Knowledge

:Knowledge Signpost/2011-03-07/WikiProject report - Knowledge

Source 📝

340:. Kaldari is an employee of the Wikimedia Foundation and admin on several Wikimedia sites including Knowledge. He joined the Feminism Task Force in July 2008 because "most of the feminism articles on Knowledge were in pretty bad shape at the time and I thought it was important that we provide more accurate and comprehensive information on the subject". After the task force outgrew WikiProject Gender Studies, he spun it off as a separate project. Carolmooredc first contributed to the Feminism Task Force in December 2008. Her interest in feminism began in the early 1970s, and her most recent efforts have been to seek "advice and support dealing with issues of sexism in Knowledge". Danger is an admin and claims to be an "ethereal entity". 256: 627: 161: 117: 107: 90: 244: 273: 284: 33: 127: 419:
with far less obnoxious behavior are chastised. I have a thick skin and can take a lot of negativity, but a lot of women will flee after just a few attacks. We need more admins willing to give stern warnings to subtly and actively hostile editors, doing it at WP:Wikiquette, WP:ANI, other complaint pages and/or at the offending editor's talk page. More short blocks would definitely encourage people to be civil.
87: 137: 97: 425:
I'll echo Carol in saying that there's little we can do, as a project, besides revert and move on. I've been subject to some pretty grotesque user talk messages following reversion of disruptive editing on feminism pages; but there's really nothing one can do about it. That said, there's only so many
367:
The fact Knowledge has admitted a problem and announced its new goals, and gotten lots of mainstream publicity for them, by itself has had a positive effect on some male editors already and I definitely have found the incivility level dropping (knock on wood.) I see a lot of good suggestions, but the
418:
about medium grade incivility by the same editor in the same week, there may be little criticism and nothing done. Senior editors and admins can get away with even more hostility to newbies and other editors in areas of controversy. Bad behavior by male editors may be ignored while uppity females
395:
that Sue Gardner and Erik Möller set up and some of the projects on Meta-Wiki and related wikis are the real center of this sort of action. For better or worse though, WikiProject Feminism has become a sort of central location to discuss the issue on-wiki, which I think reflects a lack of other
377:
I think Carol is right that civility is a big issue, both for retaining women editors and retaining new editors in general. I think it's also important to give more support and encouragement to new editors instead of just flooding their talk pages with warning templates when they make mistakes.
579:
to get articles printed about editing Knowledge and to advertise for editors in their publications. Their readers are very attentive to these publications. One big selling point: Knowledge keeps the mind active and challenged for seniors. A certain number of those women will be feminists, and
692: 540:
Educational tools and an easier interface for new and experienced editors to find their way around and get help. Videos that deal with emotional aspects of editing Knowledge for women would help. New contributors can best help by learning policy, learning dispute resolution, and being
586:
Just that one does not have to identify oneself as a feminist—or even as a woman—to be a part of this project. We welcome editors of a wide variety of philosophical and political viewpoints. As long as you don't insert the "c" word into articles in our scope, we should get along
514:
In general, the articles within our scope seem to be pretty isolated from other projects, so we're not particularly active in inter-project collaboration. The exception is, of course, our parent project WikiProject Gender Studies, which we only split from relatively
426:
times one can see grotesque rape threats on one's watchlist before fleeing to milder climes. (Although some of the vandalism on worm-related articles is surprisingly grotesque as well.) A lot of the high importance pages are protected and even those have to be
401:
Some of the project's articles cover contentious issues or are frequent targets of vandalism. What tools does the project use to patrol and maintain the neutrality of the project's articles? How does the project cope with hostility from registered and anonymous
110: 570:
To me the biggest potential recruitment area for women in general is recently retired, educated, computer savvy women who have more time on their hands and lots to offer. We need outreach to all the various Seniors groups like
301:, WikiProject Feminism became its own project in June 2010. The project focuses on articles detailing women's rights, women's health, notable activists, and the history, literature, philosophy, and concepts related to 130: 225: 100: 140: 435:
WikiProject Feminism is home to nine featured articles and five GA/A-class articles. Have you contributed toward any of these articles? Are you working toward bringing an article up to FA or GA status?
353: 212: 528:
We're currently preparing for International Women's Day (March 8th). Expect to see a lot of women-focused content on the Main Page then. The best way for people to help is to improve the various
729:
For people new to these interviews you might remind them they will be quoted verbatim in case they want to be precise in their language. (Not that I'm taking back anything I said. ;-)
549:
We need editors willing and able to dig through the dense thicket that is academic feminist writing in order to improve the various philosophy pages. You don't have to start out with
356:). Is WikiProject Feminism taking any steps to increase recruitment and contributions of women on Knowledge? What else can be done by editors both inside and outside the project? 707: 73: 576: 661: 557:! Something originally printed on a dead tree would be great. A bibliography of websites where important texts are available would be a big help in doing research as well. 753: 671: 676: 614: 605: 120: 681: 322: 738: 651: 597: 501: 410:
The vandalism tools are good. The tools for dealing with hostility over contentious issues are not sufficiently used. Even when multiple people complain to
656: 644: 345: 638: 497: 496:
Occassionally we'll jump in on another project's article collaboration if the topic is relevant. For example, we're currently helping out with the
52: 41: 529: 469:
myself (GA class), as she was the most prominent feminist from my home town (Nashville). I'm currently collaborating with some other editors on
580:
certainly mentioning the Feminist and Women's History projects to such a big, fertile pool would bring more feminists and women to the project.
819: 712: 314: 318: 719: 306: 305:. The project is home to nine Featured articles and five Good and A-class articles. To aid contributors, the project maintains a 21: 794: 696: 593: 505: 479: 279:
was the first U.S. territory to grant women's suffrage, as commemorated by the inclusion of "equal rights" in the state's seal.
262:
sold her home in England to tour the United Kingdom and United States in support of women's rights. She is most famous for her
217: 198: 789: 784: 67: 298: 478:
Does WikiProject Feminism collaborate with any other projects? Did the project play a role in the recent establishment of
779: 293: 774: 626: 46: 32: 17: 411: 430:
on a regular basis. We also have a pretty big problem with neutrality, especially regarding due weight.
264: 234:
Submit your project's news and announcements for next week's WikiProject Report at the Signpost's
508:, it basically emerged on it own, but we've tried to help promote it to get more people involved. 203: 734: 344:
There have been recent discussions about a gender gap among Knowledge's registered users (see
379: 800: 765: 8: 454: 310: 466: 259: 730: 703: 386: 382:
gadget in my spare time. Expect to see it available in the preferences some day soon.
362: 337: 333: 255: 235: 178: 248: 191: 183: 520:
What are the project's most pressing needs? How can a new contributor help today?
470: 427: 368:
most important thing is for women to take on some of these excellent projects.
195:
are seeking help improving articles and discussing ways to revamp the project.
813: 749: 550: 462: 415: 150: 458: 450: 372: 329: 392: 744:
That's a lesson best learned the hard way. Never trust a reporter.  ;)
490:
I think some people watching Feminism Wikiproject supported its creation.
443:
There definitely is one I’d love to, but I just keep getting sidetracked.
554: 243: 745: 596:. Until then, enjoy some sushi as you read previous Reports in the 302: 272: 276: 283: 309:
of project members who can provide help with specific tasks, a
297:. Originally created in February 2008 as a task force within 325:
for women featured by the National Women's History Project.
572: 457:(both featured articles), although the real credit goes to 502:
Nineteenth Amendment to the United States Constitution
396:
venues more than the focus of the project as a whole.
717:If your comment has not appeared here, you can try 378:Towards that end, I'm currently working on a new 811: 287:...with help from Knowledge editors like you! 148: 530:Did You Know articles scheduled for that day 592:Next week, we'll travel to a country that 763:Make sure we cover what matters to you – 282: 271: 254: 242: 226:March Copyedit Backlog Elimination Drive 184:United States Collaboration of the Month 720: 14: 812: 251:on a 1936 commemorative postage stamp. 216:, a backlog reduction drive hosted by 201:could use some help revitalizing the 51: 820:Knowledge Signpost archives 2011-03 27: 625: 594:renounced its right to declare war 473:to try to bring it up to GA class. 159: 53: 31: 28: 831: 702:These comments are automatically 68:Talking with WikiProject Feminism 562:Anything else you'd like to add? 135: 125: 115: 105: 95: 85: 498:U.S. Collaboration of the Month 713:add the page to your watchlist 317:in the past day, a variety of 13: 1: 577:American Seniors Association 688: 218:WikiProject Military History 199:WikiProject London Transport 18:Knowledge:Knowledge Signpost 7: 506:WikiProject Women's History 480:WikiProject Women's History 315:articles with high activity 10: 836: 299:WikiProject Gender Studies 291:This week, we talked with 754:17:20, 8 March 2011 (UTC) 739:16:56, 7 March 2011 (UTC) 500:which happens to be the 323:list of missing articles 229:is underway. Join today! 319:pages needing attention 204:London Transport Portal 710:. To follow comments, 630: 618:"WikiProject report" → 288: 280: 269: 252: 164: 36: 629: 286: 275: 258: 246: 213:Milhist March Madness 163: 35: 706:from this article's 662:Deletion controversy 610:"WikiProject report" 412:WP:Wikiquette alerts 294:WikiProject Feminism 247:American Suffragist 672:Features and admins 455:Mary Wollstonecraft 766:leave a suggestion 697:Discuss this story 677:Arbitration report 667:WikiProject report 631: 467:Anne Dallas Dudley 449:I collaborated on 289: 281: 270: 260:Emmeline Pankhurst 253: 192:WikiProject Horror 165: 65:WikiProject report 42:← Back to Contents 37: 721:purging the cache 682:Technology report 179:George Washington 47:View Latest Issue 827: 803: 768: 727:==Good report== 724: 722: 716: 695: 649: 641: 634: 617: 609: 265:Freedom or death 249:Susan B. Anthony 236:WikiProject Desk 169: 168:WikiProject news 166: 162: 153: 139: 138: 129: 128: 119: 118: 109: 108: 99: 98: 89: 88: 59: 57: 55: 835: 834: 830: 829: 828: 826: 825: 824: 810: 809: 808: 807: 806: 805: 804: 799: 797: 792: 787: 782: 777: 770: 764: 760: 759: 726: 718: 711: 700: 699: 693:+ Add a comment 691: 687: 686: 685: 642: 637: 635: 632: 621: 620: 615: 612: 607: 328:We interviewed 241: 240: 239: 232: 173: 172: 167: 160: 158: 154: 147: 146: 145: 136: 126: 116: 106: 96: 86: 80: 77: 66: 62: 60: 50: 49: 44: 38: 26: 25: 24: 12: 11: 5: 833: 823: 822: 798: 793: 788: 783: 778: 773: 772: 771: 762: 761: 758: 757: 756: 701: 698: 690: 689: 684: 679: 674: 669: 664: 659: 654: 652:News and notes 648: 636: 624: 623: 622: 613: 604: 603: 602: 591: 589: 588: 581: 559: 558: 543: 542: 534: 533: 517: 516: 509: 491: 475: 474: 471:Gloria Steinem 444: 432: 431: 420: 398: 397: 383: 369: 311:HotArticlesBot 233: 231: 230: 221: 208: 196: 187: 174: 170: 157: 156: 155: 144: 143: 133: 123: 113: 103: 93: 82: 81: 78: 72: 71: 70: 69: 64: 63: 61: 58: 45: 40: 39: 30: 29: 15: 9: 6: 4: 3: 2: 832: 821: 818: 817: 815: 802: 796: 791: 786: 781: 776: 767: 755: 751: 747: 743: 742: 741: 740: 736: 732: 723: 714: 709: 705: 694: 683: 680: 678: 675: 673: 670: 668: 665: 663: 660: 658: 655: 653: 650: 646: 640: 633:In this issue 628: 619: 611: 601: 599: 595: 585: 582: 578: 574: 569: 568:Carolmooredc: 566: 565: 564: 563: 556: 552: 551:Judith Butler 548: 545: 544: 539: 538:Carolmooredc: 536: 535: 531: 527: 524: 523: 522: 521: 513: 510: 507: 503: 499: 495: 492: 489: 488:Carolmooredc: 486: 485: 484: 483: 481: 472: 468: 464: 460: 456: 452: 448: 445: 442: 441:Carolmooredc: 439: 438: 437: 436: 429: 424: 421: 417: 413: 409: 408:Carolmooredc: 406: 405: 404: 403: 394: 390: 388: 384: 381: 376: 374: 370: 366: 364: 360: 359: 358: 357: 355: 351: 349: 341: 339: 335: 331: 326: 324: 320: 316: 312: 308: 304: 300: 296: 295: 285: 278: 274: 267: 266: 261: 257: 250: 245: 237: 228: 227: 222: 219: 215: 214: 209: 206: 205: 200: 197: 194: 193: 188: 185: 181: 180: 176: 175: 171:News in brief 152: 142: 134: 132: 124: 122: 114: 112: 104: 102: 94: 92: 84: 83: 75: 56: 48: 43: 34: 23: 19: 731:CarolMooreDC 728: 666: 645:all comments 639:7 March 2011 590: 583: 567: 561: 560: 546: 537: 525: 519: 518: 511: 504:. Regarding 493: 487: 477: 476: 451:Emma Goldman 446: 440: 434: 433: 422: 407: 400: 399: 393:mailing list 391:I think the 385: 371: 363:Carolmooredc 361: 347: 343: 342: 334:Carolmooredc 327: 292: 290: 263: 224: 211: 202: 190: 177: 54:7 March 2011 801:Suggestions 704:transcluded 657:In the news 189:Members of 465:. I wrote 79:Share this 74:Contribute 22:2011-03-07 795:Subscribe 708:talk page 555:Mary Daly 515:recently. 414:and even 354:follow-up 307:directory 814:Category 790:Newsroom 785:Archives 608:Previous 587:alright. 541:patient. 526:Kaldari: 494:Kaldari: 463:Awadewit 447:Kaldari: 428:revdeled 380:WikiLove 350:coverage 348:Signpost 321:, and a 313:list of 303:feminism 151:Mabeenot 121:LinkedIn 101:Facebook 20:‎ | 598:archive 584:Danger: 547:Danger: 512:Danger: 459:Scartol 423:Danger: 373:Kaldari 330:Kaldari 277:Wyoming 268:speech. 182:is the 111:Twitter 416:WP:ANI 402:users? 387:Danger 346:major 338:Danger 336:, and 131:Reddit 91:E-mail 780:About 210:Join 16:< 775:Home 750:talk 735:talk 616:Next 575:and 573:AARP 461:and 453:and 352:and 223:The 141:Digg 746:TCO 553:or 149:By 76:— 816:: 752:) 737:) 606:← 600:. 332:, 769:. 748:( 733:( 725:. 715:. 647:) 643:( 532:. 482:? 389:: 375:: 365:: 238:. 220:. 207:. 186:.

Index

Knowledge:Knowledge Signpost
2011-03-07
The Signpost
← Back to Contents
View Latest Issue
7 March 2011
Contribute
E-mail
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Reddit
Digg
Mabeenot
George Washington
United States Collaboration of the Month
WikiProject Horror
WikiProject London Transport
London Transport Portal
Milhist March Madness
WikiProject Military History
March Copyedit Backlog Elimination Drive
WikiProject Desk

Susan B. Anthony

Emmeline Pankhurst
Freedom or death

Wyoming

Text is available under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License. Additional terms may apply.

↑