Knowledge:Peer review/Kolkata/archive1

726:

tension between the refugees and the residents during the Bangladeh liberation war. However, the tension never amounted to any siginificant sort of violence. It would be satisfying to include that piece of information, I am looking for a solid reference. The most brutal of the riots, i.e. the 1992-93 riots has been stated. Do you think more expansion needed on that? I do not think so as the article is already getting alarmingly bigger in size, as more info is being put. The only othet tension I found out was during the

1076:(note how they incorporate crime stats and other negative info). On the other hand, I don't think there's a big problem with "whitewashing" in this article — as long as slum stats, crime, poverty rates, etc are dealt with, you don't need to worry about including every negative epithet used for the city. Other than doing light copy-editing (I've done some) and the advice given by others, I don't have much to add. This is getting close to featured status, and we can have (LOL) three Bengal-related FACs ( 1229:. The locator map, and a city map - we are working on that, as I have indicated in your talk page. Addition of fire brigade in the Utility and modification of "Education" will be done. An iconic photo will be a delight to add, but have not found one yet. Please feel free to crop the howrah bridge photo as you think necessary. The size of the article is a concern now, that's why we did not add info like the names of the 14 boroughs , neighbourhoods etc. Thanks a lot for your review. Bye.-- 615:: The request to merge the two was bourne out of the fact that neither section, as it stood at the time of my review, looked comprehensive enough to stand independently. There is no harm in separating the two, provided both sections are adequately expanded. On the other hand, I merged Utilities within Civic Administration in Bangalore because the provision of utility services by the municapity and other governmental bodies falls under the Civic administration umbrella. 317:, I am sorry if I have hurt you. Beleive me, the comment was not sarcasm as it seemed to you. I revere you as one of the oldest and most experienced wikipedian. And sorry for another mistake I committed , it was a disgraceful typo: I typed "Subjective" in stead of intended "objective". LoL. Please excuse me. And thanks a lot again for your extremely objective and careful review.-- 1132:

unit is not the most accessible form of expressing a number (but I suspect nearly everyone can understand what "1,400,000" means, opposed to "14 lakhs"). Second, the Density seems to be missing a unit. If it means 11,000 people/km², then say that. "People" is just as much a valid unit as meters or stones or apples. --

918:

This gives the impression that the city just sort of came to be and is now growing, bereft of any planning..which is obviously not true. I do not know a whole lot about Kolkata but based on what I have read from the history section and the old Tourism section, there was some city planning involved. I

37:

The article has improved a lot in last few months, especially during the last week when it was the Indian COTW. The size has been greatly reduced from the previous monstrous size, forks have been created, new template has been added, references and relevant images added. However, the article deviates

1207:

Calcutta University's turn of the century heritage should also probably be touched upon in the education section, and the reason for construction of BESU, JU and ISI. A short paragraph highlighting some information, rather than a list of college and university names which conveys little information.

1181:

The article mentions 14 boroughs. Should that be spelt out with small annotations ? I think a complete article on Calcutta, in the section on Geography, should have a subsection on neighbourhoods. I think it should also spell out the five informal regions that Kolkata is made up of - North, Central,

1131:

I have two small suggestions for the infobox. First, in population replace "lakh" with a raw number. No other figure in the infobox uses that combination of number and word, and as the infobox is supposed to be a quick reference tool (to avoid weeding through prose to get a simple figure) the "lakh"

1097:

Crime stats have been added, to some extent. Some "negative" statements like the depressive economy in 1970s and 1980s have been added. Unreferenced statement on people living in streets and footpath have also been added. Poverty rates could not be added due to lack of reference. Copyedits are going

1012:

I hope that things are not cut down for the sake of cutting down. I am not from Kolkata and I really like the details in the culture section. It shows the unique aspects of Kolkata from other Indian cities. I reckon it can be made a little shorter but I am not sure how. Only thing I can think of

832:

Several factors like labour troubles since the end of 1960s such as the predominence of trade-unions in the industries, severe power shortages, limitations on raw materials, shortage of capital, a slow depletion of water volume in the Hugli River limiting the size of ships at Kolkata’s docks. led to

1196:

Kolkata in art - should this be in culture or media. Probably maybe not even in the main article but in the subsidiary articles. But artistic depictions of Kolkata have led Indian urban artistic depictions, in much the same way NYC street photography led and still leads street photography the world

1203:

In the Utility Services section, the Fire Services should be mentioned. Since quite a few notable Kolkata heritage buildings succumbed to flames ( Bourne & Shephard, Firpo's, New Market) I think a brief mention of its lack of capability to tackle the difficult job of fighting fire in an old,

1060:

I have a feeling that the article does not indicate the so many negative aspects of the city. For example, the poverty, the slums, the indifferent nature of the common man etc. The sobriquet "dying city" is also not there in the article any more. Can you suggest where to or how to integrate such

1188:

Dare I suggest this when I know so little about it myself - how about a section on Kolkata architecture ? Mix of the old and the new, the distinctive facading of British Calcutta, North Calcutta, South Calcutta and Salt Lake, the recent explosion of overbridges (this is one thing I did not find

725:

has been covered under "History" and thought it would be a repeat to expand on it under "Demographics". That is why the words "after independence" were added along with the referenced comment on the relative communal peace in Kolkata. I do not have any ready reference, but I know that there was

279:

The above post could very well be read as sarcasm. I really don't need to defend myself against "subjective comments" as I've always had the best interests in the improvement of articles -- me being a perfectionist. To answer your query: 1) =Tourism= is extremely subjective. We have a dedicated

1192:

I strongly think that trivia should be the penultimate subsection before References. A full trivia section could be a separate article, but more interesting and illuminating facts and figures could be touched upon. It helps end an article smoothly too, albeit at the risk of making it

284:

which takes care of the tourism aspect. The article is an encyclopedia and should not be read like a tourist brochure. Important points of tourism such as museums can be easily merged with culture. 2) I was asked to review the Canberra article by the nominator before it was featured.

42:). The article yet needs some more references and maybe some more yet unmentioned aspects. Of course, Kolkata needs some copyedit also as errors continue to creep in. The language has been tried to be made NPOV as far as possible. Please help enhancing the article. Thank you.-- 704:

to a lot more instances of ethnic/religious/communal incidents than has been discussed in the article. What about the Bengali refugees that the city took in prior to and during the Indo-Pak 1971 War..was there tension between them and the citizens? You can expand on

824:

Great job, Dwaipayanc — I like the way things are taking shape. The biggest problem now with the article relates to copyediting. I will list the various issues below. Let us cleanup the article a couple of sections at a time. Below is my primary review. Thanks

1174:

A map of Calcutta with not too much detail, and which is not too touristy, listing the major neighborhoods, the bridges, the rail lines, and arterial roads of Kolkata and Howrah. (tall demand, I know - but it would be good even to get some approximation of

1071:

You can craft the most alarming or important negative aspects (slums, suicide, unemployment, etc) into a one-sentence description in the lead while relegating less important negative details to "Demographics". You can have a look at

627:: Now the civic administration is undergoing some expansion. Utility services need more matter. If we fail to provide the Utility services with more fact, we'll definitely ponder over merging the two. Thanks for pointing out.-- 455:"I don't think it is needed to increase for the sake of increasing. If somebody thinks that some vital/ important information has not been discussed under the section "Name" he/ she is welcome to modify the section."-- 326:

No grudges taken, but I request you to work on what I have reviewed. Those Culture subsections need to go, history made more fluid, tourism needs to go. On completion please let me know so that I can deep review.

1200:

Being very finicky as a photographer, I think the photograph of the Howrah Bridge should be slightly edited. It is a lovely shot - but to perfect it , it would need to be rotated and probably slightly cropped.

364:

states the name of Howrah bridge. We can remove the word "port" if others agree. Thanks. BTW, deleted the info on first railway between Calcutta and Diamond harbour - as no credible sources available. --

836:

Please rephrase this sentence. Perhaps break it up into two; there are so many commas in the sentence that one tends to lose track of what the central theme of the sentence being presented is.

1163:

I think the present state of the article is fantastic, having at one point of time worked on the article single-handedly (and very badly may I add) myself. I have a few suggestions though.

467:: I agree. The point that I was trying to make though was if there is more relevent, pertinent information out there that relates to the origins of the city's name, it should be included. 1013:

is that the architecture section does not fit very nicely in there. However, since tourism was nixed their is no other place for that important information. Maybe in ubran structure? --

270:( which is an FA). You would perhaps cite the Indian city format. But in any case, that is not a hard and fast rule! Please comment and help improve the article. Thanks a lot.-- 1167:

The map in the infobox - is that part of the template for Indian cities ? I find the colours very distracting and unmeaningful. I would much rather prefer a map template as in

1225:

Certain suggestions by you (like sub-sectioning the culture, adding trivia, adding Kolkata in art etc.)cannot be done as that would not be appropriate by the rule laid out in

487:

The then ruler of Bengal Siraj Ud Daulah attacked the Fort William at Kolkata due to various percieved provocations by the British, such as improving the city's fortifications

504:). Perhaps the anon wanted to make the view point of British clear. We retained his insertions after a bit of modification. This may need further rephrasing."-- 666: 607: 205: 1233: 993: 909: 779: 686: 573: 557: 187: 175: 119: 1155: 541: 514: 1102: 1092: 1034: 1017: 734: 713: 619: 1178:

I read the conversation about subsectioning culture. I personally feel that the culture section is too much of a pot-pourri and should be subsectioned.

1124: 459: 401: 368: 338: 321: 308: 274: 266:(2) I disagree with you that section "Culture" should not have subsections. There are so many city articles with subsections in "Culture".For example, 78: 1139: 944: 811: 751: 631: 471: 181:=Culture= section should not have subsections. "Please specify reason why Culture should not have subsections." Summarise and remove list material 1189:

mentioned in the transport section), the historic facade preservation row, maybe these warrant a separate article, but a section would also be good.

427: 360:

for futher references. However, nowhere it is mentioned that bombing was specifically done on the Calcutta port, whereas the personal account of

38:

at some portion from the recommended Indian city formats, though the deviations are not unprecedented (compared to other city articles like

529:

Please rephrase and/or delete — this is a situation that most cities in developing countries face. I don't think it is specific to Kolkata.

1219: 1065: 878: 257:(1) Why do you always make it sure that "Tourism" is not included? (I have seen you reccomending this before). Is it a Knowledge rule? 1185:

An iconic photo would help - skyline from Maidan or Hooghly, or even the controlled access ramp system and the Second Hooghly Bridge.

1120:

The problem is we could not find out one good free skyline pic. There was one previously, but the quality was not really good. Bye.--

1114: 1050: 286: 730:

movement, that has been touched in the "History" section, and that seems not be related to "Demographics" much. Please comment.--

862:

Can we perhaps further explain the correlation between human habitation and the establishment of trees and shrubs in the region?

397:. However, is that very strict rule? Or, is it possible to incorporate such content under other sections? Please help. Thanks.-- 115:: Having trouble rewriting the history. Need more references and a nice flow of language. Please help. Tried to include 1800s.-- 46: 596:" Please specify why do you wanr to merge Utilities aith civic administrations. Thses 2 subsections have been kept seperate 228: 1226: 394: 940:

Please address the commets noted above. Like I said, let us copyedit the article a couple of sections at a time. Thanks

901:- "sentence removed, as this parameter did not seem much important and difficult to explain. Check out about what it is 1211:

Copyediting - overuse of the article, particularly preceding proper nouns. Some of them can probably be done away with.

111:

The history needs a good rewrite. We can't just have the "firsts" in India. 1800-1870 seems to have escaped a mention.

982: 932:

This would just be North Kolkata...or the north Kolkata locality..ditto for The South Kolkata and the Central Kolkata

500:"well, this has a bit of history itself! 139.168.93.82 inserted the words "perceived" and some more ( detailed 649: 393:(under gross heading of People and culture) etc. I know the section "Tourism" is against the rules laid out in 378: 769:

section about the city's history in the 1950s-60s as well as 80s and 90s. Some information needs to be added.

21: 819: 85:

Good start and I sincerely hope this article can get featured. But I have lots of issues with this article.

60:

would be apericiable. Other than these two sections all are nicely covered. Some images are licensed under

352:

is a nice reference to bombing of Kolkata by Japanese. I have added that as a reference. Please also see

1073: 967:

documents the city's history pretty well. I'm sure there must be some good information available there.

501: 807:

I will post some additional comments when these issues are addressed. Thanks and good luck y'all!

373:

Many City articles, including FAs, have section "Tourism" or section like "Tourism". For example,

1215:

Again - overall, I think the present status of the article is just great! Keep up the good work!

657: 1002:

in the article, I'll copyedit later. Stuff on the Calcutta High Court, the stock exchange etc.

902: 848:

I would break this up into two sentences as well...There are natural depressions in the area,

648:

Add city development, infrastructural issues within the Civic Administration section. I found

958:

I've copyedited it a bit, but I still need you to go through the following before I continue:

138: 17: 986: 108:-- I'd like to see a credible source. -- "Provisionally removed as no credible source found" 887:

I understand the idea that you are trying to present here, but perhaps it can be rephrased?

747:

community. I shall try to fit in the information, some reference would be helpful though.--

535:

In transport, unbold Circular rail and metro railway. Create a stub for Kolkata Port Trust.

390: 8: 1081: 444:

section? Dosen't have to be by too much — just another couple of sentences would suffice.

248:. We shall try to mend the defects you have pointed out. However, I have 2 points to ask: 414:

3) It complies with the standards set out in the style manual and relevant WikiProjects.

374: 1045: 964: 722: 706: 489:. What does this sentence mean? I can't understand what its trying to say...rephrase? 422: 333: 303: 290: 223: 569:"Deleted due to rephrasing difficulty and relative unnecessity of the information"-- 1216: 845:

while there are some natural depressions in the area, probably dead river channels.

357: 676:

standpoint, you might want to discuss religious/ethnic disharmony/tensions in the

53: 1230: 1152: 1121: 1099: 1062: 990: 906: 875: 776: 772: 748: 731: 683: 663: 628: 604: 570: 554: 551:

section is a little choppy. Please merge 1-2 sentence paragraphs to promote flow.

538: 511: 505: 456: 409: 398: 386: 365: 318: 294: 271: 202: 184: 172: 116: 43: 30: 1197:

over. Desmand Doig, Rathin Mitra, the Daniel(l) brothers or cousins or whatever.

660:

stub and link directly to that. Don't link to external links within the article.

1133: 437:: Hi, pretty neat job so far. I'm going to list my concerns/suggestions below: 64: 353: 1089: 1031: 1014: 740: 739:

P.S. As a matter of fact, another smaller riot occured- after the killing of

673: 1111: 1040: 775:

07:28, 28 March 2006 (UTC) "History section needs a thourough re-write".--

701: 527:

Kolkata is an unplanned city that developed as per the need of the citizen.

417: 382: 328: 314: 298: 237: 218: 71: 860:

Human habitation has led to the establishment of mature trees and shrubs.

941: 808: 710: 616: 468: 361: 349: 154:=Climate= needs more references for figures. Extreme temperatures needed. 1171:, neat and immediately focussing the user's eye on the desired location. 1110:

I just have one comment. A city article should have a skyline picture.--

1077: 802:

section so long as the verbiage is encyclopedic and the content is NPOV

281: 57: 1168: 582: 1208:

Such a list would be better off in the Kolkata - related topics box.

289:) The subheadings were added much later and I supported the article 211:

Please remove all but the most famous institutions from =Education=.

105:

India's first railway was built between Diamond Harbour and Calcutta

1193:

un-encyclopaedic. Currently, I think the article ends too abruptly.

727: 267: 39: 1085: 245: 31: 804:. Per Nichalp's discussion above, this section should be perged. 389:(as a subsection "Arractions" under "Culture and attractions"), 381:(under the subsection of "Sites of Interest', under "Culture"), 973:

References needed for climate figures. Use non breaking spaces

600: 167: 1026:

I've embedded a few comments in the text, please address it.

1005:

Culture needs to be cut down. - "Started to cut down culture"

870:

The approximate °F value for all temperatures must be noted.

884:

The main seasonal influence upon the climate is the monsoon.

981:- All the figures in climate is taken from two references: 899:

I would explain the values noted and wikify where necessary

744: 297:

mentions that the ToC should not be overwhelming. Regards,

915:

Kolkata is an unplanned city and with an area of 185 km²..

199:==Tourism== section needs to be removed from the article. 217:

Further review after completion of the above. Regards,

70:. I am not sure with this tag, is it suitable to them. 919:

don't know if I would use the phrase "unplanned city".

700:: Umm, you will have to dwell deeper into the matter. 680:

section, or in any other section you find appropriate.

970:

The vehicle code(s) needs to be added in the infobox.

567:? Can we rephrase and/or find a more suitable phrase? 977:between a unit and its numeral. (I've done a few). 97:

Lead should summarise the article. Copyedit needed.

833:the economic decline of the city in 1960s to 1980s 682:"Provisionally done, with reference. Please see"-- 578:Please merge Utilities with Civic Administration 100:Avoid specific dates in ==History=. "In process" 1028:I took care of one of the comments that I found 784:A nice map of the city would work wonderfully. 510:" Rephrased and removed debatable portion".-- 244:objective and extremely specific review of 788:Sub-sections do not look appropriate for 129:please reference. I've never heard of it. 160:Mention the districts Kolkata comprises 52:Very nice. Some work on sections, like 14: 709:here..you may want to look into that. 125:city's port was bombed by the Japanese 1227:Knowledge:WikiProject Indian cities 27: 1088:) up for review at the same time. 92:Avoid the use of specific figures. 28: 1245: 896:Mean ventilation coefficients... 166:=Civic Administration= refer to 193:remove list material in =Media= 1182:South, Salt Lake and New Town. 13: 1: 852:probably dead river channels. 792:. Please summarize and merge. 356:and the December 20 entry in 90:Lead needs to be smoothened. 7: 652:that might pertain to this. 10: 1250: 1093:08:08, 31 March 2006 (UTC) 1074:Chetwynd, British Columbia 1066:05:33, 31 March 2006 (UTC) 1051:09:44, 30 March 2006 (UTC) 1018:17:45, 31 March 2006 (UTC) 994:06:02, 31 March 2006 (UTC) 945:22:05, 29 March 2006 (UTC) 910:05:43, 31 March 2006 (UTC) 879:06:02, 31 March 2006 (UTC) 812:19:25, 26 March 2006 (UTC) 780:20:07, 27 March 2006 (UTC) 752:03:57, 28 March 2006 (UTC) 735:03:53, 28 March 2006 (UTC) 714:03:08, 28 March 2006 (UTC) 687:11:12, 27 March 2006 (UTC) 667:08:34, 27 March 2006 (UTC) 632:03:53, 28 March 2006 (UTC) 620:03:08, 28 March 2006 (UTC) 608:08:34, 27 March 2006 (UTC) 574:08:34, 27 March 2006 (UTC) 558:18:28, 27 March 2006 (UTC) 542:08:34, 27 March 2006 (UTC) 515:04:59, 28 March 2006 (UTC) 508:08:34, 27 March 2006 (UTC) 472:03:08, 28 March 2006 (UTC) 460:08:34, 27 March 2006 (UTC) 428:19:06, 26 March 2006 (UTC) 402:18:47, 26 March 2006 (UTC) 369:14:44, 26 March 2006 (UTC) 339:16:26, 27 March 2006 (UTC) 322:19:41, 26 March 2006 (UTC) 309:19:06, 26 March 2006 (UTC) 275:14:30, 26 March 2006 (UTC) 229:14:10, 26 March 2006 (UTC) 206:18:28, 27 March 2006 (UTC) 188:18:28, 27 March 2006 (UTC) 176:20:07, 27 March 2006 (UTC) 120:03:57, 28 March 2006 (UTC) 79:11:47, 26 March 2006 (UTC) 47:10:43, 26 March 2006 (UTC) 1234:05:01, 6 April 2006 (UTC) 1220:23:29, 5 April 2006 (UTC) 1156:20:40, 4 April 2006 (UTC) 1140:19:22, 4 April 2006 (UTC) 1125:18:54, 4 April 2006 (UTC) 1115:19:36, 3 April 2006 (UTC) 1103:16:58, 1 April 2006 (UTC) 1035:17:19, 1 April 2006 (UTC) 395:Wikiproject Indian cities 989:, and have been cited.-- 765:There is nothing in the 240:for your characteristic 146:See also: Kolkata trivia 743:- directed against the 658:Calcutta Stock Exchange 195:"Provisionally removed" 553:"Provisionally done"-- 183:"provisionally done"-- 440:Can we expand on the 139:Bengal famine of 1943 18:Knowledge:Peer review 1082:Rabindranath Tagore 798:I am okay with the 702:this seems to point 650:some info on Google 565:aggressive commuter 362:Mrs Katyun Randhawa 1098:on. Please help!-- 923:provisionally done 891:provisionally done 1137: 965:Victoria Memorial 928:The North Kolkata 723:Direct Action Day 707:Direct Action Day 293:the subheadings. 1241: 1135: 1048: 1043: 933: 920: 900: 888: 863: 853: 837: 820:Follow up review 425: 420: 336: 331: 306: 301: 226: 221: 76: 69: 63: 54:Utility services 1249: 1248: 1244: 1243: 1242: 1240: 1239: 1238: 1204:unplanned city. 1046: 1041: 1000:numerous errors 931: 917: 898: 886: 861: 847: 835: 822: 423: 418: 334: 329: 304: 299: 224: 219: 171:"Almost done"-- 72: 67: 61: 35: 26: 25: 24: 12: 11: 5: 1247: 1237: 1236: 1213: 1212: 1209: 1205: 1201: 1198: 1194: 1190: 1186: 1183: 1179: 1176: 1172: 1161: 1160: 1159: 1158: 1143: 1142: 1128: 1127: 1108: 1107: 1106: 1105: 1058: 1057: 1038: 1037: 1023: 1022: 1021: 1020: 1007: 1006: 1003: 996: 971: 968: 963:I believe the 960: 959: 955: 954: 950: 949: 948: 947: 938: 925: 912: 893: 881: 868: 858: 842: 821: 818: 817: 816: 815: 814: 805: 795: 785: 782: 759: 758: 757: 756: 755: 754: 737: 692: 691: 690: 689: 669: 653: 643: 642: 641: 640: 639: 638: 637: 636: 635: 634: 589: 588: 587: 586: 576: 560: 544: 522: 521: 520: 519: 518: 517: 492: 491: 481: 480: 479: 478: 477: 476: 475: 474: 448: 447: 446: 445: 442:Origin of Name 431: 430: 406: 405: 404: 371: 347: 346: 345: 344: 343: 342: 341: 261: 260: 259: 258: 252: 251: 250: 249: 215: 214: 208: 196: 190: 178: 163: 157: 151: 142: 135:Bengal Famine? 132: 122: 109: 101: 98: 95: 87: 86: 82: 81: 34: 29: 15: 9: 6: 4: 3: 2: 1246: 1235: 1232: 1228: 1224: 1223: 1222: 1221: 1218: 1210: 1206: 1202: 1199: 1195: 1191: 1187: 1184: 1180: 1177: 1173: 1170: 1166: 1165: 1164: 1157: 1154: 1150: 1147: 1146: 1145: 1144: 1141: 1138: 1130: 1129: 1126: 1123: 1119: 1118: 1117: 1116: 1113: 1104: 1101: 1096: 1095: 1094: 1091: 1087: 1083: 1079: 1075: 1070: 1069: 1068: 1067: 1064: 1055: 1054: 1053: 1052: 1049: 1044: 1036: 1033: 1029: 1025: 1024: 1019: 1016: 1011: 1010: 1009: 1008: 1004: 1001: 997: 995: 992: 988: 984: 980: 976: 972: 969: 966: 962: 961: 957: 956: 953:More comments 952: 951: 946: 943: 939: 937: 929: 926: 924: 916: 913: 911: 908: 904: 897: 894: 892: 885: 882: 880: 877: 873: 869: 867: 859: 857: 851: 846: 843: 841: 834: 830: 829: 828: 827: 826: 813: 810: 806: 803: 801: 796: 793: 791: 786: 783: 781: 778: 774: 770: 768: 763: 762: 761: 760: 753: 750: 746: 742: 741:Indira Gandhi 738: 736: 733: 729: 724: 720: 717: 716: 715: 712: 708: 703: 699: 696: 695: 694: 693: 688: 685: 681: 679: 675: 670: 668: 665: 661: 659: 654: 651: 647: 646: 645: 644: 633: 630: 626: 623: 622: 621: 618: 614: 611: 610: 609: 606: 602: 599: 595: 594: 593: 592: 591: 590: 584: 581: 577: 575: 572: 568: 566: 561: 559: 556: 552: 550: 545: 543: 540: 536: 533: 532: 530: 528: 524: 523: 516: 513: 509: 507: 503: 498: 497: 496: 495: 494: 493: 490: 488: 483: 482: 473: 470: 466: 463: 462: 461: 458: 454: 453: 452: 451: 450: 449: 443: 439: 438: 436: 433: 432: 429: 426: 421: 415: 411: 407: 403: 400: 396: 392: 388: 384: 380: 376: 372: 370: 367: 363: 359: 355: 351: 348: 340: 337: 332: 325: 324: 323: 320: 316: 312: 311: 310: 307: 302: 296: 292: 288: 283: 280:wikiproject, 278: 277: 276: 273: 269: 265: 264: 263: 262: 256: 255: 254: 253: 247: 243: 239: 236:Thanks a lot 235: 234: 233: 232: 231: 230: 227: 222: 212: 209: 207: 204: 200: 197: 194: 191: 189: 186: 182: 179: 177: 174: 170: 169: 164: 161: 158: 155: 152: 149: 147: 143: 140: 136: 133: 130: 126: 123: 121: 118: 114: 110: 107: 106: 102: 99: 96: 93: 89: 88: 84: 83: 80: 77: 75: 66: 59: 55: 51: 50: 49: 48: 45: 41: 33: 23: 19: 1214: 1162: 1148: 1109: 1059: 1056:More comment 1039: 1027: 999: 978: 974: 935: 927: 922: 914: 895: 890: 883: 871: 865: 855: 849: 844: 839: 831: 823: 799: 797: 789: 787: 766: 764: 718: 697: 678:Demographics 677: 671: 655: 624: 612: 597: 579: 564: 562: 548: 546: 534: 526: 525: 499: 486: 485:In history, 484: 464: 441: 434: 413: 287:Archive here 241: 216: 210: 198: 192: 180: 165: 159: 153: 145: 144: 134: 128: 124: 112: 104: 103: 91: 73: 36: 1217:Pradiptaray 998:I've found 563:What is an 1231:Dwaipayanc 1153:Dwaipayanc 1122:Dwaipayanc 1100:Dwaipayanc 1078:Bangladesh 1063:Dwaipayanc 1061:aspects?-- 991:Dwaipayanc 975:  907:Dwaipayanc 876:Dwaipayanc 777:Dwaipayanc 773:Dwaipayanc 749:Dwaipayanc 732:Dwaipayanc 684:Dwaipayanc 664:Dwaipayanc 629:Dwaipayanc 605:Dwaipayanc 571:Dwaipayanc 555:Dwaipayanc 539:Dwaipayanc 512:Dwaipayanc 506:Dwaipayanc 457:Dwaipayanc 399:Dwaipayanc 391:Louisville 366:Dwaipayanc 319:Dwaipayanc 282:Wikitravel 272:Dwaipayanc 242:subjective 203:Dwaipayanc 185:Dwaipayanc 173:Dwaipayanc 162:"Done (?)" 117:Dwaipayanc 44:Dwaipayanc 1169:Kharagpur 850:which are 771:"Done".-- 662:"Done" -- 656:Create a 583:Bangalore 549:Transport 537:"Done" -- 416:Regards, 387:Sheffield 150:. "Done". 148:-- remove 1090:Saravask 1042:=Nichalp 1032:Blacksun 1015:Blacksun 728:Naxalite 672:From an 435:Comments 419:=Nichalp 410:WP:WIAFA 383:Sarajevo 330:=Nichalp 300:=Nichalp 295:WP:WIAFA 268:Canberra 220:=Nichalp 201:"Done"-- 20:‎ | 1134:maclean 1086:Kolkata 1047:«Talk»= 979:Comment 866:Removed 856:Removed 800:Tourism 790:Culture 767:History 719:Comment 698:Comment 625:Comment 613:Comment 531:"done" 465:Comment 424:«Talk»= 335:«Talk»= 315:Nichalp 313:Please 305:«Talk»= 291:without 246:Kolkata 238:Nichalp 225:«Talk»= 213:"Done". 131:"Done". 113:Comment 32:Kolkata 22:Kolkata 1084:, and 942:AreJay 809:AreJay 794:"Done" 711:AreJay 617:AreJay 601:Mumbai 469:AreJay 379:Boston 168:Mumbai 156:"Done" 137:"Yes. 94:"Done" 1175:this) 408:From 74:Shyam 65:PD-US 58:Media 16:< 1149:Done 987:that 985:and 983:This 936:done 905:" -- 903:here 872:Done 840:Done 745:Sikh 598:a la 580:a la 547:The 502:Here 375:Bath 358:this 354:this 350:Here 56:and 40:this 1112:ppm 930:... 854:- 674:FAC 603:"-- 127:-- 1151:-- 1136:25 1080:, 1030:-- 934:- 921:- 889:- 874:-- 864:- 838:- 721:: 412:: 385:, 377:, 68:}} 62:{{ 585:. 285:( 141:"

Text is available under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License. Additional terms may apply.

Knowledge

:Peer review/Kolkata/archive1 - Knowledge

Index