collectively referred to as Macedonia, though it is not actually a political entity in itself.

2605:. Please note that when the case opens I will post some questions thay I will be asking the parties (and interested others) to address. 2326: 2183: 7536: 7248: 6887: 6813: 6744: 4677: 4581: 3947:, edit warring, assumptions of bad faith, by both those supporting and opposing the change. This resulted in protection of the page. A 2435: 1529: 805: 354: 306: 244: 163: 91: 5033:

by accusing other editors of bigotry, utilizing terminology conveying ethnic hatred, and accusing other users of lying and ignorance.

3825: 2430: 2253: 1955: 7510: 7316: 4994: 4882: 3933: 3657: 1976:

Also, I call to the attention of the arbitration committee this material questioning the terms of Future Perfect's proposed renaming

420: 269: 4841: 431: 7286: 7201: 4593: 3471: 3166: 2345: 380: 249: 7548: 5902: 5899: 3439: 1453: 455: 449: 5893: 5730: 4611: 4599: 487:. That page may also be used for general comments on the evidence. Arbitrators will then vote on a final decision in the case at 259: 239: 122: 7840: 7695: 7602: 7572: 5854: 5401: 5398: 5055: 4785: 4734: 4587: 4460: 4454: 4451: 4448: 4433: 4032: 3857: 1647:

go next (and please, don't ask us to go to mediation or RFC. This issue has been discussed out, and certain parties absolutely

1377: 1361: 264: 177: 158: 6125: 5624: 5621: 5618: 1928:

I first came to this discussion after Future Perfect at Sunrise requested additional eyes and voices in the discussion on the

227: 7495: 7197: 6996: 5896: 5425: 4605: 4391:) agreed to a voluntary restriction limiting his editing and banning his use of sysop tools in Scientology-related articles. 3088:

model. When there is a good-faith dispute, editors are expected to participate in the consensus-building process, in lieu of

2300: 298: 189: 7436: 6094: 5770: 5762: 5760: 5758: 5756: 2213:

That can't be acceptable behaviour from an admin. Furthermore he wasn't being bold in making an edit like I did with moving

2163: 7926: 7769: 6772: 6703: 5777: 5720:

It is also noted that Shadowmorph has recently started broadening his areas of interest and working on improving articles.

5464: 4800: 3375:

in English call the subject." Knowledge does not take any position on whether a particular person, group or nation has the

222: 7477: 6119: 2558:

To examine admin conduct, and to assist the Community in finding a solution to the naming conflict (not select the name).

7905: 7554: 7418: 7218: 6857: 6783: 6714: 6494: 6014: 5968: 5326: 5323: 5320: 4916: 4864: 4757: 4647: 4556: 4507: 4423: 4149: 3062: 1750:

after I asked him just that. He did though reassert it could be wheel-warring in a conversation on J.delanoy's talk page

1623: 1606: 1482:(add) I should add that this issue is rather different from the other naming disputes that the Committee has looked at - 875: 775: 443: 148: 77: 7544: 6065: 4065: 3884: 7880: 6079: 5653: 5485: 4812: 4777: 3670: 1274: 637: 473: 17: 7094: 3915: 3721: 3191:, do not make an editor involved in a topic. Administrators are not empowered to enforce content policies such as the 3056: 7489: 7459: 6433: 6372: 6091: 5805: 5696: 4964: 4937: 4934: 4830: 4818: 4521: 4517: 3514: 2382: 1103: 990: 653: 526: 23: 7540: 7430: 6011: 5909: 5768: 5766: 5764: 5615: 5570: 5317: 5126: 4036: 3957: 3860: 1874: 7568: 7400: 6097: 5749: 5309: 5120: 5043: 4806: 4623: 4457: 3817: 3803: 2153: 1923: 1732: 1327: 1047: 837: 7068:

an administrator without further supervision; require that X undergo further supervision; or summarily desysop X.

6005: 5149: 3689:), an administrator with a long involvement in the debate: on April 14, 2009, he moved a disambiguation page from 3562:

is non-neutral, which could strongly suggest that their editing is not compatible with the goals of this project.

7834: 7813: 7689: 7668: 7646: 7596: 7303: 7011: 6932: 6149:

1) All editors on Macedonia-related articles are directed to get the advice of neutral parties via means such as

5977: 5881: 5866: 5789: 5579: 5526: 5481: 5203: 5165: 5108: 5102: 4971: 4824: 4218: 4040: 3961: 3733: 3727: 3724: 3433: 3291: 2368:). But since RoM is the self-identification, constitutionally, RoM is as neutral as it gets for an encyclopedia. 1667:

Since it seems clear to to me that this case is going to happen, I'm really hoping the Arbs will listen to this:

1312: 1255: 1160: 1002: 970: 945: 755: 538: 214: 54: 7632: 6053: 6050: 6047: 5965: 5857: 5851: 5665: 5588: 5585: 5582: 5410: 5407: 5395: 4084: 1834: 7902: 7290: 7213: 6852: 6778: 6709: 5567: 5564: 5404: 5236: 5114: 5096: 4912: 4860: 4753: 4642: 4575: 4552: 4503: 4474: 4470: 4419: 4168: 4165: 4162: 4145: 3987: 3384:) should also be given in the appropriate place. Bear in mind that Knowledge is descriptive, not prescriptive. 3299: 3140:

perfect. However, consistently or egregiously poor judgment may result in the removal of administrator status.

2942: 2722: 2159: 1743: 1739: 1632: 1620: 1603: 1293: 1059: 1020: 1008: 932: 894: 770: 669: 556: 544: 200: 143: 7426: 6100: 5502: 5499: 5496: 5493: 5371: 5132: 3597: 7763: 6414: 6349: 5269: 5083: 5030: 5026: 4408: 4104: 4050: 3869: 3773: 3345: 3269: 3237: 3150: 3100:

of the consensus model and process, such as misrepresenting consensus or poisoning the well, is disruptive.

3015: 2097: 1141: 1077: 1065: 996: 913: 532: 135: 7724: 7119: 6910:

Committee may remove his administrator access (either temporarily or permanently), or alter the restriction.

6082: 5962: 5470:(insinuating opponent might abuse oversight to get rid of allegedly embarrassing material). He also accused 5281: 5067: 4990:) via wikimail on May 14, 2009. Taivo subsequently released the email without permission to two other users. 3730: 7485: 7451: 7295: 7003: 6640: 6572: 6144: 6103: 5609: 4388: 4357: 4286: 4245: 4202: 4100: 3789: 3717: 3686: 3533: 3385: 3364: 3043: 2128: 1775:

1. Whether ChrisO abused his position as an administrator to disturb the consensus achieved in Knowledge.

1236: 1053: 1014: 686: 584: 550: 373: 185: 83: 6076: 5878: 5875: 5872: 5869: 5863: 5860: 5715: 5712: 5709: 5706: 5612: 5052: 5040: 4466: 4463: 4361: 1862: 1854: 1850: 1842: 1838: 1349: 7864: 7719: 7626: 7392: 6395: 6032: 5362: 5253: 5090: 4987: 4926: 4269: 4206: 3039: 3035: 2446: 2218: 2054: 1767: 1437: 1071: 742: 195: 113: 6088: 5010: 4158:) confirmed he had prior knowledge that ChrisO was considering article and disambiguation page changes. 2517:; It does seem that the community methods have broken down in this area, and that ArbCom might help. — 7894: 7852: 7793: 7707: 7614: 7481: 7307: 7035: 7015: 6652: 6584: 6401: 6378: 6039: 5974: 5971: 5662: 5659: 5656: 5644: 5641: 5638: 5635: 5522: 5468: 5449: 5392: 5386: 5383: 5380: 5377: 5049: 5046: 5037: 5034: 4710: 4694: 4436: 4298: 4118: 4056: 3875: 3694: 2663: 2450: 2410: 2179: 1846: 1823: 1560: 1420: 1122: 941: 751: 698: 596: 483:

Arbitrators, the parties, and other editors may suggest proposed principles, findings, and remedies at

234: 7422: 5516: 4439: 2206:. He effectively started an edit war, with a tactic I parallelized (in a figure of speech) similar to 1742:

that any admin reverting his change could be desysopped for wheel-warring. I later noticed him making

1360:. The issue was brought to AN by User:John Carter, and then a "centralized discussion" started in the 7781: 6670: 6658: 6602: 6590: 6381:(Kekrops) is indefinitely banned from Macedonia-related articles and their talk pages, as defined in 6254: 5890: 5887: 5884: 5603: 5600: 5597: 5441: 5358: 4948: 4570: 4316: 4304: 3501: 3491: 1879: 1684: 856: 716: 704: 614: 602: 7139: 7299: 7007: 6951: 6646: 6578: 5313: 4794: 4292: 3846: 3716:

a very long time, and has remained so since; hence, administrator rights were required to move it.

3610: 3596:

27) Excessive cross-posting, campaigning, votestacking, stealth canvassing, and forum shopping are

3549: 3420: 3316: 3210: 3136: 3130: 2659: 2361: 1901: 1897: 1870: 1648: 1591: 1322: 1180: 692: 590: 6085: 5594: 5591: 5576: 5573: 4529: 4525: 7858: 7713: 7620: 7339: 6957: 6664: 6596: 6358:

is indefinitely topic-banned from Macedonia-related articles and their talk pages, as defined in

6330: 5908:

Replacing all instances of "Republic of Macedonia" with "Former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia".

4310: 3979: 2923: 2671: 2667: 2404: 2314: 2229:. He knew that there would never be consensus to move it back, therefore he was bold in creating 2135: 1448: 1333: 710: 608: 366: 3820:) began writing a Manual of Style guide specifically for Macedonia-related articles, henceforth 1746:

change to his opening statement implying it was not an administrative action which he confirmed

7874: 7740: 6517: 4771: 3285: 3010: 2974: 2576: 2393: 2064: 1695: 1268: 1192: 631: 4023:

was proposed to find a common approach to this naming issue, but failed to achieve consensus.

2225:

to a new name for a move-protected page. The way to go, on an encyclopedia "anyone can edit"?

7846: 7798: 7787: 7701: 7608: 7084: 7046: 6475: 6320: 6285: 6228: 6198: 6068: 6062: 6059: 6056: 6029: 6026: 6023: 6020: 6017: 5995: 5992: 5989: 5986: 5983: 5980: 5954: 5951: 5948: 5945: 5942: 5939: 5936: 5933: 5930: 5927: 5924: 5921: 5918: 5915: 5912: 5799: 5746: 5743: 5740: 5737: 5690: 4958: 4210: 4181: 4137: 3983: 3704: 3110: 2984: 2610: 2373: 2278: 2187: 2076: 1989: 1966: 1946: 1758: 1536: 1428: 1407: 1385: 1353: 1210: 1198: 1097: 984: 647: 520: 73: 5667:. He has also at times shown respect for those who oppose him and willingness to compromise 3712: 1495: 1459: 7562: 6274: 5444:) is prone to exaggeration and showing lack of good faith in the motives of other editors. 5303: 4495: 4488: 3973: 3901: 3811: 3797: 3631: 3578: 3381: 3339: 3224: 3171:

8) Administrator actions pertaining to enforcing Knowledge's conduct policies, such as the

3031: 2808: 2683: 2265:? ChrisO also opened the statistics Pandora's box, with many flaws. Statistics also showed 2203: 1546:

I will only comment on what the initial issue was supposed to be: I don't see the issue in

1186: 1041: 831: 42: 7269:, and to apply particular care to avoid conflict in areas related to Greece and Macedonia. 2356:. What's with the rush, if not to create a new Knowledge status quo? WP should remain as 1515:

I would have no problems with a delay until the originally planned date of 22nd April. --

8: 7828: 7811: 7775: 7683: 7666: 7640: 7590: 7280: 7191: 6106: 6043: 5475: 5197: 5159: 5123: 4789: 4524:

using the summary "rv, the article is worthless". At the time of the second redirection,

3744: 3626: 3358: 3085: 3066: 3006: 2490: 2330: 2198:, to avoid confrontation, since all those that would care enough to object would be from 1675: 1655: 1306: 1249: 1204: 1154: 964: 6941:

and other Knowledge policies. Diversifying one's topics of interest is also encouraged.

1402:

User:Horologium, the protecting administrator), but this was not conclusively decided.--

7266: 7212:("Future Perfect at Sunrise temporarily desysopped") is lifted, effective immediately. 6456: 5230: 4566: 3497: 3027: 3023: 2936: 2919: 2880: 2844: 2739: 2716: 2562: 2353: 2239: 2199: 1699: 1365: 1287: 926: 888: 663: 498:

as needed, but this page should not be edited otherwise. Please raise any questions at

34: 7170: 7870: 7757: 7729: 6623: 6555: 6171: 5263: 5077: 5020: 4767: 4028: 3372: 3303: 3014:

at a higher standard. Unseemly conduct—including, but not limited to, edit-warring,

2818: 2696: 2572: 2392:

in the world. So I expect ArbCom examines the case thoroughly and handle it fairly.--

2266: 2235: 2144: 1264: 1135: 907: 627: 6503:

is topic-banned from Macedonia-related articles and their talk pages, as defined in

6442:

is topic-banned from Macedonia-related articles and their talk pages, as defined in

3894:

This is hard to show as this is shown by an absence of diffs so here's another view:

2475: 7153: 6536: 6523: 6304:-ing a situation to head towards stalemate resolution will be highly frowned upon. 6238: 5795: 5773: 5686: 5342: 5273: 5105: 5099: 4954: 4024: 4020: 3998: 3821: 3759:

Republic of Macedonia: The independent state by itself which was part of Yugoslavia

3641: 3458: 3398: 3196: 3188: 3180: 2910: 2864: 2790: 2646: 2606: 2543: 2369: 2104: 2082: 2019: 1985: 1962: 1942: 1814: 1802: 1754: 1751: 1491: 1424: 1403: 1381: 1230: 1093: 979: 680: 643: 515: 5175:, specifically Greek-speaking Usenet users, to support his position on Knowledge. 5086:) engaged in inappropriate canvassing after being warned about original research. 1797:

3. How the name issue of the existing "Macedonias" should be treated from now on.

7558: 4981: 3807: 3793: 3520: 3414: 3326: 3184: 3061:

3.1) Knowledge content issues —including naming conventions— are governed by its

2804: 2679: 2322: 2310:(that's not a "Greek nationalist" thing to say, but people called me that in WP) 2305: 1913: 1036: 827: 736: 6691:

Scientology case, May 2009 for WP:BLP violations and inappropriate sysop actions

6208:

the dispute over naming is concerned. Editors enforcing a case where a binding

4121:

in a topic in which he was heavily involved. ChrisO then edited the MoS leaving

7888: 7823: 7802: 7678: 7657: 7636: 7359: 7114: 6500: 6301: 6158: 5772:, but also in unrelated or loosely related ancient/Byzantine Greek pages, e.g. 5471: 5193: 5172: 5155: 5111: 5093: 3368: 3322: 3192: 3172: 3097: 3089: 2892: 2588: 2357: 2207: 2060: 1905: 1723: 1703: 1672: 1652: 1464: 1302: 1245: 1150: 1116: 960: 7342:(All related articles under 1RR whenever the dispute over naming is concerned) 4748:

Future Perfect at Sunrise's block of Sadbuttrue92 and warning by an arbitrator

2364:, since the dispute is over the name (not the existence of the state, like in 2288: 338: 7920: 7652: 7186: 7100: 6938: 6188:

All related articles under 1RR whenever the dispute over naming is concerned

5752: 5489: 5435: 5352: 5240: 5226: 5207: 5144: 5129: 3572: 3559: 3555: 3220: 3176: 3117: 2979: 2951: 2932: 2877: 2841: 2735: 2712: 2623: 2559: 2389: 2222: 2112: 1707: 1283: 922: 884: 850: 659: 6937:

26) Single-purpose accounts are strongly advised to edit in accordance with

5294:

Alfadog777 is a Macedonia-focused single purpose account who has edit-warred

3732:

He also states the move was delayed because he was on international travel.

2335:"chances are there isn't that great of a need to move it in the first place" 2227:

Is Knowledge now written by the admins, do they get to chose the names only?

2186:

about the reason (in addition to ignoring the talk page). Then he moved the

342: 6439: 6420: 6296: 5073: 5016: 4111: 3636:

1) While the disputes presented in this case are very similar to issues in

3295: 3216: 3093: 2675: 2426: 2140: 1772:

This issue has many dimensions and should all be dealt with by the ArbCom.

1747: 1417:

Response to FloNight, bainer (arbitrators), Fut (involved party) and others

1174: 1131: 903: 6161:), especially since there are significant problems in reaching consensus. 5736:

IP edits, and leads to a battleground mentality among registered editors.

5453:

in the case workshop he calls an attempt at updating guidelines "sabotage"

3749:

3) There are four meanings for "Macedonia" pertinent to this arbitration:

3329:

to views held by a relatively small minority of commentators or scholars.

2360:

as it can be. "Republic of Macedonia" is not the neutral solution either,

1999: 509: 6150: 6139: 5005: 4698: 3644:), the core dispute in this arbitration concerns Macedonia as defined in 3591: 3253: 2906: 2855: 2831: 2781: 2753: 2642: 2534: 2442: 2245: 2195: 2070: 1929: 1866: 1858: 1810: 1706:. There are dozens of similar examples, "United States of America" =: --> 1669:

treating this like any ordinary case is not going to produce good results

1639: 1578: 1551: 1226: 675: 7325:

Motion: Removal of Unused and Unusual Remedies, Macedonia (October 2023)

3018:, lack of respect for other editors, failure to work towards consensus, 6683:

Israeli apartheid case, September 2006 for abuse of administrator tools

6542: 5898:. It has even come from official sources such as the Greek Parliament: 5277: 4977: 4079: 3948: 3079: 3000: 2518: 2506: 2338: 2221:

which I discussed too. That can be reverted. Rather ChrisO was bold in

2108: 1909: 1615:

P.S.: For what it's worth, my views on the content issue are expressed

732: 2238:? The first result from Google to anyone uninformed on the matters of 1857:), but then complain loudly when others identify them as Greek (as at 1833:

motivation for the uncompromising stand of the nationalist editors as

1336:

on the application of the name "Republic of Macedonia" on the article

7884: 4502:

that closed on April 18, 2009 as "no consensus". After that closing,

4214: 4185: 3708: 3690: 2454: 2258: 2191: 2175: 1711: 1690: 1540: 1443: 1357: 62: 3438:

19) Excessive formalistic and legalistic argument over policies and

2409:

On 9 April I commented on the gestating arbitration at Talk:Greece (

7883:) for sockpuppeting in circumvention of topic ban, along with sock 7267:

policies guiding administrative acts in areas where one is involved

6355: 6336: 5431: 5348: 5087: 2457:. Even Future Perfect commenting on ChrisO's actions called them a 1539:

page, and I don't even have yet a formed opinion over moving it to

1398: 1342: 846: 340: 5057:

where he thinks FPAS is Greek and asks if he is of "Greek blood".

7363: 5337: 4631:

Passed 12 to 0 (with 2 abstentions) at 21:29, 11 June 2009 (UTC)

3649: 3452: 3388:

also deprecates the use of full formal names in article titles.

2422: 2270: 2262: 2214: 2171: 1169: 7109:

Passed 11 to 0 (with 1 abstention) at 21:29, 11 June 2009 (UTC)

6946:

Passed 13 to 0 (with 1 abstentions) at 21:29, 11 June 2009 (UTC)

6767:

Passed 12 to 0 (with 2 abstentions) at 21:29, 11 June 2009 (UTC)

6550:

Passed 10 to 3 (with 1 abstentions) at 21:29, 11 June 2009 (UTC)

6166:

Passed 12 to 0 (with 2 abstentions) at 21:29, 11 June 2009 (UTC)

5725:

Passed 10 to 2 (with 2 abstentions) at 21:29, 11 June 2009 (UTC)

5332:

Passed 12 to 0 (with 2 abstentions) at 21:29, 11 June 2009 (UTC)

5288:

Passed 12 to 0 (with 2 abstentions) at 21:29, 11 June 2009 (UTC)

4967:) has been disruptive during the arbitration case; specifically 4901:

Passed 12 to 0 (with 2 abstentions) at 21:29, 11 June 2009 (UTC)

4849:

Passed 12 to 0 (with 2 abstentions) at 21:29, 11 June 2009 (UTC)

4742:

Passed 11 to 0 (with 2 abstentions) at 21:29, 11 June 2009 (UTC)

4481:

Passed 12 to 0 (with 2 abstentions) at 21:29, 11 June 2009 (UTC)

3928:

Passed 11 to 0 (with 3 abstentions) at 21:29, 11 June 2009 (UTC)

3922:(tweak to summary at MOSMAC, which subsequently remained stable) 3700:

This required him to delete the previous page at that location,

3675:

2) The immediate precursor to this arbitration was two edits by

3665:

Passed 11 to 1 (with 2 abstentions) at 21:29, 11 June 2009 (UTC)

3205:

Passed 6 to 5 (with 3 abstentions) at 21:29, 11 June 2009 (UTC)

2166:

we finally spitted for the adjective to have it's own page like

6965:

Passed 8 to 4 (with 2 abstentions) at 21:29, 11 June 2009 (UTC)

6916:

Passed 7 to 2 (with 2 abstentions) at 21:29, 11 June 2009 (UTC)

6840:

Passed 8 to 2 (with 3 abstentions) at 21:29, 11 June 2009 (UTC)

6698:

Passed 9 to 3 (with 2 abstentions) at 21:29, 11 June 2009 (UTC)

6618:

Passed 13 to 0 (with 1 abstention) at 21:29, 11 June 2009 (UTC)

6531:

Passed 9 to 0 (with 5 abstentions) at 21:29, 11 June 2009 (UTC)

6512:

Passed 11 to 0 (with 1 abstention) at 21:29, 11 June 2009 (UTC)

6428:

Passed 13 to 0 (with 1 abstention) at 21:29, 11 June 2009 (UTC)

6367:

Passed 13 to 0 (with 1 abstention) at 21:29, 11 June 2009 (UTC)

6314:

Passed 7 to 5 (with 2 abstentions) at 21:29, 11 June 2009 (UTC)

6269:

Passed 13 to 0 (with 1 abstention) at 21:29, 11 June 2009 (UTC)

5833:

Passed 10 to 3 (with 1 abstention) at 21:29, 11 June 2009 (UTC)

5248:

Passed 9 to 2 (with 3 abstentions) at 21:29, 11 June 2009 (UTC)

5215:

Passed 10 to 3 (with 1 abstention) at 21:29, 11 June 2009 (UTC)

5062:

Passed 13 to 0 (with 1 abstention) at 21:29, 11 June 2009 (UTC)

5000:

Passed 9 to 0 (with 5 abstentions) at 21:29, 11 June 2009 (UTC)

4943:

Passed 8 to 0 (with 5 abstentions) at 21:29, 11 June 2009 (UTC)

4752:

21) On April 21, 2009, the day before this arbitration opened,

4537:

Passed 9 to 2 (with 3 abstentions) at 21:29, 11 June 2009 (UTC)

4367:

Passed 8 to 2 (with 4 abstentions) at 21:29, 11 June 2009 (UTC)

4174:

Passed 9 to 0 (with 5 abstentions) at 21:29, 11 June 2009 (UTC)

3968:

Passed 12 to 0 (with 1 abstention) at 21:29, 11 June 2009 (UTC)

3939: 3853: 3739:

Passed 13 to 0 (with 1 abstention) at 21:29, 11 June 2009 (UTC)

3567:

Passed 11 to 2 (with 1 abstention) at 21:29, 11 June 2009 (UTC)

3544:

Passed 13 to 0 (with 1 abstention) at 21:29, 11 June 2009 (UTC)

3486:

Passed 12 to 0 (with 1 abstention) at 21:29, 11 June 2009 (UTC)

3447:

Passed 7 to 4 (with 3 abstentions) at 21:29, 11 June 2009 (UTC)

3232:

Passed 13 to 0 (with 1 abstention) at 21:29, 11 June 2009 (UTC)

3161:

Passed 13 to 0 (with 1 abstention) at 21:29, 11 June 2009 (UTC)

3125:

Passed 13 to 0 (with 1 abstention) at 21:29, 11 June 2009 (UTC)

2365: 2283:

right now on the news (elections, NATO & EU ascension, etc)

1715: 1586: 1547: 1337: 343: 7144:

2.1) All articles involved in this conflict remain subject to

6489:

Passed 9 to 4 (with 1 abstention) at 21:29, 11 June 2009 (UTC)

6470:

Passed 8 to 5 (with 1 abstention) at 21:29, 11 June 2009 (UTC)

4403:

Passed 7 to 6 (with 1 abstention) at 21:29, 11 June 2009 (UTC)

3466:

Passed 9 to 4 (with 1 abstention) at 21:29, 11 June 2009 (UTC)

2274: 1896:

on following Knowledge policy using consistent wikilawyering,

1801:

ChirsO. What will the difference be from the last dictates of

1376:

involved party, and that I have commented on ChrisO's actions

344: 6687:

Kosovo case, October 2006 for edit warring and rollback abuse

6404:(Kekrops) is banned from the English Knowledge for one year. 5457:

User:Former Abbreviated Username of Future Perfect at Sunrise

3982:

was set up on March 30, 2009 to track instances of the link "

2167: 504:

Knowledge:Administrators' noticeboard/Arbitration enforcement

500:

Knowledge:Requests for arbitration#Requests for clarification

2852:

We can just move this to the injunction, no need to revote.

1594:

filibustering with people advocating nationally-based POVs.

3703:. Then, on April 16, 2009, he moved a country article from 3504:

represent a best practice approach for such circumstances.

2352:

resorted to temporary solutions, and Knowledge is not on a

7366:, broadly construed, continues to be a contentious topic. 2303:

for the actual English common usage of the word Macedonia.

1332:

I'll be as brief as I can. After an extensive edit-war, a

495: 7156:". Such sanctions may be appealed in accordance with the 5681:

Shadowmorph is a Macedonia-focused single purpose account

4723:

a discussion at the administrators' incidents noticeboard

5188:

SQRT5P1D2 is a Macedonia-focused single-purposed account

2293:

finding new statistical arguments WP could use elsewhere

2174:(an improvement). ChrisO made two moves. First he moved 1849:

illustrate. They self-identify themselves as Greek (as

1364:

page. Unfortunately, this discussion bore no fruit, and

6971:

Disputed article movement/renaming injunction extension

6155:

Geopolitical ethnic and religious conflicts noticeboard

5221:

Radjenef is a Macedonia-focused single-purposed account

2349: 1886:

of these issues is relevant to the discussion at hand.

7302:, or which is inconsistent with the principles of the 7010:, or which is inconsistent with the principles of the 6261: 4907:

Future Perfect at Sunrise is an involved administrator

3711:. ChrisO made this pagemove without prior discussion, 2481:

Arbitrators' opinion on hearing this matter (13/0/0/0)

6545:

is admonished for releasing private correspondence.

6423:

is banned from the English Knowledge for six months.

4637:

Future Perfect at Sunrise's stated intent to edit war

3223:

for endorsement or review. This does not comply with

2242:

is always the Knowledge entry named "Macedonia". So,

7571:). I've reverted the move and move-locked the page. 6976: 6504: 6443: 6382: 6359: 6339:is banned from the English Knowledge for one year. 5276:and has continued to edit war after a block ended. 5045:(note "Fyromian" is considered offensive by many), 2421:constant problems, and harm does come out of it. - 2413:, scroll down: it's the last comment of the page). 2254:"Macedonia" is used in a wide context (chronically) 7275:Passed 11 to 0 on 15:09, 16:40, 19 June 2011 (UTC) 4713:to replies to that comment by saying that he was: 3419:18) The purpose of disambiguation, as defined by 1573:Statement by Fut.Perf. (Future Perfect at Sunrise) 7030:Link to the results of the centralized discussion 6075:Examples of disruption with an anti-Greek focus. 5486:User talk:Greece666#If you are Greek, I'm Martian 4891:"I mean, does anybody seriously expect I'm still 4432:) has been incivil, intimidating, and insulting. 7918: 6975:29) No Macedonia-related article, as defined in 6846:Future Perfect at Sunrise temporarily desysopped 4373:ChrisO restricted in the Scientology arbitration 4015:Previous attempts to reach consensus have failed 3756:Macedonia (ancient kingdom), also called Macedon 2317:article, that is by itself a reason to say that 494:Once the case is closed, editors may add to the 7351: 4925:) is an administrator involved in this dispute. 4780:) because Sadbuttrue92 was harassing him. FPAS 4342:ChrisO's admits being an involved administrator 4230:ChrisO's involvement in Balkan-related articles 4217:, he did so without first obtaining consensus. 2348:. Let me just say that other neutrals like the 7210:Knowledge:Requests for arbitration/Macedonia 2 6831:to one month. All blocks are to be logged at 6526:is admonished for disruption and incivility. 4123:'template convention, mirroring RoM guideline' 7899:Knowledge:Sockpuppet investigations/SQRT5P1D2 5856:. Nationalistic fervor and insulting others: 4725:, Future Perfect at Sunrise said there that: 3938:6) In late March 2009, the status quo at the 3321:14) Article content must be presented from a 374: 7294:explained by reference to the principles of 4855:Future Perfect at Sunrise's User Conduct RFC 4021:Manual of Style (Macedonia-related articles) 3248:Passed 14 to 0 at 21:29, 11 June 2009 (UTC) 1348:Pending the filing of the case, User:ChrisO 7181:Passed 12 to 0 at 21:29, 11 June 2009 (UTC) 7165:Passed 12 to 0 at 21:29, 11 June 2009 (UTC) 7134:Passed 12 to 0 at 21:29, 11 June 2009 (UTC) 7126: 7023:Passed 11 to 2 at 21:29, 11 June 2009 (UTC) 6984:Passed 14 to 0 at 21:29, 11 June 2009 (UTC) 6832: 6451:Passed 14 to 0 at 21:29, 11 June 2009 (UTC) 6409:Passed 12 to 2 at 21:29, 11 June 2009 (UTC) 6390:Passed 14 to 0 at 21:29, 11 June 2009 (UTC) 6249:Passed 13 to 0 at 21:29, 11 June 2009 (UTC) 6222:Passed 13 to 0 at 21:29, 11 June 2009 (UTC) 6182:Passed 13 to 0 at 21:29, 11 June 2009 (UTC) 6134:Passed 10 to 0 at 21:29, 11 June 2009 (UTC) 6114:Passed 14 to 0 at 21:29, 11 June 2009 (UTC) 5892:. Search and replace tools are often used: 5784:Passed 14 to 0 at 21:29, 11 June 2009 (UTC) 5675:Passed 14 to 0 at 21:29, 11 June 2009 (UTC) 5511:Passed 14 to 0 at 21:29, 11 June 2009 (UTC) 5420:Passed 14 to 0 at 21:29, 11 June 2009 (UTC) 5182:Passed 14 to 0 at 21:29, 11 June 2009 (UTC) 5139:Passed 14 to 0 at 21:29, 11 June 2009 (UTC) 4487:Future Perfect at Sunrise's redirection of 4336:Passed 13 to 0 at 21:29, 11 June 2009 (UTC) 4264:Passed 14 to 0 at 21:29, 11 June 2009 (UTC) 4224:Passed 14 to 0 at 21:29, 11 June 2009 (UTC) 4074:Passed 14 to 0 at 21:29, 11 June 2009 (UTC) 4009:Passed 13 to 0 at 21:29, 11 June 2009 (UTC) 3993:Passed 14 to 0 at 21:29, 11 June 2009 (UTC) 3958:shows how it spilled to non-Greece articles 3943:assumptions of bad faith, personal attacks/ 3841:Passed 14 to 0 at 21:29, 11 June 2009 (UTC) 3768:Passed 14 to 0 at 21:29, 11 June 2009 (UTC) 3621:Passed 12 to 0 at 21:29, 11 June 2009 (UTC) 3605:Passed 14 to 0 at 21:29, 11 June 2009 (UTC) 3586:Passed 14 to 0 at 21:29, 11 June 2009 (UTC) 3528:Passed 14 to 0 at 21:29, 11 June 2009 (UTC) 3509:Passed 12 to 0 at 21:29, 11 June 2009 (UTC) 3428:Passed 14 to 0 at 21:29, 11 June 2009 (UTC) 3409:Passed 14 to 0 at 21:29, 11 June 2009 (UTC) 3393:Passed 14 to 0 at 21:29, 11 June 2009 (UTC) 3353:Passed 14 to 0 at 21:29, 11 June 2009 (UTC) 3334:Passed 14 to 0 at 21:29, 11 June 2009 (UTC) 3311:Passed 14 to 0 at 21:29, 11 June 2009 (UTC) 3280:Passed 14 to 0 at 21:29, 11 June 2009 (UTC) 3264:Passed 14 to 0 at 21:29, 11 June 2009 (UTC) 3145:Passed 14 to 0 at 21:29, 11 June 2009 (UTC) 3105:Passed 14 to 0 at 21:29, 11 June 2009 (UTC) 3074:Passed 12 to 0 at 21:29, 11 June 2009 (UTC) 3051:Passed 14 to 0 at 21:29, 11 June 2009 (UTC) 2995:Passed 14 to 0 at 21:29, 11 June 2009 (UTC) 7078:Passed 9 to 5 at 21:29, 11 June 2009 (UTC) 6344:Passed 9 to 5 at 21:29, 11 June 2009 (UTC) 4130:Passed 9 to 0 at 21:29, 11 June 2009 (UTC) 1789:I firmly support that his edits should be 381: 367: 7511:Coat of arms of the Republic of Macedonia 7345: 7285:The Arbitration Committee clarifies that 6209: 4879:an effort to address some of the concerns 3697:, stating that this was a "minor change". 1778:I wholly support that his actions were a 7287:Knowledge:Naming conventions (Macedonia) 7202:Knowledge:Arbitration/Requests/Amendment 5455:; calling an obvious alternate account, 4543:Future Perfect at Sunrise was put on 1RR 1786:2. Whether his edits should be reverted 7727:for editing in violation of topic ban. 6922: 5839:Collective behavior of blocs of editors 5826:. He has also expressed regret for it. 5465:accusing others of an intent to deceive 3472:Collective behavior of blocs of editors 3243:understand what has been done and why. 3167:Use of administrator tools in a dispute 2969:Passed 10 to 0 at 09:18, 19 April 2009. 1780:direct breach of 4 out of the 5 pillars 502:, and report violations of remedies at 14: 7919: 6046:with related POV or pejorative terms. 4721:After the first comment was raised in 496:#Log of blocks, bans, and restrictions 7383:Log of blocks, bans, and restrictions 5426:Avg's assumptions about other editors 5394:(calling opponent's edit vandalism), 4037:how it spilled to tangential articles 3934:Challenge to the Macedonia status-quo 7373:Passed 8 to 0 with 1 abstention by 7158:ARBMAC discretionary appeals process 6773:Future Perfect at Sunrise restricted 6704:Future Perfect at Sunrise admonished 6212:has been found are exempt from 1RR. 5488:. More evidence of lack of assuming 4526:this is what the article looked like 4516:), who had participated in the AFD, 4414:Future Perfect at Sunrise's behavior 3836:are essays, not Knowledge policies. 3645: 3638:the first Macedonia arbitration case 3177:biographies of living persons policy 3120:that follows Knowledge's policies. 3020:disrupting Knowledge to make a point 1710:, "Commonwealth of Australia" =: --> 154:Clarification and Amendment requests 7555:Coat of arms of Macedonia (country) 6495:SQRT5P1D2 topic-banned for one year 5731:IP Editors have disrupted Knowledge 4976:and sent a very demeaning email to 4883:argued at the conclusion of the RFC 3096:, or other inappropriate behavior. 30: 5272:) has edit-warred disruptively on 2436:Statement by Dr.K. (Tasoskessaris) 1530:Statement by Man with one red shoe 31: 18:Knowledge:Requests for arbitration 7938: 6434:Reaper7 topic-banned for one year 6373:Kekrops topic-banned indefinitely 6262:appeal of discretionary sanctions 5316:to push a Greek nationalist POV. 4622:for edit warring on the article. 3598:inappropriate forms of canvassing 2362:but the very one that is disputed 2329:was broken by the move. It cites 2325:situation. Besides the policy on 7573:Chase me ladies, I'm the Cavalry 6484:is admonished for edit warring. 6465:is admonished for edit warring. 4875:user conduct Request For Comment 3826:frustration was already apparent 3521:user-conduct request for comment 3515:Request for comment/User conduct 2059:I reiterate my brief comment on 1714:, "United Mexican States" =: --> 61: 7377:at 03:15, 19 October 2023 (UTC) 7095:ChrisO's administrator status 2 7087:at 03:15, 19 October 2023 (UTC) 6990:Establishing consensus on names 6977:#All related articles under 1RR 6933:Single-purpose accounts advised 6323:at 03:15, 19 October 2023 (UTC) 6231:at 03:15, 19 October 2023 (UTC) 5150:SQRT5P1D2 solicited meatpuppets 4786:blank the entry by Sadbuttrue92 4522:he redirected the article again 4213:, which was move protected, to 3481:evidence of bad-faith editing. 3292:Knowledge:Neutral point of view 2287:In the time pressure, I had to 2244:ChrisO's move can be seen as a 435:on 03:15, 19 October 2023 (UTC) 6505:All related articles under 1RR 6444:All related articles under 1RR 6383:All related articles under 1RR 6360:All related articles under 1RR 5904:. Specific types of examples: 3671:Immediate precursor of dispute 3434:Wikilawyering and stonewalling 3057:Knowledge's content governance 2249:, not an administrative move. 2046:(stable for the last 7 years) 13: 1: 6415:Reaper7 banned for six months 6350:Avg topic-banned indefinitely 6120:ChrisO's administrator status 5446:intent to edit war til banned 5068:Reaper7 engaged in canvassing 5031:Knowledge:No personal attacks 4085:ChrisO's change of a template 3856:and Greece-related articles. 2319:there is no single main topic 1845:, and (my personal favorite) 1689:Personally I was hoping that 397:on 03:06, 22 April 2009 (UTC) 7452:Ethnic Macedonian literature 7354:(Administrative supervision) 7331:The following remedies from 7319:at 14:30, 17 June 2018 (UTC) 7265:is reminded to abide by the 6925:on 16:37, 19 June 2011 (UTC) 6145:Seek neutral outside opinion 4270:ChrisO previously admonished 3386:Knowledge:Naming conventions 3365:Knowledge:Naming conventions 3300:common English language name 3270:Edit wars considered harmful 3238:Administrator communications 3193:neutral point of view policy 3151:Disruption by administrators 2344:The naming dispute might be 2295:. Please see my discussions 424:on 14:30, 17 June 2018 (UTC) 413:on 16:40, 19 June 2011 (UTC) 405:on 21:29, 11 June 2009 (UTC) 285:Conflict of interest reports 7: 7927:Knowledge arbitration cases 7909:06:53, 18 August 2009 (UTC) 7393:Macedonian culture (Slavic) 7120:Enforcement of 1RR by block 6396:Kekrops banned for one year 5790:Yannismarou has edit warred 5415:(during these proceedings) 5011:Personal attacks by Reaper7 3534:Sanctions and circumstances 3373:verifiable reliable sources 3304:verifiable reliable sources 3217:administrators' noticeboard 3063:internal editorial policies 3007:Knowledge's code of conduct 2333:as a good example and says 2219:Macedonia (ancient kingdom) 1460:Talk:Macedonia#Article move 114:Search archived proceedings 10: 7943: 7498:per the above injunction. 7439:per the above injunction. 7358:Editors are reminded that 7036:Administrative supervision 4119:several days of discussion 3695:Macedonia (disambiguation) 2962:11:52, 19 April 2009 (UTC) 2947:02:00, 19 April 2009 (UTC) 2928:22:50, 18 April 2009 (UTC) 2915:14:53, 18 April 2009 (UTC) 2902:14:40, 18 April 2009 (UTC) 2884:13:28, 18 April 2009 (UTC) 2872:13:21, 18 April 2009 (UTC) 2848:13:20, 18 April 2009 (UTC) 2836:11:41, 18 April 2009 (UTC) 2826:11:37, 18 April 2009 (UTC) 2813:11:34, 18 April 2009 (UTC) 2798:11:28, 18 April 2009 (UTC) 2758:09:41, 21 April 2009 (UTC) 2744:19:08, 19 April 2009 (UTC) 2727:14:38, 18 April 2009 (UTC) 2704:11:37, 18 April 2009 (UTC) 2688:00:11, 18 April 2009 (UTC) 2664:Macedonia (disambiguation) 2651:23:10, 17 April 2009 (UTC) 2634:18:21, 17 April 2009 (UTC) 2615:16:31, 17 April 2009 (UTC) 2598:16:19, 17 April 2009 (UTC) 2581:12:46, 17 April 2009 (UTC) 2566:10:57, 17 April 2009 (UTC) 2551:10:01, 17 April 2009 (UTC) 2522:13:18, 17 April 2009 (UTC) 2510:03:23, 17 April 2009 (UTC) 2494:03:15, 17 April 2009 (UTC) 2471:00:05, 21 April 2009 (UTC) 2447:We Don't Need Another Hero 2431:19:30, 21 April 2009 (UTC) 2400:02:43, 21 April 2009 (UTC) 2378:18:40, 20 April 2009 (UTC) 2180:Macedonia (disambiguation) 2149:17:57, 20 April 2009 (UTC) 2124:23:53, 17 April 2009 (UTC) 2090:21:44, 17 April 2009 (UTC) 1994:23:51, 19 April 2009 (UTC) 1971:15:54, 19 April 2009 (UTC) 1951:13:13, 17 April 2009 (UTC) 1918:13:00, 17 April 2009 (UTC) 1819:14:03, 19 April 2009 (UTC) 1763:09:44, 17 April 2009 (UTC) 1728:08:10, 17 April 2009 (UTC) 1679:15:02, 17 April 2009 (UTC) 1659:07:02, 17 April 2009 (UTC) 1627:11:55, 17 April 2009 (UTC) 1610:06:04, 17 April 2009 (UTC) 1568:05:04, 17 April 2009 (UTC) 1525:07:31, 18 April 2009 (UTC) 1508:07:31, 17 April 2009 (UTC) 1498:is found to be faulty. -- 1478:07:03, 17 April 2009 (UTC) 1433:01:03, 18 April 2009 (UTC) 1412:03:42, 17 April 2009 (UTC) 1390:03:00, 17 April 2009 (UTC) 441:Watchlist all case pages: 159:Arbitrator motion requests 32: 7819:00:24, 23 July 2009 (UTC) 7748:12:41, 25 June 2009 (UTC) 7674:03:12, 17 June 2009 (UTC) 7214:Future Perfect at Sunrise 6853:Future Perfect at Sunrise 6779:Future Perfect at Sunrise 6710:Future Perfect at Sunrise 6255:Uninvolved administrators 4913:Future Perfect at Sunrise 4861:Future Perfect at Sunrise 4754:Future Perfect at Sunrise 4643:Future Perfect at Sunrise 4553:Future Perfect at Sunrise 4504:Future Perfect at Sunrise 4420:Future_Perfect_at_Sunrise 4409:Future Perfect at Sunrise 4146:Future Perfect at Sunrise 4107:in a protected template, 3774:Macedonia Manual of Style 3502:Knowledge:Requested moves 3084:4) Knowledge relies on a 2383:Statement by Caspian blue 2065:my rather visual analysis 1880:2007 Fort Dix attack plot 1873:and was forced to revert 771:Future Perfect at Sunrise 7581:17:51, 6 June 2009 (UTC) 6952:Tighten the abuse filter 5314:List of national animals 3652:; see, for example, the 3492:Controversial page moves 3421:Knowledge:Disambiguation 2660:Macedonia naming dispute 2449:, because we are not in 2154:Statement by Shadowmorph 1924:Statement by John Carter 1871:Staffordshire University 1733:Statement by Jack forbes 1328:Statement by Yannismarou 474:Requests for arbitration 411:Case Amended (by motion) 7505:19:59, 5 May 2009 (UTC) 7446:19:59, 5 May 2009 (UTC) 7148:under the terms of the 7146:discretionary sanctions 7140:Discretionary sanctions 7127:#Log of blocks and bans 6833:#Log of blocks and bans 6331:Avg banned for one year 5254:Nick ts has edit-warred 4873:) was the subject of a 4641:20.1) On 2 April 2009, 3611:Return of access levels 3556:Single purpose accounts 3550:Single purpose accounts 3317:Neutral point of view 2 3211:Involved administrators 3131:Administrator standards 2817:With minor copy-edit. 2672:Macedonia (terminology) 2668:Macedonia (terminology) 2315:Macedonia (terminology) 2136:Macedonia (terminology) 2038:I specifically request 1513:Response to Carcharoth. 7653:single-purpose account 7348:(Stalemate resolution) 7289:may be modified by an 7271: 6518:John Carter admonished 5241:single-purpose account 5208:single-purpose account 4731: 4719: 4707: 4518:redirected the article 4205:) subsequently gave a 4136:ChrisO's plan to move 3718:Reactions to this move 2042:to revert back to the 1696:English-speaking world 1633:Statement by Heimstern 7304:neutral point of view 7206: 7101:request for adminship 7012:neutral point of view 6476:Alfadog777 admonished 6210:#Stalemate resolution 5979:(note edit summary), 4949:John Carter and Taivo 4727: 4715: 4703: 4329:previously admonished 4211:Republic of Macedonia 4182:Republic of Macedonia 4138:Republic of Macedonia 4125:as an edit summary. 3984:republic of macedonia 3705:Republic of Macedonia 3323:neutral point of view 3286:Neutral point of view 3221:incidents noticeboard 2476:Preliminary decisions 2337:. Another example is 2279:Republic of Macedonia 2275:stats for August 2008 2188:Republic of Macedonia 2162:after bold edits and 2098:Statement by Jim62sch 1956:Addition to statement 1537:Republic of Macedonia 1535:don't even watch the 1354:Republic of Macedonia 752:Man with one red shoe 355:Track related changes 215:Arbitration Committee 55:Knowledge Arbitration 7799:blocked indefinitely 7725:blocked for 24 hours 7633:blocked indefinitely 6275:Stalemate resolution 6038:Replacing the term " 5492:and wiki-lawyering: 5461:"disruptive purpose" 4889:". FPAS also stated 4842:not to do this again 4571:William M. Connolley 4565:) was put on 1RR on 4496:Macedonians (Greeks) 4489:Macedonians (Greeks) 4207:rational explanation 3847:Macedonia status-quo 3579:strongly discouraged 3367:states: "Generally, 3197:verifiability policy 3111:Consensus can change 2985:Purpose of Knowledge 2767:Temporary injunction 2313:If WP has to have a 2223:deciding and locking 2129:Statement by Politis 1889:Finally, we come to 1452:Main Page recently. 1323:Requests for comment 164:Enforcement requests 92:Guide to arbitration 6044:Macedonian language 5808:) has edit warred. 5517:Kekrops' disruption 5124:User:Giorgos_Tzimas 4551:of April 18, 2009, 4547:19) As a result of 3824:. Four days later, 3346:disrupt the editing 3340:Tendentious editing 3173:sockpuppetry policy 3067:Knowledge consensus 2331:Republic of Ireland 2327:WP:Naming conflicts 2321:It's just like the 2204:Bulgaria (religion) 2160:the guardians there 2055:Statement by Húsönd 1768:Statement by GK1973 1438:Statement by ChrisO 1343:consensually agreed 7315:Passed 10 to 0 by 7296:naming conventions 7281:Motion (June 2018) 7192:Motion (June 2011) 7004:naming conventions 6457:Nick ts admonished 6297:dispute resolution 5539:personal attacks. 5278:Contributions here 5118:User:Tasoskessaris 4567:Miladinov Brothers 4041:straw poll results 4033:read the summaries 3962:straw poll results 3954:read the summaries 3560:focus on one topic 3359:Naming Conventions 3044:appropriate forums 3024:offensive language 2277:, and the name of 2261:like they do with 2240:Macedonia (region) 2088: 1984:was his response. 1824:Statement by Taivo 489:/Proposed decision 186:Contentious topics 84:Arbitration policy 7869:blocked indef by 7801:for POV-pushing. 7073: 7072: 6997:naming convention 6624:ChrisO desysopped 6556:ChrisO admonished 6309: 6308: 6217: 6216: 6172:Scope of remedies 4500:subject of an AFD 4140:was pre-disclosed 3040:assume good faith 3038:, and failure to 3036:gaming the system 2960: 2632: 2469: 2267:Georgia (country) 2200:Greece (religion) 2068: 1902:WP:IDIDNTHEARTHAT 1898:WP:JUSTDONTLIKEIT 1685:Statement by PMK1 1592:WP:IDIDNTHEARTHAT 1395:Response to Coren 468: 391: 390: 358: 326: 196:General sanctions 144:All open requests 74:About arbitration 24:Knowledge:ARBMAC2 22:(Redirected from 7934: 7868: 7841:deleted contribs 7809: 7797: 7770:deleted contribs 7746: 7743: 7737: 7732: 7723: 7696:deleted contribs 7664: 7630: 7603:deleted contribs 7552: 7534: 7502: 7493: 7475: 7443: 7434: 7416: 7308:reliable sources 7264: 7171:Community review 7125:to be logged at 7041: 7040: 7016:reliable sources 6958:Abuse filter 119 6903: 6829: 6760: 6680: 6612: 6537:Taivo admonished 6446:, for one year. 6280: 6279: 6239:Tagging articles 6193: 6192: 6151:outside opinions 5774:Cyril and Method 5753:a set from an IP 5343:Avg's disruption 5274:2008 Greek riots 5106:User:Yannismarou 5100:User:Shadowmorph 4840: 4693: 4621: 4393:Findings of fact 4326: 4209:of why he moved 4116: 4110: 3980:Abuse Filter 119 3974:Abuse Filter 119 3646:#Four Macedonias 3642:Knowledge:ARBMAC 3632:Locus of dispute 3627:Findings of fact 3181:vandalism policy 3016:personal attacks 2959: 2956: 2955: 2899: 2870: 2867: 2834: 2823: 2796: 2793: 2756: 2701: 2631: 2628: 2627: 2595: 2549: 2546: 2465: 2231:a new status quo 2121: 2118: 2115: 2105:User:John Carter 2087: 2085: 2079: 2075: 2073: 2020:ethnic profiling 2000:Statement by Avg 1673:Heimstern Läufer 1653:Heimstern Läufer 1564: 1496:policy rationale 1366:edit wars ensued 1298:(naming dispute) 1279:(naming dispute) 1260:(naming dispute) 1241:(naming dispute) 1222:(naming dispute) 1220: 1165:(naming dispute) 1146:(naming dispute) 1127:(naming dispute) 1108:(naming dispute) 1089:(naming dispute) 1087: 1032:(naming dispute) 1030: 975:(naming dispute) 956:(naming dispute) 937:(naming dispute) 918:(naming dispute) 899:(naming dispute) 880:(naming dispute) 861:(naming dispute) 842:(naming dispute) 823:(naming dispute) 821: 766:(naming dispute) 747:(naming dispute) 728:(naming dispute) 726: 624: 566: 510:Involved parties 467: 466: 439: 430:Case amended by 419:Case amended by 383: 376: 369: 357: 352: 345: 324: 280:Clerk procedures 272: 230: 201:Editor sanctions 178:Active sanctions 136:Open proceedings 106: 65: 51: 50: 45: 27: 7942: 7941: 7937: 7936: 7935: 7933: 7932: 7931: 7917: 7916: 7826: 7816: 7803: 7755: 7741: 7733: 7730: 7728: 7681: 7671: 7658: 7588: 7525: 7509: 7500: 7466: 7450: 7441: 7407: 7391: 7385: 7369: 7368: 7335:are rescinded: 7327: 7283: 7216: 7208:Remedy 25.3 of 7194: 7189: 7173: 7142: 7122: 7117: 7097: 7074: 7049: 7038: 6992: 6973: 6954: 6935: 6855: 6848: 6781: 6775: 6712: 6706: 6632: 6626: 6564: 6558: 6539: 6520: 6497: 6478: 6459: 6436: 6417: 6398: 6375: 6352: 6333: 6310: 6288: 6277: 6257: 6241: 6218: 6201: 6190: 6174: 6147: 6142: 6122: 5841: 5792: 5733: 5683: 5519: 5428: 5345: 5340: 5296: 5256: 5223: 5190: 5152: 5147: 5070: 5029:) has violated 5013: 5008: 4951: 4909: 4857: 4792: 4750: 4645: 4639: 4573: 4549:this 3RR report 4545: 4530:looks like this 4528:. It presently 4492: 4416: 4411: 4375: 4344: 4278: 4272: 4232: 4189: 4142: 4114: 4108: 4087: 4082: 4017: 4001: 3976: 3936: 3849: 3776: 3747: 3745:Four Macedonias 3673: 3634: 3629: 3613: 3594: 3575: 3552: 3536: 3517: 3494: 3474: 3455: 3436: 3417: 3401: 3399:Naming disputes 3361: 3342: 3319: 3288: 3272: 3256: 3240: 3213: 3185:civility policy 3169: 3153: 3133: 3113: 3082: 3059: 3003: 2987: 2982: 2977: 2953: 2952: 2893: 2865: 2853: 2832:John Vandenberg 2830: 2819: 2791: 2779: 2769: 2754:John Vandenberg 2752: 2697: 2625: 2624: 2589: 2544: 2532: 2483: 2478: 2438: 2407: 2405:Statement by Ev 2385: 2323:American (word) 2306:Macedonia, Ohio 2289:become creative 2156: 2131: 2119: 2116: 2113: 2100: 2083: 2081: 2077: 2071: 2069: 2057: 2044:status quo ante 2002: 1958: 1926: 1826: 1770: 1735: 1687: 1649:will not listen 1635: 1575: 1562: 1532: 1440: 1330: 1325: 1317:added by Rlevse 1172: 1039: 982: 773: 678: 576: 518: 512: 469: 442: 440: 436: 425: 414: 406: 398: 387: 353: 347: 346: 341: 331: 330: 329: 318: 301: 291: 290: 289: 276: 268: 256: 231: 226: 217: 207: 206: 205: 180: 170: 169: 168: 138: 128: 125: 110: 102: 80: 49: 48: 41: 37: 29: 28: 21: 20: 12: 11: 5: 7940: 7930: 7929: 7914: 7912: 7911: 7821: 7814: 7750: 7676: 7669: 7583: 7507: 7448: 7384: 7381: 7380: 7379: 7360:Eastern Europe 7356: 7355: 7349: 7343: 7329: 7328: 7326: 7323: 7322: 7321: 7306:policy or the 7300:disambiguation 7282: 7279: 7278: 7277: 7200:voted upon at 7193: 7190: 7188: 7185: 7184: 7183: 7172: 7169: 7168: 7167: 7141: 7138: 7137: 7136: 7121: 7118: 7116: 7113: 7112: 7111: 7096: 7093: 7092: 7091: 7090: 7089: 7071: 7070: 7051: 7050: 7044: 7039: 7037: 7034: 7033: 7032: 7026: 7025: 7014:policy or the 7008:disambiguation 6991: 6988: 6987: 6986: 6972: 6969: 6968: 6967: 6953: 6950: 6949: 6948: 6934: 6931: 6930: 6929: 6928: 6927: 6847: 6844: 6843: 6842: 6774: 6771: 6770: 6769: 6705: 6702: 6701: 6700: 6625: 6622: 6621: 6620: 6557: 6554: 6553: 6552: 6538: 6535: 6534: 6533: 6519: 6516: 6515: 6514: 6507:for one year. 6496: 6493: 6492: 6491: 6477: 6474: 6473: 6472: 6458: 6455: 6454: 6453: 6435: 6432: 6431: 6430: 6416: 6413: 6412: 6411: 6397: 6394: 6393: 6392: 6374: 6371: 6370: 6369: 6351: 6348: 6347: 6346: 6332: 6329: 6328: 6327: 6326: 6325: 6307: 6306: 6290: 6289: 6283: 6278: 6276: 6273: 6272: 6271: 6256: 6253: 6252: 6251: 6240: 6237: 6236: 6235: 6234: 6233: 6215: 6214: 6203: 6202: 6196: 6191: 6189: 6186: 6185: 6184: 6173: 6170: 6169: 6168: 6146: 6143: 6141: 6138: 6137: 6136: 6121: 6118: 6117: 6116: 6110: 6109: 6072: 6071: 6035: 6034: 6000: 5999: 5958: 5957: 5840: 5837: 5836: 5835: 5791: 5788: 5787: 5786: 5732: 5729: 5728: 5727: 5682: 5679: 5678: 5677: 5518: 5515: 5514: 5513: 5427: 5424: 5423: 5422: 5344: 5341: 5339: 5336: 5335: 5334: 5295: 5292: 5291: 5290: 5282:block log here 5255: 5252: 5251: 5250: 5222: 5219: 5218: 5217: 5189: 5186: 5185: 5184: 5151: 5148: 5146: 5143: 5142: 5141: 5112:User:AndreasJS 5094:User:SQRT5P1D2 5069: 5066: 5065: 5064: 5012: 5009: 5007: 5004: 5003: 5002: 4950: 4947: 4946: 4945: 4908: 4905: 4904: 4903: 4856: 4853: 4852: 4851: 4790:Cool Hand Luke 4782:took it to ANI 4749: 4746: 4745: 4744: 4638: 4635: 4634: 4633: 4624:sanctions here 4544: 4541: 4540: 4539: 4491: 4485: 4484: 4483: 4415: 4412: 4410: 4407: 4406: 4405: 4374: 4371: 4370: 4369: 4343: 4340: 4339: 4338: 4271: 4268: 4267: 4266: 4231: 4228: 4227: 4226: 4188: 4178: 4177: 4176: 4141: 4134: 4133: 4132: 4086: 4083: 4081: 4078: 4077: 4076: 4016: 4013: 4012: 4011: 4000: 3997: 3996: 3995: 3975: 3972: 3971: 3970: 3935: 3932: 3931: 3930: 3924: 3923: 3918: 3913: 3908: 3898: 3897: 3896: 3895: 3848: 3845: 3844: 3843: 3775: 3772: 3771: 3770: 3764: 3763: 3760: 3757: 3754: 3746: 3743: 3742: 3741: 3672: 3669: 3668: 3667: 3633: 3630: 3628: 3625: 3624: 3623: 3612: 3609: 3608: 3607: 3593: 3590: 3589: 3588: 3574: 3571: 3570: 3569: 3551: 3548: 3547: 3546: 3535: 3532: 3531: 3530: 3516: 3513: 3512: 3511: 3493: 3490: 3489: 3488: 3473: 3470: 3469: 3468: 3454: 3451: 3450: 3449: 3435: 3432: 3431: 3430: 3416: 3415:Disambiguation 3413: 3412: 3411: 3400: 3397: 3396: 3395: 3369:article naming 3360: 3357: 3356: 3355: 3344:15) Users who 3341: 3338: 3337: 3336: 3318: 3315: 3314: 3313: 3294:states "Where 3287: 3284: 3283: 3282: 3271: 3268: 3267: 3266: 3255: 3252: 3251: 3250: 3239: 3236: 3235: 3234: 3212: 3209: 3208: 3207: 3168: 3165: 3164: 3163: 3152: 3149: 3148: 3147: 3137:Administrators 3132: 3129: 3128: 3127: 3112: 3109: 3108: 3107: 3081: 3078: 3077: 3076: 3058: 3055: 3054: 3053: 3009:is one of the 3002: 2999: 2998: 2997: 2986: 2983: 2981: 2978: 2976: 2975:Final decision 2973: 2972: 2971: 2966: 2965: 2964: 2949: 2930: 2917: 2904: 2890: 2889: 2888: 2887: 2886: 2838: 2828: 2815: 2800: 2768: 2765: 2763: 2761: 2760: 2746: 2729: 2711:per flonight. 2706: 2690: 2653: 2636: 2617: 2600: 2583: 2568: 2553: 2526: 2525: 2524: 2496: 2482: 2479: 2477: 2474: 2437: 2434: 2406: 2403: 2384: 2381: 2208:Yom Kippur War 2155: 2152: 2130: 2127: 2120:sch 2114:Jim 2099: 2096: 2094: 2061:Talk:Macedonia 2056: 2053: 2001: 1998: 1997: 1996: 1957: 1954: 1925: 1922: 1892:the real issue 1825: 1822: 1769: 1766: 1734: 1731: 1704:United Kingdom 1686: 1683: 1682: 1681: 1634: 1631: 1630: 1629: 1585:Regarding the 1574: 1571: 1556:walled gardens 1531: 1528: 1439: 1436: 1362:Talk:Macedonia 1329: 1326: 1324: 1321: 1320: 1319: 1300: 1281: 1262: 1243: 1224: 1167: 1148: 1129: 1110: 1091: 1034: 977: 958: 939: 920: 901: 882: 863: 844: 825: 768: 749: 730: 673: 657: 641: 625: 571: 511: 508: 438: 428: 417: 409: 401: 393: 389: 388: 386: 385: 378: 371: 363: 360: 359: 349: 348: 339: 337: 336: 333: 332: 328: 327: 319: 314: 309: 303: 302: 297: 296: 293: 292: 288: 287: 282: 277: 267: 262: 257: 252: 247: 242: 237: 232: 225: 219: 218: 213: 212: 209: 208: 204: 203: 198: 193: 182: 181: 176: 175: 172: 171: 167: 166: 161: 156: 151: 146: 140: 139: 134: 133: 130: 129: 127: 126: 121: 116: 111: 101: 94: 89: 81: 76: 70: 67: 66: 58: 57: 47: 46: 38: 33: 15: 9: 6: 4: 3: 2: 7939: 7928: 7925: 7924: 7922: 7915: 7910: 7907: 7904: 7900: 7896: 7893: 7890: 7886: 7882: 7879: 7876: 7872: 7866: 7863: 7860: 7857: 7854: 7851: 7848: 7845: 7842: 7839: 7836: 7833: 7830: 7825: 7822: 7820: 7817: 7812: 7810: 7807: 7800: 7795: 7792: 7789: 7786: 7783: 7780: 7777: 7774: 7771: 7768: 7765: 7762: 7759: 7754: 7751: 7749: 7744: 7738: 7736: 7726: 7721: 7718: 7715: 7712: 7709: 7706: 7703: 7700: 7697: 7694: 7691: 7688: 7685: 7680: 7677: 7675: 7672: 7667: 7665: 7662: 7655: 7654: 7648: 7645: 7642: 7638: 7634: 7628: 7625: 7622: 7619: 7616: 7613: 7610: 7607: 7604: 7601: 7598: 7595: 7592: 7587: 7584: 7582: 7578: 7574: 7570: 7567: 7564: 7560: 7556: 7553:was moved to 7550: 7546: 7542: 7538: 7533: 7529: 7524: 7520: 7516: 7512: 7508: 7506: 7503: 7497: 7491: 7487: 7483: 7479: 7474: 7470: 7465: 7461: 7457: 7453: 7449: 7447: 7444: 7438: 7432: 7428: 7424: 7420: 7415: 7411: 7406: 7402: 7398: 7394: 7390: 7389: 7388: 7378: 7376: 7371: 7370: 7367: 7365: 7361: 7353: 7350: 7347: 7344: 7341: 7338: 7337: 7336: 7334: 7320: 7318: 7313: 7312: 7311: 7309: 7305: 7301: 7297: 7292: 7288: 7276: 7273: 7272: 7270: 7268: 7262: 7259: 7256: 7253: 7250: 7247: 7244: 7241: 7238: 7235: 7232: 7229: 7226: 7223: 7220: 7215: 7211: 7205: 7203: 7199: 7182: 7179: 7178: 7177: 7166: 7163: 7162: 7161: 7159: 7155: 7151: 7147: 7135: 7132: 7131: 7130: 7128: 7110: 7107: 7106: 7105: 7102: 7088: 7086: 7083:Rescinded by 7081: 7080: 7079: 7076: 7075: 7069: 7065: 7061: 7057: 7053: 7052: 7048: 7045:Rescinded by 7043: 7042: 7031: 7028: 7027: 7024: 7021: 7020: 7019: 7017: 7013: 7009: 7005: 7000: 6998: 6985: 6982: 6981: 6980: 6978: 6966: 6963: 6962: 6961: 6959: 6947: 6944: 6943: 6942: 6940: 6926: 6924: 6919: 6918: 6917: 6914: 6913: 6912: 6911: 6906: 6905: 6901: 6898: 6895: 6892: 6889: 6886: 6883: 6880: 6877: 6874: 6871: 6868: 6865: 6862: 6859: 6854: 6841: 6838: 6837: 6836: 6834: 6827: 6824: 6821: 6818: 6815: 6812: 6809: 6806: 6803: 6800: 6797: 6794: 6791: 6788: 6785: 6780: 6768: 6765: 6764: 6763: 6758: 6755: 6752: 6749: 6746: 6743: 6740: 6737: 6734: 6731: 6728: 6725: 6722: 6719: 6716: 6711: 6699: 6696: 6695: 6694: 6692: 6688: 6684: 6678: 6675: 6672: 6669: 6666: 6663: 6660: 6657: 6654: 6651: 6648: 6645: 6642: 6639: 6636: 6631: 6619: 6616: 6615: 6614: 6610: 6607: 6604: 6601: 6598: 6595: 6592: 6589: 6586: 6583: 6580: 6577: 6574: 6571: 6568: 6563: 6551: 6548: 6547: 6546: 6544: 6532: 6529: 6528: 6527: 6525: 6513: 6510: 6509: 6508: 6506: 6502: 6490: 6487: 6486: 6485: 6483: 6471: 6468: 6467: 6466: 6464: 6452: 6449: 6448: 6447: 6445: 6441: 6429: 6426: 6425: 6424: 6422: 6410: 6407: 6406: 6405: 6403: 6391: 6388: 6387: 6386: 6384: 6380: 6368: 6365: 6364: 6363: 6361: 6357: 6345: 6342: 6341: 6340: 6338: 6324: 6322: 6319:Rescinded by 6317: 6316: 6315: 6312: 6311: 6305: 6303: 6298: 6292: 6291: 6287: 6284:Rescinded by 6282: 6281: 6270: 6267: 6266: 6265: 6263: 6250: 6247: 6246: 6245: 6232: 6230: 6227:Rescinded by 6225: 6224: 6223: 6220: 6219: 6213: 6211: 6205: 6204: 6200: 6197:Rescinded by 6195: 6194: 6183: 6180: 6179: 6178: 6167: 6164: 6163: 6162: 6160: 6156: 6152: 6135: 6132: 6131: 6130: 6129: 6126: 6115: 6112: 6111: 6107: 6104: 6101: 6098: 6095: 6092: 6089: 6086: 6083: 6080: 6077: 6074: 6073: 6069: 6066: 6063: 6060: 6057: 6054: 6051: 6048: 6045: 6041: 6037: 6036: 6033: 6030: 6027: 6024: 6021: 6018: 6015: 6012: 6009: 6006: 6002: 6001: 5998: 5996: 5993: 5990: 5987: 5984: 5981: 5978: 5975: 5972: 5969: 5966: 5963: 5960: 5959: 5955: 5952: 5949: 5946: 5943: 5940: 5937: 5934: 5931: 5928: 5925: 5922: 5919: 5916: 5913: 5910: 5907: 5906: 5905: 5903: 5900: 5897: 5894: 5891: 5888: 5885: 5882: 5879: 5876: 5873: 5870: 5867: 5864: 5861: 5858: 5855: 5852: 5849: 5846: 5834: 5831: 5830: 5829: 5828: 5825: 5822: 5819: 5816: 5813: 5810: 5807: 5804: 5801: 5797: 5785: 5782: 5781: 5780: 5778: 5775: 5771: 5769: 5767: 5765: 5763: 5761: 5759: 5757: 5754: 5750: 5747: 5744: 5741: 5738: 5726: 5723: 5722: 5721: 5719: 5716: 5713: 5710: 5707: 5704: 5701: 5698: 5695: 5692: 5688: 5676: 5673: 5672: 5671: 5669: 5666: 5663: 5660: 5657: 5654: 5651: 5648: 5645: 5642: 5639: 5636: 5634: 5631: 5628: 5625: 5622: 5619: 5616: 5613: 5610: 5607: 5604: 5601: 5598: 5595: 5592: 5589: 5586: 5583: 5580: 5577: 5574: 5571: 5568: 5565: 5562: 5559: 5556: 5553: 5550: 5547: 5544: 5541: 5538: 5534: 5531: 5528: 5524: 5512: 5509: 5508: 5507: 5506: 5503: 5500: 5497: 5494: 5491: 5487: 5483: 5480: 5477: 5473: 5469: 5466: 5462: 5458: 5454: 5450: 5447: 5443: 5440: 5437: 5433: 5421: 5418: 5417: 5416: 5414: 5411: 5408: 5405: 5402: 5399: 5396: 5393: 5390: 5387: 5384: 5381: 5378: 5375: 5372: 5369: 5366: 5363: 5360: 5357: 5354: 5350: 5333: 5330: 5329: 5328: 5327: 5324: 5321: 5318: 5315: 5311: 5308: 5305: 5301: 5289: 5286: 5285: 5284: 5283: 5279: 5275: 5271: 5268: 5265: 5261: 5249: 5246: 5245: 5244: 5242: 5238: 5235: 5232: 5228: 5216: 5213: 5212: 5211: 5209: 5205: 5202: 5199: 5195: 5183: 5180: 5179: 5178: 5177: 5174: 5171: 5167: 5164: 5161: 5157: 5140: 5137: 5136: 5135: 5133: 5131: 5130:User:Dragases 5127: 5125: 5121: 5119: 5115: 5113: 5109: 5107: 5103: 5101: 5097: 5095: 5091: 5089: 5085: 5082: 5079: 5075: 5063: 5060: 5059: 5058: 5056: 5053: 5050: 5047: 5044: 5041: 5038: 5035: 5032: 5028: 5025: 5022: 5018: 5001: 4998: 4997: 4996: 4995: 4992: 4989: 4986: 4983: 4979: 4975: 4972: 4969: 4966: 4963: 4960: 4956: 4944: 4941: 4940: 4939: 4938: 4935: 4932: 4928: 4924: 4921: 4918: 4914: 4902: 4899: 4898: 4897: 4896: 4894: 4888: 4884: 4880: 4876: 4872: 4869: 4866: 4862: 4850: 4847: 4846: 4845: 4843: 4838: 4835: 4832: 4829: 4826: 4823: 4820: 4817: 4814: 4811: 4808: 4805: 4802: 4799: 4796: 4791: 4787: 4783: 4779: 4776: 4773: 4769: 4765: 4762: 4759: 4755: 4743: 4740: 4739: 4738: 4736: 4730: 4726: 4724: 4718: 4714: 4712: 4706: 4702: 4700: 4696: 4691: 4688: 4685: 4682: 4679: 4676: 4673: 4670: 4667: 4664: 4661: 4658: 4655: 4652: 4649: 4644: 4632: 4629: 4628: 4627: 4625: 4619: 4616: 4613: 4610: 4607: 4604: 4601: 4598: 4595: 4592: 4589: 4586: 4583: 4580: 4577: 4572: 4568: 4564: 4561: 4558: 4554: 4550: 4538: 4535: 4534: 4533: 4531: 4527: 4523: 4519: 4515: 4512: 4509: 4505: 4501: 4497: 4490: 4482: 4479: 4478: 4477: 4476: 4472: 4468: 4464: 4461: 4458: 4455: 4452: 4449: 4446: 4443: 4440: 4437: 4434: 4431: 4428: 4425: 4421: 4404: 4401: 4400: 4399: 4398: 4394: 4390: 4387: 4384: 4380: 4368: 4365: 4364: 4363: 4362: 4359: 4356: 4353: 4349: 4337: 4334: 4333: 4332: 4330: 4324: 4321: 4318: 4315: 4312: 4309: 4306: 4303: 4300: 4297: 4294: 4291: 4288: 4285: 4282: 4277: 4265: 4262: 4261: 4260: 4259: 4255: 4251: 4247: 4244: 4241: 4237: 4225: 4222: 4221: 4220: 4219: 4216: 4212: 4208: 4204: 4201: 4198: 4194: 4187: 4183: 4180:ChrisO moved 4175: 4172: 4171: 4170: 4169: 4166: 4163: 4160: 4157: 4154: 4151: 4147: 4139: 4131: 4128: 4127: 4126: 4124: 4120: 4113: 4106: 4102: 4099: 4096: 4092: 4075: 4072: 4071: 4070: 4069: 4066: 4063: 4060: 4057: 4054: 4051: 4048: 4045: 4042: 4038: 4034: 4030: 4026: 4022: 4010: 4007: 4006: 4005: 3994: 3991: 3990: 3989: 3988: 3985: 3981: 3969: 3966: 3965: 3964: 3963: 3959: 3955: 3950: 3946: 3941: 3929: 3926: 3925: 3921: 3919: 3916: 3914: 3911: 3909: 3906: 3902: 3900: 3899: 3893: 3892: 3891: 3890: 3889: 3888: 3885: 3882: 3879: 3876: 3873: 3870: 3867: 3864: 3861: 3858: 3855: 3842: 3839: 3838: 3837: 3835: 3831: 3827: 3823: 3819: 3816: 3813: 3809: 3805: 3802: 3799: 3795: 3791: 3788: 3785: 3781: 3769: 3766: 3765: 3761: 3758: 3755: 3752: 3751: 3750: 3740: 3737: 3736: 3735: 3734: 3731: 3728: 3725: 3722: 3719: 3714: 3710: 3706: 3702: 3699: 3696: 3692: 3688: 3685: 3682: 3678: 3666: 3663: 3662: 3661: 3659: 3655: 3654:Dalmatia case 3651: 3647: 3643: 3639: 3622: 3619: 3618: 3617: 3606: 3603: 3602: 3601: 3599: 3587: 3584: 3583: 3582: 3580: 3568: 3565: 3564: 3563: 3561: 3557: 3545: 3542: 3541: 3540: 3529: 3526: 3525: 3524: 3522: 3510: 3507: 3506: 3505: 3503: 3499: 3487: 3484: 3483: 3482: 3480: 3467: 3464: 3463: 3462: 3460: 3448: 3445: 3444: 3443: 3441: 3429: 3426: 3425: 3424: 3422: 3410: 3407: 3406: 3405: 3394: 3391: 3390: 3389: 3387: 3383: 3378: 3374: 3370: 3366: 3354: 3351: 3350: 3349: 3347: 3335: 3332: 3331: 3330: 3328: 3324: 3312: 3309: 3308: 3307: 3305: 3301: 3297: 3293: 3281: 3278: 3277: 3276: 3265: 3262: 3261: 3260: 3249: 3246: 3245: 3244: 3233: 3230: 3229: 3228: 3226: 3222: 3218: 3206: 3203: 3202: 3201: 3198: 3194: 3190: 3186: 3182: 3178: 3174: 3162: 3159: 3158: 3157: 3146: 3143: 3142: 3141: 3138: 3126: 3123: 3122: 3121: 3119: 3106: 3103: 3102: 3101: 3099: 3095: 3091: 3087: 3075: 3072: 3071: 3070: 3069:themselves. 3068: 3064: 3052: 3049: 3048: 3047: 3045: 3041: 3037: 3033: 3029: 3025: 3021: 3017: 3012: 3008: 2996: 2993: 2992: 2991: 2970: 2967: 2963: 2957: 2950: 2948: 2944: 2941: 2938: 2934: 2931: 2929: 2925: 2921: 2920:Sam Blacketer 2918: 2916: 2912: 2908: 2905: 2903: 2900: 2898: 2897: 2891: 2885: 2882: 2879: 2875: 2874: 2873: 2868: 2862: 2861: 2859: 2851: 2850: 2849: 2846: 2843: 2839: 2837: 2833: 2829: 2827: 2824: 2822: 2816: 2814: 2810: 2806: 2801: 2799: 2794: 2788: 2787: 2785: 2778: 2777: 2775: 2774: 2773: 2764: 2759: 2755: 2750: 2747: 2745: 2741: 2737: 2733: 2730: 2728: 2724: 2721: 2718: 2714: 2710: 2707: 2705: 2702: 2700: 2694: 2691: 2689: 2685: 2681: 2677: 2673: 2669: 2665: 2661: 2657: 2654: 2652: 2648: 2644: 2640: 2637: 2635: 2629: 2621: 2618: 2616: 2612: 2608: 2604: 2601: 2599: 2596: 2594: 2593: 2587: 2584: 2582: 2578: 2574: 2569: 2567: 2564: 2561: 2557: 2554: 2552: 2547: 2541: 2540: 2538: 2530: 2527: 2523: 2520: 2516: 2513: 2512: 2511: 2508: 2504: 2500: 2497: 2495: 2492: 2488: 2485: 2484: 2473: 2472: 2468: 2464: 2460: 2456: 2452: 2448: 2444: 2433: 2432: 2428: 2424: 2418: 2414: 2412: 2402: 2401: 2398: 2396: 2391: 2390:lingua franca 2380: 2379: 2375: 2371: 2367: 2363: 2359: 2355: 2351: 2347: 2346:resolved soon 2342: 2340: 2336: 2332: 2328: 2324: 2320: 2316: 2311: 2309: 2307: 2302: 2298: 2294: 2290: 2285: 2284: 2280: 2276: 2272: 2268: 2264: 2260: 2256: 2255: 2250: 2248: 2247: 2241: 2237: 2232: 2228: 2224: 2220: 2216: 2211: 2209: 2205: 2201: 2197: 2193: 2189: 2185: 2181: 2177: 2173: 2169: 2165: 2161: 2151: 2150: 2146: 2142: 2137: 2126: 2125: 2122: 2110: 2106: 2095: 2092: 2091: 2086: 2080: 2074: 2066: 2062: 2052: 2049: 2045: 2041: 2037: 2033: 2030: 2024: 2021: 2015: 2012: 2008: 2007:fait accompli 1995: 1991: 1987: 1983: 1979: 1975: 1974: 1973: 1972: 1968: 1964: 1953: 1952: 1948: 1944: 1938: 1934: 1931: 1921: 1919: 1915: 1911: 1907: 1903: 1899: 1894: 1893: 1887: 1885: 1881: 1876: 1872: 1868: 1864: 1860: 1856: 1852: 1848: 1844: 1840: 1836: 1830: 1821: 1820: 1816: 1812: 1806: 1804: 1798: 1795: 1792: 1787: 1784: 1781: 1776: 1773: 1765: 1764: 1760: 1756: 1752: 1749: 1745: 1741: 1730: 1729: 1725: 1721: 1717: 1713: 1709: 1708:United States 1705: 1701: 1697: 1692: 1680: 1677: 1674: 1670: 1666: 1665: 1664: 1661: 1660: 1657: 1654: 1650: 1645: 1641: 1628: 1625: 1622: 1618: 1614: 1613: 1612: 1611: 1608: 1605: 1600: 1595: 1593: 1588: 1584: 1580: 1570: 1569: 1566: 1561:man with one 1557: 1553: 1549: 1544: 1542: 1538: 1527: 1526: 1522: 1518: 1514: 1510: 1509: 1505: 1501: 1497: 1493: 1489: 1485: 1480: 1479: 1475: 1471: 1466: 1461: 1455: 1454: 1450: 1445: 1435: 1434: 1430: 1426: 1422: 1418: 1414: 1413: 1409: 1405: 1400: 1396: 1392: 1391: 1387: 1383: 1379: 1373: 1369: 1367: 1363: 1359: 1355: 1351: 1346: 1344: 1339: 1335: 1318: 1314: 1311: 1308: 1304: 1301: 1299: 1295: 1292: 1289: 1285: 1282: 1280: 1276: 1273: 1270: 1266: 1263: 1261: 1257: 1254: 1251: 1247: 1244: 1242: 1238: 1235: 1232: 1228: 1225: 1223: 1218: 1215: 1212: 1209: 1206: 1203: 1200: 1197: 1194: 1191: 1188: 1185: 1182: 1179: 1176: 1171: 1168: 1166: 1162: 1159: 1156: 1152: 1149: 1147: 1143: 1140: 1137: 1133: 1130: 1128: 1124: 1121: 1118: 1114: 1111: 1109: 1105: 1102: 1099: 1095: 1092: 1090: 1085: 1082: 1079: 1076: 1073: 1070: 1067: 1064: 1061: 1058: 1055: 1052: 1049: 1046: 1043: 1038: 1035: 1033: 1028: 1025: 1022: 1019: 1016: 1013: 1010: 1007: 1004: 1001: 998: 995: 992: 989: 986: 981: 978: 976: 972: 969: 966: 962: 959: 957: 953: 950: 947: 943: 940: 938: 934: 931: 928: 924: 921: 919: 915: 912: 909: 905: 902: 900: 896: 893: 890: 886: 883: 881: 877: 874: 871: 867: 866:Tasoskessaris 864: 862: 858: 855: 852: 848: 845: 843: 839: 836: 833: 829: 826: 824: 819: 816: 813: 810: 807: 804: 801: 798: 795: 792: 789: 786: 783: 780: 777: 772: 769: 767: 763: 760: 757: 753: 750: 748: 744: 741: 738: 734: 731: 729: 724: 721: 718: 715: 712: 709: 706: 703: 700: 697: 694: 691: 688: 685: 682: 677: 674: 671: 668: 665: 661: 658: 655: 652: 649: 645: 642: 639: 636: 633: 629: 626: 622: 619: 616: 613: 610: 607: 604: 601: 598: 595: 592: 589: 586: 583: 580: 575: 572: 570: 564: 561: 558: 555: 552: 549: 546: 543: 540: 537: 534: 531: 528: 525: 522: 517: 514: 513: 507: 505: 501: 497: 492: 490: 486: 481: 479: 475: 465: 464: 459: 458: 453: 452: 447: 446: 437: 434: 433: 426: 423: 422: 415: 412: 407: 404: 399: 396: 384: 379: 377: 372: 370: 365: 364: 362: 361: 356: 351: 350: 335: 334: 323: 320: 317: 313: 310: 308: 305: 304: 300: 295: 294: 286: 283: 281: 278: 275: 271: 266: 263: 261: 258: 255: 251: 248: 246: 243: 241: 238: 236: 233: 229: 224: 221: 220: 216: 211: 210: 202: 199: 197: 194: 191: 187: 184: 183: 179: 174: 173: 165: 162: 160: 157: 155: 152: 150: 149:Case requests 147: 145: 142: 141: 137: 132: 131: 124: 120: 117: 115: 112: 109: 105: 100: 98: 95: 93: 90: 88: 85: 82: 79: 75: 72: 71: 69: 68: 64: 60: 59: 56: 53: 52: 44: 40: 39: 36: 25: 19: 7913: 7891: 7877: 7871:PeterSymonds 7861: 7855: 7849: 7843: 7837: 7831: 7805: 7790: 7784: 7778: 7772: 7766: 7760: 7734: 7716: 7710: 7704: 7698: 7692: 7686: 7660: 7650: 7643: 7623: 7617: 7611: 7605: 7599: 7593: 7565: 7386: 7372: 7357: 7332: 7330: 7314: 7284: 7274: 7257: 7251: 7245: 7239: 7233: 7227: 7221: 7209: 7207: 7195: 7180: 7174: 7164: 7149: 7143: 7133: 7123: 7108: 7098: 7082: 7077: 7066: 7062: 7058: 7054: 7022: 7001: 6993: 6983: 6974: 6964: 6955: 6945: 6936: 6920: 6915: 6908: 6907: 6896: 6890: 6884: 6878: 6872: 6866: 6860: 6850: 6849: 6839: 6822: 6816: 6810: 6804: 6798: 6792: 6786: 6776: 6766: 6753: 6747: 6741: 6735: 6729: 6723: 6717: 6707: 6697: 6673: 6667: 6661: 6655: 6649: 6643: 6637: 6627: 6617: 6605: 6599: 6593: 6587: 6581: 6575: 6569: 6559: 6549: 6540: 6530: 6521: 6511: 6498: 6488: 6479: 6469: 6460: 6450: 6437: 6427: 6418: 6408: 6399: 6389: 6376: 6366: 6353: 6343: 6334: 6318: 6313: 6293: 6268: 6258: 6248: 6242: 6226: 6221: 6206: 6181: 6175: 6165: 6148: 6133: 6123: 6113: 5842: 5832: 5802: 5793: 5783: 5734: 5724: 5693: 5684: 5674: 5536: 5529: 5520: 5510: 5478: 5438: 5429: 5419: 5355: 5346: 5331: 5306: 5297: 5287: 5266: 5257: 5247: 5233: 5224: 5214: 5200: 5191: 5181: 5162: 5153: 5138: 5080: 5071: 5061: 5023: 5014: 4999: 4984: 4961: 4952: 4942: 4919: 4910: 4900: 4892: 4867: 4858: 4848: 4833: 4827: 4821: 4815: 4809: 4803: 4797: 4774: 4768:Sadbuttrue92 4760: 4751: 4741: 4732: 4728: 4720: 4716: 4708: 4704: 4686: 4680: 4674: 4668: 4662: 4656: 4650: 4640: 4630: 4614: 4608: 4602: 4596: 4590: 4584: 4578: 4559: 4546: 4536: 4510: 4493: 4480: 4475:(in summary) 4471:(in summary) 4467:(in summary) 4426: 4417: 4402: 4385: 4376: 4366: 4354: 4345: 4335: 4319: 4313: 4307: 4301: 4295: 4289: 4283: 4273: 4263: 4250:edit warring 4242: 4233: 4223: 4199: 4190: 4173: 4152: 4143: 4129: 4105:changed text 4097: 4088: 4073: 4018: 4008: 4002: 3999:Polarization 3992: 3977: 3967: 3944: 3937: 3927: 3905:October 2007 3850: 3840: 3814: 3800: 3786: 3777: 3767: 3748: 3738: 3683: 3674: 3664: 3635: 3620: 3614: 3604: 3595: 3585: 3576: 3573:Meatpuppetry 3566: 3553: 3543: 3537: 3527: 3518: 3508: 3495: 3485: 3478: 3475: 3465: 3456: 3446: 3440:stonewalling 3437: 3427: 3418: 3408: 3402: 3392: 3376: 3362: 3352: 3343: 3333: 3327:undue weight 3320: 3310: 3302:as found in 3296:proper nouns 3289: 3279: 3273: 3263: 3257: 3247: 3241: 3231: 3214: 3204: 3170: 3160: 3154: 3144: 3134: 3124: 3114: 3104: 3094:edit warring 3083: 3073: 3060: 3050: 3011:five pillars 3004: 2994: 2988: 2968: 2939: 2895: 2894: 2857: 2856: 2821:Roger Davies 2820: 2783: 2782: 2770: 2762: 2748: 2731: 2719: 2708: 2699:Roger Davies 2698: 2692: 2676:Gordian Knot 2655: 2638: 2619: 2602: 2591: 2590: 2585: 2555: 2536: 2535: 2528: 2514: 2502: 2498: 2486: 2458: 2439: 2419: 2415: 2408: 2394: 2386: 2343: 2334: 2318: 2312: 2304: 2292: 2286: 2282: 2252: 2251: 2243: 2230: 2226: 2212: 2157: 2132: 2101: 2093: 2058: 2047: 2043: 2035: 2034: 2028: 2025: 2016: 2010: 2006: 2003: 1959: 1939: 1935: 1927: 1891: 1890: 1888: 1883: 1831: 1827: 1807: 1799: 1796: 1790: 1788: 1785: 1779: 1777: 1774: 1771: 1736: 1688: 1668: 1662: 1643: 1636: 1598: 1596: 1582: 1576: 1555: 1545: 1533: 1512: 1511: 1487: 1483: 1481: 1456: 1441: 1416: 1415: 1394: 1393: 1374: 1370: 1352:the article 1347: 1331: 1316: 1309: 1297: 1290: 1278: 1271: 1265:Dimorsitanos 1259: 1252: 1240: 1233: 1221: 1213: 1207: 1201: 1195: 1189: 1183: 1177: 1164: 1157: 1145: 1138: 1126: 1119: 1107: 1100: 1088: 1080: 1074: 1068: 1062: 1056: 1050: 1044: 1031: 1023: 1017: 1011: 1005: 999: 993: 987: 974: 967: 955: 948: 936: 929: 917: 910: 898: 891: 879: 872: 860: 853: 841: 834: 822: 814: 808: 802: 796: 790: 784: 778: 765: 758: 746: 739: 727: 719: 713: 707: 701: 695: 689: 683: 666: 650: 634: 628:Caspian blue 617: 611: 605: 599: 593: 587: 581: 569:filing party 568: 559: 553: 547: 541: 535: 529: 523: 493: 482: 470: 462: 456: 450: 444: 429: 427: 418: 416: 410: 408: 402: 400: 394: 392: 7651:disruptive 7333:Macedonia 2 7310:guideline. 7237:protections 7115:Enforcement 7018:guideline. 6921:Superseded 6876:protections 6802:protections 6733:protections 6653:protections 6585:protections 6524:John Carter 6040:Macedonians 5796:Yannismarou 5687:Shadowmorph 5173:meatpuppets 4955:John Carter 4813:protections 4699:Talk:Greece 4666:protections 4594:protections 4397:restriction 4299:protections 4254:involvement 3945:ad hominems 3658:Kosovo case 2607:Newyorkbrad 2451:Thunderdome 2443:Tina Turner 2370:Shadowmorph 2354:WP:DEADLINE 2246:Google bomb 2236:do I bother 2196:Good Friday 2190:article to 2040:User:ChrisO 1986:John Carter 1963:John Carter 1943:John Carter 1930:Talk:Greece 1867:Talk:Greece 1859:Talk:Greece 1755:Jack forbes 1640:Talk:Greece 1579:Talk:Greece 1552:talk:Greece 1425:Yannismarou 1404:Yannismarou 1397:: The link 1382:Yannismarou 1193:protections 1094:Jack forbes 1060:protections 1003:protections 980:John Carter 794:protections 699:protections 644:Shadowmorph 597:protections 539:protections 516:Yannismarou 403:Case Closed 395:Case Opened 119:Ban appeals 97:Noticeboard 7859:block user 7853:filter log 7788:block user 7782:filter log 7714:block user 7708:filter log 7621:block user 7615:filter log 7559:1111tomica 7340:Remedy 3.1 7249:page moves 7187:Amendments 6888:page moves 6814:page moves 6745:page moves 6665:page moves 6597:page moves 6482:Alfadog777 5537:ad hominem 5300:Alfadog777 4931:3RR report 4881:, he also 4825:page moves 4766:) blocked 4678:page moves 4606:page moves 4311:page moves 4191:12) While 4029:WP:ARBMAC2 3949:straw poll 3808:Pmanderson 3794:NikoSilver 3592:Canvassing 3496:22.1) Any 3479:ipso facto 3254:Recidivism 3090:soapboxing 3032:harassment 2980:Principles 2805:Carcharoth 2680:Carcharoth 2339:Micronesia 2308:is favored 2184:lied to us 2109:User:Taivo 1700:Macedonias 1550:page (see 1334:straw poll 1205:page moves 1072:page moves 1037:Horologium 1015:page moves 828:NikoSilver 806:page moves 711:page moves 609:page moves 551:page moves 325:(pre-2016) 312:Statistics 245:Procedures 43:WP:ARBMAC2 7903:Fut.Perf. 7865:block log 7824:SQRT5P1D2 7794:block log 7720:block log 7679:SQRT5P1D2 7637:J.delanoy 7627:block log 7586:Hankz1982 7352:Remedy 30 7243:deletions 7154:WP:ARBMAC 7150:Macedonia 6923:by motion 6882:deletions 6808:deletions 6739:deletions 6659:deletions 6591:deletions 6501:SQRT5P1D2 5472:Greece666 5194:SQRT5P1D2 5170:solicited 5156:SQRT5P1D2 5145:SQRT5P1D2 4819:deletions 4733:He later 4711:responded 4709:He later 4672:deletions 4600:deletions 4305:deletions 4215:Macedonia 4186:Macedonia 4025:WP:ARBMAC 3822:WP:MOSMAC 3709:Macedonia 3691:Macedonia 3498:page move 3459:WP:Outing 3189:WP:BATTLE 3086:consensus 3080:Consensus 3001:Etiquette 2896:Wizardman 2776:Support: 2592:Wizardman 2455:Knowledge 2259:Macedonia 2192:Macedonia 2176:Macedonia 1803:WP:ARBMAC 1712:Australia 1621:Fut.Perf. 1604:Fut.Perf. 1541:Macedonia 1492:WP:MOSMAC 1449:abuse log 1444:Macedonia 1358:Macedonia 1303:SQRT5P1D2 1246:Patton123 1199:deletions 1151:Heimstern 1066:deletions 1009:deletions 961:Hectorian 800:deletions 705:deletions 603:deletions 545:deletions 485:/Workshop 480:subpage. 478:/Evidence 250:Elections 7921:Category 7895:contribs 7881:contribs 7835:contribs 7764:contribs 7690:contribs 7647:contribs 7597:contribs 7569:contribs 7501:Tiptoety 7442:Tiptoety 7362:and the 7346:Remedy 6 7225:contribs 6864:contribs 6790:contribs 6721:contribs 6641:contribs 6573:contribs 6140:Remedies 5806:contribs 5697:contribs 5533:contribs 5482:contribs 5442:contribs 5359:contribs 5310:contribs 5270:contribs 5237:contribs 5227:Radjenef 5204:contribs 5166:contribs 5088:User:Avg 5084:contribs 5027:contribs 4988:contribs 4965:contribs 4923:contribs 4871:contribs 4801:contribs 4778:contribs 4764:contribs 4654:contribs 4582:contribs 4563:contribs 4514:contribs 4498:was the 4430:contribs 4389:contribs 4358:contribs 4287:contribs 4246:contribs 4203:contribs 4156:contribs 4117:, after 4101:contribs 3818:contribs 3804:contribs 3790:contribs 3687:contribs 3656:and the 3457:20) Per 3195:and the 3028:trolling 2954:FayssalF 2943:contribs 2933:Casliber 2878:FloNight 2842:FloNight 2736:Vassyana 2723:contribs 2713:Casliber 2626:FayssalF 2560:FloNight 2036:Request: 1791:reverted 1313:contribs 1294:contribs 1284:Radjenef 1275:contribs 1256:contribs 1237:contribs 1181:contribs 1161:contribs 1142:contribs 1123:contribs 1104:contribs 1048:contribs 991:contribs 971:contribs 952:contribs 933:contribs 923:Kapnisma 914:contribs 895:contribs 885:Jim62sch 876:contribs 857:contribs 838:contribs 782:contribs 762:contribs 743:contribs 687:contribs 670:contribs 660:chandler 654:contribs 638:contribs 585:contribs 527:contribs 35:Shortcut 7897:). See 7808:delanoy 7753:Mihalis 7735:Symonds 7663:delanoy 7649:) for " 7528:protect 7523:history 7469:protect 7464:history 7410:protect 7405:history 7364:Balkans 7298:and of 7006:and of 6463:Nick ts 6440:Reaper7 6421:Reaper7 6400:10.1) 6302:WP:GAME 6159:WP:ECCN 5776:example 5260:Nick ts 5239:) is a 5206:) is a 5074:Reaper7 5017:Reaper7 5006:Reaper7 4893:reading 4735:removed 4258:warning 3834:MOSMAC2 3806:), and 3713:arguing 3650:Balkans 3382:notable 3219:or the 2499:Comment 2453:but in 2395:Caspian 2358:neutral 2273:in the 2271:Georgia 2263:Georgia 2215:Macedon 2172:Ireland 2141:Politis 2029:himself 1906:WP:NCON 1644:without 1488:Ireland 1484:Samaria 1465:WP:BOLD 1132:Politis 904:Aramgar 322:Reports 260:History 240:Members 235:Contact 223:Discuss 87:(CU/OS) 7532:delete 7473:delete 7414:delete 7375:motion 7317:motion 7255:rights 7231:blocks 7198:motion 7196:1) By 7152:case " 7085:motion 7047:motion 6939:WP:SPA 6894:rights 6870:blocks 6851:25.3) 6820:rights 6796:blocks 6751:rights 6727:blocks 6671:rights 6647:blocks 6630:ChrisO 6603:rights 6579:blocks 6562:ChrisO 6499:15.2) 6402:ΚΕΚΡΩΨ 6379:ΚΕΚΡΩΨ 6321:motion 6286:motion 6229:motion 6199:motion 5889:, and 5523:ΚΕΚΡΩΨ 5490:WP:AGF 5463:sock; 5168:) has 5054:; and 4831:rights 4807:blocks 4701:that: 4684:rights 4660:blocks 4612:rights 4588:blocks 4379:ChrisO 4348:ChrisO 4317:rights 4293:blocks 4276:ChrisO 4274:14.1) 4236:ChrisO 4193:ChrisO 4091:ChrisO 4089:10.1) 4080:ChrisO 3940:Greece 3854:Greece 3830:MOSMAC 3780:ChrisO 3677:ChrisO 3519:23) A 3453:Outing 3225:policy 3187:, and 3183:, the 3179:, the 3175:, the 3118:change 2907:Risker 2749:Accept 2732:Accept 2709:Accept 2693:Accept 2666:, and 2656:Accept 2643:Risker 2639:Accept 2620:Accept 2603:Accept 2586:Accept 2573:bainer 2556:Accept 2529:Accept 2515:Accept 2503:itself 2491:Kirill 2487:Accept 2366:Kosovo 2048:before 1811:GK1973 1716:Mexico 1676:(talk) 1656:(talk) 1587:Greece 1548:Greece 1517:ChrisO 1500:ChrisO 1470:ChrisO 1338:Greece 1227:GK1973 1211:rights 1187:blocks 1078:rights 1054:blocks 1021:rights 997:blocks 942:ΚΕΚΡΩΨ 812:rights 788:blocks 717:rights 693:blocks 676:Husond 615:rights 591:blocks 574:ChrisO 557:rights 533:blocks 432:motion 421:motion 265:Clerks 123:Report 7731:Peter 7549:views 7541:watch 7537:links 7496:moved 7490:views 7482:watch 7478:links 7437:moved 7431:views 7423:watch 7419:links 6543:Taivo 6377:9.1) 6354:8.1) 6335:7.1) 5521:35) 4978:Taivo 3377:right 3098:Abuse 2860:levse 2786:levse 2539:levse 2519:Coren 2507:Coren 2467:logos 2463:Dr.K. 2411:diff. 2269:over 2168:Irish 2164:talks 1910:Taivo 1350:moved 733:Taivo 299:Audit 16:< 7889:talk 7885:Ridm 7875:talk 7847:logs 7829:talk 7815:adds 7776:logs 7758:talk 7742:talk 7702:logs 7684:talk 7670:adds 7641:talk 7631:was 7609:logs 7591:talk 7577:talk 7563:talk 7545:logs 7519:talk 7515:edit 7494:was 7486:logs 7460:talk 7456:edit 7435:was 7427:logs 7401:talk 7397:edit 7219:talk 7129:. 6956:28) 6858:talk 6784:talk 6777:24) 6715:talk 6708:22) 6635:talk 6628:20) 6567:talk 6560:19) 6541:18) 6522:17) 6480:14) 6461:13) 6438:12) 6419:11) 6153:and 5800:talk 5794:38) 5691:talk 5685:36) 5527:talk 5476:talk 5436:talk 5430:34) 5353:talk 5347:33) 5304:talk 5298:32) 5264:talk 5258:31) 5231:talk 5225:30) 5198:talk 5192:29) 5160:talk 5154:28) 5078:talk 5072:27) 5042:and 5021:talk 5015:26) 4982:talk 4959:talk 4953:25) 4927:here 4917:talk 4911:24) 4895:it?" 4865:talk 4859:23) 4795:talk 4772:talk 4758:talk 4695:said 4648:talk 4576:talk 4557:talk 4508:talk 4494:18) 4424:talk 4418:17) 4383:talk 4377:16) 4352:talk 4346:15) 4327:was 4281:talk 4240:talk 4234:13) 4197:talk 4150:talk 4144:11) 4095:talk 3832:and 3812:talk 3798:talk 3784:talk 3681:talk 3554:25) 3363:16) 3290:13) 2937:talk 2924:talk 2911:talk 2866:Talk 2809:talk 2792:Talk 2751:. -- 2740:talk 2734:. -- 2717:talk 2684:talk 2647:talk 2611:talk 2577:talk 2545:Talk 2459:coup 2427:talk 2397:blue 2374:talk 2301:here 2299:and 2297:here 2182:and 2170:and 2145:talk 2107:and 1990:talk 1982:this 1978:here 1967:talk 1947:talk 1914:talk 1884:none 1875:this 1863:here 1855:here 1853:and 1851:here 1847:here 1843:here 1839:here 1835:here 1815:talk 1759:talk 1748:here 1744:this 1740:here 1724:talk 1720:PMK1 1691:this 1617:here 1599:knew 1565:shoe 1521:talk 1504:talk 1486:and 1474:talk 1429:talk 1421:here 1408:talk 1399:here 1386:talk 1378:here 1307:talk 1288:talk 1269:talk 1250:talk 1231:talk 1175:talk 1155:talk 1136:talk 1117:talk 1113:PMK1 1098:talk 1042:talk 985:talk 965:talk 946:talk 927:talk 908:talk 889:talk 870:talk 851:talk 832:talk 776:talk 756:talk 737:talk 681:talk 664:talk 648:talk 632:talk 579:talk 521:talk 316:Talk 307:Talk 274:Talk 254:Talk 108:Talk 78:Talk 7656:". 7635:by 7557:by 7291:RfC 7261:RfA 6900:RfA 6826:RfA 6757:RfA 6677:RfA 6609:RfA 6356:Avg 6337:Avg 5432:Avg 5349:Avg 5338:Avg 5134:. 4837:RfA 4697:at 4690:RfA 4618:RfA 4569:by 4323:RfA 4184:to 4112:MKD 4019:9) 3978:7) 3792:), 3707:to 3693:to 3306:." 3135:6) 3046:. 3005:2) 2881:♥♥♥ 2845:♥♥♥ 2695:. 2622:-- 2563:♥♥♥ 2281:is 2217:to 2202:or 2178:to 2072:Hús 2011:not 1651:.) 1563:red 1356:to 1217:RfA 1084:RfA 1027:RfA 847:Avg 818:RfA 723:RfA 621:RfA 563:RfA 190:Log 7923:: 7901:. 7579:) 7547:| 7543:| 7539:| 7535:| 7530:| 7526:| 7521:| 7517:| 7488:| 7484:| 7480:| 7476:| 7471:| 7467:| 7462:| 7458:| 7429:| 7425:| 7421:| 7417:| 7412:| 7408:| 7403:| 7399:| 7204:: 7160:. 6999:. 6835:. 6689:; 6685:; 6385:. 6362:. 6264:. 6127:, 6105:, 6102:, 6099:, 6096:, 6093:, 6090:, 6087:, 6084:, 6081:, 6078:, 6067:, 6064:, 6061:, 6058:, 6055:, 6052:, 6049:, 6031:, 6028:, 6025:, 6022:, 6019:, 6016:, 6013:, 6010:, 6007:, 5994:, 5991:, 5988:, 5985:, 5982:, 5976:, 5973:, 5970:, 5967:, 5964:, 5953:, 5950:, 5947:, 5944:, 5941:, 5938:, 5935:, 5932:, 5929:, 5926:, 5923:, 5920:, 5917:, 5914:, 5911:, 5901:, 5895:, 5886:, 5883:, 5880:, 5877:, 5874:, 5871:, 5868:, 5865:, 5862:, 5859:, 5853:, 5850:, 5847:, 5823:, 5820:, 5817:, 5814:, 5811:, 5779:. 5755:, 5751:, 5748:, 5745:, 5742:, 5739:, 5717:, 5714:, 5711:, 5708:, 5705:, 5702:, 5670:. 5664:, 5661:, 5658:, 5655:, 5652:, 5649:, 5646:, 5643:, 5640:, 5637:, 5632:, 5629:, 5626:, 5623:, 5620:, 5617:, 5614:, 5611:, 5608:, 5605:, 5602:, 5599:, 5596:, 5593:, 5590:, 5587:, 5584:, 5581:, 5578:, 5575:, 5572:, 5569:, 5566:, 5563:, 5560:, 5557:, 5554:, 5551:, 5548:, 5545:, 5542:, 5504:, 5501:, 5498:, 5495:, 5467:, 5459:a 5451:, 5448:, 5412:, 5409:, 5406:, 5403:, 5400:, 5397:, 5391:, 5388:, 5385:, 5382:, 5379:, 5376:, 5373:, 5370:, 5367:, 5364:, 5325:, 5322:, 5319:, 5280:, 5128:, 5122:, 5116:, 5110:, 5104:, 5098:, 5092:, 5051:, 5048:, 5039:, 5036:, 4993:, 4973:, 4970:, 4936:, 4933:, 4929:, 4844:. 4626:. 4532:. 4473:, 4469:, 4465:, 4462:, 4459:, 4456:, 4453:, 4450:, 4447:, 4444:, 4441:, 4438:, 4435:, 4395:, 4256:, 4252:, 4167:, 4164:, 4161:, 4115:}} 4109:{{ 4103:) 4067:, 4064:, 4061:, 4058:, 4055:, 4052:, 4049:, 4046:, 4043:, 4039:, 4035:, 4031:, 4027:, 3960:, 3956:, 3907:.) 3886:, 3883:, 3880:, 3877:, 3874:, 3871:, 3868:, 3865:, 3862:, 3859:, 3828:. 3726:, 3723:, 3600:. 3581:. 3092:, 3034:, 3030:, 3022:, 2958:- 2945:) 2926:) 2913:) 2869:• 2863:• 2854:— 2811:) 2795:• 2789:• 2780:— 2742:) 2725:) 2686:) 2662:, 2649:) 2641:. 2630:- 2613:) 2579:) 2571:-- 2548:• 2542:• 2533:— 2445:: 2429:) 2423:Ev 2376:) 2350:UN 2341:. 2291:, 2210:. 2147:) 2117:62 2084:nd 1992:) 1969:) 1949:) 1920:) 1916:) 1900:, 1841:, 1837:, 1817:) 1761:) 1726:) 1619:. 1523:) 1506:) 1476:) 1431:) 1410:) 1388:) 1368:. 1315:) 1296:) 1277:) 1258:) 1239:) 1170:Ev 1163:) 1144:) 1125:) 1106:) 973:) 954:) 935:) 916:) 897:) 878:) 859:) 840:) 764:) 745:) 567:, 506:. 491:. 460:, 454:, 448:, 7906:☼ 7892:· 7887:( 7878:· 7873:( 7867:) 7862:· 7856:· 7850:· 7844:· 7838:· 7832:· 7827:( 7806:. 7804:J 7796:) 7791:· 7785:· 7779:· 7773:· 7767:· 7761:· 7756:( 7745:) 7739:( 7722:) 7717:· 7711:· 7705:· 7699:· 7693:· 7687:· 7682:( 7661:. 7659:J 7644:· 7639:( 7629:) 7624:· 7618:· 7612:· 7606:· 7600:· 7594:· 7589:( 7575:( 7566:· 7561:( 7551:) 7513:( 7492:) 7454:( 7433:) 7395:( 7263:) 7258:· 7252:· 7246:· 7240:· 7234:· 7228:· 7222:· 7217:( 6902:) 6897:· 6891:· 6885:· 6879:· 6873:· 6867:· 6861:· 6856:( 6828:) 6823:· 6817:· 6811:· 6805:· 6799:· 6793:· 6787:· 6782:( 6759:) 6754:· 6748:· 6742:· 6736:· 6730:· 6724:· 6718:· 6713:( 6679:) 6674:· 6668:· 6662:· 6656:· 6650:· 6644:· 6638:· 6633:( 6611:) 6606:· 6600:· 6594:· 6588:· 6582:· 6576:· 6570:· 6565:( 6157:( 6108:. 6070:. 5956:. 5803:· 5798:( 5694:· 5689:( 5530:· 5525:( 5479:· 5474:( 5439:· 5434:( 5356:· 5351:( 5307:· 5302:( 5267:· 5262:( 5234:· 5229:( 5201:· 5196:( 5163:· 5158:( 5081:· 5076:( 5024:· 5019:( 4985:· 4980:( 4962:· 4957:( 4920:· 4915:( 4868:· 4863:( 4839:) 4834:· 4828:· 4822:· 4816:· 4810:· 4804:· 4798:· 4793:( 4775:· 4770:( 4761:· 4756:( 4692:) 4687:· 4681:· 4675:· 4669:· 4663:· 4657:· 4651:· 4646:( 4620:) 4615:· 4609:· 4603:· 4597:· 4591:· 4585:· 4579:· 4574:( 4560:· 4555:( 4511:· 4506:( 4427:· 4422:( 4386:· 4381:( 4355:· 4350:( 4325:) 4320:· 4314:· 4308:· 4302:· 4296:· 4290:· 4284:· 4279:( 4243:· 4238:( 4200:· 4195:( 4153:· 4148:( 4098:· 4093:( 3815:· 3810:( 3801:· 3796:( 3787:· 3782:( 3684:· 3679:( 3640:( 2940:· 2935:( 2922:( 2909:( 2858:R 2807:( 2784:R 2738:( 2720:· 2715:( 2682:( 2645:( 2609:( 2575:( 2537:R 2425:( 2372:( 2143:( 2078:ö 1988:( 1965:( 1945:( 1912:( 1813:( 1757:( 1722:( 1624:☼ 1607:☼ 1519:( 1502:( 1472:( 1427:( 1406:( 1384:( 1310:· 1305:( 1291:· 1286:( 1272:· 1267:( 1253:· 1248:( 1234:· 1229:( 1219:) 1214:· 1208:· 1202:· 1196:· 1190:· 1184:· 1178:· 1173:( 1158:· 1153:( 1139:· 1134:( 1120:· 1115:( 1101:· 1096:( 1086:) 1081:· 1075:· 1069:· 1063:· 1057:· 1051:· 1045:· 1040:( 1029:) 1024:· 1018:· 1012:· 1006:· 1000:· 994:· 988:· 983:( 968:· 963:( 949:· 944:( 930:· 925:( 911:· 906:( 892:· 887:( 873:· 868:( 854:· 849:( 835:· 830:( 820:) 815:· 809:· 803:· 797:· 791:· 785:· 779:· 774:( 759:· 754:( 740:· 735:( 725:) 720:· 714:· 708:· 702:· 696:· 690:· 684:· 679:( 672:) 667:· 662:( 656:) 651:· 646:( 640:) 635:· 630:( 623:) 618:· 612:· 606:· 600:· 594:· 588:· 582:· 577:( 565:) 560:· 554:· 548:· 542:· 536:· 530:· 524:· 519:( 463:4 457:3 451:2 445:1 382:e 375:t 368:v 270:+ 228:+ 192:) 188:( 104:+ 26:)

Text is available under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License. Additional terms may apply.

Knowledge

:Requests for arbitration/Macedonia 2 - Knowledge

Index