Knowledge

Real bills doctrine

Source 📝

536:
to endow the central bank with such an authority. The author describes how in the initial passage of the act in 1913, Congress demonstrated its steadfast commitment to the "real bills" doctrine in two interrelated ways: 1) by limiting what assets the Fed could purchase, discount, and use as collateral for advances, and 2) by ensuring that any newly created government-sponsored credit enterprises were kept separate from the Federal Reserve System. During the Great Depression, however, Congress passed legislation that blurred the line between monetary and credit policy, slowly chipping away at the real bills doctrine as it sought to combat the crisis. It was in this context that Congress added Section 13(3) to the Federal Reserve Act. In tracing this history, the author concludes that the original framers of Section 13(3) meant to sanction direct Federal Reserve lending to the real economy, rather than simply to a weakened financial sector, in emergency circumstances. This Depression-era history provides insights into the evolving role of the Federal Reserve as an emergency provider of liquidity.
387:
consistent with full employment and then let the money stock adjust to money demand to achieve that desired target rate. In effect, this means that the Fed would relinquish control over the money stock, letting it expand as required in a vain effort to eliminate discrepancies between the market rate and the predetermined target rate. This low target interest rate proposal has much in common with the long-discredited real bills doctrine, according to which the money supply should expand passively to accommodate the legitimate needs of trade.
105: 63: 22: 214:, the doctrine assures that the volume of money created will be just enough to allow purchasers to buy the finished goods off the market as final product without affecting prices. From their sales receipts, businessmen then pay off their real bills bank loans. Banks retire the returned money from circulation until the next batch of goods need financing. 302:, "This so-called commercial loan theory or real bills doctrine was a basic principle underlying the money functions of the new system. The essential fallacy in the doctrine was that note issue would also vary with the price level as well as the real volume of trade. Thus its operation would be inherently inflationary or deflationary." 453:
intermediation. The quantity-theory prescription, in contrast, is for restrictions on private intermediation designed to separate 'money' from credit. Although our models are consistent with quantity-theory predictions about money supply and price-level behavior under these two policy prescriptions, the models imply that the
414:
particularly of the stock-market variety. Few bankers wished to expose themselves to such withering interrogation. To avoid such questioning, bankers refrained from applying for Federal Reserve emergency liquidity aid even though they needed it. This was especially so in the panicky situation of the October
386:
With recession lingering and interest rates remaining high, one hears increasingly that the Fed should abandon its money growth targets and move to a policy of lowering interest rates to full employment levels. All would be well, we are told, if only the Fed would set a fixed low interest rate target
535:
At the height of the financial crisis of 2007–09, the Federal Reserve conducted emergency lending under authority granted to it in the third paragraph of Section 13 of the Federal Reserve Act. This article explores the political and legislative origins of the section, focusing on why Congress chose
186:
representing claims to real goods in the process of production, the loans will be just sufficient to finance the production of goods. The doctrine seeks to have real output determine its own means of purchase without affecting prices. Under the real bills doctrine, there is only one policy role for
263:
in 1929 launched his Direct Pressure initiative. It required all member banks seeking Federal Reserve discount window assistance to affirm that they had never made speculative loans, especially of the stock-market variety. No self-respecting banker seeking to borrow emergency reserves from the Fed
418:
when bank depositors were seeking to cash in their checking deposits and take the cash from the banks. Instead of borrowing the reserves needed to meet the cash drain from the Fed and exposing themselves to "Direct Pressure" questioning, those banks failed in huge numbers. Humphrey and Timberlake
419:
assert that a real bills doctrine is essentially a "metastable mechanism", since it is "beyond" stable. They contend that the doctrine itself "does not imply either a stable or an unstable system", but that "it depends completely on the institutional environment in which the doctrine appears".
475:
The founders of the Federal Reserve desired to end financial panics. In order to achieve this end, they created a decentralized collection of reserve depositories – the Federal Reserve banks. They also wanted to remove control of the financial system from Wall Street. At the time, policymakers
413:
contraction of the money stock which precipitated the Great Depression. The "Direct Pressure" letter required any commercial bank seeking to avail itself of Fed lender-of-last-resort assistance to show, beyond a shadow of a doubt, that it had never even thought of making "speculative" loans,
354:
between "productive activity" and "speculative activity", Humphrey and Timberlake argue, the Doctrine wrongfully impugned speculation as the source of asset price bubbles and financial panic. Such flawed premises made the Fed unduly reluctant to make full use of the United States' ample gold
285:
Here was the doctrine's third flaw. It calls for pro-cyclical contractions and expansions of the money stock when correct stabilization policy calls for counter-cyclical ones. The doctrine fell into disuse in the late 1930s, but its legacy still influences banking policy from time to time.
452:
in 1982. They contended that "Two competing monetary policy prescriptions are analyzed within the context of overlapping generations models" and that "the real-bills prescription is for unfettered private intermediation or central bank operations designed to produce the effects of such
259:. Adhering to the doctrine's second flaw, namely that speculative activity/paper can be sharply distinguished from purely productive activity/paper (as if production motivated by uncertain expected future profits does not involve a speculative element), long-time Fed Board member 248:(1760–1815) was an early critic of the real bills doctrine. He noted one of the doctrine's three main flaws, namely that by linking money not to real output as the original intention was, but to the price times quantity—or nominal dollar value—of real output, it set up a positive 264:
was willing to undergo such interrogation, especially given that a "hard-boiled" Federal Reserve was unlikely to grant such aid. Instead, the banks chose to fail (and the Federal Reserve let them), which they did in large numbers, almost 9000 of them. These failures led to the
476:
understood financial panics as resulting from speculative excess, especially on Wall Street. These "real bills" views of financial panic originated in the 19th century American experience. They influenced monetary policy significantly until the post-World War II period.
700:
Reform of the Nation's Banking and Financial Systems: Hearings Before the Subcommittee on Financial Institutions Supervision, Regulation, and Insurance of the Committee on Banking, Finance, and Urban Affairs, House of Representatives, One-hundredth Congress, First
399:(1866–1953), long-term member of the Federal Reserve Board of Governors as the person most responsible. Under the influence of the RBD, Miller launched his "Direct Pressure" initiative in late 1929. That initiative, a letter sent out to all member banks of the 489:, wrote in 1927 that "The 'real bills doctrine' has its origin in banking developments of the 17th and 18th centuries. It received its first authoritative exposition in Adam Smith's Wealth of Nations, was then repudiated by 237:, by using land as a measure of, and collateral for, real activity. Smith then substituted short-term self-liquidating commercial paper for Law's production proxy, land, and so the real bills doctrine was born. 505:
in the currency-banking debate of the mid–19th century. Even now, echoes of the real bills doctrine reverberate in modern monetary theory." Green's description of the real bills doctrine was later repeated in
252:
running from price to money to price. When the monetary authority holds the market (loan) rate of interest, below the profit rate on capital, this feedback loop can generate continuing inflation.
229:(1705) originated the basic idea of the real bills doctrine, the concept of an "output-governed currency secured to real property and responding to the needs of trade". Law sought to limit 1165: 548:, and their state is maintained through distributed consensus, the concept of the real bills doctrine may have no obvious impact on their use. There have reportedly been 366:
was an American statistician and economist who was instrumental in bringing about the Treasury-Fed Accord of 1951. Riefler served as an assistant to the chairman of the
514:-backed search engine for academic publications begun in 2015. Green wrote the article entry about the "Real Bills Doctrine in Classical Economics" published in 191:: lending commercial banks the necessary reserves against real customer bills, which the banks offer as collateral. The term "real bills doctrine" was coined by 437:
cause, of the Great Depression. However, Warburton did not single out Adolph Miller as Direct Pressure's principal formulator, as Humphrey and Timberlake have.
433:
and was the only economist Timberlake and Humphrey could find who, other than themselves, identified the Direct Pressure initiative as a major cause, if not
794: 255:
Doctrinal historians have noted the real bills doctrine's place as one factor contributing to the instability of the U.S. money supply precipitating the
1063: 465:
has observed that Sargent and Wallace's version of the real bills doctrine is not the same as the one prevailing in the 19th and early 20th centuries.
278:. The result was a decade-long fall of real output and prices, which by the needs-of-trade logic of the real bills doctrine justified shrinkage of the 1201: 866: 698: 893: 370:
from 1948 to 1959. His Riefler-Burgess framework was in opposition to the real bills doctrine's use as a guiding philosophy of
1073: 849: 645: 839: 635: 523:
In 2018, Parintha Sastry's article "The Political Origins of Section 13(3) of the Federal Reserve Act" was published in the
1211: 35: 182:
says that as long as bankers lend to businessmen only against the security (collateral) of short-term 30-, 60-, or 90-day
367: 985: 876: 165: 147: 49: 750:
Laidler, David (1 February 1984). "Misconceptions about the Real-Bills Doctrine: A Comment on Sargent and Wallace".
429:
who wrote in the 1940s, 1950s, and early-1960s at a time when most other economists were Keynesians, worked for the
584:
Mints, Lloyd (February 1923). "Open Market Borrowing to Finance the Production of Goods Sold for Future Delivery".
468: 295: 1090: 486: 114: 79: 531:. In this article Sastry discussed the role of the real bills doctrine in the financial crisis of 2007–2009: 449: 395:, discussed the real bills doctrine (RBD) and the chief personnel involved in its failure. They identified 1115: 717:
Journal of Institutional and Theoretical Economics (JITE) / Zeitschrift für die gesamte Staatswissenschaft
1196: 342:
and led to the Great Depression. Skeptics of this hypothesis that cite other monetary crises – like the
485:
Australian Professor Emeritus Roy Green, a Special Advisor and Chair for UTS Innovation Council at the
1166:"Facebook's Mark Zuckerberg seeks to reassure wary lawmakers about Libra, elections in rare D.C. trip" 490: 245: 1141: 524: 454: 294:
In 1988, economist James Parthemos, a former senior vice president and director of research at the
41: 403:, led to the wave of bank failures. Nine-thousand banks failed, and their failure resulted in the 938: 553: 511: 502: 339: 1216: 400: 118: 923: 497:
in the famous bullionist controversy, and was finally rehabilitated as the 'law of reflux' by
343: 335: 310:
held that opinion but did not discuss its full implications in their book published in 1963,
371: 222: 448:
published "The Real-Bills Doctrine Versus The Quantity Theory: A Reconsideration" for the
129: 8: 363: 206:
are granted to businessmen in the form either of new bank notes or of additions to their
966: 775: 732: 601: 347: 323: 230: 1036: 274:
contraction of the money stock, which, according to Friedman and Schwartz, caused the
1069: 970: 958: 919: 872: 845: 779: 767: 724: 641: 605: 441: 207: 1206: 950: 759: 637:
Legislating Instability: Adam Smith, Free Banking, and the Financial Crisis of 1772
593: 544:
systems do not require a central authority such as the Federal Reserve Bank or the
516: 507: 396: 331: 275: 260: 256: 183: 393:
Gold, the Real Bills Doctrine, and the Fed: Sources of Monetary Disorder 1922–1938
422: 351: 303: 234: 199:. The doctrine was previously known as "the commercial loan theory of banking". 125: 841:
Monetary Policy in the United States: An Intellectual and Institutional History
623:(1945 ed.). Chicago & London: University of Chicago Press. p. vi. 565: 541: 458: 338:" – the unprecedented collapse of the U.S. money supply, which began after the 1190: 962: 771: 728: 715:
Selgin, G. A. (1989). "The Analytical Framework of the Real-Bills Doctrine".
494: 462: 327: 307: 249: 227:
Money and Trade Considered: With a Proposal for Supplying a Nation with Money
1143:
How 18th Century Ideas of Money Supply Can Help Identify Problems with Libra
670:
Money and Trade Considered With a Proposal for Supplying a Nation with Money
685:
An Enquiry into the Nature and Effects of the Paper Credit of Great Britain
561: 549: 498: 445: 241: 188: 1011: 279: 211: 192: 736: 939:"The Real-Bills Doctrine versus the Quantity Theory: A Reconsideration" 557: 545: 426: 415: 218: 203: 1091:"The Political Origins of Section 13(3) of the Federal Reserve Act" 954: 763: 597: 621:
A History of Banking Theory in Great Britain and the United States
1116:"China Is Said to be Cracking Down on a Cryptocurrency Loophole" 350:– to their true source: the real bills doctrine. By drawing a 430: 391:
Thomas Humphrey and Richard Timberlake in their 2019 book,
334:. Today the gold standard remains a popular scapegoat for " 480: 865:
Glasner, David; Cooley, Thomas F.; Murphy, Larry (1997).
461:
and the real-bills prescription is." Monetary historian
289: 1062:
Eatwell, John; Milgate, Murray; Newman, Peter (1992).
210:, which deposits constitute the main component of the 937:
Sargent, Thomas J.; Wallace, Neil (1 December 1982).
1061: 894:""The Treasury-Fed Accord." Federal Reserve History" 827:. Princeton, New Jersey: Princeton University Press. 901:
Federal Reserve Bank of Richmond Economic Quarterly
864: 802:
Federal Reserve Bank of Richmond Economic Quarterly
825:A Monetary History of the United States, 1867-1960 76:Needs to reflect best academic historical opinion. 986:"The Real Bills Views of the Founders of the Fed" 1188: 1065:The New Palgrave Dictionary of Money and Finance 868:Business Cycles and Depressions: An Encyclopedia 822: 892:Hetzel, Robert; Leach, Ralph F. (Winter 2001). 244:, anti-slavery activist, and monetary theorist 936: 682: 217:The doctrine has roots in some statements of 823:Friedman, Milton; Schwartz, Anna J. (1963). 795:"Historical Origins of the Cost-Push Theory" 891: 672:(2nd ed.). Edinburgh: Andrew Anderson. 72:needs attention from an expert in Economics 50:Learn how and when to remove these messages 837: 556:(formerly known as Libra), a commissioned 358: 128:. Please do not remove this message until 633: 166:Learn how and when to remove this message 148:Learn how and when to remove this message 913: 704:. U.S. Government Printing Office. 1988. 124:Relevant discussion may be found on the 749: 481:Real bills doctrine in the 21st century 377: 312:A Monetary History of the United States 1189: 984:Hetzel, Robert (Second Quarter 2014). 983: 714: 683:Thornton, Henry; Hayek, F. A. (1939). 82:may be able to help recruit an expert. 1202:Great Depression in the United States 618: 583: 425:, an early-pre-Friedman-and-Schwartz 240:The British banker, parliamentarian, 1163: 792: 317: 290:Commercial bank clearinghouse system 98: 56: 15: 918:. Social Science Research Network. 667: 560:which was proposed by the American 13: 1088: 992:. Federal Reserve Bank of Richmond 368:Federal Reserve Board of Governors 14: 1228: 31:This article has multiple issues. 1164:Romm, Tony (19 September 2019). 1095:Federal Reserve Bank of New York 469:Federal Reserve Bank of Richmond 382:In 1982, Thomas Humphrey wrote, 296:Federal Reserve Bank of Richmond 103: 61: 20: 1157: 1134: 1108: 1082: 1055: 1029: 1016:University of Technology Sydney 1004: 977: 930: 907: 885: 858: 844:. University of Chicago Press. 838:Timberlake, Richard H. (1993). 831: 816: 487:University of Technology Sydney 471:economist Robert Hetzel wrote: 39:or discuss these issues on the 786: 743: 708: 691: 676: 661: 634:Goodspeed, Tyler Beck (2016). 627: 612: 577: 1: 570: 943:Journal of Political Economy 914:Humphrey, Thomas M. (1982). 752:Journal of Political Economy 640:. Harvard University Press. 586:Journal of Political Economy 450:Journal of Political Economy 7: 1212:History of economic thought 197:A History of Banking Theory 130:conditions to do so are met 74:. The specific problem is: 10: 1233: 871:. Taylor & Francis. 619:Mints, Lloyd W. (1945). 525:New York Federal Reserve 916:The Real Bills Doctrine 512:artificial intelligence 359:Financial panic of 1929 340:1929 stock market crash 298:, wrote for the bank's 538: 529:Economic Policy Review 478: 401:Federal Reserve system 389: 687:. New York: Rinehart. 554:Diem digital currency 533: 473: 384: 344:German hyperinflation 336:the Great Contraction 80:WikiProject Economics 793:Humphrey, Thomas M. 457:prescription is not 378:Federal Reserve Bank 372:U.S. monetary policy 1089:Sastry, Parinitha. 364:Winfield W. Riefler 330:did not create the 225:(1671–1729) in his 180:real bills doctrine 117:of this article is 1197:Monetary economics 990:Economic Quarterly 668:Law, John (1720). 348:Mississippi Bubble 324:Richard Timberlake 300:Economic Quarterly 231:monetary expansion 195:in his 1945 book, 1075:978-1-349-11721-5 851:978-0-226-80384-5 647:978-0-674-08888-7 442:Thomas J. Sargent 318:The gold standard 208:checking deposits 176: 175: 168: 158: 157: 150: 97: 96: 54: 1224: 1181: 1180: 1178: 1176: 1161: 1155: 1154: 1152: 1150: 1138: 1132: 1131: 1129: 1127: 1112: 1106: 1105: 1103: 1101: 1086: 1080: 1079: 1059: 1053: 1052: 1050: 1048: 1043:. 20 August 2011 1041:The Conversation 1033: 1027: 1026: 1024: 1022: 1008: 1002: 1001: 999: 997: 981: 975: 974: 949:(6): 1212–1236. 934: 928: 927: 911: 905: 904: 898: 889: 883: 882: 862: 856: 855: 835: 829: 828: 820: 814: 813: 811: 809: 799: 790: 784: 783: 747: 741: 740: 712: 706: 705: 695: 689: 688: 680: 674: 673: 665: 659: 658: 656: 654: 631: 625: 624: 616: 610: 609: 581: 517:The New Palgrave 508:Semantic Scholar 412: 411: 407: 397:Adolph C. Miller 332:Great Depression 276:Great Depression 273: 272: 268: 261:Adolph C. Miller 257:Great Depression 184:commercial paper 171: 164: 153: 146: 142: 139: 133: 107: 106: 99: 92: 89: 83: 65: 64: 57: 46: 24: 23: 16: 1232: 1231: 1227: 1226: 1225: 1223: 1222: 1221: 1187: 1186: 1185: 1184: 1174: 1172: 1170:Washington Post 1162: 1158: 1148: 1146: 1140: 1139: 1135: 1125: 1123: 1114: 1113: 1109: 1099: 1097: 1087: 1083: 1076: 1060: 1056: 1046: 1044: 1035: 1034: 1030: 1020: 1018: 1010: 1009: 1005: 995: 993: 982: 978: 935: 931: 912: 908: 896: 890: 886: 879: 863: 859: 852: 836: 832: 821: 817: 807: 805: 797: 791: 787: 748: 744: 713: 709: 697: 696: 692: 681: 677: 666: 662: 652: 650: 648: 632: 628: 617: 613: 582: 578: 573: 483: 455:quantity-theory 423:Clark Warburton 409: 405: 404: 380: 361: 352:false dichotomy 320: 308:Anna J.Schwartz 304:Milton Friedman 292: 270: 266: 265: 235:price stability 172: 161: 160: 159: 154: 143: 137: 134: 123: 108: 104: 93: 87: 84: 78: 66: 62: 25: 21: 12: 11: 5: 1230: 1220: 1219: 1214: 1209: 1204: 1199: 1183: 1182: 1156: 1133: 1107: 1081: 1074: 1054: 1028: 1003: 976: 955:10.1086/261118 929: 906: 884: 877: 857: 850: 830: 815: 785: 764:10.1086/261213 758:(1): 149–155. 742: 723:(3): 489–507. 707: 690: 675: 660: 646: 626: 611: 598:10.1086/253494 575: 574: 572: 569: 566:Facebook, Inc. 552:problems with 542:cryptocurrency 482: 479: 459:Pareto optimal 379: 376: 374:in the 1930s. 360: 357: 319: 316: 291: 288: 246:Henry Thornton 242:philanthropist 174: 173: 156: 155: 111: 109: 102: 95: 94: 69: 67: 60: 55: 29: 28: 26: 19: 9: 6: 4: 3: 2: 1229: 1218: 1217:Gold standard 1215: 1213: 1210: 1208: 1205: 1203: 1200: 1198: 1195: 1194: 1192: 1171: 1167: 1160: 1145: 1144: 1137: 1121: 1117: 1111: 1096: 1092: 1085: 1077: 1071: 1067: 1066: 1058: 1042: 1038: 1032: 1017: 1013: 1007: 991: 987: 980: 972: 968: 964: 960: 956: 952: 948: 944: 940: 933: 925: 921: 917: 910: 903:: footnote 5. 902: 895: 888: 880: 878:9780824009441 874: 870: 869: 861: 853: 847: 843: 842: 834: 826: 819: 803: 796: 789: 781: 777: 773: 769: 765: 761: 757: 753: 746: 738: 734: 730: 726: 722: 718: 711: 703: 702: 694: 686: 679: 671: 664: 649: 643: 639: 638: 630: 622: 615: 607: 603: 599: 595: 591: 587: 580: 576: 568: 567: 563: 559: 555: 551: 547: 543: 537: 532: 530: 526: 521: 519: 518: 513: 509: 504: 500: 496: 492: 488: 477: 472: 470: 466: 464: 463:David Laidler 460: 456: 451: 447: 443: 438: 436: 432: 428: 424: 420: 417: 402: 398: 394: 388: 383: 375: 373: 369: 365: 356: 353: 349: 345: 341: 337: 333: 329: 328:gold standard 325: 322:According to 315: 314:, 1867–1960. 313: 309: 305: 301: 297: 287: 283: 281: 277: 262: 258: 253: 251: 250:feedback loop 247: 243: 238: 236: 233:and maintain 232: 228: 224: 220: 215: 213: 209: 205: 202:Moreover, as 200: 198: 194: 190: 185: 181: 170: 167: 152: 149: 141: 131: 127: 121: 120: 116: 110: 101: 100: 91: 81: 77: 73: 70:This article 68: 59: 58: 53: 51: 44: 43: 38: 37: 32: 27: 18: 17: 1173:. Retrieved 1169: 1159: 1147:. Retrieved 1142: 1136: 1124:. Retrieved 1119: 1110: 1098:. Retrieved 1094: 1084: 1068:. Springer. 1064: 1057: 1045:. Retrieved 1040: 1031: 1019:. Retrieved 1015: 1006: 994:. Retrieved 989: 979: 946: 942: 932: 915: 909: 900: 887: 867: 860: 840: 833: 824: 818: 806:. Retrieved 801: 788: 755: 751: 745: 720: 716: 710: 699: 693: 684: 678: 669: 663: 651:. Retrieved 636: 629: 620: 614: 589: 585: 579: 562:social media 550:money supply 539: 534: 528: 522: 515: 484: 474: 467: 446:Neil Wallace 439: 434: 421: 392: 390: 385: 381: 362: 321: 311: 299: 293: 284: 254: 239: 226: 216: 201: 196: 189:central bank 179: 177: 162: 144: 135: 113: 85: 75: 71: 47: 40: 34: 33:Please help 30: 1037:"Roy Green" 1012:"Roy Green" 440:Economists 280:money stock 212:money stock 193:Lloyd Mints 1191:Categories 592:: 128–38. 571:References 558:blockchain 546:World Bank 427:monetarist 416:1929 crash 355:reserves. 219:Adam Smith 204:bank loans 115:neutrality 36:improve it 971:153585267 963:0022-3808 780:222442568 772:0022-3808 729:0932-4569 606:154699071 520:in 2018. 503:Fullarton 138:June 2020 126:talk page 88:June 2020 42:talk page 1149:19 April 737:40751223 653:21 April 564:company 491:Thornton 346:and the 223:John Law 119:disputed 1207:Finance 1120:Fortune 924:2120000 701:Session 495:Ricardo 408:⁄ 269:⁄ 1175:14 May 1126:14 May 1122:. 2018 1072:  1047:12 May 1021:12 May 996:27 May 969:  961:  922:  875:  848:  778:  770:  735:  727:  644:  604:  540:Since 326:, the 1100:9 May 967:S2CID 897:(PDF) 808:9 May 798:(PDF) 776:S2CID 733:JSTOR 602:S2CID 510:, an 499:Tooke 1177:2020 1151:2020 1128:2020 1102:2020 1070:ISBN 1049:2020 1023:2020 998:2020 959:ISSN 920:SSRN 873:ISBN 846:ISBN 810:2020 804:: 58 768:ISSN 725:ISSN 655:2020 642:ISBN 501:and 493:and 444:and 431:FDIC 306:and 187:the 178:The 112:The 951:doi 760:doi 721:145 594:doi 527:'s 435:the 1193:: 1168:. 1118:. 1093:. 1039:. 1014:. 988:. 965:. 957:. 947:90 945:. 941:. 899:. 800:. 774:. 766:. 756:92 754:. 731:. 719:. 600:. 590:31 588:. 282:. 221:. 45:. 1179:. 1153:. 1130:. 1104:. 1078:. 1051:. 1025:. 1000:. 973:. 953:: 926:. 881:. 854:. 812:. 782:. 762:: 739:. 657:. 608:. 596:: 410:3 406:1 271:3 267:1 169:) 163:( 151:) 145:( 140:) 136:( 132:. 122:. 90:) 86:( 52:) 48:(

Index

improve it
talk page
Learn how and when to remove these messages
WikiProject Economics
neutrality
disputed
talk page
conditions to do so are met
Learn how and when to remove this message
Learn how and when to remove this message
commercial paper
central bank
Lloyd Mints
bank loans
checking deposits
money stock
Adam Smith
John Law
monetary expansion
price stability
philanthropist
Henry Thornton
feedback loop
Great Depression
Adolph C. Miller
Great Depression
money stock
Federal Reserve Bank of Richmond
Milton Friedman
Anna J.Schwartz

Text is available under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License. Additional terms may apply.