Knowledge

6117: 7346:, the 100 revision (in namespaces 0,1) cut off makes these results a particular way of looking at the topic area. Without the limit, the topic area looks a bit different. For example, from 2022-01-01 to the present there were 44739 distinct actors (excluding bots) that made at least 1 edit to a topic area article or talk page. 'Actor' rather than 'user' because that includes 23124 distinct unregistered IPs. And the total number of revisions to those 2 namespaces was 473212 in that period, which is considerably more than the sum of the PIA column in the stats. So, for me, this way of looking at events in the topic area with an edit count cutoff and a notion of dominant contributors presupposes things about the actual nature of the topic area. It divides contributions up in way that is great for pointing fingers in a partisan information war but may not reflect reality very well. From a single account 'contributor' perspective it seems to be the contributors with low edit counts that may have the largest impact on topic area (although it is impossible to really tell). I'll make some plots for the entire topic area over various periods to show who is doing the editing (in terms of account age) when I get a chance. 10286: 10055: 9170:(emphasis added) I supported coming here because I think AE is ill-suited to a multi-party sprawling request like this. I actually think האופה is the least important party here in most ways and if the thread had stayed constrained to them a rough consensus would have been found. Instead, the discussion ballooned to potential misconduct by multiple other editors. For me the editors whose conduct needs examining would be BilledMammal, Iskandar323, Nableezy, and Selfstudier and I think ArbCom should review, and hopefully endorse, the work SFR has been doing as an uninvolved administrator given the concerns at least one of the parties (Nableezy) has raised about that work. Additionally, I think Levivich has been promoting, in this and some other recent AE reports, claims of misconduct based on tagteaming/edit warring that I personally don't find convincing (even if the same conduct does show other misconduct I do find convincing, namely a battleground mentality) but which ArbCom is better positioned to examine both because it can do so comprehensively, rather than in a series of one-off AE requests, and because of the authority ArbCom has to 11580: 14618:. I would also welcome direct case requests or AE referrals if there are allegations that a particular editor is behaving tendentiously (ie, the sum of their contributions is disruptive even if no one diff in isolation is sanctionable) and AE admins are unable to reach a conclusion. And something that stood out to me from AHJ (and which I've been reminded of, reading some of the comments above about how knowledgeable many Wikipedians are on their chosen subject) was the analysis of sources; I didn't think it was ArbCom's place to be doing that analysis itself, but but it could be valuable to have an agreed baseline of what the academic literature says, which (aside from being useful in itself) would then support (or refute) allegations of source misrepresentation. One final thing we could do is avoid the use of news media and primary reporting in articles on current events (this could potentially be done by consensus, or ArbCom writ, or part of the suite of sanctions administrators have available and applied article by article). 10582:@Arkon. Whatever the outcome, I think this lengthy exchange of views, explorations of so many standard terms used to (mis)characterize what goes on in the putatively 'toxic' IP area, has been very useful. Instead of the intrinsic litigiousness of standard AE/ANI reports, this has been a productive (?hmm many will think TLDR perhaps) exploration in civilised dialogue, yeah with the odd edge of irritation or annoyance showing through, but that's picayune compared to the overall tone, of issues that we've never had quite the time to look into. The emergence of toolkit algorithmically generated evidence also was refreshing, an attempt, even if in my view, not quite as successful as one would like, to get a minimal empirical handle on what often is read as mere opinionizing. The rules of etiquette and strict topic focus all too often hinder discussions of what is really on editors' mind, before a community and its arbiters, and it is all to the good that we have been afforded this opportunity. 7068: 10170: 10766:. I had the distinct impression the line I quoted summed up (a) BM giving empirical evidence and (b) being attacked for doing so by several editors. My impression was that BM answered my solicitation for such evidence (on another page), came up with his charts and was immediately thanked by sean.hoyland and myself. Then Hoyland, Zero, with a professional competence in these things, questioned aspects of the chart, or the inferences BM drew from them as did SashiRolls. This was absolutely normal, consensual discussion. The only blip was Nableezy being upset at the way BM's chart distorted his comments. BM and Nableezy often collaborate and at times get annoyed at each other, but that is not 'multiple editors' getting at BM. What has been suggested is that his particular modelling of the data produces the kind of result he'd be comfortable with, and that is a point very frequently made of papers in population genetics and other fields. 10093:@User:BilledMammal. I'm sorry, but language and grammar are merciless in these things (and the fact that such niceties are missed so often is one reason reading ANI/AE discussions is, certainly for me, so painful -I was in part permabanned because one admin could not understand irony, though everyone else saw the amicable comedy of my, to him alone, 'aggressively' 'uncivil'/abusive remark). You are simply wrong. If you have played lawn bowls, then grasping whether the ball you are drawing has a wide or narrow bias is fundamental to mastering the art. The whole point of RSN deliberations, and you engage in them often, is to distinguish between narrow and wide bias in newspapers. A narrow bias doesn't imperil the general reliability of a source: a wide bias can lead to deprecation. I guess now, having told you you are flat-out wrong, I have now produced a diff that can be cited in just one more 5783:(calling them "fringe"). We call this adoption of the mainstream bias "neutral point of view." Everyone will always disagree with some parts of it, but it'll be different parts. Sure, I also think our ARBPIA articles are riddled with bias, but not the same parts that Hen Mazzig is talking about, and Arbcom isn't going to resolve that disagreement between us. We are not here because of bias in articles, and I don't think there is any chance that we are going to stick NPOV tags on thousands of articles, nor are we going to elect a body that can come up with a way to write a bias-free summary of the most complicated and controversial geopolitical dispute in history. Let's keep our expectations reasonable: we can kick people out who are causing a lot of trouble, and maybe find ways to reduce the amount of volunteer time wasted on unnecessary writing (cough), that's what we can try to do. 10604: 7480: 14611: 6041:@Sean.hoyland thanks for the numbers, they are really informative! I will say, it is fairly obvious a giant influx of editors to the topic area happened recently as a result of the conflict (myself included), though obviously the analysis of such a large dataset to confirm or deny toxicity by a core group would go beyond just numbers. I think the pure mass of folks in the topic area is just a lot harder to govern around and regulate, especially with the contentiousness of the topic area. And as the conflict spreads beyond obviously ARBPIA pages to tangentially related pages, the regulations get murkier. I think if PIA5 does happen, a key issue is just how to govern and regulate en masse, as well as on the individual editor/cabal level, and how to handle PIA content on pages that aren't just pure PIA (see the 9321: 7238:, that table is interesting, but my challenge would be - what is the utility of an unfalsifiable label? Also, if I made that I would have pretty low credence in the labels because I don't know how to write an algorithm to reliably tell the difference between "a pro-Palestine point of view"/"a pro-Israel point of view" and a policy compliant source-based view. This is the tricky thing for me. There's the personal bias, plus a person's source sampling bias that limits what they can see, plus their personal interpretation of policies like due weight, plus what they personally identify as bias etc. and you can't just do a Fourier transform to decompose them. Sticking a label on editors strikes me as an understandable attempt to impose order on something more complex and chaotic. 10851: 11284: 7300: 7464: 16167:- merge discussions are processed in the same venue as deletion discussions. So there potentially is a chance that what is a merge discussion may soon turn out to have consensus in favour of deletion. You didn't intend to delete, but you did get involved in a deletion discussion after all because the final result was delete. And yes, the nom has no control over how the discussion goes. Blocking for violating TBan in this case would be unfair, but you will definitely find people who will assert he violated his TBan regardless. It doesn't matter if mergers/blanking-and-redirecting are not technically deletions. The matter is, that discussion may yield a delete result. 11457: 10824: 9512: 13530:'s point of view above... while this is clearly a hugely emotive and contentious topic area for many and of course there are numerous disputes, my from-a-distance perspective is that conduct is actually a lot better than you might expect. While many editors fall into one of two "camps", the WP principles of compromise, respecting others and objective analysis still seem to be present in many debates. I'd urge ArbCom to be extremely cautious about imposing too many editing restrictions or topic bans in this area, on either side of the debate, I think that would lead to less good coverage of the subject rather than more. 9881:. When a theory fails, those convinced of it invent another theory (Untouchables here) to account for why it was not accepted, etc.). The result here is a series of intemperate variations of a boilerplate meme chanted about the I/P area, which I have heard for a dozen years used of individual editors but now used of a group, first targeted by several off-wiki sites and now pushed as a reality which slipped past our monitoring for 20 years. And it is just an unsubstantiated opinion, esp. from editors I’ve almost never seen here, and, surprisingly seems to be getting some traction. 13416:. To be clear, I am not denying that contentious topics are likely to have more sockpuppetry or newer editors in the topic areas than a "tame" subject would. That does not, however, justify cherrypicking PAGs that support one side, and ignoring arguments to the contrary - and it especially does not justify bludgeoning discussions so that the closer has no choice but to find those arguments "stronger" simply because people either tire out of refuting the claims, tire out of pointing out the failures of the arguments made, or are threatened with administrative action by those who 10928:), led me to find the editing environment disturbingly toxic, and not due to some simple problem with a small number of easily identified editors. Rather, it felt like a fairly large number of experienced editors, together, were acting in a way inconsistent with a CTOP subject. That strikes me as something that AE is poorly equipped to deal with. And it fits exactly with the concept that ArbCom should accept cases where the community has tried, but been unsuccessful, to resolve. So I recommend that ArbCom accept this case, and do so with a large number of named parties. -- 11525: 14071: 13469:(outside obvious socks/SPAs/etc that AE can continue to handle), or resolve the issues in this topic area by some other means. As it stands, editors on the side with more experienced editors can continue to weaponize AE to remove editors they don't like from the topic area since AE admins feel obligated to continue reviewing reports with what ideally should be an impending case - and as they've said multiple times, AE isn't the right place nor equipped to handle reports regarding conduct that crosses over a plethora of editors. -bɜ:ʳkənhɪmez | 11173:(Perhaps I'm posting here too much, but ArbCom's near-silence creates a vacuum.) ArbCom, don't get distracted by outside publications claiming bias in our content. It's special pleading, and ArbCom shouldn't end up with another Polish Holocaust case. We've got a problem, apparently, with a bottomless well of newish accounts that make life difficult for good-faith editors, which is something that AE should be able to handle. And I believe strongly that we have a problem with experienced editors who make it too difficult for AE to do its job. -- 14596: 10943:(Added after some other editors have kindly said that they agree with me; I don't know if they will agree with what follows.) ArbCom should know that the problems with "the usual suspects" that cannot be handled by AE generally do not fall along the expected POV fault-lines of Israeli versus Palestinian POVs, or antisemitism or Islamophobia. (I'm sure there are POV pushers like that, but they can be handled at AE.) If anything, there's a divide between different lines of Jewish thought, with the most problematic editors favoring 7429: 9039:, simple cases of misbehavior of newish accounts are fairly easily handled, as I think my ~80 AE sanctions this year show. The issue arises when we're asked to look into tag-team or long-term edit warring, as we were in this case, and even cursory investigation shows that a large number of editors are involved. You can't have edit warring or tag teaming with just one party or one side. AE is not equipped to handle, or at least they're is no appetite to handle, multiple long-term edit wars involving large numbers of editors. 12520:, or try to push a POV over what reliable sources support. And definitely some of that has been happening here, and I encourage ArbCom to look at the behavior of individual editors in this topic area. But I don't think this stuff coming from established editors is a systemic issue over and above the inherent fact that the Israel/Palestine conflict just is a contentious topic. It's fine to not want to edit in a contentious topic area but I don't think that a topic area being intimidating to edit in is by itself an issue. 8955:. I've done my best to take care of all of the obvious cases that won't have to set aside a dozen hours of time to deal with, but much of the behavior is by editors with numerous prior warnings and sanctions but that topic banning, interaction banning, and blocking is not a simple matter. Most AE reports in the topic area involve behavior that is widespread among many parties, and picking out a single party for sanctioning and allowing other editors to continue the behavior isn't how enforcement should be working. 13541:. I'd like to know what I was supposed to do differently in that instance? Perhaps it could have instead been a "no consensus" close, but the effect of endorsing the RM close would have been the same. It's been long-established that consensus building on Knowledge takes place by viewing comments through the lens of policy, but equally closers almost always find consensus for the majority vote if there isn't a lot to choose between the strength of arguments. Bluntly, there isn't an objective policy that says 3528:. The issue with the previous motion is that Remedy 6-8 rely on the "primary articles" and "related content" distinction, and establish some special rules that are not found in the rest of the CTOP/ARBECR world. This motion would retain some of the guidance on the templates but broadly eliminate the formal differences in enforcement rules. One other option is to bring some of the rules from ARBPIA into the broader arbitration enforcement procedures. I think there is some merit in that idea — currently, all 10445:(38,036 edits). Another successful sock tagteaming operation since they did manage to change the name before being caught out. I don't know if it is proper to call this misrepresentation 'lying'. It is nonetheless the kind of error which can easily insinuate itself when one is applying to a massive data field algorithms that have no feel for context. Note that Icewhiz/User:Seggallion is missing from BilledMammal's chart unaccountably., comfortably slipping through the tool net despite 38,036 edits. 5137: 7449:, there was a similar argument, where one "side" was claimed to be the pro-Palestinian side, and the other the pro-Israel side. But that, like most of these disputes, was not true. One side was indeed pushing an identifiably nationalistic narrative identified with one "side" in the geopolitical conflict, the other was not. The two "sides" here have never been symmetrical here. As far as BilledMammal's highly subjective understanding of bludgeoning, he lists me as having bludgeoned 5367:. The criteria used for the database search can be seen as a (flawed, but useful) proxy for the latter. The former requires contextual analysis as to whether or not someone is simply posting the same point a bazillion times in response to different people; showing diffs in the same discussion where someone is repeating the same point over and over (and over) again across a multitude of comments would provide better evidence towards that point than the analysis currently does. — 6416:; for bludgeoning, I would suggest instead a rule that direct replies to !votes be disallowed, indirect replies and responses only in own sections as at AE. As for exclusion from !voting, I would go along with this provided that every editor that had made even one edit to an AI/IP article was similarly excluded (I assume that such excluded editors would still be permitted to open formal discussions? eg opening an RM is usually considered equivalent to a bolded !vote.) 10564:, and sometimes it may be quite disconcerting for those whose general information on the conflict comes from TV and mainstream newspapers to find that there is another, equally valid, perspective on events, and we must balance them for NPOV. There is absolutely no problem in finding massive coverage of events from a pro-Israeli perspective, but you have to frequently go to the scholarship to see the other side. And much of that scholarship comes from places like 10205: 6078:* regarding the "secret majority" theory proposed by some, I argue that folks use the idea that CTOP contentiousness is driven by a small group of editors to pursue a "burn the house down" strategy of removing/wounding an editor population they perceive to be ideologically biased in one direction. Sean.Hoyland has already produced statistics indicating that editor counts are diverse and that the area is contentious primarily because the topic is contentious. 7597: 12961:, there is a consistent group of editors that repeatedly accuse a list of sources they have deemed to be "anti-Israel" while also defending-ad-bludgeon advocacy sources like the ADL and categorically defining Israeli news media as reliable. These discussions do not display the converse: there is no bloc of editors that rejects Israeli sources out of hand while categorically insisting that pro-Palestinian sources are reliable (for further evidence, see 9652: 9190: 11603: 7363:, I'm just counting revisions and excluding bots so it shouldn't change the top 20 counts. Or maybe I would get slightly different counts. I haven't actually checked. Should probably do that but I can't imagine it would be significantly different as we are doing roughly the same thing. What would be nice would be to see how many reverts are spent on enforcing ARBECR, but there is a lot of diversity in people's edit summaries making it tricky. 2932: 2904: 10985: 5988:* There is benefits to having folks with bias on here, especially the most heaviest editors, doing major work. Bias is inherent to humanity and pretending otherwise is just an excuse to press the red ban button without considering consequences (or especially because they hate the current bias of Knowledge compared to their preferred bias). The way to deal with bias is using the principles we have, rules we can apply even handedly, 12545: 7620:. You know what’s a problem in this topic area? People making things up and saying it with a straight face so that others believe them. Again, I would highly recommend that you all not take such absolutely bad faith "evidence" at face value. There are multiple examples in that table in which BM is straight up lying about an editors position. Oh, and guess who started that RM? The supposedly non-existent problem of socks. 6523: 11392:'s experience here echoes mine. The tendentiousness, bludgeoning, and sealioning behavior from these battleground editors makes it exhausting and frustrating for non-battleground editors to participate. In any event, I see the "usual suspects" attempting to downplay or deny that there's any dispute, in contrast to the uninvolved parties saying, essentially: "It's you: you're the problem." I think that's rather telling. 6855:...what are the answers? Nobody knows, but we know from the data that they are a constant presence, make thousands of edits, participate in many discussions and have a significant impact on the dynamics of the topic area (including the things often referred to as 'heat' and 'temperature' - slightly misleading terms because those are measurable quantities in the real world that are unreliable subjective guesses here). 9367: 13763:, if I see that editor A supported move B for an article about C, it feels a bit superficial for me to think, 'aha, editor A is a pro-C partisan' instead of thinking, 'I had better immerse myself in the relevant literature and see if I agree that the secondary sources support move B for topic C'. To the extent that POV pushing is the animating concern of this referral, it rather matters that we know what 12168: 8900: 11354: 14239: 13432:, and ultimately through derailing any chance that the behavior is addressed. That is why this is back at ArbCom after what, 4 prior cases? And of course, many of the problematic experienced editors have already shown up to this request to bludgeon here with chants of "there is no war in Ba Sing Se" over, and over, and over again to try and deflect from and/or justify their own behavior. 11782:. I dabbled in editing within the topic area some months back, but quickly opted to mostly stay away - since December or so, my related editing has only been in the Current Events portal/ITNC and various admin/arbitration noticeboards. This pivot was due to the absurd levels of incivility, condescension, POV-pushing, bludgeoning, edit-warring, hypocrisy, and virtually every other type of 8712: 7323:...absolutely. I would go as far as to say the entire pro-Israel vs pro-Palestine model is very likely to be the wrong model. It's a trap, sometimes used intentionally, sometimes used unintentionally, something that traps people into ways of thinking about solutions that cannot possibly produce effective solutions. Better models could be honest vs dishonest, Knowledge rules : --> 13456:. One need only look at the significant number of experienced editors who are not a part of the "in group" who've commented here that they avoid this topic area because they have no hope of participating constructively against the other experienced editors - whether they're working in coordination or simply independently being disruptive. As such, I see the only solution being 9022:, the tldr is the original complaint was more or less about tag team edit warring, looking into it I saw that it was, in my view, broadly similar to much of the behavior widespread in the topic area, and wasn't terribly interested in making one-off sanctions. It's incredibly widespread, as well as other disruptive behavior, and AE isn't the place to address topic-wide issues. 7221: 8118:. I've manually re-reviewed all of Iskandar323's other !votes, and they appear accurate, but if you have any issues with them please let me know - although preferably on the talk page, to avoid requiring the Arb's to wade through the collaborative process of improving that table. If I refuse to change the table I think that would be when it is appropriate to raise here. 8846:(b) Overall, 975 days are included. This means that even the largest edit count, that of Selfstudier, is only 15 edits per day (in fact effectively less, guessing 9–10, as Selfstudier often makes consecutive small edits). My count at #16 in the list is only 2.5 edits per day, which is remarkably few given that my watchlist of length 8,687 includes most ARBPIA articles). 14455:. A case with a set number of named parties that led to this arriving at ARCA would allow us to more thoroughly examine those issues and determine if this is something specific to those editors that might require sanctions, or if there may be more general actions that can be taken, in which case we can do so with a more thorough examination of the facts via a case. - 6859: 13166:. All of these edits should have been uncontroversial. But I know that when I do the former (ie.removing "in Israel" from places which have been occupied by Israel since 1967) I can expect a tsunami of insults and threats, while when I do the latter (ie: placing Arab cities in Israel), I have *never* recieved any such reaction. Why this difference, I wonder?cheers, 10306: 13845:: The recent motions are well-intentioned efforts to deal with the issues presented by this situation without dealing with the editors involved. While that approach is tempting and understandable, I believe that, as some have pointed out, that they might make things worse, promote tag-teaming and offsite canvassing, and constitute a failure to act if not worse. 10386:. As far as I can see, your statistics do not note a deterioration over time of editing in the IP area. They only indicate that roughly half of the cases brought there are IP related, and that AE has efficiently sanctioned a large number of the editors reported. I could make many other inferences but leave a proper analysis to those competent in these matters. 12260:) from appearing on BilledMammal's list. That said, and as others have already said on the talk page (or when it is was brought to ANI as an attack page), showing that people engaged in discussion, provided RS, debunked silly arguments, responded to sockpuppet provocation, etc. does not show that people "bludgeoned" anything. As the explanatory essay says: 14043:, and explicitly mark them as such to readers with an appropriate banner? To remove this banner, we could introduce more stringent criteria requiring a wider consensus, including input from uninvolved editors. Articles that fail to pass these reviews would remain marked as "potentially biased". It would also be easier to re-introduce a banner if needed. 14075: 8269:, I believe that 13, collectively making 75,383 edits to the topic area since 2022, generally align with a pro-Palestinian position. I believe two, collectively making 5,832 edits, generally align with a pro-Israeli position. The remaining five, collectively making 19,550 edits, are either neutral or have a position that I have been unable to determine: 9877: 11492: 8811:. Levivich deconstructs this division better than I could, and I wholeheartedly endorse his analysis. In terms of disputes, the most common division is between those who uncritically accept Israeli official versions and those who don't. Being critical of Israeli propaganda is completely different from being uncritical of Palestinian propaganda. 16351: 332: 340: 8929:. This is a dreadful idea. Practically nobody attends these discussions without a pov. The effect will be that newcomers summoned on off-wiki groups, who usually come with a minimum of knowledge, will have greater rights than dedicated editors who are expert on the subject. Also, there will be endless argument over who is "involved". 6063:. All areas of Knowledge has "regulars" and regulars generally provide the most institutional wisdom to the project, rejection of "regulars" ability to vote would likely represent a repudiation of the current coverage of the conflict in favor of the implicit view by some that "secret majorities" have overrun the CTOP areas. For 6867: 3090: 12541: 11292:-ing innocent new editors, is often not obvious. Part of the reason an ArbCom case is needed is because the community and AE aren't equipped for that; but this also means it's important to approach the case with an eye towards the drive-by / SPA problem, at least as context for the behavior of parties to the case, and not 10512:'s political history of Tibet at 17; to specializing academically in the concepts of nationalist exceptionalism -all underdog stories and therefore a sense that any judgment must be grounded in universalist principles or logic. When I started reading wiki IP articles, Palestinian history was absent from most (so I rewrote 10079:, They are not valid evidence for what you claim for a very simple linguistic reason. 'Severe bias' and 'bias' are not interchangeable, the adjectival qualifier makes all the difference. All newspapers have bias, like humans. 'Severe bias' in a newspaper/organization is what makes it unacceptable, as distinct from others. 16147: 8793: 9671:(and anyone else watching) I think at this point there are no bad ideas. Part of my rationale for proposing the motions was to see if they sparked any better ideas. Separate cases might be worth thinking more about. How would we structure a general case about the topic area to avoid it becoming a mud-slinging contest? 12752:. I would like to see a case in which the most frequent participants in the area are scrutinized, and that this will be proposed as a principle to guide any and all remedies. The repeated insistence from frequent participants that only newbies and socks are the problem has further convinced me that this is necessary. 11091:(Although, in my case, it might not show what you expect now.) I'd suggest other editors, with more experience in the content area than I have, consider doing that, too. Arbs might want to click on those source links to check them for yourselves, but that's as far into source material as I expect you will need to go. 2953: 8772:, none of them started an RM nor (on a cursory scan) questioned the use of "massacre". But this tacit acceptance of the facts is absent from your analysis. This is just one example of how your raw data tends to misrepresent reality. A proper analysis would need to compare reliable sources against !voting patterns. 11221:, while I don't particularly appreciate being snidely labelled a pro-Israel complainer, I do appreciate an immediate example of "experienced editors . . turning the entire topic into even more of a WP:BATTLEGROUND than it needs to be". So—on balance, notwithstanding its intention—I thank you for your statement! 10472:. My instincts told me immediately that there was some echo in that voice I recognized from the past, and a few moments of thought prompted me to associate it with a prior editor, highly intelligent and articulate, very pro-Israel, but utterly unfamiliar with any of the scholarship. The name that popped up was 5907:. There are POV-fork type issues, but this is one of those topics where every time there is a question of how to categorize the conflict, it opens up the same exact battle lines of arguments in a million pages, even if they cover completely different aspects that may involve Israel/Palestine as one example. 13324: 10612:) is systematically ignored. To state that, given the disparity, is not to espouse a pro-Palestinian perspective. It is simply to insist that our civilization in its laws and ethical principles commends our sympathies to go out to whoever suffers, regardless of the mean divisions of politics and ethnicity. 8829:(academics at opposite ends of the pov spectrum). Incidentally, none of the articles directly related to the 2023 Hamas attack on Israel or the subsequent Israeli response appear among my 1,500 most-edited articles, and Talk pages come it at number 412. No wonder I failed my Pro-Palestinian Activism exam. 3706:: I guess the question is whether it'd be worth codifying this distinction for the other CTOP areas as well. We can go in the other direction and borrow some of this language for use in the broader enforcement procedures — ARBPIA is not particularly unique in the sense of being a broad topic area. Best, 6345: 14195: 13356: 13115: 13050: 12540: 11491: 11055: 10850: 10480: 10459: 10305: 10300: 9297: 9189: 8668: 8640: 7596: 7507: 7325: 7324: 6435: 6393: 6100: 6014: 5940: 5811: 5611: 5438: 2663: 2307: 2157: 16455: 15985: 15820: 14613: 14595: 14450: 14428: 14014: 13809: 13805: 13407: 13334: 11898: 11728: 11628: 11549: 11283: 11202: 9447: 8792: 8689: 8647: 8379: 7896: 7874: 7643: 7402: 7202: 7187: 6902: 6874: 6858: 6562: 6522: 5704: 5683: 5631: 5619: 5546: 5276: 2446: 14610: 13954: 13447: 13330: 13040: 12911: 12888: 12830: 12647:, replying more so to you because you've provided the strongest argument against my own and have convinced me to some degree. The most critical issue, in my opinion, is tag-teaming. Which regular editors in the area are working together to !vote lockstep, always in a way that favors the same cause? 12440: 12386: 11884: 11650: 11624: 11602: 10969: 10866: 10549: 10285: 10059: 10054: 9783: 9730: 9651: 9526: 9466: 9320: 9264: 8848:(c) The top 20 contributors made 23% of the edits. I don't know how to check this, but I'm guessing that in most areas of similar size the top 20 contributors make a larger fraction of edits than this. Without this information, it cannot be concluded that a small cabal of editors dominate the area. 8387: 7581: 7142: 5921: 5777: 5599: 5107: 3684: 3089: 2782: 2198: 16146: 14487: 14413: 14238: 13959: 13949: 13145: 13054: 13032: 12560: 12215: 11676: 11423: 11347: 11311: 11144: 10999: 10904: 10823: 10603: 10411: 10204: 9627: 7582: 7428: 7377: 7220: 7122: 7067: 5884: 5650: 5468: 3014: 16468: 15023: 14568: 13545: 12747: 12544: 12512: 12191: 11456: 11254: 11018: 10984: 10025: 9692: 9220: 8966: 7444: 7299: 6935: 6344: 5615: 5476: 5146: 14320: 12655: 12492: 12362: 11353: 11044: 10662: 10520: 10136: 8820: 6116: 5687: 16350: 15950: 13463: 12167: 11579: 11045: 9876: 7479: 7463: 6866: 5782: 5576: 3051: 2764:, I'm afraid I don't recall in any greater depth than my comments at the workshop, sorry. The userspace exception was suggested by Huldra and Zero0000, who made some comments re: user talk pages that on review, look like reasonable concerns; whether or not they're still applicable I can't say. ♠ 16135: 15845: 12788:. This often leads to situations where there's an apparent consensus which goes against (the natural or customary interpretation of) our content policies. The result is passionate edit warring, with one side righteously enforcing consensus, and the other righteously enforcing content policies. 9753: 9511: 8899: 8711: 8657: 5271: 2652: 15680: 13468: 13323: 8426: 7170: 5547: 14074: 13221: 10169: 9366: 8962: 8923:. This will be a gift to tag-teams, who will get 500 words per person. Also, this will prevent the most productive comments, which bring reliable sources and quote from them. This motion would effectively limit discussions to "you say, I say", when they should be "this reliable source says". 12854: 10881: 10507: 5816: 11524: 10666: 14645: 13157: 8036: 5469: 7793: 14321: 2612:' requires that before CTOP, ECR and 1RR are applied to any page other than an article the enforcement templates have been added to that page which is "only when disruption creates a need for additional administrative tools" and that this can never happen on userpages or user talk pages. 15681: 14070: 5696:). I don't know whether Enforced BRD or Consensus Required is better, or if either are improvements over neither, but we do not have enough data to know. Let admins apply them to pages first, and see how they work out, before we consider applying either of them to the entire topic area. 5984: 5295: 3052: 2783: 15164: 15729: 12606: 12513: 9053: 7504: 13491:. A full case, with evidence, should be opened. If after the full case, ArbCom still feels those motions are the best way to resolve this, well fine. But an ARCA is not the place to expect to be given all the evidence, so we will just end up with a case eventually. -bɜ:ʳkənhɪmez | 5688: 3159: 13921: 13755:, etc., and deciding how to note-vote ought to involve basing one's decision on what sources say. Without that context, it's presuming too much to look at information presented in this manner and conclude something about an editor's "pro"-ness of X or Y or what have you, which is 5674: 12098: 7488: 8759: 6503: 2851: 11798:, as from both sides of the POV-war, there's a near-constant attitude of "my side is doing nothing wrong, if we just sanctioned the POV-pushers everything would be fine," rather than any introspection on the absolutely toxic environment created by nearly all participants. 10658: 8532: 5961: 9410: 3333: 7403: 6841: 11706: 3385: 12926: 8005: 8383: 8084: 6808: 13192:: "Once discovered, a sockpuppet account is automatically blocked" No, they are not. I am 100% sure that a Tombah-sock is active at present, but he is still unblocked. And Nocal works in the tech/computer-industry and knows every trick in the book to avoid detection. 11197: 8430: 8482: 11082: 10867: 5831: 2835: 15832:) after a clear consensus had been made to do so by other editors. If this is indeed too adjacent to my BLAR and/or XFD topic-bans for comfort, then I will cease doing it again until the topic ban is lifted (and not try to convince other editors to do it for me). 12574: 15701:. It is unwarranted and unnecessarily punitive; and is not reflective or proportionate of my conduct or intent. A new finding will unfairly suggest that I did something wrong meriting a new set of sanctions, and would prejudice any future request to remove the 12357: 7634: 16170: 15785: 13404:(and sometimes uncivil) through attempting to deprecate sources that have a bias towards opinions they disagree with. This is but one example of the experienced editors blatantly admitting to ignoring PAGs when they disagree with the inevitable outcome of them. 12965:). We do occasionally see editors pop up who reject Israeli sources out of hand on talk pages (usually alongside US and potentially even European sources), but I don't see anyone named in this report that exhibits this behavior. Such editors are shown the door. 316: 16268: 13620:. Have one case to handle the editor conduct issues highlighted at the AE thread here (focusing on individuals) and then a second one to address the climate in the topic area writ large (focusing on policy changes to the topic). Trying to conflate the two a la 14176: 7484:. Since I know he means me, Ill just state that I do not edit Knowledge to push a POV. I edit Knowledge to try to make it so that article in this topic area are based on the balance of the best sources available. And if somebody does not like what the sources 6495: 15994: 13504: 13357: 11341: 10667:‘pro-Israeli’ editors as opposed to 13 aligning with a ‘pro-Palestinian’ position hard to reconcile with evidence on his chart of which makes him the lowest (10%) IP contributor - though he is the most familiar name to me on that list, - when it includes 11966: 10360:. Just out of curiosity, if Arbcom opens a case, who are the editors whose behaviour is to be examined. The list given by Red-tailed hawk, or is it larger? I say that because there is a massive imbalance in the people singled out, according to the usual 8844:(a) The table combines talk page edits and article edits (BM: you should indicate that). The fraction of a user's edits that are in article space differs a lot and needs to be considered before judging an editor's habits, but this information is missing. 16391: 11094: 7803: 12659: 7118: 2253: 12195: 11931:- see how some of those named in this case pretty much receive only logged warnings and/or minor things such as revert restrictions for substantial incivility, abuse of AE process, edit-warring, etc that would've gotten a newer user swiftly blocked. 10151:). When I read your first post here I remembered that contretemps. I never reported it as a misuse of admin tools, and I never hold grudges. But I do remember things, and took your generalization as coming from someone 'involved' in the topic area. 12858: 11241: 10259: 9239: 10516:) - there was a bias to just an israeli narrative of Jewish traditions there. So 'pro-Pal' is risible. Indeed, if I have an intellectual challenge reflected in my work here, it is to read to the end of trying to grasp how the universalism of the 2447: 13913: 13565: 12795: 5691: 13055: 12346:, though that is not to say the same behavious doesn't occur across more than the two editors singled out in that diff. Though I have seen tendentious editing multiple times, I am very reticent to call it out, in part because such accusations 2343: 2699: 11348: 7044:. The distributions vary but younger accounts appear to dominate in the topic area in terms of revision counts, at least based on this small sample. It would be interesting to see what this distribution looks like for the entire topic area. 10010: 6558: 5198: 15332: 5454:, than almost any other topic area. Discussions about sources can't happen in 500-1000 words; the very notion is ridiculous. More to the point, any kind of topic-wide restriction would be a horrible, counterproductive overreach. The vast, 13482: 11500:. Are you *really* sure this is the example you want to bring up? You're making my point about "It's you: you're the problem" quite well for me. But sure, you never hold grudges... except for the one you've apparently held for 17 years. 8071:, as while you can argue you didn't support "massacre", I don't think you're arguing you opposed it? I've also manually reviewed all the others of yours, and they appear correct; if you disagree with any of the others, please let me know. 14581:, with a list of desired parties, evidence of disruptive behavior of each, evidence of prior dispute resolution attempts about each, and without a general unenforceable aspersion-casting "we need to remove everyone from the topic area". 14469: 12464:". This is a repeating problem and is only leading to parties that are able to mobilise more effectively getting changes made. I'm not saying policy is being purposefully gamed here, but if it was, this is one way it might look. Tagging 11259: 13229: 11794:- they wholly disregard WP policies and prior warnings/sanctions, as most ARBPIA sanctions for experienced editors have effectively amounted to slaps on the wrist. I'd also like to specifically emphasize the point made by Swatjester of 8415: 3238: 12264:. If there were any utility to a page which simply counts the number of times someone's signature appears on a page, I would ask him to rerun the data based on 18 comments in 4 discussions so that NoCal100 would appear in his list. -- 7670: 16488: 14640: 13569: 11899: 9812:"Blake Flayton, a vocal commentator on Jewish and Israeli issues, responded to the post, calling the changes “egregious” and urging someone with expertise to edit the page to reflect what he considers to be a more accurate portrayal" 5477: 11067: 9548: 7617: 7378: 6249:, shows the contrary, an influx of new editors in recent times. Difficult to be certain without more data but my sense is that the pattern will hold up for other articles as well. It is of course possible that both things are true. 9974: 6377: 9387: 15328: 2816: 12651: 5670: 9221: 8861:, Iskandar323 actually proposed two titles with "massacre" in them. I'll leave it for readers to decide whether or not this is irrelevant to the claim that Iskandar323 only supports "massacre" when the victims are Palestinian. 6026: 10663: 3616:. I think there's a strong interest in standardization, so I would rather have separate up-or-down votes on those two things, and then it would seem logical for you to support both of those motions. Curious for your thoughts. 15542: 11000: 10544:, I believe that 13, collectively making 75,383 edits to the topic area since 2022, generally align with a pro-Palestinian position. I believe two, collectively making 5,832 edits, generally align with a pro-Israeli position. 8982: 8528: 5616: 8196: 3340: 15518: 8614: 3795: 1957: 16433:@SN, that is fair, I suppose my thinking is that merges are far enough removed from deletion (even though some content may be left out of the final product) that they would not fall under the "broadly construed" umbrella. 15324: 15316: 13400:- I am unsure if this has actually happened (and if it has whether it's happened in the Israel-Palestine subject area), but it only takes a quick look through contentious topics on RSN to see that editors are engaging in 13385: 12880: 11629: 13873: 13607: 8878: 3072: 7457:, where BM has some 73 comments there. I dont think that subpage is accurate either in its definition or its counting, and Id caution that evidence by editors who are highly involved not simply be accepted as accurate. 6113:, now defined as looking for the “colonization of land outside Europe”), in spite of substantial opposition. The current situation both scares away potential great editors and destroys our credibility and neutrality. 3395: 2811: 11019: 3024: 3399: 15103: 14046: 13821: 12945: 3403: 13116: 12496: 8055:- euphemistic in the extreme, an "incident" in which an army kills 6 children and a cameraman, and all casualties are civilians? No source calls it an incident either. As far as sources calling it a massacre, well 3038: 2208: 14914: 12815:, I don't know what is. Some editors argued that titles do not imply statements, effectively saying that POV names do not exist. Such arguments tend to be invoked selectively. The move received significant press ( 9956:(many of whom have been with us for well over a decade) who are primarily on Knowledge to push their POV . . for most of the last two decades the two sides have been seriously mismatched in terms of numbers and 5433: 3791: 3116: 1953: 1902: 14380: 12819: 16181: 15320: 15312: 11109: 8171:. As for the RM statistics, Seggallion only participated in one; if you like, I can try to group sockpuppets under their masters as I did at the activity statistics, but better to discuss that on the talk page. 15598:, the Arbitration Committee did not consider turning an article into a redirect to be a violation of the topic ban. I did not think any of these actions would have violated the ban. But now I am not certain. 13101:(and no: that isn't because our editing is that bad: some of the very worst abuse I have suffered was after I removed that the Western Wall was "In Israel" (It isn't, according to the International community.) 9497:, namely BilledMammal, Nableezy, and Selfstudier (and maybe also Levivich?). I think some of these allegations are stronger than others but those allegations are 100% part of why this case was referred to you. 7759: 7406:. The abuse of sockpuppets is a powerful advantage at Knowledge, and wooden enforcement of teh rulz about conduct, ignorant of content and context, a powerful disincentive to being honest and straightforward. 6871:, for the disposable account fan, for people to edit war and advocate to their hearts content and stick a disclaimer on the articles for readers. Things like that would be interesting and possibly informative. 7836: 7644: 7265: 7000: 3557:). If it would be useful to import some language from Remedy 6-8, that could be on the table. But there may not be much appetite for doing so, in which case we can just adopt the motion as drafted here. Best, 2635: 16371: 15890: 13877: 10476:, with whom I engaged in at considerable length around 2016. But I had no, and do not have, and don't care to have, any proof that this intuition might be correct and indicate a dual account. What I did was 7800: 2262: 1916: 9081: 8609: 2542: 14186: 9116:, we don't know what's going to pass yet, so we don't know that any tools are being added to our toolbox. I think a clear statement from Arbcom about the topic area would be handy if they're going to punt. 7147: 5965: 2410: 2398: 2336: 2106: 1971: 14160: 3787: 3779: 1949: 1941: 7771: 3550: 16519: 15308: 8576: 5885: 16330: 14633: 3685: 3360: 14605: 14536: 7846: 6001:). Seeing a list of highly motivated folks in this topic area is not a sign necessarily they are always hogging the attention, so much as they provide much of the energy to keep Knowledge up to doate. 5130: 14590: 14527: 14382: 13448: 6813:" applies to them. We know this because we have lots of data about how new highly motivated biased editors cross (or tunnel through) the EC barrier and what they do when they get into the topic area. 6805: 5143: 4820: 11848: 10437: 2968: 16493: 16483: 16375: 16136: 12831: 10499: 14375: 14248: 13778: 13062: 12849: 11145: 3269:'s idea; I'm open to them changing the motion text if I missed something. It's a simple and clear solution, and simplifying confusing conditions that have actually caused confusion is good to me. 16462: 16428: 14233: 10433:, of BilledMammal classifying you as a supporter of the term 'massacre' when you did no such thing, confirms my wariness about drawing any conclusions from broad statistical charts like that. In 3783: 3775: 2258: 2209: 1945: 1937: 13342: 8917:. This gives more discretion to admins without good reason. A better idea would be to encourage AE to forward individual appeals to ArbCom if they think ArbCom is better equiped to handle them. 5124: 15857: 15300: 11979:, et al. This complete lack of introspection/acknowledgement that "hey, maybe I'm part of the problem too" is exactly why many in the area, if not all its experienced users, deserve sanctions. 6953: 264: 12006: 5899: 3754: 2479: 11959: 3248: 1874: 1869: 1862: 1857: 1852: 1847: 1842: 1837: 1832: 1827: 1822: 1817: 1812: 1807: 1802: 1797: 1792: 1787: 1782: 1777: 1770: 1765: 1760: 1755: 1750: 1745: 1740: 1735: 1730: 1069: 1064: 1057: 1052: 1047: 1042: 1037: 1032: 1027: 1022: 1017: 1012: 1007: 1002: 997: 992: 987: 982: 977: 972: 965: 960: 955: 950: 945: 940: 935: 930: 925: 12398: 8552: 2232: 14658: 12045: 9072: 4928: 3482: 1725: 1720: 1715: 1710: 1705: 1700: 1695: 1690: 1685: 1678: 1673: 1668: 1663: 1658: 1653: 1648: 1643: 1638: 1633: 1628: 1623: 1618: 1613: 1608: 1603: 1598: 1593: 1586: 1581: 1576: 1571: 1566: 1561: 1556: 1551: 1546: 1541: 1536: 1531: 1526: 1521: 1516: 1511: 1506: 1501: 1494: 1489: 1484: 1479: 1474: 1469: 1464: 1459: 1454: 1449: 1444: 1439: 1434: 1429: 1424: 1419: 1414: 1409: 1402: 1397: 1392: 1387: 1382: 1377: 1372: 1367: 1362: 1357: 1352: 1347: 1342: 1337: 1332: 1327: 1322: 1317: 1310: 1305: 1300: 1295: 1290: 1285: 1280: 1275: 1270: 920: 915: 910: 905: 900: 895: 890: 885: 880: 873: 868: 863: 858: 853: 848: 843: 838: 833: 828: 823: 818: 813: 808: 803: 798: 793: 788: 781: 776: 771: 766: 761: 756: 751: 746: 741: 736: 731: 726: 721: 716: 711: 706: 701: 696: 689: 684: 679: 674: 669: 664: 659: 654: 649: 644: 639: 634: 629: 624: 619: 614: 609: 604: 597: 592: 587: 582: 577: 572: 567: 562: 557: 552: 547: 542: 537: 532: 527: 522: 517: 512: 505: 500: 495: 490: 485: 480: 475: 470: 465: 16174: 14366: 10460: 7900: 16072: 11927: 11790: 6786: 4765: 3771: 3029: 1933: 1265: 1260: 1255: 1250: 1245: 1240: 1235: 1230: 1225: 460: 455: 450: 445: 440: 435: 430: 425: 420: 10550: 10265: 7797: 2528:, as userspace is traditionally given broad latitude too, it seems that WP:ECR and WP:UOWN should have their own jurisdiction, and on the balance WP:ECR should not be excessively broad. 2456: 2387: 16504: 5963: 1200: 395: 15660: 13487:. By resolving this without any sanctions against the editors making this topic area contentious, that is only going to give those editors more reason to continue their disruption and 9163: 8946: 7453:, but a, that isnt a formal discussion, and b. that is a back and forth with a handful of users. That isnt bludgeoning by any reasonable definition. They also somehow neglected to add 7087: 2777: 2255: 2117: 15291: 12947: 12668: 8651: 8090: 7832: 5947: 1185: 380: 11362: 7995: 5496:. Those of you who have done so may want to either strike your comments or add some diffs to support your allegations, before arbcom gets around to asking who the parties should be. 14679: 9350: 9002: 7956: 12256: 8547: 5397: 2581: 2277: 15706: 15016: 12568: 7446: 5409:; emphasis mine) is that I had to submit it here rather than as a case request. If this is to change going forward, the instructions should probably be tweaked to clarify this. — 1121: 15872: 12958: 11655: 11192: 10227: 6875: 5805: 5492: 5443: 3283: 2566: 2296: 15717:, for a year, but which apparently are self renewing and perpetual). I've followed all of them. Asking for them to be removed is not something in my contemplation at this time. 11063: 9946: 6359: 5555:. Only HaOfa and I are relevant to this AE, and with HaOfa not editing since the filing, I don't think it's necessary or a good use of Arbcom's time to look at HaOfa's conduct. 5527: 5315: 3763: 3407: 3344: 1925: 240: 216: 12962: 9152: 9137: 9125: 9108: 9091: 9063: 9048: 9031: 9014: 8644: 5402: 5163: 15561:) is topic banned from deletion discussions, broadly construed. This ban may be appealed twelve months after the enactment of this remedy, and every twelve months thereafter." 15537:) is topic banned from deletion discussions, broadly construed. This ban may be appealed twelve months after the enactment of this remedy, and every twelve months thereafter." 12800: 12709: 5394: 4874: 2830: 2405: 2081: 16036: 15178: 15037: 14936: 14811: 14711: 11366: 10951:, and some other editors (sometimes more crudely) finding such source material to be contrary to popular political opinion. In my experience, getting caught in the middle of 9718: 8992: 3427: 3186: 15277: 12025: 10747:(sock) , to mention a few of the names I mostly recognize as coming under that kind of general category.But then, this kind of analysis is way out of my field of competence. 8636: 7454: 5297: 3740: 16130: 16030: 15964: 13743: 12535: 9403: 6067:, what would be defined as recent? editwars may take the form of months long warring, in which case which edit is a revert, and which is disputed becomes contested as well 14798: 14694:, an uninvolved administrator may require that appeals be heard only by the Arbitration Committee. In such cases, the committee will hear appeals at ARCA according to the 14557: 9862: 9613: 8858: 8756: 15815: 14089: 13587: 12441: 12375: 11625: 11230: 9322: 6490: 6202: 5977: 5931: 5879: 3077: 16474: 16008: 15933: 15828:. I have performed a couple merges since then, but these have been good-faith attempts to make sure at least some of the content makes it into the target article (e.g., 15745: 15689: 12353: 9968: 8566: 13560: 11809:, as I don't think starting from scratch could make things any worse than they currently are - that said, I understand that's a rather draconian/heavy-handed solution. 11212: 9778: 9475:. Selfstudier and I draw different conclusions about that statement we agree on and the Arbs can decide which conclusion they agree with as it's ultimately up to them. 6546: 6179:. Many of the editors here, including myself and several of the uninvolved administrators, were participants and the case revolved around behavior (and content) at the 6166: 6087: 6054: 6036: 5956: 5916: 5894: 5861: 5826: 2756: 13649: 6176: 15807: 15776: 13800: 13374: 13199:" Keeping entrenched editors to protect us from socks and newbies is like keeping cats to protect the mice from kittens" I have no idea what this is supposed to mean. 12901: 12862: 12010: 9767: 7658: 15895: 12955: 12548: 5644: 16325: 16191: 16125: 16096: 14125: 13730: 13418: 12487: 12103: 12037: 10786: 10704: 9740: 9158: 8658: 5422: 5380: 5332: 5290: 5257: 5230: 5212: 5189: 2575: 14452: 13648: 12387: 10926: 10481: 8555: 7157: 2282: 163: 16156: 14785: 13813: 13681: 12906: 12774: 12742: 12639: 12600: 12462: 12234: 12210: 11384: 10920: 10477: 10056: 10008: 9836: 8648: 8631: 7482: 7397: 5635: 2556: 2547: 356: 15157: 14907: 14791: 13881: 13617: 13593: 12188: 9283: 7936: 1099: 15867: 14120: 13635: 13317: 13267: 12401: 12314: 11574: 11236: 11040: 10845: 10795: 9867: 7404: 6184: 2797: 1116: 16140: 14920: 14691: 14285: 14102:, which allows only uninvolved editors to vote. I believe this motion would greatly benefit sockpuppets and meatpuppets at the expense of experienced editors. 13613: 10561: 2567: 2548: 2227: 16419: 16197: 14061: 13980: 13900: 13513: 13499: 12940: 12916: 12779: 12162: 9831: 9801: 9258: 8625: 8592: 8507: 8468: 8443: 8397: 8257: 8213: 8180: 8127: 8102: 8021: 7965: 7909: 7884: 7862: 7813: 7781: 7423: 7387: 7372: 7355: 7334: 7309: 7247: 7230: 7212: 7197: 7181: 7132: 7077: 7053: 6986: 6965: 6884: 6825: 6776: 6532: 6517: 6095: 5428: 2631: 16041: 15024: 12413: 12278: 12014: 10541: 9345: 8839: 8266: 7979: 7825: 5447: 106: 16360: 13975: 13937: 13860: 13837: 13579: 13521: 13477: 13327: 12889: 12571: 12529: 12183: 11765: 10914: 10899: 10876: 7753: 7528: 7096: 6425: 6403: 6387: 6371: 6354: 6331: 6313: 6287: 6258: 6240: 6218: 6205:. Editors named here continue to respond there. Although procedurally a separate AE case, it was filed contemporaneously with and is part and parcel of the 6196: 2474: 16366: 15098: 13664: 12749: 11203: 11104: 11031: 10810: 10132:. Surely you shouldn't take exception to a somewhat playful implication you were a 'cat'. Your presence is very rare in the IP area and your remarks about 9578: 6575: 6148:, just two days after blaming another editor for being a sock solely based on some shared topics of interest with a blocked editor who had 72,000(!) edits 5680: 5244: 16344: 14549: 14155: 13795: 12984: 12506: 12481: 12306: 12268: 11568: 11518: 11475: 11442: 11182: 11168: 11154: 11139: 11119: 11056: 11009: 10994: 10979: 10964: 10818: 10149: 9710: 9683: 9078: 8434:(Nishidani, I do have more to say in regards to your comments - I'm not ignoring the questions/statements you made - but I don't have time at the moment) 7853: 6430: 2806: 2792: 2272: 2241: 2220: 2186: 2169: 16304: 15752: 15269: 14673: 14408: 13736: 12951: 12339: 12274: 10552: 10400: 9574: 8873: 8787: 8750: 8727: 8617: 8584: 8541: 8499: 8460: 8435: 8389: 8249: 8205: 8172: 8119: 8094: 8013: 7957: 7901: 7876: 7854: 7842: 7805: 7773: 7745: 7235: 7064: 6485: 5512: 5338: 4368: 3697: 2772: 15252: 15010: 13366: 13262: 12935: 12250: 11749: 11723: 11697: 11671: 11645: 11619: 11543: 11410: 11305: 10937: 10860: 10779: 10621: 10591: 10577: 10530: 10490: 10454: 10421: 10395: 10373: 10349: 10315: 10295: 10236: 10214: 10195: 10160: 10124: 10106: 10088: 9661: 9637: 9622: 9604: 9590: 9558: 9536: 9521: 9506: 9484: 9457: 9438: 9420: 9397: 9376: 9359: 9338: 9307: 9292: 9274: 9249: 9230: 9213: 9203: 9183: 8833: 8551:. I admit, I don't consider it a priority (although I have already spent some time on it), as I don't see what useful information it would provide, and 7418: 5195: 5055: 3815: 2748: 2721: 13380: 12426: 11337:, so this is the one suggestion here that is at least aimed at what I'd consider the real problem... but it would probably be better to treat it as a 10642: 10430: 10076: 9566: 5302: 16442: 15151: 14901: 14497: 14482: 14030: 13707: 13464: 13351: 12920: 11596: 11379: 11277: 10925: 10756: 10069: 8941: 8904: 8883: 8865: 8852: 8815: 8797: 8776: 8740: 8716: 8694: 8673: 8662: 7927: 7575: 7551: 7537: 7517: 7498: 7473: 6470: 6160: 5792: 5765: 5592: 2688: 2291: 15122: 13652: 13256: 9140: 8537: 7392: 5309: 3732: 16320: 16282: 14414: 14084: 14056: 14008: 12976: 12844: 12178: 12156: 12122: 11998: 11950: 11918: 11867: 11678: 9701: 7726: 7653: 7629: 7606: 7591: 7438: 6794: 6126: 6008: 5714: 5660: 5607: 5564: 5536: 5505: 5486: 2451: 2440: 2421: 2377: 2348: 2315: 313: 15113: 14515: 14264:(in a humourous context that I chuckled at), and referrals to ArbCom from AE have not been common, I wanted to make sure there was clarification. 14261: 11159: 10712: 8641: 6569: 6149: 3507: 3278: 14872: 13555: 13175: 13129: 13110: 13085: 13079: 12205: 12076: 11828: 10112: 6479: 6224: 3642: 3597: 3583: 3323: 3309: 13699: 13661: 13088: 12676: 10805: 10407: 9773: 9426: 3953: 2436: 15723: 14464: 14438: 14423: 14401: 14351: 14330: 14308: 14294: 14273: 13307: 13291: 13245: 13016: 11885: 10840: 8821: 8233: 6790: 6449: 3905: 3061: 15951: 13094: 12565: 12228: 10813: 8736: 8419: 8232: 7698: 6810: 3675: 57: 13546: 13276: 12825: 12797: 10655: 9471: 8380: 6928: 5579: 5311: 3151: 16084:, specifically referencing this same "broadly construed" language, so I'm now not sure that "don't do that again" hasn't already been said. ― 15412: 15346: 15285: 13596:(April 2024 - present), of 75 threads (discounting the two duplicates) 38 of them are PIA-related. And of 94 threads from Oct. 2023 (and the 10676: 10412: 8958: 6015: 5273: 5086: 1207: 402: 15789: 15602: 13725: 12382: 11328: 8951: 8421: 16307:. Participating in any AfD would be an unambiguous violation of their topic bans, contrary to your hypothetical reasoning that would allow 15509: 14182: 14135: 13621: 12882: 12686:. That's not to say it's not a huge problem, but the current focus is established users, and there are factors that make this more urgent: 10568: 9165: 8733: 7930: 7701: 7450: 2514: 1164: 14687: 14577:. If we aren't able to evaluate a single party's conduct, we aren't able to hear a case either. And if we are, a case can be requested at 14429: 1110: 15460: 13379: 12712: 5800: 4784: 14621: 12236: 8690: 6899: 5272: 3125:: I would assume the two terms should be viewed identically. Further thoughts forthcoming — currently discussing among ourselves. Best, 2174: 13870: 13712: 12192: 11652: 7092: 6845:"How many sock accounts are currently active in the topic area, or outside the area (to gain EC or access to wiki-mail for canvassing)" 6798: 6508: 6146: 6140: 4536: 4145: 15821: 13452:, and via strength in numbers can continue to make systemic bias worse, silence opposition/alternative points of view, and ultimately 12391: 11893: 9814:. When we are faced with this sort of off-wiki canvassing is it any surprise that there's some level of disruption to the topic area? 16024: 16002: 15958: 15927: 15910: 13034: 11320: 6932: 5900: 5551: 4947: 4796: 4385: 4193: 62: 15853: 15606: 13757: 12690: 12047: 7640: 6977:. I guess many editors might be flowing upstream from the new post-Oct 7 extensions to the topic area to update pre-Oct 7 articles. 15672: 13667: 11889:, bludgeoning, weaponization of process, less "blatant" incivility, and so on are difficult to definitively sanction - you have to 10338: 6228: 4814: 4802: 4241: 4049: 3947: 3379: 2143: 2002: 1168: 5666: 5108: 3899: 2960: 2598: 2591: 16102: 15625: 15621: 15617: 15260:, I've added "within the area of conflict" above to avoid any possible impression of the motion applying to all edits wiki-wide. 13807: 13655: 4790: 4289: 3588: 3369: 16239: 9595: 8388: 2376: 2304: 15829: 15534: 15498: 15406: 14695: 13760: 13740: 13658: 10947:-compliant scholarly work by largely-Jewish academics, but doing so with a massive-scale disregard for the ArbCom principle of 8909: 7973: 7095: 4892: 4808: 4632: 4584: 4488: 1103: 280: 16057:'d (noting that the section for BLAR contains a "see also" hatnote linking to the deletion policy's section on redirections). 15643: 12472: 10137: 6143: 3929: 15613: 15503: 12822: 10277: 9872: 9845: 7612: 7272: 7143: 6318: 6133: 6101: 5217: 4729: 4680: 4433: 4337: 4001: 3856: 2413: 11051: 6132: 5640: 5007: 3917: 16335: 15595: 15558: 15454: 14569: 14109: 13217:, I don't know what is." That is the problem; you think you know "the Truth", but you obviously haven't read what genocide 5080: 4904: 344: 7203: 2609: 2602: 15647: 15363: 13538: 12720:. Keeping entrenched editors to protect us from socks and newbies is like keeping cats to protect the mice from kittens. 12319: 8536: 8265: 7103: 4952: 4922: 4910: 4741: 4530: 4139: 4097: 81: 16300: 15172: 15089: 15031: 14930: 14916: 14805: 14705: 14130: 12706: 7708: 3421: 3180: 2095: 16296: 16081: 15676: 15629: 14131: 13970: 13932: 13895: 13855: 13832: 13713: 10255: 7768: 7041: 6995: 6795: 5348: 5017: 4898: 4759: 4747: 4379: 4187: 2622: 2259: 15682: 14664: 12694: 7508: 13791: 7163: 6974: 6943: 6893: 6549: 6109:(read the lead) with its own voice. Many disputed changes like this have been introduced through edit warring (check 5521: 4916: 4735: 4235: 4043: 1996: 142: 7505: 5027: 4972: 3390:. Once added by any editor, any marking, template, or editnotice may be removed only by an uninvolved administrator. 16480: 14602: 10404: 9628: 8151: 7287: 7277: 4997: 4977: 4753: 4283: 3971: 2616: 16269: 13420:. Funnily enough, when one of these editors has their conduct called out, the others tend to show up and bludgeon 11872: 8491: 7663: 5941: 5319: 4982: 4962: 3977: 3923: 16225: 16106: 14015: 13026: 12137:. Good-faith ideas that I appreciate, but not sure if they'd fully deal with the core issues of the ARBPIA area. 11744: 11718: 11692: 11666: 11640: 11614: 11591: 11060: 10500: 9807: 9148: 9121: 9104: 9087: 9059: 9044: 9027: 9010: 8988: 6136: 4987: 4838: 4778: 4626: 4578: 4482: 2740: 2713: 2680: 2045: 49: 15651: 15436: 13162: 12030: 11496: 10708: 10465: 7008: 5473: 5442: 5037: 5032: 5022: 5012: 3965: 1890: 1085: 16534: 15430: 14923:. These restrictions must be logged and may be appealed in the same way as all contentious topic restrictions. 13159: 12839: 11729: 11651: 10970: 9988: 8971: 8579:. If you can provide me a couple of topic areas of similar size to ARBPIA, I can address both your request and 5904: 5833: 5756:. This is an example of why "outside voices" aren't necessarily better than the voices of experienced editors. 5042: 5002: 4992: 4957: 4942: 4674: 4427: 4331: 3995: 3959: 3850: 2462: 2308:"area of conflict" to exclude talkspace, because then the ECR restrictions on talkspace would not apply to it. 359: 21: 15484: 15424: 14565: 13430: 12516: 10138: 8935:. This could work if "substantive reason" requires a talk page explanation and not just a brief edit summary. 6361: 5062: 3911: 3822: 16217: 16018: 15996: 15952: 15921: 15904: 15139: 13676: 13630: 12656: 8166: 7615: 4967: 4850: 4560: 4169: 3552: 2503: 2057: 71: 16456: 15657: 15472: 9928: 9697: 8544:, and I have spent a considerable amount of time addressing those requests, including two of three you made. 7262: 5967: 5778: 5623: 4409: 4217: 3081: 15478: 15418: 15357: 13067: 12801: 11786: 11226: 11208: 10829: 9425: 6278: 6083: 6072: 6050: 6032: 5973: 5952: 5927: 5912: 5890: 5875: 5857: 5822: 5077: 4868: 4856: 4548: 4265: 4157: 4091: 4073: 3941: 2857: 2769: 2075: 2063: 2026: 1193: 388: 16143: 15939:@7&6=13: I know I am "implicated". That's why I upper-cased "involved" in my section header *facepalm* 15693: 11358: 6302: 5450: 5357: 5074: 4397: 4313: 4205: 3893: 16539: 16061: 10791: 9731: 9167: 7686:. This drives editors away from the topic area, worsening issues with POV pushing and stealth canvassing. 6246: 4844: 4656: 4608: 4554: 4512: 4253: 4163: 4061: 3535: 2051: 2014: 14138:. This is unavoidable given the volume of scholarship involved. But it was largely kept out of the RfC ( 13164: 13007: 11550: 10000: 7171: 5643:; they go back two weeks. Look at how much of other editor's time they wasted on talk pages. Just their 4704: 4457: 4361: 4301: 4025: 3880: 16512: 16292: 16117: 16088: 15800: 15769: 15738: 15543: 15528: 15466: 15400: 14229: 14201: 12335: 9763: 9736: 9610: 9144: 9117: 9100: 9083: 9055: 9040: 9023: 9006: 8984: 8486: 5059: 4886: 4862: 4773: 4644: 4596: 4500: 4403: 4211: 3819: 3801: 3728: 3638: 3579: 3305: 3147: 3112: 2627:'General sanctions upon related content' says it applies to related content but then redefines this is 2069: 15387: 14142:) itself. The RfC itself was orderly. And finally, it was closed by a panel with a detailed rationale. 12033:) - I support coming down on them as hard as I do the former group, including more than a few editors 11730: 9212: 8089: 6801: 5612: 4692: 4445: 4349: 4121: 4013: 3868: 16204: 16187: 16152: 15519: 13099: 13037: 12768: 12736: 12633: 12594: 10720: 9329: 9099:, I mean any guidance at all. Absent a case I want to know what Arbcom wants to see for enforcement. 6552: 5705: 5439: 5416: 5398: 5374: 5326: 5284: 5251: 5224: 5206: 5183: 5157: 5118: 4723: 4542: 4259: 4151: 4067: 2931: 2903: 2824: 2571: 2552: 2020: 15567: 15375: 15341: 14342: 13950: 13226: 13097: 11370:, which is why they haven't been done yet, but sweeping from-above solutions aren't a substitute. -- 10608:, i.e. held without trial, lawyers or due process, and probably without a skerrick of evidence like 9990: 9527: 9172: 8967: 5740:, all by accounts new to the topic area, at the same time as high-profile off-wiki commentary, e.g. 5461: 5069: 4109: 3827: 16208: 16065: 15850: 15552: 15448: 14115: 13671: 13625: 13526: 13091: 12129: 11806: 10605: 10554: 10381: 9698: 7409: 6463: 4391: 4307: 4199: 2729: 2517: 2199: 1978: 203: 67: 13945:: Yes, one can argue that all articles in controversial subject areas will be viewed as biased by 12664:. People who assert academic consensus on a subjective controversial topic are at best victims of 12231:, but as a quick roll-over of that link shows, he is controlling what page visitors are aware of. 10115: 8229:; while some individual sources are biased, I also think a lot of the criticism of Israel is fair. 6139:, Selfstudier casts aspersions on other editors who joined the discussion and disagreed with them 14204: 14139: 14039: 13787: 12871: 12449: 12445: 12343: 11775: 11222: 11204: 10473: 9921: 8968: 8456: 7636: 7460: 6811: 6440: 6079: 6068: 6046: 6028: 5969: 5948: 5923: 5908: 5886: 5871: 5853: 5818: 5737: 5733: 5729: 5725: 5721: 5700: 5543: 5104: 5100: 5096: 5092: 4650: 4602: 4524: 4506: 4247: 4133: 4055: 3936: 3352: 2765: 2726: 2008: 14574: 14570: 14561: 14190: 14183: 12227: 10905: 10700: 9325: 6394: 3888: 2601:' applies CTOP, ECR and 1RR applies to all other pages except userpages and user talk pages if ' 2465: 2371:" So now, we ask, what is the "topic area" in the case of ARBPIA? That sentence has a footnote: 16046: 15977: 13985: 13966: 13928: 13891: 13851: 13828: 13772: 13510: 13496: 13474: 13393: 12517: 12409:, and it's hard to imagine whatever fills this void being worse than what is already here. As @ 12406: 12246: 11783: 11317: 11199: 10787: 10680: 10504: 8952: 8621: 8588: 8503: 8464: 8439: 8393: 8253: 8209: 8176: 8123: 8098: 8017: 7961: 7905: 7880: 7858: 7809: 7777: 7749: 7383: 7368: 7351: 7330: 7305: 7243: 7226: 7208: 7193: 7177: 7128: 7073: 7049: 6982: 6961: 6924: 6880: 6821: 6772: 6528: 6513: 6436: 5342: 4698: 4451: 4373: 4355: 4295: 4181: 4019: 3874: 2470: 16500: 11130: 8201: 16506: 16356: 16340: 15892: 15794: 15763: 15757: 15732: 15662: 15524: 15395: 15247: 15146: 15005: 14896: 14780: 14653: 14628: 14477: 14144: 13768: 13576: 13484: 13417: 12525: 12502: 12298: 12288: 12221: 11928: 11791: 11026: 10910: 10895: 10872: 10856: 10434: 9885: 9759: 9732: 9678: 7734: 7719: 7712: 6421: 6399: 6383: 6367: 6350: 6327: 6309: 6283: 6266: 6254: 6236: 6214: 6192: 5849: 5837: 5518: 5352: 4881: 4638: 4590: 4494: 4229: 4037: 3692: 3353: 2803: 2789: 2744: 2717: 2684: 2268: 2237: 2216: 2182: 2165: 1990: 353: 17: 12049: 6458:, these knowledgeable Wikipedians, who exactly are they? If you are thinking of those often 2160: 16415: 16183: 16148: 15381: 14337: 13429: 13189: 12932: 12753: 12721: 12618: 12579: 12477: 12422: 12217: 12132: 11843: 11556: 11531: 11506: 11463: 11430: 11398: 11178: 11164: 11150: 11135: 11115: 11100: 11048: 11005: 10990: 10975: 10960: 10933: 10716: 10201: 10166: 10129: 10018: 9935: 8974: 8145: 7765: 7525: 7414: 6042: 5493: 5410: 5368: 5320: 5278: 5245: 5218: 5200: 5177: 5151: 5112: 4718: 4686: 4439: 4343: 4277: 4115: 4007: 3862: 3748: 3122: 2969: 2818: 2256: 1144: 15860: 14392: 13331: 10441: 8: 16409: 16050: 16042: 15839: 15636: 15584: 15548: 15443: 14388: 14104: 13748: 13425: 13362: 13347: 12923: 12376: 11739: 11713: 11687: 11661: 11635: 11609: 11586: 11493: 11375: 11301: 11273: 10775: 10752: 10617: 10587: 10573: 10565: 10526: 10486: 10450: 10417: 10391: 10369: 10345: 10311: 10291: 10232: 10210: 10191: 10156: 10120: 10102: 10084: 10065: 9706: 9657: 9633: 9618: 9600: 9586: 9554: 9532: 9517: 9502: 9480: 9453: 9434: 9416: 9393: 9372: 9355: 9334: 9303: 9288: 9270: 9245: 9226: 9199: 9179: 8963: 8227: 7847: 5989: 5867: 4832: 4620: 4572: 4476: 3003: 2981: 2736: 2709: 2676: 2664: 2594:' applies CTOP, ECR and 1RR to all articles broadly related to the Arab-Israeli conflict. 2287: 2039: 15899: 8262: 6462: 6151:. I can only guess how this editor feels right now and how long they will stay with us. 5091: 3495: 2888: 2646:"(i.e. pages not otherwise related to the area of conflict)" is replaced with "(see ])". 367: 209: 39: 16438: 16424: 16316: 16278: 15369: 15265: 15109: 14698:. A rough consensus of arbitrators will be required to overturn or amend the sanction. 14669: 14586: 14523: 14080: 14052: 14026: 14004: 13488: 13401: 12876: 12614: 12610: 12549: 12354: 12323: 11497: 11313: 11285: 11243: 9847: 9816: 9786: 7646: 7622: 7599: 7584: 7568: 7544: 7530: 7510: 7491: 7466: 7431: 6156: 6122: 6011: 5944: 5788: 5761: 5710: 5656: 5588: 5560: 5532: 5501: 5482: 4668: 4519: 4421: 4325: 4128: 4103: 3989: 3844: 3593: 3478: 3319: 3274: 3020: 2401: 2107: 1972: 1127: 31: 12866: 12716: 10250: 6022: 5083: 2859: 2369: 16253: 15668: 13990: 13986: 13961: 13923: 13886: 13846: 13823: 13764: 13752: 13551: 13506: 13492: 13470: 13336: 13214: 12897: 12812: 12665: 12557: 12327: 12201: 12145: 12111: 12085: 12065: 12011: 11987: 11939: 11907: 11886: 11856: 11817: 10767: 10688: 10598: 10469: 10274: 10220: 10183: 10141: 10039: 9926: 9407: 8765: 8684: 8220: 8160: 8154:) is included in the activity statistics; they're grouped as one of Icewhiz's socks: 7990: 7682: 7379: 7364: 7347: 7326: 7301: 7239: 7222: 7204: 7189: 7173: 7124: 7069: 7045: 6978: 6957: 6876: 6817: 6768: 6524: 6509: 6106: 5770: 5749: 5741: 5176: 4176: 3387: 2518: 2466: 1124:. Numerous legacy and current shortcuts can be used to more quickly reach this page: 13414: 10023: 9688: 8049: 7970: 7011: 5277: 3007: 2985: 2417:". Why does that make any sense? You want to remove talkspace from the topic area?? 16352: 16336: 16014: 15971: 15351: 15257: 15241: 15140: 14999: 14890: 14774: 14647: 14622: 14545:: I invented ECP, so I am 100% with rule changes to make the cat herding easier -- 14471: 14445: 14260: 14223: 14099: 14020:"Knowledge is not just an online encyclopedia. It’s a battleground for narratives." 13779: 13643: 13604: 13571: 13458: 13389: 13241: 13171: 13125: 13106: 13075: 13012: 12644: 12521: 12518: 12498: 12395: 12390: 12359: 11924: 11020: 10906: 10891: 10887: 10883: 10868: 10852: 10825: 10740: 10736: 10732: 10438: 10044: 9748: 9672: 9647: 9473: 9445: 9068: 9036: 8761: 8076: 7111: 6475: 6455: 6445: 6417: 6395: 6379: 6363: 6346: 6323: 6305: 6279: 6250: 6232: 6210: 6188: 5462: 4224: 4085: 4032: 3722: 3703: 3686: 3663: 3659: 3632: 3613: 3609: 3573: 3299: 3167: 3141: 3106: 3086: 3082: 3078: 3048: 2974: 2916: 2798: 2784: 2533: 2487: 2431: 2382:" So we click on that link and find a big table. ARBPIA is near the end. It says: 2358: 2340: 2326: 2264: 2233: 2212: 2202: 2178: 2161: 1985: 1910: 1159: 1149: 12931: 12322: 11796: 9915: 9073: 8081: 7321: 6851:"How many revisions to articles, talk pages, RfCs, RSN etc. are by sock accounts?" 5720: 2954: 2363: 16490: 16475: 16229: 16221: 15240: 15119: 15094: 14868: 14597: 14546: 14533: 14493: 14460: 14434: 14419: 14397: 14389: 14371: 14347: 14326: 14304: 14290: 14269: 14244: 13814: 13597: 13534: 13303: 13287: 13272: 13142: 12717: 12473: 12418: 12303: 12265: 12247: 11779: 11771: 11551: 11526: 11501: 11458: 11425: 11393: 11389: 11261: 11174: 11160: 11146: 11131: 11111: 11096: 11015: 11001: 10986: 10971: 10956: 10929: 10744: 10696: 10509: 10461: 10442: 10242: 10144: 10094: 9995: 9899: 9132: 8769: 8706: 8601: 8141: 8042: 7920: 7410: 5870:) or incidental tag-team editwarring should be treated similarly would be useful 5817: 4272: 3671: 3503: 3244: 3069: 3057: 3034: 2620: 2339: 2248: 1154: 1118: 15685:, and I will not repeat them here. I had no intent to violate the TOPIC BAN on 10643: 9648: 5056: 3816: 2959: 2411: 2399: 2158: 233: 16243: 16054: 16017: 15980: 15825: 14614: 14573:'s conduct and close the original AE report with or without a sanction against 14488: 14315: 14280: 14255: 13771:. Otherwise we're just going by feel and will have every chance of producing a 13756: 13744: 13721: 13449: 13358: 13343: 13253: 13233: 13138: 12673: 12434: 12364: 12347: 12331: 12091: 11976: 11734: 11708: 11682: 11656: 11630: 11604: 11581: 11486: 11371: 11338: 11297: 11289: 11269: 11218: 10948: 10771: 10763: 10748: 10684: 10668: 10649: 10635: 10613: 10609: 10583: 10569: 10522: 10482: 10446: 10413: 10387: 10365: 10357: 10341: 10307: 10287: 10228: 10206: 10187: 10179: 10152: 10116: 10098: 10080: 10061: 9958: 9949: 9878: 9702: 9668: 9653: 9629: 9614: 9596: 9582: 9550: 9543: 9528: 9513: 9498: 9476: 9449: 9430: 9412: 9389: 9368: 9351: 9330: 9299: 9284: 9266: 9241: 9222: 9195: 9175: 9113: 9096: 8894: 8450: 8410: 8244: 8136: 8000: 7891: 7869: 7281: 7107: 6868: 6802: 6791: 6339: 6296: 5845: 5841: 5779: 5608: 5604: 5571: 5404: 5312: 4827: 4615: 4567: 4471: 3529: 2996: 2761: 2731: 2704: 2671: 2539: 2525: 2283: 2131: 2034: 1134: 345: 251: 227: 8495: 7035: 6245: 2331: 1886: 1081: 328: 16528: 16434: 16420: 16312: 16274: 16257: 16249: 16164: 15883: 15714: 15710: 15261: 15105: 14665: 14582: 14578: 14519: 14150: 14076: 14067: 14048: 14022: 14000: 13942: 13910: 13783: 13542: 13457: 13453: 13413: 13210: 13206: 13151: 13147: 12969: 12832: 12816: 12808: 12675: 12553: 12383: 12372: 12257: 12172: 11972: 11836: 11247: 10728: 10692: 10551: 10426: 10043: 10029: 9981: 9570: 9463: 9191: 9019: 8998: 8938: 8901: 8880: 8862: 8849: 8830: 8826: 8812: 8794: 8773: 8737: 8713: 8691: 8670: 8659: 8514: 8477: 8406: 8191: 8109: 8043: 8028: 7983: 7820: 7788: 7761: 7702: 7683: 7611: 7360: 7339: 7316: 6970: 6409: 6152: 6142:, Nableezy asks the opening editor on their page if it's their first account 6118: 6102: 6023: 5813: 5784: 5757: 5706: 5676: 5652: 5584: 5556: 5552: 5528: 5497: 5478: 5239: 5171: 4663: 4416: 4320: 3984: 3839: 3589: 3525: 3474: 3315: 3270: 3044: 3016: 2508: 2504: 2498: 2448: 2437: 2418: 2345: 2312: 2193: 2150: 2138: 2123: 1139: 16101: 12242: 11876: 10146: 9960:, either by long-term tag teaming or by swinging poorly-attended discussions 9298: 7025: 6910: 2492: 2155: 13960: 13547: 13252: 12893: 12467: 12455: 12410: 12402: 12296: 12197: 12138: 12104: 12058: 11980: 11932: 11900: 11849: 11810: 11265: 11064: 10944: 10724: 10171: 9963: 8204: 8156: 6830: 6563: 5866: 3015: 2544: 2524: 14198: 13567: 13426: 12302: 10271: 8859: 6466:, blatant and obvious. If members of the committee can't see it happening 5136: 16289: 16075: 14542: 13527: 13237: 13167: 13121: 13102: 13071: 13008: 12683: 11703: 11451: 11418: 10834: 10672: 7503: 7291: 7188: 6471: 6441: 5998: 5848:) had been placed in text for long while (and therefore should remain by 5636: 4080: 16397: 16113: 14177: 13624: 13059: 12609: 7032: 6950: 6137: 5684: 3350:("Definition of the 'area of conflict'") is amended to read as follows: 1891: 1086: 15090: 14864: 14514: 14489: 14456: 14430: 14415: 14393: 14367: 14343: 14322: 14300: 14286: 14265: 14240: 13533: 13381: 13299: 13283: 13268: 12405:'s suggestion of nuking the topic area with mass topic bans. This is a 11880: 11296:"who are the bad people we can make go away in order to solve this." -- 10133: 9941: 9280: 9255: 9236: 9209: 8822: 7951: 5775: 5753: 5745: 5387: 3667: 3605: 3499: 3240: 3053: 3030: 2852: 2695: 16177: 14066: 11246:, which is rarely enforced) as well as the battleground / aspersion / 11086:"Brief quote from a source." (). "What an editor put on the page." (). 9381: 9143: 8559: 8522: 16382: 15697: 14217: 14209: 14167: 13717: 13096:, while others have managed to get by with hardly a single scratch; 12285: 11498: 10266: 10175: 9725: 8580: 8064: 5266: 3716: 3708: 3653: 3626: 3618: 3612:, the more appropriate way to do so would be by amending the text at 3567: 3559: 3293: 3285: 3266: 3135: 3127: 3100: 3092: 2842: 2563: 2521:, as the broadest possible thing would be no exception to userspace. 16392: 12885:, which I wrote 15 years ago but is just as relevant today as then. 11837: 9784: 9493: 6183: 4466: 1903: 204: 16214: 15577: 11803: 10517: 8056: 5997: 1888: 1083: 12990: 12750: 9402: 14863: 12792: 12700: 12697: 12679:), and such avoidance will almost always produce better results. 9977: 6917: 6413: 6180: 6110: 5693: 2639: 2507:, and the opposing side would be "add exception of userspace" to 16291: 12786: 11807: 9986: 7558: 6973:, removing topic area articles created from Oct 7, 2023 onwards 6412: 5679:" in a brief discussion. We can't analyze the number of RSes in 2643:"with the exception of userspace" is removed from the definition 1122: 12703: 10560: 10513: 8349: 7542: 7253: 6572: 6177: 2971:. This leads to the following result, which is confusing to me: 1109: 9495: 9075: 8457: 7828: 7727: 7106: 6906: 6272: 5943: 3334: 2917: 2836: 1892: 1087: 277: 176: 136: 124: 78: 13383: 13282: 11268:, ignoring the underlying causes or more complex aspects.) -- 11250: 8577: 8046:, and is emblematic of the civility issues in the topic area. 7455: 5844: 2177:, the same technicality being referred to by another editor. 1106: 15755:(who is implicated here) who posted the irrelevant personal 13185: 10890: 3608:: I would consider that if we want to exempt userspace from 1120: 15695: 14641: 11681:, which I'm not sure either of us would agree is the case. 9970:, from a core group of editors that perennially show up to 7689: 6499: 2495: 2126:(Idk if it is worth changing both to link to namespace 1). 15278: 10301: 7269: 6837: 3741: 2629:(i.e. pages not otherwise related to the area of conflict) 252: 228: 13539: 10770: 10464: 5901: 3160: 2889: 15886:" has a pretty strict meaning on Knowledge. A topic ban 14134: 13236:: I have given no such advice!!!!! Quite the opposite! 8613: 16252: 13117: 11770: 8114: 8067: 6848:"How has the number of sock accounts varied over time?" 6542: 6145:, and Sean Hoyland accused the creator of being a sock 5647: 3170: 16405: 16303: 15493: 13388: 12057: 11333: 9265: 7014: 5542: 5196: 5103:, or 0RR restrictions on large numbers of individuals 4937: 2090: 16267: 15612: 12371: 9894: 3524: 2990: 2301: 16240: 16049:, therefore potentially resulting in the content of 14161: 14095: 14018: 13806: 13443: 9427: 8498:, when I answered the equivalent question from you) 5681: 2977:'s extended-confirmed restriction does not apply to: 309: 15601:I created this clarification request after reading 13810:and aired their views on the subject of civility. 13084:Also, some cats have been more attacked than most, 13066:defined ;/, I didn' think I scratched a cat's face 10036: 9429:which was closed as moot after this ARCA referral. 9071:, if you're trying to avoid a case, something like 8542: 8225:Personally, I don't subscribe to the position that 7925:I've attempted to address your request to identify 6247: 6185: 3538:; this contentious topics procedure applies to all 3534:Unless otherwise specified, contentious topics are 2999:' extended-confirmed restriction does not apply to: 14564:/ HaOfa, 2024-08-11, 20:50 UTC. The reported user 13600:) to this past March, 41 of them are PIA related. 12784:Number 57's point gets at the heart of the issue: 12613:on articles. Conclusions reached by a WikiProject 10562:Media coverage of the Israeli–Palestinian conflict 7837:argued that it was unreliable due to "severe bias" 7451:Talk:Sbarro restaurant suicide bombing#MEMRI quote 5992:to correctly attribute which side says what, etc. 5581:the replies that actually happened split the focus 5194:@Levivich: There's currently a discussion over at 2484:This amendment request came to my attention after 8538:User talk:BilledMammal/ARBPIA activity statistics 8238:Generally, I don't think we're mischaracterizing 5627:editors who follow RS vs. a bunch of socks; it's 16526: 16376:Conduct in deletion-related editing: Clerk notes 15574:initiating or participating in merge discussions 13918:topic area is concerned. Others, I do not know. 8248:by Thebiguglyalien, and my RM table, is useful. 7138:Replicators (socks) - the gift that keeps giving 6796:plenty of accounts evading topic bans and blocks 3166:For the purposes of editing restrictions in the 15514:I request clarification on these two remedies: 14094:I wasn't intending to comment, but then I read 12718:We've known the dangers of cats for a long time 8571:Edits made since 2022 to article and talk space 8288:Generally align with a pro-Palestinian position 8242:, but if you want something more solid I think 7982:, regarding the prevalence of sock puppets and 6921:The number of unique editors reducing over time 6913:Compare the topic area to the rest of Knowledge 3172:the Arab-Israeli conflict, broadly interpreted. 2207:has now raised the question indirectly as well 15609:to a merge discussion violated the topic ban. 13460:who have, even just once, turned the heat up. 12959:a recent discussion of general Israeli sources 9954:core group of 10-15 editors in this topic area 7344:The top 20 contributors made 23% of the edits. 5351:) regarding the bludgeoning. I would point to 333:Click here to file a request for clarification 13154:, after nearly 20 years each for both of you. 10223:. Thanks Sean. That is precisely the kind of 10097:suit to be filed against me in the future:):( 9914:in a way inconsistent with a CTOP subject.' ( 8669:and one statement in the Discussion section. 5458:majority of editors are doing nothing wrong. 1201: 396: 322:To file a clarification or amendment request: 15986:may not edit at all, even if the edits seem 15835:I don't see anything wrong with placing the 15761:that I called out at the merger discussion. 14998:Proposed. Per SFR. To mitigate bludgeoning. 12892:It is a huge task. I am not volunteering. -- 12883:User:Ravpapa/The Politicization of Knowledge 7104:Biased non-extendedconfirmed probable-sock B 5836:, there are still questions of how to apply 5603:Somebody tries to get Knowledge to say that 3363:is amended by appending the following text: 1165:Knowledge:Arbitration/Requests/Clarification 16305:WP:Articles for deletion/Bent's Camp Resort 15751:As a point of clarification, I note it was 15118:There is no register of whom is involved -- 14196:Remedies that only ArbCom can impose (e.g. 13995: 12299:deleted the mention of these 15,802 changes 10645:multiple others accuse that editor of lying 8494:(Also, I would appreciate an answer to the 8335:Generally align with a pro-Israeli position 7942:; sock puppets and masters are marked with 7294:was also "discovered" as a sock months ago. 5651:the RS, and then checkuser the other side. 3043:I don't see any contradiction between what 2144:The discussion here refers (at the bottom) 16449:I'll tackle these in the order presented: 16301:Talk:Mamie Lake (Wisconsin)#Merge Proposal 14518:, but it is starting to sound inevitable. 13025:And then we have cat-herders who likes to 12993:Solution: slaughter all the cats (<- I 12827:, etc), damaging Knowledge's credibility. 12662:overwhelming agreement in reliable sources 12224:enticing several editors into responding. 10013:nuking the topic area with mass topic bans 9906:. . it felt like a fairly large number of 9758:than it was the day before the war began. 7562:to an editor? And to have the gall to say 6936:subsets of a larger set, but it's a start. 6555:Here are some numbers and some questions. 5131:Statement by Red-tailed hawk (AE referral) 3809:Clauses to which an amendment is requested 3068:Is this a real problem or an edge case? -- 1966:Clauses to which an amendment is requested 1208: 1194: 403: 389: 341:Click here to file a request for amendment 16469:link as truly too tenuous to be in scope. 11036:What I'm trying to convince ArbCom to do 9888:this is a sprawling case where basically 8840:this contributions table by Billed Mammal 7976:, regarding the prevalence of POV pushing 6304:+1, I would indeed like to see the data. 6276:than it was the day before the war began. 2812:Statement by Red-tailed hawk (Definition) 287:No arbitrator motions are currently open. 132:Currently, no arbitration cases are open. 12850:Suggestion for Radical Change by Ravpapa 9944:behavior from these battleground editors 8059:was in the article until it was removed. 336:of an arbitration decision or procedure. 295:Requests for clarification and amendment 15946:actually saying that merge discussions 14921:Arab-Israeli conflict contentious topic 14692:Arab-Israeli conflict contentious topic 14299:Support accepting this as a full case. 13735:Without the context, I'm not convinced 13450:tend to gravitate towards the same side 10882:discussing. There are previous cases - 9837:Comments on the motions (TarnishedPath) 8234:that they are biased against Palestine. 7725:12 replies out of 34 by Selfstudier at 7718:15 replies out of 45 by Selfstudier at 7123:subpopulation that is harder to reach. 6464:Here is some "source misrepresentation" 3542:broadly related to a topic, as well as 2702:regarding the exemption for userspace. 14: 16527: 15830:List of Nitty Gritty Dirt Band members 15642:tag to a number of articles including 13993:by bad-faith editors from both sides. 13761:User:BilledMammal/ARBPIA_RM_statistics 13741:User:BilledMammal/ARBPIA_RM_statistics 11929:heavily-experienced, long-term editors 9565:I want to bring to ArbCom's attention 9001:, that part of BANPOL is just quoting 7284:was "discovered" as a sock months ago. 7022:Selecting 35 fairly prominent articles 2610:General sanctions upon related content 2603:General sanctions upon related content 2311:Or maybe I missed the point entirely. 16287:Szmenderowiecki, your statement that 13753:exception of non-neutral common names 13396:. However, Nishidani is correct that 13070:, but that cat apparently disagreed! 12682:I see the sockpuppetry issue to be a 12262:Participating fully isn't a bad thing 9992:in defense of violation of WP policy. 9808:this article at Jewish News Syndicate 6903:getting perceived opponents blocked. 1111:directly to the Arbitration Committee 15882:Yes, I think I agree. It's because " 7711:26 replies out of 59 by Levivich at 6975:doesn't seem to make much difference 5517:26 replies out of 59 by Levivich at 5337:I have read through the analysis by 3532:says about scoping is one sentence ( 2599:Definition of the "area of conflict" 2592:Definition of the "area of conflict" 2337:Definition of the "area of conflict" 180:Clarification and Amendment requests 16271:, but it was not added explicitly. 16045:should or shouldn't be merged into 15302:Conduct in deletion-related editing 15248: 15147: 15006: 14897: 14781: 14654: 14629: 14478: 13716:), so that should be reviewed too. 13398:a wide bias can lead to deprecation 12240:. This is also why I learned that 11027: 9930:combative, actively hostile methods 9896:that AE hasn't been able to resolve 9679: 8606:Because it’s data, not methodology. 6171:1.There is another relevant recent 5049:Information about amendment request 3693: 2967:to the ARBPIA area as described at 2101:Information about amendment request 107:Ongoing problems surrounding Yasuke 27: 15189:Support votes needed for majority 15048:Support votes needed for majority 14947:Support votes needed for majority 14822:Support votes needed for majority 14722:Support votes needed for majority 14132:Talk:Jerusalem/2013 RfC discussion 12963:the recent Electronic Intifada RfC 12294:list of sockpuppets in that table. 12018:"/their behavior is justified/etc. 11677:right. I was once even accused of 10111:And Huldra thanks indeed for that 10048:even just once, turned the heat up 9940:tendentiousness, bludgeoning, and 8947:Statement by ScottishFinnishRadish 8575:(c) - This is actually similar to 5903:. Allegations of just genocide or 5583:, it was the first admin comment. 3438:Support votes needed for majority 3197:Support votes needed for majority 28: 16551: 16060:Given that the discussion was at 14532:We probably need to hold PIA5. -- 13603:I get the sense that the ongoing 12273:It is worth noting that the data 10540:looking at the top 20 editors at 7736:Added 01:28, 27 August 2024 (UTC) 7093:Biased extendedconfirmed editor A 7018:I've tried to look at this by... 5938:Regarding Number57's assessment, 5298:which was imposed on NewImpartial 15942:@Primefac. I don't think anyone 15607:7&6=thirteen's contributions 14680:Motion 1: Appeals only to ArbCom 14136:very lengthy analysis of sources 14096:#Motion 3: Involved participants 13439:to have more heat than light in 13161:others do so rutinely as well, 12216:rebuffed. As a single example, 8915:Motion 1: Appeals only to ArbCom 8240:pro-Knowledge as pro-Palestinian 7029:for each article and talk page. 6782:Being realistic/know your limits 5600:other, or is it just the truth? 5365:simply dominating by pure volume 5135: 2930: 2902: 15873:Statement by INVOLVED Seriality 15719:Nevertheless, I will implement 15017:Motion 3: Involved participants 11193:Statement by AirshipJungleman29 10557:Volume 17, Issue 1 pp. 116-135) 10468:posed by an unfamiliar editor, 10364:of the IP area's POV-stand-off. 10057:the list of 100 new IP articles 10042::I see the only solution being 9843:Motion 3: Involved participants 9005:, it can be changed by Arbcom. 8927:Motion 3: Involved participants 8549:disturb the point want to make 7059:Using evidence-based approaches 6939:Random sample (15000 articles). 6862:Certainly, it's a problem that 6045:talk page RFC for an example)? 5806:Statement by Bluethricecreamman 3380:ArbCom Arab-Israeli enforcement 2929: 2901: 2393:" (my emphasis) So in fact ECR 2389:with the exception of userspace 2378:Arbitration Committee sanctions 16520:18:24, 20 September 2024 (UTC) 16494:12:32, 11 September 2024 (UTC) 16484:20:48, 10 September 2024 (UTC) 16361:15:15, 10 September 2024 (UTC) 16321:04:30, 12 September 2024 (UTC) 16256:, as the article has not been 16226:WP:Deletion policy#Redirection 16192:10:21, 10 September 2024 (UTC) 16031:11:18, 11 September 2024 (UTC) 16009:10:16, 10 September 2024 (UTC) 15916:17:28, 6 September 2024 (UTC) 15270:22:29, 16 September 2024 (UTC) 15253:21:20, 15 September 2024 (UTC) 15152:21:20, 15 September 2024 (UTC) 15123:10:05, 19 September 2024 (UTC) 15114:22:27, 16 September 2024 (UTC) 15099:18:38, 16 September 2024 (UTC) 15011:21:20, 15 September 2024 (UTC) 14902:21:20, 15 September 2024 (UTC) 14873:15:03, 16 September 2024 (UTC) 14786:21:20, 15 September 2024 (UTC) 14674:12:23, 17 September 2024 (UTC) 14659:21:20, 15 September 2024 (UTC) 14498:20:22, 16 September 2024 (UTC) 14483:20:09, 16 September 2024 (UTC) 14465:19:55, 16 September 2024 (UTC) 14439:00:35, 12 September 2024 (UTC) 14156:15:01, 18 September 2024 (UTC) 14121:13:42, 16 September 2024 (UTC) 14085:12:20, 16 September 2024 (UTC) 14057:11:17, 17 September 2024 (UTC) 14031:20:31, 17 September 2024 (UTC) 14009:01:01, 16 September 2024 (UTC) 13976:13:03, 18 September 2024 (UTC) 13938:22:35, 17 September 2024 (UTC) 13901:20:27, 16 September 2024 (UTC) 13866:Specific views on the motions: 13861:13:39, 16 September 2024 (UTC) 13838:23:13, 12 September 2024 (UTC) 13817:needs to be strictly enforced 13693: 13514:06:18, 16 September 2024 (UTC) 13500:00:50, 16 September 2024 (UTC) 13478:01:07, 12 September 2024 (UTC) 13308:05:53, 15 September 2024 (UTC) 12775:17:23, 16 September 2024 (UTC) 12392:Discord servers are being used 12222:Talk:Zionism#Colonial project? 12157:23:00, 16 September 2024 (UTC) 12082:Also, with all due respect to 11805:. I will openly disclose that 11569:21:33, 16 September 2024 (UTC) 11544:00:28, 16 September 2024 (UTC) 11380:05:37, 18 September 2024 (UTC) 11183:18:26, 18 September 2024 (UTC) 11169:21:56, 16 September 2024 (UTC) 11155:21:45, 16 September 2024 (UTC) 11140:21:52, 15 September 2024 (UTC) 10915:20:02, 16 September 2024 (UTC) 10435:the example where you are said 9863:03:33, 16 September 2024 (UTC) 9832:13:54, 17 September 2024 (UTC) 9711:21:53, 16 September 2024 (UTC) 9684:21:42, 16 September 2024 (UTC) 9662:20:34, 16 September 2024 (UTC) 9638:01:07, 16 September 2024 (UTC) 9623:00:31, 16 September 2024 (UTC) 9605:00:12, 16 September 2024 (UTC) 9153:18:41, 18 September 2024 (UTC) 9126:00:59, 16 September 2024 (UTC) 9109:00:22, 16 September 2024 (UTC) 9092:22:16, 15 September 2024 (UTC) 8942:07:33, 16 September 2024 (UTC) 7720:Talk:Zionism#Colonial project? 7713:Talk:Zionism#Colonial project? 7388:04:34, 18 September 2024 (UTC) 6426:14:22, 16 September 2024 (UTC) 6088:21:45, 15 September 2024 (UTC) 5905:Genocide_of_indigenous_peoples 5834:Genocide of indigenous peoples 5793:05:20, 18 September 2024 (UTC) 5766:20:33, 16 September 2024 (UTC) 5715:20:07, 16 September 2024 (UTC) 5519:Talk:Zionism#Colonial project? 5097:imposition of 0RR restrictions 5060:recent Arbitration Enforcement 3820:recent Arbitration Enforcement 3666:to avoid further confusion. - 3546:that are related to the topic. 3370:ArbCom Arab-Israeli editnotice 3079:extended confirmed restriction 2653:enforcement templates on them. 346:contentious topics restriction 13: 1: 16443:19:40, 8 September 2024 (UTC) 16429:18:29, 8 September 2024 (UTC) 16345:15:47, 9 September 2024 (UTC) 16283:04:34, 9 September 2024 (UTC) 16157:17:20, 8 September 2024 (UTC) 16126:14:02, 8 September 2024 (UTC) 16097:13:15, 8 September 2024 (UTC) 16037:Statement by GhostOfDanGurney 15965:18:56, 8 September 2024 (UTC) 15934:13:10, 8 September 2024 (UTC) 15868:20:43, 8 September 2024 (UTC) 15824:I was also topic-banned from 15808:12:27, 9 September 2024 (UTC) 15777:16:41, 8 September 2024 (UTC) 15746:12:54, 8 September 2024 (UTC) 15570:Does this topic ban include: 15292:05:24, 8 September 2024 (UTC) 14688:contentious topic restriction 14634:19:29, 1 September 2024 (UTC) 13796:16:48, 2 September 2024 (UTC) 13726:09:20, 2 September 2024 (UTC) 13682:22:01, 2 September 2024 (UTC) 13489:"civil" POV pushing behaviors 13435:A contentious topic does not 13292:21:55, 2 September 2024 (UTC) 13257:00:11, 3 September 2024 (UTC) 13246:00:10, 3 September 2024 (UTC) 12743:21:24, 1 September 2024 (UTC) 12342:illustrated this excellently 12307:12:38, 3 September 2024 (UTC) 12016:there is no war in Ba Sing Se 11120:23:48, 2 September 2024 (UTC) 11105:22:58, 2 September 2024 (UTC) 11032:22:50, 1 September 2024 (UTC) 11010:21:38, 1 September 2024 (UTC) 10796:09:59, 3 September 2024 (UTC) 10780:16:37, 3 September 2024 (UTC) 10757:03:52, 3 September 2024 (UTC) 10622:22:43, 2 September 2024 (UTC) 10592:22:07, 2 September 2024 (UTC) 10578:21:01, 2 September 2024 (UTC) 10531:20:09, 2 September 2024 (UTC) 10491:16:23, 2 September 2024 (UTC) 10455:12:38, 2 September 2024 (UTC) 10422:10:15, 2 September 2024 (UTC) 10060:highly personalized grudges. 9908:experienced editors, together 9719:Statement by Theleekycauldron 9591:20:37, 8 September 2024 (UTC) 9559:14:46, 3 September 2024 (UTC) 9537:23:57, 2 September 2024 (UTC) 9522:23:43, 2 September 2024 (UTC) 9507:21:46, 1 September 2024 (UTC) 9360:15:23, 1 September 2024 (UTC) 9064:00:06, 3 September 2024 (UTC) 9049:13:26, 2 September 2024 (UTC) 8905:15:12, 3 September 2024 (UTC) 8884:14:29, 3 September 2024 (UTC) 8866:09:38, 3 September 2024 (UTC) 8853:07:22, 3 September 2024 (UTC) 8834:06:16, 3 September 2024 (UTC) 8816:06:16, 3 September 2024 (UTC) 8798:04:58, 3 September 2024 (UTC) 8777:04:27, 3 September 2024 (UTC) 8741:14:55, 2 September 2024 (UTC) 8626:12:51, 3 September 2024 (UTC) 8615:again encourage you to do so. 8593:08:04, 3 September 2024 (UTC) 8508:04:36, 3 September 2024 (UTC) 8469:22:58, 2 September 2024 (UTC) 8444:22:15, 2 September 2024 (UTC) 8398:16:43, 2 September 2024 (UTC) 8258:15:48, 2 September 2024 (UTC) 8214:14:59, 2 September 2024 (UTC) 8181:14:20, 2 September 2024 (UTC) 8128:14:32, 2 September 2024 (UTC) 8103:14:12, 2 September 2024 (UTC) 8022:05:14, 2 September 2024 (UTC) 7654:14:25, 2 September 2024 (UTC) 7630:11:53, 2 September 2024 (UTC) 7373:14:43, 3 September 2024 (UTC) 7356:13:11, 3 September 2024 (UTC) 7335:04:56, 3 September 2024 (UTC) 7310:03:00, 3 September 2024 (UTC) 7248:16:21, 2 September 2024 (UTC) 7231:15:36, 2 September 2024 (UTC) 7213:11:40, 2 September 2024 (UTC) 7198:08:41, 2 September 2024 (UTC) 7182:10:48, 2 September 2024 (UTC) 7133:02:40, 1 September 2024 (UTC) 7027:at the time the edit was made 6480:21:26, 1 September 2024 (UTC) 6404:16:53, 2 September 2024 (UTC) 6388:14:32, 2 September 2024 (UTC) 6372:12:45, 2 September 2024 (UTC) 5661:21:24, 2 September 2024 (UTC) 5095:to multiple individuals, the 3733:16:00, 2 September 2024 (UTC) 2111:Change userspace to talkspace 16293:WP:Merging#Proposing a merge 16131:Statement by Szmenderowiecki 16119:"Ghost of Dan Gurney" (talk) 16111:"Either merge it or AFD it." 16090:"Ghost of Dan Gurney" (talk) 16082:"only warning" in March 2023 15725:For what it's worth, I have 13594:current group of AE archives 12536:Statement by Thebiguglyalien 10521:write anything encyclopedic. 9966:: This pivot was due to the 9806:Not sure if anyone has seen 7762:viewpoint is in the majority 7699:ARBPIA discussion statistics 6203:This one as well (PeleYoetz) 5307:I would hesitate to apply a 2480:Statement by Sir Kenneth Kho 324:(you must use this format!) 7: 16367:Statement by {other-editor} 16297:WP:Proposed article mergers 16062:Talk:Mamie Lake (Wisconsin) 15816:Statement by TenPoundHammer 15605:, where editors found that 14919:of restrictions within the 14606:20:36, 29 August 2024 (UTC) 14591:23:26, 28 August 2024 (UTC) 14550:06:48, 22 August 2024 (UTC) 14537:18:08, 20 August 2024 (UTC) 14528:12:35, 20 August 2024 (UTC) 14424:20:25, 27 August 2024 (UTC) 14402:03:33, 27 August 2024 (UTC) 14376:23:26, 19 August 2024 (UTC) 14352:15:21, 29 August 2024 (UTC) 14331:18:27, 27 August 2024 (UTC) 14309:16:41, 26 August 2024 (UTC) 14295:15:14, 19 August 2024 (UTC) 14274:15:07, 19 August 2024 (UTC) 14249:14:40, 19 August 2024 (UTC) 14234:18:39, 17 August 2024 (UTC) 14090:Statement by starship.paint 13636:17:39, 31 August 2024 (UTC) 13588:Statement by Jéské Couriano 13580:14:54, 26 August 2024 (UTC) 13556:10:52, 23 August 2024 (UTC) 13367:17:11, 30 August 2024 (UTC) 13352:22:15, 22 August 2024 (UTC) 13339:would clean up discussions. 13277:20:56, 22 August 2024 (UTC) 13176:22:58, 23 August 2024 (UTC) 13130:23:17, 22 August 2024 (UTC) 13111:22:24, 22 August 2024 (UTC) 13080:20:07, 22 August 2024 (UTC) 13017:18:49, 21 August 2024 (UTC) 12977:14:24, 21 August 2024 (UTC) 12956:a recent discussion of +972 12936:14:21, 21 August 2024 (UTC) 12902:05:12, 21 August 2024 (UTC) 12845:01:06, 21 August 2024 (UTC) 12640:23:46, 20 August 2024 (UTC) 12601:22:47, 20 August 2024 (UTC) 12530:19:54, 20 August 2024 (UTC) 12507:16:26, 20 August 2024 (UTC) 12482:22:09, 22 August 2024 (UTC) 12427:11:58, 20 August 2024 (UTC) 12269:02:03, 27 August 2024 (UTC) 12251:11:07, 20 August 2024 (UTC) 12206:05:47, 20 August 2024 (UTC) 12179:23:26, 19 August 2024 (UTC) 12123:23:25, 23 August 2024 (UTC) 12077:23:11, 23 August 2024 (UTC) 11999:18:43, 20 August 2024 (UTC) 11951:18:49, 20 August 2024 (UTC) 11919:00:14, 20 August 2024 (UTC) 11868:22:37, 19 August 2024 (UTC) 11829:22:25, 19 August 2024 (UTC) 11750:23:57, 23 August 2024 (UTC) 11724:00:35, 23 August 2024 (UTC) 11698:00:36, 21 August 2024 (UTC) 11679:being a friend of Nishidani 11672:23:23, 20 August 2024 (UTC) 11646:20:34, 20 August 2024 (UTC) 11620:19:21, 20 August 2024 (UTC) 11597:19:28, 19 August 2024 (UTC) 11519:16:00, 23 August 2024 (UTC) 11476:23:40, 23 August 2024 (UTC) 11443:03:11, 23 August 2024 (UTC) 11411:18:53, 19 August 2024 (UTC) 11306:18:37, 21 August 2024 (UTC) 11278:18:09, 19 August 2024 (UTC) 11231:13:55, 21 August 2024 (UTC) 11213:12:51, 19 August 2024 (UTC) 10995:18:19, 30 August 2024 (UTC) 10980:20:30, 29 August 2024 (UTC) 10965:23:18, 19 August 2024 (UTC) 10955:can be quite unpleasant. -- 10938:21:02, 18 August 2024 (UTC) 10900:15:52, 22 August 2024 (UTC) 10877:21:03, 19 August 2024 (UTC) 10861:17:48, 18 August 2024 (UTC) 10841:01:51, 18 August 2024 (UTC) 10396:19:57, 31 August 2024 (UTC) 10374:21:29, 30 August 2024 (UTC) 10350:14:05, 30 August 2024 (UTC) 10316:10:14, 30 August 2024 (UTC) 10296:21:03, 29 August 2024 (UTC) 10237:16:45, 24 August 2024 (UTC) 10215:19:11, 23 August 2024 (UTC) 10196:16:58, 23 August 2024 (UTC) 10161:09:30, 23 August 2024 (UTC) 10125:01:49, 23 August 2024 (UTC) 10107:01:36, 23 August 2024 (UTC) 10089:13:47, 22 August 2024 (UTC) 10070:10:16, 21 August 2024 (UTC) 10015:. This is a WP:BATTLEGROUND 9802:22:28, 17 August 2024 (UTC) 9768:09:58, 21 August 2024 (UTC) 9741:20:10, 17 August 2024 (UTC) 9485:18:39, 30 August 2024 (UTC) 9458:17:08, 30 August 2024 (UTC) 9439:17:02, 30 August 2024 (UTC) 9421:15:24, 30 August 2024 (UTC) 9398:00:07, 29 August 2024 (UTC) 9377:16:27, 20 August 2024 (UTC) 9339:15:29, 19 August 2024 (UTC) 9308:00:02, 29 August 2024 (UTC) 9293:16:45, 26 August 2024 (UTC) 9275:15:34, 19 August 2024 (UTC) 9250:15:09, 19 August 2024 (UTC) 9231:14:45, 19 August 2024 (UTC) 9204:20:09, 17 August 2024 (UTC) 9184:19:55, 17 August 2024 (UTC) 9032:00:03, 29 August 2024 (UTC) 9015:15:15, 19 August 2024 (UTC) 8993:12:29, 19 August 2024 (UTC) 8732:In several places, such as 8717:04:36, 30 August 2024 (UTC) 8695:01:34, 25 August 2024 (UTC) 8674:09:44, 20 August 2024 (UTC) 8663:11:34, 22 August 2024 (UTC) 7966:12:53, 27 August 2024 (UTC) 7910:01:58, 23 August 2024 (UTC) 7885:23:47, 22 August 2024 (UTC) 7863:10:34, 22 August 2024 (UTC) 7814:22:47, 20 August 2024 (UTC) 7782:13:12, 19 August 2024 (UTC) 7754:09:41, 19 August 2024 (UTC) 7607:14:32, 29 August 2024 (UTC) 7592:17:48, 23 August 2024 (UTC) 7576:16:55, 23 August 2024 (UTC) 7552:16:29, 21 August 2024 (UTC) 7538:23:50, 20 August 2024 (UTC) 7518:23:34, 20 August 2024 (UTC) 7499:23:09, 20 August 2024 (UTC) 7474:16:18, 20 August 2024 (UTC) 7439:01:51, 18 August 2024 (UTC) 7419:13:06, 18 August 2024 (UTC) 7078:18:43, 27 August 2024 (UTC) 7054:15:30, 26 August 2024 (UTC) 6987:08:29, 25 August 2024 (UTC) 6966:15:21, 24 August 2024 (UTC) 6885:02:27, 24 August 2024 (UTC) 6826:04:35, 23 August 2024 (UTC) 6777:16:02, 21 August 2024 (UTC) 6533:18:10, 20 August 2024 (UTC) 6518:15:18, 20 August 2024 (UTC) 6450:17:05, 18 August 2024 (UTC) 6355:17:04, 30 August 2024 (UTC) 6332:17:41, 24 August 2024 (UTC) 6314:10:24, 21 August 2024 (UTC) 6288:10:11, 21 August 2024 (UTC) 6259:09:34, 21 August 2024 (UTC) 6241:22:14, 19 August 2024 (UTC) 6223:3.In the interim, avoiding 6219:12:59, 18 August 2024 (UTC) 6197:22:55, 17 August 2024 (UTC) 6161:08:43, 22 August 2024 (UTC) 6127:09:49, 20 August 2024 (UTC) 6055:16:53, 21 August 2024 (UTC) 6037:23:11, 20 August 2024 (UTC) 5978:20:07, 20 August 2024 (UTC) 5957:19:56, 20 August 2024 (UTC) 5932:17:13, 20 August 2024 (UTC) 5917:17:10, 20 August 2024 (UTC) 5895:19:15, 17 August 2024 (UTC) 5880:19:11, 17 August 2024 (UTC) 5862:19:11, 17 August 2024 (UTC) 5827:18:58, 17 August 2024 (UTC) 5593:17:29, 30 August 2024 (UTC) 5565:01:19, 29 August 2024 (UTC) 5537:01:47, 27 August 2024 (UTC) 5506:16:29, 23 August 2024 (UTC) 5487:14:22, 19 August 2024 (UTC) 5423:23:44, 28 August 2024 (UTC) 5381:23:03, 27 August 2024 (UTC) 5359:as pointing at two things: 5333:00:46, 20 August 2024 (UTC) 5291:19:01, 17 August 2024 (UTC) 5258:11:20, 20 August 2024 (UTC) 5231:18:07, 17 August 2024 (UTC) 5213:18:03, 17 August 2024 (UTC) 5190:17:48, 17 August 2024 (UTC) 5164:17:38, 17 August 2024 (UTC) 5125:17:38, 17 August 2024 (UTC) 3765:Palestine-Israel articles 4 3755:17:38, 17 August 2024 (UTC) 3698:21:30, 29 August 2024 (UTC) 3676:01:02, 23 August 2024 (UTC) 3643:00:22, 23 August 2024 (UTC) 3598:19:38, 21 August 2024 (UTC) 3584:19:29, 21 August 2024 (UTC) 3508:07:05, 22 August 2024 (UTC) 3483:20:35, 21 August 2024 (UTC) 3409:Palestine-Israel articles 4 3346:Palestine-Israel articles 4 3324:19:35, 21 August 2024 (UTC) 3310:19:29, 21 August 2024 (UTC) 3279:14:17, 17 August 2024 (UTC) 3249:07:03, 22 August 2024 (UTC) 3152:18:29, 17 August 2024 (UTC) 3117:01:43, 16 August 2024 (UTC) 2831:18:26, 17 August 2024 (UTC) 2576:23:24, 21 August 2024 (UTC) 1927:Palestine-Israel articles 4 1183:Clarification and Amendment 378:Clarification and Amendment 10: 16556: 16218:WP:Deletion policy#Merging 15903:broad an interpretation). 12220:made about 48 comments on 11288:-pushing themselves while 10503:(b) and the effect of the 9779:Statement by TarnishedPath 9443:Selfstudier: I agree that 8496:question I asked you above 7931:ARBPIA activity statistics 7258:This statement is false. 6486:Statement by IOHANNVSVERVS 5465:, which arbcom cannot do. 5452:that contradict each other 5363:in replies to others, and 3062:18:30, 1 August 2024 (UTC) 2807:18:06, 1 August 2024 (UTC) 2793:12:24, 1 August 2024 (UTC) 2773:02:24, 1 August 2024 (UTC) 2586:My understanding is that" 2273:17:40, 1 August 2024 (UTC) 1884: 1179: 1079: 374: 29: 16401:content should live, not 15792:so the record is clear. 15297:Case or decision affected 14696:community review standard 14098:as originally written by 13801:Statement by Figureofnine 13749:neutrally naming articles 13394:WP:NPOV § Bias in sources 13375:Statement by berchanhimez 12952:the recent Al-Jazeera RfC 12348:add more fuel to the fire 10721:User:The Mountain of Eden 10555:Media, War & Conflict 9932:of those they look up to. 8977:, who came up with this.) 7659:Statement by BilledMammal 7566:are making things toxic? 7154:They made a lot of edits. 7004:Can we see this effect? 6491:Statement by Sean.hoyland 5773:'s comment that there is 5645:last 1000 mainspace edits 3760:Case or decision affected 3658:I would support amending 3073:18:52, 31 July 2024 (UTC) 3039:02:30, 31 July 2024 (UTC) 3025:11:18, 30 July 2024 (UTC) 3008:RMs are not edit requests 2986:RMs are not edit requests 2749:07:29, 31 July 2024 (UTC) 2722:07:26, 31 July 2024 (UTC) 2689:07:16, 31 July 2024 (UTC) 2557:16:50, 28 July 2024 (UTC) 2475:12:51, 28 July 2024 (UTC) 2457:Statement by Sean.hoyland 2452:04:37, 29 July 2024 (UTC) 2441:12:25, 28 July 2024 (UTC) 2422:11:54, 28 July 2024 (UTC) 2349:02:43, 28 July 2024 (UTC) 2316:15:14, 26 July 2024 (UTC) 2292:14:58, 26 July 2024 (UTC) 2242:17:55, 28 July 2024 (UTC) 2221:12:10, 28 July 2024 (UTC) 2187:10:42, 28 July 2024 (UTC) 2170:08:43, 28 July 2024 (UTC) 1922:Case or decision affected 1917:13:43, 26 July 2024 (UTC) 1097:This is not a discussion. 301:Use this page to request 197: 194: 191: 188: 156: 153: 99: 96: 93: 90: 16326:Statement by Newyorkbrad 16234:Alternatives to deletion 16232:) are subsections under 16107:Talk:"Weird Al" Yankovic 15249:Penny for your thoughts? 15148:Penny for your thoughts? 15007:Penny for your thoughts? 14898:Penny for your thoughts? 14782:Penny for your thoughts? 14655:Penny for your thoughts? 14630:Penny for your thoughts? 14479:Penny for your thoughts? 14126:Statement by Vice_regent 13765:perspective is expressed 13731:Statement by Hydrangeans 13612:matter to this, akin to 13561:Statement by Doug Weller 13537:, seemingly criticising 12615:are recognized as essays 12488:Statement by LokiTheLiar 12021:Does that mean that the 11028:Penny for your thoughts? 10727:(63%) low editaccount; 10606:administrative detention 9902:the editing environment 9680:Penny for your thoughts? 8033:As I said on that page: 7560:your atrocious behaviour 7393:Statement by Iskandar323 7063:I would like to commend 6167:Statement by Selfstudier 5361:overly repeating oneself 4713:Referring administrators 3833:Involved AE participants 3694:Penny for your thoughts? 2778:Statement by Doug Weller 2624:(that is, not articles). 2118:Statement by Selfstudier 16295:(information page) and 16207:) and content removal ( 16066:Talk:Bent's Camp Resort 15707:WP:DELETION DISCUSSIONS 15705:2-year-old topic bans ( 15699:not justified or needed 13769:highest quality sources 12907:Statement by Black Kite 12748:ago, Arbcom reaffirmed 12367:expressly stating this 12281:show conclusively that 12211:Statement by SashiRolls 12041:got themselves TBANned. 12035:in this very discussion 11385:Statement by Swatjester 10921:Statement by Tryptofish 10719:(56%, NoCal100 sock); 10707:(76%, low edit count); 10466:I had a note on my page 8910:Comments on the motions 8838:Some quick comments on 7984:single purpose accounts 7398:Statement by Dan Murphy 5544:the first admin comment 5400:'s relevant part (i.e. 16047:Mamie Lake (Wisconsin) 15992: 15918: 15596:this Amendment request 15158:Motion 4: Enforced BRD 14908:Motion 2b: Word limits 14792:Motion 2a: Word limits 13454:control the topic area 13318:Statement by Shushugah 13298:lol. But not really. 12671:Encouraging people to 12446:History repeats itself 12334:, particularly of the 12315:Statement by Domedtrix 11575:Statement by Number 57 11237:Statement by Aquillion 10846:Statement by Vanamonde 10806:Statement by DMH223344 10711:(89% low edit count); 10703:(43% low edit count); 10691:(70%, low edit count); 10681:User:Personisinsterest 10653: 10600: 10546: 10282: 10252: 9868:Statement by Nishidani 9774:Statement by PeleYoetz 9579:this ongoing AE report 9159:Statement by Barkeep49 8933:Motion 4: Enforced BRD 8921:Motion 2a: Word limits 8488: 8061: 8039: 7114:, to revert the edits. 3356:, broadly interpreted. 2582:Statement by Callanecc 2278:Statement by Barkeep49 139:Recently closed cases 16535:Knowledge arbitration 16309:the editor spam AfDs 16242:(guideline, shortcut 16198:Statement by Flatscan 16068:, I do think there's 15983: 15880: 15758:argumentum ad hominem 15663:User:7&6=thirteen 15235:Arbitrator discussion 15134:Arbitrator discussion 14993:Arbitrator discussion 14884:Arbitrator discussion 14768:Arbitrator discussion 14566:has not edited since. 14453:in that AE discussion 14202:ScottishFinnishRadish 14062:Statement by Springee 13981:Statement by Amayorov 13424:discussion - through 13001:support this option!) 12941:Statement by Rosguill 12798:long list of scholars 12780:Statement by xDanielx 12336:Righting Great Wrongs 12163:Statement by Zanahary 11223:~~ AirshipJungleman29 11205:~~ AirshipJungleman29 10814:Statement by M.Bitton 10687:(39% banned from IP); 10640: 10596: 10538: 10263: 10248: 9611:ScottishFinnishRadish 9145:ScottishFinnishRadish 9118:ScottishFinnishRadish 9101:ScottishFinnishRadish 9084:ScottishFinnishRadish 9056:ScottishFinnishRadish 9041:ScottishFinnishRadish 9024:ScottishFinnishRadish 9007:ScottishFinnishRadish 9003:Arbitration procedure 8985:ScottishFinnishRadish 8632:Statement by Zero0000 8484: 8050: 8034: 7424:Statement by Nableezy 6096:Statement by ABHammad 5429:Statement by Levivich 5405:request for amendment 5008:ScottishFinnishRadish 4774:ScottishFinnishRadish 3519:Arbitrator discussion 3354:Arab-Israeli conflict 3260:Arbitrator discussion 2297:Statement by Zero0000 360:Arbitration CA notice 50:Arbitration Committee 18:Knowledge:Arbitration 14384:Historical elections 13999:Here’s one example. 13522:Statement by Amakuru 13190:User:Thebiguglyalien 12379:for political ends. 12184:Statement by Ravpapa 11766:Statement by The Kip 10717:User:Kentucky Rain24 9841:To me it seems that 7729:were to sock puppets 7722:were to sock puppets 7715:were to sock puppets 7042:Here are the results 6944:Here are the results 6833:, regarding socks, 6550:This is a small part 6408:10: Enforced BRD or 6043:Herrenvolk_democracy 5093:issuance of warnings 4770:(referral initiator) 3548:) and one footnote ( 3544:parts of other pages 3265:I hope this matches 2961:"all of these pages" 164:Historical elections 15603:this ANI discussion 15510:Statement by Cunard 15182: 15041: 14940: 14889:Proposed. Per SFR. 14815: 14773:Proposed. Per SFR. 14715: 14558:enforcement request 13745:using a common name 13485:immune to sanctions 13213:. If that isn't a 13041:he would have felt. 12985:Statement by Huldra 12807:Another example is 12332:tendentious editing 11424:metaphors, thanks. 10819:Statement by Buidhe 10675:(53% permabanned); 10647:about the evidence. 10542:activity statistics 10501:Cromwell's conquest 9924::a large number of 9904:disturbingly toxic, 9890:all of the regulars 8455:You misunderstand; 8267:activity statistics 7980:Activity statistics 6538:A plea for humility 6431:Statement by fiveby 6322:. Just so we know. 5523:26 replies were to 3431: 3375:editnotice and the 3190: 16540:Knowledge requests 16205:WP:Deletion policy 16109:in which they say 16103:this given example 16051:Bent's Camp Resort 16043:Bent's Camp Resort 15790:Related discussion 15177: 15036: 14935: 14810: 14710: 14556:There has been an 13263:Statement by Arkon 12948:the recent ADL RfC 12811:. If that isn't a 12460:. The rationale? " 11776:AirshipJungleman29 10723:(low edit count); 10715:, low edit count; 10474:Monochrome Monitor 10075:Billed Mammal. Re 9922:AirshipJungleman29 9892:in the topic area 9810:which states that 9649:Jeske's suggestion 8300:CarmenEsparzaAmoux 7676:Stealth canvassing 7461:AirshipJungleman29 7255:- Thebiguglyalien 6231:would be as well. 6225:this sort of thing 6080:Bluethricecreamman 6069:Bluethricecreamman 6047:Bluethricecreamman 6029:Bluethricecreamman 5970:Bluethricecreamman 5949:Bluethricecreamman 5924:Bluethricecreamman 5922:be wonderful too. 5909:Bluethricecreamman 5887:Bluethricecreamman 5872:Bluethricecreamman 5854:Bluethricecreamman 5819:Bluethricecreamman 5801:Statement by האופה 5641:last 1000 contribs 5101:select individuals 4953:Bluethricecreamman 3937:Bluethricecreamman 3426: 3185: 2997:contentious topics 2727:Premeditated Chaos 2538:nicely pointed to 281:Arbitrator motions 114:16 September 2024 16248:If other editors 16209:WP:Editing policy 15753:SerialNumber54129 15336: 15305:arbitration case 15217: 15216: 15076: 15075: 14975: 14974: 14850: 14849: 14750: 14749: 14386:Proposed decision 14216: 14037:A naive proposal: 13974: 13936: 13907:Biased by default 13899: 13859: 13836: 13708:Statement by RAN1 13402:civil POV pushing 12933:Black Kite (talk) 12666:confirmation bias 12377:Knowledge's voice 12154: 12120: 12074: 11996: 11948: 11916: 11887:civil POV-pushing 11865: 11826: 11567: 11542: 11517: 11474: 11441: 11409: 11077:Focus on conduct. 11074:Focus on conduct. 11071:Focus on conduct. 10788:Personisinsterest 10768:Confirmation bias 10735:(57% few edits); 10689:User:Mistamystery 10278:978-0-241-00443-2 10221:User:Sean.hoyland 10184:Irvin Leigh Matus 10077:this set of diffs 8892: 8785: 8766:Kfar Aza massacre 8748: 8725: 8704: 8682: 8655:There is a reason 8373: 8372: 7737: 7639:that Iskandar323 7172: 7151:There were a lot. 6766: 6765: 6207:related AE thread 6173:related AE thread 6107:Israeli apartheid 3802:related AE thread 3799: 3768:arbitration case 3715: 3625: 3566: 3536:broadly construed 3494:Per my reasoning 3466: 3465: 3292: 3225: 3224: 3134: 3099: 3002:Edit requests in 2980:Edit requests in 2943: 2942: 2698:: See discussion 2429: 2356: 2324: 1961: 1930:arbitration case 1898: 1897: 1880: 1879: 1093: 1092: 1075: 1074: 274: 273: 270:8 September 2024 260: 173: 172: 121: 120: 16547: 16518: 16508:7&6=thirteen 16414: 16408: 16299:(process page), 16124: 16120: 16095: 16091: 16079: 15975: 15865: 15863:Ten Pound Hammer 15844: 15838: 15806: 15796:7&6=thirteen 15781:Meanwhile, they 15775: 15765:7&6=thirteen 15744: 15734:7&6=thirteen 15641: 15635: 15590:tags to articles 15589: 15583: 15525:7&6=thirteen 15499:7&6=thirteen 15488: 15461:deleted contribs 15440: 15413:deleted contribs 15396:7&6=thirteen 15391: 15364:deleted contribs 15306: 15250: 15183: 15176: 15173: 15149: 15042: 15035: 15032: 15008: 14941: 14934: 14931: 14899: 14816: 14809: 14806: 14783: 14716: 14709: 14706: 14686:When imposing a 14656: 14631: 14480: 14449: 14412: 14341: 14319: 14284: 14259: 14214: 14194: 14140:WP:RFC/Jerusalem 14112: 14107: 13998: 13997: 13964: 13926: 13889: 13849: 13826: 13700: 13697: 13679: 13647: 13633: 13622:The Omnibus Case 13605:Israel-Hamas war 13574: 13051:57 has in mind, 12997:cats, and would 12912:probably go all 12835: 12771: 12765: 12762: 12759: 12756: 12739: 12733: 12730: 12727: 12724: 12636: 12630: 12627: 12624: 12621: 12597: 12591: 12588: 12585: 12582: 12471: 12459: 12452:is confirmed by 12450:contentious move 12438: 12301: 12295: 12263: 12177: 12171: 12155: 12153: 12150: 12143: 12136: 12121: 12119: 12116: 12109: 12089: 12075: 12073: 12070: 12063: 11997: 11995: 11992: 11985: 11949: 11947: 11944: 11937: 11917: 11915: 11912: 11905: 11866: 11864: 11861: 11854: 11847: 11827: 11825: 11822: 11815: 11747: 11742: 11737: 11721: 11716: 11711: 11695: 11690: 11685: 11669: 11664: 11659: 11643: 11638: 11633: 11617: 11612: 11607: 11594: 11589: 11584: 11566: 11564: 11563: 11560: 11554: 11541: 11539: 11538: 11535: 11529: 11516: 11514: 11513: 11510: 11504: 11490: 11473: 11471: 11470: 11467: 11461: 11455: 11440: 11438: 11437: 11434: 11428: 11422: 11408: 11406: 11405: 11402: 11396: 11029: 10837: 10741:User:Izzy Borden 10739:low edit count; 10737:User:Onlineone22 10733:User:Greyshark09 10505:the great famine 10439:User:Izzy Borden 9886:theleekycauldron 9760:theleekycauldron 9752: 9733:theleekycauldron 9729: 9681: 9547: 9349: 9323:Iranian politics 9214:raised the issue 8978: 8898: 8890: 8877: 8791: 8783: 8754: 8746: 8731: 8723: 8710: 8702: 8688: 8680: 8605: 8553:your explanation 8518: 8481: 8454: 8414: 8280:Extended content 8276: 8275: 8247: 8224: 8195: 8170: 8140: 8117: 8113: 8080: 8070: 8032: 8004: 7994: 7955: 7940: 7924: 7895: 7873: 7845:the same editor 7824: 7792: 7735: 7649: 7625: 7602: 7587: 7571: 7547: 7533: 7513: 7494: 7469: 7459:Also, regarding 7445:upon a time, in 7434: 7169: 6583: 6582: 6438:tag team editing 6343: 6300: 6270: 6267:Theleekycauldron 5639:. Look at their 5515:'s comment that 5419: 5413: 5408: 5396:, my reading of 5392:With respect to 5391: 5377: 5371: 5329: 5323: 5310: 5287: 5281: 5274:have driven away 5270: 5254: 5248: 5243: 5227: 5221: 5209: 5203: 5186: 5180: 5175: 5160: 5154: 5139: 5121: 5115: 5018:Theleekycauldron 4932: 4882:Theleekycauldron 4878: 4824: 4769: 4708: 4681:deleted contribs 4660: 4633:deleted contribs 4612: 4585:deleted contribs 4564: 4537:deleted contribs 4516: 4489:deleted contribs 4461: 4434:deleted contribs 4413: 4386:deleted contribs 4365: 4338:deleted contribs 4317: 4290:deleted contribs 4269: 4242:deleted contribs 4221: 4194:deleted contribs 4173: 4146:deleted contribs 4125: 4098:deleted contribs 4077: 4050:deleted contribs 4029: 4002:deleted contribs 3981: 3954:deleted contribs 3933: 3906:deleted contribs 3884: 3857:deleted contribs 3769: 3713: 3695: 3657: 3623: 3564: 3553:topic ban policy 3432: 3425: 3422: 3384: 3378: 3374: 3368: 3290: 3191: 3184: 3181: 3132: 3097: 2934: 2933: 2906: 2905: 2862: 2861: 2827: 2821: 2801: 2787: 2757:Statement by PMC 2630: 2623: 2537: 2502: 2491: 2435: 2427: 2362: 2354: 2330: 2322: 2252: 2231: 2206: 2197: 2154: 2142: 2135: 2085: 2030: 2003:deleted contribs 1931: 1893: 1222: 1221: 1210: 1203: 1196: 1177: 1176: 1119: 1098: 1088: 417: 416: 405: 398: 391: 372: 371: 363: 343: 335: 323: 298: 297: 259: 256: 186: 185: 151: 150: 146: 88: 87: 42: 16555: 16554: 16550: 16549: 16548: 16546: 16545: 16544: 16525: 16524: 16505: 16412: 16406: 16394: 16378: 16369: 16328: 16211:) are distinct. 16203:Page deletion ( 16200: 16184:Szmenderowiecki 16149:Szmenderowiecki 16133: 16118: 16114: 16089: 16085: 16073: 16039: 15969: 15919: 15875: 15861: 15842: 15836: 15818: 15793: 15762: 15731: 15691:Indeed, I have 15666: 15639: 15633: 15587: 15581: 15512: 15446: 15398: 15349: 15280: 15171: 15168: 15167: 15160: 15030: 15027: 15026: 15019: 14929: 14926: 14925: 14910: 14804: 14801: 14800: 14794: 14704: 14701: 14700: 14682: 14643: 14443: 14406: 14390:User:Black Kite 14338:Red-tailed hawk 14335: 14313: 14278: 14253: 14188: 14179: 14163: 14154: 14128: 14110: 14105: 14092: 14064: 13994: 13983: 13909:? I think that 13803: 13733: 13710: 13705: 13704: 13703: 13698: 13694: 13677: 13641: 13631: 13590: 13572: 13563: 13524: 13377: 13320: 13265: 13143:User:Swatjester 12987: 12968: 12943: 12909: 12852: 12842: 12833: 12782: 12769: 12763: 12760: 12757: 12754: 12737: 12731: 12728: 12725: 12722: 12634: 12628: 12625: 12622: 12619: 12611:local consensus 12605:In response to 12595: 12589: 12586: 12583: 12580: 12538: 12490: 12465: 12453: 12432: 12407:WP:BATTLEGROUND 12317: 12297: 12289: 12261: 12218:Kentucky Rain24 12213: 12186: 12175: 12169: 12165: 12152: 12146: 12139: 12133:Thebiguglyalien 12130: 12118: 12112: 12105: 12083: 12072: 12066: 12059: 12053:- mine is that 11994: 11988: 11981: 11946: 11940: 11933: 11914: 11908: 11901: 11863: 11857: 11850: 11844:Thebiguglyalien 11841: 11824: 11818: 11811: 11784:WP:BATTLEGROUND 11768: 11745: 11740: 11735: 11719: 11714: 11709: 11693: 11688: 11683: 11667: 11662: 11657: 11641: 11636: 11631: 11615: 11610: 11605: 11592: 11587: 11582: 11577: 11561: 11558: 11557: 11552: 11536: 11533: 11532: 11527: 11511: 11508: 11507: 11502: 11484: 11468: 11465: 11464: 11459: 11449: 11435: 11432: 11431: 11426: 11416: 11403: 11400: 11399: 11394: 11387: 11318:WP:BATTLEGROUND 11239: 11200:WP:BATTLEGROUND 11195: 10923: 10848: 10835: 10821: 10816: 10808: 10745:User:Seggallion 10697:User:Eladkarmel 10510:Tsepon Shakabpa 10462:tacit knowledge 10443:User:Seggallion 10429:. The instance 10243:User:CaptainEek 10019:Thebiguglyalien 10002:variety. , , , 9870: 9839: 9781: 9776: 9746: 9723: 9721: 9693:took but it is 9541: 9343: 9261:refer to Arbcom 9161: 8975:Red-tailed hawk 8972: 8953:WP:BATTLEGROUND 8949: 8912: 8889: 8871: 8809:pro-Palestinian 8782: 8770:Alumim massacre 8762:Be'eri massacre 8745: 8722: 8701: 8679: 8634: 8599: 8512: 8475: 8448: 8404: 8374: 8281: 8243: 8218: 8189: 8155: 8134: 8115: 8107: 8074: 8068: 8026: 7998: 7988: 7949: 7938: 7918: 7889: 7867: 7818: 7786: 7661: 7647: 7623: 7600: 7585: 7569: 7545: 7531: 7526:Thebiguglyalien 7511: 7492: 7467: 7447:a land far away 7432: 7426: 7400: 7395: 6594:talk_revisions 6504:non-compliance? 6493: 6488: 6433: 6337: 6294: 6264: 6169: 6098: 5808: 5803: 5431: 5421: 5417: 5412:Red-tailed hawk 5411: 5401: 5385: 5379: 5375: 5370:Red-tailed hawk 5369: 5331: 5327: 5322:Red-tailed hawk 5321: 5308: 5289: 5285: 5280:Red-tailed hawk 5279: 5264: 5256: 5252: 5247:Red-tailed hawk 5246: 5237: 5229: 5225: 5220:Red-tailed hawk 5219: 5211: 5207: 5202:Red-tailed hawk 5201: 5188: 5184: 5179:Red-tailed hawk 5178: 5169: 5162: 5158: 5153:Red-tailed hawk 5152: 5147:unexpected way. 5133: 5123: 5119: 5114:Red-tailed hawk 5113: 4884: 4830: 4776: 4721: 4719:Red-tailed hawk 4666: 4618: 4570: 4522: 4474: 4419: 4371: 4323: 4275: 4227: 4179: 4131: 4083: 4035: 3987: 3939: 3891: 3842: 3749:Red-tailed hawk 3743: 3651: 3420: 3417: 3416: 3382: 3376: 3372: 3366: 3336: 3179: 3176: 3175: 3162: 3123:Red-tailed hawk 2965:related content 2956: 2880:Support needed 2854: 2838: 2829: 2825: 2820:Red-tailed hawk 2819: 2814: 2799: 2785: 2780: 2759: 2628: 2621: 2584: 2568:Sir Kenneth Kho 2549:Sir Kenneth Kho 2531: 2496: 2485: 2482: 2459: 2426: 2353: 2321: 2299: 2280: 2246: 2228:Sir Kenneth Kho 2225: 2200: 2191: 2148: 2136: 2129: 2120: 2037: 1988: 1905: 1900: 1899: 1894: 1889: 1216: 1215: 1214: 1188: 1174: 1173: 1117: 1102:Arbitrators or 1096: 1094: 1089: 1084: 411: 410: 409: 383: 362:|SECTIONTITLE}} 357: 339: 331: 321: 296: 293: 292: 291: 290: 289: 284: 283: 276: 275: 257: 246:17 August 2024 183: 182: 175: 174: 148: 147: 140: 135: 134: 129: 128: 123: 122: 85: 84: 77: 63:purge this page 53: 46: 45: 38: 34: 26: 25: 24: 12: 11: 5: 16553: 16543: 16542: 16537: 16523: 16522: 16497: 16496: 16486: 16472: 16471: 16470: 16463: 16457: 16447: 16446: 16445: 16393: 16390: 16389: 16388: 16385: 16384: 16377: 16374: 16368: 16365: 16364: 16363: 16327: 16324: 16265: 16264: 16263: 16262: 16237: 16212: 16199: 16196: 16195: 16194: 16175: 16172: 16168: 16160: 16159: 16144: 16141: 16132: 16129: 16038: 16035: 16034: 16033: 15982: 15981: 15967: 15940: 15879: 15874: 15871: 15817: 15814: 15813: 15812: 15811: 15810: 15787: 15724: 15718: 15696: 15690: 15665: 15659: 15632:and added the 15592: 15591: 15578: 15575: 15565: 15564: 15563: 15562: 15549:TenPoundHammer 15540: 15539: 15538: 15511: 15508: 15507: 15506: 15504:TenPoundHammer 15501: 15490: 15489: 15444:TenPoundHammer 15441: 15393: 15338: 15337: 15298: 15279: 15276: 15275: 15274: 15273: 15272: 15237: 15236: 15232: 15231: 15227: 15226: 15222: 15221: 15215: 15214: 15211: 15207: 15206: 15203: 15199: 15198: 15195: 15191: 15190: 15187: 15175: 15174: 15162: 15161: 15159: 15156: 15155: 15154: 15136: 15135: 15131: 15130: 15126: 15125: 15116: 15101: 15086: 15085: 15081: 15080: 15074: 15073: 15070: 15066: 15065: 15062: 15058: 15057: 15054: 15050: 15049: 15046: 15034: 15033: 15021: 15020: 15018: 15015: 15014: 15013: 14995: 14994: 14990: 14989: 14985: 14984: 14980: 14979: 14973: 14972: 14969: 14965: 14964: 14961: 14957: 14956: 14953: 14949: 14948: 14945: 14933: 14932: 14912: 14911: 14909: 14906: 14905: 14904: 14886: 14885: 14881: 14880: 14876: 14875: 14860: 14859: 14855: 14854: 14848: 14847: 14844: 14840: 14839: 14836: 14832: 14831: 14828: 14824: 14823: 14820: 14808: 14807: 14796: 14795: 14793: 14790: 14789: 14788: 14770: 14769: 14765: 14764: 14760: 14759: 14755: 14754: 14748: 14747: 14744: 14740: 14739: 14736: 14732: 14731: 14728: 14724: 14723: 14720: 14708: 14707: 14684: 14683: 14681: 14678: 14677: 14676: 14642: 14639: 14638: 14637: 14608: 14593: 14554: 14553: 14552: 14530: 14512: 14511: 14510: 14509: 14508: 14507: 14506: 14505: 14504: 14503: 14502: 14501: 14500: 14364: 14363: 14362: 14361: 14360: 14359: 14358: 14357: 14356: 14355: 14354: 14236: 14178: 14175: 14174: 14173: 14170: 14169: 14162: 14159: 14148: 14127: 14124: 14091: 14088: 14063: 14060: 14034: 14033: 14016: 13982: 13979: 13904: 13903: 13868: 13867: 13802: 13799: 13732: 13729: 13709: 13706: 13702: 13701: 13691: 13690: 13686: 13685: 13684: 13673:Jéské Couriano 13627:Jéské Couriano 13598:Re'im massacre 13592:Looking at my 13589: 13586: 13584: 13562: 13559: 13523: 13520: 13519: 13518: 13517: 13516: 13480: 13412:using PAGs to 13376: 13373: 13372: 13371: 13370: 13369: 13340: 13332: 13328: 13325: 13319: 13316: 13315: 13314: 13313: 13312: 13311: 13310: 13264: 13261: 13260: 13259: 13249: 13248: 13234:User:Jehochman 13231: 13227: 13203: 13202: 13201: 13200: 13194: 13193: 13183: 13182: 13181: 13180: 13179: 13178: 13155: 13139:User:Number 57 13133: 13132: 13113: 13082: 13060: 13052: 13045: 13044: 13043: 13042: 13030: 13020: 13019: 13005: 13004:Problem solved 13002: 12991: 12986: 12983: 12981: 12966: 12942: 12939: 12929: 12928: 12924: 12921: 12908: 12905: 12878: 12877: 12873: 12872: 12868: 12867: 12851: 12848: 12838: 12781: 12778: 12714: 12713: 12710: 12707: 12704: 12701: 12698: 12695: 12577: 12576: 12572: 12569: 12566: 12537: 12534: 12533: 12532: 12514: 12489: 12486: 12485: 12484: 12443: 12316: 12313: 12312: 12311: 12310: 12309: 12286: 12277:has assembled 12229:clarifications 12212: 12209: 12185: 12182: 12164: 12161: 12160: 12159: 12126: 12125: 12051:is not my view 12043: 12042: 12019: 12004: 12003: 12002: 12001: 11970: 11961: 11960: 11956: 11955: 11954: 11953: 11895: 11894: 11870: 11792:WP:UNBLOCKABLE 11767: 11764: 11763: 11762: 11761: 11760: 11759: 11758: 11757: 11756: 11755: 11754: 11753: 11752: 11626: 11576: 11573: 11572: 11571: 11522: 11521: 11482: 11481: 11480: 11479: 11478: 11386: 11383: 11364: 11363: 11350: 11349: 11344: 11343: 11330: 11329: 11324:, not better. 11309: 11308: 11238: 11235: 11234: 11233: 11194: 11191: 11190: 11189: 11188: 11187: 11186: 11185: 11157: 11142: 11128: 11127: 11126: 11125: 11124: 11123: 11122: 11092: 11089: 11088: 11087: 11080: 11079: 11078: 11075: 11072: 11061: 11049: 11046: 10997: 10982: 10922: 10919: 10918: 10917: 10902: 10879: 10847: 10844: 10820: 10817: 10815: 10812: 10807: 10804: 10803: 10802: 10801: 10800: 10799: 10798: 10713:User:Wagtail66 10685:User:Dovidroth 10669:User:Marokwitz 10639: 10638: 10631: 10630: 10629: 10628: 10627: 10626: 10625: 10624: 10610:Khalida Jarrar 10601: 10558: 10547: 10536: 10535:Billed Mammal. 10533: 10494: 10493: 10457: 10424: 10398: 10383:Jéské Couriano 10377: 10376: 10353: 10352: 10335: 10334: 10333: 10332: 10331: 10330: 10329: 10328: 10327: 10326: 10325: 10324: 10323: 10322: 10321: 10320: 10319: 10318: 10283: 10261: 10253: 10246: 10052: 10051: 10037: 10027: 10016: 9993: 9979: 9961: 9947: 9933: 9919: 9897: 9869: 9866: 9838: 9835: 9780: 9777: 9775: 9772: 9771: 9770: 9757: 9720: 9717: 9716: 9715: 9714: 9713: 9699:Jéské Couriano 9645: 9644: 9643: 9642: 9641: 9640: 9593: 9563: 9562: 9561: 9539: 9509: 9491: 9490: 9489: 9488: 9487: 9441: 9423: 9379: 9364: 9363: 9362: 9318: 9317: 9316: 9315: 9314: 9313: 9312: 9311: 9310: 9206: 9160: 9157: 9156: 9155: 9130: 9129: 9128: 9094: 9079: 9076: 9066: 9051: 9034: 9017: 8980: 8979: 8964: 8948: 8945: 8911: 8908: 8887: 8886: 8847: 8845: 8843: 8801: 8800: 8720: 8719: 8698: 8697: 8666: 8665: 8652: 8649: 8645: 8642: 8633: 8630: 8629: 8628: 8611: 8607: 8597: 8596: 8595: 8573: 8563: 8556: 8545: 8534: 8530: 8526: 8519: 8492: 8489: 8473: 8472: 8471: 8432: 8428: 8424: 8417: 8416:contributions. 8402: 8401: 8400: 8385: 8381: 8371: 8370: 8369: 8368: 8365: 8362: 8359: 8356: 8346: 8345: 8342: 8332: 8331: 8328: 8325: 8322: 8319: 8316: 8313: 8310: 8307: 8304: 8301: 8298: 8295: 8283: 8282: 8279: 8274: 8273: 8272: 8271: 8270: 8263: 8236: 8230: 8216: 8202: 8187: 8186: 8185: 8184: 8183: 8132: 8131: 8130: 8082: 8072: 8065: 8062: 8047: 8040: 8011: 8010: 8009: 8008: 8007: 7996: 7977: 7947: 7934: 7916: 7915: 7914: 7913: 7912: 7898: 7851: 7850: 7849: 7843:Al Jazeera RFC 7839: 7826: 7816: 7801: 7798: 7795: 7784: 7769: 7743: 7742: 7741: 7740: 7739: 7738: 7732: 7731: 7730: 7723: 7716: 7692: 7691: 7690: 7687: 7677: 7674: 7673: 7672: 7660: 7657: 7579: 7578: 7556: 7555: 7554: 7522: 7521: 7520: 7477: 7425: 7422: 7399: 7396: 7394: 7391: 7313: 7312: 7297: 7296: 7295: 7285: 7282:User:O.maximov 7275: 7267: 7263: 7185: 7184: 7161: 7160: 7159: 7158: 7155: 7152: 7116: 7115: 7100: 7039: 7038: 7037: 7036: 7033: 7023: 7016: 7015: 7012: 7009: 6955: 6954: 6951: 6941: 6940: 6937: 6933: 6926: 6925: 6922: 6915: 6914: 6911: 6853: 6852: 6849: 6846: 6843: 6815: 6814: 6806: 6799: 6764: 6763: 6760: 6757: 6754: 6750: 6749: 6746: 6743: 6740: 6736: 6735: 6732: 6729: 6726: 6722: 6721: 6718: 6715: 6712: 6708: 6707: 6704: 6701: 6698: 6694: 6693: 6690: 6687: 6684: 6680: 6679: 6676: 6673: 6670: 6666: 6665: 6662: 6659: 6656: 6652: 6651: 6648: 6645: 6642: 6638: 6637: 6634: 6631: 6628: 6624: 6623: 6620: 6617: 6614: 6610: 6609: 6606: 6603: 6600: 6596: 6595: 6592: 6589: 6586: 6581: 6580: 6579: 6578: 6577: 6576: 6573: 6570: 6564: 6560: 6553: 6547: 6506: 6505: 6492: 6489: 6487: 6484: 6483: 6482: 6432: 6429: 6391: 6390: 6291: 6290: 6275: 6168: 6165: 6164: 6163: 6097: 6094: 6093: 6092: 6091: 6090: 6057: 6039: 6020: 6019: 6018: 6017: 6016: 6012: 6009: 6005: 6004: 6003: 6002: 5982: 5981: 5980: 5936: 5935: 5934: 5897: 5882: 5864: 5850:WP:NOCONSENSUS 5838:WP:NOCONSENSUS 5829: 5807: 5804: 5802: 5799: 5798: 5797: 5796: 5795: 5698: 5697: 5689: 5685: 5672: 5664: 5609:West Jerusalem 5605:East Jerusalem 5597: 5596: 5595: 5540: 5509: 5490: 5430: 5427: 5426: 5425: 5415: 5383: 5373: 5353:WP:ARBBLUDGEON 5335: 5325: 5305: 5293: 5283: 5262: 5261: 5260: 5250: 5235: 5234: 5233: 5223: 5205: 5182: 5156: 5132: 5129: 5128: 5127: 5117: 5109: 5089: 5088: 5087: 5084: 5081: 5078: 5075: 5071: 5070: 5064: 5063: 5051: 5050: 5046: 5045: 5040: 5035: 5030: 5025: 5020: 5015: 5010: 5005: 5000: 4995: 4990: 4985: 4980: 4975: 4970: 4965: 4960: 4955: 4950: 4945: 4939: 4938: 4934: 4933: 4879: 4825: 4771: 4715: 4714: 4710: 4709: 4661: 4613: 4565: 4517: 4468: 4467: 4463: 4462: 4414: 4366: 4318: 4270: 4222: 4174: 4126: 4078: 4030: 3982: 3934: 3886: 3885:(AE initiator) 3836: 3835: 3830: 3828: 3824: 3823: 3811: 3810: 3806: 3805: 3761: 3742: 3739: 3738: 3737: 3736: 3735: 3681: 3680: 3679: 3678: 3646: 3645: 3602: 3601: 3600: 3521: 3520: 3516: 3515: 3511: 3510: 3491: 3490: 3486: 3485: 3471: 3470: 3464: 3463: 3460: 3456: 3455: 3452: 3448: 3447: 3444: 3440: 3439: 3436: 3424: 3423: 3338: 3337: 3335: 3332: 3331: 3330: 3329: 3328: 3327: 3326: 3262: 3261: 3257: 3256: 3252: 3251: 3235: 3234: 3230: 3229: 3223: 3222: 3219: 3215: 3214: 3211: 3207: 3206: 3203: 3199: 3198: 3195: 3183: 3182: 3164: 3163: 3161: 3158: 3157: 3156: 3155: 3154: 3075: 3066: 3065: 3064: 3047:says and what 3027: 3013: 3012: 3011: 3010: 2993: 2992: 2991: 2988: 2955: 2952: 2950: 2948: 2947: 2941: 2940: 2938: 2935: 2928: 2925: 2922: 2919: 2913: 2912: 2910: 2907: 2900: 2897: 2894: 2891: 2885: 2884: 2881: 2878: 2875: 2872: 2869: 2866: 2853: 2850: 2849: 2848: 2845: 2844: 2837: 2834: 2823: 2813: 2810: 2779: 2776: 2758: 2755: 2754: 2753: 2752: 2751: 2668: 2667: 2666: 2665: 2657: 2656: 2655: 2654: 2647: 2644: 2633: 2632: 2625: 2614: 2613: 2606: 2595: 2583: 2580: 2579: 2578: 2481: 2478: 2458: 2455: 2444: 2403: 2402: 2383: 2372: 2333: 2332: 2298: 2295: 2279: 2276: 2119: 2116: 2115: 2114: 2113: 2112: 2103: 2102: 2098: 2097: 2092: 2091: 2087: 2086: 2032: 1982: 1981: 1979: 1975: 1974: 1968: 1967: 1963: 1962: 1923: 1904: 1901: 1896: 1895: 1887: 1885: 1882: 1881: 1878: 1877: 1872: 1866: 1865: 1860: 1855: 1850: 1845: 1840: 1835: 1830: 1825: 1820: 1815: 1810: 1805: 1800: 1795: 1790: 1785: 1780: 1774: 1773: 1768: 1763: 1758: 1753: 1748: 1743: 1738: 1733: 1728: 1723: 1718: 1713: 1708: 1703: 1698: 1693: 1688: 1682: 1681: 1676: 1671: 1666: 1661: 1656: 1651: 1646: 1641: 1636: 1631: 1626: 1621: 1616: 1611: 1606: 1601: 1596: 1590: 1589: 1584: 1579: 1574: 1569: 1564: 1559: 1554: 1549: 1544: 1539: 1534: 1529: 1524: 1519: 1514: 1509: 1504: 1498: 1497: 1492: 1487: 1482: 1477: 1472: 1467: 1462: 1457: 1452: 1447: 1442: 1437: 1432: 1427: 1422: 1417: 1412: 1406: 1405: 1400: 1395: 1390: 1385: 1380: 1375: 1370: 1365: 1360: 1355: 1350: 1345: 1340: 1335: 1330: 1325: 1320: 1314: 1313: 1308: 1303: 1298: 1293: 1288: 1283: 1278: 1273: 1268: 1263: 1258: 1253: 1248: 1243: 1238: 1233: 1228: 1218: 1217: 1213: 1212: 1205: 1198: 1190: 1189: 1181: 1180: 1175: 1172: 1171: 1162: 1157: 1152: 1147: 1145:WP:A/R/C&A 1142: 1137: 1131: 1126: 1091: 1090: 1082: 1080: 1077: 1076: 1073: 1072: 1067: 1061: 1060: 1055: 1050: 1045: 1040: 1035: 1030: 1025: 1020: 1015: 1010: 1005: 1000: 995: 990: 985: 980: 975: 969: 968: 963: 958: 953: 948: 943: 938: 933: 928: 923: 918: 913: 908: 903: 898: 893: 888: 883: 877: 876: 871: 866: 861: 856: 851: 846: 841: 836: 831: 826: 821: 816: 811: 806: 801: 796: 791: 785: 784: 779: 774: 769: 764: 759: 754: 749: 744: 739: 734: 729: 724: 719: 714: 709: 704: 699: 693: 692: 687: 682: 677: 672: 667: 662: 657: 652: 647: 642: 637: 632: 627: 622: 617: 612: 607: 601: 600: 595: 590: 585: 580: 575: 570: 565: 560: 555: 550: 545: 540: 535: 530: 525: 520: 515: 509: 508: 503: 498: 493: 488: 483: 478: 473: 468: 463: 458: 453: 448: 443: 438: 433: 428: 423: 413: 412: 408: 407: 400: 393: 385: 384: 376: 375: 370: 369: 368: 365: 354: 351: 350: 349: 337: 319: 318: 314: 299: 294: 285: 279: 278: 272: 271: 268: 261: 254: 248: 247: 244: 237: 230: 224: 223: 220: 213: 206: 200: 199: 196: 193: 190: 184: 178: 177: 171: 170: 167: 159: 158: 155: 149: 138: 137: 130: 126: 125: 119: 118: 115: 112: 110: 102: 101: 98: 95: 92: 86: 80: 79: 76: 75: 65: 60: 58:recent changes 54: 48: 47: 44: 43: 35: 30: 15: 9: 6: 4: 3: 2: 16552: 16541: 16538: 16536: 16533: 16532: 16530: 16521: 16516: 16515: 16510: 16509: 16503: 16499: 16498: 16495: 16492: 16487: 16485: 16482: 16479: 16478: 16473: 16467: 16464: 16461: 16458: 16454: 16451: 16450: 16448: 16444: 16440: 16436: 16432: 16431: 16430: 16426: 16422: 16418: 16411: 16404: 16400: 16396: 16395: 16387: 16386: 16383: 16380: 16379: 16373: 16362: 16358: 16354: 16349: 16348: 16347: 16346: 16342: 16338: 16334: 16323: 16322: 16318: 16314: 16310: 16306: 16302: 16298: 16294: 16290: 16285: 16284: 16280: 16276: 16272: 16270: 16261: 16259: 16255: 16251: 16245: 16241: 16238: 16235: 16231: 16227: 16223: 16219: 16216: 16215: 16213: 16210: 16206: 16202: 16201: 16193: 16189: 16185: 16180: 16176: 16173: 16169: 16166: 16162: 16161: 16158: 16154: 16150: 16145: 16142: 16139: 16138: 16137: 16128: 16127: 16123: 16122: 16121: 16112: 16108: 16104: 16099: 16098: 16094: 16093: 16092: 16083: 16080:gave them an 16077: 16071: 16067: 16063: 16058: 16056: 16052: 16048: 16044: 16032: 16029: 16028: 16027: 16022: 16021: 16016: 16013: 16012: 16011: 16010: 16007: 16006: 16005: 16000: 15999: 15991: 15989: 15979: 15973: 15968: 15966: 15963: 15962: 15961: 15956: 15955: 15949: 15945: 15941: 15938: 15937: 15936: 15935: 15932: 15931: 15930: 15925: 15924: 15917: 15915: 15914: 15913: 15908: 15907: 15902: 15898: 15894: 15889: 15885: 15878: 15870: 15869: 15864: 15858: 15856: 15851: 15849: 15841: 15833: 15831: 15827: 15822: 15809: 15804: 15803: 15798: 15797: 15791: 15788: 15784: 15780: 15779: 15778: 15773: 15772: 15767: 15766: 15760: 15759: 15754: 15750: 15749: 15748: 15747: 15742: 15741: 15736: 15735: 15728: 15722: 15716: 15712: 15708: 15704: 15700: 15694: 15688: 15684: 15679: 15675: 15671: 15664: 15661:Statement by 15658: 15655: 15653: 15649: 15645: 15638: 15631: 15627: 15623: 15619: 15615: 15610: 15608: 15604: 15599: 15597: 15586: 15579: 15576: 15573: 15572: 15571: 15568: 15560: 15557: 15554: 15550: 15546: 15545: 15544: 15541: 15536: 15533: 15530: 15526: 15522: 15521: 15520: 15517: 15516: 15515: 15505: 15502: 15500: 15497: 15496: 15495: 15494: 15486: 15483: 15480: 15477: 15474: 15471: 15468: 15465: 15462: 15459: 15456: 15453: 15450: 15445: 15442: 15438: 15435: 15432: 15429: 15426: 15423: 15420: 15417: 15414: 15411: 15408: 15405: 15402: 15397: 15394: 15389: 15386: 15383: 15380: 15377: 15374: 15371: 15368: 15365: 15362: 15359: 15356: 15353: 15348: 15345: 15344: 15343: 15342: 15334: 15330: 15326: 15322: 15318: 15314: 15310: 15304: 15303: 15299: 15296: 15295: 15294: 15293: 15290: 15287: 15284: 15271: 15267: 15263: 15259: 15256: 15255: 15254: 15251: 15245: 15244: 15239: 15238: 15234: 15233: 15229: 15228: 15224: 15223: 15219: 15218: 15212: 15209: 15208: 15204: 15201: 15200: 15196: 15193: 15192: 15188: 15185: 15184: 15180: 15170: 15169: 15166: 15153: 15150: 15144: 15143: 15138: 15137: 15133: 15132: 15128: 15127: 15124: 15121: 15117: 15115: 15111: 15107: 15102: 15100: 15096: 15092: 15088: 15087: 15083: 15082: 15078: 15077: 15071: 15068: 15067: 15063: 15060: 15059: 15055: 15052: 15051: 15047: 15044: 15043: 15039: 15029: 15028: 15025: 15012: 15009: 15003: 15002: 14997: 14996: 14992: 14991: 14987: 14986: 14982: 14981: 14977: 14976: 14970: 14967: 14966: 14962: 14959: 14958: 14954: 14951: 14950: 14946: 14943: 14942: 14938: 14928: 14927: 14924: 14922: 14918: 14903: 14900: 14894: 14893: 14888: 14887: 14883: 14882: 14878: 14877: 14874: 14870: 14866: 14862: 14861: 14857: 14856: 14852: 14851: 14845: 14842: 14841: 14837: 14834: 14833: 14829: 14826: 14825: 14821: 14818: 14817: 14813: 14803: 14802: 14799: 14787: 14784: 14778: 14777: 14772: 14771: 14767: 14766: 14762: 14761: 14757: 14756: 14752: 14751: 14745: 14742: 14741: 14737: 14734: 14733: 14729: 14726: 14725: 14721: 14718: 14717: 14713: 14703: 14702: 14699: 14697: 14693: 14689: 14675: 14671: 14667: 14663: 14662: 14661: 14660: 14657: 14651: 14650: 14636: 14635: 14632: 14626: 14625: 14619: 14617: 14609: 14607: 14604: 14601: 14600: 14594: 14592: 14588: 14584: 14580: 14576: 14572: 14567: 14563: 14559: 14555: 14551: 14548: 14544: 14540: 14539: 14538: 14535: 14531: 14529: 14525: 14521: 14517: 14513: 14499: 14495: 14491: 14486: 14485: 14484: 14481: 14475: 14474: 14468: 14467: 14466: 14462: 14458: 14454: 14447: 14442: 14441: 14440: 14436: 14432: 14427: 14426: 14425: 14421: 14417: 14410: 14405: 14404: 14403: 14399: 14395: 14391: 14387: 14385: 14379: 14378: 14377: 14373: 14369: 14365: 14353: 14349: 14345: 14339: 14334: 14333: 14332: 14328: 14324: 14317: 14312: 14311: 14310: 14306: 14302: 14298: 14297: 14296: 14292: 14288: 14282: 14277: 14276: 14275: 14271: 14267: 14263: 14257: 14252: 14251: 14250: 14246: 14242: 14237: 14235: 14231: 14228: 14225: 14222: 14219: 14212: 14211: 14206: 14203: 14199: 14192: 14185: 14181: 14180: 14172: 14171: 14168: 14165: 14164: 14158: 14157: 14152: 14147: 14146: 14141: 14137: 14133: 14123: 14122: 14119: 14117: 14113: 14108: 14101: 14097: 14087: 14086: 14082: 14078: 14072: 14069: 14068:Gaza Genocide 14059: 14058: 14054: 14050: 14044: 14042: 14038: 14032: 14028: 14024: 14021: 14017: 14013: 14012: 14011: 14010: 14006: 14002: 13992: 13991:WP:CANVASSing 13988: 13987:WP:TAGTEAMing 13978: 13977: 13972: 13968: 13963: 13958: 13953: 13948: 13944: 13940: 13939: 13934: 13930: 13925: 13919: 13917: 13912: 13908: 13902: 13897: 13893: 13888: 13884: 13883: 13882: 13879: 13875: 13871: 13865: 13864: 13863: 13862: 13857: 13853: 13848: 13844: 13840: 13839: 13834: 13830: 13825: 13820: 13816: 13811: 13808: 13798: 13797: 13793: 13789: 13785: 13781: 13776: 13774: 13773:false balance 13770: 13766: 13762: 13759:. Looking at 13758: 13754: 13750: 13746: 13742: 13738: 13728: 13727: 13723: 13719: 13715: 13696: 13692: 13689: 13683: 13680: 13675: 13674: 13669: 13666: 13663: 13660: 13657: 13654: 13651: 13645: 13640: 13639: 13638: 13637: 13634: 13629: 13628: 13623: 13619: 13615: 13611: 13606: 13601: 13599: 13595: 13585: 13582: 13581: 13578: 13575: 13568: 13558: 13557: 13553: 13549: 13544: 13543:Gaza genocide 13540: 13536: 13531: 13529: 13515: 13512: 13508: 13503: 13502: 13501: 13498: 13494: 13490: 13486: 13481: 13479: 13476: 13472: 13467: 13466: 13465: 13461: 13459: 13455: 13451: 13446: 13445:wide reaching 13442: 13438: 13433: 13431: 13427: 13423: 13419: 13415: 13411: 13405: 13403: 13399: 13395: 13391: 13387: 13382: 13368: 13364: 13360: 13355: 13354: 13353: 13349: 13345: 13341: 13338: 13333: 13329: 13326: 13322: 13321: 13309: 13305: 13301: 13297: 13296: 13295: 13294: 13293: 13289: 13285: 13281: 13280: 13279: 13278: 13274: 13270: 13258: 13255: 13251: 13250: 13247: 13243: 13239: 13235: 13232: 13228: 13225: 13220: 13216: 13212: 13211:Gaza genocide 13208: 13207:User:xDanielx 13205: 13204: 13198: 13197: 13196: 13195: 13191: 13188: 13187: 13186: 13177: 13173: 13169: 13165: 13163: 13160: 13156: 13153: 13152:Knowledge:RD3 13149: 13148:Knowledge:RD2 13144: 13140: 13137: 13136: 13135: 13134: 13131: 13127: 13123: 13119: 13114: 13112: 13108: 13104: 13100: 13098: 13095: 13092: 13089: 13086: 13083: 13081: 13077: 13073: 13069: 13065: 13061: 13058: 13053: 13049: 13048: 13047: 13046: 13039: 13036: 13031: 13028: 13027:play as a cat 13024: 13023: 13022: 13021: 13018: 13014: 13010: 13006: 13003: 13000: 12996: 12992: 12989: 12988: 12982: 12979: 12978: 12975: 12974: 12973: 12964: 12960: 12957: 12953: 12949: 12938: 12937: 12934: 12925: 12922: 12919: 12918: 12917: 12915: 12904: 12903: 12899: 12895: 12890: 12886: 12884: 12875: 12874: 12870: 12869: 12865: 12864: 12863: 12860: 12856: 12847: 12846: 12841: 12836: 12828: 12826: 12823: 12820: 12817: 12814: 12810: 12809:Gaza genocide 12805: 12803: 12799: 12794: 12789: 12787: 12777: 12776: 12772: 12766: 12751: 12745: 12744: 12740: 12734: 12719: 12711: 12708: 12705: 12702: 12699: 12696: 12693: 12689: 12688: 12687: 12685: 12680: 12678: 12674: 12669: 12667: 12663: 12657: 12653: 12650: 12646: 12642: 12641: 12637: 12631: 12616: 12612: 12608: 12603: 12602: 12598: 12592: 12573: 12570: 12567: 12564: 12563: 12562: 12559: 12555: 12551: 12546: 12542: 12531: 12527: 12523: 12519: 12515: 12511: 12510: 12509: 12508: 12504: 12500: 12494: 12483: 12479: 12475: 12469: 12463: 12457: 12451: 12447: 12444: 12442: 12436: 12431: 12430: 12429: 12428: 12424: 12420: 12416: 12412: 12408: 12404: 12399: 12397: 12393: 12388: 12385: 12380: 12378: 12374: 12370: 12366: 12361: 12360:Wikilawyering 12356: 12351: 12349: 12345: 12341: 12337: 12333: 12329: 12325: 12320: 12308: 12305: 12300: 12293: 12287: 12284: 12280: 12276: 12272: 12271: 12270: 12267: 12259: 12255: 12254: 12253: 12252: 12249: 12245: 12244: 12239: 12238: 12232: 12230: 12225: 12223: 12219: 12208: 12207: 12203: 12199: 12193: 12189: 12181: 12180: 12174: 12158: 12151: 12149: 12144: 12142: 12134: 12128: 12127: 12124: 12117: 12115: 12110: 12108: 12102: 12097: 12093: 12087: 12081: 12080: 12079: 12078: 12071: 12069: 12064: 12062: 12056: 12052: 12048: 12040: 12036: 12032: 12031:case in point 12028: 12024: 12020: 12017: 12013: 12009: 12008: 12007: 12000: 11993: 11991: 11986: 11984: 11978: 11974: 11971: 11969: 11968: 11967:participants. 11963: 11962: 11958: 11957: 11952: 11945: 11943: 11938: 11936: 11930: 11926: 11922: 11921: 11920: 11913: 11911: 11906: 11904: 11897: 11896: 11892: 11888: 11883: 11879: 11875: 11871: 11869: 11862: 11860: 11855: 11853: 11845: 11839: 11835: 11834: 11833: 11832: 11831: 11830: 11823: 11821: 11816: 11814: 11808: 11804: 11799: 11797: 11793: 11789: 11785: 11781: 11777: 11773: 11751: 11748: 11743: 11738: 11732: 11727: 11726: 11725: 11722: 11717: 11712: 11705: 11701: 11700: 11699: 11696: 11691: 11686: 11680: 11675: 11674: 11673: 11670: 11665: 11660: 11654: 11649: 11648: 11647: 11644: 11639: 11634: 11627: 11623: 11622: 11621: 11618: 11613: 11608: 11601: 11600: 11599: 11598: 11595: 11590: 11585: 11570: 11565: 11555: 11548: 11547: 11546: 11545: 11540: 11530: 11520: 11515: 11505: 11499: 11495: 11488: 11483: 11477: 11472: 11462: 11453: 11448: 11447: 11446: 11445: 11444: 11439: 11429: 11420: 11415: 11414: 11413: 11412: 11407: 11397: 11391: 11382: 11381: 11377: 11373: 11369: 11361: 11357: 11352: 11351: 11346: 11345: 11340: 11336: 11332: 11331: 11327: 11326: 11325: 11323: 11319: 11315: 11307: 11303: 11299: 11295: 11291: 11287: 11282: 11281: 11280: 11279: 11275: 11271: 11267: 11263: 11258: 11253: 11249: 11245: 11232: 11228: 11224: 11220: 11217: 11216: 11215: 11214: 11210: 11206: 11201: 11184: 11180: 11176: 11172: 11171: 11170: 11166: 11162: 11158: 11156: 11152: 11148: 11143: 11141: 11137: 11133: 11129: 11121: 11117: 11113: 11108: 11107: 11106: 11102: 11098: 11093: 11090: 11085: 11084: 11081: 11076: 11073: 11070: 11069: 11066: 11062: 11059: 11054: 11050: 11047: 11043: 11039: 11035: 11034: 11033: 11030: 11024: 11023: 11017: 11013: 11012: 11011: 11007: 11003: 10998: 10996: 10992: 10988: 10983: 10981: 10977: 10973: 10968: 10967: 10966: 10962: 10958: 10954: 10950: 10946: 10942: 10941: 10940: 10939: 10935: 10931: 10927: 10916: 10912: 10908: 10903: 10901: 10897: 10893: 10889: 10885: 10880: 10878: 10874: 10870: 10865: 10864: 10863: 10862: 10858: 10854: 10843: 10842: 10839: 10838: 10831: 10827: 10811: 10797: 10793: 10789: 10785: 10784: 10783: 10782: 10781: 10777: 10773: 10769: 10765: 10761: 10760: 10759: 10758: 10754: 10750: 10746: 10742: 10738: 10734: 10730: 10729:User:Bolter21 10726: 10722: 10718: 10714: 10710: 10709:User:טבעת-זרם 10706: 10702: 10698: 10694: 10693:User:XDanielx 10690: 10686: 10682: 10678: 10674: 10670: 10664: 10660: 10656: 10652: 10651: 10648: 10646: 10637: 10633: 10632: 10623: 10619: 10615: 10611: 10607: 10602: 10599: 10595: 10594: 10593: 10589: 10585: 10581: 10580: 10579: 10575: 10571: 10567: 10563: 10559: 10556: 10553: 10548: 10545: 10543: 10537: 10534: 10532: 10528: 10524: 10519: 10515: 10511: 10506: 10502: 10498: 10497: 10496: 10495: 10492: 10488: 10484: 10479: 10475: 10471: 10467: 10463: 10458: 10456: 10452: 10448: 10444: 10440: 10436: 10432: 10428: 10425: 10423: 10419: 10415: 10410: 10406: 10403:BilledMammal 10402: 10399: 10397: 10393: 10389: 10385: 10384: 10379: 10378: 10375: 10371: 10367: 10363: 10359: 10355: 10354: 10351: 10347: 10343: 10340: 10339:Finally, this 10337: 10336: 10317: 10313: 10309: 10304: 10299: 10298: 10297: 10293: 10289: 10284: 10281: 10279: 10276: 10272: 10268: 10262: 10258: 10254: 10251: 10247: 10244: 10240: 10239: 10238: 10234: 10230: 10226: 10222: 10218: 10217: 10216: 10212: 10208: 10203: 10199: 10198: 10197: 10193: 10189: 10185: 10181: 10180:Joseph's Tomb 10177: 10173: 10168: 10164: 10163: 10162: 10158: 10154: 10150: 10147: 10145: 10142: 10139: 10135: 10131: 10128: 10127: 10126: 10122: 10118: 10114: 10110: 10109: 10108: 10104: 10100: 10096: 10092: 10091: 10090: 10086: 10082: 10078: 10074: 10073: 10072: 10071: 10067: 10063: 10058: 10049: 10045: 10041: 10038: 10035: 10031: 10028: 10024: 10020: 10017: 10014: 10009: 10005: 10001: 9997: 9994: 9991: 9987: 9983: 9980: 9978: 9973: 9969: 9965: 9962: 9959: 9955: 9952:: there is a 9951: 9948: 9945: 9943: 9937: 9934: 9931: 9927: 9923: 9920: 9917: 9916:See this note 9913: 9909: 9905: 9901: 9898: 9895: 9891: 9887: 9884: 9883: 9882: 9880: 9879:Occam's razor 9875: 9874:behaviourally 9865: 9864: 9861: 9860: 9859: 9856: 9853: 9850: 9844: 9834: 9833: 9830: 9829: 9828: 9825: 9822: 9819: 9813: 9809: 9804: 9803: 9800: 9799: 9798: 9795: 9792: 9789: 9769: 9765: 9761: 9755: 9750: 9745: 9744: 9743: 9742: 9738: 9734: 9727: 9712: 9708: 9704: 9700: 9696: 9691: 9687: 9686: 9685: 9682: 9676: 9675: 9670: 9666: 9665: 9664: 9663: 9659: 9655: 9650: 9639: 9635: 9631: 9626: 9625: 9624: 9620: 9616: 9612: 9608: 9607: 9606: 9602: 9598: 9594: 9592: 9588: 9584: 9580: 9576: 9572: 9568: 9564: 9560: 9556: 9552: 9545: 9540: 9538: 9534: 9530: 9525: 9524: 9523: 9519: 9515: 9510: 9508: 9504: 9500: 9496: 9492: 9486: 9482: 9478: 9474: 9470: 9465: 9461: 9460: 9459: 9455: 9451: 9446: 9442: 9440: 9436: 9432: 9428: 9424: 9422: 9418: 9414: 9409: 9405: 9401: 9400: 9399: 9395: 9391: 9386: 9385: 9380: 9378: 9374: 9370: 9365: 9361: 9357: 9353: 9347: 9342: 9341: 9340: 9336: 9332: 9328: 9324: 9319: 9309: 9305: 9301: 9296: 9295: 9294: 9290: 9286: 9282: 9278: 9277: 9276: 9272: 9268: 9263: 9262: 9257: 9253: 9252: 9251: 9247: 9243: 9238: 9234: 9233: 9232: 9228: 9224: 9219: 9215: 9211: 9207: 9205: 9201: 9197: 9193: 9188: 9187: 9186: 9185: 9181: 9177: 9173: 9169: 9168: 9154: 9150: 9146: 9142: 9138: 9134: 9131: 9127: 9123: 9119: 9115: 9112: 9111: 9110: 9106: 9102: 9098: 9095: 9093: 9089: 9085: 9080: 9077: 9074: 9070: 9067: 9065: 9061: 9057: 9052: 9050: 9046: 9042: 9038: 9035: 9033: 9029: 9025: 9021: 9018: 9016: 9012: 9008: 9004: 9000: 8997: 8996: 8995: 8994: 8990: 8986: 8976: 8970: 8965: 8961: 8960: 8959: 8956: 8954: 8944: 8943: 8940: 8936: 8934: 8930: 8928: 8924: 8922: 8918: 8916: 8907: 8906: 8903: 8896: 8885: 8882: 8875: 8870: 8869: 8868: 8867: 8864: 8860: 8855: 8854: 8851: 8841: 8836: 8835: 8832: 8828: 8827:Ephraim Karsh 8824: 8818: 8817: 8814: 8810: 8806: 8799: 8796: 8789: 8781: 8780: 8779: 8778: 8775: 8771: 8767: 8763: 8758: 8752: 8743: 8742: 8739: 8735: 8729: 8718: 8715: 8708: 8700: 8699: 8696: 8693: 8686: 8678: 8677: 8676: 8675: 8672: 8664: 8661: 8656: 8653: 8650: 8646: 8643: 8639: 8638: 8637: 8627: 8623: 8619: 8616: 8612: 8608: 8603: 8598: 8594: 8590: 8586: 8582: 8578: 8574: 8572: 8568: 8564: 8561: 8557: 8554: 8550: 8546: 8543: 8539: 8535: 8531: 8527: 8524: 8520: 8516: 8511: 8510: 8509: 8505: 8501: 8497: 8493: 8490: 8487: 8479: 8474: 8470: 8466: 8462: 8458: 8452: 8447: 8446: 8445: 8441: 8437: 8433: 8429: 8425: 8422: 8418: 8412: 8408: 8403: 8399: 8395: 8391: 8386: 8382: 8378: 8377: 8376: 8375: 8366: 8363: 8360: 8357: 8354: 8353: 8352: 8350: 8343: 8340: 8339: 8338: 8336: 8330:IOHANNVSVERVS 8329: 8326: 8323: 8320: 8317: 8314: 8311: 8308: 8305: 8302: 8299: 8296: 8293: 8292: 8291: 8289: 8285: 8284: 8278: 8277: 8268: 8264: 8261: 8260: 8259: 8255: 8251: 8246: 8241: 8237: 8235: 8231: 8228: 8222: 8217: 8215: 8211: 8207: 8203: 8200: 8193: 8188: 8182: 8178: 8174: 8168: 8165: 8162: 8158: 8153: 8150: 8147: 8143: 8138: 8133: 8129: 8125: 8121: 8111: 8106: 8105: 8104: 8100: 8096: 8092: 8088: 8083: 8078: 8073: 8066: 8063: 8060: 8058: 8054: 8048: 8045: 8041: 8038: 8030: 8025: 8024: 8023: 8019: 8015: 8012: 8002: 7997: 7992: 7987: 7986: 7985: 7981: 7978: 7975: 7974:RM statistics 7972: 7971: 7969: 7968: 7967: 7963: 7959: 7953: 7948: 7945: 7941: 7935: 7932: 7928: 7922: 7917: 7911: 7907: 7903: 7899: 7893: 7888: 7887: 7886: 7882: 7878: 7871: 7866: 7865: 7864: 7860: 7856: 7852: 7848: 7844: 7840: 7838: 7834: 7830: 7829: 7827: 7822: 7817: 7815: 7811: 7807: 7802: 7799: 7796: 7790: 7785: 7783: 7779: 7775: 7770: 7767: 7766:WP:COMMONNAME 7763: 7758: 7757: 7756: 7755: 7751: 7747: 7733: 7728: 7724: 7721: 7717: 7714: 7710: 7709: 7707: 7706: 7704: 7700: 7696: 7695: 7693: 7688: 7685: 7684:fourth pillar 7681: 7680: 7678: 7675: 7669: 7668: 7666: 7665: 7664: 7656: 7655: 7651: 7650: 7642: 7638: 7632: 7631: 7627: 7626: 7619: 7614: 7609: 7608: 7604: 7603: 7594: 7593: 7589: 7588: 7577: 7573: 7572: 7565: 7561: 7557: 7553: 7549: 7548: 7541: 7540: 7539: 7535: 7534: 7527: 7523: 7519: 7515: 7514: 7506: 7502: 7501: 7500: 7496: 7495: 7487: 7483: 7478: 7476: 7475: 7471: 7470: 7462: 7456: 7452: 7448: 7443: 7442: 7441: 7440: 7436: 7435: 7421: 7420: 7416: 7412: 7407: 7405: 7390: 7389: 7385: 7381: 7375: 7374: 7370: 7366: 7362: 7358: 7357: 7353: 7349: 7345: 7341: 7337: 7336: 7332: 7328: 7322: 7318: 7311: 7307: 7303: 7298: 7293: 7289: 7286: 7283: 7279: 7276: 7274: 7271: 7270: 7268: 7264: 7261: 7260: 7259: 7256: 7254: 7250: 7249: 7245: 7241: 7237: 7233: 7232: 7228: 7224: 7219: 7215: 7214: 7210: 7206: 7200: 7199: 7195: 7191: 7183: 7179: 7175: 7168: 7167: 7166: 7165: 7156: 7153: 7150: 7149: 7146: 7145: 7144: 7140: 7139: 7135: 7134: 7130: 7126: 7120: 7113: 7109: 7105: 7101: 7098: 7094: 7090: 7089: 7088: 7085: 7084: 7080: 7079: 7075: 7071: 7066: 7061: 7060: 7056: 7055: 7051: 7047: 7043: 7034: 7031: 7030: 7028: 7024: 7021: 7020: 7019: 7013: 7010: 7007: 7006: 7005: 7002: 6998: 6997: 6993: 6992:Meme check #2 6989: 6988: 6984: 6980: 6976: 6972: 6968: 6967: 6963: 6959: 6952: 6949: 6948: 6947: 6945: 6938: 6934: 6931: 6930: 6929: 6923: 6920: 6919: 6918: 6912: 6909: 6908: 6907: 6904: 6900: 6897: 6895: 6891: 6890:Meme check #1 6887: 6886: 6882: 6878: 6872: 6870: 6865: 6860: 6856: 6850: 6847: 6844: 6840: 6836: 6835: 6834: 6832: 6828: 6827: 6823: 6819: 6812: 6807: 6804: 6800: 6797: 6793: 6789: 6788: 6787: 6784: 6783: 6779: 6778: 6774: 6770: 6761: 6758: 6755: 6752: 6751: 6747: 6744: 6741: 6738: 6737: 6733: 6730: 6727: 6724: 6723: 6719: 6716: 6713: 6710: 6709: 6705: 6702: 6699: 6696: 6695: 6691: 6688: 6685: 6682: 6681: 6677: 6674: 6671: 6668: 6667: 6663: 6660: 6657: 6654: 6653: 6649: 6646: 6643: 6640: 6639: 6635: 6632: 6629: 6626: 6625: 6621: 6618: 6615: 6612: 6611: 6607: 6604: 6601: 6598: 6597: 6593: 6590: 6587: 6585: 6584: 6574: 6571: 6568: 6567: 6565: 6561: 6557: 6556: 6554: 6551: 6548: 6545: 6544: 6543: 6540: 6539: 6535: 6534: 6530: 6526: 6520: 6519: 6515: 6511: 6502: 6501: 6500: 6497: 6481: 6477: 6473: 6469: 6465: 6461: 6457: 6454: 6453: 6452: 6451: 6447: 6443: 6439: 6428: 6427: 6423: 6419: 6415: 6411: 6406: 6405: 6401: 6397: 6389: 6385: 6381: 6376: 6375: 6374: 6373: 6369: 6365: 6362: 6357: 6356: 6352: 6348: 6341: 6334: 6333: 6329: 6325: 6321: 6316: 6315: 6311: 6307: 6303: 6298: 6289: 6285: 6281: 6277: 6273: 6268: 6263: 6262: 6261: 6260: 6256: 6252: 6248: 6243: 6242: 6238: 6234: 6230: 6226: 6221: 6220: 6216: 6212: 6208: 6204: 6199: 6198: 6194: 6190: 6186: 6182: 6178: 6174: 6162: 6158: 6154: 6150: 6147: 6144: 6141: 6138: 6135: 6131: 6130: 6129: 6128: 6124: 6120: 6114: 6112: 6108: 6104: 6103:Gaza genocide 6089: 6085: 6081: 6077: 6076: 6074: 6070: 6066: 6062: 6058: 6056: 6052: 6048: 6044: 6040: 6038: 6034: 6030: 6025: 6021: 6013: 6010: 6007: 6006: 6000: 5996: 5995: 5994: 5993: 5991: 5987: 5986: 5983: 5979: 5975: 5971: 5968: 5966: 5964: 5960: 5959: 5958: 5954: 5950: 5946: 5942: 5937: 5933: 5929: 5925: 5920: 5919: 5918: 5914: 5910: 5906: 5902: 5898: 5896: 5892: 5888: 5883: 5881: 5877: 5873: 5869: 5865: 5863: 5859: 5855: 5851: 5847: 5843: 5839: 5835: 5830: 5828: 5824: 5820: 5815: 5810: 5809: 5794: 5790: 5786: 5781: 5776: 5772: 5769: 5768: 5767: 5763: 5759: 5755: 5751: 5747: 5743: 5739: 5735: 5731: 5727: 5723: 5719: 5718: 5717: 5716: 5712: 5708: 5703: 5695: 5690: 5686: 5682: 5678: 5677:Gaza genocide 5673: 5669: 5668: 5667: 5663: 5662: 5658: 5654: 5648: 5646: 5642: 5638: 5633: 5630: 5626: 5621: 5617: 5613: 5610: 5606: 5601: 5594: 5590: 5586: 5582: 5578: 5573: 5569: 5568: 5567: 5566: 5562: 5558: 5554: 5550: 5545: 5539: 5538: 5534: 5530: 5526: 5522: 5520: 5514: 5508: 5507: 5503: 5499: 5495: 5494:WP:ASPERSIONS 5489: 5488: 5484: 5480: 5474: 5472: 5466: 5464: 5459: 5457: 5453: 5449: 5445: 5440: 5437: 5424: 5420: 5414: 5407: 5406: 5399: 5395: 5389: 5384: 5382: 5378: 5372: 5366: 5362: 5358: 5354: 5350: 5347: 5344: 5340: 5336: 5334: 5330: 5324: 5318: 5314: 5306: 5303: 5299: 5294: 5292: 5288: 5282: 5275: 5268: 5263: 5259: 5255: 5249: 5241: 5236: 5232: 5228: 5222: 5216: 5215: 5214: 5210: 5204: 5197: 5193: 5192: 5191: 5187: 5181: 5173: 5168: 5167: 5166: 5165: 5161: 5155: 5148: 5144: 5142: 5138: 5126: 5122: 5116: 5110: 5106: 5102: 5098: 5094: 5090: 5085: 5082: 5079: 5076: 5073: 5072: 5068: 5067: 5066: 5065: 5061: 5057: 5053: 5052: 5048: 5047: 5044: 5041: 5039: 5036: 5034: 5031: 5029: 5028:TarnishedPath 5026: 5024: 5021: 5019: 5016: 5014: 5011: 5009: 5006: 5004: 5001: 4999: 4996: 4994: 4991: 4989: 4986: 4984: 4981: 4979: 4976: 4974: 4973:IOHANNVSVERVS 4971: 4969: 4966: 4964: 4961: 4959: 4956: 4954: 4951: 4949: 4946: 4944: 4941: 4940: 4936: 4935: 4930: 4927: 4924: 4921: 4918: 4915: 4912: 4909: 4906: 4903: 4900: 4897: 4894: 4891: 4888: 4883: 4880: 4876: 4873: 4870: 4867: 4864: 4861: 4858: 4855: 4852: 4849: 4846: 4843: 4840: 4837: 4834: 4829: 4826: 4822: 4819: 4816: 4813: 4810: 4807: 4804: 4801: 4798: 4795: 4792: 4789: 4786: 4783: 4780: 4775: 4772: 4767: 4764: 4761: 4758: 4755: 4752: 4749: 4746: 4743: 4740: 4737: 4734: 4731: 4728: 4725: 4720: 4717: 4716: 4712: 4711: 4706: 4703: 4700: 4697: 4694: 4691: 4688: 4685: 4682: 4679: 4676: 4673: 4670: 4665: 4662: 4658: 4655: 4652: 4649: 4646: 4643: 4640: 4637: 4634: 4631: 4628: 4625: 4622: 4617: 4614: 4610: 4607: 4604: 4601: 4598: 4595: 4592: 4589: 4586: 4583: 4580: 4577: 4574: 4569: 4566: 4562: 4559: 4556: 4553: 4550: 4547: 4544: 4541: 4538: 4535: 4532: 4529: 4526: 4521: 4520:TarnishedPath 4518: 4514: 4511: 4508: 4505: 4502: 4499: 4496: 4493: 4490: 4487: 4484: 4481: 4478: 4473: 4470: 4469: 4465: 4464: 4459: 4456: 4453: 4450: 4447: 4444: 4441: 4438: 4435: 4432: 4429: 4426: 4423: 4418: 4415: 4411: 4408: 4405: 4402: 4399: 4396: 4393: 4390: 4387: 4384: 4381: 4378: 4375: 4370: 4367: 4363: 4360: 4357: 4354: 4351: 4348: 4345: 4342: 4339: 4336: 4333: 4330: 4327: 4322: 4319: 4315: 4312: 4309: 4306: 4303: 4300: 4297: 4294: 4291: 4288: 4285: 4282: 4279: 4274: 4271: 4267: 4264: 4261: 4258: 4255: 4252: 4249: 4246: 4243: 4240: 4237: 4234: 4231: 4226: 4223: 4219: 4216: 4213: 4210: 4207: 4204: 4201: 4198: 4195: 4192: 4189: 4186: 4183: 4178: 4175: 4171: 4168: 4165: 4162: 4159: 4156: 4153: 4150: 4147: 4144: 4141: 4138: 4135: 4130: 4129:IOHANNVSVERVS 4127: 4123: 4120: 4117: 4114: 4111: 4108: 4105: 4102: 4099: 4096: 4093: 4090: 4087: 4082: 4079: 4075: 4072: 4069: 4066: 4063: 4060: 4057: 4054: 4051: 4048: 4045: 4042: 4039: 4034: 4031: 4027: 4024: 4021: 4018: 4015: 4012: 4009: 4006: 4003: 4000: 3997: 3994: 3991: 3986: 3983: 3979: 3976: 3973: 3970: 3967: 3964: 3961: 3958: 3955: 3952: 3949: 3946: 3943: 3938: 3935: 3931: 3928: 3925: 3922: 3919: 3916: 3913: 3910: 3907: 3904: 3901: 3898: 3895: 3890: 3887: 3882: 3879: 3876: 3873: 3870: 3867: 3864: 3861: 3858: 3855: 3852: 3849: 3846: 3841: 3838: 3837: 3834: 3831: 3829: 3826: 3825: 3821: 3817: 3813: 3812: 3808: 3807: 3803: 3797: 3793: 3789: 3785: 3781: 3777: 3773: 3767: 3766: 3762: 3759: 3758: 3757: 3756: 3753: 3750: 3747: 3734: 3730: 3727: 3724: 3721: 3718: 3711: 3710: 3705: 3701: 3700: 3699: 3696: 3690: 3689: 3683: 3682: 3677: 3673: 3669: 3665: 3661: 3655: 3650: 3649: 3648: 3647: 3644: 3640: 3637: 3634: 3631: 3628: 3621: 3620: 3615: 3611: 3607: 3603: 3599: 3595: 3591: 3587: 3586: 3585: 3581: 3578: 3575: 3572: 3569: 3562: 3561: 3556: 3554: 3547: 3545: 3541: 3537: 3531: 3527: 3523: 3522: 3518: 3517: 3513: 3512: 3509: 3505: 3501: 3497: 3493: 3492: 3488: 3487: 3484: 3480: 3476: 3473: 3472: 3468: 3467: 3461: 3458: 3457: 3453: 3450: 3449: 3445: 3442: 3441: 3437: 3434: 3433: 3429: 3419: 3418: 3415: 3414: 3413:are repealed. 3412: 3410: 3405: 3401: 3397: 3392: 3391: 3389: 3381: 3371: 3362: 3358: 3357: 3355: 3349: 3347: 3342: 3325: 3321: 3317: 3313: 3312: 3311: 3307: 3304: 3301: 3298: 3295: 3288: 3287: 3282: 3281: 3280: 3276: 3272: 3268: 3264: 3263: 3259: 3258: 3254: 3253: 3250: 3246: 3242: 3237: 3236: 3232: 3231: 3227: 3226: 3220: 3217: 3216: 3212: 3209: 3208: 3204: 3201: 3200: 3196: 3193: 3192: 3188: 3178: 3177: 3174: 3173: 3169: 3153: 3149: 3146: 3143: 3140: 3137: 3130: 3129: 3124: 3120: 3119: 3118: 3114: 3111: 3108: 3105: 3102: 3095: 3094: 3088: 3084: 3080: 3076: 3074: 3071: 3067: 3063: 3059: 3055: 3050: 3046: 3042: 3041: 3040: 3036: 3032: 3028: 3026: 3022: 3018: 3009: 3005: 3001: 3000: 2998: 2994: 2989: 2987: 2983: 2979: 2978: 2976: 2973: 2972: 2970: 2966: 2962: 2958: 2957: 2951: 2945: 2944: 2939: 2936: 2926: 2923: 2920: 2918: 2915: 2914: 2911: 2908: 2898: 2895: 2892: 2890: 2887: 2886: 2882: 2879: 2876: 2873: 2870: 2867: 2864: 2863: 2860: 2858: 2847: 2846: 2843: 2840: 2839: 2833: 2832: 2828: 2822: 2809: 2808: 2805: 2802: 2795: 2794: 2791: 2788: 2775: 2774: 2771: 2767: 2763: 2750: 2746: 2742: 2738: 2734: 2733: 2728: 2725: 2724: 2723: 2719: 2715: 2711: 2707: 2706: 2701: 2697: 2693: 2692: 2691: 2690: 2686: 2682: 2678: 2674: 2673: 2662: 2661: 2659: 2658: 2651: 2650: 2649:Then either: 2648: 2645: 2642: 2641: 2640: 2637: 2626: 2619: 2618: 2617: 2611: 2607: 2604: 2600: 2596: 2593: 2589: 2588: 2587: 2577: 2573: 2569: 2565: 2561: 2560: 2559: 2558: 2554: 2550: 2546: 2541: 2535: 2529: 2527: 2522: 2520: 2515: 2512: 2510: 2506: 2500: 2493: 2489: 2477: 2476: 2472: 2468: 2464: 2454: 2453: 2450: 2443: 2442: 2439: 2433: 2424: 2423: 2420: 2416: 2412: 2408: 2400: 2396: 2392: 2390: 2384: 2381: 2379: 2373: 2370: 2366: 2365: 2364: 2360: 2351: 2350: 2347: 2342: 2338: 2335:As I see it, 2328: 2320: 2319: 2318: 2317: 2314: 2309: 2305: 2302: 2294: 2293: 2289: 2285: 2275: 2274: 2270: 2266: 2261: 2257: 2250: 2244: 2243: 2239: 2235: 2229: 2223: 2222: 2218: 2214: 2210: 2204: 2195: 2189: 2188: 2184: 2180: 2176: 2172: 2171: 2167: 2163: 2159: 2152: 2146: 2145: 2140: 2133: 2127: 2125: 2110: 2109: 2108: 2105: 2104: 2100: 2099: 2096: 2094: 2093: 2089: 2088: 2083: 2080: 2077: 2074: 2071: 2068: 2065: 2062: 2059: 2056: 2053: 2050: 2047: 2044: 2041: 2036: 2033: 2028: 2025: 2022: 2019: 2016: 2013: 2010: 2007: 2004: 2001: 1998: 1995: 1992: 1987: 1984: 1983: 1980: 1977: 1976: 1973: 1970: 1969: 1965: 1964: 1959: 1955: 1951: 1947: 1943: 1939: 1935: 1929: 1928: 1924: 1921: 1920: 1919: 1918: 1915: 1912: 1909: 1883: 1876: 1873: 1871: 1868: 1867: 1864: 1861: 1859: 1856: 1854: 1851: 1849: 1846: 1844: 1841: 1839: 1836: 1834: 1831: 1829: 1826: 1824: 1821: 1819: 1816: 1814: 1811: 1809: 1806: 1804: 1801: 1799: 1796: 1794: 1791: 1789: 1786: 1784: 1781: 1779: 1776: 1775: 1772: 1769: 1767: 1764: 1762: 1759: 1757: 1754: 1752: 1749: 1747: 1744: 1742: 1739: 1737: 1734: 1732: 1729: 1727: 1724: 1722: 1719: 1717: 1714: 1712: 1709: 1707: 1704: 1702: 1699: 1697: 1694: 1692: 1689: 1687: 1684: 1683: 1680: 1677: 1675: 1672: 1670: 1667: 1665: 1662: 1660: 1657: 1655: 1652: 1650: 1647: 1645: 1642: 1640: 1637: 1635: 1632: 1630: 1627: 1625: 1622: 1620: 1617: 1615: 1612: 1610: 1607: 1605: 1602: 1600: 1597: 1595: 1592: 1591: 1588: 1585: 1583: 1580: 1578: 1575: 1573: 1570: 1568: 1565: 1563: 1560: 1558: 1555: 1553: 1550: 1548: 1545: 1543: 1540: 1538: 1535: 1533: 1530: 1528: 1525: 1523: 1520: 1518: 1515: 1513: 1510: 1508: 1505: 1503: 1500: 1499: 1496: 1493: 1491: 1488: 1486: 1483: 1481: 1478: 1476: 1473: 1471: 1468: 1466: 1463: 1461: 1458: 1456: 1453: 1451: 1448: 1446: 1443: 1441: 1438: 1436: 1433: 1431: 1428: 1426: 1423: 1421: 1418: 1416: 1413: 1411: 1408: 1407: 1404: 1401: 1399: 1396: 1394: 1391: 1389: 1386: 1384: 1381: 1379: 1376: 1374: 1371: 1369: 1366: 1364: 1361: 1359: 1356: 1354: 1351: 1349: 1346: 1344: 1341: 1339: 1336: 1334: 1331: 1329: 1326: 1324: 1321: 1319: 1316: 1315: 1312: 1309: 1307: 1304: 1302: 1299: 1297: 1294: 1292: 1289: 1287: 1284: 1282: 1279: 1277: 1274: 1272: 1269: 1267: 1264: 1262: 1259: 1257: 1254: 1252: 1249: 1247: 1244: 1242: 1239: 1237: 1234: 1232: 1229: 1227: 1224: 1223: 1220: 1219: 1211: 1206: 1204: 1199: 1197: 1192: 1191: 1187: 1184: 1178: 1170: 1169:.../Amendment 1166: 1163: 1161: 1158: 1156: 1153: 1151: 1148: 1146: 1143: 1141: 1138: 1136: 1133: 1132: 1129: 1125: 1123: 1114: 1112: 1107: 1105: 1100: 1078: 1071: 1068: 1066: 1063: 1062: 1059: 1056: 1054: 1051: 1049: 1046: 1044: 1041: 1039: 1036: 1034: 1031: 1029: 1026: 1024: 1021: 1019: 1016: 1014: 1011: 1009: 1006: 1004: 1001: 999: 996: 994: 991: 989: 986: 984: 981: 979: 976: 974: 971: 970: 967: 964: 962: 959: 957: 954: 952: 949: 947: 944: 942: 939: 937: 934: 932: 929: 927: 924: 922: 919: 917: 914: 912: 909: 907: 904: 902: 899: 897: 894: 892: 889: 887: 884: 882: 879: 878: 875: 872: 870: 867: 865: 862: 860: 857: 855: 852: 850: 847: 845: 842: 840: 837: 835: 832: 830: 827: 825: 822: 820: 817: 815: 812: 810: 807: 805: 802: 800: 797: 795: 792: 790: 787: 786: 783: 780: 778: 775: 773: 770: 768: 765: 763: 760: 758: 755: 753: 750: 748: 745: 743: 740: 738: 735: 733: 730: 728: 725: 723: 720: 718: 715: 713: 710: 708: 705: 703: 700: 698: 695: 694: 691: 688: 686: 683: 681: 678: 676: 673: 671: 668: 666: 663: 661: 658: 656: 653: 651: 648: 646: 643: 641: 638: 636: 633: 631: 628: 626: 623: 621: 618: 616: 613: 611: 608: 606: 603: 602: 599: 596: 594: 591: 589: 586: 584: 581: 579: 576: 574: 571: 569: 566: 564: 561: 559: 556: 554: 551: 549: 546: 544: 541: 539: 536: 534: 531: 529: 526: 524: 521: 519: 516: 514: 511: 510: 507: 504: 502: 499: 497: 494: 492: 489: 487: 484: 482: 479: 477: 474: 472: 469: 467: 464: 462: 459: 457: 454: 452: 449: 447: 444: 442: 439: 437: 434: 432: 429: 427: 424: 422: 419: 418: 415: 414: 406: 401: 399: 394: 392: 387: 386: 382: 379: 373: 366: 361: 355: 352: 347: 342: 338: 334: 330: 329: 327: 326: 325: 315: 312: 311: 310: 308: 304: 303:clarification 288: 282: 269: 266: 262: 255: 253: 250: 249: 245: 242: 238: 236: 235: 231: 229: 226: 225: 222:26 July 2024 221: 218: 214: 212: 211: 207: 205: 202: 201: 189:Request name 187: 181: 168: 166: 165: 161: 160: 152: 144: 133: 116: 113: 111: 109: 108: 104: 103: 91:Request name 89: 83: 82:Case requests 74:this template 73: 69: 66: 64: 61: 59: 56: 55: 51: 41: 37: 36: 33: 23: 19: 16513: 16507: 16501: 16476: 16465: 16459: 16452: 16416: 16402: 16398: 16381: 16370: 16332: 16329: 16308: 16288: 16286: 16273: 16266: 16254:page history 16247: 16233: 16178: 16163:Replying to 16134: 16116: 16115: 16110: 16100: 16087: 16086: 16069: 16059: 16040: 16025: 16023: 16020:SerialNumber 16019: 16003: 16001: 15998:SerialNumber 15997: 15993: 15987: 15984: 15959: 15957: 15954:SerialNumber 15953: 15947: 15943: 15928: 15926: 15923:SerialNumber 15922: 15920: 15911: 15909: 15906:SerialNumber 15905: 15900: 15896: 15887: 15881: 15876: 15862: 15859: 15854: 15852: 15847: 15834: 15823: 15819: 15801: 15795: 15782: 15770: 15764: 15756: 15739: 15733: 15726: 15720: 15702: 15698: 15692: 15686: 15683:my talk page 15677: 15673: 15669: 15667: 15656: 15611: 15600: 15593: 15569: 15566: 15555: 15531: 15513: 15492: 15491: 15481: 15475: 15469: 15463: 15457: 15451: 15433: 15427: 15421: 15415: 15409: 15403: 15384: 15378: 15372: 15366: 15360: 15354: 15340: 15339: 15301: 15288: 15283:Initiated by 15282: 15281: 15242: 15186:Abstentions 15163: 15141: 15045:Abstentions 15022: 15000: 14944:Abstentions 14917:standard set 14913: 14891: 14819:Abstentions 14797: 14775: 14719:Abstentions 14685: 14648: 14644: 14623: 14620: 14615: 14612: 14598: 14472: 14409:BilledMammal 14383: 14226: 14220: 14208: 14197: 14166: 14143: 14129: 14103: 14093: 14073: 14065: 14045: 14040: 14036: 14035: 14019: 13984: 13962:Figureofnine 13956: 13951: 13946: 13941: 13924:Figureofnine 13920: 13915: 13906: 13905: 13887:Figureofnine 13880: 13876: 13872: 13869: 13847:Figureofnine 13842: 13841: 13824:Figureofnine 13818: 13812: 13804: 13777: 13737:BilledMammal 13734: 13711: 13695: 13687: 13672: 13626: 13609: 13602: 13591: 13583: 13564: 13532: 13525: 13462: 13444: 13440: 13436: 13434: 13421: 13409: 13408:are good at 13406: 13397: 13386:deprecation. 13384: 13378: 13266: 13223: 13218: 13184: 13063: 13056: 12998: 12994: 12980: 12971: 12970: 12944: 12930: 12913: 12910: 12891: 12887: 12879: 12861: 12857: 12853: 12829: 12806: 12790: 12785: 12783: 12746: 12715: 12691: 12681: 12672: 12670: 12661: 12658: 12654: 12648: 12643: 12604: 12578: 12547: 12543: 12539: 12495: 12491: 12461: 12439: 12417:articles. -- 12414: 12400: 12389: 12381: 12368: 12352: 12340:BilledMammal 12321: 12318: 12291: 12282: 12275:BilledMammal 12241: 12235: 12233: 12226: 12214: 12194: 12190: 12187: 12166: 12147: 12140: 12113: 12106: 12100: 12095: 12086:Sean.hoyland 12067: 12060: 12054: 12050: 12046: 12044: 12038: 12034: 12026: 12022: 12015: 12012:berchanhimez 12005: 11989: 11982: 11965: 11964: 11941: 11934: 11909: 11902: 11890: 11881: 11877: 11873: 11858: 11851: 11840:gathered by 11819: 11812: 11802: 11800: 11795: 11787: 11769: 11731:back in 2007 11578: 11523: 11388: 11367: 11365: 11359: 11355: 11334: 11321: 11310: 11293: 11256: 11251: 11240: 11196: 11057: 11052: 11041: 11037: 11021: 10952: 10924: 10849: 10833: 10822: 10809: 10725:User:Afdshah 10665: 10661: 10657: 10654: 10644: 10641: 10597: 10539: 10470:Annette Maon 10408: 10401:BilledMammal 10382: 10361: 10302: 10273:Penguin UK. 10270: 10264: 10256: 10249: 10245:. You write: 10224: 10172:Kaifeng Jews 10053: 10047: 10040:berchanhimez 10033: 10022: 10012: 10007: 10003: 9999: 9989: 9985: 9976: 9971: 9967: 9957: 9953: 9939: 9929: 9925: 9911: 9907: 9903: 9893: 9889: 9873: 9871: 9857: 9854: 9851: 9848: 9846: 9842: 9840: 9826: 9823: 9820: 9817: 9815: 9811: 9805: 9796: 9793: 9790: 9787: 9785: 9782: 9722: 9694: 9689: 9673: 9646: 9575:BilledMammal 9567:this message 9494: 9472: 9468: 9444: 9406:about RTH's 9383: 9382: 9326: 9260: 9259: 9217: 9171: 9166: 9164: 9162: 9139:You can see 9136: 8981: 8973:(Hat tip to 8957: 8950: 8937: 8932: 8931: 8926: 8925: 8920: 8919: 8914: 8913: 8888: 8874:Sean.Hoyland 8856: 8837: 8819: 8808: 8804: 8802: 8788:BilledMammal 8751:BilledMammal 8744: 8728:BilledMammal 8721: 8685:Sean.hoyland 8667: 8654: 8635: 8618:BilledMammal 8585:BilledMammal 8570: 8560:this comment 8548: 8523:this comment 8500:BilledMammal 8485: 8461:BilledMammal 8436:BilledMammal 8420: 8390:BilledMammal 8358:Wafflefrites 8348: 8347: 8344:BilledMammal 8334: 8333: 8312:Onceinawhile 8287: 8286: 8250:BilledMammal 8239: 8226: 8221:Sean.hoyland 8206:BilledMammal 8198: 8173:BilledMammal 8163: 8148: 8120:BilledMammal 8095:BilledMammal 8086: 8052: 8051: 8035: 8014:BilledMammal 7991:Sean.hoyland 7958:BilledMammal 7943: 7937: 7926: 7902:BilledMammal 7877:BilledMammal 7855:BilledMammal 7806:BilledMammal 7774:BilledMammal 7764:or what the 7746:BilledMammal 7744: 7694:Bludgeoning 7667:POV pushing 7662: 7645: 7633: 7621: 7616: 7610: 7598: 7595: 7583: 7580: 7567: 7563: 7559: 7543: 7529: 7509: 7490: 7485: 7481: 7465: 7458: 7430: 7427: 7408: 7401: 7380:Sean.hoyland 7376: 7365:Sean.hoyland 7359: 7348:Sean.hoyland 7343: 7342:, regarding 7338: 7327:Sean.hoyland 7320: 7314: 7302:Sean.hoyland 7257: 7252: 7251: 7240:Sean.hoyland 7236:BilledMammel 7234: 7223:Sean.hoyland 7217: 7216: 7205:Sean.hoyland 7201: 7190:Sean.hoyland 7186: 7174:Sean.hoyland 7162: 7141: 7137: 7136: 7125:Sean.hoyland 7121: 7117: 7086: 7083:PIA dynamics 7082: 7081: 7070:Sean.hoyland 7065:BilledMammal 7062: 7058: 7057: 7046:Sean.hoyland 7040: 7026: 7017: 7003: 6999: 6991: 6990: 6979:Sean.hoyland 6969: 6958:Sean.hoyland 6956: 6942: 6927: 6916: 6905: 6901: 6898: 6889: 6888: 6877:Sean.hoyland 6873: 6863: 6861: 6857: 6854: 6838: 6829: 6818:Sean.hoyland 6816: 6785: 6781: 6780: 6769:Sean.hoyland 6767: 6591:actor_count 6559:thereabouts. 6541: 6537: 6536: 6525:Sean.hoyland 6521: 6510:Sean.hoyland 6507: 6498: 6494: 6467: 6459: 6437: 6434: 6407: 6392: 6360: 6358: 6335: 6319: 6317: 6301: 6292: 6271: 6244: 6222: 6206: 6200: 6172: 6170: 6115: 6099: 6064: 6060: 5990:WP:WIKIVOICE 5939: 5868:WP:CANVASSED 5774: 5771:Figureofnine 5701: 5699: 5665: 5649: 5634: 5628: 5624: 5622: 5618: 5614: 5602: 5598: 5580: 5575: 5548: 5541: 5524: 5516: 5513:BilledMammal 5510: 5491: 5475: 5470: 5467: 5460: 5455: 5451: 5441: 5435: 5432: 5403: 5393: 5364: 5360: 5356: 5345: 5339:BilledMammal 5316: 5301: 5149: 5145: 5140: 5134: 5105:coupled with 5054:Pursuant to 4998:BilledMammal 4978:Sean.hoyland 4925: 4919: 4913: 4907: 4901: 4895: 4889: 4871: 4865: 4859: 4853: 4847: 4841: 4835: 4817: 4811: 4805: 4799: 4793: 4787: 4781: 4762: 4756: 4750: 4744: 4738: 4732: 4726: 4701: 4695: 4689: 4683: 4677: 4671: 4653: 4647: 4641: 4635: 4629: 4623: 4605: 4599: 4593: 4587: 4581: 4575: 4557: 4551: 4545: 4539: 4533: 4527: 4509: 4503: 4497: 4491: 4485: 4479: 4454: 4448: 4442: 4436: 4430: 4424: 4406: 4400: 4394: 4388: 4382: 4376: 4369:BilledMammal 4358: 4352: 4346: 4340: 4334: 4328: 4310: 4304: 4298: 4292: 4286: 4280: 4262: 4256: 4250: 4244: 4238: 4232: 4214: 4208: 4202: 4196: 4190: 4184: 4177:Sean.hoyland 4166: 4160: 4154: 4148: 4142: 4136: 4118: 4112: 4106: 4100: 4094: 4088: 4070: 4064: 4058: 4052: 4046: 4040: 4022: 4016: 4010: 4004: 3998: 3992: 3974: 3968: 3962: 3956: 3950: 3944: 3926: 3920: 3914: 3908: 3902: 3896: 3877: 3871: 3865: 3859: 3853: 3847: 3832: 3814:Pursuant to 3764: 3751: 3746:Initiated by 3745: 3744: 3725: 3719: 3707: 3687: 3635: 3629: 3617: 3576: 3570: 3558: 3549: 3543: 3539: 3533: 3435:Abstentions 3408: 3394: 3393: 3364: 3359: 3351: 3345: 3339: 3302: 3296: 3284: 3194:Abstentions 3171: 3165: 3144: 3138: 3126: 3109: 3103: 3091: 3006:1 ("Talk"); 2984:1 ("Talk"); 2964: 2963:) is (only) 2949: 2865:Motion name 2856: 2855: 2841: 2815: 2796: 2781: 2760: 2730: 2703: 2670: 2669: 2638: 2634: 2615: 2585: 2530: 2523: 2516: 2513: 2494: 2483: 2467:Sean.hoyland 2460: 2445: 2425: 2414: 2406: 2404: 2394: 2388: 2386: 2375: 2368: 2352: 2334: 2310: 2306: 2303: 2300: 2281: 2245: 2224: 2190: 2173: 2156: 2147: 2128: 2121: 2078: 2072: 2066: 2060: 2054: 2048: 2042: 2023: 2017: 2011: 2005: 1999: 1993: 1926: 1913: 1908:Initiated by 1907: 1906: 1182: 1115: 1108: 1101: 1095: 377: 320: 306: 302: 300: 286: 232: 208: 179: 169:13 Sep 2024 162: 131: 105: 16353:Newyorkbrad 16337:Newyorkbrad 15972:Newyorkbrad 15392:(initiator) 15258:HJ Mitchell 15243:HJ Mitchell 15142:HJ Mitchell 15001:HJ Mitchell 14892:HJ Mitchell 14776:HJ Mitchell 14649:HJ Mitchell 14624:HJ Mitchell 14473:HJ Mitchell 14446:HJ Mitchell 14100:HJ Mitchell 13780:Hydrangeans 13644:HJ Mitchell 13573:Doug Weller 13511:talk to me! 13497:talk to me! 13475:talk to me! 13158:"Palestine" 13029:, at times, 12684:red herring 12645:HJ Mitchell 12550:WP:ACTIVIST 12355:WP:FOOTBALL 12328:tag teaming 12324:bludgeoning 12290:which is a 11925:LokiTheLiar 11314:WP:CIVILPOV 11286:WP:CIVILPOV 11244:WP:CIVILPOV 11022:HJ Mitchell 10907:Vanamonde93 10892:Vanamonde93 10869:Vanamonde93 10853:Vanamonde93 10677:User:Drsmoo 10673:User:Tombah 10431:you provide 10362:perceptions 10257:politically 9766:• she/her) 9749:Selfstudier 9739:• she/her) 9674:HJ Mitchell 9448:case here. 9408:INVOLVEMENT 9069:HJ Mitchell 9037:HJ Mitchell 8805:pro-Israeli 8803:Concerning 8755:Please add 8529:"massacre". 8364:IvanScrooge 8327:Vice regent 8318:Durranistan 8303:Makeandtoss 8297:Iskandar323 8294:Selfstudier 8077:Selfstudier 7679:Incivility 7292:User:FourPi 6994:TLDR -: --> 6892:TLDR -: --> 6566:Questions: 6456:HJ Mitchell 6418:Selfstudier 6396:Selfstudier 6380:Selfstudier 6364:Selfstudier 6347:Selfstudier 6324:Selfstudier 6306:Selfstudier 6280:Selfstudier 6251:Selfstudier 6233:Selfstudier 6211:Selfstudier 6189:Selfstudier 6059:Comment on 5999:Pareto rule 5945:WP:NOTAVOTE 4983:Iskandar323 4963:Selfstudier 4905:protections 4851:protections 4797:protections 4742:protections 4225:Iskandar323 4033:Selfstudier 3704:HJ Mitchell 3688:HJ Mitchell 3662:to reflect 2800:Doug Weller 2786:Doug Weller 2597:#2 in the ' 2590:#1 in the ' 2534:Selfstudier 2488:Doug Weller 2463:this revert 2432:Selfstudier 2359:Selfstudier 2327:Selfstudier 2265:Selfstudier 2234:Selfstudier 2213:Selfstudier 2203:Doug Weller 2179:Selfstudier 2162:Selfstudier 2058:protections 2031:(initiator) 1986:Selfstudier 1911:Selfstudier 364:to do this. 52:proceedings 16529:Categories 16491:Guerillero 16477:CaptainEek 16410:notability 16228:(shortcut 16220:(shortcut 15840:notability 15721:my promise 15637:Notability 15585:Notability 15479:block user 15473:filter log 15431:block user 15425:filter log 15382:block user 15376:filter log 15262:~ ToBeFree 15181:reference 15120:Guerillero 15106:~ ToBeFree 15040:reference 14939:reference 14814:reference 14714:reference 14690:under the 14599:CaptainEek 14583:~ ToBeFree 14547:Guerillero 14534:Guerillero 14041:by default 13996:(Redacted) 13819:especially 13662:individual 13535:Domeditrix 13428:, through 13361:(he/him • 13346:(he/him • 13337:WP:SOAPBOX 13215:WP:POVNAME 12813:WP:POVNAME 12802:threatened 12649:Especially 12558:WP:NOTHERE 12474:Domeditrix 12419:Domeditrix 12338:variety. @ 12304:SashiRolls 12266:SashiRolls 12248:SashiRolls 12027:Not at all 11838:this chart 11801:In short, 11780:Swatjester 11772:Tryptofish 11390:Tryptofish 11255:course, I 11175:Tryptofish 11161:Tryptofish 11147:Tryptofish 11132:Tryptofish 11112:Tryptofish 11097:Tryptofish 11016:Tryptofish 11002:Tryptofish 10987:Tryptofish 10972:Tryptofish 10957:Tryptofish 10930:Tryptofish 10705:User:רמרום 10701:User:האופה 10202:Swatjester 10167:Swatjester 10134:sealioning 10130:Swatjester 10046:who have, 9996:Domeditrix 9942:sealioning 9936:Swatjester 9900:Tryptofish 9346:‌Nishidani 9133:Tryptofish 8823:Ilan Pappe 8707:CaptainEek 8602:SashiRolls 8558:Regarding 8521:Regarding 8431:disparity. 8361:Borgenland 8355:Chomik1129 8324:Ali Ahwazi 8245:this table 8142:Seggallion 7921:Black Kite 7835:an editor 7411:Dan Murphy 7315:Regarding 5754:Hen Mazzig 5746:Brianna Wu 5099:on either 4988:Dan Murphy 4917:page moves 4863:page moves 4809:page moves 4754:page moves 4699:block user 4693:filter log 4651:block user 4645:filter log 4603:block user 4597:filter log 4555:block user 4549:filter log 4507:block user 4501:filter log 4452:block user 4446:filter log 4404:block user 4398:filter log 4356:block user 4350:filter log 4308:block user 4302:filter log 4273:Dan Murphy 4260:block user 4254:filter log 4212:block user 4206:filter log 4164:block user 4158:filter log 4116:block user 4110:filter log 4068:block user 4062:filter log 4020:block user 4014:filter log 3972:block user 3966:filter log 3924:block user 3918:filter log 3875:block user 3869:filter log 3590:~ ToBeFree 3475:~ ToBeFree 3430:reference 3316:~ ToBeFree 3271:~ ToBeFree 3189:reference 3070:Guerillero 3017:~ ToBeFree 2995:All other 2605:' applies. 2519:WP:BROADLY 2249:Guerillero 2070:page moves 2021:block user 2015:filter log 265:orig. case 241:orig. case 217:orig. case 154:Case name 143:Past cases 127:Open cases 97:Initiated 16171:deletion" 15485:block log 15437:block log 15388:block log 14316:Barkeep49 14281:Barkeep49 14256:Barkeep49 14207:). Best, 14153:on reply) 13751:with the 13566:Rosguill. 13390:WP:BIASED 13359:Shushugah 13344:Shushugah 13254:Jehochman 12927:accounts. 12435:Number 57 12396:WP:CANVAS 12369:shouldn't 12101:potential 11882:in theory 11494:aspersion 11487:Nishidani 11372:Aquillion 11335:happening 11298:Aquillion 11270:Aquillion 11219:Nishidani 10888:WP:ARBGWE 10884:WP:ARBIRP 10772:Nishidani 10749:Nishidani 10743:, sock); 10650:Barkeep49 10614:Nishidani 10584:Nishidani 10570:Nishidani 10523:Nishidani 10483:Nishidani 10447:Nishidani 10414:Nishidani 10388:Nishidani 10366:Nishidani 10342:Nishidani 10308:Nishidani 10288:Nishidani 10267:Ian Black 10229:Nishidani 10225:empirical 10207:Nishidani 10188:Nishidani 10176:Gadubanud 10153:Nishidani 10117:Nishidani 10099:Nishidani 10081:Nishidani 10062:Nishidani 10034:two sides 10026:this. . . 9998:there is 9950:Number 57 9703:Barkeep49 9669:Barkeep49 9654:Barkeep49 9630:Barkeep49 9615:Barkeep49 9597:Barkeep49 9583:Barkeep49 9551:Barkeep49 9544:Nishidani 9529:Barkeep49 9514:Barkeep49 9499:Barkeep49 9477:Barkeep49 9450:Barkeep49 9431:Barkeep49 9413:Barkeep49 9404:AN thread 9390:Barkeep49 9369:Barkeep49 9352:Barkeep49 9331:Barkeep49 9300:Barkeep49 9285:Barkeep49 9267:Barkeep49 9242:Barkeep49 9223:Barkeep49 9218:mechanics 9216:that the 9196:Barkeep49 9176:Barkeep49 9114:Barkeep49 9097:Barkeep49 8895:Barkeep49 8565:(a) - It 8451:Nishidani 8411:Nishidani 8384:accurate. 8309:Nishidani 8137:Nishidani 8001:Nishidani 7892:Nishidani 7875:pushing. 7870:Nishidani 7641:supported 7288:Exhibit C 7278:Exhibit B 7273:Exhibit A 7112:WP:ARBECR 7102:Step 2 - 7091:Step 1 - 6996:more data 6894:some data 6340:Barkeep49 6297:Nishidani 6134:EC editor 5572:Barkeep49 5525:confirmed 5463:WP:BANPOL 5038:DMH223344 5033:Nishidani 5023:PeleYoetz 5013:Barkeep49 4911:deletions 4857:deletions 4828:Barkeep49 4803:deletions 4748:deletions 4705:block log 4657:block log 4616:DMH223344 4609:block log 4568:Nishidani 4561:block log 4513:block log 4472:PeleYoetz 4458:block log 4410:block log 4362:block log 4314:block log 4266:block log 4218:block log 4170:block log 4122:block log 4074:block log 4026:block log 3978:block log 3930:block log 3881:block log 3664:WP:CT/A-I 3660:WP:ARBECR 3614:WP:ARBECR 3610:WP:ARBECR 3087:WP:ARBECR 3083:WP:ARBECR 3049:WP:CT/A-I 3004:namespace 2982:namespace 2975:WP:ARBPIA 2762:Callanecc 2732:Callanecc 2705:Callanecc 2672:Callanecc 2415:talkspace 2407:userspace 2341:WP:ARBECR 2284:Barkeep49 2260:this edit 2132:Barkeep49 2122:To match 2064:deletions 2035:Barkeep49 2027:block log 1160:WP:A/R/CA 1150:WP:A/R/CL 1128:Shortcuts 307:amendment 16435:Primefac 16421:Primefac 16333:problems 16313:Flatscan 16275:Flatscan 16250:disagree 16230:WP:ATD-R 16222:WP:ATD-M 16165:Flatscan 16064:and not 15978:you said 15888:narrowly 15884:deletion 15687:DELETION 15670:DELETION 15559:contribs 15535:contribs 15455:contribs 15407:contribs 15358:contribs 15179:Majority 15038:Majority 14937:Majority 14812:Majority 14712:Majority 14666:Primefac 14560:against 14520:Primefac 14205:suggests 14149:(Please 14106:starship 14077:Springee 14049:Amayorov 14023:Amayorov 14001:Amayorov 13971:contribs 13943:Levivich 13933:contribs 13911:Amayorov 13896:contribs 13856:contribs 13833:contribs 13815:WP:CIVIL 13610:separate 13224:scholars 13219:scholars 13209:: "...s 13064:minutely 13038:unhinged 12972:Rosguill 12967:signed, 12834:xDanielx 12677:an essay 12607:the link 12384:Zanahary 12373:ABHammad 12363:despite 12258:NoCal100 12173:Zanahary 11704:Huldra's 11262:WP:CIVIL 10518:haskalah 10427:Nableezy 10409:dominate 10405:I second 10095:WP:CIVIL 10030:xDanielx 9982:Zanahary 9571:Levivich 9464:Levivich 9020:ToBeFree 8999:Levivich 8515:Zero0000 8478:Zero0000 8407:Levivich 8367:Arminden 8321:Zero0000 8306:Nableezy 8192:Zero0000 8169:) (×6) 8167:contribs 8152:contribs 8110:Nableezy 8029:Nableezy 7897:pushing. 7821:Rosguill 7789:Nableezy 7671:sources. 7648:nableezy 7624:nableezy 7618:massacre 7601:nableezy 7586:nableezy 7570:nableezy 7546:nableezy 7532:nableezy 7512:nableezy 7493:nableezy 7486:actually 7468:nableezy 7433:nableezy 7361:Zero0000 7340:Zero0000 7317:Zero0000 7164:See plot 6971:Zero0000 6460:claiming 6320:regulars 6153:ABHammad 6119:ABHammad 6065:Motion 4 6061:Motion 3 5785:Levivich 5758:Levivich 5707:Levivich 5671:appeals. 5653:Levivich 5585:Levivich 5557:Levivich 5529:Levivich 5498:Levivich 5479:Levivich 5436:anyone's 5349:contribs 5240:Zero0000 5172:Levivich 5043:M.Bitton 5003:Zero0000 4993:Nableezy 4958:ABHammad 4943:Levivich 4893:contribs 4839:contribs 4785:contribs 4730:contribs 4675:contribs 4664:M.Bitton 4627:contribs 4579:contribs 4531:contribs 4483:contribs 4428:contribs 4417:Zero0000 4380:contribs 4332:contribs 4321:Nableezy 4284:contribs 4236:contribs 4188:contribs 4140:contribs 4092:contribs 4044:contribs 3996:contribs 3985:ABHammad 3948:contribs 3900:contribs 3851:contribs 3840:Levivich 3526:ToBeFree 3428:Majority 3404:Remedy 8 3400:Remedy 7 3396:Remedy 6 3361:Remedy 5 3341:Remedy 4 3314:Thanks! 3187:Majority 3085:.) Now, 2877:Passing 2874:Abstain 2868:Support 2741:contribs 2714:contribs 2681:contribs 2499:Zero0000 2194:Zero0000 2151:Zero0000 2139:Zero0000 2046:contribs 1997:contribs 1186:archives 1155:WP:A/R/A 381:archives 358:{{subst: 192:Motions 94:Motions 32:Shortcut 22:Requests 20:‎ | 16258:deleted 16244:WP:BLAR 15897:process 15877:Quote: 15826:WP:BLAR 15786:scale.' 15730:happen. 15580:adding 15230:Abstain 15220:Support 15129:Abstain 15079:Support 14988:Abstain 14978:Support 14879:Abstain 14853:Support 14763:Abstain 14753:Support 14616:en banc 14516:WP:PIA5 13843:Motions 13784:she/her 13767:by the 13665:editors 13659:hitting 13548:Amakuru 13230:others. 12914:Portals 12894:Ravpapa 12793:Zionism 12575:remedy. 12468:Joe Roe 12456:Amakuru 12411:Ravpapa 12403:The_Kip 12365:WP:VOTE 12292:partial 12198:Ravpapa 12092:WP:SOCK 12039:already 11977:WP:BRIE 11339:WP:ROPE 11290:WP:BITE 10949:WP:BRIE 10764:Barkeep 10731:(69%); 10699:(43%), 10683:(49%); 10679:(48%); 10671:(72%); 10636:Barkeep 10358:Barkeep 10004:editors 9984:: It’s 9964:The Kip 9910:, were 9384:despite 8893:editor 8807:versus 8786:editor 8757:this RM 8749:editor 8726:editor 8705:editor 8683:editor 8610:actors. 8315:Irtapil 8199:editing 8157:Icewhiz 7841:At the 7833:ADL RFC 7831:At the 7637:claimed 7108:WP:SOCK 7097:AE case 6869:WP:SOCK 6842:like... 6831:The Kip 6803:WP:SOCK 6792:WP:SOCK 6414:Zionism 6181:Zionism 6111:Zionism 5846:WP:ONUS 5842:WP:ONUS 5780:WP:NPOV 5694:Zionism 5313:WP:BITE 3530:WP:CTOP 3514:Abstain 3469:Support 3406:of the 3388:comment 3343:of the 3255:Abstain 3228:Support 2871:Oppose 2540:WP:TBAN 2526:WP:UOWN 2430:editor 2357:editor 2325:editor 2175:And now 1135:WP:ARCA 198:Posted 157:Closed 72:discuss 40:WP:ARCA 16224:) and 16179:per se 16076:Tamzin 16053:being 15783:struck 15715:WP:DYK 15713:, and 15711:WP:ARS 15650:, and 15628:, and 15624:, and 15347:Cunard 15286:Cunard 15225:Oppose 15084:Oppose 14983:Oppose 14858:Oppose 14758:Oppose 14579:WP:ARC 14543:Huldra 14210:KevinL 14111:.paint 13957:failed 13650:rather 13528:Buidhe 13238:Huldra 13168:Huldra 13122:Huldra 13103:Huldra 13072:Huldra 13009:Huldra 12692:should 12561:this. 12554:WP:SPA 12415:within 12096:always 11973:WP:RGW 11778:, and 11736:Number 11710:Number 11684:Number 11658:Number 11653:my RfA 11632:Number 11606:Number 11583:Number 11562:Jester 11537:Jester 11512:Jester 11469:Jester 11452:Huldra 11436:Jester 11419:Huldra 11404:Jester 11342:count. 11248:WP:AGF 10836:buidhe 10695:(89%); 10514:Hebron 10260:that:- 10032:: the 10006:here 9972:scream 9912:acting 9690:during 9577:about 9192:WP:HJP 8969:tomats 8533:again. 8427:socks. 8341:Tombah 8087:proves 8053:Oppose 8044:WP:AGF 7564:others 7218:Labels 6762:59678 6748:52636 6734:19716 6720:21711 6706:14908 6692:15812 6678:23643 6664:21463 6650:18541 6636:23195 6622:23773 6608:17754 6472:fiveby 6442:fiveby 6410:WP:CRP 6024:WP:TNT 5814:WP:RSN 5750:X post 5742:X post 5738:revert 5734:revert 5730:revert 5726:revert 5722:revert 5637:FourPi 5553:WP:ARC 5418:(nest) 5376:(nest) 5328:(nest) 5286:(nest) 5253:(nest) 5226:(nest) 5208:(nest) 5185:(nest) 5159:(nest) 5120:(nest) 4968:fiveby 4923:rights 4899:blocks 4869:rights 4845:blocks 4815:rights 4791:blocks 4760:rights 4736:blocks 4081:fiveby 3709:KevinL 3619:KevinL 3560:KevinL 3489:Oppose 3402:, and 3286:KevinL 3233:Oppose 3168:ARBPIA 3128:KevinL 3093:KevinL 3045:WP:ECR 2883:Notes 2826:(nest) 2770:(talk) 2509:WP:ECR 2505:WP:PIA 2461:Maybe 2395:agrees 2124:WP:ECR 2076:rights 2052:blocks 1140:WP:ARA 1104:Clerks 317:bans). 234:Motion 210:Motion 117:3/0/0 100:Votes 16417:start 16399:where 16026:54129 16004:54129 15960:54129 15929:54129 15912:54129 15727:never 15703:three 15674:MERGE 15091:Aoidh 14865:Aoidh 14575:האופה 14571:האופה 14562:האופה 14490:Aoidh 14457:Aoidh 14431:Aoidh 14416:Aoidh 14394:Aoidh 14368:Aoidh 14344:Z1720 14323:Z1720 14301:Z1720 14287:Z1720 14266:Z1720 14241:Z1720 14191:האופה 14184:האופה 13792:edits 13688:Notes 13678:v^_^v 13632:v^_^v 13300:Arkon 13284:Arkon 13269:Arkon 12999:never 12764:alien 12732:alien 12629:alien 12590:alien 12283:known 12094:will 11891:badly 11788:every 11322:worse 11266:WP:EW 11065:WP:AE 10945:WP:RS 10478:reply 10280:p.8 ) 10182:and 9938:;The 9756:lower 9569:from 9327:could 9281:Z1720 9256:Z1720 9237:Z1720 9210:Z1720 8581:NebYs 8037:page. 8006:list. 7952:Aoidh 7929:with 7266:rate. 6864:could 6759:6287 6756:2024 6745:6778 6742:2023 6731:2464 6728:2022 6717:2755 6714:2021 6703:2110 6700:2020 6689:1907 6686:2019 6675:2184 6672:2018 6661:2091 6658:2017 6647:1848 6644:2016 6633:2167 6630:2015 6619:2483 6616:2014 6605:2096 6602:2013 6588:year 6274:lower 5577:here. 5471:could 5388:Z1720 5300:, of 5141:Note: 4948:האופה 3889:האופה 3668:Aoidh 3606:Aoidh 3540:pages 3500:Aoidh 3496:above 3241:Aoidh 3054:Aoidh 3031:Aoidh 2946:Notes 2696:Aoidh 2545:WP:GS 2409:" at 2397:with 195:Case 16:< 16439:talk 16425:talk 16357:talk 16341:talk 16317:talk 16279:talk 16188:talk 16153:talk 16070:just 16055:BLAR 15988:good 15893:GoDG 15553:talk 15529:talk 15467:logs 15449:talk 15419:logs 15401:talk 15370:logs 15352:talk 15266:talk 15210:4–5 15202:2–3 15194:0–1 15110:talk 15095:talk 15069:4–5 15061:2–3 15053:0–1 14968:4–5 14960:2–3 14952:0–1 14869:talk 14843:4–5 14835:2–3 14827:0–1 14743:4–5 14735:2–3 14727:0–1 14670:talk 14587:talk 14524:talk 14494:talk 14461:talk 14435:talk 14420:talk 14398:talk 14372:talk 14348:talk 14327:talk 14305:talk 14291:talk 14270:talk 14262:here 14245:talk 14218:L235 14151:ping 14081:talk 14053:talk 14027:talk 14005:talk 13989:and 13967:talk 13947:both 13929:talk 13916:this 13892:talk 13852:talk 13829:talk 13788:talk 13722:talk 13718:RAN1 13714:diff 13668:only 13656:just 13653:than 13577:talk 13552:talk 13437:need 13422:that 13392:and 13363:talk 13348:talk 13304:talk 13288:talk 13273:talk 13242:talk 13172:talk 13150:and 13141:and 13126:talk 13107:talk 13076:talk 13068:here 13035:more 13013:talk 12995:love 12898:talk 12791:The 12770:talk 12761:ugly 12738:talk 12729:ugly 12635:talk 12626:ugly 12596:talk 12587:ugly 12526:talk 12522:Loki 12503:talk 12499:Loki 12478:talk 12448:. A 12423:talk 12344:here 12330:and 12279:here 12237:here 12202:talk 12023:many 11878:main 11702:For 11559:SWAT 11534:SWAT 11509:SWAT 11466:SWAT 11433:SWAT 11401:SWAT 11376:talk 11368:hard 11360:does 11302:talk 11294:just 11274:talk 11264:and 11257:also 11252:easy 11227:talk 11209:talk 11179:talk 11165:talk 11151:talk 11136:talk 11116:talk 11101:talk 11053:real 11006:talk 10991:talk 10976:talk 10961:talk 10953:that 10934:talk 10911:talk 10896:talk 10886:and 10873:talk 10857:talk 10792:talk 10776:talk 10753:talk 10618:talk 10588:talk 10574:talk 10527:talk 10487:talk 10451:talk 10418:talk 10392:talk 10370:talk 10346:talk 10312:talk 10292:talk 10275:ISBN 10233:talk 10211:talk 10192:talk 10157:talk 10121:talk 10113:link 10103:talk 10085:talk 10066:talk 10021:the 9858:Path 9827:Path 9797:Path 9764:talk 9737:talk 9726:L235 9707:talk 9658:talk 9634:talk 9619:talk 9601:talk 9587:talk 9555:talk 9533:talk 9518:talk 9503:talk 9481:talk 9454:talk 9435:talk 9417:talk 9394:talk 9373:talk 9356:talk 9335:talk 9304:talk 9289:talk 9271:talk 9246:talk 9227:talk 9200:talk 9180:talk 9149:talk 9141:here 9122:talk 9105:talk 9088:talk 9060:talk 9045:talk 9028:talk 9011:talk 8989:talk 8939:Zero 8902:Zero 8881:Zero 8863:Zero 8850:Zero 8831:Zero 8813:Zero 8795:Zero 8774:Zero 8768:and 8738:Zero 8734:here 8714:Zero 8692:Zero 8671:Zero 8660:Zero 8622:talk 8589:talk 8567:does 8540:and 8504:talk 8465:talk 8440:talk 8409:and 8394:talk 8254:talk 8210:talk 8177:talk 8161:talk 8146:talk 8124:talk 8099:talk 8091:here 8057:this 8018:talk 7962:talk 7944:bold 7906:talk 7881:talk 7859:talk 7810:talk 7794:RSN. 7778:talk 7750:talk 7697:See 7613:here 7415:talk 7384:talk 7369:talk 7352:talk 7331:talk 7306:talk 7244:talk 7227:talk 7209:talk 7194:talk 7178:talk 7129:talk 7110:and 7074:talk 7050:talk 6983:talk 6962:talk 6881:talk 6822:talk 6773:talk 6529:talk 6514:talk 6476:zero 6446:zero 6422:talk 6400:talk 6384:talk 6368:talk 6351:talk 6328:talk 6310:talk 6284:talk 6255:talk 6237:talk 6229:this 6215:talk 6193:talk 6157:talk 6123:talk 6105:and 6084:talk 6073:talk 6051:talk 6033:talk 5974:talk 5953:talk 5928:talk 5913:talk 5891:talk 5876:talk 5858:talk 5823:talk 5789:talk 5762:talk 5711:talk 5657:talk 5629:that 5589:talk 5561:talk 5549:does 5533:talk 5511:Re: 5502:talk 5483:talk 5456:vast 5448:here 5444:here 5343:talk 5267:L235 5058:, a 4887:talk 4833:talk 4779:talk 4724:talk 4687:logs 4669:talk 4639:logs 4621:talk 4591:logs 4573:talk 4543:logs 4525:talk 4495:logs 4477:talk 4440:logs 4422:talk 4392:logs 4374:talk 4344:logs 4326:talk 4296:logs 4278:talk 4248:logs 4230:talk 4200:logs 4182:talk 4152:logs 4134:talk 4104:logs 4086:talk 4056:logs 4038:talk 4008:logs 3990:talk 3960:logs 3942:talk 3912:logs 3894:talk 3863:logs 3845:talk 3818:, a 3800:and 3717:L235 3672:talk 3654:L235 3627:L235 3594:talk 3568:L235 3504:talk 3498:. - 3479:talk 3459:4–5 3451:2–3 3443:0–1 3411:case 3365:The 3348:case 3320:talk 3294:L235 3275:talk 3267:L235 3245:talk 3218:4–5 3210:2–3 3202:0–1 3136:L235 3101:L235 3058:talk 3035:talk 3021:talk 2804:talk 2790:talk 2745:logs 2737:talk 2718:logs 2710:talk 2700:here 2685:logs 2677:talk 2572:talk 2564:L235 2553:talk 2471:talk 2449:Zero 2438:Zero 2419:Zero 2346:Zero 2313:Zero 2288:talk 2269:talk 2238:talk 2217:talk 2183:talk 2166:talk 2040:talk 2009:logs 1991:talk 1167:and 258:none 68:view 16502:not 16460:Yes 16453:Yes 16246:): 16105:at 15976:As 15948:are 15901:too 15866:• 15848:did 15678:not 15594:In 15327:) ( 15319:) ( 15311:) ( 14215:aka 14200:as 14116:RUN 13952:all 13885:--- 13739:'s 13670:. — 13618:AP2 13614:COL 13441:any 13120:, 13118:dog 13057:far 12758:big 12755:The 12726:big 12723:The 12623:big 12620:The 12584:big 12581:The 12394:to 12243:18% 12148:Kip 12141:The 12114:Kip 12107:The 12068:Kip 12061:The 12055:all 11990:Kip 11983:The 11942:Kip 11935:The 11910:Kip 11903:The 11859:Kip 11852:The 11820:Kip 11813:The 11733:). 11356:can 11058:not 11042:not 10566:TAU 10303:was 9855:hed 9852:nis 9849:Tar 9824:hed 9821:nis 9818:Tar 9794:hed 9791:nis 9788:Tar 9573:to 9469:but 9194:). 8857:At 8825:or 8116:- 8069:- 7703:RSN 7652:- 7628:- 7605:- 7590:- 7574:- 7550:- 7536:- 7516:- 7497:- 7472:- 7437:- 7319:'s 6946:. 6839:can 6753:11 6739:10 6468:now 6336:7: 6227:or 5852:). 5840:vs 5812:in 5752:by 5744:by 5702:and 5446:or 5355:'s 5317:not 4929:RfA 4875:RfA 4821:RfA 4766:RfA 3790:) ( 3782:) ( 3774:) ( 3714:aka 3624:aka 3565:aka 3291:aka 3133:aka 3098:aka 2766:PMC 2660:OR 2082:RfA 1952:) ( 1944:) ( 1936:) ( 1875:128 1870:127 1863:126 1858:125 1853:124 1848:123 1843:122 1838:121 1833:120 1828:119 1823:118 1818:117 1813:116 1808:115 1803:114 1798:113 1793:112 1788:111 1783:110 1778:109 1771:108 1766:107 1761:106 1756:105 1751:104 1746:103 1741:102 1736:101 1731:100 1070:128 1065:127 1058:126 1053:125 1048:124 1043:123 1038:122 1033:121 1028:120 1023:119 1018:118 1013:117 1008:116 1003:115 998:114 993:113 988:112 983:111 978:110 973:109 966:108 961:107 956:106 951:105 946:104 941:103 936:102 931:101 926:100 305:or 70:or 16531:: 16489:-- 16466:No 16441:) 16427:) 16413:}} 16407:{{ 16403:if 16359:) 16343:) 16319:) 16311:. 16281:) 16190:) 16155:) 15944:is 15855:de 15843:}} 15837:{{ 15709:, 15654:. 15646:, 15640:}} 15634:{{ 15620:, 15616:, 15588:}} 15582:{{ 15329:pd 15313:ev 15289:at 15268:) 15246:| 15213:3 15205:4 15197:5 15145:| 15112:) 15097:) 15072:3 15064:4 15056:5 15004:| 14971:3 14963:4 14955:5 14895:| 14871:) 14846:3 14838:4 14830:5 14779:| 14746:3 14738:4 14730:5 14672:) 14652:| 14627:| 14589:) 14526:) 14496:) 14476:| 14463:) 14437:) 14422:) 14400:) 14374:) 14350:) 14329:) 14307:) 14293:) 14272:) 14247:) 14232:) 14145:VR 14083:) 14055:) 14029:) 14007:) 13969:• 13931:• 13894:• 13854:• 13831:• 13794:) 13790:| 13786:| 13747:, 13724:) 13554:) 13509:| 13507:me 13495:| 13493:me 13473:| 13471:me 13410:ab 13365:) 13350:) 13306:) 13290:) 13275:) 13244:) 13174:) 13128:) 13109:) 13087:, 13078:) 13015:) 12954:, 12950:, 12900:) 12843:\ 12824:, 12821:, 12818:, 12804:. 12773:) 12741:) 12638:) 12617:. 12599:) 12528:) 12505:) 12480:) 12425:) 12350:. 12326:, 12204:) 12196:-- 12090:- 11975:, 11774:, 11378:) 11316:/ 11304:) 11276:) 11229:) 11211:) 11181:) 11167:) 11153:) 11138:) 11118:) 11110:-- 11103:) 11095:-- 11038:is 11025:| 11008:) 10993:) 10978:) 10963:) 10936:) 10913:) 10898:) 10875:) 10859:) 10832:) 10828:· 10794:) 10778:) 10762:@* 10755:) 10620:) 10590:) 10576:) 10529:) 10489:) 10453:) 10420:) 10394:) 10372:) 10348:) 10314:) 10294:) 10269:, 10235:) 10213:) 10194:) 10178:, 10174:, 10159:) 10148:, 10143:, 10123:) 10105:) 10087:) 10068:) 9709:) 9677:| 9660:) 9636:) 9621:) 9603:) 9589:) 9581:. 9557:) 9535:) 9520:) 9505:) 9483:) 9456:) 9437:) 9419:) 9396:) 9375:) 9358:) 9337:) 9306:) 9291:) 9273:) 9248:) 9229:) 9202:) 9182:) 9174:. 9151:) 9135:, 9124:) 9107:) 9090:) 9062:) 9047:) 9030:) 9013:) 8991:) 8891:To 8784:To 8764:, 8747:To 8724:To 8703:To 8681:To 8624:) 8591:) 8583:. 8569:; 8506:) 8467:) 8459:. 8442:) 8396:) 8351:: 8337:: 8290:: 8256:) 8212:) 8179:) 8126:) 8101:) 8093:. 8020:) 7964:) 7908:) 7883:) 7861:) 7812:) 7780:) 7752:) 7705:. 7417:) 7386:) 7371:) 7354:) 7333:) 7308:) 7290:, 7280:, 7246:) 7229:) 7211:) 7196:) 7180:) 7131:) 7076:) 7052:) 6985:) 6964:) 6896:. 6883:) 6824:) 6775:) 6725:9 6711:8 6697:7 6683:6 6669:5 6655:4 6641:3 6627:2 6613:1 6599:0 6531:) 6516:) 6478:) 6448:) 6424:) 6402:) 6386:) 6370:) 6353:) 6330:) 6312:) 6293:5. 6286:) 6257:) 6239:) 6217:) 6209:. 6201:2. 6195:) 6175:, 6159:) 6125:) 6086:) 6075:) 6053:) 6035:) 5976:) 5955:) 5930:) 5915:) 5893:) 5878:) 5860:) 5825:) 5791:) 5764:) 5748:, 5736:, 5732:, 5728:, 5724:, 5713:) 5659:) 5625:is 5591:) 5574:: 5563:) 5535:) 5504:) 5485:) 5150:— 5111:— 3792:pd 3776:ev 3752:at 3731:) 3691:| 3674:) 3641:) 3596:) 3582:) 3506:) 3481:) 3462:3 3454:4 3446:5 3398:, 3383:}} 3377:{{ 3373:}} 3367:{{ 3322:) 3308:) 3277:) 3247:) 3221:3 3213:4 3205:5 3150:) 3115:) 3060:) 3037:) 3023:) 2937:4 2927:0 2924:1 2921:1 2909:5 2899:0 2896:1 2893:0 2768:♠ 2747:) 2743:• 2739:• 2720:) 2716:• 2712:• 2687:) 2683:• 2679:• 2574:) 2555:) 2511:. 2473:) 2428:To 2355:To 2323:To 2290:) 2271:) 2240:) 2219:) 2211:? 2185:) 2168:) 1954:pd 1938:ev 1914:at 1726:99 1721:98 1716:97 1711:96 1706:95 1701:94 1696:93 1691:92 1686:91 1679:90 1674:89 1669:88 1664:87 1659:86 1654:85 1649:84 1644:83 1639:82 1634:81 1629:80 1624:79 1619:78 1614:77 1609:76 1604:75 1599:74 1594:73 1587:72 1582:71 1577:70 1572:69 1567:68 1562:67 1557:66 1552:65 1547:64 1542:63 1537:62 1532:61 1527:60 1522:59 1517:58 1512:57 1507:56 1502:55 1495:54 1490:53 1485:52 1480:51 1475:50 1470:49 1465:48 1460:47 1455:46 1450:45 1445:44 1440:43 1435:42 1430:41 1425:40 1420:39 1415:38 1410:37 1403:36 1398:35 1393:34 1388:33 1383:32 1378:31 1373:30 1368:29 1363:28 1358:27 1353:26 1348:25 1343:24 1338:23 1333:22 1328:21 1323:20 1318:19 1311:18 1306:17 1301:16 1296:15 1291:14 1286:13 1281:12 1276:11 1271:10 1130:: 1113:. 921:99 916:98 911:97 906:96 901:95 896:94 891:93 886:92 881:91 874:90 869:89 864:88 859:87 854:86 849:85 844:84 839:83 834:82 829:81 824:80 819:79 814:78 809:77 804:76 799:75 794:74 789:73 782:72 777:71 772:70 767:69 762:68 757:67 752:66 747:65 742:64 737:63 732:62 727:61 722:60 717:59 712:58 707:57 702:56 697:55 690:54 685:53 680:52 675:51 670:50 665:49 660:48 655:47 650:46 645:45 640:44 635:43 630:42 625:41 620:40 615:39 610:38 605:37 598:36 593:35 588:34 583:33 578:32 573:31 568:30 563:29 558:28 553:27 548:26 543:25 538:24 533:23 528:22 523:21 518:20 513:19 506:18 501:17 496:16 491:15 486:14 481:13 476:12 471:11 466:10 348:). 267:) 243:) 219:) 16517:) 16514:☎ 16511:( 16481:⚓ 16437:( 16423:( 16355:( 16339:( 16315:( 16277:( 16260:. 16236:. 16186:( 16151:( 16078:: 16074:@ 16015:​ 15990:. 15974:: 15970:@ 15805:) 15802:☎ 15799:( 15774:) 15771:☎ 15768:( 15743:) 15740:☎ 15737:( 15652:3 15648:2 15644:1 15630:5 15626:4 15622:3 15618:2 15614:1 15556:· 15551:( 15547:" 15532:· 15527:( 15523:" 15487:) 15482:· 15476:· 15470:· 15464:· 15458:· 15452:· 15447:( 15439:) 15434:· 15428:· 15422:· 15416:· 15410:· 15404:· 15399:( 15390:) 15385:· 15379:· 15373:· 15367:· 15361:· 15355:· 15350:( 15335:) 15333:t 15331:/ 15325:t 15323:/ 15321:w 15317:t 15315:/ 15309:t 15307:( 15264:( 15108:( 15093:( 14867:( 14668:( 14603:⚓ 14585:( 14541:@ 14522:( 14492:( 14459:( 14448:: 14444:@ 14433:( 14418:( 14411:: 14407:@ 14396:( 14370:( 14346:( 14340:: 14336:@ 14325:( 14318:: 14314:@ 14303:( 14289:( 14283:: 14279:@ 14268:( 14258:: 14254:@ 14243:( 14230:c 14227:· 14224:t 14221:· 14213:( 14193:: 14189:@ 14118:) 14114:( 14079:( 14051:( 14025:( 14003:( 13973:) 13965:( 13935:) 13927:( 13898:) 13890:( 13858:) 13850:( 13835:) 13827:( 13782:( 13775:. 13720:( 13646:: 13642:@ 13616:/ 13550:( 13302:( 13286:( 13271:( 13240:( 13170:( 13124:( 13105:( 13093:, 13090:, 13074:( 13011:( 12896:( 12840:C 12837:/ 12767:( 12735:( 12632:( 12593:( 12556:/ 12552:/ 12524:( 12501:( 12476:( 12470:: 12466:@ 12458:: 12454:@ 12437:: 12433:@ 12421:( 12200:( 12176:꧂ 12170:꧁ 12135:: 12131:@ 12088:: 12084:@ 12029:( 11923:@ 11874:a 11846:: 11842:@ 11746:7 11741:5 11720:7 11715:5 11694:7 11689:5 11668:7 11663:5 11642:7 11637:5 11616:7 11611:5 11593:7 11588:5 11553:⇒ 11528:⇒ 11503:⇒ 11489:: 11485:@ 11460:⇒ 11454:: 11450:@ 11427:⇒ 11421:: 11417:@ 11395:⇒ 11374:( 11300:( 11272:( 11225:( 11207:( 11177:( 11163:( 11149:( 11134:( 11114:( 11099:( 11014:@ 11004:( 10989:( 10974:( 10959:( 10932:( 10909:( 10894:( 10871:( 10855:( 10830:c 10826:t 10790:( 10774:( 10751:( 10634:@ 10616:( 10586:( 10572:( 10525:( 10485:( 10449:( 10416:( 10390:( 10380:@ 10368:( 10356:@ 10344:( 10310:( 10290:( 10241:@ 10231:( 10219:@ 10209:( 10200:@ 10190:( 10186:. 10165:@ 10155:( 10140:, 10119:( 10101:( 10083:( 10064:( 10050:. 9918:) 9762:( 9751:: 9747:@ 9735:( 9728:: 9724:@ 9705:( 9695:a 9667:@ 9656:( 9632:( 9617:( 9609:@ 9599:( 9585:( 9553:( 9546:: 9542:@ 9531:( 9516:( 9501:( 9479:( 9462:@ 9452:( 9433:( 9415:( 9392:( 9371:( 9354:( 9348:: 9344:@ 9333:( 9302:( 9287:( 9279:@ 9269:( 9254:@ 9244:( 9235:@ 9225:( 9208:@ 9198:( 9178:( 9147:( 9120:( 9103:( 9086:( 9058:( 9043:( 9026:( 9009:( 8987:( 8897:: 8876:: 8872:@ 8842:. 8790:: 8753:: 8730:: 8709:: 8687:: 8620:( 8604:: 8600:@ 8587:( 8562:: 8525:: 8517:: 8513:@ 8502:( 8480:: 8476:@ 8463:( 8453:: 8449:@ 8438:( 8423:. 8413:: 8405:@ 8392:( 8252:( 8223:: 8219:@ 8208:( 8194:: 8190:@ 8175:( 8164:· 8159:( 8149:· 8144:( 8139:: 8135:@ 8122:( 8112:: 8108:@ 8097:( 8079:: 8075:@ 8031:: 8027:@ 8016:( 8003:: 7999:@ 7993:: 7989:@ 7960:( 7954:: 7950:@ 7946:. 7939:* 7933:. 7923:: 7919:@ 7904:( 7894:: 7890:@ 7879:( 7872:: 7868:@ 7857:( 7823:: 7819:@ 7808:( 7791:: 7787:@ 7776:( 7748:( 7524:@ 7413:( 7382:( 7367:( 7350:( 7329:( 7304:( 7242:( 7225:( 7207:( 7192:( 7176:( 7127:( 7099:) 7072:( 7048:( 6981:( 6960:( 6879:( 6820:( 6809:" 6771:( 6527:( 6512:( 6474:( 6444:( 6420:( 6398:( 6382:( 6366:( 6349:( 6342:: 6338:@ 6326:( 6308:( 6299:: 6295:@ 6282:( 6269:: 6265:@ 6253:( 6235:( 6213:( 6191:( 6187:. 6155:( 6121:( 6082:( 6071:( 6049:( 6031:( 5972:( 5951:( 5926:( 5911:( 5889:( 5874:( 5856:( 5821:( 5787:( 5760:( 5709:( 5692:( 5675:" 5655:( 5587:( 5570:@ 5559:( 5531:( 5500:( 5481:( 5390:: 5386:@ 5346:· 5341:( 5304:. 5269:: 5265:@ 5242:: 5238:@ 5174:: 5170:@ 4931:) 4926:· 4920:· 4914:· 4908:· 4902:· 4896:· 4890:· 4885:( 4877:) 4872:· 4866:· 4860:· 4854:· 4848:· 4842:· 4836:· 4831:( 4823:) 4818:· 4812:· 4806:· 4800:· 4794:· 4788:· 4782:· 4777:( 4768:) 4763:· 4757:· 4751:· 4745:· 4739:· 4733:· 4727:· 4722:( 4707:) 4702:· 4696:· 4690:· 4684:· 4678:· 4672:· 4667:( 4659:) 4654:· 4648:· 4642:· 4636:· 4630:· 4624:· 4619:( 4611:) 4606:· 4600:· 4594:· 4588:· 4582:· 4576:· 4571:( 4563:) 4558:· 4552:· 4546:· 4540:· 4534:· 4528:· 4523:( 4515:) 4510:· 4504:· 4498:· 4492:· 4486:· 4480:· 4475:( 4460:) 4455:· 4449:· 4443:· 4437:· 4431:· 4425:· 4420:( 4412:) 4407:· 4401:· 4395:· 4389:· 4383:· 4377:· 4372:( 4364:) 4359:· 4353:· 4347:· 4341:· 4335:· 4329:· 4324:( 4316:) 4311:· 4305:· 4299:· 4293:· 4287:· 4281:· 4276:( 4268:) 4263:· 4257:· 4251:· 4245:· 4239:· 4233:· 4228:( 4220:) 4215:· 4209:· 4203:· 4197:· 4191:· 4185:· 4180:( 4172:) 4167:· 4161:· 4155:· 4149:· 4143:· 4137:· 4132:( 4124:) 4119:· 4113:· 4107:· 4101:· 4095:· 4089:· 4084:( 4076:) 4071:· 4065:· 4059:· 4053:· 4047:· 4041:· 4036:( 4028:) 4023:· 4017:· 4011:· 4005:· 3999:· 3993:· 3988:( 3980:) 3975:· 3969:· 3963:· 3957:· 3951:· 3945:· 3940:( 3932:) 3927:· 3921:· 3915:· 3909:· 3903:· 3897:· 3892:( 3883:) 3878:· 3872:· 3866:· 3860:· 3854:· 3848:· 3843:( 3804:. 3798:) 3796:t 3794:/ 3788:t 3786:/ 3784:w 3780:t 3778:/ 3772:t 3770:( 3729:c 3726:· 3723:t 3720:· 3712:( 3702:@ 3670:( 3656:: 3652:@ 3639:c 3636:· 3633:t 3630:· 3622:( 3604:@ 3592:( 3580:c 3577:· 3574:t 3571:· 3563:( 3555:. 3502:( 3477:( 3318:( 3306:c 3303:· 3300:t 3297:· 3289:( 3273:( 3243:( 3148:c 3145:· 3142:t 3139:· 3131:( 3121:@ 3113:c 3110:· 3107:t 3104:· 3096:( 3056:( 3033:( 3019:( 2735:( 2708:( 2694:@ 2675:( 2608:' 2570:( 2562:@ 2551:( 2536:: 2532:@ 2501:: 2497:@ 2490:: 2486:@ 2469:( 2434:: 2391:. 2385:" 2380:. 2374:" 2367:" 2361:: 2329:: 2286:( 2267:( 2251:: 2247:@ 2236:( 2230:: 2226:@ 2215:( 2205:: 2201:@ 2196:: 2192:@ 2181:( 2164:( 2153:: 2149:@ 2141:: 2137:@ 2134:: 2130:@ 2084:) 2079:· 2073:· 2067:· 2061:· 2055:· 2049:· 2043:· 2038:( 2029:) 2024:· 2018:· 2012:· 2006:· 2000:· 1994:· 1989:( 1960:) 1958:t 1956:/ 1950:t 1948:/ 1946:w 1942:t 1940:/ 1934:t 1932:( 1266:9 1261:8 1256:7 1251:6 1246:5 1241:4 1236:3 1231:2 1226:1 1209:e 1202:t 1195:v 461:9 456:8 451:7 446:6 441:5 436:4 431:3 426:2 421:1 404:e 397:t 390:v 263:( 239:( 215:( 145:) 141:(