97:
65:
135:
76:
290:
34:
169:
83:
225:
207:
1045:
982:
1180:, which puts the above quote into context. I understand "liked article" to mean "linked article in en.wiki", and perhaps we need to insert that term to avoid ambiguity. I don't think a link to another language Knowledge is enough for a dab page entry: the reader should be able to find out more in English about the topic, so we need a blue link to complement the
75:
82:
1153:
to be on
English Knowledge but were since deleted at AFD/PROD, but the old articles were already translated to other language editions, resulting in an apparent "gap" that won't be filled. But yeah, go read the other language's article, and take a decent guess as to whether it'd pass notability
1157:
That being said, disambiguation pages are the wild west, and I was put off from editing them for some time after another editor rather rudely reverted me several times when I added some red links, when I had even been planning on translating the added articles over to en-wiki. (In the realm of
1140:
DABRED contains the information you're looking for: "Do not create red links to articles that are unlikely ever to be written, or are likely to be removed as insufficiently notable topics." Bearing in mind that other language editions of
Knowledge have differing standards of notability, and
1219:
To be clear, I'm definitely not advocating for mass inclusion of anything in any other language wiki. As I wrote above, a foreign language article is a good clue that the topic is notable, but a clue != inclusion for sure. That said, I'm not sure the number of incoming links is really
1158:
saltily fighting ancient battles, I will note that all of the links I added except one do indeed have articles now.) So there are clearly editors who disagree out there, and you might yet run into one; I just think they're wrong and not in compliance with the guideline.
1224:
useful a measure. I've found articles on plainly 100% notable people who, when I searched for them, had mentions all over the place on
English Knowledge, but that were in plain text and not already linked. (Mostly academics whose work was being cited in citations.)
1488:
Wikidata has had serious issues regarding verifiability and reliability. So, while we don’t mind if
Wikidata takes its information from us, it does not work in the other direction. We don’t take information from Wikidata (except in the limited ways specified).
1107:. Wouldn't it be a good idea to add something about it? I'd like to add something about it, but I'm not sure what to add. If the article exists in a foreign language Knowledge, would it count as a blue link? or would all the rules for red links still apply?
1271:
a few years ago, which after a great deal of discussion concluded "OK in some circumstances, but leave it to editors to use common sense and judgement of context to decide for themselves what these circumstances are."
1190:
red link. If we allow entries which are only linked to a non-English wikipedia article, our dab pages could expand to include every biography on any other wikipedia, every hamlet in the world even where there is no
601:
1387:
is itself concerned with acronyms. This makes it quite "meta" and harder to read and understand. An example using acronyms that are about something other than acronyms would make it much clearer in my opinion.
842:
1134:
1116:
1517:
Yes, we absolutely should not be linking directly to wikidata from disambiguation pages. Although there has been some contention elsewhere about whether it might be acceptable to use wikidata with
838:
1094:
1290:. Perhaps I'll start a discussion on that talk page regarding what does "under certain circumstances" mean. I, for one, have no idea. Examples, which this page has lots of, would be useful.
1178:
A link to a non-existent article (a "red link") should be included on a disambiguation page only when a linked article (not just other disambiguation pages) also includes that red link.
1268:
1353:
1125:, and there are tons of articles that could be added to it if it's allowed to add articles in foreign language Wikipedias. But I'm not sure whether this would be permissible.
763:
757:
751:
745:
739:
733:
727:
721:
715:
709:
703:
697:
691:
685:
679:
673:
667:
661:
655:
649:
643:
637:
631:
625:
619:
613:
607:
595:
589:
583:
577:
571:
565:
470:
466:
462:
458:
454:
450:
446:
442:
438:
434:
430:
426:
422:
418:
414:
410:
406:
402:
398:
394:
390:
386:
382:
378:
374:
370:
366:
362:
358:
354:
350:
346:
342:
338:
334:
1089:
559:
553:
547:
541:
535:
529:
523:
517:
511:
330:
326:
322:
318:
314:
310:
306:
302:
298:
1026:
1482:
1031:
968:
909:
1064:
1001:
1304:
I would suggest that the solution to having a redlinked article on a DAB page isn’t to link to a sister project, but to write an article on that topic/subject
1572:
Personally, I don't think it ever is. But in articles, there has been some contention about this. But for disambiguation page, it has never been appropriate.
1567:
1512:
1498:
1372:
1321:
1299:
1281:
1167:
905:
1580:
1549:
1473:
I think the sentence should be about not linking to non-encyclopedic sister projects such as
Wikidata or Wikivoyage, since Knowledge is an encyclopedia.
1397:
1247:: often, topics are mentioned in other more generic or related articles, so you can actually start even without a red link if you're unsure if there's
1260:
1331:
1103:
is currently silent on whether it would be OK to add entries to disambiguation pages if the article exists in a foreign language wikipedia using the
188:
923:
1432:
1414:
828:
1535:
1141:
differing levels of willingness / ability to enforce their standards... in general, a foreign language article is a good clue that the topic
852:
1234:
1214:
159:
1462:
Knowledge article has an entry in
Wikidata. Wikidata is the database used to connect entries between different languages. See for example
1554:
Suggest you look in the archives, both here and at the various
Village Pump pages… we have had a LOT of discussions about how (and even
1601:
1440:
928:
899:
251:
848:
862:
182:
70:
1378:
895:
247:
232:
212:
1341:
242:
1055:
1037:
992:
974:
858:
918:
177:
955:
1545:
1508:
1478:
1349:
1295:
1130:
1112:
17:
822:
96:
64:
1082:
1019:
192:
of
Knowledge's policy and guideline documents is available, offering valuable insights and recommendations.
144:
45:
483:
1104:
780:
112:(MoS) guidelines by addressing inconsistencies, refining language, and integrating guidance effectively.
1541:
1504:
1474:
1345:
1291:
1126:
1108:
148:
109:
104:
872:
818:
237:
152:
884:
1452:
Do not add entries where the content is on any other sister project, like
Wikidata or Wikivoyage
108:, a collaborative effort focused on enhancing clarity, consistency, and cohesiveness across the
799:
147:
procedure and is given additional attention, as it closely associated to the
English Knowledge
1122:
51:
1419:
Not yet. I'll go away and think of one. I may be a while. In the meantime please enjoy some
1410:
1244:
948:
8:
1446:
1333:
1287:
1248:
868:
1563:
1494:
1368:
1360:
1317:
1277:
1230:
1163:
1059:
996:
791:
1577:
1532:
1428:
1393:
1173:
1076:
1013:
189:
guidance on how to contribute to the development and revision of Knowledge policies
1405:
1050:
987:
941:
1205:
479:
1595:
1559:
1490:
1364:
1359:
So as to not have two discussions at two pages… please leave any comments at
1313:
1273:
1256:
1226:
1159:
289:
134:
1540:
You lost me. Why would it be acceptable to use {{ill}} to link to Wikidata?
1573:
1528:
1521:
1424:
1389:
1192:
1184:
1149:
fine. As an extreme example of the bad case, there are some articles that
1558:) we should incorporate Wikidata. There is a lot of negativity about it.
1420:
1384:
1070:
1007:
484:
1100:
1463:
1449:
about wikidata and wikivoyage makes no sense. The sentence reads as "
1196:
1095:
Red links in English, but blue links in Wikipedias in other languages
176:
For information on Knowledge's approach to the establishment of new
1252:
481:
168:
1062:. Readers of this page are welcome to comment on this redirect at
999:. Readers of this page are welcome to comment on this redirect at
1033:
970:
1065:
Knowledge:Redirects for discussion/Log/2024 April 25 § Mos:DAB
1044:
1002:
Knowledge:Redirects for discussion/Log/2024 April 25 § Mos:Dab
981:
485:
1243:
I think the best way to proceed is to look for instances of
224:
206:
1527:
to provide links to multiple languages within articles.
250:, where you can join the project or contribute to the
1058:
to determine whether its use and function meets the
995:
to determine whether its use and function meets the
492:
283:
1503:Then it sounds like we don't wnat to link to it.
1469:Not clear what is the purpose of this prohibition
240:pages on Knowledge. If you wish to help, you can
1593:
1312:to use inter-language links on the DAB page.
949:
774:This page has archives. Sections older than
1308:on enWP. Do that and there is no longer any
162:carefully and exercise caution when editing.
1286:Thank you for this info. I wasn't aware of
236:, an attempt to structure and organize all
1121:The reason I am asking is that I recently
956:
942:
1342:Knowledge talk:Disambiguation#Proposal #3
246:attached to this talk page, or visit the
44:does not require a rating on Knowledge's
514:: Apr 2005–Jun 2005 (Pre-implementation)
102:This page falls within the scope of the
14:
1594:
1441:Sentence about wikidata and wikivoyage
158:Contributors are urged to review the
118:Knowledge:WikiProject Manual of Style
260:Knowledge:WikiProject Disambiguation
155:. Both areas are subjects of debate.
121:Template:WikiProject Manual of Style
33:
31:
27:
1464:the entry for Knowledge on Wikidata
1403:Have a particular example in mind?
263:Template:WikiProject Disambiguation
50:It is of interest to the following
23:
167:
133:
24:
1613:
1379:MOS:DABACRO - not a great example
1123:created a new disambiguation page
778:may be automatically archived by
230:This page is within the scope of
1602:WikiProject Disambiguation pages
1383:The example given to illustrate
1043:
980:
288:
223:
205:
95:
81:
74:
63:
32:
1068:until a consensus is reached.
1005:until a consensus is reached.
1581:23:02, 19 September 2024 (UTC)
1568:21:29, 19 September 2024 (UTC)
1550:21:06, 19 September 2024 (UTC)
1536:20:58, 19 September 2024 (UTC)
1513:18:38, 19 September 2024 (UTC)
1499:16:59, 19 September 2024 (UTC)
1483:15:59, 19 September 2024 (UTC)
18:Knowledge talk:Manual of Style
13:
1:
1172:But the previous sentence of
7:
1105:Template:Interlanguage link
10:
1618:
1433:10:08, 1 August 2024 (UTC)
1415:00:50, 1 August 2024 (UTC)
1398:00:34, 1 August 2024 (UTC)
1145:notable, so a red link is
1090:21:51, 25 April 2024 (UTC)
1027:21:51, 25 April 2024 (UTC)
789:
233:WikiProject Disambiguation
143:This page falls under the
1373:00:52, 31 July 2024 (UTC)
1354:22:41, 30 July 2024 (UTC)
1322:20:18, 17 July 2024 (UTC)
1300:20:47, 16 July 2024 (UTC)
1282:16:10, 16 July 2024 (UTC)
1261:07:26, 16 July 2024 (UTC)
1235:08:45, 16 July 2024 (UTC)
1215:07:33, 16 July 2024 (UTC)
1168:06:06, 16 July 2024 (UTC)
1135:05:22, 16 July 2024 (UTC)
1117:05:18, 16 July 2024 (UTC)
859:Organizing dos and don'ts
286:
218:
175:
141:
105:Knowledge:Manual of Style
90:
58:
1445:The current setnence in
1056:redirects for discussion
1038:Redirects for discussion
993:redirects for discussion
975:Redirects for discussion
924:Pages in need of cleanup
124:Manual of Style articles
760:: Jan 2013–October 2015
266:Disambiguation articles
178:policies and guidelines
781:Lowercase sigmabot III
172:
138:
1332:Proposal to move the
171:
153:article titles policy
137:
1542:The Mountain of Eden
1505:The Mountain of Eden
1475:The Mountain of Eden
1346:The Mountain of Eden
1292:The Mountain of Eden
1127:The Mountain of Eden
1109:The Mountain of Eden
839:Organizing long dabs
1060:redirect guidelines
1054:has been listed at
997:redirect guidelines
991:has been listed at
754:: Aug 2010–Dec 2012
748:: Aug 2009–Oct 2009
742:: Oct 2008–Aug 2009
736:: May 2008–Oct 2008
730:: Mar 2008–Apr 2008
724:: Oct 2007–Mar 2008
718:: Jul 2007–Nov 2007
712:: May 2007–Jun 2007
706:: May 2007–Jun 2007
700:: Feb 2007–May 2007
694:: Jan 2007–Feb 2007
688:: Nov 2006–Jan 2007
682:: Sep 2006–Oct 2006
676:: Aug 2006–Sep 2006
670:: Aug 2006–Sep 2006
664:: Jul 2006–Aug 2006
658:: May 2006–Jul 2006
652:: Apr 2006–May 2006
646:: Mar 2006–Apr 2006
634:: Feb 2006–Mar 2006
622:: Jan 2006–Feb 2006
616:: Jan 2006–Feb 2006
586:: Dec 2005–Jan 2006
568:: Nov 2005–Dec 2005
556:: Aug 2005–Oct 2005
550:: Aug 2005–Oct 2005
544:: Jul 2005–Aug 2005
538:: Jul 2005–Aug 2005
532:: Jul 2005–Aug 2005
526:: Jul 2005–Aug 2005
1099:The guidelines in
173:
160:awareness criteria
145:contentious topics
139:
46:content assessment
966:
965:
919:Disambig category
788:
787:
491:
490:
282:
281:
278:
277:
274:
273:
200:
199:
196:
195:
1609:
1526:
1520:
1408:
1212:
1203:
1189:
1183:
1088:
1053:
1047:
1025:
990:
984:
958:
951:
944:
929:Pages with links
889:
883:
808:
807:
802:
783:
493:
486:
292:
284:
268:
267:
264:
261:
258:
245:
227:
220:
219:
209:
202:
201:
186:. Additionally,
126:
125:
122:
119:
116:
99:
92:
91:
86:
85:
84:
79:
78:
77:
67:
60:
59:
37:
36:
35:
28:
1617:
1616:
1612:
1611:
1610:
1608:
1607:
1606:
1592:
1591:
1524:
1518:
1443:
1404:
1381:
1338:
1206:
1197:
1187:
1181:
1097:
1087:
1069:
1049:
1041:
1024:
1006:
986:
978:
962:
906:CJKV task force
887:
881:
829:Manual of Style
806:
805:
798:
794:
779:
766:: October 2015–
500:
487:
482:
265:
262:
259:
256:
255:
241:
149:Manual of Style
123:
120:
117:
115:Manual of Style
114:
113:
110:Manual of Style
80:
73:
71:Manual of Style
22:
21:
20:
12:
11:
5:
1615:
1605:
1604:
1590:
1589:
1588:
1587:
1586:
1585:
1584:
1583:
1570:
1515:
1471:
1470:
1467:
1442:
1439:
1438:
1437:
1436:
1435:
1380:
1377:
1376:
1375:
1337:
1330:
1329:
1328:
1327:
1326:
1325:
1324:
1269:RFC about this
1264:
1263:
1241:
1240:
1239:
1238:
1237:
1155:
1096:
1093:
1073:
1040:
1030:
1010:
977:
967:
964:
963:
961:
960:
953:
946:
938:
935:
934:
933:
932:
931:
926:
921:
915:
914:
913:
903:
892:
891:
890:
885:Disambiguation
878:
877:
876:
866:
856:
849:Dos and don'ts
846:
836:
826:
813:
812:
811:Disambiguation
804:
803:
795:
790:
786:
785:
773:
770:
769:
768:
767:
761:
755:
749:
743:
737:
731:
725:
719:
713:
707:
701:
695:
689:
683:
677:
671:
665:
659:
653:
647:
641:
635:
629:
623:
617:
611:
605:
602:/Subcategories
599:
593:
587:
581:
575:
569:
563:
557:
551:
545:
539:
533:
527:
521:
515:
506:
505:
502:
501:
496:
489:
488:
480:
478:
475:
474:
294:
280:
279:
276:
275:
272:
271:
269:
257:Disambiguation
238:disambiguation
228:
216:
215:
213:Disambiguation
210:
198:
197:
194:
193:
174:
164:
163:
157:
140:
130:
129:
127:
100:
88:
87:
68:
56:
55:
49:
38:
15:
9:
6:
4:
3:
2:
1614:
1603:
1600:
1599:
1597:
1582:
1579:
1575:
1571:
1569:
1565:
1561:
1557:
1553:
1552:
1551:
1547:
1543:
1539:
1538:
1537:
1534:
1530:
1523:
1516:
1514:
1510:
1506:
1502:
1501:
1500:
1496:
1492:
1487:
1486:
1485:
1484:
1480:
1476:
1468:
1465:
1461:
1458:
1457:
1456:
1454:
1453:
1448:
1434:
1430:
1426:
1422:
1418:
1417:
1416:
1412:
1407:
1402:
1401:
1400:
1399:
1395:
1391:
1386:
1374:
1370:
1366:
1363:and not here
1362:
1358:
1357:
1356:
1355:
1351:
1347:
1343:
1335:
1323:
1319:
1315:
1311:
1307:
1303:
1302:
1301:
1297:
1293:
1289:
1285:
1284:
1283:
1279:
1275:
1270:
1267:There was an
1266:
1265:
1262:
1258:
1254:
1250:
1246:
1245:WP:DABMENTION
1242:
1236:
1232:
1228:
1223:
1218:
1217:
1216:
1213:
1211:
1210:
1204:
1202:
1201:
1195:, and so on.
1194:
1186:
1179:
1175:
1171:
1170:
1169:
1165:
1161:
1156:
1152:
1148:
1144:
1139:
1138:
1137:
1136:
1132:
1128:
1124:
1119:
1118:
1114:
1110:
1106:
1102:
1092:
1091:
1085:
1084:
1079:
1078:
1072:
1067:
1066:
1061:
1057:
1052:
1048:The redirect
1046:
1039:
1035:
1029:
1028:
1022:
1021:
1016:
1015:
1009:
1004:
1003:
998:
994:
989:
985:The redirect
983:
976:
972:
959:
954:
952:
947:
945:
940:
939:
937:
936:
930:
927:
925:
922:
920:
917:
916:
911:
907:
904:
901:
897:
894:
893:
886:
880:
879:
874:
870:
867:
864:
860:
857:
854:
850:
847:
844:
840:
837:
834:
830:
827:
824:
820:
817:
816:
815:
814:
810:
809:
801:
797:
796:
793:
782:
777:
772:
771:
765:
762:
759:
756:
753:
750:
747:
744:
741:
738:
735:
732:
729:
726:
723:
720:
717:
714:
711:
708:
705:
702:
699:
696:
693:
690:
687:
684:
681:
678:
675:
672:
669:
666:
663:
660:
657:
654:
651:
648:
645:
642:
639:
636:
633:
630:
627:
624:
621:
618:
615:
612:
609:
606:
603:
600:
597:
594:
591:
588:
585:
582:
579:
576:
573:
570:
567:
564:
561:
558:
555:
552:
549:
546:
543:
540:
537:
534:
531:
528:
525:
522:
519:
516:
513:
510:
509:
508:
507:
504:
503:
499:
495:
494:
477:
476:
473:
472:
468:
464:
460:
456:
452:
448:
444:
440:
436:
432:
428:
424:
420:
416:
412:
408:
404:
400:
396:
392:
388:
384:
380:
376:
372:
368:
364:
360:
356:
352:
348:
344:
340:
336:
332:
328:
324:
320:
316:
312:
308:
304:
300:
295:
293:
291:
285:
270:
253:
249:
244:
243:edit the page
239:
235:
234:
229:
226:
222:
221:
217:
214:
211:
208:
204:
203:
191:
190:
185:
184:
179:
170:
166:
165:
161:
156:
154:
150:
146:
136:
132:
131:
128:
111:
107:
106:
101:
98:
94:
93:
89:
72:
69:
66:
62:
61:
57:
53:
47:
43:
39:
30:
29:
26:
19:
1555:
1472:
1459:
1451:
1450:
1447:WP:DABSISTER
1444:
1382:
1339:
1336:to this page
1334:WP:DABSISTER
1309:
1305:
1288:WP:DABSISTER
1249:WP:POTENTIAL
1221:
1208:
1207:
1199:
1198:
1177:
1150:
1146:
1142:
1120:
1098:
1081:
1075:
1063:
1042:
1036:" listed at
1018:
1012:
1000:
979:
973:" listed at
832:
775:
497:
296:
287:
248:project page
231:
187:
181:
142:
103:
52:WikiProjects
42:project page
41:
25:
1421:smooth jazz
1385:MOS:DABACRO
1340:Please see
896:WikiProject
869:Reader help
764:/Archive 42
758:/Archive 41
752:/Archive 40
746:/Archive 39
740:/Archive 38
734:/Archive 37
728:/Archive 36
722:/Archive 35
716:/Archive 34
710:/Archive 33
704:/Archive 32
698:/Archive 31
692:/Archive 30
686:/Archive 29
680:/Archive 28
674:/Archive 27
668:/Archive 26
662:/Archive 25
656:/Archive 24
650:/Archive 23
644:/Archive 22
638:/Archive 21
632:/Archive 20
626:/Archive 19
620:/Archive 18
614:/Archive 17
608:/Archive 16
596:/Archive 15
590:/Archive 14
584:/Archive 13
578:/Archive 12
572:/Archive 11
566:/Archive 10
183:WP:PROPOSAL
180:, refer to
1406:Paradoctor
1101:MOS:DABRED
640:: Mar 2006
628:: Feb 2006
610:: Jan 2006
604:: Jan 2006
598:: Jan 2006
592:: Jan 2006
580:: Dec 2005
574:: Dec 2005
562:: Oct 2005
560:/Archive 9
554:/Archive 8
548:/Archive 7
542:/Archive 6
536:/Archive 5
530:/Archive 4
524:/Archive 3
520:: Jul 2005
518:/Archive 2
512:/Archive 1
297:Archives:
252:discussion
151:, and the
1274:Dan Bloch
1174:WP:DABRED
819:Guideline
800:WT:MOSDAB
1596:Category
1560:Blueboar
1491:Blueboar
1365:Blueboar
1314:Blueboar
1227:SnowFire
1160:SnowFire
1147:probably
792:Shortcut
498:Archives
1556:whether
1425:Jameboy
1390:Jameboy
1051:Mos:DAB
1034:Mos:DAB
988:Mos:Dab
971:Mos:Dab
776:90 days
1361:WT:DAB
1071:Utopes
1008:Utopes
48:scale.
1578:wiser
1574:older
1533:wiser
1529:older
1460:EVERY
1193:WP:RS
1154:here.
40:This
16:<
1564:talk
1546:talk
1509:talk
1495:talk
1479:talk
1455:".
1429:talk
1423:. --
1411:talk
1394:talk
1369:talk
1350:talk
1318:talk
1310:need
1306:here
1296:talk
1278:talk
1257:talk
1251:. --
1231:talk
1222:that
1164:talk
1151:used
1131:talk
1113:talk
1083:cont
1077:talk
1020:cont
1014:talk
910:talk
900:talk
873:talk
863:talk
853:talk
843:talk
833:talk
823:talk
1522:ill
1253:Joy
1200:Pam
1185:ill
1176:is
1598::
1576:â‰
1566:)
1548:)
1531:â‰
1525:}}
1519:{{
1511:)
1497:)
1481:)
1431:)
1413:)
1396:)
1388:--
1371:)
1352:)
1344:.
1320:)
1298:)
1280:)
1259:)
1233:)
1188:}}
1182:{{
1166:)
1143:is
1133:)
1115:)
1080:/
1017:/
888:}}
882:{{
471:44
469:,
467:43
465:,
463:42
461:,
459:41
457:,
455:40
453:,
451:39
449:,
447:38
445:,
443:37
441:,
439:36
437:,
435:35
433:,
431:34
429:,
427:33
425:,
423:32
421:,
419:31
417:,
415:30
413:,
411:29
409:,
407:28
405:,
403:27
401:,
399:26
397:,
395:25
393:,
391:24
389:,
387:23
385:,
383:22
381:,
379:21
377:,
375:20
373:,
371:19
369:,
367:18
365:,
363:17
361:,
359:16
357:,
355:15
353:,
351:14
349:,
347:13
345:,
343:12
341:,
339:11
337:,
335:10
333:,
329:,
325:,
321:,
317:,
313:,
309:,
305:,
301:,
1562:(
1544:(
1507:(
1493:(
1477:(
1466:.
1427:(
1409:(
1392:(
1367:(
1348:(
1316:(
1294:(
1276:(
1255:(
1229:(
1209:D
1162:(
1129:(
1111:(
1086:)
1074:(
1032:"
1023:)
1011:(
969:"
957:e
950:t
943:v
912:)
908:(
902:)
898:(
875:)
871:(
865:)
861:(
855:)
851:(
845:)
841:(
835:)
831:(
825:)
821:(
784:.
331:9
327:8
323:7
319:6
315:5
311:4
307:3
303:2
299:1
254:.
54::
Text is available under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License. Additional terms may apply.
