537:
525:
110:
130:
196:
440:
959:
103:
674:
90:
459:
120:
36:
140:
100:
150:
402:
its highest category of concern: India–Pakistan and Israel–Palestine. If the precedent is established to invite experts into an ArbCom trial, each side would enlist its own champion advocate in Court TV fashion. The volunteer arbitrators would have to decide who won the battle of experts, despite having no formal qualifications to do so.
398:
the site over to an exclusive club of specialists. Previous experiments have flopped, such as
Nupedia – the predecessor to Knowledge – which required volunteer contributors with appropriate subject matter expertise for every article. That project was shut down in 2003 after producing only 21 articles during its inaugural year.
410:
Harrison reports that some issues in
Knowledge's coverage identified by Graboswki and Klein have since been addressed, due to an injection of new blood in the topic area, although he says this can be a hit-and-miss process given the prevalence of battleground behaviour and cases of entrenched editors
356:
Harrison notes that there are competing historical narratives. According to the one promoted by Poland's current right-wing government, World War II marked "a period when the nation achieved the peak of moral virtue", exemplified by its steadfast refusal to collaborate with the
Germans. Scholars like
291:
The idea of a single world encyclopedia that is available to read everywhere and universally accepted as a reasonable compromise between the world's competing truth claims has both attractive and unattractive sides. What is attractive about it is that it would break up information silos, where people
401:
Contentious issues, moreover, don't cease being contentious when experts are called in, and there are other ways that involving experts in
Knowledge's adjudicative process could backfire in future cases. Consider the two other topics that, along with the Holocaust in Poland, Knowledge has placed in
343:
It is hard to convey the sheer magnitude of the underlying historical tragedies at issue—From 1941 to 1945, Nazi
Germany murdered some 6 million Jews. Roughly half of these victims had resided in Poland, which claimed prewar Europe's largest Jewish population. The Auschwitz complex of concentration
397:
Could experts really save
Knowledge? On the one hand, there is a lot to be said for greater collaboration between scholars and Knowledge; after all, Wiki pages often have far more reach and page views than traditional scholarly papers. But some Wikipedians are understandably cautious about handing
283:
You know that in various formats, on different forums and at different levels, the point of view has been repeatedly expressed that we need to create an equivalent of
Knowledge, and that would contain verified and accurate information, objective information, because we know that there are a lot of
414:
At the end of his article, Harrison notes that some of the editors at the centre of the controversy are vigorously defending their actions in the court of public opinion. He comments on how engaging with such emotive subject matter can be a risky affair, linking to a press report on how
Grabowski
473:
has changed
Twitter's name to X Corp. as well as the corporation's state of registration. Twitter, a Delaware corporation owned by Musk, was merged into X Corp, which is owned by a Nevada holding company X Holdings Corp., which is owned by Musk. Twitter is gone. Only X Corp. and X Holdings Corp.
351:
Polish Jews and the broader nation of Poland were thus victims of previously unimaginable horrors, and acknowledging one tragedy, and the suffering of one population, shouldn't detract from the other. But the historical record remains subject to intense political scrutiny, unresolved wounds, and
744:
Shellenberger characterizes this as the Aspen
Institute "training, or brainwashing, all these journalists to say if something is leaked, we should not cover it in the way that journalists have traditionally covered it." He views it as one of the ways parts of the U.S. government exercise undue
405:
More fundamentally, looping in experts at a content trial would undercut the ethos of Knowledge. The spirit of the site is that volunteer editors curate information by following certain policies, such as using reliable sources. So long as those policies are followed, it's not supposed to make a
255:
Roskomnadzor, the federal service that supervises communications in Russia, recently ordered the deletion of 133 Knowledge pages, claiming the website was anti-Russian and "fake news" for publishing articles containing facts about the war in Ukraine. Now, government and judiciary officials are
263:
Isvestia reported that Knowledge could be the latest non-Russian site to be blocked in the country, and there's little domestic alternative. According to Isvestia, experts estimate Russian versions of online encyclopedias like Runiversalis, Bolshaya Rossyskaya Entsiklopedia (The Great Russian
347:
The suffering of Poland's non-Jewish population was also extraordinary, even by the standards of World War II. Poland was the only nation to be attacked simultaneously by the Third Reich and the Soviet Union, both of whom rejected Poland’s right to exist as a sovereign nation and set about
1049:
374:
Looking at how Knowledge deals with this topic area, Harrison revisits the 2019 story of the "fake Nazi death camp" as one example of misinformation raised by Grabowski and Klein that lasted for more than a decade in Knowledge before being corrected in 2019 (see previous
259:
The Wikimedia Foundation, the supervisory organization of Knowledge, has battled courts in Russia over claims of discrediting the army and feykov (fake news) since June 2022 ... it has amassed a total of R10 million (USD $ 123,305) in fines to date.
225:
800,000 roubles ($ 9,900). Russian news agencies in the courtroom said Wikimedia had been charged with failing to remove materials related to a song by the alternative rock band Psychea, or Psyshit, which has been officially designated "extremist".
371:), sparked the current arbitration case – would like to see greater acknowledgment of the fact that Poland saw some of the same antisemitism that existed elsewhere in Europe and that there were cases of Polish involvement in Jewish suffering.
143:
393:– both university teachers who have worked with Knowledge in the classroom, though they are on opposite sides in this case – as saying that it would be good to have more academics contributing to Knowledge. Harrison is sceptical, however:
113:
517:
324:
153:
299:
But whatever one may think of the idea, it seems unlikely to be realised anytime soon. Not least because some governments are unwilling to accept anything less than complete suppression of some viewpoints. –
419:
Their situation serves as a stark reminder that the boundary between "real" life and Knowledge activity can be perilously thin, and that engaging with this painful history poses risks for everyone involved.
133:
242:
2 million rubles ($ 24,464) for not removing a Knowledge article titled “Russian occupation of the Zaporizhzhia region,” a reference to one of four Ukrainian provinces that Russia annexed last September.
794:
with representatives from major technology companies and U.S. government agencies to share insights and discuss ways they are addressing potential disinformation issues in relation to the election." –
723:
in the run-up to the 2020 US presidential elections. The exercise, described as essentially a Zoom call, allegedly looked at how best to mitigate any upcoming, Russian-inspired controversy concerning
382:). He also explains that addressing such cases is made more difficult by the fact that Knowledge's arbitration committee is not permitted to rule on content but can only decide conduct disputes.
70:
415:
himself was taken to court in Poland over some of his academic writing and noting that some of the editors with whom Grabowski and Klein disagree are reporting sustained off-wiki harassment.
890:
1085:
Elon Musk has essentially shown why you shouldn't use Knowledge as a source. In all honesty, Elon Musk is basically an example of everything you should not do if you control something. ―
775:, centering it around a fictitious leaks website releasing "doctored documents, appearing to allege that perhaps we don’t know the full truth about Hunter Biden’s role with the company"
578:. According to Becker, after the adoption of the current flag in 1929, it was used in diverging versions for years, and even today, due to what he gently criticizes as a failure by the
348:
eliminating the country’s political, cultural, and military elites. More than 2 million non-Jewish Poles are estimated to have perished during the war, which left the country in ruins.
296:
it is reported. However, there is also an obvious downside involved in having such a global reference source – over the years, it might easily become too monopolistic and monolithic.
1102:
Quite. Whenever I see criticisms of the WMF or Jimbo, I always think "things really aren't bad. Things could be a lot worse." We now have a case study of how much worse it could be.
76:
557:
998:
1064:
1028:
1018:
745:
influence on media and tech companies, including the Wikimedia Foundation – based on the fact that the Aspen Institute has received government funding, although the
631:, too. But @depthsofwiki should have scrolled down to Britannica's "Vatican City" article which has a white-disked flag – E.B. gives an unexplained split decision.
1023:
884:). The original study's authors have reportedly rejected Humphreys' main criticisms while welcoming further discussion of their findings. The story is covered by
536:
336:
123:
1038:
1013:
983:
787:
698:
946:
937:
881:
379:
332:
188:
976:
30:
Contested truth claims in Knowledge: Covering Russia, Poland, the Vatican, the U.S., and the "perilously thin" boundary between real life and Knowledge.
925:
1111:
993:
970:
570:
in 2017 which lasted as the main Knowledge illustration of the flag through 2022. It quotes Father William Becker, of the St. Columbanus Parish in
55:
44:
214:
1003:
586:
to fill), "a flagmaker is likely to go to a source like Knowledge, and it may vary in its accuracy." The official Vatican City website does give
749:
article points out that the non-profit is also "funded by donors such as the Carnegie Corporation, the Gates Foundation, the Ford Foundation".
1033:
896:
308:
1125:
1096:
1008:
843:
1192:
231:
877:
claims to have debunked last year's study that concluded Knowledge was influencing Irish judges' reasoning and language use (see previous
598:
320:
478:
497:. Knowledge first published the news five-and-a-half hours after Slate at 2:01 UTC, April 11. A non-notable, unreliable crypto blog,
1069:
666:
757:
614:
21:
756:
characterizing it as a "startling finding", the (apparently) same tabletop exercise had already been covered in an October 2020
1168:
1076:
272:
93:
920:
Do you want to contribute to "In the media" by writing a story or even just an "in brief" item? Edit our next edition in the
844:
Elon Musk says Twitter is using a Knowledge list to help decide which news organizations are labeled 'government-funded media'
451:
1163:
1158:
921:
857:
853:
719:
that the Wikimedia Foundation and various newspapers and tech companies took part in a "tabletop exercise" conducted by the
498:
385:
Harrison argues that there is something "deeply unsatisfying" about this dichotomy, but he sees no easy solution. He quotes
791:
692:, alleges undue influence by parts of the U.S. government on media and tech companies, including the Wikimedia Foundation.
501:
cited Knowledge as one of their sources at about 5:00 UTC April 11. Musk's first mention of the news seems to have been a
1153:
547:, which includes moon rocks and the explanation "This flag of your state was carried to the Moon and back by Apollo 11"
1053:
363:
681:
502:
486:
728:
1137:
1148:
958:
587:
49:
35:
17:
639:
571:
874:
288:
Once such an alternative exists, Peskov said, it would make sense to talk about banning Knowledge.
833:
703:
623:
292:
on one side of the earth don't even know what news is reported to people on the other side, and
264:
Encyclopedia), and Znanie (Knowledge) will only begin to compete with Knowledge in a few years.
685:
885:
618:
610:
602:
1121:
712:
689:
248:
1174:
1091:
870:
716:
563:
553:
524:
518:
Who is to blame for wrong Vatican flags – Knowledge? Britannica? NASA? the Vatican itself?
8:
1107:
819:
708:
647:
606:
628:
559:
Knowledge had the wrong Vatican City flag for years. Now incorrect flags are everywhere
727:. The article says the exercise took place in June 2020, about four months before the
1060:
733:
654:
sitting next to a red disk flag on a 1998 state visit to Italy. So who's to blame? –
651:
506:
432:
167:
1117:
848:
482:
235:
582:
to "make some design specifications more available" online (a gap that he created
1086:
902:
806:
772:
720:
656:
511:
179:
406:
difference whether experts are actually involved in the article-making process.
1103:
780:
544:
481:
dated April 4, but the document was apparently not noticed by the media until
386:
368:
1186:
796:
786:
Later in October 2020, the Wikimedia Foundation had published a post titled "
768:
566:. The CNA article says that a Wikipedian added a red disk at the base of the
426:
358:
302:
276:
163:
439:
724:
390:
202:
816:
635:
567:
195:
673:
494:
485:
published the story on April 10 at 20:29 UTC (4:29 PM New York time).
823:
800:
660:
646:
in 1969, which was put on display in the Vatican Museum. And a later
643:
470:
269:
175:
771:
described himself as having co-organized the exercise together with
579:
575:
210:
The Wikimedia Foundation has received another two fines in Russia.
171:
790:
which among other things mentioned how "specific members of are
776:
218:
458:
344:
and extermination camps was located in Poland, as were others.
1116:
Washington Examiner doing the "mainstream bad" thing again. --
583:
779:(motivated by concerns about how the media had handled the
860:
738:
591:
247:
Russianlife.com, a site critical of Russia's government,
783:
leak in the run-up to the 2016 presidential election).
493:
responded to a question about the deal, but only with a
339:). Commenting on the historical context, Harrison says:
601:
for bringing the issue to their attention. It was also
1133:
Get the latest headlines on your user page – just add
788:
How Knowledge is preparing for the 2020 U.S. Election"
256:
discussing a possible ban on the online encyclopedia.
741:had taken possession of Biden's abandoned laptop.
505:
at 7:03 UTC, April 11, "X". For further details see
1074:If your comment has not appeared here, you can try
900:. Humphreys has published a summary article in the
634:However, the Reddit discussion, which started this
531:
Currently displayed flag, after corrections in 2022
906:and submitted the full paper by invitation to the
642:that NASA had sent a red disk flag to the moon on
1184:
908:Cambridge Handbook of Experimental Jurisprudence
556:has appeared throughout the world according to
543:The allegedly wrong flag in an exhibit in the
325:World War II and the history of Jews in Poland
856:is used to guide decision-making at Twitter.
813:Podcast on diversity in Knowledge biographies
189:More fines for Wikimedia Foundation in Russia
161:
858:But look away from the elephant in the room:
205:and Knowledge do not exactly see eye to eye
822:with scientist and Knowledge personality
840:Who's "government-funded"? Ask Knowledge
1093:
1077:
14:
1185:
323:about the ongoing arbitration case on
854:Category:Publicly funded broadcasters
477:Twitter first revealed the move in a
54:
29:
1193:Knowledge Signpost archives 2023-04
767:'s laptop story broke). Its author
763:(published about a week before the
71:Contested truth claims in Knowledge
27:
957:
867:Irish judges controversy continues
815:: Economist and media personality
737:, but about half a year after the
672:
588:an illustration without a red disk
535:
523:
457:
452:Twitter X'd, Knowledge scoops Musk
438:
194:
56:
34:
28:
1204:
1059:These comments are automatically
667:Alleged U.S. government influence
364:The Journal of Holocaust Research
312:covers Holocaust arbitration case
465:A poop emoji as shown on Twitter
238:and others, the WMF was fined –
221:and others, the WMF was fined –
148:
138:
128:
118:
108:
98:
88:
367:, co-written with Shira Klein (
1070:add the page to your watchlist
590:, albeit as a somewhat grainy
352:understandable sensitivities.
13:
1:
597:Father Becker and CNA credit
411:being hostile to newcomers.
1045:
852:– according to the article,
615:past "citogenesis" incidents
611:put the issue in the context
18:Knowledge:Knowledge Signpost
7:
572:Blooming Prairie, Minnesota
10:
1209:
1126:20:42, 27 April 2023 (UTC)
1112:21:07, 29 April 2023 (UTC)
1097:17:19, 26 April 2023 (UTC)
830:Five games about Knowledge
284:distortions on Knowledge.
820:hosts a podcast interview
729:Hunter Biden laptop story
680:American writer and past
629:their version of the flag
627:includes the red disk in
446:Try to top these scoops!
704:The Washington Examiner
650:to @depthsofwiki shows
624:Encyclopedia Britannica
576:a book on Vatican flags
552:A bogus version of the
1067:. To follow comments,
962:
924:or leave a tip on the
686:Governor of California
677:
599:a March 22 Reddit post
540:
528:
462:
443:
422:
408:
354:
286:
268:Pakistani news outlet
266:
245:
228:
199:
39:
1138:Signpost-subscription
961:
713:Michael Shellenberger
690:Michael Shellenberger
676:
539:
527:
461:
442:
417:
395:
341:
281:
253:
240:
223:
198:
38:
1063:from this article's
717:Joe Rogan Experience
564:Catholic News Agency
554:flag of Vatican City
316:Stephen Harrison in
230:And on 13 April, as
607:Depths of Knowledge
503:single letter Tweet
1054:Discuss this story
999:Arbitration report
963:
678:
541:
529:
463:
444:
275:Kremlin spokesman
200:
45:← Back to Contents
40:
1078:purging the cache
1029:From the archives
1019:News from the WMF
930:
875:Richard Humphreys
836:by Makeuseof.com.
792:regularly meeting
734:The New York Post
652:Pope John Paul II
361:– whose paper in
50:View Latest Issue
1200:
1177:
1142:
1136:
1081:
1079:
1073:
1052:
1024:Featured content
981:
973:
966:
950:"In the media" →
949:
941:
926:suggestions page
918:
897:Irish Legal News
863:is on that list.
849:Business Insider
803:
663:
514:
429:
305:
236:Associated Press
182:
152:
151:
142:
141:
132:
131:
122:
121:
112:
111:
102:
101:
92:
91:
62:
60:
58:
1208:
1207:
1203:
1202:
1201:
1199:
1198:
1197:
1183:
1182:
1181:
1180:
1179:
1178:
1173:
1171:
1166:
1161:
1156:
1151:
1144:
1140:
1134:
1130:
1129:
1095:
1094:Blaze Wolf#6545
1083:
1075:
1068:
1057:
1056:
1050:+ Add a comment
1048:
1044:
1043:
1042:
974:
969:
967:
964:
953:
952:
947:
944:
939:
933:
932:
931:
903:Irish Law Times
809:
795:
773:Vivian Schiller
721:Aspen Institute
694:
693:
670:
669:
655:
638:business, also
584:his own website
549:
548:
533:
532:
521:
520:
510:
467:
466:
455:
454:
448:
447:
436:
435:
425:
314:
301:
213:On 6 April, as
207:
206:
192:
191:
184:
183:
160:
159:
158:
149:
139:
129:
119:
109:
99:
89:
83:
80:
69:
65:
63:
53:
52:
47:
41:
31:
26:
25:
24:
12:
11:
5:
1206:
1196:
1195:
1172:
1167:
1162:
1157:
1152:
1147:
1146:
1145:
1132:
1131:
1128:
1115:
1114:
1058:
1055:
1047:
1046:
1041:
1039:Traffic report
1036:
1031:
1026:
1021:
1016:
1014:Special report
1011:
1006:
1001:
996:
991:
986:
984:News and notes
980:
968:
956:
955:
954:
945:
942:"In the media"
936:
935:
934:
917:
915:
914:
912:
911:
864:
837:
827:
808:
805:
781:Podesta emails
695:
684:candidate for
679:
671:
668:
665:
550:
545:Vatican Museum
542:
534:
530:
522:
519:
516:
487:Slate reported
479:court document
468:
464:
456:
453:
450:
449:
445:
437:
434:
431:
369:User:Chapmansh
327:(see previous
313:
307:
208:
201:
193:
190:
187:
186:
185:
157:
156:
146:
136:
126:
116:
106:
96:
85:
84:
81:
75:
74:
73:
72:
67:
66:
64:
61:
48:
43:
42:
33:
32:
15:
9:
6:
4:
3:
2:
1205:
1194:
1191:
1190:
1188:
1176:
1170:
1165:
1160:
1155:
1150:
1139:
1127:
1123:
1119:
1113:
1109:
1105:
1101:
1100:
1099:
1098:
1092:
1090:
1089:
1080:
1071:
1066:
1062:
1051:
1040:
1037:
1035:
1032:
1030:
1027:
1025:
1022:
1020:
1017:
1015:
1012:
1010:
1007:
1005:
1002:
1000:
997:
995:
992:
990:
987:
985:
982:
978:
972:
971:26 April 2023
965:In this issue
960:
951:
943:
929:
927:
923:
916:
909:
905:
904:
899:
898:
893:
892:
887:
883:
880:
876:
872:
868:
865:
862:
859:
855:
851:
850:
845:
841:
838:
835:
831:
828:
825:
821:
818:
814:
811:
810:
804:
802:
798:
793:
789:
784:
782:
778:
774:
770:
769:Garrett Graff
766:
765:New York Post
762:
760:
755:
750:
748:
742:
740:
736:
735:
730:
726:
722:
718:
714:
710:
706:
705:
700:
691:
687:
683:
675:
664:
662:
658:
653:
649:
645:
641:
637:
632:
630:
626:
625:
620:
616:
612:
608:
604:
600:
595:
593:
589:
585:
581:
577:
573:
569:
565:
561:
560:
555:
546:
538:
526:
515:
513:
508:
504:
500:
496:
492:
488:
484:
480:
475:
472:
460:
441:
430:
428:
421:
416:
412:
407:
403:
399:
394:
392:
388:
383:
381:
378:
372:
370:
366:
365:
360:
359:Jan Grabowski
353:
349:
345:
340:
338:
334:
330:
326:
322:
319:
311:
306:
304:
297:
295:
289:
285:
280:
278:
277:Dmitry Peskov
274:
271:
265:
261:
257:
252:
250:
244:
239:
237:
233:
227:
222:
220:
216:
211:
204:
197:
181:
177:
173:
169:
165:
164:Andreas Kolbe
155:
147:
145:
137:
135:
127:
125:
117:
115:
107:
105:
97:
95:
87:
86:
78:
59:
57:26 April 2023
51:
46:
37:
23:
19:
1087:
1084:
989:In the media
988:
977:all comments
919:
913:
907:
901:
895:
889:
878:
866:
847:
839:
829:
812:
785:
764:
758:
753:
752:Despite the
751:
746:
743:
732:
725:Hunter Biden
702:
696:
636:red hat-ring
633:
622:
619:pointing out
596:
574:, who wrote
558:
551:
490:
476:
469:
423:
418:
413:
409:
404:
400:
396:
384:
376:
373:
362:
355:
350:
346:
342:
328:
317:
315:
309:
298:
293:
290:
287:
282:
267:
262:
258:
254:
246:
241:
229:
224:
212:
209:
203:Roskomnadzor
168:Bluerasberry
94:PDF download
68:In the media
1175:Suggestions
1118:Firestar464
1061:transcluded
891:Independent
817:Tyler Cowen
568:Papal tiara
279:as saying:
144:X (Twitter)
1088:Blaze Wolf
871:High Court
682:Democratic
507:"not news"
495:poop emoji
433:Top scoops
331:coverage:
180:Smallbones
82:Share this
77:Contribute
22:2023-04-26
1169:Subscribe
1104:Blythwood
1065:talk page
834:presented
824:Jess Wade
731:broke in
644:Apollo 11
640:uncovered
562:from the
474:remain.
471:Elon Musk
387:Chapmansh
270:UrduPoint
1187:Category
1164:Newsroom
1159:Archives
994:Obituary
940:Previous
922:Newsroom
882:coverage
879:Signpost
873:justice
869:: Irish
807:In brief
754:Examiner
747:Examiner
711:made by
617:, while
580:Holy See
499:CoinGape
380:coverage
377:Signpost
329:Signpost
232:reported
215:reported
134:Facebook
124:LinkedIn
114:Mastodon
20: |
1004:Opinion
777:Burisma
761:article
715:on the
699:article
603:covered
594:image.
491:Twitter
391:Piotrus
219:Reuters
1034:Humour
709:claims
707:cites
609:, who
321:writes
273:quotes
178:, and
154:Reddit
104:E-mail
1154:About
1009:Op-Ed
832:: As
759:Wired
648:reply
621:that
489:that
483:Slate
318:Slate
310:Slate
16:<
1149:Home
1122:talk
1108:talk
948:Next
894:and
509:. –
389:and
249:says
176:HaeB
886:RTE
861:NPR
739:FBI
701:in
697:An
613:of
605:by
592:JPG
294:how
234:by
217:by
172:Bri
162:By
79:—
1189::
1141:}}
1135:{{
1124:)
1110:)
938:←
888:,
846:–
842::
799:,
797:AK
688:,
659:,
427:AK
424:–
335:,
303:AK
251::
174:,
170:,
166:,
1143:.
1120:(
1106:(
1082:.
1072:.
979:)
975:(
928:.
910:.
826:.
801:H
661:H
657:S
512:S
337:2
333:1
Text is available under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License. Additional terms may apply.
