Knowledge:Articles for deletion/Log/2023 March 8

16146:- my main issue with this list is its lack of coherence. Jacqueline Kennedy's bodyguard is in the 'former police and security agents' section (should those subjects be in a list for police instead, perhaps?) whereas the bodyguards who assassinated Indira Gandhi, 21 years later, in the historic section. It's one thing to be an independently hired "bodyguard" but a number of subjects in this list were/are Secret Service or Protection Command members - presumably, these could go under those specific listings, rather than this hodgepodge list of arbitrary criteria. 17652:

and there is likely media coverage of any campaign or time in office. As a community, we've accepted official records as sufficient to verify meeting the SNG, and those official sources could be used to expand the article. Curbon7 describes some of the challenges that may exist in Somalia that may make it more difficult to find sources. To me, the presumption of notability in NPOL means that the burden is to prove sources do not exist, instead of showing there are sufficient sources to keep an article. -

9258:.There's multiple sources listed where they either talk about him or something he had said or done. Newspapers in his area seemed to value what he thought. He clearly was somebody locally. A couple of the links like the obituary aren't really relevant to the argument, but for sourcing purposes, it's good work. A lot of time, effort and care was put into this and I think the OP did a good job in writing this up. It also likely seems that more information could be found to strengthen his case further. 13585: 9433:. Little sign of the type of impact we look for in academic notability. I will comment that it is harder to assess due to his propensity to switch fields every few years, but also that this propensity makes academic impact less likely. As far as GNG notability, there is the book, which at least shows circumstantial evidence of having been written by a relative; a bunch of inappropriately-used primary sources; and glancing human interest coverage in small town local news (which 12102:. She has published one book via a reputable Finnish publisher and edited two other books. There is no evidence of these books having had a significant impact. She has not held any relevant position in academia, and mainly works as a yoga teacher, and has published articles with fringe theorists Arto Annila and Tuomo Suntola. She was the president of the Green Cultural Association (in finnish: Vihreä sivistysliitto), for 2-3 years, but that association does not seem notable. 7224:. It odd that there are no reviews of his films and TV series. Doesn't anyone watch them? Or are they so unnotable that nobody writes about them? Most of the articles cited are amazingly short, so the citation list looks more impressive than it is. If someone wants this article in mainspace they should provide citations to reliable sources that critically reviewed his films/TV/web series. They should also have a go at writing articles about films/series he has been in. 6881: 15560: 15274: 160: 35: 9197:

least 10 pages of material on this person in this book. It also seems like the author of the article (a very active editor) did put in the work to properly source the article and aggregate sources both online and offline to put this together, so I would give this the benefit of the doubt. Clearly a borderline case but I dont see any reason to delete the article (except pedantry). --

16798: 16786: 16774: 10033:

Russia, Japan and South Korea. However, Mr Gao said the launch had been postponed until November. He said initially the airline would fly to Beijing, Shanghai, Guangzhou and Shenzhen. Although reluctant to reveal further details, he said Swan would invest 10 billion yuan (about HK$ 13.49 billion) in 30 aircrafts by the year 2000 and planned to have 300 pilots by 1995."

4046: 4034: 4022: 4010: 3998: 6072:(which is more about Nichi-Iko), on the Pharma Intelligence website, most of the other online mentions are either (1) press releases from the company (mostly about company acquisitions), (2) clear repetitions of company press release, (3) mentions of voluntary recalls, or (4) glancing mentions of Sagent in articles about something else. I find a lack of 16765:, but has a lot of primary aspects ("Staring down the camera lense , Melvin Minter speaks with a tone...") and is in a small-town paper by a reporter exclusively dedicated to covering Chesterfield FC. Local sources should be assessed with care, and I don't think this writeup has the distance from its subject that is needed to produce an NPOV bio. 6389:, though it certainly doesn't look "run of the mill" and is created by a well known architect. However, there's not even the slightest indication of news or book coverage that might meet WP:GNG requirements. The Seidler website doesn't mention it winning any accolades. Sufficient for it to be listed and described briefly in the 17273:

much an NPOL test-case, as this subject was alive recently enough that print sources likely exist, but due to the country that is involved, these print sources have not yet been digitized. Most importantly, this means there is room for expansion, as proven by the snippet I added of his tenure as district commissioner.

9229:. Larded with in-depth personal detail and primary sources, making it difficult to discern whether there is any in-depth coverage or whether there is anything of significance hidden somewhere in the picayune life story. Article claims "He is best known for his work in the academic field." but provides no evidence for 10514:- I've been around here for 3 years. After never having interaction with this user, we have met 14 times around a month after I rejected the user's attempt to draftify an article. This will be Onel's 6th Afd Nomination attempt on me this week. The user publicly claimed yesterday, "Too late, this same editor also has 4480:. The Fiji Times source is not in-depth and most of it is Q&A. I cannot open the FBC News source, so if someone believes there is something highly useful there I'd appreciate if they could post an excerpt here. That said one decent source on a youth athlete isn't going to satisfy the GNG under any circumstance. 17970:, I was able to locate a TV Guide source (know some editors oppose these) as well as the casting source from CountryLiving which was more profile piece than a casting notice despite the heading. Since they show has run five seasons and is still on-air I believe it has the potential more notable sourcing. 12603:

Alexf: I see you are a longtime wiki admin. Can you explain COI and NN? Also Im afraid to create any wiki pages for artists and waste my time. Do state and local newspapers and magazines qualify as notable sources? I have Colorado and European newspaper publications for other artists. I’ve asked some

11331:

I ended up here looking for an article I created many years ago named "Dera (woreda)", which I thought was satisfactorily distinct. However, I find that a few years back it was moved first to "Dera, Amhara (woreda)", then made into a redirect to this page. WTF is going on? I fixed this silliness, but

10125:

The article notes from Google Translate: "China Northern Swan Airlines is a joint-stock air transport enterprise established along with the reform and development of the civil aviation industry. Based in Harbin International Airport, the company is mainly engaged in domestic and foreign air passenger

9327:

Makes not claim of significance and is essentially is a framework article built piece by piece using a whole bunch of disparate sources to represent a whole that wouldn't necessarily be what the man was like during his real life. The 1940's, 50's and 60's are not some dead period where people of note

18604:

while this person has a long and storied career, I can't seem to locate sigcov relating to them in either books or print. Would love to be proven wrong on this as I think eventually someone will write about this person (maybe after their passing), but I think it is too early to say they are notable.

17651:

states that there is a presumption of notability for "international, national, or (for countries with federal or similar systems of government) state/province–wide office." For national legislators, there would be official records of time in service, votes taken, and, quite likely, official speeches

14981:

Yeah this is what happens when I don't speak Turkish! I was taking that from the news articles Google translated and brief mentions in other places (Legal Monitor Worldwide which I didn't include and Armenpress). So is what you're saying that there are **two** Nationalist Turkey Parties and that one

9196:

I disagree, without having access to one of the main sources of the article "Comollatti, Jane (2012). Antonio Comollatti & Ann Reed: Early settlers of Duaringa" it is hard to evaluate whether there is significant coverage or not. Given that the article mentions pp 14-25 it seems that there is at

17272:

Re-iterating my keep !vote, I have hid the uncited extraneous biographical information and leaving only his uncited DoB-DoD, referenced service in the Somali Parliament, referenced district commissioner tenure and action he did in that office, and uncited tenure as minister of finance. This is very

17228:: Somali biographies are notoriously difficult to find sources for, as access to the Internet in that country is practically nonexistent; it is also difficult as there may be different combinations of names that refer to a single subject. Cabinet ministers are generally considered to be notable via 15707:

Just another company, making products and getting some mentions of their numbers and stuff in some publications--but it's all regular run of the mill kind of coverage. Please see the history for a chunk of material that suggested notability (and possibly COI editing), but had no secondary sourcing.

10152:

The article notes from Google Translate: "Swan Air was established in 1993 and is headquartered in Harbin. In 1997, Beihang Heilongjiang Branch and Swan Airlines jointly established Beikong Swan Airlines. Later, due to the reorganization of civil aviation, Beihang was merged into China Southern.

8426:

The presented temporal operator schema appears quite notable, as they can be applied in defining earlier operators. Moreover, point-accessibility appears quite natural and handy, compared to Priorian operators for branching systems. I think it is important to share this original idea of Von Wright,

7444:

Compilation album by a very notable musician, full of highly notable songs (that debuted on other albums) and named after a highly notable hit-single, but as far as I can determine from searches on GBooks, Newspapers.com, and the internet archive, there just hasn't been even a single review of this

1576:

Unsure of the notability, College Park is not a major metropolis like Baltimore. Working as a small town mayor isn't necessarily notable. Having child pornography charges brought against him doesn't help or hinder his notability. Also concerned about the undue weight the mention of these charges in

18053:

That is just a different tab of the same listing ("Overview" v "Seasons & Episodes"). The TVovermind article might work, despite being written like a very bad high school essay and mentioning only two things about the show (namely, "As it sounds, Bahamas Life is an HGTV series about people who

17565:

been deleted at AfD; we presume that there is a near-certain chance that offline sources are written about these figures, even if we don't have direct online access to these sources, due to their impact on society by virtue of holding office; this is kind of the point of why it's an alternative to

11834:

of Belarus that included the rulers of the territory that is currently within the borders of the present nation state. But if you were going to do that, you would have the de facto rulers of the countries concerned: Tsarist Russia, then Poland and the U.S.S.R. in parallel, followed by the U.S.S.R.

11735:

Should we take that seriously? The titles are "chairman", "executive secretary" and "first secretary", not "leader", let alone "national leader'. Especially in a Soviet Communist context, which is explicitly internationalist and anti-nationalist, "national leader" doesn't make much sense. "head of

17357:

with its existence. NPOL is not clearly met as the claimed positions appear appointed. Articles have to demonstrate meeting Knowledge's notability guidelines; if they can't, they shouldn't be here. Someone has to put in the work to present sources, not just leave unreferenced content indefinitely

4561:

The most "significant" fact is simply his debut in the youth team, followed by some very brief facts about his background and aspirations, with no in-depth discussion about any of these things (thus not even close for GNG, let alone SUSTAINED). This is not surprising since the subject is only 15.

541:

Another tough one. First Tahitian in Fed Cup. Two Bronze medals in the same international tournament at the 2015 Pacific Games. Usually when looking at a tennis career that might be enough. The only problem is in looking at her full pro career it's a blank slate. Per the WTA she played no events

10032:

The article notes: "Sunbase was hardly known in Hongkong until last October, when the company announced it was to set up a Harbin-based air carrier, Swan Airlines, with several mainland enterprises. Plans called for Swan Airlines to be operating in March, with international flights to Hongkong,

8392:

I find notability as a criterion of the deletion quite strange, for the extension I present is quite notable: PA-operators are able to express the antique statistical operators, Priorian operators (both for linear and branching systems), and of course all particular examples of Von Wright's

4884:

I can't find english language sources establishing notability. The only academic English sources I can find discussing him are about the racist media coverage in Poland. There are a handful of contemporaneous english news articles about the HIV case, but nothing that establishes notability.

18054:

are planning to settle in the Bahamas." and "Bahamas Life is certainly interesting, but its very nature means that it leaves out a lot of the complexities that should be involved in something as major as moving to another country.") I can't evaluate the other link, because it's paywalled.

15485:: This is a shame, considering he has worked on a decent amount of notable stuff (and I am always looking to expand the project's overview of J-pop). But sadly, the only sources I was able to find are incidental mentions as a producer or press releases. Ping me if more sources are found. 11701:); we might move some content from the former to the latter if useful. The reason why I'm not proposing this as a "merge" but a "delete" is because of the vagueness of the term "ruler". We should no longer use the term "ruler" to lump very different types of positions/jobs together. (See 5077:, given that there is also significant coverage of his activism that was published prior to his arrest. There's plenty enough to write an article about here, so deletion for failing to meet the relevant notability criterion is out of the question. Complaints about content are answered by 11705:, and search for my "Thanks for chiming in" comment for more commentary on Belarus). The now-deleted "Category:Belarusian rulers" also excluded any non-monarchs, so all 20th- and 21st-century presidential/parliamentary republican heads of state wouldn't fit in it anyway. Cheers, 4351:

in the case of a user who presented an opinion other that what you expected from them (and I fully understand the message was posted on Spider’s talk page and not here because the AFD was closed and later reopened. However I want to sure others are aware of this conversation).

7795: 10126:

and cargo transportation, and also operates aviation catering, tourism and other businesses. At present, there are 4 MD90 aircrafts and 4 MD82 aircrafts, and 46 domestic routes and 7 international routes have been opened to 45 large and medium-sized cities at home and abroad."

542:

ever. Per the minor league ITF Challenger level I see no events played. Per the minor-minor league ITF events I see no events ever played. Did they lose her records or did she never play anything other than Fed Cup and the Pacific Games those two years? All I see is some

615:

simply for being the first Tahitian to play in that particular tournament as described. This would also help combat "Western nation only" bias on wiki, where anything and everything from a western nation gets noted, but hardly anything from elsewhere on the planet does.

4579:. I don't think the coverage shown is enough for GNG – especially since we're more strict on those who are young, and this one's only 15. I'd be alright with draftification, although I think it'd probably be several years before Vosagaga has a chance at being notable. 4215:. There is a consensus among participating editors that GNG is met here. There is also a vocal opposition to that judgment but the consensus is to Keep this article even if some of the Keeps are Weak Keeps, either explicitly or in terms of the Keep opinions put forth." 2812:

and its a sizeable business with unique products that has enough significance and impact on the market which it serves. It has also gained momentum and recognition via Television media after being featured on Shark Tank India on one of India's biggest TV Stations.

17157:

No references on the page for many years. I have no reason to believe it isn't true, but I also don't think we can have pages without references. I don't find anything which meets the GNG, which one might expect if he was a national politician in the government.

3390:

It only says she holds records. I now assume that records can be won without a championship, so if I'm processing this correctly, being the best in a smaller (population 850,000) nation at many track events (holding the record) is not an indicator of notability?

10921: 14454:

where he's just answering an interview question. Everything else is just trivial squad announcements. He's only played five competitive international games as well, so I think it's safe to say that there's no real chance of significant offline sources either.

12631:

TimothyBlue: I know the owners of the ColoradoSprings venue that supports and features new artists and wrote about Mr.Logan. They said he was also just featured in a local magazine for artists as well. I asked his wife (who attended the show) to send me his

16182:. If the majority of subjects in this list, at present, would be better off in other categories more specific to their occupation, i.e. Secret Service agents, then the number of independent topics may be quite small and the article could warrant deletion. 10842: 7231:

says that the Antariksh "series is going to be one of the country’s first space fiction show that will see the actor playing the part of an astronaut.", whereas the Knowledge article on Ruhaan Rajput makes an uncited claim that it was released in 2019.

9328:

were not recorded somehow as other folk who lived have and would have done in other periods. If he was significant, it would have been much more obvious. But it's not. It just a bunch of tiny facts glued together and none of it is significant. Fails

3991:

unless they go waaaay beyond the standard regional press covering high school sports. Do you know how many thousands more (predominantly western) kids would have wikipedia articles if we applied these same ultra-low standards of sourcing to everyone?

711:

with no prejudice towards recreation if Tahitian sources are found that cover her more in depth. I found absolutely nothing on normal searches of Google and Newspapers.com, but imagine there could be local sources that we're somehow missing here. Per

14932:- I managed to find quite a bit of coverage and updated the article with a few references. It's a weak keep because almost all of them are in Turkish and it's entirely possible that there are other factors making them not notable that I can't read. 8240: 665:

Discussion of whether there are or are not multiple reliable and independent sources which cover this subject in reasonable depth would be helpful in determining notability. Tangential discussions of "first", "western", or the like are generally

10834: 10826: 2498:. From what I can see from the news stories found by a Google news search, it would be possible to write an interesting and useful article about the company, and the various problems it has faced over time. Doing this in draft would be best. 5571:

This has useful information for an increasingly common thing with lowering American public opinion on the police force and officials. If you think the name is bad, then it can be changed. Sorry if anyone disagrees with this. Have a good day.

7515:: based on the lack of coverage both FOARP and I have found. Even if there was charting to find outside of the US and UK, I doubt it'd be enough for convincing notability, and it could be easily squeezed into that discography table anyway. 10878: 8459:

In principle, I can see that defining Priorians in terms of PAOs might be more informative than defining PAOs as a generalisation of Priorians, but they are still not notable because they do not have enough coverage in independent sources

3904:, how are two sentences enough to meet SPORTBASIC, let alone the higher sourcing requirements of YOUNGATH? The FBC article isn't much better, with under 5 independent sentences on him. He fails NSPORT and all former iterations of NFOOTY ( 3244:, prong 5 ("Sports biographies must include at least one reference to a source providing significant coverage of the subject, excluding database sources."). Article is a micro stub based solely on a database and fails to cite any SIGCOV. 13701: 5490:

if the only rationale is the name. Even a quick scan of the headlines in the references section would indicate that the term is commonly used in RS to describe this activity, despite originating from the practitioners themselves. See

836:

And which I also listed above. Per the sources that Oaktree found, they're all... kind of passing mentions of Zima herself, but really terrific information about the team at large. It honestly reinforces my !vote towards redirecting.

9395:

contains SIGCOV, it's worth noting that the author, Jane Comollatti, is Diamond's cousin. This means it's not independent and it's also likely the passages mentioning him are primary accounts of him rather than secondary commentary.

7413: 6693: 17589:. Appointed officials are equivalent to an elected official, what matters is that the individual served in an "international, national, or (for countries with federal or similar systems of government) state/province–wide office," -- 15200:— Apart from a single source, the references found during this AfD are about a different party that never came to be. My own search yields no additional results, so without multiple references this doesn't pass the GNG nor NCORP. 3349:: I added some content, noting she has represented her country on multiple occasions. I don't know the sports guidelines well, so have a question: does holding multiple national records not make her presumed notable? Is that what 3373:

Depends on the country. It is far more difficult to hold national records in China than in Niue. If Comoros has national championships, and she has won them, then yes, NATH #4 would apply, but I do not see that in the article.

14995:

is a source about Akşener denying that she was going to create a party (April 2017) after those rumours appeared. Then later in October she created the other party. However, the Armenpress source is about the actual 2011 party.

734:

Want to explicitly note here that Oaktree b's article is a great find, but I don't think it's enough significant coverage to pass muster. A note should be added to the talk page with links to the few references we have for her.

13007: 9895: 12636:

I have some other Colorado Springs artists and musicians to post on Knowledge as well and their publications are from Denver and local newspapers but am now unsure if I can use this for new Knowledge articles. Please advise!

12566:

Hello, it would help if you would explain how you know the subject of the article. Also, could you clarify if you took the photo in the article yourself or did you receive permission from the subject to use the photo. Thanks,

13312: 9275:: there are few sources here that comply with the "significant coverage" required by the GNG, but all the same one or two of those is enough. Many primary or less reliable sources, but they can be relied on for simple facts. 8161: 11639: 16062:). If there questions that about how to discern that, that is an editing decision and not grounds for deletion. The page serves as a perfectly fine navigational page and the existence of a category does not change that per 14818: 1957: 17919:

Fails GNG. Despite running for five seasons on a relatively well known network, I cannot find any reliable, independent that discuss or review the show. The closest I found is one or two articles noting its casting calls.

17126: 5819: 5349: 12063: 7752: 17527:. This is cited. Also cited is a previous position he's held and an action he did in that position. This is typically more than enough for a keep on basis, as his holding of high-ranking NPOL-conferring positions means 9634: 9292:

As the article currently stands it contains no evidence of notability for this person (in academia : no significant research output mentioned, no mention of his impact in education ; in politics : nothing significant).

9108: 10418: 4513:

The Seaqaqa Central College student started playing at the age of nine and with the help of his coach Mohamed Imran he booked a place in their district team and played during the Inter-District Championship last year.

3134: 1051: 15958: 10915: 12464: 8675: 4562:

Given that Knowledge is a lagging indicator of notability, we should let other dedicated outlets cover his potential rise, and consider creating a page when coverage of that becomes both substantial and significant.

3721: 10851: 10846: 8153: 8145: 6291: 10855: 2672: 1545: 18995: 16397: 7027: 18401: 17888: 17298:

as "He served as Minister of State for Fishing and Sea resources." and "became a member of the transitional government's parliament and cabinet, and he was the Finance Minister in Somalia's federal government."

14344: 8197: 15676: 15390: 17233: 10838: 10096:

The book notes: "It also cancelled the licences of several airlines and allowed small airlines to be taken over by larger carriers, e.g. Swan Airlines by China Northern and Fujian Airlines by Xiamen Airlines."

429: 13991: 4853: 2264: 5964:

Because we are no longer a publicly traded company, there are often not enough articles written about us to have outside sources. We do not do prese releases and articles are generally not written about us.

2938: 2894: 13622: 11156: 8234: 4960:

is not one of them. Sources don't have to be academic, or even in English. There are many sources listed on the article, and the Polish Knowledge has more. I sampled a few and found non-trivial coverage

215: 210: 17999:, or is there another? I'm having trouble seeing how that would establish notability combined with the single Country Living piece. Even if it may meet notability some day, it seems like it'd fall into 12495:

Promo BLP, lacks proper sourcing, no SIGCOV addressing the subject directly and indepth from I RS. Article creator also uploaded "Headshot of The Artist Daniel Logan (DALO)" to commons for article.

7058:

Bringing this here for discussion as, while it's not a G4, it does not appear the factors have changed from the first two AfDs. Sourcing is thin in quality, and it does not appear he meets N:ACTOR.

2872: 6614: 5509: 17083: 17030: 7228: 18814:: there is enough significant coverage here to comply with the GNG. Clearly also a significant career, which is not what the GNG is about, but it ought to be a factor in any room for manoevre. 18036: 13614: 13606: 4318:

Different topic areas have different ways of assessing what is SIGCOV and compliance with other P&Gs. But regardless, as noted below, SUSTAINED is straight from N and clearly applies here.

3543: 3019: 13695: 690:

Happy to go with emerging consensus below. WP:BEFORE shows an almost complete lack of SIGCOV. Routine match listings, incidental mentions in a few news reports that lead with Carol Lee. Best

11670: 5071: 1645:

Regarding his arrest and the charges in isolation from his career, as child pornography suspects are concerned he's run-of-the-mill. At least in the absence of new findings that he's been a

13658: 10153:

In 2004, the Civil Aviation Administration of China approved the cancellation of Beihang Goose Airlines Co., Ltd., and agreed to resume the operation of China Southern Heilongjiang Branch."

9591: 9538: 7407: 6687: 12751:

Non-notable artist. "Air Force" refers to the US Air Force apparently, though the article appears to be too-USA focused to make that clear. I don't find sourcing beyond alumni newspapers.

9677:

does not seem to exist. Massive claims to notability made in the article but no evidence to support them. Please review the previous discussion to gain context before !voting if you can.

8170: 8165: 7370: 6606: 6598: 15989:

Unclear what the purpose of this article is or the criteria for notability of bodyguards. If there is such a thing, this list should be substantially longer. Personally I think it fails

14490:

of the article and even I can put my hand up and say this isn't contributing much at all to the encyclopedia. It's more bloat than anything, and all of its useful information is already

15915: 15862: 12928: 11728: 11698: 8174: 18664:, following expansion. He played a significant role in the constitutional development of Tokelau. Also, his book on China is referenced by many academic studies of Sino–NZ relations. 13001: 9889: 6650: 13111:- edit summary states that the content of the article was approved directly by the director of this company, awards and media section is longer than the rest of the article combined 10965: 5500: 16690:

It seems you did a better job of finding the sources there, it's just borderline for me. Could be a weak keep, however my vote after some review of overall is basically will sit at

13306: 10825: 8157: 2808: 16759: 16618: 11633: 11055: 7212:. He has had something like "in depth coverage" in independent reliable sources, but the articles seem to have been written to promote shows that he is making or is going to make: 5127:

Fair enough. The paper helps notability. Also I didn't notice that most of the media coverage came after that first deletion. I won't object if this gets closed early as a 'keep'.

14812: 12207:. No sources in the article which are independent of the subject; notability is not established by a single book review. Not turned anything else up in my own search for sources. 11702: 1951: 17120: 3995:

is a local interview-style article on children (fails YOUNGATH) that contains around two sentences of independent coverage, with the rest being direct quotes or "Vosagaga said",

14982:

of them is established and one of them is just rumoured to exist? And that the references I've found are about one that doesn't **actually** exist, just was perhaps going to? --

14739: 5813: 5417: 5343: 1878: 1660:

major political role within its jurisdiction, but do we go by that is it discerned relative to political office holders throughout the area? But, also, that second criterion at

754: 469: 12541:

Citation sources for article have been updated to fall within the Knowledge guidelines. The two qualifying sources featuring the artist have been updated for proper citation.

12057: 9926:

Fails GNG and NCORP. No sources available with SIGCOV addressing the subject directly and indepth from I RS. No objection to a redirect to parent company if consensus exists.

7746: 2905: 14472:- It's been here for 4 years and is only being deleted due to new rules. The article isn't bothering or hurting anything and is just removing useful information from the site. 14042: 13430:. I see no evidence that the title is in common usage for Olympic decathlon/heptathlon champions and "The best, or most successful, living sportsperson" is totally subjective 13039: 12920: 12912: 12123: 10647:

My best guess is that they ar confusing nominator with article creator and are claiming that the AFD is an attack against them since it doesn’t make any sense thr other way.--

9628: 9170: 9102: 8737: 7892: 6984: 6925: 6920: 6915: 3871:

The Seaqaqa Central College Year 11 student featured for his district at the 2022 Courts Inter District Championship and his performance caught the eyes of national selectors.

1126: 10412: 7794:

is met. There was a flurry of media coverage about the discovery of what was claimed to be the first pregnant mummy, but other researchers have published papers stating that

4435:

non-primary sentences on him, the rest is qoutes from him. It is massively disapointing to see experienced editors claiming that is enough for a 15-year old kid to pass GNG.

3128: 1045: 70: 16635:(100000+ views), among many more sources, including many more YouTube and podcast interviews. Clearly significant figure in non league football with ongoing career. Thanks, 15952: 13462:: Seems like an obvious unnecessary disambiguation page. Being the reigning Olympic decathlon or Olympic heptathlon champion does not make one the world's greatest athlete. 10936: 5740: 2927: 12458: 8669: 8574: 3715: 2939:

https://www.hindustantimes.com/lifestyle/health/world-diabetes-day-2022-parenting-tips-on-portion-control-mindful-eating-to-avoid-diabetes-in-teenagers-101668321671542.html

16084: 12964: 12723:

Ah! I thought having permission to use the picture counted for that. Ok! No worries, I’ll learn with your suggestions! Greetings from Germany! Thank you for your help :)

11984: 10903: 9852: 7673: 7083: 6285: 5938:

3 of the references in the article, while they may be valid, are not independent of the subject. The goal here is for the article to gain enough reliable sources to pass

2895:

https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/industry/cons-products/food/health-food-maker-lilgoodness-announces-launch-of-disney-marvel-inspired-products/articleshow/96174049.cms

106: 82: 10630:

means quite literally that people !voting in the AfD shouldn't attack the nominator, i.e. in this case you should't attack Onel5969. Which is exactly what you are doing.

8287: 10458: 9555: 9029: 2666: 1539: 18989: 16391: 13494:). That said, the hatnote on the film page is sufficient to provide the effective links because it's unlikely that this target will be internally linked from articles. 7021: 18535: 18395: 17882: 16939:- there's a lot of non-independent and unreliable content being discussed here and incorrectly used to support notability. Joelle's source assessment appears correct. 14731: 14723: 14555:- I agree with SmackJam's honest assessment of an article that they essentially wrote (massive respect to anyone that can accept that an article that they wrote fails 14338: 12385: 11279: 5405: 4810: 4757: 1870: 1862: 1656:

can be met by "Major local political figures who have received significant press coverage." But I don't know what mayor of College Park is "major". What's major? It's

972: 782:

Tahiti Infos is a news site, and its the source for pretty much everything in French Polynesia. Radio1 and TNTV are also good sources for French Polynesian content.--

15670: 15384: 13631: 13626: 13269: 11596: 5065: 423: 14957: 13985: 5857:

Of the Google search, I see a lot of non-independent sources, as well as recruitment sites. I admittedly don't know anything about the other sources that come up.

4847: 2258: 546:. Did she get injured and retire? Did she die? Because she did absolutely nothing else I would lean towards Delete but perhaps a better idea is to redirect this to 14775: 13635: 7343: 7338: 5732: 5724: 3642: 2873:

https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/tech/startups/health-focused-food-brand-lilgoodness-aims-to-achieve-turnover-of-rs-500-crore-by-fy26/articlesh.ow/95914994.cms

1914: 8402: 1093:. I'm not seeing any reliable sources for GNG. There are several books, but they appear to be self-published, and more importantly, no reviews are apparent for 17025: 13116: 11976: 11968: 8432: 8387: 7993: 7665: 7657: 7488: 7347: 13797:: Sources in article are directory style listings, dead links, government websites, nothing from I RS with SIGCOVV addressing the subject directly and indepth. 11733:...including its presidents both before and after the Soviet era, and the Soviet leaders themselves, who, unlike the Presidents, were not formal Heads of State. 10897: 7651: 1278: 18237: 16010: 13618: 13360: 11791: 11220: 11150: 9547: 9524: 9021: 9013: 8489: 8436: 8255: 8008: 6623: 6618: 5924:

Sagent Pharmaceuticals is a company in Schaumburg IL. The citations and page are all valid and speaks to what the company does. Why would you delete the page?

5776: 5306: 5135: 5121: 5098: 5020: 5006: 757: 11745: 4505:

15-year-old Vilikesa Vosagaga who is part of the Baby Bula Boys squad took up the sport after watching Nalaubu play for Suva, Lautoka, and the national team.

2432: 15459: 14046: 12703:

to the photo under Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 4.0 International. This means anyone can use this photo for any purpose, commercial or personal.

12377: 12369: 12020: 8394: 8222: 7709: 7330: 6930: 6627: 5413: 5162: 4926: 3418: 3311: 3206: 3174: 2724: 2351: 1466: 964: 956: 507: 475: 65: 60: 55: 51: 47: 10860: 7103: 6477:

per Djflem. Seidler is a notable and extremely well recognised architect in Australia, and this work would be an entirely appropriate addition to his page.

4516:

Vosagaga who has maternal links to Sasa in Macuata is the first from his family to make it to a national squad and is also the youngest player in the team.

3280:

but something seems up with that website and the article isn't making sense. That's all I could find. Looks like a GNG fail unless that book has something.

1716: 18916: 17626:: There are strong arguments for both keeping and deleting. On one hand, there does appear to be some inherent claim to notability. But on the other hand, 17536: 16318: 14914: 10893: 10317: 9533: 9065: 8278:

in this sense was introduced for the first time, and on which the page is largely based on. The article itself was published in 2021 and has no citations.

6948: 5380:

Non-notable use of a term that is limited to a few web channels or youtube videos. No usage of the term in RS in Gnews, does not appear to have caught on.

2814: 2757: 2593: 2319: 17961: 11260: 7141: 6069: 5183: 19181: 19115: 19051: 18794: 18154: 17635: 17503: 16465: 16225: 15721: 14646: 14400: 14265: 14172: 13754: 13511: 12840: 12421: 12292: 11878: 10375: 8917: 8419: 8144: 8066: 6610: 6343: 5646: 5573: 4943: 4665: 3782: 3634: 3626: 3534: 3258:

I've looked through all the google results and at other wikis and here's what I've found: the French wiki has a slightly more detailed article and lists

3194: 3091: 2883: 2453: 1756: 1311: 1008: 766: 763: 699: 495: 11727:

contains a statement which argues against the idea that some of the people mentioned weren't "head of state", and thus the article shouldn't be renamed

8351: 7160: 7122: 6792:- the roles claimed in the article are not ones that would automatically mean notability, nor is there significant coverage to establish notability. -- 5045: 4992: 4511:“I like his playing style, his speed, he looks like he has fun all the time while on the field and I want to be like that. He is also a humble person.” 3214: 1142: 515: 19122: 18467: 18457: 18162: 18069: 18048: 18018: 17989: 17375: 17195: 16505: 15857: 15597: 15311: 14428: 13112: 12823: 11779: 11714: 11411: 11380: 10872: 9174: 8428: 7989: 7823: 6747: 5461: 5449: 3827: 2407: 1702: 1598: 675: 559: 17398: 11807: 11236: 10943: 10603:

rules were broken before nomination, nullifying it and the user continued to break rules by bringing up other articles that aren't related to this to

9411: 8454: 7476: 6076:. (Not relevant to the question of notability, but glaringly annoying: the misapprehension by what appears to be multiple Sagent employees that it is 2916: 1319: 17943: 16819: 13890: 12300: 12131: 11422: 9718: 8763: 8632: 8365:

Non-notable logical operator, and deleting it isn't anyone's loss because it was copied from an open-access paper anyway. Might deserve a mention on

8295: 7587: 7130: 6894: 6809:. Since 2007, we have had a strong consensus that student government leaders are not automatically notable. In 2023, to argue otherwise is specious. 6190: 5477: 5429: 5401: 4918: 3678: 3289: 533: 18201: 17787: 13716: 13141: 13055: 12777: 9988: 9942: 8333: 7541: 6096: 4986: 4403: 3802: 3473: 2461: 2339: 1253: 1183: 18614: 18590: 18547: 18500: 18479: 18108: 17714: 17699: 17232:, especially a high-ranking minister like finance; that said, I was not able to quickly find a source confirming this. However, I was able to find 16678: 16656: 15745: 14968:

instead. So the topic of the article should be the 2011 party, while Refs 2, 3 and 4 are about the rumoured party which in a way never came to be.

14050: 13912: 13817: 13766: 12937: 12932: 11899: 11859: 11845: 11376: 9954: 9825: 9820: 9178: 8393:

operators. If it helps, the article could be renamed as Temporal Operators. I intended to add definitions of the earlier operators to the article.

7111: 6735: 6347: 6248: 6056: 5902: 4970: 3231: 2732: 2728: 2359: 2355: 2185: 2030: 1606: 1458: 1450: 1383: 1208: 575: 133: 128: 103: 17323: 16910: 16593: 16497: 16477: 13683: 13120: 12249: 12144: 10232: 10059:

The article notes: "The completed acquisitions are China Northern's takeover of Swan Airlines and China Northwest's purchase of Nanjing Airlines."

9446: 9302: 9242: 8304: 8216: 8139: 8041: 7912: 7242: 5974: 5718: 3559: 2822: 1444: 1166: 887: 831: 605: 19063: 19055: 18908: 18900: 17199: 16728: 16644: 16485: 16310: 16302: 15749: 15713: 15709: 15426: 14882: 14404: 13471: 13069: 12941: 12848: 12524: 12270: 12191: 11474: 11372: 11306: 10038: 9958: 9829: 8510: 7428: 7200: 6940: 6900: 6708: 5906: 5876: 5654: 5437: 5070:). His case also appears to be a fairly standard case that's used in examination of criminal law around intentionally infecting people with HIV ( 4930: 4367: 4327: 4312: 4283: 4140: 3937: 3925: 3895: 3883: 3786: 3520: 3496: 3453: 3426: 3368: 3222: 2585: 2577: 2368: 2323: 1764: 1602: 1341: 1230: 1195: 729: 18765: 17685: 17532: 17341: 17305: 16746: 16576: 16457: 16233: 14528: 12716: 12691: 12623: 12580: 12560: 12533: 11341: 11322: 11295: 10991: 10616: 10594: 9971: 9381: 9219: 8925: 7570: 4503:

The likes of Fiji Football captain Roy Krishna and striker Sairusi Nalaubu have been a source of inspiration to young and upcoming footballers.

4122: 4103: 3853: 3837: 3319: 3305: 2386: 2065: 2005: 1636:

to work from. I'm not the nominator and I'm not !voting, at least just yet, so I don't have to do the due diligence 😀 but can say that I don't

850: 791: 19189: 19147: 19059: 18802: 17661: 17207: 16945: 16841: 16827: 16813: 16514: 16445: 16155: 16134: 16117: 15828:. Further discussion is necessary concerning the inclusion criteria for this list, but there is a strong consensus to keep some version of it. 14654: 14596: 14547: 14507: 14408: 14257: 14249: 13770: 13483:: this disambiguation page does not constitute original research. Some basic research (or even reading the linked pages) will reveal that (see 13095: 13077: 12520: 12258: 12135: 12111: 11795: 11451: 10677: 10575: 10519: 10256: 9695: 9367: 9346: 9267: 9201: 8862: 8855: 8806: 8767: 8482: 8380: 8074: 7974: 7395: 6675: 6436: 6322:

No refs on the page for many years. I see some RS which mention the development but don't see anything much which would count towards the GNG.

5953: 5933: 4914: 4081: 3962: 3820: 3790: 3337: 3253: 2490: 2034: 1679: 1502: 1199: 503: 18218: 16931: 16557: 16191: 16173: 16075: 16042: 14487: 14481: 13810: 13519: 13498: 13408: 12760: 12742: 12172:(link to archive.org). I can't find any further RS-coverage from casual Google searches. In total, no evidence that the subject passes either 10009: 9727: 9708: 9518: 9423: 8179: 7997: 5600: 4617: 4159: 3182: 2741: 2508: 2047: 2018: 1739: 1615: 1114: 641: 18952: 18522: 18128: 17203: 16354: 15717: 15589: 15581: 15303: 15295: 14886: 13242: 13237: 13211: 12924: 12906: 12801: 12216: 11569: 11564: 10868: 10656: 10523: 10497: 10484: 10203: 10195: 10102: 9812: 9405: 9284: 9187: 8892: 8832: 8776: 8212: 7827: 7149: 6910: 6782: 6751: 5915: 5465: 4934: 4922: 4737: 4549: 4531: 4185: 4064: 3435: 3202: 2906:

https://www.indianretailer.com/news/lil-goodness-ropes-in-namrata-shirodkar-and-her-daughter-sitara-for-an-exclusive-brand-association.n14176

2852: 2795: 2629: 2038: 625: 499: 97: 19164: 19131: 18823: 17643: 17511: 16703: 16022: 14565: 14437: 14180: 13826: 13450: 12596: 11434: 10909: 10704: 8883:, as there are other sources easily found. The one university source relied on here is significant coverage but not altogether independent. 8874: 8751: 7955: 7930: 6592: 6004:

I am the head of Marketing. We are not publishing anything that isn't non factual. No opinions. Just general information about the company.

5890: 5506: 5492: 5389: 3979: 2100: 1793: 817: 777: 19109: 18727: 18653: 18575: 18462: 18358: 17845: 17364: 16889: 16540: 16096: 15776: 15758: 15467: 15463: 14748: 14743: 14464: 14301: 14091: 13774: 13369: 13352: 13246: 13022: 12508: 12165:(paywalled). The others are either about someone else (her husband), closely associated with her, or otherwise unreliable. For example the 12127: 11573: 11310: 10488: 9962: 9910: 9699: 9319: 8946: 7896: 7880: 7868: 7087: 6125: 6031: 6013: 5868: 5581: 5105: 4673: 4268: 3406: 3385: 3198: 2327: 1887: 1882: 1130: 566: 19075: 17616: 17575: 17282: 17010: 15494: 15148: 15086: 15064: 15037: 14621: 14420: 13788: 13506:. I make this suggestion after much research and reflection upon all available options. The best outcome would be to redirect to the page 11359: 10736: 9683: 7861: 7839: 7524: 7071: 5532: 5503: 4962: 4902: 4588: 4462: 3811:- I've added refs. These were easy to find, and I'm surprised the nominaotr didn't add them rather than leaping immediately to deletion.-- 2928:

https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/business/india-business/millet-brands-expected-to-gain-from-budgets-promotion/articleshow/97588458.cms

2761: 872:

as per Nomader as an ATD. Also preserves history, and if more sourcing can be found in future, no prejudice against recreating. I think

748: 19155:- I found no sources on Google to support only statistics references which doesn't help the situation thereby making him fail notability. 17056: 17051: 15633: 15476: 15347: 14923: 14870: 14752: 14120: 14059: 13904: 13896: 13327: 12989: 12659: 11962: 11384: 11224: 10864: 9877: 9158: 8916:. Deletion could be considered if the subject wasn’t notable, however, as I have detailed above the subject has demonstrable notability. 8191: 8020: 7811: 4297:

No, GNG explains what constitutes GNG coverage of all subjects, which includes young athletes. And I believe GNG to be met in this case.

2177: 2169: 1891: 100: 18710: 18687: 18673: 17935: 17585:

I sense that it has been verified that the subject did serve in the Transitional Federal Parliament of Somalia and would therefore pass

17448: 17167: 15289: 14559:). I couldn't find any decent sources myself. Nothing found in ProQuest as well as search engines that others probably already checked. 13600: 11654: 10562:

and has in-depth coverage. I'll see everyone later today when Onel attempts the same thing for other articles in some attempt to secure

10472: 8262: 5999: 5561: 5512:

cited on the page that all use this term. Even if this name shouldn't be used, it should be a discussion for a move request, not an AfD.

5248: 3415:

with the exception of those that have never been ranked in the top 60 on the IAAF world leading list at the end of a given calendar year

2163: 17598: 17552: 17477: 17415: 17267: 17249: 17060: 16002: 14833: 13677: 13294: 13229: 11556: 6528: 6486: 6419: 5749: 5744: 5409: 5279: 5274: 4489: 4153:

I think it's tough to assess on that criterion right now given that the subject is still only 15. We'd have to revisit in a few years.

1972: 1776:

keep articles about mayors of cities of that size. Obviously, there are exceptions, but they have lots of deep coverage, rather than a

386: 17141: 15004: 14986: 14976: 12592:

as NN. I do not see why we are here, when this is a candidate for Speedy Deletion. NN and looks like advertisement, and maybe COI? --

11621: 11187:

This page purports to be an article but it is entirely unsourced. If it were a disambiguation page it would be cluttered with invalid

10457:, absolutely no in-depth coverage at all, just some short promotional blurbs, all relating to the single event. Very similar case to 8729: 7500: 6511: 6461: 6381: 5621: 5057: 4571: 4444: 3770: 3620: 205: 16224:. The challenge will be limiting its contents to notable people, but that in and of itself isn’t a valid justification for deletion. 15208: 14936: 14800: 14735: 14147: 13948: 12363: 11993: 11988: 10757: 8846:. I'd like to maybe see some translations of the titles of his various works and I'd like to see some sources added to his biography. 7682: 7677: 7334: 6402: 5834: 5753: 5364: 5283: 5068: 4752: 2221: 2087:

as a private primary school. It pains me that these pages are still here, especially one like this that is so poor as almost meeting

1939: 1874: 869: 708: 547: 483: 313: 17219: 17182: 17108: 16437: 14906: 14079: 12078: 10639: 9794: 9007: 7767: 7389: 6801: 6765: 6669: 6359: 2966: 2084: 1586: 17043: 15188: 15119: 13640: 13605: 11997: 10820: 9649: 9564: 9559: 9123: 9038: 9033: 7686: 5801: 5331: 4648: 4175:- two sources that GS points out are just about enough for GNG. GNG is not a ridiculously high bar. We simply need two independent 252: 16296: 13673: 12045: 11282:(as it's clearly not the primary topic), and, if there are any issues with the content, blank and redirect to the general article 10433: 8468: 7734: 7352: 3149: 2712: 2307: 1066: 19039: 18300: 17173:

Another thought: we might have an issue of spelling in English (or Somali) which may be affecting the sources that can be found.

15973: 12394: 12389: 11271: 10348: 10343: 9616: 9568: 9090: 9042: 7317: 6331: 5736: 5266: 4229: 3064: 3059: 981: 976: 18445: 14388: 12479: 10400: 8690: 7984:: All sources focus not on the subject of the article, but projects with which they have been involved - also fails criteria at 6632: 3736: 3297:

Djamalidine is one of the greatest track and field athletes in their country's history. Deleting this article will only further

3116: 1033: 19047: 18678:

Do you have sources to back your claim "his book on China is referenced by many academic studies of Sino–NZ relations"? Thanks

18581:

True but that doesn't necessarily mean they meet the notability requirements. Could you find sources with sigcov? I could not.

18453: 17385:

could not find a single source or reference and the claims in the article about the subject cannot be verified clearly fails

17191: 15940: 15888: 15883: 15741: 15455: 14878: 14396: 14038: 13762: 12671: 12516: 12398: 12170: 12119: 11980: 11787: 11368: 11302: 11216: 10480: 10352: 9950: 9691: 9166: 8759: 8187: 7888: 7819: 7669: 7484: 7385: 7079: 6743: 6665: 6339: 6306: 6091: 5898: 5457: 5397: 4991:

Yes, the peer reviewed paper I found talking about the unreliable coverage of the case is specifically about those two papers.

4910: 3778: 3259: 3190: 3068: 2720: 2347: 2315: 2026: 1649:

distributor, I doubt word of it would have reached beyond his immediate media coverage zone, and that it would it be sustained.

1594: 1191: 1122: 985: 491: 195: 94: 91: 79: 18894: 15733: 13652: 12983: 12446: 11208: 10002: 9871: 8657: 8228: 7561:, the article is basically just a track list, and the article is entirely unsourced. Tag with r from album after redirecting. 7312: 3703: 1856: 18784: 18753: 18745: 18139: 18086: 18065: 18014: 17957: 17931: 17488: 17426: 16856: 15892: 15159: 15130: 15099: 13723: 10172: 10078: 9551: 9025: 8605: 8600: 7364: 7172: 6597: 6273: 5541: 4196: 3651: 3646: 2687: 1560: 654: 587: 257: 109: 88: 19010: 16412: 15842: 15447: 14717: 13288: 9354:. Looks like a GNG pass with the sources in the article, plus some sources I can't access look like possible SIGCOV (namely 7042: 3033: 18416: 18115:

I can't find any sourcing for the show. A Gnewspaper search turns up the phrase, but no tv show articles. I suppose it's a

17903: 15575: 14359: 12381: 11615: 11405: 11113: 10335: 8609: 8183: 7326: 7318: 6644: 6221: 6216: 3755:

is no longer a valid SNG, so GNG must be met. It needs several refs from independent, reliable, secondary sources to pass

3655: 3051: 2654: 1708: 1527: 968: 277: 263: 18977: 16379: 15691: 15405: 14992: 14794: 14030: 12946: 11538: 9834: 7435: 7009: 6715: 1933: 950: 808:

What about a redirect to the Pacific Oceania team that competed, there plenty of coverage about the team she played with?

524:- one of those "trivial" sources establishes a claim to notability: the first Tahitian to compete in the Federation Cup.-- 18383: 17870: 17102: 16179: 15875: 14326: 14243: 12979: 11887: 11817: 11724: 11694: 10648: 9867: 9502: 6724:

He has a role in a student federation and is also a PR person in Muhimmathul Muslimeen Education Centre. He lack SIGCOV.

6225: 5850:

Contested PROD, so this is the next step. Another editor commented on the taIk page that they don't see how this passes

4131:? The only two sources that aren't trivial occurred within a week of each other, clearly failing the "prolonged" clause. 3271: 2571: 444: 85: 21: 18737: 18028: 16922:. I agree that the Derbyshire Times source is reasonably good, but not enough. The other sources are trivial / routine. 16766: 16621: 15658: 15372: 14952:. The sources only say that after getting expelled from the MHP in 2017, Akşener was going to create her own party with 14006: 13251: 12788:

based contributor, I can perhaps provide you with an easy criterium for notability for artists in the region - Does the

10131: 5795: 5325: 4868: 2279: 18173: 17985: 17771: 14451: 13400: 13284: 13064:

Thank you for your suggestion. I'm new here to write the article so that I need to learn more and get used to with it.

12670:

for review until you gain experience. They will be very helpful if you ask them questions about sources. There is also

12039: 11578: 11283: 8592: 8477: 8375: 7728: 7360: 5174:. In any case, sourcing does not have to be in the English language, so the nomination is based on a false premise. -- 3638: 1475: 1470: 411: 180: 175: 14757: 13973: 11611: 9610: 9084: 5496: 4835: 2884:

https://www.indianretailer.com/interview/retail-people/new-commerce/how-lilgoodness-healthifying-kids-snacking-segment

2811:. There is enough coverage of this Indian company and the founder on reliable and mainstream Indian news portals.: --> 2246: 2056:

No claim whatsover of notability. Two of the sources are dead links and the other is merely a run-of-the-mill listing.

1896: 18925: 18920: 17065: 16997:. Consensus is we have verification of role that meets N:POL. Sourcing to improve the article can be found after AfD 16327: 16322: 16161: 14790: 14494:

at the Wayback Machine. I'm as big an inclusionist as the next guy but this was already a borderline pass of the old

13424: 13386: 12958: 11682: 10394: 9846: 9816: 6957: 6952: 6208: 6005: 5966: 5925: 4055:

is another trivial mention by the same outlet as #5. This is exceptionally far from passing GNG, let alone YOUNGATH.

3110: 2602: 2597: 1929: 1479: 1027: 328: 185: 17098: 15934: 14486:

It would be different if there was any verifiable information out there on him, but there just isn't. Hell, I wrote

13648: 13492: 13029: 9917: 5758: 5288: 4424: 3993: 19103: 18929: 18331: 18326: 17818: 17813: 17690:

The source found by Curbon7 (and now in the article) shows that the subject did serve in the Somalia Parliament. -

17394: 16331: 15421:

A quick Google search didn't reveal any independent sources for this musician, who doesn't seem to meet any of the

14274: 14269: 14104: 13689: 13263: 13068:

might seem promo article, I will fix that thing right aways. Thank you for spending some time to read my articles.

12792:

hold at least one of their pieces? If not, then they are most likely to end up here, in the Articles For Deletion.

12440: 12229: 12002: 11171: 9929:

This editor has had 11 articles moved to draftspace, and 10 articles rejected at AFC, 2 speedy deletes and 3 AFDs.

8651: 7939: 7691: 6961: 5791: 5321: 3697: 2917:

https://www.indianretailer.com/article/retail-business/consumer-trends/what-makes-healthy-snacking-next-big-segment

2606: 2428: 2295:

The page has COI in past. Currently, all news are related to company profile, funding, data breach incident. Fails

1274: 153: 34: 18733: 13334: 12035: 11590: 9573: 9047: 7724: 7554: 7512: 7464: 7295: 6267: 3275: 18335: 17822: 15606: 15601: 15320: 15315: 14769: 14278: 12911: 12738: 12655: 12619: 12556: 12403: 11661: 11442:. Ultimately it's a partial match for a wide range of places and concepts; the search system is better for that. 11418: 11138: 10357: 9799: 9606: 9080: 6640: 4507:

The Saivou, Seaqaqa in Macuata youngster says he was inspired by how the Lautoka striker performed on the field.

4053: 3073: 1908: 1462: 990: 232: 170: 42: 17: 17077: 15897: 14840: 14491: 13644: 13042:. Sources are all promotional, nothing that meets SIGCOV addressing the subject directly and indepth from I RS. 10390: 8501:

does not meet notability guidelines. No prejudice to recreating the article in the future when and if it does.

8369:, but the author being its inventor also makes it verge on promotion. Would not be useful as a redirect either. 7401: 6681: 3106: 2648: 1979: 1521: 1023: 631: 18971: 18912: 18649: 18571: 18233: 18102: 17442: 17258:

Mm. I agree generally, however with little information that we can verify, I'm not sure how we write the page.

17148: 16373: 16314: 16087:

suggestion. Almost everyperson in that list are not famous/notable for being bodygurad and need to be removed.

15930: 15610: 15436: 15324: 14022:

Couldn't find any significant coverage in independent reliable sources, and subject doesn't appear to meet any

13233: 12674:

where you can post sources and ask questions regarding notability. You can also request help/advice anytime at

11560: 10975: 8614: 7583: 7356: 7003: 6944: 5770: 5300: 5130: 5001: 4897: 4041: 3660: 3528:

This continues the systematic bias problem, but unfortunately the sources don't establish that WP:NBIO is met.

2589: 359: 354: 18377: 17864: 15077:

I am convinced by the discussion above that this party is not notable. Struck through former comment. Delete.

14320: 13484: 13216: 12436: 12014: 11673:. The CfD reached an agreement that "Belarus" as we know it today didn't exist until the 20th century, and as 8647: 7787: 7703: 6230: 5841: 5371: 3693: 1781: 18318: 18024: 17805: 15652: 15366: 14261: 13921: 13916: 13507: 13480: 13459: 13417: 13379: 13194: 12233: 12085: 11188: 9585: 9059: 8816: 8472: 8370: 7857: 7774: 6636: 6263: 4783: 4778: 2194: 2189: 1772:

per above discussion. Specifically, I wish to note that College Park is a city of about 35,000 residents. We

363: 18749: 16125:

No more indiscriminate than any other list of people by profession, a perfectly acceptable topic for a list.

13490: 12415: 10369: 9656: 9130: 4274:

YOUNGATH explains what constitutes GNG coverage of young athletes, it's not a separate guideline criterion.

3085: 2611: 1484: 1002: 405: 242: 18934: 17047: 16336: 15909: 15593: 15307: 13967: 13925: 12954: 12819: 11543: 11191:. It is not useful to the reader in any substantive way. There is also a disambiguation page, currently at 10440: 10313: 9842: 9808: 9800: 6966: 6186: 5244: 4829: 4787: 4428: 4005: 3156: 2644: 2240: 2198: 1698: 1664:

has a footnote that uses the word "depth" a number of times, and I don't think we have depth at this point.

1517: 1440: 1073: 472: 190: 18967: 18699: 18340: 17827: 17675:

but we are unable to find source so I think that we should have to take help from any establish editor of

17603:

Clarifying - there are sources that verify service in the Somali Parliament meaning the subject does pass

16369: 15980: 15767:

They've purchased another company, but that's about all the coverage there is in Gnews. Not meeting CORP.

14283: 12995: 12696:

You stated "I asked his wife (who attended the show) to send me his headshot." The photo you uploaded at

11677:

argued (successfully in my opinion), the princes of Polotsk, Minsk, Turov and the Grand Duke of Lithuania

11247:

per nom. I came across this the other day and noticed it but didn't get around to doing anything about it.

9883: 8626: 7799: 6999: 3672: 247: 19097: 18956: 18889: 18373: 18362: 17860: 17849: 17390: 16884: 16358: 15919: 15637: 15615: 15351: 15329: 14961: 14779: 14722: 14316: 14305: 13952: 13662: 13273: 13259: 12968: 12486: 12425: 12024: 11855: 11741: 11710: 11600: 11256: 11117: 10882: 10379: 9856: 9595: 9069: 8697: 8636: 8461: 8342:

It would not be a very useful redirect, since the title is quite complicated and the page is an orphan. —

8271: 8201: 7713: 7374: 7195: 6988: 6654: 6252: 6242: 5780: 5310: 5270: 4889: 4814: 3743: 3682: 3095: 2804: 2633: 2424: 2225: 1918: 1861: 1506: 1270: 1012: 543: 390: 346: 237: 146: 18741: 15648: 15362: 13300: 11586: 10112: 6502:

would be the best choice, since he himself is notable and this apartment building is part of his work.

6313: 4384:

based on comments by Hey man I’m Josh and Beaniefan11. Upon a further review of sources, it is probably

2703:

Not meeting CORP. Routine funding announcements and product launches are all that's discussed in media.

368: 17781: 17712: 17683: 17373: 17321: 17303: 17087: 17015: 17004: 14765: 13930: 13908: 12950: 11627: 9838: 8133: 7097: 7065: 6087: 4966: 4792: 4770: 4644: 2623: 2203: 2181: 1904: 1496: 760: 401: 18946: 17073: 16348: 14806: 13963: 12640:

Ive posted other artists (particularly musicians) under other wikinames before with similar sources.

12411: 12107: 11132: 10046: 10019: 8347: 8283: 6978: 4825: 2694: 2236: 1945: 1567: 1090:

notability for this 2013 PhD with a handful of articles and few citations. Google scholar profile at

19206: 19017: 18863: 18840: 18610: 18586: 18352: 18277: 18254: 18229: 17839: 17758: 17735: 17114: 16985: 16962: 16419: 16273: 16250: 15816: 15793: 15534: 15511: 15248: 15225: 14964:

in the article, the Nationalist Turkey Party was already founded in 2011 (p. 4), and Akşener created

14694: 14671: 14295: 14220: 14197: 13867: 13844: 13559: 13536: 13467: 13255: 13225: 13217: 13181: 13158: 12888: 12865: 12773: 12340: 12317: 11939: 11916: 11835:

followed by the present nation-state of Belarus. A history of Belarus is a better way to handle that.

11825: 11821: 11552: 11544: 11514: 11491: 11031: 11008: 10797: 10774: 10673: 10527: 10296: 10273: 9767: 9744: 9486: 9463: 8986: 8963: 8570: 8550: 8527: 8450: 8415: 8329: 8114: 8091: 8037: 7906: 7647: 7627: 7604: 7579: 7566: 7537: 7282: 7259: 7049: 6855: 6832: 6588: 6568: 6545: 6432: 6165: 6142: 6052: 5766: 5723: 5714: 5694: 5671: 5596: 5296: 5253: 5223: 5200: 5115: 5092: 5016: 4982: 4733: 4713: 4690: 4613: 3905: 3869:

Vosagaga, who hails from Saivou Village in Seaqaqa, plays for his district’s senior and youth teams.

3599: 3576: 3006: 2983: 2548: 2525: 2403: 2140: 2117: 2008:

reference but it's clearly just a database profile page and there is nothing to suggest that this is

1833: 1810: 1423: 1400: 927: 904: 695: 300: 18423: 17910: 15627: 15341: 14366: 12010: 11582: 7699: 5807: 5337: 4509:

A striker himself, Vosagaga says he wants to follow in the footsteps of his fellow Vanua Levu mate.

1997: 17981: 15698: 15412: 14761: 12051: 11967: 11400: 11086: 11081: 10979: 10668:: Per nom. I find the above keep vote unconvincing and it fails to address the rationale provided. 10339: 10014: 9581: 9442: 9298: 9238: 9055: 8398: 7740: 7656: 4518:

The Sunil Kumar-coached side will face Samoa in its first OFC Under-17 Championship next Thursday.

3422: 3315: 3210: 3178: 3055: 1900: 1712: 1138: 1110: 511: 479: 380: 17069: 16793: 16783:

is a This is Local London "young reporter" contributed essay, not an article by a staff reporter,

16630: 13942: 12604:

classical musicians to send me pictures and news articles for wiki. Are those typically allowed?

11681:

That means all entries up to 1795 are to be deleted; it might be useful to move some content from

11095: 10365: 9622: 9096: 8366: 4804: 4113:

per the sources on the article. I agree with GiantSnowman that there is enough here to pass GNG.

3081: 2215: 998: 451: 17386: 17039: 17016: 15905: 15879: 14013: 13136: 12815: 11690: 11232: 11204: 11128: 11090: 10652: 10406: 10309: 10239: 10071: 9997: 9984: 9780: 9523: 9514: 9012: 7454: 6778: 6182: 5762: 5292: 5240: 5155: 4875: 4207:

I had closed this discussion as Keep but it has been challenged so I'm relisting this discussion.

3298: 3267: 3122: 2818: 2286: 1694: 1436: 1039: 827: 555: 15946: 12006: 10952:

Unsourced OR essay. Subject lacks SIGCOV addressing the subject directly and indepth from I RS.

10693:. We don't need a Knowledge entry for every person who gets some inane, inconsequential record. 8622: 8274:. The user who created the page identifies as the author of the article in which the concept of 7695: 7467:

as an ATD but I hesitate to do this undiscussed because this appears potentially controversial.

6116:. To argue that there's nothing wrong, when even ordinary readers know otherwise, is untenable. 5048:

you cite is indeed peer-reviewed, that would be another source that contributes towards passing

3668: 1652:

Putting the two together, his position and the charges, is how this got more than local notice.

716:, she doesn't meet the mark right now but it seems oddly strange that this is all she ever did. 19185: 19144: 18798: 18696: 18158: 18044: 18032: 17639: 17507: 16906: 16653: 16590: 16229: 16208: 14650: 14589: 14544: 14176: 13515: 13495: 13396: 12844: 12452: 12368: 12296: 11874: 11851: 11737: 11706: 11252: 10699: 10322: 9577: 9051: 8921: 8663: 8596: 8070: 7970: 6238: 5650: 5577: 5262: 5254: 4669: 4396: 4360: 4305: 4261: 4118: 3934: 3892: 3850: 3834: 3709: 3038: 2457: 2335: 2303: 1760: 1315: 955: 18852:

The following discussion is an archived debate of the proposed deletion of the article below.

18266:

The following discussion is an archived debate of the proposed deletion of the article below.

17747:

The following discussion is an archived debate of the proposed deletion of the article below.

16974:

The following discussion is an archived debate of the proposed deletion of the article below.

16262:

The following discussion is an archived debate of the proposed deletion of the article below.

15805:

The following discussion is an archived debate of the proposed deletion of the article below.

15523:

The following discussion is an archived debate of the proposed deletion of the article below.

15237:

The following discussion is an archived debate of the proposed deletion of the article below.

14683:

The following discussion is an archived debate of the proposed deletion of the article below.

14209:

The following discussion is an archived debate of the proposed deletion of the article below.

13856:

The following discussion is an archived debate of the proposed deletion of the article below.

13548:

The following discussion is an archived debate of the proposed deletion of the article below.

13170:

The following discussion is an archived debate of the proposed deletion of the article below.

12877:

The following discussion is an archived debate of the proposed deletion of the article below.

12699:

indicates this is your own work, that you are the copyright holder, and that you have legally

12407: 12329:

The following discussion is an archived debate of the proposed deletion of the article below.

11928:

The following discussion is an archived debate of the proposed deletion of the article below.

11503:

The following discussion is an archived debate of the proposed deletion of the article below.

11421:, but it's unreferenced. Another possible marker to move it away from the base title could be 11020:

The following discussion is an archived debate of the proposed deletion of the article below.

10786:

The following discussion is an archived debate of the proposed deletion of the article below.

10361: 10285:

The following discussion is an archived debate of the proposed deletion of the article below.

10159: 10065: 9756:

The following discussion is an archived debate of the proposed deletion of the article below.

9475:

The following discussion is an archived debate of the proposed deletion of the article below.

8975:

The following discussion is an archived debate of the proposed deletion of the article below.

8539:

The following discussion is an archived debate of the proposed deletion of the article below.

8103:

The following discussion is an archived debate of the proposed deletion of the article below.

7616:

The following discussion is an archived debate of the proposed deletion of the article below.

7271:

The following discussion is an archived debate of the proposed deletion of the article below.

6844:

The following discussion is an archived debate of the proposed deletion of the article below.

6557:

The following discussion is an archived debate of the proposed deletion of the article below.

6279: 6154:

The following discussion is an archived debate of the proposed deletion of the article below.

5683:

The following discussion is an archived debate of the proposed deletion of the article below.

5212:

The following discussion is an archived debate of the proposed deletion of the article below.

4702:

The following discussion is an archived debate of the proposed deletion of the article below.

4449:

And lets not forget, those two sources are from 1 and 7 January 2023 which would utterly fail

3953:- Per above. Clearly young significant figure in Fijian football with ongoing career. Thanks, 3588:

The following discussion is an archived debate of the proposed deletion of the article below.

3077: 2995:

The following discussion is an archived debate of the proposed deletion of the article below.

2537:

The following discussion is an archived debate of the proposed deletion of the article below.

2129:

The following discussion is an archived debate of the proposed deletion of the article below.

1822:

The following discussion is an archived debate of the proposed deletion of the article below.

1412:

The following discussion is an archived debate of the proposed deletion of the article below.

994: 916:

The following discussion is an archived debate of the proposed deletion of the article below.

289:

The following discussion is an archived debate of the proposed deletion of the article below.

19202: 19201: