Knowledge

Talk:Macedonians (ethnic group)/Archive 6

Source 📝

10137:'Roman' and maybe they're not and maybe the Macedonians are part-Greek and maybe they're not. Really a matter of opinion as verifying these things is difficult and historians don't always agree. Romanian opinions actually vary so I'm not sure where you got your concensus from. Some I've met, including an ex-roommate, believe they are part Roman from Italy, others not so much, but again the point is still the Macedonians. Are we catering to Greek nationalism or just presenting an article about a people who happen to be called Macedonians TODAY? In fact, if for example they examined say the DNA of someone they believe to be an ancient Macedonian and it matched say a Slavic Macedonian then what? None of us know for sure that they aren't part Greco-Macedonian and that's not really the point. We're not here to take sides as the point has been made clear through the disambiguation page already and on the Macedonian people page as well. The UN, most of the governments on earth, reference books (some which I looked at during this debate) all call it Macedonia and the people Macedonians. Not ethnic Macedonians or whatever else. There is sometimes a reference that these are Slavic speaking Macedonians not to be confused with the ancient Greek speakers during the descriptive part, but other than that they just talk about them. And so after the disambiguation page and the section that states that these are Macedonian Slavs it's still 'vague'? Come on. If people don't get it at that point, perhaps they should work on their reading and comprehension skills. What are we really talking about here? I have no problem with Jimbo Wales or whatever adminstrator weighing in, but this does seem to be just a way to kick the Macedonians around and 'put them in their place' as non-Macedonian Greeks more than a way to formulate clarity. 9972:
though it's rather obvious. As for the Romania usage, it's ultimately derived from the Roman Empire, started and based in Italy, and the analogy is not murky at all as it is the same situation here. The use of a name that one group does not want confused with another that they claim as 'theirs'. In the case of Italy I imagine they just don't really care, but that's really besides the point. Also, 'Roman' colonists doesn't mean Italians and people seem to claim a lot of things all over the world that turn out to not be true. Romans were in Britain, Tunisia, Portugal, Armenia so having colonists who were 'Roman' doesn't really mean anything as a Roman citizen could have come from Gaul or Mauretania or Sarmatian troops in Britain. All of that aside, as you seem to be hung up on the analogy rather than the intitial point of the Macedonians usage, why should Macedonians be treated differently? If reference books, the CIA factbook, and everyone else use the term Macedonians why can't wikipedia just refer to them as such? This does now appear to be catering to Greek indignation of the use of the name rather than just confusion since there seems to be extreme sensitivity to convey that these aren't Macedonian Greeks. And for the record, I am changing my position somewhat due to some convincing arguments as I initially was leaning towards Macedonian people to create some uniformity, but now think it's absurd to have to emphasize the obvious, that they are an ethnic group when that's done at the disambiguation page and if we just put Macedonian people it would come to the page where you can AGAIN explain that these aren't the Macedonian Greeks, but the people of a country called Macedonia. Not sure what math has to do with this, but okay.
5337:
this big empire, your ancestors were uneducated and far from Europe. In Greek anyone could be called Macedonian, like anyone can be called Cretean,Rhodean, Pelloponesian, Athenian, e.t.c.. The stupid problem with that name is because persons like you, who are too nationalists, can not recognize that Macedonia is home of all its residents and anyone from there can be called Macedonian. Greek Macedonians were much earlier than you as Macedonians. As about the names that Knowledge has for self identifying, well yes but you prefer to say only few words from those rules, and those who are good for you. Knowledge, yes it says for self identifying, so yes there is the article Republic of Macedonian, eventhough it is FYROM. Yes, you will be described as Macedonians, but there is something more about that rule. You will be self identifying as Macedonians but there is the rule which I showed you that will be- as it was- in parenthesis to say that it is for Slavs.This will refer that by macedonian ethnicity it will refer to the slavic side. As for violations; you began first by changing the article. I am really very curious to listen with which you have agreed to be written right that and you made this isolations. with who??? The Slav Macedonians between you??? and what a choice to be fair for isolation!!!! Macedonian (ethnic group) or Ethnic Macedonian!!!! Really you are the bests for making agreements!!! Well I have just told you my warnings. I chose first to discuss it with you but really don't make me to not have any other choice to begin as i did few days ago. Because that will continue for a long. So let's find something that we both agree
12029:
twice to Bulgarian forms. Do you want me to scan some documents from my family, if there's any? I urge everyone to do the same thing, if they have some Bulgarian occupation documents to post it as pictures. I hope it will be sourced then, OK? I do not know how to source those things. The second thing: how do you permit only the Serbization and Hellenization policies to be present here? Why is Bulgarization process, which was the most fierce and bloody of all, omitted and three times reverted? A Japanese, for instance, could think that only the Bulgarians did NOT assimilate the Macedonians, maybe because the Macedonians were INDEED Bulgarians? It confuses me. Also, "Medieval sources traditionally describe them as Bulgarians, a definition which survived well into the period of Ottoman rule as attested by the Ottoman archives and by descriptions of historians and travellers, for example Evliya Celebi and his Book of Travels." Well, we in Serbia where I live have all the possible sources that prove that Emperor Dusan, for instance, called himself "The Emperor of Serbs, Albanians and Greeks". Bulgarians were never mentioned in his title, while all of Macedonia was under his rule. It is impossible that the fact were opposite to Krste Misirkov statements - Macedonians were Serbs at that time. How came Emperor Dusan forget the largest national group in his Empire, if all the Macedonians were Bulgarians? Strange. I don't know how anything except Evliya Celebi's quotation can be proved. I suggest to drop it, because they were not uniformly considered Bulgarians. Should I quote it from somewhere? Saluti cordiali!
12806:
Bulgarians....wouldnt they have killed him in Plovdiv or Sofia?Why kill him in Skopje?And you still havent answered y question as to why MACEDONIAN REGIMENT was formed in RUSSIA....if these men were free....which is wht they were....wouldnt they have chosen to call themselves "THE BULGARIAN REGIMENT"?What is the point in being named"THE MACEDONIAN REGIMENT"?If theyre all Bulgarians?Im sure youll find some more ways to get around the question......another question i have is the colony of MAcedonians in St.Petersburg.......why dont they call themselves Bulgarians?They were known as the Macedonian Colony......on their flag they had the sun in the bottom corner and Bukefal in the top.....this is before the turn of the 20th century......so why would these people choose to refer to themselves as MAcedonians?Place Macedonian symbols on their flag?WHat for?BEcause theyre Bulgarians?Is that how a Bulgarian expresses love for his nation?By calling him or herself a MAcedonian?What about when the Bulgarian government(back in the the day) recognized the Macedonians living within Bulgaria....claiming that there were oer 100,000 Macedonians living there.....and then why did they go back and say there are no Macedonians....only Bulgarians living in Macedonia?How can you stand there and tell me all this stuff in the face of all that evidence?YOUR OWN GOVERNMENT RECOGNIZED THEM AND THE REVERSED ITS POSITION....why?First.....why even bother recognizing us as a seperate ethnicity and seocnd why did they take it back?
9878:
encyclopedias and reference books I've read do just say Macedonians so Macedonian people in accordance with how wikipedia works would be logical. The reality is that most people outside the Balkans probably will never take the time to learn the differences or even care. It seems to come down to bragging rights and claims to the name. As far as I know, most Macedonians don't claim to be Alexander's descendents or Greeks. This debate is going on with the Azerbaijanis too. Apparently, since the name is new they have no history etc. These are just names ultimately used by living people. I sympathize with the Greeks quite a bit. I pretty much think Turkey was wrong in Cyprus, although the Greeks probably could have been more accomodating to their Turkish minority, but I also believe the Macedonians who live in Macedonia have a right to an identity and don't deserve to have to pass some litmus test to use a name. Romania is not Roman, but the language is Latin and the Italians aren't telling them to stop calling themselves Romanians even though they aren't really of Roman ancestry. I'm trying to be objective here and just say that Macedonian people is fair and consistent and can include a caption at the top that explains that these aren't the Macedonians of ancient Greece etc. after some reader comes upon a disambiguation page that relates the ethnic Slavic Macedonians of Macedonia or something to that effect. That's a pretty fair compromise I think.
10843:
Thus, if there is propaganda of an extreme variety (such that I have actually seen from Macedonians as well as Greeks, Turks, Kurds, Russians, Americans etc.) that should be dealt with. I only want the people to be treated the same as everyone else. If there are points that are deemed unverifiable, then fine contest those points. You are going far beyond my initial point of contention, just treating the Macedonians as a people regardless of their origins and not tagging this with an over-emphasis upon them not being Greek etc. As for kicking around the Macedonians comment, again if you look at the context I meant that in terms of turning this into a way to say that they have no claims to anything other than being aliens or something. Nationalism does work both ways and I see your points, some of which I will grant are valid. I'm not claiming to be unbiased, but I do claim to be trying. Can you say the same given your measure of how the Slavs are more biased than the Greeks? Perhaps you don't know that I was accused of taking the side of the Greeks when I did some editing on the Greek people page or that I was siding with the Azeris over the Persians on the Azeri history page. Now why would I want to align myself with so many disparate groups if I was trying to promote some biased agenda exactly? You don't think it's emphasized enough so that speaks volumes here. Usually the disambiguation page is enough for most articles.
1265:
such names as "Brandenburg", "Saxony", "Hanover" etc defined national groupsm and cultures. It wasn't until 1871 that Gertmany became one country, and even then some regions(eg Austria) weren't invluded. Since 1871 terms like "Hanoverian" and "Bavarian" no longer refer to national identities because they're all just "German" or "Deutsch". However, if a foreign non-German people were to suddenly use the name of say 'Bavaria' as their national identity, and call their non-German language and culture "Bavarian" ALL Germans would take offense to it. This is something of a no-brainer. In exactly the same way, there used to be literally hundreds of separate Greek nations, varying greatly in size, power, culture, and other things. They fought both with and against eaxh other. Today however there is a single Greek state which does not include all the historical Greek lands. However if a foreign non-Greek people were to try and appropriate a regional name that is indisputably Greek(like with Nacedonia) it will understandably anger ALL Greeks. Because Macedonia was one of those hundreds of Greek regional states. What's more today more than 80 per cent of Macedon proper is within the Greek boundaries, and not FYROM's boundaries. So thus FYROM has no legitimate claim to use the name "Macedonia", except to describe its southern regions like Bitola and Ochrid(sp?) in a historical context....... Kurt Stein
10673:
read that study also and some other studies that were done that cluster the Pashtuns with Iranian peoples who are generally similar to Mediterranean populations especially via the Y-chromosome and the genetic studies have been inconclusive, but do show that there was Greek settlement in Afghanistan in the form of Bactria, but nothing really major and these sporadic Greek genes probably also show up in Slavic neighbors. What many genetic tests have shown is that there is an autochthonous origins for many people which somewhat downplays the notion of invasions drastically altering populations. Thus, the Greeks of today are in the majority the Greeks of ancient times, etc. All of that aside, I'm not supporting any monopolization of the name Macedonian. I believe that you are assuming that I am arguing on points that I'm really not. I've also studied the various assessments made of Macedonian and Balkan backgrounds in general, both historical records, anthropological and genetic views, and other points so I think we actually agree more than you realize. Also, I would make one point here and that is that there was a 'Romanization' of elites that usually left out the masses. The Byzantines in fact thought themselves Roman and Greek at the same time and in this regard and a good example of who was more 'Roman' comes from the encounter with the Crusaders as related by
8516:
came naturally via the population exchange that resettled Greeks in the region. Anyway I never completely removed the references on changes of toponyms, so what you just quoted is already covered in the article. The sources were required on different edits that I have analysed on the previous section. It's not so much what the article says, it is the "how" it says it. It was written by Macedonian Slav nationals, it's normal for its content to be biased. One thing that I don't agree with the quotation that you provided, is the use of "from Macedonian to Greek". There's no proof that those Slavic names were "Macedonian Slavic" and not Serbian or Bulgarian. That's completely POV. I provided two neutral sources above, a) the Ottoman census and b) the Italian education watch, both of which verify the fact that a "Macedonian nationality" did not exist at the time. It's important to point out at this point that this whole story was viewed from its contemporaries as a Greek-Bulgarian conflict, as nobody was aware of a "Macedonian Slavic nation". User:Macedonia was insisting on linking to .mk sites, with the naive belief that it would qualify in wikipedia as "credible source". Then he would insist on adding an utterly unsourced and POV example of a name change, first regarding
10651:. They didn't even consider the "Macedonian" part of the "Macedonian ethnic group" as a literal term, which proves the opposite of what you thought. What you suggest your opinion and I respect it, but it's still a POV. A large number of assumptions, "there have been examples of this and that", that's just not good enough to make a solid point, nor to monopolize a name which culturally belongs to another ethnic group. Nobody regards the "Macedonian Slavs" as a representative Macedonian nation except themselves. If that's what you believe then you are as much delusional as they are. In German there's even a different word for "Greek/ancient Macedonian" and "Slavic Mazedonien". Nobody told the Slavs not to use the term "Macedonian", they were told not to monopolise it. Greed is an important sin. They want to monopolise it, hence they risk their recognition under international organisations. Anyway, by the way you compare the British and the Americans, I see you have no good understanding of the situation. You probably don't even know of Tito's linguistic and political reforms on the region, nor about the American government's official rejection of the existence of a "Macedonian nation" during the 40's. Which doesn't surprise me. 724:. All main points of disagreement can be seen here. They are mostly figures and phrasing. I want us all to look for sources regarding the figures and then analyse them here before reverting anything. The name of the articles should be Macedonians (ethnic group) for now. As Britannica and 10 other encyclopaedias use that name, it cannot be viewed as unacceptable, and givan that that name is the one that Knowledge's naming policy requires to be used, that one should be used UNTIL a good reason is found that this case is an exception to that rule. I should also point out that a) Greeks officially call these people Macedonian Slavs NOT Skopjans. You will not find any official Greek document using the name Skopjans. They all use the name Slavomakedhones (Macedonian Slavs). Skopjans is just an way of refering to them without using the name Macedonia and is only used unofficially. Also, the poll which Theathenae keeps on talking about was a draw, a consensus needs 60% support. Therefore it only serves as a reference and is not binding. Knowledge's naming policy (which mandates the name Macedonians) as a consensus and should be used until it has been proven that this case is an exception. Everyone, please try to co-operate. 12815:
documents from this period. Do not forget that I am talking only about one book. As for Evliya Chelebi Ivanov comment him and supposed notice that E. Chelebi inform about Bulgarians in Novi Pazar among with Serbians. Ivanov supposed that there was some Bulgarian dealers in this town. I had to opportunity to see your writings about Evlija Chelebi in other discussion and therefore I'll comment this source: Evlija Chelebi really notice Bulgarians in Belgrade and Bosnia, but he met there not only Bulgarians. Bulgarians are in the list of the other groups. He met and Serbs in Bulgarian territories too. One of the instances is Bulgarian town Samokov. From other sources we know that there was Serbian migrations in this region. Why we can not accept that there was Bulgarian presence in Serbian regions? There was migrations in Ottoman period right up to Bosnia. Even in ХІХ c. there was Bulgarian colonies in Shumadia. Like Evlija Chelebi L. Batalaka wrote that there was many Bulgarians in Belgrade - Баталака, Л.А. "Историја српског устанка", т.І, Београд 1888, 56-58. (In this moment I can scan the book of Jordan Ivanov, but I'll try to do further. Meantime you can ask me about this book or something else). --
3166:
subjects. Possibly most of your information is not by non-neutral sources and most of you don't have any personal experience. Nationalists from various countries made Knowledge's articles about the balkans realy a mess. Like it or not, Greece is today the country of the Balcans with the most stable and developed sense of identity. And this sence is constant not only among those who speak Greek and only Greek. It is also so among Arvanites, Aromanians, Slavomacedonians and Roma. Making Greece look like a country with the biggest minority problem, is such exists, is toataly unfair. Expecialy when propaganda is done by people in FYROM (UCK is still present there isn't it?) and from Albanians, whose country has been oppresing greeks of northern Epirous (or Southern Albania if you like) for decades. Not to mention Bulgarian natinalists that keep draming. Nationalists may ofcourse continue to edit articles in the way the like, and I think that that's what they will do, making themselfs and all other Balcanians something to laugh at. Their national feeling may get stronger when discovering all their "brothers" that "suffer" in Greece, but if they care a litle bit about reality they should start thinking.
13039:
close to Bulgarian. Do you know what I mean? People did not oppose the Bulgarian identity there that much. Also, in Vidin area, there was a bit of Serbian feeling before 1878. I talked to the Vidinians in Sofia, and they told me so. Look, the whole Serbian area that belonged to the Exarchate, and the whole Bulgarian area as marked by Belic, was desputable. Of course, tje whole of Macedonia too. I met a man in Belgrade who told me that his grandfather was a Serb Macedonian refugee from Dhrama, Eastern Greece! In Kavala, also Aegean Macedonia, I met a man who told me he could speak Serbian, because he is of Serbian origins. Of course, he spoke the pure Macedonian. What am I trying to say? The identity is deeply a decision of a person, connected with the education and breed. noboby can tell these people they were Macedonians or Bulgarians. Nobody can persuade some Macedonians from Kostur living in Sofia they are not Bulgarians, 100%. The Solunians are 100% Greek now. The Skopians are Macedonians, and the Pirotians and Vranians Serbs. No further story about it. I do not understand the Bulgarian attempts to prove their point, but let them be.
1284:
should be: "What region did the ancient(ie original) Macedonians regard as "Macedonia"? It doesn't matter what the Romans, Ottomans, Russians, or whoever thought was Macedonia, what did the actual blood/ethnic Nacedonains refer to as 'Macedonia' ? And the answer is modern Greek Macedonia, and a small part of southern FYROM. What is also very important is your(and many other peoples') continued use of the term "Republic of Macedonia" . While the wikipedia administrators may have bowed to your insistence on this term, the United Nations does not recognize any country with that name. The name "Former Yugoslav Republic Of Macedonia" was supposed to be a tempary name until a proper name could be agreed upon(and that does definitely NOT include "Republic of Macedonia") . But FYROM assumed that by just ignoring the problem it would go away. Of course people are angry and are saying things that are POV, because this is a very sensitive issue. Whenever anybody attempts to take anything that rightly and legitimately belongs to somebody else it will create negative feelings and emotions, and bring out the nastiness in people.......John Miller
11215:
diverge anyway and the Bulgarians aren't the same people they once were anyway. Big Adamsky's point on acculturation is possibly applicable as I discovered while editing the Azeris page (after Khoikhoi told me of its problems) that genetic tests have revealed the Azeris to be closer to their Caucasian neighbors than to Central Asian Turks which does point to language adoption and cultural shift rather than population replacement. The same results came up when I worked on the Sinhalese page, again after Khoikhoi asked me to (he does get around), and also found that the Sinhalese seem to be largely indigenous. More widespread DNA evaluations may shed light on just what sort of relationship Macedonians have with Greeks and other Slavic neighbors in addition to the historical record which often relates events that impact the ruling elites rather than the masses. Name usage, as long as it is not 'monopolized' and used to make claims that are, at best, somewhat difficult to ascertain shouldn't be a big problem and that's why I backed the idea of Macedonian people after the disambiguation page.
10249:
tribes as their own anyway as people change, intermingle, move around etc. Many Romanian historians are increasingly turning to a Dacian background for the people just as a rediscovery of partial Celtic origins has sprung up in England, the Hittites in Turkey, Phoenicians in Lebanon etc. Also, the Dacians, themselves a branch of Thracians, may not even be the earliest inhabitants, but a progression of people afterwards had no doubt changed things for the region. Alright, look, forget my Romanian example anyway. It was meant to discuss the GENERAL claims upon names and not to be an exact analogy. Lastly, I don't think I agree that people should have exclusive rights to claiming names or ancient people. Since we've just go through talking about how the Macedonians may not have been Greeks it stands to reason that exclusive rights should not be a factor here. We're not here to cater to any one group. The disambiguation page clarifies the various Macedonian usages. The page for Macedonians then clarifies their Slavic language. How much more does the point need to be made? Bottom-line.
12893:
forming of San Stefano Greater Bulgaria). But, those 3 ideas were strongly supported by the 3 neighbouring states, adn Macedonian autonomist and autochtonous idea had no basic state or financial help! Even the Russian believed the Bulgarian propaganda and supported Bulgarian PoV. But the Macedonians were very poor, many of them "pechalbars" derived from the "sorrow and painful work abroad" ("pecal" means "pain" in Slavic!). They obbeyed any propaganda because of their poverty. It is their fault they have been assimilated. Because they were submissive and passive, unfortunately. It brought Macedonians only pain, but every man personally was not that affected. The head on the shoulders was what mattered, and the slice of bread a day. Do not underestimate the poverty from 1900. Many Italians and Greeks and Dalmatians went to America, Argentina, Australia. Irish? Germans? Many! Why not obbeying to the very similar nation? It is easy to discuss with the full stomach, nowadays, about the patriotism and ideas. Try to go back in your mind... You'll see.
11197:
your opinion on the Macedonians-Bulgarians ethnic relationship? The sentence, IMO, constitutes a false statement in many ways - it implies that Macedonians are actually Bulgarians, that due to the historical contigency, have become a separate nation. ("How dare they?") Not only it is a obsolete sentence (I've given an example with the Czechs and Slovaks, I can give a several more), but there is no evidence that Macedonians actually were Bulgarians at a given point in history - the foreign observers mostly regarded them as a somewhat hybrid populations, and thus they were labeled "Bulgarians", but also "Southern Serbs" (very often), "Slavophone Greeks" (rarely). Moreover, there is absolutely no source that could confirm that Macedonians have "cultural" similarities with Bulgarians - culture, especially modern culture is a too broad concept to give such statements. Linguistically, the Macedonian language is similar with Bulgarian, but also to Serbian. Personally, I understand Serbian much better than Bulgarian. --
8201:"Following the 1913 Treatry of Bucharest, the original Macedonian place names that existed in Aegean Macedonia were gradually changed to Greek names, as well as the surnames of all Macedonians, according to the 1927 Greek Government Legislative Edict. The Greek Government Gazette declared that "there are not any non-Greek people in Greece". This was part of a process called "Hellenization" whereby all the names of Macedonian villages, towns, regions, lakes, rivers, mountains, etc. were changed, together with the surnames of ethnic Macedonians, into Greek-sounding names. For example, the village of "Lerigovo", on the Chalcidice peninsula, was later renamed to "Arnaía" by Greek officials in 1927. Although many modern Greeks will argue that the Greek name was its original name before the Slav invasion of the 6th century AD, it is certain that many villages and towns, like this one, had never existed in Ancient times but were originally established by the Slavs and other invaders." (talk) 1144:
Macedonia may in fact have wholly Slavonic roots? You can't; in just the same way, you can't deny that there is a reasonable possibility that ethnic Macedonians may have, in some obscure form, descent from the Ancient Macedonians. The fact is that you cannot say who whose ancestors were two and a half thousand years ago. The Greeks in the Greek-controlled part of Macedonia do not identify as Macedonians in an ethnical sense, but only in a regional sense. They identify ethnically and nationally as Greeks. The people discussed in this article however, identify ethnically, nationally and regionally as Macedonians. If they did identify nationally and ethnically as Macedonians, then they would be an ethnic minority. Curiously, Greece claims to have no ethnic minorities. What does that mean? Please note that the word "Macedonia" covers a wide spectrum and is a specific modern name. It does not necessarily imply links to the Ancient Macedonians. The people of the
8626:, because it's written it shouts that it was written by a Macedonian Slav who wants to monopolise "Macedonian". What missing is the bold, underlined marking over "Ethnic" or "other ethnic groups" or "strictly". That's ridiculous. The Greeks have had a region named "Macedonia" for thousands of years, and the term "Macedonian" was used in a regional sense such as "Cretan". That is a F A C T, and no matter how it pisses you off, it has to be mentioned because it's true. If for no good reason, simply because it justifies the psychology of the Greeks for not recignizing a "Macedonian" ethnic group that has no record of official existence prior to 1948 (prove me wrong if you can by citing sources). If we leave this out then we're saying half of the story, which is what MacSlav nationalists want. For that very reason, I have replaced the above with " 7576:
Macedonian population. Independent researches state that there are 200,000 people of Macedonian decsent in northern Greece. So the number adds to 1,901,512, but lets just say 1.9 million. Then there are neutral estimates of Macedonians in bulgaria and albania not included in the total, at about 30,000 in albania and 25,000 in bulgaria, so the total adds up to some 1,950,000 Macedonians. Lastly, there are no Macedonians included from the "Rest of the World" heading that is mentioned in the article, only because it is "unknown". This is unfair for many reasons and there should at least be an estimated number noted. To back this up, even though some 31,000 Canadians declared themselves as Macedoninas in canada, community spokesmen and local officials estimate that there are actually 100,000 - 150,000 Canadians of Macedonian descent in Canada
10336:
explained the usage and wanted to move on. Dude, latching on to some comments doesn't really change my original intent at all. Fine, the example isn't the best when deconstructed, but my intent was not to draw an exact analogy, just something that came to mind right off the bat. Keep in mind though, that what is irrelevant to you may not be irrelevant to others. I don't care if Macedonians are Greeks or descendents of Alexander, but I don't think this name has to become some exclusive property based largely upon nationalism. Your opinion of my analogy or what I know and don't know really doesn't make any difference BECAUSE I explained its original intent while you decided to tell me what I already knew about Romania and the Romans. Congrats on explaining things for yourself. Now moving on to the usage of Macedonian people...
6715:"The results were surprising. Only 6.3 percent of the total genetic variation was explained by differences among major populations (Lewontin's seven geographical units). In other words, close to 94 percent of human genetic diversity occurs within these very large groups. The larger population subdivisions within the geographical clusters (e.g., within the category Caucasians: Arabs, Basques, Welsh) account for another 8.3 percent. Thus geographical and local "races" together account for just 15 percent of all human genetic variation, leaving the remaining 85 percent unaccounted for. The vast majority of genetic differences among human beings is explicable in terms of differences from one village to another, one family to another, and, to a very significant degree, one person to another---even within the same family." 1139:
given up the claim to the name Macedonia, or if the Slavic Macedonians had control of all of ancient Macedon(which they have tried to accomplish) then perhaps they could call themselves Mcedonians without any controversey. The problem is the "American" model,namely merely living in an area makes you that ethnicity. However since Greece has 3 peripheries called Macedonia, occupies the majority of ancient Macedonia, and the Greeks are the direct descendants of the ancient Macedonians, having a non-Macedonian Slavic group calling themselves Macedonians, their language Macedonian, and adopting undeniably Greek symbols, whilst only living on the outskirts of what is true Macedonia is obviously going to cause a negative response. There can be no doubt that the "Macedonians" are far more Bugarian than they are Macedonian.
8968:) public media groups outside Greece refer to the Macedonians, as just that – Macedonians, the same applying to the naming dispute. I don't object to having the term "Macedonian Slavs" on the page, I simply object to the use of the word 'often', can this be changed to a similar word of lesser degree? My second concern is the statement “The Macedonians are primarily the descendants of the Slavic tribes …” I understand that there is a notice calling on citation, but until proper citation is provided can this be edited slightly to something like … “In some circles, it is thought that the Macedonians are …” and furthermore, I ask that the general Macedonian view be represented; that is, that the current Macedonians are descendants of the ancient Macedonians and that the Slav tribes assimilated with these people. -- 1223:
doesn't have a clear parallel with Macedonia. The Greeks still regard macedonia as a Greek REGION (not country) . There is undoubtedly Slavic blood in modern Greeks, and Greek blood in modern Slavs, BUT there has continually been a Greek presence/language/culture in Macedonia that regards istelf as Greek nationally and Macedonian regionally. By you own admission the Slavic peoples calling themselves "Macedonians" is a comparatively recent concept. Whether you like it or not, one hundred years ago most Macedonians (Slavic) considered themselves Bulgaraians living in the region of Macedonia, and wanted full unification with Bulgaria. Only after Bulgaria lost three consecutive wars to Greece and Serbia/Yugoslavia did the idea of being "Macedonian" emerge, after Bulgaria had had to give up all claims to the land.
4313:) and the ongoing content-disputes on Macedonia*disambiguation pages show that we have a problem. This problem isn't yet solved. When our friend FlavSavr was disappointed by the results of the big poll (yes there was no consensus for anything, that's why I said this shouldn't be interpreted in binary: yes and no) I told him back in August that he should go for RFC and RFMed. And then I, among with others, was accused as a greek far right extremist who don't want Med. How could any greek answer at that time (early October) what he/she thinks about Med when he was already accused as an extremist? Let me point out that calling all the people who had expressed their opinion in the poll (by both sides) as nationalists doesn't solve the problem and in my opinion yes, you and the other admins are neutral. 7764:, irrelevant to the sites you posted. Anyway those sites wouldn't exist in the first place if FYROM didn't try to steal Greek and Bulgarian history. Macedonian Slavs were never a majority in Greek Macedonia, simply because they didn't exist. All demographies state them as "Bulgarians", but they were never a majority anyway, that's just the Big Brother talking again. All Macedonian Slavs on the internet come up with the same story "my parents were evicted by the smelly Greeks and I go back to visit the billions of Slavophones every month blah blah blah". If there's so many of them, how come none of the Greeks have ever seen any? I mean I know they're all a bunch of liars and thieves to you, who would never admit beeing with Mac Slavs in order to be able to torture them eternally, but they can't be 7816:
land until the Balkan wars. The only place that was originally Greek, was south of Thessalie, mostly around Sparta and those broken rocks in Athens which Greece cherishes so much as their "rich history". And now that Greece got hold of a land like Macedonia, they are holding it tight with both hands. Now that RoM has declared independence in 1991, they are holding it tighter. Although the RoM has never made land claims on Greece, has a population of only 2 million people, and has almost no army, Greece is still worried about Greek Macedonia because they know that Macedonia is not really theirs, they know what they did in the past was wrong, they know there are alot of angry Macedonians who are from northern Greece who might want to seperate, and they know that one day the truth will come out.
6920:) Its a fact that Macedonians in Greece exist, you can't change it. I also feel that judging by your POV, you may only be cosidering Greek-point-of-view sources in your research. Have you ever tried any non-Greek sources? Britannica? Human Rights Watch? Reality? Only Greeks stubbornly consider the Macedonians in Greece as Slavophone Greeks, despite what the international community thinks. I advise you to accept the truth. Accept that "Slavophone Greeks" is a racist term used by Greeks to refer to the Macedonians, who to this day suffer the lack of basic human rights and decades of racism and discrimination by Greeks. And yet Greece, continually tries to deny the the existence of Macedonians, forbidding them to express their culture, language, views, and most importantly, their IDENTITY. - 6906:, and their massacres against the Greco-Jewish population of Thessaloniki, I think that's a tiny detail that needs to be mentioned every time someone wants to bring up Greek policies in the region. Furthermore Metaxas was a fascist and not a representative of the Greek people, so his actions should not be abstractly referred to as the actions of the "Greeks". Thirdly, Slavophones not all Slavophones today are recognised by neither themselves nor by others as "Macedonians", and any claims on the opposite are just unsourced POV. Slavophone Greeks do however have the status of "Greek citizens" in the same way that "French Arabs" have a French nationality and are only recognised as such. They are therefore equal by law, stop trying to lie about this on the article. 3634:
pages). Will all the WP rules be broken and bented in this issue? All that needs to be done is to find a good disambiguation term. Various have been proposed, but all have been rejected in favor of Macedonians plain vanilla. Have they been self-identifying as Macedonians plain vanilla since 1992, write it in WP as the rules say. Have they used other terms before? Can any of them be used as a disambiguation? Why all other Macedonians are Macedonians-something? If the terms slav-slavic is offensive why do their historians and their politicians use it? Can something like that be used as a disambig? Well I don't know because they never answered such questions because they wanted to be named plain-vanilla-Macedonians. And after the one night consensus they got it.
10624:
with other Mediterranean populations so it's not beybond a reasonable doubt that Macedonians have some Greek ancestry of indeterminate origin. Historical records often discuss conquests by a small group or tribe OR some major events, while the masses are left unrepresented. You can see this with the American Revolution in which a large proportion of 'Americans' favored remaining a part of Britain. The usage of Macedonia from a geographic perspective is perfectly valid AND since no one can agree as to who are the real Macedonians, we can just go by their language and still classify them as Slavs which is already the case. This doesn't in any way alter the situation as cultural assimilation can take many forms and exclusive name usage is rather pointless.
12911:
many Bulgarians. Would they be Serbs if there was no Tito? Maybe, probably. With some rebels, like in Bulgaria. But not more than 5.000 of them, like in Bulgaria. People get assimilated now and then. But they were always Macedonians, like the Dalmatian Croats will always be Dalmatians, and Croats - ...well, depending on the historic circumstances. But one thing is certain for me, although I am partly Bulgarian - if Macedonians were something else during their history, they were Serbs in the Middle Ages, and they were Serbs only as a part of a bigger identity, like I was Yugoslav once upon a time. When Serbia fell, the Macedonians remained what they have always been - Macedonians. When Yugoslavia fell, we are not Yugoslav any longer....
3162:
5000. On the other hand there is no matter about Arvanites and Aromanians. You may search all greece and you won't find nowadays more than 500 people that speak those languages and not consider themselfs as greeks. Other countries are afraid minorities too. FYROM in it's censuses consider Aromanians as different ethinicisty from Greeks, even though 99% of the masculine population and more than the haalf of female population spoke Greek too 50-100 years ago, and almost all of them cosnidered themselfs as greeks. This is done deliberetaly to avoid admiting the existance of a greek minority in it's borders. It's the last thing FYROM would want. Same does Albania with Aromanians, although the subject is more complicated there.
12840:
Milos Obrenovic and Karadjordje took it once in their Serbian Uprising and kept planning how to liberate it?) were Bulgarized? How many there are Serbs in Bulgaria? There are 5.000 Macedonians, but how many Vlach or Serbs? None. All assimilated. How many Bulgarians in Serbia? Two municiplaities! All of them! Bosilegrad and Dimirovgrad (ex-Caribrod). Why did not the Serbs assimilated them into the Serbian nation, if they intended to assimilate the 100% of "Bulgarians" in Macedonia? Their surnames have not been changed ever since! In Macedonia, all the surnames were changed in 1912. It coul mean only one thing - the Serbs assimilated only what they considered their nation, not the foreigners (except Vlachs).
13271:
aren't Serbs native of Serbia??? If we considered your point that today's Macedonians are direct decendents from these Slav invaders who settled in the region 1500 years ago, well isn't 1500 years native enough to you? (despite the Slavs mixing with the ancient ethnic groups in the region who have been there thousands of years before). One can only see all the irony when Macedonians of Macedonia are not considered native to you, while Greeks in Macedonia who originate from Pontic refugees from Turkey, first coming in the 1920's, are considered native to you. Greeks have even given the name to Macedonians in Greece as "dopia" meaning natives, so what are you trying to prove with your annoying reverts? --
10580:. Like Decius said, what is yet to be proved is that ancient Macedonians did exist at the time, and they did live in region of Vardar. Let me remind you that ancient Macedon was initially much smaller than Greek Macedonia. Philip expansion integrated Northern lands (Southern FYROM), which was called Upper Macedonia and was inhabited by Thraco-Illyrians. The proper FYROM region was inhabited by Paeonians and Dardanians. Even if we take into consideration the "assimilatioon" theory, one will never prove that assimilation with actual "Ancient Macedonians" ever took place. It is most likely that those populations that assimilated with Slavs in FYROM, were Hellenized Thraco-Illyrians. According to 5420:
must be called Macedonians. As about wikipedia policy, you have just edited the part of wikipedia rules that you like; I mean the half rule. As I said, yes, your people will be called Macedonians mainly because of Knowledge's rule, but on the other hand this article with name macedonians, according to wikipedia, will refer in parenthesis that it is for slavs. As about reverting without discussion, I remind you that you r the first one that reverted the article when it had the name Macedonian (Slav). And that without discussion. Sorry if I am wrong you had discussed it with other Slavic Macedonians. Because according to you Knowledge is for Slav Macedonians!
10219:, and if Dacia/Dacian was also claimed by a people to the south of these northerly "Dacian" people; and to make it even better, if to the northeast of these "Dacians" (Romanians), there was a country full of people who still called themselves Romanians, and who claim (with much historical evidence) that the "Dacians" only began calling themselves "Dacians" in the past 60 years or so, and before that they were known as Romanians and were the same people as the rest of the Romanians, with only regional differences. Then I would be applauding your skill at finding parallel examples. With that said, there are good arguments for either name for the article: 5996:
it, one can get the impression that only the Bulgarians DID NOT assimilate the Macedonians, and it was quite the opposite! Actually, the Bulgarization process of Macedonians and Serbs from Eastern Serbia and what is now Bulgaria (Vidin, Kjustendil etc), especially during the Bulgarian occupations in the I and II World wars were among the storngest in the history of Balkans. As a person of Serbian, Macedonian, Bulgarian and Aromanian origins, I have a clear right to say that. I will continue with posting the Bulgarization article until the malicious people stop reverting it, OK? Also, I would like to explain the surname endings once again.
12670:
themselves merely Christians or Slavic Macedonians, and then the 1848 came, and the moder nationalist consciousness rose up, and here we are. It's not only Misirkov, these are not only the nationalists, it is quite obvious that the uniformness of "Bulgarian self-identification of Macedonians until 1878" is simply not true. Why believing other sources that claim the Bulgarian origins of Macedonia? The Turks or the Greeks were objective????? About the Vanevski family, these are my relatives. I'll try to produce some documents, but it's hard. I hope that someone will help me - I call everyone from the area to help me. Saluti!
552:. Even if we reach some concensus here, how can I know that when we leave Knowledge (for various reasons) the article will not simply be changed by any nationalist from any of the sides? I am not planning to leave soon, but what if some nationalistic Macedonian, Greek, Bulgarian, Albanian etc... just appears one day and slowly, little by little changes this page into one that will fit his POV. I am not sure it is worthed to waste so much time, when users that were already banned on some other regional Knowledge for spreading propaganda can still be a part of this Knowledge and again, spread propaganda. 13029:
borders of Bulgarian 1878 there is no (or very little) Serb self-consciousness, no matter that the people from both sides of the Serb-Bulgarian border without any doubt belong to the same ethnic entity. Mixed self-consciousness exists only in the territories which until 1919 represent the Bulgarian territory and later entered within Serbia. In the same way the division between the Macedonian and the two neighboring Slavic nations was made on a political and geographic basis. This is why I think tagging many people from Macedonia in the 19th century as Bulgarians is anachronism. Regards --
8520:'s name (POV), and then a Slavic-to-Greek conversion of a family name (that he probably invented himself). I've been reverting his edits mercilessly, only after I verified with admins that if falls under "official policy vandalism". He's been doing the same in other articles, that are still under his unsourced version. Ironically enough, he reported me in the AdminBoard under the fallacy that "I would blindly revert all edits from all users" on that article. He didn't only hide information but he also lied about my intentions. I urged him many times to read 6722:"These latest data dramatize even further the results obtained by Lewontin, leading one geneticist to conclude, "These results indicate that individual variation in DNA profiles overwhelm any interpopulational differences, no matter how the populations are racially or ethnically classified" (Cummings, 1994, p. 500). And while not quite as overwhelming, all the genetically based studies cited here support Lewontin's initial results, strongly indicating that the great majority of human variation does occur within human populations---not between them." 12764:
King Leopold I urged the MACEDONIAN PEOPLE TO FIGHT....i wont do this work for you...you can find these sources yourself....anyways....after this failed rebellion and the Austrian withdrawl...certain MACEDONIANS fled and ended up in Russia....where they were incorporated into the Russian military....holding the title of "The MACEDONIAN regiment"....now if these were Bulgarians...wouldnt it have been named the "BULGARIAN REGIMENT" or was it just a way to say that these were Bulgarians from Macedonia so they called it "The Macedonian regiment"?:)
10678:
and for their country is really up to them. They call themselves Macedonians. The disambiguation page splinters off the different meanings and leaves the reader with the solid conceptual realization that the term Macedonian has different meanings. Thus, Macedonian people would not be confusing at all, especially with an Italicized reminder at the top explaining that these are Slavic-speaking Macedonians as opposed to the ancient Macedonians. If written in this fashion it is neutral and doesn't promote any relationship other than name usage.
11556:"Macedonia" Bertrand de la Brocuiere didn't ment some part ot the present region of Macedonia (Vardar, Pirin or Aegean). Like many other authors he was influenced from some medieval ideas for Macedonia (the other authors was influenced from earliest antique's ideas for Balkan geography) and he clearly defined Macedonia in present day Thrace, in Maritsa valley. He wrote that the capital of Macedonia was Filipopolis (Plovdiv) in present Bulgaria. And when he talk about Macedonians he didn't ment the inhabitants of present Macedonia. 1099:(the proof is, as I pointed out, that the Moldovans in Romania did not proclaim their separateness from Romanians, nor was any assimilation done to prevent them from proclaiming this if they wanted to. So new "ethnic groups" can be created by outside forces who act on an initially regional impetus. Of course, each case is different. In the case of Macedonian, there was more difference in the language between Macedonian and standard (?) Bulgarian, whereas in Moldovan there is only some regionalisms. But still, it can happen.) 9440:- I feel that it's preferable to maintain the current disambiguation. "Macedonian people" is much too vague - it covers anyone who lives in Macedonia (Greeks, Bulgarians, Macedonians, Vlachs etc...). However, "Macedonians (ethnic group)" makes it clear that the article's subject is the ethnic group of that name. Note that in the other examples cited by Khoikhoi there's no confusion between the ethnic group and a geographical region as there is between Macedonians (ethnic and geographical)/Macedonia/Republic of Macedonia. -- 12043:": it shows proofs of being a very serious and conscientious work. Only it would be better if you used as examples names of people you are certain exist, and citing bothfirst and second name: while speaking of name transformations in Greek Macedonia, add example of true people, like "Vasil Natchev became Vasilios Natsulis", if you have been informed of such person whose name has had such modification. And adding to the article an image or two of documents of name changes from Bulgarian or Serbian Macedonia would be nice. 7749:
northern Greece almost every year and from personal experiances, Macedonians are very visible in Western Macedonia. I've been able to get around speaking in Macedonian and English and not Greek. It was last year when I even heard for the first time Macedonian music broadcasted live on the radio in Florina and Nauosa. I also heard Macedonian music being played in clubs and bars in Edessa. Macedonian village festivals are always being held in Edessa, and what really shocked me, was when I heard the Macedonian song
11028:
understand how most macSlavs fall for this propaganda anyway. All countries have a dose of nationalist propagandas, but in most countries I'm familiar with, the majority tends to mock it. So far I have not encountered a single Macedonian Slav that doesn't go over the same old arguments again and again, the ones that are posted in websites, published in FYROM schoolbooks etc. The most moderate and due all the respect "civilised" person I've met is Flavrsarv. I still disagree with 99% of what he says.
10825:. They just keep trying to make us believe that the "BULGARIAN Patriarchate of Orchid", is in fact the modern Macedonian Orthodox Church (not recognized by any christian body). Have a look at the contributions of the pre-mentioned users. All you can see is edit-warring, nationalist edits, edit-warring, POV-pushing and some edit-warring. So don't talk about "kicking around poor MacSlavs" and having "already empasised" enough. I find it hard to believe that you're the most unbiased editor yourself. 5127:
the macedonian greeks and macedonian bulgarians. I don't find a reason to be more Macedonians than the others. I remind you that wikipedia is a neutral encyclopedia and not a place for your people to make propaganda. Greeks don't accept for macedonian ethnicity. I think the previous article was fair. It was refering for Macedonians which you claim that is your ethnicity and it was in parenthesis Slavs. I think the article name must cover all the sides. Just see what even Knowledge suggests...
31: 12547:
and smaller communities in Skadar,Podgorica and Spuzh,Serbian tribes live in eastern mountains Altin-Ili in Dibr-Sipre in the area of Struga as well as in eastern coast of the Ohrid Lake, further in the valleys of Rezna and Prespa in the city of Monastir and its northeastern surrounding, in the valley Srebrnica,and by name on communities of Optorosh,Shrbica,Mahmusha,Mrtvuca,along the left, eastern coast of White Drim in communities of Kremovik, Mirozhizh, Cuprevo, Grebnik, Zlokuche."
11046:
really besides the point here. I'm backing the view that mostly they are descended from Slavic invaders who merged with some other groups in the region. I'm not saying they can lay any exclusive claim to anything let alone the Macedonian Greeks. So to be clear, all I'm saying is call it Macedonian people or Macedonians, while allowing the disambiguation page to clarify as to the different meanings and applications of Macedonian including geographic, historical, linguistic, etc. Okay?
12831:
surname Vukadinov (from Serbian name Vukadin, with the vocalised U, not Bulgarian form V'lkadinov). I know it because my uncle in Sofia has the surname Vukadinov. There were lot of Bulgarians that migrated together with Serbs from Kjustendil to Vojvodina. Novi Sad, Vojvodina's capital, was called Mlada Loza in 1748, in Bulgarian. Why don't Bulgarians try to remembre their Serbianized people in Vojvodina, but kept insisting on the non-existent Bulgarian majority in Macedonia? Strange.
5964: 5700: 5653: 5567: 5536: 5443: 5361: 5323: 5179: 5096: 5023: 4978: 4942: 4870: 4795: 4745: 4668: 4617: 4549: 4440: 4337: 4152: 4058: 3857: 3812: 3670: 3569: 3362: 3202: 3104: 3020: 2941: 2865: 2745: 2702: 2587: 2532: 2405: 2340: 2269: 2198: 2128: 2003: 1936: 1829: 1713: 1569: 1387: 1251: 1208: 1125: 574: 537: 511: 480: 454: 419: 379: 349: 314: 287: 245: 2915:
nation can not be grown over night. An average lifetime is about 75 years. Also, I think you know that the family is the one who raises you to be a part of some religion or nationality (I am sure if you were born in Indian Hindu family, you would probably that, an Indian Hindu). So, think about it how ridiculous is to claim that just 100 years ago we were Bulgarians. If you are in my scin now, you would know how senceless that seems to me (as a ethnic Macedonian).
11329:, which was the official holder of the land. Your nationalist interpretation was straight-away "conquered from the Slavs!". Those are the results of a 60-year old nationalist propaganda, thank you for the demonstration. Melas was himself a Macedonian, a Greek one of course. He had no reason to regard his motherland as a foreign region. The "conquest" of (Greek) Macedonia from the Turks was in fact liberation to him. That's right, there have always been Greeks in 8837:"My family's name was originally Nachev; they were forced to change it in the 1920s to a Greek name. Two years ago I tried to change it back. I went to the nomarch's office to do it; I was told that it was a "foreign-sounding" name, and that I could not change it. I didn't appeal the decision. In theory it is possible to appeal such a thing, but I know from talking with others that there is no way I could win." 12103:(Emperor) of Romans and Serbs". Now the title of Emperor in the Middle Ages could only come from a connection with the Roman Empire, because this was the sole source of supreme legitimacy. The version you give of his title was only present in some versions of the law code, and I ask myself if it is a correct English translation, and if "Macedonian" isn't really "Roman". The source that give the transcript are nationist, so can harldly be trusted. 9547:- I really don't know. I doubt there will be a great confusion if it redirects to "Macedonian people" (it would also be consistent with other similar articles), but on the other hand, I don't know what's wrong with the current disambiguation. "Ethnic" is a relatively new word/concept in the Balkans, so the folks here tend to associate it (I guess) with the recent wars, and has a somewhat negative reputation. The word, in itself, is OK, however. -- 9646:
then? Or Bulgarian Macedonians as they are pretty much the same group, BUT it seems that they are not behaving as such lately. That way it would be clear that there are two types of Macedonians. It seems strange, but are there even plans for Greek Macedonians page? Perhaps if there were two pages, as Bomac seems to suggest, there would be disambiguation page that would allow readers to choose one and realize that the two are somewhat distinct?
9400:: there has been a conflict between Greece and the state of Macedonia over the name "Macedonia", whether or not it should exclusively apply to the separate state or to the Greek region. "Macedonians" is not unambiguous whether it implies only the people of the Macedonian state, only the people of the Greek province, or "ethnic" Macedonians (that live in both countries) - so the bracketed qualifier "(ethnic group)" seems on its place to me. -- 4269:
did too, that there was little chance of obtaining consensus from two groups of rival nationalists. If this solution was imposed, it was only because neither side wanted to compromise or follow Knowledge's rules. That's not a situation that administrators can tolerate indefinitely. Ed and I aren't partisans in the Greek-Macedonian conflict, but we do have a responsibility to defend and where necessary enforce Knowledge's basic policies. --
12002: 9565:- I see no major problem with either of the titles/terms. Clearly, a "people" constitute a people (or nation) if they deem themselves to be a distinct collectivity of persons, and are identified as such by other peoples. If there is a need in this case to emphasize the distinction between peoplehood and citizenship or between similarly named peoples (past or present), then perhaps the title merits added considerations to disambiguate. 9352: 5486: 5409: 5306: 5218: 5118: 5043: 5005: 4900: 4849: 4497: 4463: 4406: 4227: 4213: 4199: 4181: 4129: 4095: 4011: 3940: 3741: 3718: 3696: 3406: 3322: 3236: 3068: 2788: 2764: 2722: 2627: 2427: 2302: 2292: 2235: 2151: 1917: 1806: 1754: 1734: 1672: 1606: 1544: 1428:. Apparently MATIA thinks that we are in violation of Knowledge policy by allowing the article to remain at Macedonians (ethnic group) and he asked users from the Greek Knowledge to "migrate" to the English WP and (quote): "δώσε ένα χεράκι" (i.e. give a hand, help). This concerted attempt to "force" a particular POV onto the English (i.e. the BEST) Knowledge is unacceptable. Knowledge should be neutral and we should all observe 12563:
faith of Serbia and Upper Moesia.It must therefore be evident that the great danger to be apprehended to the rule of the Osmanli in these provinces, is the successful inroad of the Serbian nationality into Macedonia; with this people they have the tradition of right, and their former greatness, aided by the powerful ties of race and creed" Edmund Spencer, "Travels in European Turkey", vol. II , London, 1851, pp. 30
8657:
Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia" to normalize relations with Greece in the dispute of '95, so I dont know where you're going with this. Secondly, no one has proof to what the ancient Macedonians were, there are many references though making them an independent people or a people related to the Ancient Greeks, so its not upto you or wikipedia to decide what they were. So I don't see why Greeks would call themselves "
7557:" right? That's interesting, because I could swear that I have see you constantly propagating on how the term "Slav" is a racial slur. Actually I don't even have to swear, all I have to do is browse the history of this discussion a little bit. But anyway, I suppose now it became "sometimes really annoying". Well, what can you do, times change, people change, hell even the names of nations change, isn't that right? 12741:
Ivanov "Bulgarians in Macedonia" (Sofia 1917, 1986) are included 240 documents that shows the Bulgarian belonging of Macedonians. Only in one book! Please do not force ne to translate entire book. Let do not forget how many historical persons present Maceonian ideology "devides" with Bulgarians and how many (how little) with Serbians, Greeks, Albanians. Why it is so difficult between Bulgarians and Macedonians? --
1490: 8547:, one was from the Human Rights Watch, done by independent researchers who have visited Greek Macedonia and done a report on it. The other two were Macedonian websites, but I chose them only because they had sourced, reliable references on their page with none or neutral POVs. Despite all these sources which he repetedly ignored and deleted, he was accusing me of vandalism and not knowing what sourcing was. Even 12656:
chief city of Old Serbia.....the rural population, although it is Serbian in origin, has for the most parts given its support to the Exarchate, since a Bulgarian bishop is for them more acceptable than a Greek bishop of the Ecumenical Church to which they formerly belonged. This is how the rural population around Skoplje has today come to be mostly Bulgarian; the same is true of the purely Serbian Tetovo".
13102:. I don't understand something though - at no place in there does it say that restrictions and harrasment by the Greek authorities are the cause of the fact that the vast majority of "Slavophones" identify as Greeks. If there is such a section, please copy it here. I personally cannot find a reason for the Greek self identification of vast majority of the ethnic Macedonians in Greece in that document. -- 12865:
correct, it offends me presonally. The Slavs had the predominant genetic role in forming of Bulgarian nation. They are pure Slavs, as Macedonians or Serbs or Croats. Besides, the genentic structures showed that Serbs and Croats, for instance, have some 40% of Illyrian/Thracian blood (National Geographic Hrvatska, page XVI, October 2004, Zagreb). Bulgarians are not less Slavs than Serbs or Macedonians.
10295:" means they claim they are Italian. I'm going on about this because your example really is unsatisfactory (it's not quite, as you say, "maybe Romanians are part Roman, and maybe they're not", unless you mean "part Italic", which is irrelevant). The Macedonian situation is pretty different, nor do you seem to have had much of a clue about the Macedonian situation up until yesterday and today. Be as 7684:
reason that Macedonian is mostly spoken in the Northern Greek districts. So I consider myself a Macedonian, with ancestry who came from Aegean Macedonia (or modern Greece). So no Miskin, I do not speak Greek. I speak English and Macedonian. I do however, only know one phrase roughly in Greek : Δεν μιλώ τα ελληνικά, και δεν θέλω να μάθω πώς να μιλήσω τα ελληνικά. Μιλώ Μακεδόνικά και αγγλικά μόνο. -
1498: 10893:. His theory was that those lands were too fertile and gave Greeks the chance to develop rapidly their economy after WW2. Hence it should have been FYROM in the place of Greece now. I've heard this before and it's certain that you can find it on the internet somewhere. It wasn't told at random, it's an actual part of the ex-communist propaganda. I don't think I need to elaborate any further. 11042:
most part, but there is some input from Germanic tribes. Think about how many Visigoths there were and the population of Spain which was considerably bigger. It's like saying the French are all Franks. That's absurd. You're making the mistake of equating invasions and settlement withtout considering the number of natives who generally outnumber invaders in most scenarios around the world.
10735:, for example). IMO and in the opinion of many historians, Slavs invaded Macedonia before the Vlachs. I would be curious to see how many historians claim that Vlachs were in Macedonia before Slavs. The occasional Vlach or group of Vlachs may have went down into Macedonia for whatever reason before the Slavic invasion, but as a sizable mass, the Slavs were probably there before Vlachs. 2896:"So, which Greek census we can use, when Greece is ignoring and assimilating the Macedonians for more than 100 years?" It's true that Greece had done alot to get rid of minority languages, including the slavomacedonian language. One of the sad outcomes of the greek politicy in this subject is that we don't have any Greek census. But that doesn't mean we can use an imaginary census.-- 3077:
money and time to perform a "census"? Did a group of researchers go around all northern Greece and asked every single person what language he/she speaks? I am not amnesiac and I don't remember anyone asking neither me, nor my grandparents living in Florina region. I have no idea on how Ethologue (that surely is a reputable publisher) found that number. It's realy surprising.
6055:
true for the Greeks as the ancient Macedonians, the modern Macedonians or for that matter the Koreans, the Welsh, or the Egyptians. What's more, much of this kind of discussion is motivated by some peculiar notion that modern legitimacy derives from ancient roots, which again is as peculiar a notion for the Macedonians or the Greeks as for the Israelis or the Sinhalese. --
501:
can not be denied. Also, any ethnic group from south Balkan has a right to feel the same. Many nations feel some origin from the Antique Macedonians, including the Greeks, Macedonians, Bulgarians, Albanians and Romanians. It is shame if Knowledge takes sides on this. The culture, language and beleives of the Antique Macedonians are different from any of the modern ones.
7234:
place in the world where "Slavic" is used as a racial slur. For those and the rest of the obvious reasons, Slavic should be pointed out. The reason you didn't want to mention it in the first place was to fool the historically ignorant readers into thinking that "ancient Hellenic" has a remote connection to "Modern Slavic" one. And that wouldn't be a nice thing to do.
11504:(from the records of the Synod of the Ohrid Archbishopric) - In 1891, Cardinal J. Pitra published a collection of documents (155 in number) which refer to the Ohrid Archbishopric during the time of Archbishop Demetrius Homatian (1216-1235). It is established from these records that in this period in Macedonia, the majority of the population consisted of Macedonians. 12873:
our country and proud of it, so we started to forget our separate identities, feeling ourselves a part of a bigger and mightier identity, Yugoslavs. 8 out of 30 pupils in my Grammar School declared themselves Yugoslavs - all were Slavs that felt they are part of something bigger, not Serbs, Croats, Macedonians or Slovenes, but Yugoslavs. And they were proud of it.
8283:"Forcibly" only means that the population exchange was done, as in the Greece-Turkey case, without asking the opinion of the local populations in both countries, and in both countries imposing the will of the government over that of the people. Or do you think that everybody was all too happy to leave his farm and village, to migrate to a future uncertain at best? 1045:
western Macedonian dialects formal Macedonian is based on). For the rest, you are only bullshitting again, trying to evoke other editers' pity about "the poor little Macedonians" and "the big bad Bulgarians and Greeks". I can defend my points and I do it, don't think that you can get away with your edits just because of pity for you and your nation, no way, dear.
8294:
territory. I think that detail justifies the behaviour of the Greeks on a minority that was regarded at the time as "Bulgarian". If this is left out, it is implied that Greeks were discriminated MacSlavs just because they're evil, racist bastards (MacSlav POV). Same goes for the rest of the edits I pointed out. And I don't understand why you keep removing the
12727:"19th century ethnographers and travellers were generally united in identifying them as Bulgarians until the period between 1878 and 1912 when the rival propaganda machines of Serbia, Greece and Bulgaria succeeded in effectively splitting the Slavophone population of Macedonia into three distinct parties, a pro-Serbian, pro-Greek and pro-Bulgarian one" 13167:
God only knows what. And the same argument can be made for nearly all ethnic or regional parties. And remember that all the numers of the party are already given in the sub-paragraph on the Macedonians in Greece today. For this I'll remove the piece, only leaving "It should be noted that language and ethnicity are not coterminous", which makes sense.
11292:, and although I don't remember in detail, I'm sure as hell that it didn't have any implications on a "Macedonian nation". The Greeks were never aware of a Macedonian nation before 1991, neither were Bulgarians and apparently nor was anybody except the post-Tito Yugoslavians. Even if the book said something like that, your claim would fall under 8741:, thank you very much, now even more people owe me an apology. The fault is that you're coming up with a fictional example, for a possible fictional scenario. In other words you're turning the article into Sci&Fi (which is pretty much it anyway). Save your personal examples for your friends and family, but please keep them out of public view. 2696:
killer like Alexander the Great was) But, it is a fact that those historians can not be ignored, because they are reality (same as your claim that the Antique Macedonians are Greeks, no matter most of the world denies it and no matter there are at least 20 centuries difference between those people and the formation of the modern Greek identity).
277:
us, so no one stopped them to grow intoa nation. On the other hand, Macedonia stayed in the hands of the Ottomans many years more, therefore the Macedonian nation was formed little latter, somewhere at the end of the 19th and beggining of the 20th sentury. Anyway, this formation was lasting for centuries, probably starting in the medieval ages.
7583:. But for the sake of you Greeks and propagandic nationalists who are stubournly trying to ignore facts and put the lowest number of Macedonians as possible, I was puting in the article "1.6 - 2 million Macedonians (est)" just to try to be nice. So lets just leave it at that and end this dispute since there is nothing to be disputed about. - 5901:. The latest census didn't have a separate graph for ethnic affiliation. This has caused several protests from the Greek and other minorities (including Macedonian) in Albania. This has to be mentioned in the text, as well as the information that estimates of Macedonians in Albania, vary from 5000 to 30000, which is a significant difference. 7694:, did you forget about that? They were also forced out of their houses, but of course Big Brother doesn't talk about it. Those were different times that cannot be judged with our meta-modern criteria. Haven't you ever thought that it's been a long time since your parents left Macedonia (the real one)? 2,000,000 Greeks were forced out of 13122:. Even worse is to say that because of "harrasment and discrimination" from the Greek government outlined in an old report that current identity politics and voting should be dismissed -- this is purely speculative and wouldn't cut it in an Opinion Editorial, much less here. Please don't fuss over trying to find the right wording for 12686:
you take the observations of ignorant foreigners and talk about them like theyre fact....these are the facts.....these nations......most nations(excluding Greece) recognize us for what we are.....why has WIKIPEDIA taken sides?Personal points of view shouldnt mattter......Knowledge has become a puppet for these propagandists...good job.
6828:. Now, the reason for my concerns is not my opposition to that claim, but the fact than nobody seemed to dispute it, in times when the Ancient Macedonian ancestry was vigorously denied. How come? I haven't seen any sources that would support significant Bulgar, Kuman or Pecheneg influence in the Macedonians' ethnic complexity . -- 11067:- but when you think about it, many states and peoples are named after states and peoples that no longer exist as separate identifiable entities; often, successor states of ancient empires, direct descendants and cultural heirs are primarily found elsewhere or nowhere at all. Compare the etymologies of these these contemporary 8780:- This comment simply proves that you haven't been reading my edits. I haven't changed anything, I've pointed this out 3 times already, and one of them was right above your last edit. I never denied changes in placenames, and I didn't take it out of the article, I denied that those names were in fact "Macedonian" as opposed to 10181:
we are supporting an exclusive use of Macedonia for Macedonian Slavs? I merely said that this article should be treated like all the others FOLLOWING a clearly marked disambiguation page. Everything else seems to be set these people apart further still. Comparing the Nazis to the Macedonians? That your idea of being serious?
11435:, and point out that several scholars classify it as a Greek-Slavic language. If you don't do this, then you'll be using double standards. Until you do this, you don't have the right to isolate those quotes and put them here according to the interpretation you have chosen to give. Furthermore, this source would only satisfy 10997:
significance such as the case of the MacSlav propaganda. The problem with the MacSlav claims is that they are insulting on the Greeks, who have long been connected to the history of the Macedonian region. If the Greeks had somehow been lost in history, I'm sure that nobody would raise more than an eyebrow in the site of a
12064:" a general consensus that in the Middle Ages Macedonians and Bulgarians were one people" - this statement is simply not true. Which medieval history handbooks? Where does Ostrogorsky says this? The truth of the matter, there are much more Serbian references than Bulgarian in Macedonia in 14-18 century. Have a look here: 9846:: they're not going anywhere. If evidence and legitimate references exist for any of the various modern Macedonian claims, it will be included in the article in the main sections (otherwise, they will have to be relegated to a section describing modern unsubstantiated claims or else completely removed). I'll go find that 7221:. Plus, everyone who will search this article, will certainly search something about the Macedonians (as an ethnicity). Noone will get confused here with the Greek, Bulgarian or even Marsian Macedonians. So, I don't know what's Miskin's problem. I insist "Slavs" not to be mentioned there (for a hundred times). Regards, 12620:
celebrated by Serbs not only in Serbia,in Austria,Hungary,Bosnia,Montenegro,Kosovo,Morava and area of Prizren,but also in the areas of Skopje,Veles,Prilep,Bitola and Ohrid,including also Debar and the area of Tetovo.All inhabitants in the mentioned area who speak with the Slavo-Serbian dialect keep that custom holy."
12869:
Bulgarian (than predominanlty Asiatic) aristocracy and made their own kingdom, Samuil's Empire. This was a liberation of Western Slavs from the Bulgarian state, not the "moving of the capital" westwards. Then Macedonian Slavs united under the Macedonian regional name, because the tribal differences were forgotten.
3217:
mean that we can't be right. Why don't you find some sources to prove your claim that Greece is 100% Greek speaking and that Britannica is lying? Until you do, you will be simply trolling the article. The international human rights organisations estimates on the number of Vorioipirote Greeks in Albania are used on
10963:
term at any rate. I'm not saying that Macedonian Slavs are or aren't partially descended from the ancient Macedonians, but whether they are or not shouldn't be used against them to further denote what some view as their questionable nationality. It's all subjective and nationalities can take the form or religion (
11999:. I'd suggest that you use portraits of contemporary people, who are universally regarded as Macedonians (which haven't stated another nationality), such as your president or prime minister, some other important, influential or just popular figure and so on. These portraits now will only intensify any disputes. 8552:
know why you would take out "Hellenization" but keep "A number of Macedonian Slavic and Turkish place names and Slavic personal surnames were renamed during this period." Then, to back up this sentence, I gave an example of a town named Lerin, that was renamed during Hellenization to Florina. According to the
6258:, though there is no way at present to verify this. If present, the transmission of genes from the ancient Macedonians could have happened via the descendants of Hellenized ancient Macedonians, many historians believing that the ancient Macedonians were completely Hellenized by the time of the Slavic arrival." 6041:
Macedonians were Hellenized by the time the Slavs came, and if they are right that means there were Greeks and Slavs mixing, not ancient (no longer ancient in Byzantine times) Macedonians mixing with Slavs. The burden seems to be on the opposing party to bring references that argue for a late survival of the
5611:
the projected state. "This Government considers talk of Macedonian "nation", Macedonian "Fatherland", or Macedonia "national consciousness" to be unjustified demagoguery representing no ethnic nor political reality, and sees in its present revival a possible cloak for aggressive intentions against Greece".
12583:
Filip Aleksich proshenijem od 21 t.m. mole Knjaza da bi se obshtini ninoi Selachkoi u Albaniji za Crkvu shtogod knjiga pravitelstvom srpskim za sirotinske crkve u Turskoj nabavljeni podarilo. Djambazovski, K. et al. "Arhivska Gragja za istorijata na Makedonskiot narod" Beograd 1979 vol I, book 2, pp. 235
9954:(that's why "Italians are not complaining"). Being Academic is a good idea. I'm not upset, just a bit irritated by the murkiness of your statements; nor am I really that against "Macedonian people" for this article or anything. It's just the philosophy: "If you're going to do the math, do the math right". 9996:
Everyone would call themselves Romans or successors of the Roman Empire, including Germans, Greeks, Russians and Turks. At the end of the day, the Romanians speak a "Romance language", which proves that they have a cultural heritage from the Romans, and therefore a real reason to call themselves as such.
11923:, who was later named into 'Bulgaroktonos' i.e. the "Bulgar-slayer". What more proof do you want in order to accept that Macedonian Slavs were part of the Bulgarian nation before the 20th century BC, and that "Macedonians" was a term which was reserved primarily for ethnic Greeks? A time-machine maybe? 13166:
I'm all with JKelly. This POV of using a parties vote to estabilish Macedonian ethnicity is absurd: if we accepted it, in Scotland (just to make an example) only those who vote for the Scottish National Party could be considered Scots, while all the other (3/4 of the population) are really English or
12880:
11. What the Greeks or the Turks thought of Macedonian identity, is not relevant, and not worth quoting it. They sticked to their first impressions from the Bulgarian Empire. For example, the majority of people called Czechoslovakians just Czechs, or Britons just English! How many times we have heard
12751:
JSimin, it is very doubtful that all those 240 references are about medieval time. I suspect most of them are about 19 century. Even the ones before, are mostly from travelers like Evliya Celebi, who found Bulgarians in Belgrade and Sarajevo.Why don't you scan the references so we can compare, if is
12736:
I knew this was all leading somewhere.....you guys leave out a very imporant part......its a crucial cog in the propaganda....that is....the fact that TITO created this false Macedonian nation...he gave the people their orders.....they saluted and conformed....because they have such a long history of
12705:
The 20th century?That is the 1900's if im correct.This is quite funny because a political and national identity was formed before the turn of the previous century...some would argue that it was formed millenia ago...others would say centuries ago...you have chosen to limit our history to a handful of
12641:
75) A conclusion by the linguist Petar Draganov about the songs of "Macedonian Slavs":"It is a strikingly obvious that within the circle of Cars,Kings,dukes,heroes and other individuals of these songs one can find only persons and significant events from the medieval,new and latest Serbian history".
12626:
73) "Divided by faith on three parts, divided out of political destiny, under various jurisdictions, Serbian race has the missfortune to be dispersed over various provinces, names of which hinther its unity.Serbia, Old Serbia, (in today's Turkish vilayets of Kosovo and Sandjak) , Bosnia, Herzegovina,
12546:
63) A statement by Joseph Muller, Austrian, Medical officer in Turkish Army in early 19th century, who worked in Albania about Slavs in neighboring countries that were visited by him.Dr. Muller was a fluent speaker of the Serbian language. "Together with Slavic community of Spiz on Triplex confinium
12493:
55) Archbishop of Bar, Vichentije Zmajevich mentiones that "main places in Serbia are: Belgrade, Smederevo, Nish, Skoplje, Prokuplje, Novo Brdo, Prishtina, Trepcha, Prizren and Pech, and forts Kachanik, Tetovo, Janjevo, Vuchitrn, Mitrovica, Djakovica and Novi Pazar" "Scritture riferite nei congressi
12486:
54) Dimitrije Petrov from Kichevo arrived in Russia to collect funds for building church dedicated to St. Demetrius in Kichevo.He declared himself as coming from the Serbian land of Kichevo (Serbskie zemli goroda Karacheva) .The arrival is recorded as being by the: "(From) Serbian land (from) Ohrid's
12220:
15) In the year 1515 Gjuragj Kratovian was burnt.In his biography stands:...From the Serbian root and guided by Holy Spirit you have left fatherland and relatives in Kratovo and moved to the Sardakian City (Ot korene srpskago i douhom svetim vodimi ostavil jesi otachastvo i srodniki izhe v' Kratovja,
12138:
3) Around 1229/1230 Bulgarian Emperor John Asen II wrote an inscription in Trnovo:"I have took the land from Adrianopolis to Drach,Greek,Albanian and also Serbian".Since Serbian states were situated far north from the line outlined in this commemorative text,it is not unlikely that "Serbian" means an
12119:
1) Around 950,Byzantine Emperor Constantin Porphyrogenitos stated that city of "Ta Serbia" situated north-western from Thesaloniki,has it's name from its Serbian founders (around early 7th century A.D.) and in 10th century that same city is mentioned as "Srpchishte" in the manuscript by the Byzantine
12049:
like removing it; also, I had heard on my own of much unrest in the territory and of the repressions of the Serbs against all other ethnic groups. Instead the simple existence of a bulgarization process is rarely spoken of, making it all the more necessary strongly sourcing statements on the argument.
12048:
As for the second point, the Bulgarization process: the point is that the Hellenization policies are well known, and (generally) adequately sourced; the Serbian one is not so adequately sourced, but I didn't feel like removing it because it was already there when I started monitoring, and didn't feel
11160:
It might not be much fun - but I think that it is preferable that we stick to the disputed content. Now, I've copy-pasted a couple of sentences, that, IMO, need to be changed. Now, that's a specific dispute, involving the relationship between Macedonians and Bulgarians, and not about the relationship
11027:
assimilation. This is a mere 3rd degree hypothesis, which is probably valid for most mediterranean and middle eastern nations that came into contact with the Greco-Macedonian armies. I really can't see how some people are even willing to question the validity of something as ludicrous. I really don't
10766:
The question of whether the Macedonians constitute a distinct ethnic group is controversial, as many scholars believe that they are merely a subset of another people, usually the Bulgarians. Linguistically and culturally, there is not a great distinction between Macedonians and Bulgarians, but due to
10136:
Thanks for the history lesson, but I'm well aware of the background of Romania/Moldova etc. and you know full well what the point was here. People can claim whatever they want, but the simple fact is that there are a Macedonian people and they have a country. Period. Well maybe the Romanians are part
8697:
During the years between World Wars I and II, Greece followed a policy of assimilating the Macedonian minority and Hellenizing the Macedonian region in northern Greece. The government changed place names and personal names from Macedonian to Greek, ordered religious services to be performed in Greek,
8694:
So why are you changing the story now, before you wanted me to prove that a government sponsered process called Hellenization took place, and I did (Slavic names being changed to Greek names, which you verified above), then you wanted souces, which I provided (hrw.org), and now you're telling me that
7030:
I would like to propose a change in the structure of the article. I think that we should merge the "Major Populations of Macedonians by country" and "The situation today" section. This section could be after or before the history section. We will then have subsections regarding the various countries,
6901:
Can someone justify why the article implies that Slavophones in Greece are ALL ethnic Macedonians who are treated by the Greek government, people and dogs like trash? I mean how more ignorant POV do I need to chase out of this article? The Slavs that were expelled during WW2 were viewed as BULGARIANS
6322:
Not totally true. Ancestry is often established by gene-comparison, as is kinship. For example, if we find ancient Macedonian mummies with sufficient genetic material intact and compare it to modern populations, this is accepted science for comparing kinship and descent. Something similar to this was
5610:
The Department has noted with considerable apprehension increasing propaganda rumors and semi-official statements in favor of an autonomous Macedonia, emanating principally from Bulgaria, but also from Yugoslav Partisan and other sources, with the implication that Greek territory would be included in
5432:
Concerning the UN and EU... I am sure you know why they call the country FYR Macedonia. If Greece was not a powerful member of them both, no other country in the world would ever support this injustice. Actually, here is what the former United Nations special envoy to Macedonia Henry Sokalski thinks:
5394:
and the people in question themselves can recommend the use of the name "Macedonians", who are you to say otherwise? Please tell us what changes you want to make to the article and why. Otherwise you will simply be trolling the article and as for your threat, reverting without discussion will get you
3195:
Mik, a short comment. Are you even aware how ridiculous this post looks like? You obviously have no knowledge about the region. I invite you to visit Republic o Macedonia, you will be suprised when you realise that all that you learned in your school has no base in real lie. Propaganda claims can not
3161:
Greeks? You mean the state I suppose. All Balcan countries, including Greece, are afraid of possible diferent ethinisities in their borders. Greece is afraid mainly the possible existance of some people that speak slavic and do not cosnider themselfs greeks. I am 95% sure that they can't be more that
3076:
Does anyone have any information about that cencus? By whom it was done, what methods were used, and who is considered a "Macedonian language speaker" in it? And remember they sey "cansus", not "estimation". Since greek governement doesn't ask questions about minority languages in census, who had the
2910:
I personaly beleive that an estimate of 100.000-200.000 is realistic for people Macedonian (ethnic group) origin. I am not so sure how much of them speak the Macedonian language, because they were not allowed to speak it for more than 50 years (as you know, because as you said, you lived in Florina).
2844:
Look, it is simple. Greece does not recognize minorities within its borders. Also, there are inormous ammount of data all around the web, including every major human rights organization who claims there is significant Macedonian (or Slav, as you say) minority in northern Greece. I know this is truth,
2295:
16:34, 1 November 2005 (UTC) Look, Theathenae, all jokes aside now. Can't we come up with a compromise to solve all these issues? i'm sure that I can convince Bomac, FlavrSavr etc to consent to the Greek figures. Big Deal! I'll consent if you stop POV pushing and try to find a neutral compromise like
2171:
How do you know how many Macedonians (ethnic group) live in Greece when Greece denies any existance of minorities in Greece and does not include ethnicities in the census? Are you trying to hide all the reports of various human rights organizations who harshly criticise Greece? Are you trying to hide
2159:
I disputed your preposterous claim that there are 180,180 Greek citizens who identify ethnically as "Macedonians". The real number is closer to 2,955, the precise number of votes received by the Rainbow Party at the last European Parliament elections in the 13 Macedonian prefectures of Greece. As for
1779:
Of course, especially the policies on sources, such as UNESCO, which you reject for the mere reason that you disagree with what you say. Where are your sources? All you ever say is that we should check your previous contributions. You have NEVER provided a direct argument. It has always been evasion,
1143:
You are wrong in saying that the Greeks are direct descendents of the Ancient Macedonians and the people discussed in this article are not. That is a blatantly racist approach to take - it is not possible to know the ancestry of three million people. Do you deny that a substantial number of Greeks in
1062:
Considering Moldova... I can bet my life that there were also a Moldavian ethnicity before 1945th, but probably after 1945th they finally managed to show that in front of the world. Maybe they also had incredible problems with assimilation from someone else, as we did. I don't know their story, but I
903:
2) In the communism, the most basic idea was to keep the comunism because that was our only choise. It was the most powerful brain-washing system ever known. How did Tito manage to make us change the nation, when he didn't manage to make us keep the comunism? Was that brain-washing more powerful? Did
694:
Actually, I am 1/8 Greek. I am actually hiring a Greek girl here in Skopje and we have wonderful cooperation. I was in Greece just few months ago and I had great time with my potential business partner, a very rich Greek guy. When was the last time you were in Republic of Macedonia? When was the last
342:
As I already mentioned, a separate Macedonian ethnicity was mentioned in many older sources (before the 20th century), but this feeling was most often presured by assimilative actions from ourneighboors, who always outnumber us (because of just 2 million Macedonians around the world compared to 25-30
280:
These people clearly divide the Macedonian history, culture, language etc between Greece and Bulgaria. And, it is clearly of their interest the modern Macedonians to disapear. Because, if not, all the sceletons that they have in their closets will start appearing, one by one, until the world sees the
13270:
He points out that this is a POV and that Slavs invaded in the region in the 6th century AD. Well Miskin, your right, Slavs did invade in the region 1500 YEARS AGO, including Greece. Bulgarians are decendents of these invaders, aren't Bulgarians considered native to Bulgaria??? Serbs are also Slavs,
12984:
what can you people say about the claims i heard expressed on both the press and by personal acount to me by GREEKS who live in territories of the Greek Province of Macedonia who are claimed by the Invented by Tito Pseudo Nation and quasi state of Skopje which calls it self Macedonia, that they were
12962:
I'm sorry, but I'll have to revert. Your POV is absurd: if we accepted it, in Scotland (just to make an example) only those who vote for the Scottish National Party could be considered Scots, while all the other (3/4 of the population) are really English or God only knows what. And the same argument
12910:
18. But the idea is the following - there was always a local Macedonian Slav identity. Would they be Bulgarians if the Bulgarian empire lasted until now? Probably, but the most of today's Serbs would too. Would they be Serbs if the Serbian Mediaeval Empire survived until now? Probably. Together with
12902:
15. When the Bulgarians and Serbs came to Macedonia in 1912, the people of Macedonia was dominantly happy because they were liberated from the 600 years of terrible Turkish and Islamic rule "zulum", and the liberators spoke almost the same language, were Orthodox Christians! What more is there to be
12892:
14. The idea of a separate Macedonian nation was thus growing side by side with the idea of riviving Dusan's Serbian Empire (mainly in Vardar Macedonia), Greekophilia (Aegean Macedonia prevalently) or the reviving of the Bulgarian Empire (supported by Turks by forming of the Exarchate, or Russia, by
12888:
13. The propaganda of 3 powers was mighty. Please, do not speak of the Hellenization as a assimilation policy, it was a policy that most of the Aromanians, for example, suppoprted, although they spoke Roman-derived language. For instance, Sterija's main hero "Kir Janja", Aromanian in Vojvodina, kept
12864:
7. It is not useful to call Bulgarian names, as many Macedonians do, including my young relatives from Skopje. The sentences like "they are Tatars or Asians" or "they are Gypsy-like people whose language is a perverted version of Macedonian, the oldest and the most beautiful Slavic language" are not
12814:
Cigor, chronological period of the documents included in the book of Yordan Ivanov is the same like the above mentoned 78 documents - from 10 to 19 century. From mediaeval period (until 1686 if you petmit to use this questionable year) in this book are 60 documents. In your references there are less
12662:
78) Referring to the establishment of the Bulgarian Exarchate in Macedonia,Karl Oestreich noted: "A considerable part of the rural population, although it then felt to be Serbian, seized the first opportunity of obtaining Slavic priests and so declared itself to be Bulgarian ......Whoever joined the
12600:
In order to avoid persecution, the population renounced its nationality and called itself Bulgarian........during the last thirty or forty years, propaganda has been rife in which the Bulgars have encouraged the Turks to act against Serbs and Greeks. Hence, throughout Macedonia, Thrace and Dardania,
12566:
67) "Serbian tribes are by language and according to origin in possession of the greatest part of western part of European Turkey.At east they are distributed up to Nishava and Struma, Strumion of the Ancients, which goes in the Gulf of Orpheus.From southern to the northern border of Greek language,
12497:
56) In 1723 Gerard Cornelius von Driesch,secretary of the Austrian delegation heading for Constantinople, mentioned that in Pirot there are "Greeks and Serbs in those lands" (Grichen oder Raitzen dieses landes) .He also mentioned place named Grobblian located eastern of Sofia saying that the greater
11416:
There are other occasiones too where Delta uses the term Makedonitiki dialektos to refer to the Slav language spoken in the region. We may recall that both Pavlos Melas, in at least one of his letters to his wife, and Dragoumis call this language Makedoniki: indeed, Dragoumis who also claims it is a
11246:
which have assumed so. Right now what you're doing is not only POV-pushing, but an official promotion of Macedonian Slavic land claims towards Greece. Most people (including FYROM politicians) say that MacSlavs have no land-claims, they just want to be called "Macedonians" etc, etc. Well, you're the
11196:
Now, now - no need for bitterness. :) I didn't intend to berate anyone, I just wanted to point out that the discussion had become too dispersed to have any implications on the text. Honestly, I couldn't agree more on your understanding of the dynamics of a nation, however, I didn't understand what's
11045:
I'm not supporting the other points regarding Macedonian nationalism actually. I just got through saying that and you're still arguing with me as if I'm here to defend extremist views. Also, speaking in absolutes doesn't help here. Due to being neighbors there is usually SOME interaction, but that's
11041:
First off, what are you talking about regarding the Spaniards? They are largely a Mediterranean people descended from a fusion Iberians-Basques-Celts while the other groups appear to have contributed somewhat less. Genetic testing has shown their affinities and it's not with Germanic peoples for the
10857:
I never said that Greeks were not biased. Of course Greeks are biased, since after all they're concerned by this topic, but being biased or concerned doesn't make you wrong. Greeks are often hysterical, often exaggerating, but they never make up things nor spread propaganda like the Macedonians Slav
10842:
Strange that you would accuse me of being biased when you claim that the Slavs are biased and not the Greeks. Perhaps both are a bit. Here's the thing, you are talking about other matters that, due to their ambiguity, are not verifiable and not things I support at any rate due to a lack of evidence.
10677:
when the Crusaders, with disdain, called the Byzantines 'Greeks' and the Greeks called them Germans as both were claiming to represent some 'Roman' entity. That's the thing with names and usage. The Macedonians of today may not be the Macedonians of the past, but using the name in a geographic sense
10154:
Kick the Macedonian Slavs around? Just because the Macedonian Slav politicians have brainwashed their people (since they days of communism) that they have exclusive rights to anything derived from "Macedonia", it doesn't mean that everybody else objects to that needs to shut up because he's "kicking
8551:
above noted that there was no excuse to take out Hellenization because it was fully sourced. Secondly, although he left in the article that "A number of Macedonian Slavic and Turkish place names and Slavic personal surnames were renamed during this period" - that is what Hellenization is, so I don't
8313:
What I'm simply trying to point out by changing "Slavophone Greeks" to "Bulgarians", is the fact that Greeks regarded the Slavic population of the region as "Bulgarian" and that the term "Macedonian" at the time didn't have an ethnic nature. The Greek government restricted the rights of the Slavs in
7815:
Yes, Slavs were invaders in the region. But that was 1500 YEARS AGO! And what's ironic is when a Greek in Macedonia who was just yesturday deported from Turkey, Ukraine, or Russia, say that the Slavs were invaders and Greeks (like themselvs) were always in Macedonia. Macedonia has never been a Greek
7683:
Let me clarify something. I am not a Slavophone. A Slavophone is an ethnic Greek who speaks a Slavic language. I am not an ethnic Greek. I was not born in Greece. I was born and living in Canada. My parents are MACEDONIANS and were born in the Greek part of Macedonia. They speak broken Greek for the
7592:
I was switching it to 1.6 by accident, since I thought thats what the numbers added up to. I'm getting rid of your range for the reason that not all these Macedonians abroad are ethnic Macedonians (the title of this page). The Macedonian diaspora includes Albanian Macedonians, Aromanian Macedonians,
7405:
Almost. Except of course that Bomac and the rest of the crew don't realize that there's ethnically Greek or Bulgarian Macedonian apart from just Slavic. They just recognize what Big Brother says. The only reason he didn't want "Slavic" to be there, was what I explained above: To confuse the ignorant
6299:
just sounds more specific, like you're trying to make a point. Unless you're suggesting that the modern Macedonians inherited their mysterious ability to jump from tree to tree from the Ancient Macedonians via the relevant gene, it just sounds silly, and no reasonable source would ever use that word
6078:
Genes have no ethnicity. But genes from members of one ethnic group pass to members of other ethnic groups, directly or indirectly, in varied amounts. There are no such things as ancient Macedonian genes. But there are such things as genes that passed from ancient Macedonians to other peoples, which
6021:
Look Zikicam, I'm not saying you're lying; it may even be true, but what counts is 1) no unsourced statements 2)no Mac-Bulg-Greek nationalistic sources, including Krste Misirkov. I have nothing against Macedonians, quite the contrary, but you must understand this article is not only for Macedonians,
5995:
I warn the people reverting my entries not to do this if they have no clear purpose. For example, once again I had to post the entry of Bulgarization in Pirin Macedonia, because there are just 2 assimilation processes left: the Serbization and the Hellenization. What about the Bulgarization? Without
5236:
There is no Macedonian ethnic group but a slav macedonia ethnic group. I know only Macedonians who are residents of the Macedonian region. And even if I assume you are right, we have a disagreement. The poll decided to remain as Slavs. I REALLY PROMISE, I SWEAR, I WILL KEEP DOING WHAT I HAVE DONE IN
5089:
MATIA, you can not expect the history of the beggining of the 20th century to be neutral on this issue. The history was written by winners, I am sure you are aware of that. Just compare the situation the Macedonians were in during that period with the situation Greece and Bulgaria was in during that
4778:
I just want to put a note for you, Chris. If this is happening now on Knowledge (and everywhere else), now in the 21st century, and we (Macedonians) still can not release ourselves from all the propagandas against us, despite the fact that the separate Macedonian nation is not denied by any relevant
4774:
If the Arbitration Committee is neutral, it is completely OK for me for them to include. The problem is that they should not ignore the Knowledge policies and make exceptions just because of a claim from one or 2 nations against the 3rd nation. Especially when there is more than 100 years of similar
4753:
I think that on the two most contentious issues - the names "Macedonians" and "Republic of Macedonia" - we are probably going to have to get a binding ruling from the Arbitration Committee with an agreed set of enforcement actions. We will probably also need to have something like the big red box at
3342:
I forgot that nationalists don't understand other colors than black and white. Also I can see a complex of inferiority here. Anyway, I am too old and too tired to go on discussing about the 200.000 Macedonians in Greece, 400.000 Chinese in Cyprus and and 5.000.000 Klingons in Sweden. As long as some
3093:
Mik2, the simplest solution to this is Greece to allow a free census and stop the represions against the Macedonians (ethnic group). Even then, after years and years of represion, we can not expect every Macedonian to register as such. But, it is a start. A start that can make us get over this issue
3033:
Anyway, talking about the present the 180180 estimation is out of this world and should be removed. Maybe some people can listen their heart beat when listening to such estimations, but it causes a laughter to anyone that have any personal experience with Greece. It should be revomed for the good of
2687:
Anyway... you are talking about the Antient Macedonians, who lived 25 centuries ago. For you to see how long is that, just rty to count year by year. Than, try to figure our... each of those years has 365 days. Do you know how many things changed and how much mixing between the people happened since
2121:
Concerning the 51%, that is also ridiculous. The region of Macedonia does not have strict borders, neighter bordering regions from all sides, so there is no base to calculate with percents. The number of 51% shows alone that this claim was only added for giving the reader false impresion that Greece
563:
I personally know at least of 2 more examples like the ones with the modern Macedonians. And, one of them have no chance to deffend themselves, hence their internet activity which is less than 0.5%. That bothers me a lot, but I can not dedicate any time on those issues. Actually, all my time goes to
500:
Only Greeks use another name for us. Even the Bulgarians use the name "Macedonians". Also the United Nations and all its members (except Greece and Cyprus). I agree that there should be distinction bewteen the Antique Macedonians and the modern Macedonians, but our particial origin from those people
372:
The most of the Wiki Users support that politics with a simple reason... that is what they were tought to in their society. You should see the suprise of the Greek businessman who travel to Republic of Macedonia and have regular chanses to meet Macedonians, when they realise that all they know about
364:
No, not Greeks in general. During the last 15 years since Macedonian independance, many of them understood that all we want from them is to be our good neighboor. The Greek goverment was always representing us as people who want to occupy half of todays Greece. But, having close contacts, the people
303:
Sources mention Macedonians as ethnicity (separate from Greeks, Bulgarians or Serbs) even in the 15th century (I posted some links to lists of those sources few days ago). Anyway, the same people that were listed as Macedonians in the 15th century started to be formed as mixture of Slavic tribes and
276:
On the other hand Bulgaria is trying to represent the Macedonian ethnicity as separated from the Bulgarian. It is clear that we have some little origin that we share, but the both ethnicities were existing pararerly. The only difference was that Bulgaria got its independance from the Ottomans before
13280:
To call the Slavs in Macedonia natives is a blatant POV to every editor except yourself. Please try to realise that wikipedia is no place express you nationalistic insecurities and ethnic feelings. According to the non-Slavic demography, Macedonian Greeks were a majority in both Macedonian (Aegean)
13251:
I am not saying that the discrimination made Macedonians think they are Greek, I'm saying that the discrimination makes them scared to say they are Macedonian so they say they are Greek. But anyway, like JKelly and Aldux said, mentioning the results of the votes of Rainbow Party is not nessecary or
13214:
Most people here are afraid to express themselves openly, to say that they are Macedonian. This has been particularly true since Christos Sideropoulos was convicted in court just for saying "I feel Macedonian." And lots of people are afraid to travel across the border to visit their relatives
13038:
OK, it's true. The division is political. But I must say that for instance in Pirot, where part of my family comes from, people feel a bit of Bulgarian spirit, after the Vuk Karadzic's reforms that neglected the Serbian Eastern (Prizren-Timok) dialects. Therefore, I sometimes feel Serbian, but also
12906:
17. The Communist Party declared what they declared. It only brought back to light the old idea of "regional identity being stronger that the Serbianity (ol Bulgarity)" - why learning the Serbian cases, and trying to sound "fancy" and "aristocratic"? When you can speak your own proper dialect which
12889:
saying "We Greeks..." or "The old Greek wisdom says...", while speaking the broken Macedonian dialect from Krusevo, Bitola, Voden or who knows where...! Many Macedonians wilfully accepted the Hellenism. The Miladinovs were Grekomans first, before they converted to the promoters of Slavic localisms!
12884:
12. The Macedonians forgot the name Serbs, because it was forbidden to use, because of the Serb resistance. Once again, the Macedonians fell under the common name Risjani (Christians), Rajani (Villeins), or tribal names (Brsjaci etc.). Some of them called themselves Macedonians, in the sense of the
12872:
9. Later on, the Serbs came and gave the Macedonians feel of dignity. Since the Macedonian Slavs were a part of Serbian army, they were proud of their new state and position in it, and started to call themselves Serbs amongst each other. It is no wonder, because we in Yugoslavia were satisfied with
12767:
I suggest WIKIPEDIA present a peoples history and views the way those people themselves would like to be seen and have their views expressed....obviously there will be conflicting information on the other pages because every nation or people has its own take on things.....leave it up the reader to
12763:
JSimin,If Macedonians are Bulgarians who does the political party OMO-ILINDEN represent?You say there is little evidence of a "nonbulgarian belonging of Macedonian Slavs in the past." Well in 1689 there was a rebellion in Northern Macedonia by a man who we today only know as "Karpos"...the Austrian
12740:
O, there are very little evidences about nonbulgarian belonging of Macedonian Slavs in the past. Less than 80. I have two considerations: 1. They do not prove that the Macedonian Slavs were Macedonian like ethnic group. They only put a guestion on their Bulgarian past. 2. Only in the book of Yordan
12698:
Isnt this true for most of the Balkans?Thats different ethnicities have migrated over a variety of territories?Isnt it true for most of Europe for that matter?For the world even.What is the point in singling out Macedonia to show that a variety of people have crossed its borders in the past?I think
12685:
I have a question.....at the bottom of the article you have the section "SITUATION TODAY".....it clearly states that Bulgaria recognizes the Macedonians as a seperate ethnic group...as do the Serbian and Albanian governments....my question is why do you choose to refer to us as Bulgarians or why do
12562:
66) Edmund Spencer's comment about ethnicity of peoples in the region of Macedonia, visited by him in the mid-19th century: "The inhabitants are for the most part composed of Rayahs, a mixed race of Greeks, Bulgarians and Serbians, who, it cannot be doubted, would join to the man their brethren in
11214:
Surely the Macedonians and Bulgarians can be considered offshoots of an earlier Slavonic group that is more closely related than say the aforementioned Serbs. I do agree that it would be incorrect usage to say Macedonians are an offshoot of the Bulgarians as modern populations as they exist tend to
10967:
who are Muslim Han Chinese and thus not considered real Hans) or be based upon geographic origin (Sephardic vs. Ashkenazi Jews) etc. And the claims of Greekness can't really be given 100% credence simply due to the Macedonian language being Slavic, but doesn't rule out cultural assimilation as took
10672:
Mishkin, for the sake of exact usage, yes you are correct it was a Greek, but since most of the original 'Greeks' who were part of the initial invasion force were Macedonians, I was using it in that context, but indeed I apologize if there was some misunderstanding as that was not my intent. Yes, I
10593:
by ludicrous theories on assimilations, which will never be proved nor disproved anyway. In my opinion there's no single Mediterranean nation that hasn't assimilated with Greeks at some point in its history, that wouldn't give Greeks the right to claim everybody's history or heritage, nor the other
10180:
It's the local name of the former province that is now a country. Period. Notice that this argument is not being waged in any reference books? It's nationalism pure and simple. They are noted as Macedonian Slavs at least 3 times. Just how much do they need to be set apart here? And where is it that
9822:
were often contestants in Roman chariot races in various arenas as late as the 3rd or 4th century AD, and if that's correct there was at least a regional Macedonian identity at that time. That book by the way was originally written in Greek in 1979 or so and the essays in it were under the auspices
8903:
Miskin, if you are certain that today's Macedonians are not descendents of the ancient Macedonians, you will not be bothered with that - is it written there or not. And please, stop seeing the things black and white and stop thinking that everyone (except you) spreads propaganda here, 'caus you too
8732:
that Greeks use it the way I just described. You don't even want to think about it, but FYROM will be forced to think about it after their candidature in EU and NATO is vetoed. And honestly, find someone else to speak about ancient Macedonia, because with me you're out of your league. The debate on
8707:
I think the reason of our dispute is you poor knowledge of the situation. As you said you've lived all your life in Canada, so I don't see how can you draw conclusions on how Greek peoples view each other. The fact that more than one ethnic groups inhabit Macedonia doesn't mean they they all use it
8515:
changes in names did take place, nobody denies that, it's not a secret. To claim (as User:Macedonia did) that Greeks deny it, is a straight-forward lie. However this name-change did not fall under some official assimilation program that was known as "Hellenization" like the article says, part of it
8195:
article already, Its been in the Greek Macedonia article for months now and was approved by administrators and users with reliable sourced references. why are you making it sound like a POV? why are you always deleting it from the Macedonian ethnic group article? Do it again and ill report you for
7292:
I see no reason why "Slavic" should not be there if it is accurate and assists in disabmiguation. However, if the fact that they are Slavs is already well-explained somewhere else, then it may be unnecessary to mention it again in the notice. Remember, it is a disambiguation notice - its purpose is
6276:
I don't know why it suddenly came to your attention now, but saying that "it is likely that their ancestry includes elements of autochthonic groups such as the etc." was saying the exact same thing all along. Also unreferenced. Physical descent (ancestry) is reckoned by genes, physical kinship with
5908:
number of ethnic Macedonians in Bulgaria at this moment, is 5.071. This figure should remain in the infobox, with the see below note. It would be explained that official number of Macedonians changed dramatically in the course of the 20th century, and several other topics related to the Macedonians
5419:
As I said before your refering those sides that you like. You have now remembered about United Nations and European Union! When the Greeks were telling you about what name does UN and EU recognize your country, you were rejecting the name FYR Macedonia. Now you remembered UN and EU to say that you
4048:
Matia, the term "Macedonian Slavs" that is used by the Macedonians (ethnic group) reffers to the Slavic tribes that settled Macedonia and that latter mixed with the other people living in the area, which finaly resulted in a separate Macedonian nation. So, when this term is used, it is about people
3663:
All censuses made in that time include the Macedonians as part of Bulgarians, Serbs or Greeks. If you take all sources together, it seems like one person can be Greek, Serb and Bulgarian in the same time. All in favor of satisfying some nationalistic claims from those countries towards the teritory
3216:
Why don't you stop insulting people? It's common knowledge that Greece and every other continental European country has ethnic minorities. Just because you don't believe or don't want to believe or believe but don't want other people to believe that there are ethnic minrities in Greece that doesn't
2967:
Some people indeed used to describe the slavs of Macedonia as different from Bulgarians (I don't know their reasons for that, maybe slightly different language, mayby different lovation, maybe politics). But since only a very few slavs of macedonia identified themselfs as different from Bulgarians,
2892:
you say "But, it is a fact that the national feeling can not just be lost like that.". It's questionable if a "macedonian national feeling" ever existed between slavs of Makedonia, even in FYROM teritories. Almost all of them would identify themselfs as Bulgarians or Greeks 100 years ago. No matter
2808:
Apart from the above, the 180,180 as an estimation of Slavic speakers in Greece is totaly imaginary in my opinion. What "1986 census" is that? Who did it? I guess they might just have sumed up the total population of vilages that used to have slavic speakers 50 years ago. Anyway, this number seems
1929:
I completely agree with you, guys. We should identify all the problems and write the article in a NPOV way. An article like this can not be assimilative and saying that the modern Macedonians are product of Tito's imagination, when there are great number of sources for separate Macedonian ethnicity
1222:
The Macedonians (Greeks living in Macedonia) do not recognise themelves nationally as Macedonians, because "Macedonian" ceased to be a national identity in the same way that "Athenian" or "Spartan" ceased to be a national identity when Greece was unified under a Macedonian king. The British example
1138:
There is no dispute that the modern "Macedonians" have been in the area for over a thousand years, and that they feel that they are ethnic "Macedonians". However the fact is that they are NOT the direct descendants of the ancient Macedonian people, who were undeniably Greek. If the Greek people had
1044:
overnight and pretty much at the some point - 1944-1945. According to the latest census only 2% of the population of Moldova declared itself as Romanian despite the fact that there were almost no differences between the dialects of Moldova and Romania (which existed between formal Bulgarian and the
942:
6) Why no one gives attention to the poor (or non-existant) Human rights of the minorities in Greece or Bulgaria? Did you mayeb read what the European Court of Human rights thinks of what they do? And that is now, in the 21st century. Can you imagine what they were doing some 50-100 years ago, when
368:
Anyway, the general position of an average Greek is clearly against us. Greece will never recognize their mistake, because all the lies and assimilation will be easily seen. So, they would use all the sources to deny the modern Macedonians, despite the fact that many of us acnowledge that we do not
307:
I would like to clearly note that any historian would say that tyhe modern nations were formed not sooner than the 15th century or even latter. Anyway, the history is the most sensitive topic, so it can not be described briefly. It is not my intention to give you the "Macedonian" part of the story,
13028:
that were part of Bulgaria from 1878-1919. The national division between the Serbs and Bulgarians was political. In the territories that were permanently given to the Serb state, there was no (or very little) Bulgarian self-consciousness, as well as the territories which entered permanently in the
12996:
Nevertheless these are real data of Greek citizens, eligible to vote, who strongly feel macedonian slavs. I have rephrased to remove any possible trace of POV. I trust readers to judge and I trust you to either respect this presentation of facts or insist if you believe that this sentence distorts
12876:
10. When Serbian Empire fell, Macedonians once again formed their half-independent kingdom, under the rule of Prince Marko (King Marko) Mrnjavcevic, of Serbian dynasty from Herzegovina. The Serbian heroes became Macedonian heroes too, with Krale Marko (Prince Marko) the greatest hero of all. I can
12868:
8. The "fact" that Samuil was a Bulgarian king I heard first from the Lonely Planet Guide last summer when I was in Bulgaria! The Bulgarians, according to my history book (Serbian), conquered Macedonia, but after the fall of the eastern part, Macedonian Slavs used the opportunity to split from the
12856:
4. The Slavs came and conquered the vast area of Byzantine Empire and today's Macedonia and Greece, from Skopje to Athens. They could not call themselves Macedonians, because their area was much bigger than just Macedonia (Slavic territories included Dardania, Epiros, Thessalia, Thrace etc.). They
12830:
OK, JSimin, I totally support your attitude towards the Bulgarians in Serbia and Bosnia, it was quite normal that the Bulgarians were moving to Serbia and vice versa during the Turkish rule. Personally, I know that there are many Serbs in Samokov region, proving that there are many people with the
12809:
FInally id like to say that today BULGARIA DOES RECOGNIZE US AS A SEPERATE ETHNIC GROUP....it doesnt matter what you think....the Bulgarian government has spoken for all 10 million of you....and even if they deny rights to the people in OMO....they will never be able to deny those people living in
12320:
29) Archbishop Bianki of Bar divided Serbia into upper and lower.In the area of Upper, he sorted Prokuplje, Novo Brdo, Trepcha, Janjevo, Skopska Crna Gora, Skoplje and Kratovo,places where "all Catholics are of Serbian speech".In Lower Serbia's domain Prizren, Guri and Shegec were included by him.
12134:
Constantin Porfyrogenitus "De Administrando Imperio" Erdeljanovich.J. "O naseljavanju Slovena u Maloj Aziji i Siriji od VII do X veka" Glasnik geografskog drushtva vol. VI 1921 pp.189 Lequen,M. "Oriens Christianus" I, 1740, pp.659-660 Micotky,J."Otiorum Chroate", Vol. I ,Budapest, 1806, pp.89-112
12028:
OK, it's the end of the page now :) OK, no unsorced information. But why did you revert my SURNAME ENDINGS CHANGES? It's the complete history of everyone's families - I call everyone from Macedonia to cover up the story. My grandfather changed his surname 4 times in his life - twice to Serbian and
11626:
May everybody know when the peasants of my native village of Radibus, Krivorechka Palanka, hired me as a teacher in our village school as well as at Rankovce and Krivi Kamen, for 1800 groschen a year. I was born of my father, priest Dimitrija, and mother Varskija as the seventh of twelve children,
11426:
Check the link you posted a little bit better. It doesn't mention a Macedonian ethnicity, it exclusively mentions "Greeks and Bulgarians" of Macedonia. It also refers to the so-called "Macedonistiki" as a Greco-Slavic language spoken by the ethnic Bulgarians of Macedonia. If you really want to use
11022:
was originally defined by the etho-linguistic elements of peoples or peninsulas. MacSlavs currently possess 40% of the Macedonian region, none of which includes the ancient Kingdom of Macedon, hence the game of a peninsula is lost. There are not cultural links between them and the Macedonians (who
10996:
and settled in Spain. How the Spaniards have never claimed to be Visigoths nor Germans, hence that makes a huge difference on the nature of their assumptions. This is a mere cultural subject, which at an extremist level could take nationalistic overtones, but it would never have the same political
10623:
who claim Macedonian ancestry in fact do not show any genetic markers to corroborate, although the Kalash did show small markers that could either mean they are part Macedonian or have some other general European ancestry that remains unclear. Similarly, genetic tests with Macedonians cluster them
10372:
Lol. I spent like two minutes responding to you quoting from other articles because frankly you really couldn't face the issue head-on and had to resort to tangential arguments about exact analogies. Hey think what you like sport, but telling me what you just read off of other articles without an
10335:
Oh come on. I meant most Romanians are probably not of Roman origin. It was not meant as an absolute. Surely you knew that I was not saying there was NO Roman settlement as I just got through saying that it could MEAN anyone from the Roman Empire. You're really going off on a tangent there AFTER I
10305:
here) stock, and I would like you to find one reputable historian who even believes this. If a person has no idea what they're talking about when they make comparisons, why do they even bother to make comparisons. This is not even an issue of ethnic claims, these are accepted historical facts, and
9645:
Hmm, this is complicated and no single answer will suffice it seems. I only supported the idea of Macedonian people as I wanted the same format to be applied so that all of the ethnic groups would be referred in the same manner. Ultimately though, perhaps Macedonian Slavic people would work better
8720:
is the largest province of the state. The term "Macedonian" is used as a self-descriptive term by both "Greek Macedonians" and by other Greeks. That's the reason that a new "Macedonian nation" can't be recognised, because the name is already in use. If the Macedonian Slavs had wanted to officially
8669:
Obviously the name Atanasoski is made up, I said already I used it from the Serbanization part of the article and that I wanted to show an example of a typical Macedonian sounding name changed to a typical Greek sounding name, just like in the Serbanization part. I don't see how you can have fault
8579:
First of all, what do you mean when you say "hopefully he learned his lesson"? Last time I checked you were also blocked as much as I did, so did all your compatriots who were edit-warring with me on other articles. Nobody favoured you over me nor the other way around, and if that's what you think
7869:
for the second time, which explains why there's are hardly any Slavophones/Bulgarians left. Anyway the rest of you edit causes me nothing but pity. Although I'm relatively familiar with your country's social situation, it always amazes me to find out how brainwashed some people are. No comments, I
7698:
in 1922, do you know of anything that can match this number? Yet you don't see Greek people bitching all over the internet about it. Maybe it's time to forget about the past and think of the present. There's almost no Slavophone minority left in Greek Macedonia as there's no Greek minority left in
7615:
Macedonian is the official language of the Republic of Macedonia, formerly the Yugoslavian Socialist Republic of Macedonia; it has a total of 2 million speakers including 1.4 million in Macedonia and about 200,000 in Greece. There are also speakers in Yugoslavia ( Republic of Serbia), Albania, and
6784:
Basically, I've made some edits I've announced some week ago, and nobody seem to object them. I've changed the ethnic Macedonian population in other countries from 10,000 to Unknown, since nobody gave reasons, nor cited sources for that estimate. The previous number of 100,000 Macedonians was also
6040:
Miskin brought this article back to my attention. My latest edits are based on two considerations: 1) the presence of Thracian, Illyrian, ancient Macedonian genes etc. in any degree in modern Macedonians cannot yet be proven, though it is very likely. 2) Many historians do believe that the ancient
5875:
article. I guess if nobody disputes them there, nobody would dispute their relevance here, but I'll leave them in the discussion page, if they are any complaints about their relevance. Also, I would be grateful if someone provides a link to ethnic Macedonian populations in other countries (eg. UK,
5553:
Ilegal... that is how much you know about the region. It is a fact that the Albanians lived in the region of Macedonia since ever. But, if you live in Greece, it is understandable why you don't know this fact. Greece actually never acnowledged any other nation... they actually beleive they are the
5126:
I am the "vandalist" of this article. I want to remind you that before me there was anorther vandalism, which changed the article from Macedonian Slavs into Macedonian ethnic group. The reason i "vandalized" was a reaction of your vandalism. You cannot call for macedonian ethnicity while there are
4372:
is rejecting the idea of mediation on the grounds of a lie. It is true that Macedonians are widely known as Skopyani in Greece, but officially, they are known as Macedonian Slavs. All Greek official documents call them Macedonian Slavs. Skopyani is just a way of referring to them without using the
4330:
The problem is that very few of the administrators know the basics of the dispute. It is clear dispute: "present identity" versus "far history and teritory nowdays belonding to Greece which will obviously stay Greek forever". Also, the big part of the dispute is based on unjustified fear. And yes,
4268:
Third, and I'm sorry to have to say this, it was clear that many editors on both sides of the dispute - including yourself - were not interested in following the NPOV policy. The comments made in the poll and the continuing dispute since then have made that very clear. I concluded, and I'm sure Ed
4122:
Kollias didn't explain anything. Stop making personal attacks, it wasn't a move in one night, it had been debated on this talk page for weeks (check if you like). It's you own fault if you couldn't be bothered to participate. Why don't you tell me what you would change about the article and why? I
4028:
term - I can't. Would you like to see editors from RoM to propose a wiki-name that won't break the disambiguation? Even Arvanites and Albanians self-identified as Macedonians around 1600, of course they weren't Mac.Slavs or Mac.Greeks. I would love to see those editors to find a name, at least for
3838:
I was hoping that we would make progress, and start solving the other disputes, step by step, according to their complexity. Ancient history is probably the worst place to start. We should solve the more simple disputes, like the populations of ethnic Macedonians in various countries. These can be
3501:
believe that they are merely a subset of another people, usually the Bulgarians. They call themselves Macedonians but this term is vehemently opposed by Greeks when used to describe the Slav majority of Republic of Macedonia or a Slavic minority in northern Greece. Greece argues that this usage is
2691:
I agree that the article should say that the biggest part of our origin is Slavic (like it always said), but a part of that origin is from several other ethnicities (including the Antique Macedonians) that lived here before the Slavic arived. Same as the Bulgars are a part of the Bulgarian now, no
1264:
In the past there was no such nation as "Germany". It consisted of literally hundreds of states, some kingdoms, some duchies, some simply a city. Over the centuries these states fought against each other, allied with each other, and even absorbed each other. Each state was a proper country, and so
1197:
I also would like to remind you that Greece got its teritories called "Macedonia" just some 20-30 years ago. Before that, the region was called "Northern Greece". This is not my claim. This is a fact that is supported by relevant European historians. Please read what the German historian Christian
995:
I appologise for my arogancy, but I would really want any of you to be a part of this nation to feel how is to constantly be denied and assimilated and everything that you ever had to be grabbed by your neighboors, who actually supposed to be your best friends. It is very easy to "negotiate" about
334:
Since the beggining of the 20th century, the majority of the sources around the world. There are many sources that promote anti-Macedonian propaganda, with a simple reason: Macedonia did not get their independance until 1991st, and before that (from 1945th) it was a part of strict regime where any
272:
Also, Greece is trying to get exclusive rights over the name "Macedonia", pushing us in a sencless dispute. And, just for reminder, just some 30 years ago the term "Macedonia" was completely and strictly forbiten in Greece. General Metaxas was even sending people to jail because of using it. Also,
12582:
69) A 1854 request of the inhabitants of village Selce near Debar to HRM King Alexander Karadjordjevich. 22 Oktovra Arsenije Janovich,Gavril Janovich,Damjan Markovich, Vasil Milich, Tane Ninovich, Trifun Grujovich, Stanisha Nikolich, Cvetko Damjanovich, Despot Potnikovich, Gligorije Naumovich i
12054:
As regards Stefan Dusan, I believe his full title was "Tsar and autocrat of Serbs, Romans (Greeks), Bulgarians and Albanians", when brief only "Emperor of Serbs and Romans". So, you see, he did not forget the Bulgarians. The point is that among scholarship there is a general consensus that in the
10962:
page in both cases this universal human trait of claiming what is perceived as nationalist mythology reared its head. One guy claiming that the Spaniards were predominantly a Germanic people, derived from Visigoths and Vandals, and others saying that the Sinhalese were mainly Aryans, a linguistic
9859:
OK, my beef was more about the extra treatment of ancient Macedonians, who, IMHO, should deserve a similar treatment as the Thracians. Nobody seemed to matter about the latter. I have adressed this problem earlier. I'll restore the original formulation by Kanchov and Weigand, until we discover to
8917:
There are many things that would normally not bother me. For example I don't really expect anyone of basic education to link FYROM with "Macedonia", and I don't think that this article gets many visitors in the first place. The reason I'm still editing, is because I'm unable to just sit and watch
8824:
Miskin, I am tired of arguing back to your senseless unsupported arguments. I have found that you are very sensitive about the family name although it makes no difference if it was made up or not. Now, isnt it true that Slavic names were changed to Greek names. yes. Isn't true that Lerin was that
8772:
to the time of the argument. There's not a reference to a Macedonian people, only to a Bulgarian one. If you want to find out why, then see "Macedonian" (disambiguation page). I have much more sources which demostrate the demography of the era, not a single one mentions "Macedonians" as an ethnic
8614:
Because it contains seriously biased POV. The name "Atanopoulos" doesn't even exist, it was invented by the author of this article, and as for Lerin becoming Florina, you need to show evidence that it was changed as such. The link that you provided (hrw.org) verifies that changes in toponyms took
8594:
I had a look on your personal page and I find it rather disturbed. I don't really expect to change on your opinion, so eventually I'm gonna have to seek mediation. I saw your personal page and it's rather disturbed, it looks like the rants of a fanatic. Although I have explained my few edits many
7820:
because people aren't that stupid and they would already know it was Greek, and strict measures would be placed down on the RoM. But its not Greek, and thats why some 150 nations around the world have recognized the RoM as "Macedonia" including the United States, Russia, and China. Thats why last
7748:
Thirdly, you have to be blind not notice the large number of Macedonians in Florina, Edessa, Kastoria, Kozani, and so on. I mean, I know in the past that Macedonians were the majority and things have changed now, but how can you say there are absolutny no Macedonians left in Greece today? I visit
7310:
I insist to be like in all other similar articles. And, as I said, some users claim that in this way someone will "get confused" with other Macedonians (in a regional sense). Here, in this paragraph ("modern macedonians") there is nothing "confusing", plus the disambiguation link stays one way or
6587:
Look, no one here appears to be a geneticist. In absence of references, we can only treat the ancestry claims as claims. Not unlikely claims, considering that other studies usually find great genetc (or whatever) variation, and indications of older substratums, or whatever. In the case of ancient
6054:
The whole notion of "Greek genes", "Slavic genes", "Ancient Macedonian genes", etc. is very problematic. There has been linguistic, cultural, and genetic mixing in this area for a long time, and linguistic, cultural, and genetic identity -- and political power -- rarely align neatly. This is as
5336:
Dear Macedonian (your ancestors became macedonians the last 100 years!!!) and Rex the Albanian. The greeks don't need your permission to be called Macedonians because they were Macedonians for thousand years, while your ancestors were in Central Asia.When Alexander the Great Greek Macedonian, did
5111:
a) where are the personal attacks? Is criticising articles a personal attack? b) the NPA parole in sot in force yet, and c) why aren't you helping us reach a compromise? We are discussing here trying to solve this dispute and you are not co-operating. No wonder you rejected the idea of mediation.
5016:
There are some OK guys from the other side that, despite their nationalistic aproach, realise that the situation is quite different than they tought so before. But the one that you mentioned... in my oppinion he should be banned here for life. Maybe it would be safest for the whole world if he is
3893:
Approval voting is encouraged for page moves requested on this page. Requested moves may be implemented if there is a Knowledge community consensus (60% or more) supporting the moving of an article after five (5) days under discussion on the talk page of the article to be moved, or earlier at the
2546:
Oh really? How would YOU (anonimous) feel if the name of your language has some prefixes or suffixes in it? On the other hand, there are many variants of the Greek language (for example), but nobody adds some stupid unnecessary addings. Other, say the language as his speakers want to - Macedonian
2471:
Macedonian language, we are still calling it "Macedonian language" (not South-West Bulgarian or something), with added information for disambiguation. The simple fact is that there are two languages that are called "Macedonian". Knowledge pracitice in these cases is disambiguation, either by more
1283:
It IS EXTEMELY important!! To claim that the ancient Macedonians were not Greek is a grave insult to all Greek peoples. If you don't find it very important maybe YOU should not argue on this page. The region described as "Macedonia" has of course varied widely throughout history, but the question
972:
Is it more important what some guy who never visited Macedonia wrote, than we, as a living proof? We are here, waving, screaming, jumping... how come you can not see us? Are we so small and meaningless? Are we and the sources that support us less worthed than a pro-Bulgarian page hosted on a free
962:
The anti-Macedonian propaganda is lasting for centuries. And it still does. Of course there are some sources supporting those ideas, because the anti-Macedonian propaganda is lead by 2 much more powerful countries than Macedonia is (Bulgaria and Greece, the last was the biggest pet of the Western
922:
4) If just some 65 years ago we were something else, how come we developed in so self-aware nation? We even risk getting blocked by Greece on our road to EU and NATO. If we were something else than "Macedonians", why would we risk all our future to deffend something that is not ours? Macedonia is
182:
describing the characteristics of "people who have Macedonian ethnicity" - which includes their history, customs, language, geographical distribution, etc. For example, how many of them live in the various countries of the world? Or how many "speakers of the 'Macedonian language'" live in various
13328:
I'm not removing, I'm only restoring it. Disambiguation serves to identify unrelated things, nothing's wrong with the use of 'unrelated' except the paranoia of the Vardar slavic editors. Every single disambig of "Macedonian" is unrelated in every context outside the borders of FYROM. Many things
13019:
Hi, JSimin I didn’t realize that you answered until now. Talk pages related to Macedonia tends to expand at malign cancer speed, so it’s hard to keep track. Regarding the references what I tried to say is there is very little (close to none) original sources 14-18 century where somebody is being
12860:
5. When the Greeks re-conquered their previous terriories, they assimilated the Slavs by culture. The Slavs were prevalent only in today's all of Macedonia (Aegean, Vardar and Pirin). 6. At the same time, Bulgarians formed the Empire that covered the area of Slavic settlements all over Balkans,
12839:
There were Bulgarians in Macedonia too, of course, but I claim that they were minority there, not majority. OK, they were assimilated after Balkan Wars, first Serbianized, then Macedonized. But is it not true that the Serbs in Kjustendil, Vidin (was predominantly Serbian until 19th cenutry, even
12791:
As for Karposh we know something for him which is not in accordance with narrowly mаcedonistic interpretаtion: The hronists Rashid and Defterdar inform that ab initial he was a leader of "hajduts" in Dospat planina, in Rhodpi mauntain - i.e. in the border of geographical regions of Macedonia amd
12655:
77) Remark of Dr. Karl Oestreich about Skoplje: "The city's population consist of all possible elements-some of whom have come out in favor of the Bulgarian Exarchate and call themselves 'Bulgars'-and Albanians or Mohammedanized Serbs. Although it is situated south of Sar-planina, Skoplje is the
12542:
62) Correspondence by the Czech philologist Dobrovski to a Slovenian colleague B. Kopitar between 1809-1810 contains this opinion by Dobrovski: "I have little regard for geographical names.Dubrovnikers, Macedonians, Bosnians are nevertheless Serbs" : "Die geographischen Benennungen kummern mich
11555:
I am very grateful for the quotation of Bertrandonde la Brocuiere the above. I spent some time to verify this sourse, but it was useful for me, because I found one more confirmation for my personal oppinion for Macedonistic (non Macedonian, because I am Macedonian too) theory. So, under the term
11354:
Sincerely, if there really was a "Macedonian nation" in the early 20th century, would we really be in need of such references (Delta's novel etc) in order to be aware of it? It's not that we're talking about a lost trible from 500 BC where scholars would point out "Herodotus mentions blah, blah,
10045:
or current Rome, not just the empire, and that some may say that only the descendants of the citizens of ancient Rome should be called "Romanians". Well, guess what: Romanians didn't decide to suddenly call themselves Romanians. The Romanized inhabitants of the Balkans lost their specific ethnic
9995:
is a completely different thing), so any nation that relates to the Romans, doesn't mean that it claims Italian ethnicity. The case of the "Romanians" was a bad example. As Decius said, the term "Roman" lost its ethnic identification very early in history, probably before Dacians were Latinized.
9990:
are via the concept of the "peninsula". If could use the same criterion for the Greeks to claim heritage from Macedon, then we'd have to change FYROM's name to Vardar right away. Things are complicated because we're using the loose criterion of "Greekness" in order to define the ethnicity of the
9971:
Well, yes I was feeling out possible compromises rather than just taking a side for the sake of taking a side. Reasons are important here. Why can't they just be called Macedonians especially since that's what every other reference book does? Until Rex pointed it out, I hadn't thought of it even
9766:
It was a little more than "a wave" of Hellenization, I think most historians would agree. More like a tsunami. By the 5th Century AD, the consensus (=most historians, or the more authoritative historians) is (as far as I've determined; others have stated this also) that the Macedonians were long
8754:
posted earlier, and tell me honestly, do you really regard this as neutral and credible? Even if we assume that it's 100% credible, it doesn't prove what you're trying to push in the article. In the fomer paper, we only see references of a region called "Macedonia", and the people who live there
8661:
This is a 100% Greek POV. It is a fact though, that today Greeks, Vlachs, Albanians, and other ethnic groups might call themselves "Macedonians" only because they inhabit the region that is called Macedonia, I don't have a problem with that. But you claiming that Macedonia and its inhabitats was
8656:
Miskin, you arguments are getting out of controll. I've seen that sentence from Britannica a million times already, and I agree with it 100% for the fact that Macedonia has been traditionally a Greek land for some 90 years now, and yes, the country did have to adopt a temporary title "The Former
8556:
article, the former name of the town was Macedonian: "Lerin". So there was no excuss to take that out either. The family name that I provided was the same name example used above in the Serbanization part. I just showed how an average Macedonian sounding name that was changed to a Greek sounding
7575:
is always changing the total population to 1.6 million, when the list in the article adds upto 1,701,512 (you can even add it yourself). The only concern with 1,701,512 is that it does not include any Macedonians in Greece. Greece is one of the few countries besides th RoM that has a significant
7233:
Don't say "regards", you so blatantly copied that from me. Anyway as I demonstrated above, Britannica writes "Slavic Macedonians", politicians from FYROM have occasionally referred to their nation as "Slavic", and at the end of the day it is "Slavic". I don't buy the myth of FYROM being the only
3165:
Anyway, you people from former "communist" democracies are looking for an identity. It's totaly understood why you are so eager to descover suffering minorities in Greece. I hope it will fade away with the years, for your sake too. Untill then you should be more carefull when reafrering to those
2963:
Have in mind that a nation is not something like the race or the colour of your skin, that exists de facto. Nation is a politic and social term. A nation exists only and only if some people believe they belong to it (if and only if there is a national consiousness). When it comes to the slavs of
2959:
To clear some thinks: The slavs of Greek Makedonia traditionaly use the word "Makedonski" to describe themselfs and their language. But they don't use the word like you in FYROM use it. "Makedonski" for the vast majority of them means "someone living in Macedonia" or "the language used by us the
2914:
The question of the Macedonians identify as Bulgarians some 100 years ago is very questionable. I tried to explain it several times before. Maybe you can look through my posts, because it is quite boring to keep repeating the same things. Anyway, I hope you are aware that a completely self-aware
2695:
Also, it is unacceptable you to erase the part saying that the some historians connects us closer to the Antique Macedonians. To be honest, I really do not care are they right or not (as I said before, I am not very happy that there is a possibility a part of my origin to be of a senceless crazy
2683:
Firstable, you can not add a paragraph denying the relation between the 2, because only a fool can claim that there is no relation at all. It is about time you and all your fellow nationalist to wake up from your dream and realise that not only Greece can be connected to the Antient Macedonians.
1863:
step by step, starting with the top of the article. That would be the populations of Macedonians in various countries? After we work out a specific version that would be in accordance with the NPOV policy, we would go and try to solve the other disputes. The logic behind this is that there is no
1118:
Another, final question: If Macedonians were Bulgarians, would they fight the Bulgarian occupation on the side of the partizans and Tito (a Croatian)? Do you claim that so many people that joined the partizans decided to join their enemy and kill their brother? Tito was not on power in Macedonia
13007:
Although many think that Macedonians in Greece only vote for the Rainbow Party, you are wrong. A vast mjority of Macedonians in Greece tend to vote for the leading Political parties like Nia Demokratia and PASOK, for the reason that these parties have offered many more benefits in financial and
12852:
3. Therefore, Alexander the Great was Greek (of very similar, Ancient Macedonian origin), like Gogol' was Russian (of Ukrainian origin), or my grandfather a Bulgarian etc... Assimilated by the close and admired advanced culture. It is not useful for us to claim that Ancient Macedonians were not
12619:
72) In 1886 Russian publicist I.S. Jastrebov published his book "Obichai i pesni tureckih serbov v Prizren,Ipek,Morava,i Dibra" ("Customs and songs of the Turkish Serbs in Prizren,Pech,Morava and Debar) in which the following reference to the important Serb custom of "Slava" is found: "Slava is
11940:
Third - How can you claim that Macedonians were Bulgarians before the 20-th century, when Greece created the "Abecedar", a pure-Macedonian book (I can tell you that on the picture in the article there are Macedonian sentences) which was confiscated by Bulgaria and Serbia caus' of their fear for
10876:
The list can go on, but I think the final point is sufficient. The state of FYROM since the days of communism has been promoting national myths, propaganda and hatred against the Greek nation. It's typical for a poor and undevelopped country to search and find someone else who's responsible for
10248:
Yeah, I've heard that theory that the Macedonians were not Greek, however most indications are that the Slavs had not arrived in the Balkans by that time period, so even if they weren't say a type of Greeks, they most likely weren't Slavs either. I have trouble with people 'claiming' historical
10070:). Your example is weak. Bulgarians and Greeks, remember, claim these people only began calling themselves Macedonians in the past hundred years or less; if that's true, ain't no way that "it is the same situation" as the Romanian situation; by the way, more Romanians are interested in claiming 8293:
That's honestly the least that concerns me. The article hides tiny wheeny detail, that literally all sources at the time refer to the Slavic population of Macedonia as "Bulgarians". The second Balkan war was instigated by Bulgaria's attack on Greece and Serbia, in order to expand its Macedonian
8068:
This is something I should have done a long time ago. All my efforts of talking sense into the MacSlav editors failed, for the simple reason that I was dealing with extremists who had no desire of contributing seriously. In that respect, I'm forced to proceed with the editing of this article by
7079:
Personally I'm against. While you're absolutely right that we're not here to determinate the truth, a problem which should be left to scholars, I believe we have a sort of duty to our readers and coeditors to at least try not to furnish misleading information and try to represent the mainstream
4694:
Now, some time ago, I've proposed a step-by-step method, for this matter. I get a feeling that the naming dispute isn't solved? Fine, let's work it out, because that's by far the most important an by far the most banal dispute. Now I believe that we have a specific Knowledge policy dealing this
1348:
prosperity. But if it is viewed from the aspect of its political forms, one comes to the conclusion that all the misfortunes of the barbarian administration have been assembled here in order to paralyze one of the most beautiful regions of the world in all its richness and variety of products".
1347:
At the end, here is what the French Consul in Salonica (end of 18th century) Felix de Beaujour tought of Macedonia: "If one regards Macedonia from the point of view of its natural advantages, one comes to the conclusion that there exists no land in Europe where the people have more prospects of
893:
1) The same people you are talking about were 500 years under the Ottoman empire. And you all know the methods the Ottomans used on this area. So, how can anyone beleive that Tito managed to "change" the ethnicity of this group for just 35 years (1945th-1980th, when he died), something that the
210:
How come that there are Macedonians that live in Greece or Bulgaria and that were never under influence of Tito still regard as Macedonians (as ethnicity, not as regionality)? How come there are Macedonians who left the region and moved to USA, Canada or Australia even before 1940th, but regard
13329:
annoy me as an editor, but I don't remove them without a valid reason, so I don't see why we should compromise to editors who just can't face a reality. However I'm willing to compromise if they stop adding such ridiculous and hateful POV, for now and forever. All it can do is cause edit-wars.
12227:
16) Stephan Gerlach wrote in 1574 that relative of Mehmed Pasha "Became Archbishop in Bulgaria,and his seat is ten days away from Adrianopolis in the city of Ohrid,on the border between Epirus and Serbia" (Zu eineim Erz-bischopff in der Bulgarey gemacht worden,hat seinen Sitz zehn Tagreiss von
12129:
2) In the year 680 in Bythinia, city of Gordoservon is mentioned whose name is derived from the Serbs resettled in Asia Minor by Byzantine Emperor Constance II from the areas around river Vardar (FYROM) . Isidor,the Episcop of Gordoservon is mentioned in 680/681 and the fact that this town was
12098:
Just a bit of sloppiness ;-) really I only meant that here is a consensus that there was not a separate Macedonian people in the Middle Ages. When speaking of Ostrogorsky (Hist. of the Byz. Empire) and my other sources who consider Bulgarian Tsar Samuel's empire Bulgarian, and never refer to a
10794:
I gotta agree with that assessment myself. I think there is already undue emphasis being placed on avoiding confusion that these aren't the exact same Macedonians of Alexander's time. Calling the article Macedonian people neither add to any confusion after the disambiguation page AND a caption
10586:
The Aetolians, the Acarnanians, the Macedonians, men of the same language, are united or disunited by trivial causes that arise from time to time; with aliens, with barbarians, all Greeks wage and will wage eternal war; for they are enemies by the will of nature, which is eternal, and not from
5587:
This document sent out by the Secretary of State in 1944 contends that before Tito and Yugoslav partisan claims were put forward to do with a Macedonian fatherland, there existed no political or historical reality before hand which constituted a "Macedonian" fatherland, conscience or ethnicity
5377:
As I have said, about eight times; Britannica, The CIA World Factbook, The Columbia Encyclopedia, The Harvard Dictionary of Music, Philip's Encyclopedia, The Macmillan Encyclopedia, Crystal Reference Encyclopedia, Penguin Encyclopedia of Places, The Companion to British History, The Hutchinson
4785:
Chris, I do not want to get your pitty with this. I just want you (and anyone else) to think a little on this issue. Why is Macedonia and the Macedonians so big problem for the Greeks and Bulgarians? Because their sceletons that they keep in the closets will show up? Serbia already passed that
3633:
NPOV says to state the facts. Some facts were pre-agreed before the big poll - they are still out of the article. What is the majority and what is the minority view in the scientific community? What do those people feel about it? (they stated their opinion in the poll and later in various talk
2140:
What about you Theathenae. I have given you sources stating the number of Macedonians in Greece nad you pretend they don't exist! This is stupid! You are the nationalist. I am merely a moderate person who wants to see NPOV on Knowledge. You are the nationalist. Anyone can verify that from your
1506:Οι Κρητικοί ήταν και είναι Έλληνες. Και κυρίως νιώθουν Έλληνες. Οι Σκοπιανοί από το 1940 περίπου βαφτίστηκαν Μακεδόνες κι όλα γίναν μακεδονικά. Μακεδονικό δηνάριο, δημοκρατία μακεδονίας, μόνο τον χαλβά δε μας φάγανε ακόμα. Το νόμισμά τους όπως και τα υπόλοιπα είναι κομμάτι της προπαγάνδας τους. 1244:
Concering the Macedonians beeing Bulgarian... you can clearly see what happened during the World War 2 and how the Bulgarian occupators were treated by the Macedonians. That was before Tito, but still 1000s of Macedonians fighted against the Bulgarians with one reason only... they wanted their
12400:
40) In 1665 Archbishop Petar of Sophia wrote that:"Now in this Kingdom of Serbia there is one Metropolitan church,that of Skoplje"(Al presente si trovano in cotesto regno di Servia una chiesa Metropolitana,cioe,Scopia) ,than saying that Pope Urban VIII in his declaration on foundation of "del
9700:
How about "ancient Macedonians and/or Greeks"? As far as I know, nobody provided a definite proof that the ancient Macedonians were totally subsumed within the Greek ethnicity, although it is indisputable that they have adopted a great deal of Greek culture. And why is nobody requiring a good
8314:
those regions because they were the cause of the Second Balkan War. Not only the Ottomans, but also Bulgarians and literally every demographic source available describes them as "Bulgarians", and not as "Macedonians" nor "Macedonian Slavs". Another evidence from a neutral source would be the "
4516:
accept mediation later on. He has some house reparations to do, but he said he'd be available in mid-November. Matia, you're not being correct when you say that I was dissapointed by the results of the poll, I was dissapointed by the poll itself, right from the beginning. To remind everybody:
2930:
and see that there are even documents that mention separate Macedonian ethnicity even back in 15th century. Also, that link will show you even Greek sources from the 1930s that recognize the separate Macedonian ethnicity, much before Tito even appeared. Just a reminder that all the Macedonian
2580:
REX does not label them as Albanians. It only shows the origin of the language, as supported by any relevant source on the world. Again, if your nationalistic mind does not like it, that is not mine or Knowledge's problem. Knowledge is trying to give real information. Not someone's wishes and
12669:
Let the readers decide. The source might be a nationalist, but the references are not. It is more likely that it was like Misirkov said: Samuil's Empire was Macedonian Slavic kingdom, then Macedonians embrace the name Serbs, then forgot about it under the Turkish pressure, so they considered
7131:... I really don't know why all Balkan people are so obsessed with him, I think we should be more focused on the future, and on putting an end to our present economic, political and cultural impotence. That is not to say that the past is not important, but we shouldn't be obsessed with it. -- 5616:
The approved policy of this Government is to oppose any revival of the Macedonian issue as related to Greece. The Greek section of Macedonia is largely inhabited by Greeks, and the Greek people are almost unanimously opposed to the creation of a Macedonian state. Allegations of serious Greek
1087:
Moldovans (in Romanian Moldova and in the Moldova across the river) had a regional identity and strong Moldovan feelings, but they were one people, on both sides of the river, who identified as Romanians beyond their regional identity. After the Russian nation-building, we have two groups of
12604:
If it is desired to designate these Slavs correctly, than they must be considered as Serbs, for the Serbian name is so popular among them that for example male children are sometimes christened "Srbin" *. the Serbian hero of the folk poems, Marko Kraljevich is obviously the Serbian ruler in
10010:
claim to be the descendents of Greeks, but that doesn't mean they are now does it? Matter of opinion as to whether my example was good or bad depending upon CONTEXT and name usage and not an exact analogy. I agree though that Roman lost its exclusive Italic application after losing its city
6640:
Genes are just a fancy way of saying ancestors here. And it seems certain that many people currently identified as Macedonian (Slavic-speaking) have some ancestors who would have been identified as Macedonian (different meaning, of course) in the 5c BC. And there are many people currently
206:
His claims would (and are) laughted at by any Macedonian that gets here on Knowledge, but he still keeps promoting that we are insane people who were brainwashed in just 60 years. How come we lost the Bulgarian feeling in just 60 years, but we didn't loose it during the 500 years of Ottoman
13205:
Harassment of the Macedonian minority has led to a widespread climate of fear. A large number of people interviewed by the mission stated specifically that they did not want their names used, for fear of losing jobs or suffering from the kind of harassment experienced by human rights
12596:
This circumstance was widely exploited by the Bulgars in order to spread their propaganda among the Serbs outside the principality. Whoever was reluctant to become a Bulgar and persisted in calling himself a Serb was denounced to the Turks as conspiring with Serbia, and could expect severe
12592:
71) "It is understandable that the Turks preferred the patient and submissive Bulgar to the rebellious Serb or Greek. Since the Serbian principality had gained its freedom, the Turks regarded every Serb who declared himself to be such as a rebellious conspirator against the Turkish regime.
12482:
53) Bratan Ivanov,a Serb from Macedonian land arrived in Russia (Makedonskie zemli Serbin' Bratan' Ivanov) in the year 1704. Archive of the Russian Ministry For Foreign Affairs,Year 1704 Kapterev,N.A. "Harakter otnoshenii Rossii k Pravoslavnomu Vostoku v XVI i XVII stoletija" 1914 pp.348
11906:
a Slav, therefore the term "Macedonian" was not restricted to any Slavic people, who were at the time the main enemies of the Byzantines. How can "Macedonian" be linked to the Slavs, since the enemies of the Slavs were called Macedonians, and since the Vardar Valley (FYROM) was part of the
8858:
The only difference is that you don't have a clue of what's happening in neither FYROM nor Greece. You believe the propaganda sites you read on the net, and believe in national myths. Anyway if you have real examples on name changes, then refrain from using made-up ones. Why did you change
8675:
The Macedonian ethnic group did exist before "1948" , and it was mostly mentioned by international observers starting in the 19th century (Im not going to source that, its almost everywhere), although, there are some historical texts dating back to the 15th century proving the existence of
6916:
Just face it that THERE ARE MACEDONIANS IN GREECE. I myself am one. Its propagandists like you who ignite the spark in situations causing ethnic conflicts. Im not even going to try to prove to you that Macedonians in Greece exist, just search the web, books, where ever, there are plenty of
3003:
Also, we do not need your view of the politics if it is based on denials. It is enought of that bullshit here. Knowledge is a free enciclopedia and you can not expect it to follow your own POV which is based on denial of the Macedonian nation, so you can have exclusive rights over the name
2960:
Makedonski". Anyone leaving in north Greece may also use that word saying "I am Macedonian", not only slavic speakers. In other words, by saying "I am Makedonski" they don't mean "I belong to the Macedonian nation", but they mean "I live in Macedonia". No dought, they do live in Macedonia.
12200:
12) Dimitar,writer from Kratovo in 1446 said that he begin to translate "Law" for the Archbishoprics of Ohrid from Greek language into Serbian (v ezhe sastaviti mi pisaniem srbskoga ezika sochinenie, rekshe knigu imenuemu zakonik) under order of Ohrid Archbishop Dorotej,who visited him in
9877:
Hello guys. I usually try to be as academic as possible and I fixed up some aspects of the Greek people page even as some people (or just one guy probably) thought I was doing a Greek nationalist job which was not my intent so I'm not anti-Greek here! I think Rex raises a good point. Most
7821:
week, the RoM got official candidate status for the EU. And that's why, even today, you can still see Greek propagnada efforts posing that Macedonia was "Greek", you can take a bus in Salonika and notice that on the bus ticket, for no apparent reason, randomly says: "Macedonia is Greek!".
9792:
I think it is best to only mention "indigenious population" - I also believe that most of the indigenious inhabitants of the Balkans didn't have a separate ethnic identity in the 6 century AD - even the Greeks considered themselves to be a sort of "Eastern Romans" or something like that.
9718:
Thracians are referenced by (Kanchov, Weigand). I don't have at the moment references on how completely Macedonians were absorbed by the time the Slavic tribes came. However, on the basis of what numerous editors have testified and what is surely the case (the consensus among historians;
8565:. On top of this, he is always insulting the Macedonian people as a whole in his talk. Anyway, I am glad that the article was protected, and that Miskin was blocked from reverting any more. Hopefully, he learned his lesson and will stop this nonsense unless he wants to get blocked again. 2353:
If there is anything more pitiful than Greeks insisting "Macedonians were Greek", it is Slavs insisting "Macedonians are Slavs". Why isn't there even a disambiguation notice? Just divide the turf, make all unspecified "Macedonian" articles simple disambiguation pages, and then talk about
12330:"Va p doi mesi cheo mi trovo in Servia visitando queste vile contorno Prisren che e Servia Inferiore, che la Servia Superore questa esta passat e stata gran mortalita della pesta, e che p alcuni mesie stata cessata.Hora di novo si trovano loughli infetati Scopia,Jagnevo, e Montenevo"... 12259:
21) In 17th Century,Hadji Kalpha,a Turkish geographer recorded that mountains of the Castoria district are peopled by Serbs and Aromanians.He also mentions that on the bank of the lake between Seres,Thesaloniki and Siderocaps there is a village inhabited by Greeks,Serbs and Aromanians.
9771:. It's doubtful you could even refer to them as "a regional unit" in that time, but that's very possible; I would have to see the references. Both sides need more references here, but the ancient Macedonian claim needs a specific legitimate reference. I have not read Kanchov or Weigand. 8847:
article. As for the Ancient Macedonian claim, the article is not claiming that today's Macedonians are related to ancient Macedonians, it states a fact that the Macedonian government says its people are related to the Ancient Macedonians. I am therefore putting it back in the article.
6480:, and some genes are lost during reproduction. You may have inherited a gene from yout mother, but that does not mean that it will be passed to your children. It may be lost. Genes are not used to determine ancestry outside those limited cases (pure patrilineal or matrilineal descent). 12978:
and I quote from the relevant entry: "For example, an order of magnitude estimate for a variable between about 3 billion and 30 billion (such as the human population of the Earth) is 10 billion". Within this definition, the 1/4 of Scottish voters indicate the order of magnitude of the
4893:
I am pleased with the article as it is. Evidently MATIA, Theathenae & co. have a problem with certain aspects of the article. What are they? Focus on issues please, what would you change in the article. Create a duplicate article if you like and we'll go through it point by point.
12737:
conformity:))))He was even able to convince "Macedonians" whod been living in North America and Australia before the turn of the century that they were neither Bulgars,Serbs or Greeks but they were Macedonians and the followed him like sheep....right?WHERE IS CENTO WHEN YOU NEED HIM!
10602:
claimed assimilation from the ancient Macedonian soldiers, as there are historical records would verify it. If we decided to use the "possible assimilation" logic to define the ethnicity of every nation on the planet, then we'd have to change every single ethnic article in wikipedia.
932:
5) Why no one gives attention to the Macedonian minorities in Greece and Bulgaria. Did maybe Tito make them "change" their nationality? Or the Macedonians in USA that live there for generations. Did maybe JFK make them become Macedonians? What about those in Canada, Australia, Sweden
12877:
support the theory of Misirkov that Macedonians were proud to be Serbs, by quoting such national heroic poems in Macedonian schoolbooks like "The Building of Scutari" - which was clearly Serbian myth, and never under any influence of Macedonia or Macedonian kings or regional rulers!
7461:
I thought both Bomac and Miskin had a point - the key points being that the Macedonian ethnic group is (a) modern (hence a disambig from the ancient Macedonians) and (b) Slavic-speaking (hence a disambig from the non-Slavic (geographical) Macedonians). So I've combined these. :-) --
12805:
In regards to Karpos..he was a MINER from the KRATOVO region....he was called "THE KING OF KUMANOVO" by the Austrian king...not the king of Kyustendil or the King of Sofia......but Kumanovo and he was mutilated on the stone bridge in Skopje...if they wanted to send a message to the
3180:
pay some bills of Helsinki watch? Do those sources or encylcopedias have a NPOV policy? In some USA states it is taught in scools that Darwin was wrong and human is made by god as the bible says. Those people have their encyclopedias too. Do we have to cosnider those encyclopedias
4399:
What I can't understand is why did all the Greeks try to get out of mediation. If one was of good faith and wanted to get this dispute over with, they would have accepted. The fact that they rejected the idea of mediation has prolonged this dispute and wasted everyone's time.
8708:
as a self-describe term. Albania has some 1% or 2% of the Macedonian region and Buglaria has 10%, so how would you expect them to give importance to it. In Albanian administration it's not even called Macedonia. Greece however, not only has some good 50%, but it also has the
7936:
that you people shamelessly call "occupied". The data didn't include the Muslim and Jewish populations in the region, I was meant to compare Greek vs Slavic. Now what is that trash you present me with? You can't be expecting me to take 12 abstract lines as a credible source.
7753:
being played at a weddding in Ptolemeida back in 2003. And yet with all this, Greece is still denying the existence of Macedonians, just like how you are. Now how can you say theres no Macedonians left in Greece, you are either being really stubourn or you are very stupid. -
11247:
live example, the undisputed evidence, of why the land-claims are actually true. Not only in the government circles, but also in the culture, MacSlavs are brought up to believe in those things. You're justifying my participation in those ethnic debates that I so much abhor.
7056:
way. That means that we should state only the facts - "The government of country X/the offical census counts X Macedonians, Macedonian communties claim Y Macedonians, neutrals say the number of Macedonians is Z". If you think that I've somehow made up their claim, here is a
4931:
Most of the Macedonians are aware that we are not direct descendants of the Antique Macedonians. Same as the Greeks are not. But,both of us have at least partial origin from them. To be honest, I beleive that several other nations have some origin from these Antique people
11631:, and his father was called Josif, a priest, and his grandfather, Stoiman, a priest. I also took the surname of Makedonski, and not that of my father or grandfather, so that it may be known that we are Slavs from Macedonia. On the day of the Great Holy Mother of God, 1846. 5547:^^ the albanian population is for the vast part illegal and therefore should not be counted. and how exaclty is Greece repressing the rainbow party by allowing it to compete in elections rather than smothering it as is the case with the Greek minority in FYROM and Albania 4991:
I think that we're making a mountain out of a molehill. Theathenae & co. haven't even told us what their problem is, despite regular requests for them to do so. It looks like they're never going to/ Perhaps they have no grievences and are just trying to cause trouble,
2665:
If we leave the Makedonski Slavic editors have it their way, then we might as well add in the Ancient Macedonian Language article that it might have been a Slavic language. As from now, any unjustified reverts to my edits will be regarded as an act of edit war. Regards.
11296:. Like 99% of your edits, you're trying to push another a nationalist misinterpretation into the article. Just have a look at your personal page, what on earth is that thing? Wake up and smell the roses, what do you think you're doing in wikipedia? It's never gonna work. 4254:
policy did not exist at the time of the naming poll. With a change (or rather, a creation) of a guiding policy the poll results are effectively invalidated, as the participants were operating without any clear guidelines. Second, the issue of whether or not we follow the
7118:, there. I've already stated that I actually don't believe that the number of Macedonians is that high. I think that the other editors should reconsider my proposal, as well, and I'll leave it to them to decide whether we should put that number in the article, or not. -- 4971:
I agree. Knowledge NPOV. That is what I am talking about. I am not very happy reading on Knowledge that Bulgarians claim that we are brainwashed brothers of theirs. But, that claims exist and they should be ignored (as far as the text is not offensive and assimilative).
4719:
In the meantime, I'd strongly suggest that people avoid edit and revert wars on this and related articles. It isn't helping anyone, and people on both sides of the dispute are going to earn bans if they keep communicating by reverting rather than using talk pages... --
2620:
He wans't labeling Arvanites as Albanians, he was implementing the SOURCES on the disputed status of Arvanitic which ic called an Albanian dialect by UNESCO, Ethnologue, Britannica, Encarta, The University of Ohio etx but Matia doesn't believe them. Are they all wrong?
12511:
58) In the year 1744 Russian Empress Elisabeth addressed the "Noble and honest lords of Serbian lands in Macedonia,Skandaria,Montenegro and Primorje of Montenegrin people,to the governors , dukes, princess and captains as well as their spiritual and secular masters".
265:
The official politics of Greece and Bulgaria is all in favor of denial of the Macedonian separate ethnicity, culture, language... including the Macedonian minority in those countries, who are constantly victims of sometimes even brutal assimilation during the last 100
10576:" I could put a bet that those two scholars never said "Slavs mixed with ancient Macedonians", like you constantly imply. Those scholars must have said that the Slavic peoples that invaded the Balkans mixed the indegenious population, which is pretty much stating the 4713:
some time ago. I'd certainly be interested in doing it. However, now isn't really a good time for me - my PC is going in for servicing in a few days' time and I won't have much Internet time while it's away. We could probably get the ball rolling at the start of next
13117:
This paragraph is problematic. Using the number of votes for what I understand to be a single-issue ethnic party to determine the number of people identifying as belonging to that ethnicity is dodgy, and unless someone has suggested that this is meaningful, is also
8851:
BTW, the fact that I live in Canada makes no difference to my understanding of my ancestreral land Macedonia. The only difference is that I see the situation from a neutral point-of-view, where as you see everything in a Greek-point-of-view from your home in Greece.
8243:
I never denied the existence of people who have Greek names and claim to be Macedonian Slavic (in Rainbow for example). However that does not prove anything about "Greek government changing forcefully all Macedonian Slavic names into Greek ones" or similar extremist
3659:
Also, note that there are no sources before the 20th century that denies a separate Macedonian ethincity. These sources appeared when the assimilation politics from Greece, Serbia and Bulgaria took more power, at the beggining of the 20th century. And all because of
13195:
pg 27 In spite of this avowal (it lists the human rights of a Greek citizen above), as well as the international human rights laws forbidding discrimination, the Greek government has discriminated against and failed to protect the rights of its Macedonian minority.
9666:
connection between the modern and the ancient Macedonians - so the Slavs could have mixed with Vlachs, Trachians, and the Illyrians, but with the ancient Macedonians - no way! Someone could have added Japanese there, and nobody would complain, but to say that it is
7406:
reader (who comes here to be educated) into thinking that "ancient Macedonian" was also "ethnic Macedonian". In order to achieve this of course, the word Slavic should be swept under the rug. Talking about propaganda in wikipedia... I tell ya, I could write a book.
9626:
is a higher level of identity organisation. So, I don't think Macedonians should be marked with any prefixes or suffixes, due to before-mentioned fact and the fact that Greek/Bulgarian Macedonians are Greeks/Bulgarians. In the end, why don't we make articles about
13023:
Zikicam, you pointed several times that there are Bulgarians and Serbia and that is some kind of proof of tolerance in Serbia. I don’t think so. There is no tolerance in Balkan!! At least not in 19/20 century to be sure. What you are referring is the people from
12193:
11) Sometimes in the beginning of 15th century Bulgarian chronicles are written,where remark that Turkish Sultan Murat had went to conquer either Bulgars or Ugljesha.Ugljesha and King Vukashin gathered a great Serbian army (Sobra sja mnozhestvo voisk Serbskih) .
11165:. So, again, all of you, please see the disputed sentenced above and put some comments about them, or if you are willing to discuss another subject please open a new section. So far, my first proposal seems to be accepted, but I'm not sure about the second one? -- 1563:) is quite bussy in something which is not so ridiculous as this dispute is, but I would like to ask him to express his oppinion on this kind of actions. Are we allowed to do them? If we are allowed, we should know, so we can react respectivly. Thanks in advance. 12709:"Medieval sources traditionally describe them as Bulgarians, a definition which survived well into the period of Ottoman rule as attested by the Ottoman archives and by descriptions of historians and travellers, for example Evliya Celebi and his Book of Travels. 12135:
Niederle,L. "Slovanske starozhitnosti" Dilu II,Svazek pp.389-399; pp. 444-446 Ostrogorski,G."Bizantisko-Juzhnoslovenski odnosi",Enciklopedija Jugoslavije 1,Zagreb 1955,pp. 591-599 Ramsay,W.M. "The Historical Geography Of Asia Minor", London, 1890, pp.183, pp.210
12075:
Regarding Dushan, in Dushan's Law Code, Tsar Stephan Dushan was titled as "the honorable and reverent Macedonian Tsar Stephan, ruler of Serbia, Bulgaria, Hungary, Dalmatia, Albania, Hungaro-Wallachia , etc... This is typical for someone that claim Tsar status -
6010:
I put the new chapter about surname changes. I pleed people not to revert it, and to proove the difference. My family LIVED there actually. I urge this Aldux guy not to revert my entries. You are an Italian, man, you don't know what was happening then and there.
5237:
PREVIOUS WEEKS IF YOU DON'T AGREE TO CHANGE THE ARTICLE, SORRY!!!!!! And something more; the solutions to the potential ambiguities, were solved by the Slav Macedonians between them and not with Greeks, because you think that you are alone in this Encyclopedia
2172:
that even now in the 21st century there are often and violent represions against anyone who declares as Macedonian? If that is happening now, can you imagine what was happening in the past, some 100 years ago, when the humman rights were not so important issue?
13231:
What you are saying is wrong, you are saying that pressure from the Greek government caused them to believe that they are Greek. In reality, the ones you are mentioning in private, do admit their Macedonian ethnicity. A more accuate phrasing is the following:
12715:"In the late 19th century and the beginning of 20th century, there were lot of clashes of Serbophile Chetniks (originating from Macedonia) and Bulgarophile Komitas all over the Slavic-speaking Macedonia, which shows the lack of their proper national feeling." 6588:
Macedonian claims, we have to consider the general historical view that the ancient Macedonians were Hellenized before the Slavic invasion, and any ancient Macedonian physical element in modern Macedonians according to this view would be via Byzantine Greeks.
1452:
Knowledge should be neutral. If you have any sources or any arguments, write there here so that we can examine them, directing us to examine your "previous contributions" is not an argument. I cannot find anything in your previous contributions that justifies
567:
Spending all this time deffending something that comes natural to any human beeing as basic human right (in the democratic world), something that will be revealed by its own, something that the world can not ignore anymore. Does all this time really worth it?
13179:
While I agree with you, that's not what I'm getting at. I am requesting User:Macedonia's source that harassment and discrimination by the Greek state is the cause of the majority of the ethnic Macedonian minority in Greece self-identifying as Greek. You dig?
12360:
34) Petar Bogdani had wrote in 1650 a letter of recommendation for his relative Andria Bogdani from Albania ,saying about him that he is recommended for Archbishopric of Ohrid in Serbia (Proposto per L'Archivescovato d' Ochrida su in confini della Servia) .
12147:
4) In the Law of Serbian Emperor Stephan Dushan (Dushanov Zakonik) issued 1349-1354 in Skoplje and Seress following peoples are mentioned in Serbia:Serbs,Greeks,Albanians (Arbanasi) (art.77,82) , Aromanians (Vlasi) (art.32,77,82) , Saxons (Sasi) (art.123) .
8492:
Decree No.332 of 1926 ordered the Slavic names of towns, villages, mountains and rivers changed to Greek names. See Appendix A for a list of place names changed according to Decree 332. Law No. 87 of 1936 ordered Macedonians to change their names to Greek
2114:
I already asked some administrators to check his edits and see his methods here on Knowledge. Won't anyone ask an arbitration for this guy for this kind of tactics? Sweedish Knowledge already gave him life-time ban. And I don't think it was because he was an
5978:"Other ethnic minorities in Serbian Macedonia were also persecuted during the inter-war period, with thousands being arrested." I'll erase this. Where is the source for that? My gradfather lived in Macedonia until 1948 and he told me it was not true. C'mon. 11933:
OK, first - Bulgars was the common name for all south Slavs in that period. Constantin Bodin was a Serb who took the title "Bulgarian tzar", just like Tzar Samuil (if he really did that), which doesn't makes him a Bulgarian, but a Slavic tzar or something.
12463:
50) Mitropolit Jevtimije from Serbian land of Skoplje (Serbskija zemli goroda Skopija) arrived in Russia in 1687 where he delivered a request in which he says that he is Mitropolit of Serbian land of Skoplje (Mitropolit Serbskije zemli Skopskie Crkve) .
8767:
Empire as a "Macedonian Empire", and I keep asking myself, if you're really so sure about the historical existence of your people, then how come your state and your scholars feed you with such lies? I provided you with 2 credible sources already which are
7593:
Turkish Macedonians, Roma Macedonians, etc.. etc.. etc.. I know that the Greek Macedonians are missing but that's at most an extra 200,000 and that is why 1.7 is an estimate. The same thing is done on the Estonians and Slovenians page for the same reasons.
5295:
Why don't you propose something. Also, please sign your posts with four tildes ~~~~ and this will produce your ID and the date/time. I encourage you to open an account, as it then will be easier to know who you are because now you are only a number to me.
10808:
I don't think that it's emphasised enough. If there's a nationalist crowd of people, that would be the Slavic one not the Greek. The majority of the Greek crowd that's editing here, is reacting to the extremities of the MacSlav propaganda. Have a look at
3299:
by the European Court of Human Rights for petty Human Rights violations? Greece is one of the countries that have shown minimal degrees of development since joining the EU. They wasted all that aid that they were given; they didn't use it wisely like the
8892:
Take my advice and stop wasting your time by reverting the phrase "ancient Macedonians" in the article. Nobody's ignorant enough to ever fall for that hoax. Leave the edits made by Alexander_007, it's the best case scenario that can be arranged for you.
7874:
Why are you only naming municipalities with significant Greek populations, but not the WHOLE REGION in general? Here are the REAL numbers from Ottoman sources on the whole region of Greek Macedonia in the early 1900's (before the arrival of Pontic Greek
5316:
That is the reason why Knowledge is so weak on this issue. Anyone can edit it. Even if we stay here for months and finaly reach an agreevement, someone else like this guy can come here (regardless of his nationality) and destroy everything we worked on.
11404: 3013:
And, by that name: "Macedonians". The past is much diffferent than the one you want to present here, but I am not going to waste my time on that now. Lets talk about reality, about the present. A present where the modern "Macedonian" nation is reality.
8113:
deleting or altering part of a Knowledge official policy with which the vandal disagrees, without any attempt to seek consensus or recognize an existing consensus. Improving or clarifying policy wording in line with the clear existing consensus is not
202:
We can not describe the characteristics of these people when having assimilators here, whose only purpose is to deny the Macedonian nation and promote their history and culture as theirs. Please see the posts of VMORO, so you can see what I am talking
2964:
Macedonia, even thouth they did use the word "Makedonski" to describe themselfs, they didn't have the fealing of being a nation. (see the paragraph i wrote before). Therefore a "Macedonian" nation didn't exist before the begining of the 20th century.
442:
I am talking about the modern Macedonians, (more-less) described by the page above. A Macedonian ethnicity, not regionality. In the history there are only 2 ethnicities with this name: Antique Macedonians and modern Macedonians. Between them there is
6941:
Britannica recognizes only a "Slavic Macedonian" ethnic group. The Macedonian natioanality applies to both Slavs and Albanians within the Republic. Let me guess, is that more Greek POV? Those dirty Greeks, I bet they're hairy and they smell bad too.
4104:
Kollias explained that, would you like a photo of the book? I'll send it to your talk page. Again personal attacks REX? I did with Arvanites the same thing I proposed to FlavSavr and others to do here. Are or aren't you behind the move in one night?
1522:
Cretans were and are Greeks. And they mainly feel Greeks. Skopyans from round about 1940 were baptised (ie started to be called) Macedonians and everything became Macedonian. Macedonian denar, Republic of Macedonia, all they haven't taken yet is our
11687:
Yeah, Macedonian Greeks (but when the pigs will fly!). There were no Greeks who were describing as Macedonians then (honestly, I don't believe the even exist now). And from which "neutral sources" did you read that, o Miskin, o neutral sourced man?
7380:
as opposed to the ethnically Greek or ethnically Bulgarian Macedonians. That's fair enough - however, Miskin seems to think that it's not disambiguated far enough, that there are still some ambiguities. Let's ask them what they are and resolve them
7358:
But, dear MATIA, that's the paragraph mentioned before. As for the "modernity", it is only in sense to avoid saying things zillion times and other Macedonians are modern Macedonians in a regional sense, but they are modern Greeks or Bulgarians in a
12554:
64) "The Serbian pastoral tribes are separated from the Bulgarian agrarian population of Macedonia by the Greeks, who inhabit the central and coastal regions of this great land". Cyprian Robert, "Les Slaves de Turque" Paris, 1844, Vol. II pp.234
12518:
59) In a 1756 letter main cities in Serbia (La Servie) are mentioned, and among them Skoplje ,where Serbian Archbishop reside; Cratovo,by which province is named (Scopia, ou reside Archeveque Rascien; Cratovo, qui donne son nom au Gouvernement) .
12309:
28) Congregation approves purchase of a house in Skoplje ( " della Casa in Scopie " ) in which four or five young Serbs ("4, o 5 giovani Servian") are to be trained and send into the Illyrian College in Loretto ( " Collego Illirico di Loreto " )
447:
10 centuries difference (probably more). So, we clearly can not talk about the same people, aldough it is a fact that the modern Macedonians have at least a little part of origin from those people (like almost all the south Balkan ethnic groups).
12574:
68) From 1880 to 1881 the Serbian Brsjaci Revolt (Brsjachka Buna) was fought in the areas of Demir-Hisar,Porech and Kichevo.The leaders of this uprising were local Chetniks:Ilija Delija,Rista Kostadinovich,Micko Krstich and Andjelko Tanasovich.
8017:
About the Paionia part, Paionia was considered an independent Macedonian tribe, or the northern fringes of Macedon. Nevertheless, it was inhabited by ancient Macedonians, and it was also part of ancient Macedon in Alexander's empire in 334 BC. -
6765:
article is laid out in a number of areas. It includes discussions of ethnic origins in a ==History== section, which is what I recommend for this article as well, rather than summarizing a complex, controversial issue in an opening paragraph. The
6557:. No pseudo-science to say that so-and-so a people have genes from such-and-such an ancient people. It's an accepted manner of speaking in these fields. Of course, nothing on this subject should be added without credible sources in this article. 2660:
Remove the ludicrous reference on the "origin" section on how some "Macedonian historians" (whatever that means) believe that Macedonian Slavs are not really the descendants of the Slavs but of the ancient Macedonians and the related disgraceful
2089:
I am a co-worker of a Greek girl here in Republic of Macedonia. Her whole family (Cilimingas) is Greek and they are all registered as a Greeks. I would be glad to ask her for her comment. I am sure she will be glad to comment on this nonsence by
12985:
offered bribes (on some acounts up to 1000 €) in order for them to vote for this Rainbow party. The party who is owned by a Greek opurtunist bussinessman who has a factory in Skopje who is supported by funds of money from the Skopje Government.
12055:
Middle Ages Macedonians and Bulgarians were one people; you may not like this, or find it false, but the fact is that this is the position assumed by all medieval history handbooks. If you want me to cite a name, I'll just remember Ostrogorsky.
7616:
Bulgaria. Outside of Europe there are speakers in the USA, Canada, and Australia. Numbers of speakers are not available for Bulgaria or Albania because of those countries' language policies. Total speakers may number 2.5 million (Friedman 1985).
11511:
The second national population element in importance and numbers with in the borders of the Epirus despocy in that period were the Macedonians, of whom there is frequent mention in the records of the archbishopric (over 50 times). For example,
4738:
Also, I think we should discuss how to protect the page from future nationalistic edicts from both sides. I do not want to spend days and days of editing and my work to be destroyed by some nationalist newbie (I repeat, from any of the sides).
2398:
There is also NO "Slavic Macedonian Language". There can only be "Macedonian language" whose origin is dominantly Slavic. But the official name of the language, supported again by more than 95% of the relevant sources is "Macedonian language".
3271:
Yugoslavia supposed to have. So, don't make Greece as one of the "most reasonable and advanced countries in the Balkan region". And, there is a big number of macedonians and other minorities in Greece, no matter how much you want to hide taht
12393:
39) In an inscription from 1659 stands:"Mihail Mitropit, visitor of Holy God's Grave in the Holy Jerusalem, from the Serbian land city of Kratovo" (Mihail Mitropolit,poklonik bozhia groba svetago Ierusalima ot Srbskie zemli grada Kratova) .
1110:
Another fact: In case of the ridiculous claim that the Macedonians were Bulgarians... How come only the Bulgarians in Republic of Macedonia accepted (completely) the Macedonian ethnicity, but the Albanian, Vlachs, Serbs, Roma etc. kept their
13020:
declared as Bulgarian. Like, I, (name here) X from the city Y (from Macedonia) did this and that. Unlike Serbian sources. Almost all references are indirect i.e. traveler reports, slave market reports etc. This is what I was talking about.
12695:"The geographical region of Macedonia, which is divided between Bulgaria, Greece and the Republic of Macedonia, has been inhabited by a variety of other peoples including Albanians, Bulgarians, Jews, Turks, Serbs, Roma, Greeks and Vlachs." 5617:
participation in any such agitation can be assumed to be false. This Government would regard as responsible any Government or group of Governments tolerating or encouraging menacing or aggressive acts of "Macedonian Forces" against Greece.
4072:
Can you explain why the Arvanites of Epirus and Western Macedonia call themselves Shqiptar if it is so offensive. Does the offensive card only apply in selective cases? We can name the Macedonians against their will, but not the Arvanites.
698:
By the way, your last edit is a clear Personal Attack. I should remind you that PAs in Knowledge are counter-productive and will only cause you pain in the long run. I am not goint to tolerate you, same as the Swedish didn't tolerated you.
10266:
By the way, just 'cause you keep sticking to your comparison, there is no dispute among historians AFAIK that there is some Roman ancestry in the Romanian stock: whether Romanized indigenous peoples who, by the fact that they lived in the
1743:
Also, I don't care much for you personal attacks. Don't you dare dicipline me for PA after you have behaved this way. So I called a poll, so what? I am a man of honour, I have nothing to fear (and nothing to lose). I wanted the article at
6641:
identified as Albanians and Vlachs and Bulgarians and Greeks and Turks and Serbs who have some ancient Macedonian ancestors. And I'll admit that the Welsh and Danish have fewer ancient Macedonian ancestors, and the Japanese even fewer.
3097:
All the problems and arguements we have between us are only in our heads. In real life, nothing of that is valid. When we both (Macedonians and Greeks) free our minds, we might find a solution and finally start living as real neighboors.
2060:'s nationalistic edits that he has no sources about. That is just another of his nationalistic POVs. And this is also another of his tacktics of moving our attention away from the real problem and wasting time here. As you probably know, 952:
7) Do you maybe know how does it feel all your famous revolutioners who fighted for Macedonia to be killed by your own neighboor, and latter the same neighboor to claim that they were actually their revolutioners? Then, why did they kill
12948:
I believe that it is necessary since if the info "The Hutchinson Educational Encyclopedia estimates the number of the Macedonian speakers living in Greece between 100,000-200,000 (1994)" were accurate, one would expect many more voters.
11976:
Sorry for being unclear. I am speaking about the four portraits on the top of the article, who are supposed to represent Macedonians. I see all four portraits are in one image. Please describe these people in the image description page.
6204:
Anyway, I think it's getting a bit racist now, don't you? Ancient Macedonian genes, where did that come from? Genes control specific characteristics of an organism (height, metabolism etc). What does that have to do with their ancestry?
1665:
What do you mean, wiki-stalking, MATIA. It's you who are wiki-stalking. That you look at people's contribs is well-known. If you check, you would notice that I had an account at the Greek Knowledge before you did. You followed me there!
1190:
The Antient Macedonian state surely used the Greek language as official, but only as try to represent themselves in a more cultural way. It is an undenied fact that in everyday life they actually used a separate language, which was not
11179:
any dispute, but more as points to ponder. Whether "fun" or not, I think it would be healthy to draw inspiration from similar disputes on WP titles and content, for reasons of conformity and comparability. And so, the discussion is not
10011:
definition sure. Ultimately, the Macedonians aren't going to be considered Greeks because they do not speak Greek. Academics don't simply assign people to become another people based upon claims that they are descendents of some group.
3506:
who have inhabited the region since the days of ancient Macedonia. (The question of whether the ancient Macedonians were in fact Greek is controversial, as many ancient Greeks - especially political enemies of Macedonian Kings, such as
6794:
I've added more info in the Major Populations. I explained the need for this above. I propose the "Major Populations" and the "The situation today" sections to be merged, since they seem to elaborate similar topics. What do you think?
6348:
Are you suggesting that every Macedonian has inherited a gene from a specific group people? Even the English test you mention (which showed discontinuity with the Ancient Britons - apparently, in some areas, English people have strong
2805:
Ethologue mentions 180,180 Macedonian language speakers in Greece (1986 census). This noumber here is used as a synonymous to "Macedonians"!! That's not right since only a handfull of slavic speakers in Greece would claim an not-greek
357:
Are you talking about contributors to Knowledge, i.e., people who have edited the WP article or signed comments on this talk page? Or Greeks in general? Or certain Greek or other politicians, university professors, book authors, etc.?
12401:
collegio Illyrico" says that there are three Biscopates in Serbia :those of Skoplje,Justinijana called Prizren ,and Nish (Che sono del regno di Servia tre vescovati:cioe Scupi,ovvero Scopia,Justiniana detta Prisren,et anche Nissa) .
11268:
I am not sure if Delta states that Pavlos Melas described macedonia as New conquered territories, although it is a fact that Delta states in her novel that Pavlos Melas refered to the slavonic language spoken by locals as Macedonian,
10468:
Lol. This must be part of the no personal attacks routine. Man, do you always do what you say you aren't really doing or are you just not really aware of it? That's a rhetorical question by the way so feel free to not answer it.
10421:
Oooo, Alex is angry at me. See, when someone says they aren't going for a personal attack they usually turn out to be, well, someone like you. Good thing you don't have to prove anything to me 'cause you sure didn't 'prove' jack.
2075:'s nationalistic claims. On the other side, every major human rights organization in the world which is present in the region has given harsh critics towards Greece for its poor (or non-existant) human rights given to the minorities. 7212:
Izehar, that "disputed sentence" by Miskin clearly states "modern macedonians". I think is so irrelevant to write Slavic here. I mean, in the ethno-box there is a part where clearly is stated that Macedonians are connected to other
1537:
I must express my shock to this hurtful statement and attempt to strip the Macedonians of their identity. I guess we now know what MATIA's views on the issues are. I hope that MATIA can give a satisfactory explanation for all this.
12426:
44) It is stated in the "Report about Serbian or Skopje's Diocese" ( Relazione della diocesi di Servia o Skopia ) about "Main places in Serbia : Prizren , Skoplje...." (" Li loughi principali della Servia: Prisren, Scopia ....")
6415:
Alright, I may have (or may not have, I'm not convinced) used the word gene in a wrong way. Then substitue DNA or alleles or whatever in their place. But when people claim physical ancestry, they claim a physical link---DNA, then.
12446:
47) Archbishop of Skoplje writes about Serbia and says that Skoplje is capital city in Serbia (Scopia....metropolli di Servia) .Further,He mentions that Orthodox houses in Skoplje are Greek and Serbian (Case Greche e Serviane) .
11355:
blah", we're talking about something recent. Why are there always so many "coincidental" confusions between Bulgarians and Macedonian Slavs? Why does the POV history of the "Macedonian Slavs", always coincide with Bulgarian (e.g.
9661:
Aldux, the ancient Macedonians are an indigenious population. You have a source (Kanchov, Weigand), that claim that it is possible that they have mixed with the Slavs. What I find totally irresposible is the continuous removal of
12633:
74) An observation by the Austro-Hungarian Field Marshal Anton Tuma von Waldkampf: "In Macedonia Serbs are living, partly in the great plain of Bitolj,partly in Vardar plain and are particularly compact in the valley of Tetovo"
10926:
is a dynamic concept based primarily on a current collective identity and sense of belonging/community that includes certain myths/narratives of (a) common origin(s) ("stock") and, hopefully, a belief in a common destiny/future.
5172:
Just to remind you... we are talking about nationality/ethnicity. No matter of anything, the nationality/ethnicity of the "Macedonian Greeks" and "Macedonian Bulgarians" will never be something different than Greek or Bulgarian.
504:
Also, they can not be used as a reason for denying our name. They existed more than 20 centuries ago. Only a uneducated person can think that someone can have direct origin from them on a so multi-cultured area as the Balkan is.
12535:
61) A group of French staff officers in 1807,with the permission of the Turks, traveled around Macedonia compiling a statistical survey of the population. Apart from Greeks,Turks,Albanians and Aromanians they found only Serbs.
12453:
48) Canonical Visit by Archbishop of Skoplje Peter Bogdani in 1680 indicated that inhabitans of Skoplje are "Greeks, Serbs, Jews, Armenians". "Scritture orig. rif. nelle. congr. gen. vol. 482 ad congr. die 5 maii 1681 Nro 24"
12285:
25) Mitropolit Sergius said in Russia that he was appointed as Mitropolit in Greven by Archbishop of Ohrid,Nectarij of Serbian land (Posvjashchen on na mitropoliju grevenskuju arhiepiskop ohridskim ,Nektariem serbskoi zemli) .
12272:
23) In the October of 1605 delegation of monks went in Russia and among them was Diakon Avksentij from the Serbian land, Nicholas Monastery in Strumica (Serbskoi zemli nikolskoga monastira chto na Strumicja,Diakon Avksentii) .
9740:
I doubt they have had a strong Macedonian ethnic identity in the 6th century AD - there were strong waves of Hellenization and later on, Romanization. Same applies for the Thracians and Illyrians, though. Do Kanchov and Weigand
7790:
been inhabited by Greeks, and no-one has to right to have land claims on that region. It's always been a Greek land, wake up the smell the roses. If there's someone that needs to go away would be the 5 remain whiny Slavophones.
5952:. Dispete the kinky past, nowdays the Macedonians and the Serbs are extremely close and support each other. I personally have several Serbian friends that I love as my brothers and sisters. I would give my life for some of them. 3850:
Yeah, I am in (as you said). Just I want to know one thing: After long hours of dealing and comparing sources... how will we know that one day some Greek or Macedonian nationalist won't come and destroy everything we worked on?
1114:
Another fact, the most powerful one: in that time, the Macedonian separate ethnicity was already a proven and accepted fact by the international comunity. That can be found in enormous ammount of document from the period before
174:
for the article about them. They exist, they can be described, they can be talked about behind their backs! Greeks can call them names - or refuse to "let them" have their "proper" name. There's nothing we can do to stop this.
10775:
controversy whether the Macedonians constitute a distinct ethnic group - you can check every serious modern international source (even those who refer to them as "Macedonian Slavs" regard them as a separate ethnic group). The
2931:
supported the Greek communist party during the Greek civil war with one reason only: the other option was denying the existance of the separate Macedonian ethnicity, same as the Greek goverment does today, in the 21st century.
1432:
and all the other policies until it has been proven that this case is an exception. MATIA is always directing us to read his previous contributions to see why we are wrong and he is right. I've just searched them all, there's
1380:
Many of the documents and facts that proove our separate identity are not on internet. The sources given above are more than enough to proove that our identity did not appear in 1945th. But, that is just a few of the sources.
8918:
Balkan lies and national myths to be unsupervised. Most editors and admins don't care because this article is of no importance, so I suppose if it weren't for people like me, MacSlav nationalist would claim that they are the
559:
I would like to ask you personaly... have you ever tought that Knowledge might misinform the people, without knowing it? Who takes responsobility for that? Because many times "no responsibility" is association with anarchy.
12433:
45) 1676 Secretary of the society "De Propaganda Fide" wrote a report to Pope Inocentius about Catholic Church in Bosnia and neighboring countries, in which Biscop of Skoplje,Andrea Bogdani in Serbia (Servia) is mentioned.
9719:
consensus=most agree), the burden here is to get a specific usable reference (e.g., from a historian, not an unsourced tourist page folks) that Macedonians were still an ethnicity when the Slavic tribes came into Macedonia.
2191:
I will insisnt the issue of human rights in Greece to be considered, always offering relevant sources. And, I will be glad if you can find one (neutral please, not a Greek nationalistic POV push), instead of imagining them.
10227:. There are of course Macedonians who don't make all those claims, and simply reserve the right to call themselves Macedonians and claim some ancient Macedonian heritage, which few people I think would have a problem with. 11134:
Yeah, lots of factors that seem to span the globe really. Just with the articles I've edited, there is a lot of ultranationalist intent. Guy I know from Ghana has a lot of problems with many of the local countries. The
8662:
historically Greek for thousands of years is not a fact, its the same Greek propaganda such as Greek nationalists claiming that Instandbul in Turkey, Southern Albania, Sicily, Northern Egypt and other non Greek lands were.
2934:
So, the next time when you go to Florina, ask some of those people and talk to them as friend. If they trust you (having on mind the represions they still experience), they will tell you what they feel as their ethnicity.
12733:"The key events in the formation of a distinctive "Macedonian" identity thus came during the first half of the 20th century in the aftermath of the Balkan Wars of 1912-1913 and especially following the Second World War." 12292:
26) Comment by Dominican Nicolo Longi from Dubrovnik states that "it is useful to send 3-4 Serbian priest in Serbia, because in Nish, Kragujevac, Jagodina, Crna Gora (Skopska Crna Gora-I.M) and Kratovo Serbian is spoken"
12143:
Daskalov,H.S. "Otkritija v drevnei stolicji Bolgarskoi,Ternovo"Moskva, 1859 pp.18-19 Dujchev,I. "Car Ivan Asen II" Sofija, 1941 pp.23-24 Makushev,V "Bolgarija v' koncjah XII i v pervoi polovini XIII veka" ,1872 pp.56-57
11376:(practically a dialect of the former). Don't you see too many coincidences there? Repeated coincidence, is not a coincidence. Who are you trying to convince of the "Macedonian nation"'s long existence, us, or yourselves? 564:
the "Macedonia" related pages, aldough I have many other interests. But, I simply can not spare more time, because I love my wife and I wouldn't like her to divorce me because of all the time I spent here instead on her.
10211:); not only that, many Macedonians believe that the ancient Macedonians were a Slavic people, and the modern people are their direct descendants. Romanians would be a good parallel example if Romanians called themselves 10202:
You're welcome for the history lesson, and now here's my next lesson: many (I'd say most) Macedonians believe that the ancient Macedonians were not Greek (very possible; I kinda agree, but it's just one possibility: see
9690:
The removal is legitmate and has been explained. It does not in any way logically follow that if some Thracians were still around, there were still un-Hellenized Macedonians around. Find good references: simple as that.
8842:
Therefore, there is absolutney no excuse to not use this as an example of hellenization. I still dont know why you'r deleting Florina - Lerin, since it is confirmed that Florina was known as the Slavic name Lerin in the
7015:
So if you are a Slavophone in Greece let's speak in Greek then. Oh I know, you don't want to be rude to the rest of wikipedians. That's just sad. Don't you ever change my edits (such as the title of this section) again.
6022:
but for all those who read wikipedia, even if Japanese. It also in your interest to adeguately source your edits, because that way nationalists from neighbouring countries will not be able to oppose reasonable arguments.
5354:
of a lists o documents that proof the existance of a separate Macedonian nation back to 15th century. Strangely, but some o those documents are Greek. It is pitty that your history book is the only source or your posts.
4569:
Changing the subject, this article has been protected now for nearly two weeks, which is much longer than is normally allowed. Can anyone tell me if it would be OK to unprotect it now, or is this still being sorted out?
234:
At first, I have to say that we have to make difference between citizenship, nationality and nation. As recognized by most relevant factors in the world, the members of the ethnicity (more-less) described in the article
4735:) supervise this. Until now, you have been quite neutral and it seems that you know enought about the topic. I am just sorry for all the time you would have to spend. I hope that it will at least result into a solution. 3562:
Again, I willnot ever (same as any Macedonian in the world) accept this kind of POV push. If there were anti-Macedonian assimilation attempts and denials some 100 years ago, that can not be allowed in the 21st century.
13053:
How can one claim that there was "strong resistance" on the part of the indigenous population in Vardar Macedonia during WW2? It's well known that the couple of "Macedonian" partisan "Brigades" came from the North...
7008:
Remind yourself why Rainbow Party was creatd in the firstplace. If there was really free expression in Greece, there would be no Rainbow Party and the HRW would never have got involved with the Macedonians of Greece.
4935:
But non of us can claim direct origin. Therefore, Knowledge is completely right to make clear distinction between. But, a (potential) partial origin can not be denied, not even one neutral historian ever denied that.
2852:
I am avare that through the period of endless assimilation that was happening there, many of those people started proclaiming themselves as Greek. But, it is a fact that the national feeling can not just be lost like
4859:
I would agree to accept another name as soon as the Greeks agree to change their name. Is so much nicer to be on that side MATIA. No one is denying your identity. All you do is talk about history. I am talking about
12172:
8) In the second half of 14th century, monk Isaiah said that Ugljesha has risen Serbian and Greek army (Srbskija i Grchskiija voiska) and his brother Vukashin,and with that army they confronted the invading Turks.
11485:? Do you know where was the Hungarians in 9 century AD(except after 895, i.e. in the end of 9 century itself). Please, quote the sources right and then we will see what it prove (if it proves something). Regards, -- 12252:
20) In the year 1584 Alexander Komulovich mentioned that in Serbia (Servia) ,Skoplje is principal city (Scopia principale citta) and that it is situated in the middle of the province (nel mezzo della provincia) .
12186:
10) A 1401 remark from government of Venice says about the envoy of "Konstatntin,master of Serbia,which is around our Drach area" (Constantini domini Servie teritorii,quod est circa teritorium nostrum Durachii) .
11419:
So there is the source you wanted, no "Macedonian Slav" POVs or anything like that, there is no excuss to take it out, so I am putting back in the article the language part and not the conquerred territory part. -
8688:
The link that you provided (hrw.org) verifies that changes in toponyms took place, which is something that I never denied, what I denied were your silly examples, generalizations, and anachronistic use of the term
12810:
the ROM......neither them or the Greeks nor the Serbs...will be able to make us change our names again...or listen to priest we dont understand...or fight for nations we have no allegiance to..never again. Adios.
11139:
page is already getting editors who are pushing either the Iranic or Turkic exclusive origin even thought I put up genetic studies that link them to other Caucasus peoples moreso than either of the other groups.
8557:
name, this is not a POV, this is commen sense. Miskin has even had a long history of other edit reverting wars with other users as well that went beyond the 3RR. Just have a look at the history of these articles:
6323:
done in England and English populations not too long ago, and they found great continuity between the ancient English sample and modern populations in a region of England. So, I conclude that I'm not too far off.
12419:
43) 1667 Emperor Leopold gave some privileges to the Greeks (Graeci) and Serbs (Rasciani) who emigrated toward Northern Hungary and most of them arrived from Macedonia (Praesertim autem ex Macedonia adventum) .
10905:
Linguistically and culturally, there is not a great distinction between Slovak and Czechs, but due to political and historic circumstances, the Slovaks have come to consider themselves a separate people from the
11414:, written by David Ricks and Michael Trapp. Page 48 viewed on Google book search. This chapter is about Macedonia and Macedonians mentioned in Delta's novel "Secrets of the swamp". I will tell you what it says. 8777:
So why are you changing the story now, before you wanted me to prove that a government sponsered process called Hellenization took place, and I did (Slavic names being changed to Greek names, which you verified
8473:
OK, although I've took some rest, but it seems this article is still in trouble. I cannot understand why Miskin repeatedly reverts the fact that the Greek government sponsored a Hellenization policy. There is a
6449:). This can prove patrilineal descent, as chromosomes contain DNA. However, as Chromosomes are mixed during fertilisation, they are not used in determining ancestral links, due to the question of what is whose. 1186:
I can tell you that you have wrong sources that the Antique Macedonians were Greeks. Actually, it is a fact that many famous Greeks actually were opposing the idea to accept the Antient Macedonians as a part of
12558:
65) "Serbian branch includes, with the exception of Serbian Principate, Montenegro, Bosnia, also many other enclaves in Albania and Macedonia" Cyprian Robert, "Die Slaven der Turkei" Stuttgart, vol.II pp. 278
12373:
36) 1652 In the documents of Russian Imperial House,it is recorded that Serbian Mitropolit Mihailo (Serbskii Mitropolit Mihailo) had dinner with the Russian Emperor.He is the same person from reference above.
12380:
37) 1653 Jeromonah Damaskin,wrote a letter to his cousin,mitropolit Mihailo of Kratovo,in which there is a statement about mercy of the Russian Emperor towards our Serbian language (Jeziku nashemu Srbskom) .
12207:
13) Remains of John Rilski are transferred from Trnovo in the Monastery of Rila.That was described by Vladislav Gramatik,in 1469,who also mentioned Serbian soldiers (Srbskiie voje) in the 1371 Marica battle.
5156:
Dear "vandal". You should also understand that Knowledge's neutrality is not based on what one nations feels like. Check the internet, check any relevant source. They all reffer to these people as Macedonians.
13241: 13185: 13151: 13107: 3221:
though. So we can use the Helsinki watch's estimates when estimating the number of Greeks in other countries but we can't use their estimates on how many ethnic Macedonians there are in Greece? These blatant
776:
Doubting our separate ethnicity is unacceptable. No matter did it formed in 1991st, 1945th, 1918th, 10 or 25 centuries ago. It is important that it is reality now. So, it is even offensive to even talk about
9328: 5399:. Also, please sign your name at the end of your post with four tildes ~~~~ as this will produce your name and the date-time. When you have come up with an acceptable and neutral proposal, please inform us. 4077:? Everyone should be treated equally, and I'm sure that if you searched in the .mk domains for "Macedonian Slavs" and then for "Macedonians", the overwhelming majority of results would be for "Macedonians". 1403:
Hello everyone, I think that you all should know that there has been "movement" on the Greek Knowledge. I was there editing a few articles and I stumbled onto some rather interesting discussions. Apparently
4414:
Check all my comments on FlavSavr's talk page and then remove the personal attacks from your comment here. Take care. And premature is related to my english level (i'm not a native or an advanced speaker).
3124:
I would like too to see a census about national consiousness in Greece. But untill it is done one we realy cannot estimate a number of people in Greece that proclaim a non-greek identity. (100.000-200.000!
1992:
When REX contacted me, he only asked me to vote on the issue. On the other hand, there are clear contributions of yours at the Greek Knowledge where you are calling the users there against the Macedonians.
12504:
57) The Urgent Congregation of Roman Catholic Church in 1742 issued an report which states that "Serbs of Greek Rite" are peopling Croatia,Slavonia,Hungary,Serbia,Thrace,Macedonia,Albania and Montenegro.
11161:
between modern and ancient Macedonians. We shouldn't attempt to resolve general real world problems, nor to discover what are their "true" origins - mostly we are here to discuss what is to be included in
6353:
with the Norwegians). Also, you cannot inherit genes. Your genes are formed from DNA which is half from your mother and half from your father, and different circumstances make them express themselves (see
2511:
page. To pick up the term that you are looking for. And, Yes, Slavic is an adjective, but putted together it seems that the name of the language is "Slavic Macedonian Language". And, as you can see on the
1107:
In the Macedonia issue, it is clear that is not the case. The same people were under the Turks for 5 centuries, but did not become muslim (having on mind that the Ottoman empire was proclaiming the islam).
6358:). In other words, when you say you have your father's eyes; that is inaccurate. Your eye colour is controlled by a group of genes, which are cut-and-pasted randomly from all your ancestors (according to 4640:. Is it the naming dispute? Is it the number of Macedonians in various countries? Is it a certain point in their history? Unless we specify that we would always get stuck in general forum-like discussion 3728: 555:
All the articles concerning Macedonia are full of anti-Macedonian propaganda. And I am sure that this happens in several other occasions. Outnumbering your opponents is always the most succesful method.
308:
because Greek and Bulgarian users will object it. We should all reach a clear point as concensus, but that can not be based on denials and propaganda as the one present at the locked version of the page.
11018:. There are no traces of cultural assimilation that would Support Slavic Macedonian claims, not a single one. Why would you ask from us to show sympathy for something as scientifically ludicrous? Modern 8636:
In deference to Greece, which has an area traditionally known as Macedonia, the country adopted as its formal title The Former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia and normalized relations with Greece in 1995.
6953:
In deference to Greece, which has an area traditionally known as Macedonia, the country adopted as its formal title The Former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia and normalized relations with Greece in 1995.
1417: 607:
Just a reminder that the last pull was drawn. So, neighter side won. And, anyone who check the results of the poll can see that 90% of the users that voted for the "Macedonian Slavs" option are of Greek
10036:
colonists). I'm not interested in debating your position at this particular moment, but I am going to continue with your (unintentional) misrepresentations. You seem to be "hung up" on the concept that
7772:
Greek that wouldn't be so evil to admit it, but strangely I haven't met anybody yet, nor know anyone that has. Unless of course you believe that they're all as evil as your grandparents described them.
7109:
that, and I believe that is a relevant info to add - as we are actually talking about them. That is not to say that there are actually 150,000 Macedonians in Albania, only that the Macedonian community
2918:
Also, I have to say that our history books dedicate very little time to these area of the history. Out national Macedonian feeling can not be lost just because someone else says that we are Bulgarians.
10715:; south of that, the evidence leads scholars to include the region of Macedonia in the sphere of Hellenization. By the way, I know of no proof (though such proof may exist and I may be mistaken) that 2395:
We can not specify those pages, because there is no "Macedonian Slavs" in the world. The term "Macedonians" is used by more than 95% of the relevant sources around the world for discribing this group.
10903:
The purpose of the second sentence is clear - creating a special relationship between the Macedonians and Bulgarians. I'll give a similar example, just to illustrate how shallow the sentence sounds:
2684:
Maybe now most of the teritory of that Greece is in Greece, but it is a fact that some 100 years ago that teritory was populated mostly by Slavic people (no matter were they Bulgarian or Macedonian).
13199:
pg 18 The Greek government's denial of the existence of the Macedonian minority violates international human rights agreements to which the government of Greece is a party.
11955:
Who are the four macedonians on top? Does wikipedia have articles about them? If they are notable to represent all macedonians, articles must be. I would suggest to describe them in the image page.
8502:" can be included, but it most be noted that the Greeks use "Macedonian" as a regional identifier, as well to add the fact that it is unknown whether the Ancient Macedonians were Greeks, or not. -- 7745:
Secondly, Im sorry if you got the impression that I was an opressed ethnic Macedonian in Greece, but I do consider myself a Macedonian with many relatives who are "opressed" Macedonians in Greece.
7337:
I would really like to understand how Bomac and other editors from RoM see it (for the time being I try to). From past discussions one would guess that Slavic speaking is ok. One week before Bomac
6981:
Rainbow Party (Ουράνιο Τόξο) tried the elections, and that's a proof of free expression at Greece. The numbers of the "Macedonian Slavs" in Greece have been discussed before, however I must remind
2716:
I support Miskin in this case. The differences between Ancient Macedonians and the modern ethnic group must be quite clear in order to avoid confusion if we want the article to remain where it is.
114: 7293:
to resolve any ambiguities. The reader should know who he/she is reading about at the start, not start by thinking he is reading about the Greeks and the sees Slavs and thinks "Oops, wrong page".
7031:
which would start with the speculated numbers of Macedonians there, which would be followed with a brief explanation on the human rights issues regarding Macedonians in that particular country. --
780:
I would be glad to join you in the creating a proper form of the article. But, I am not planning to accept any kind of assimilative or denial attempts towards me, my culture, history and language.
656:
Are you trying to present the press as minorities? Maybe you respect the press, but you clearly do not respect the minorities in Greece (whether they are Albanian, Macedonian, Turkish, Roma etc.).
11742:
ruler. I really don't know why do you think that the Byzantine empire was Greek empire. Pavlos Melas was certainly not a Slav, even more a Macedonian (caus' he was anti-Slav), but he was simply,
10968:
place all over the world. Only in exception events has population replacement taken place as with Central Asia and the Turkic-Mongols and of course much of the Americas by European colonization.
12177:
Novakovich,S. "Srbi i Turci XIV i XV veka , 1893,pp.184, Mikloshich ,F. "S.Joannis Chrystostomi homilia in ramos palmarum", 1845, pp.71 Mikloshich,F. "Chrestomatia Paleoslovenica", 1861, pp 41
10589:"), the Macedonians had been fully Hellenized well into the Hellenistic age (assuming that they were ones a non-Greek people). Furthermore, I think it's irrational to try and determine a modern 6727:--It is pseudoscience to speak of "their ancestry", so my revision changed an erroneous generalization to a consideration of the ancestry of a random individual Macedonian (ethnic group) member: 8935:
Then, I shall give you my suggestion: don't edit this article anymore. Is it enough for you not to edit this article if I say that you are always right (and the Greek history science)? Cheers,
8825:
Slavic name of Florina? yes. So what more perfect examples of Hellenizing Greek Macedonia are there? Although you refused the name Atanasoski, I found a real name from the same HRW publication:
1368:
is ridiculous, that is science fiction. Many of the older population of the Republic of Macedonia says that they were talking Macedonian and were declaring as Macedonians before 20-th century.
304:
natives since the 6th century. Anyway, their ethnicity was first mentioned in the 15th century, aldough those people were parts and even leaders of some medieval states and religious movements.
269:
The poor assimilative minority rights in Bulgaria and especially in Greece is fact supported by any relevant human rigths organization in the world, even by the European Court for Human rights.
12881:
that there's a "Russian Front" in WWII? Or the Russian missiles? In fact they were Soviet (14 more republics apart from Russia). But the people uneasily give up their old names. Clear enough?
12166:
7) The place of 1371 battle at Marica,when Kings Vukashin and Ugljesha, leading armies from their provinces in Old Serbia ,clashed with the Turks, was named "Sirf-Sindughi"-"Serbian defeat".
11459:
Here are numerous quotes which not only establish a Macedonian nation, but also distinguish these Macedonians as different people to the Bulgarians and Greeks. These were taken from the book “
11012:
And the claims of Greekness can't really be given 100% credence simply due to the Macedonian language being Slavic, but doesn't rule out cultural assimilation as took place all over the world.
8365:
been discussed? I was very amused reading it, it sounds like a very elaborate joke played on the Greeks. I really love the graphics, too. Needless to say, the paper turned out to be worthless
4081:. In English, these people are more commonly known as Macedonians (how else whould you explain the fact that the vast majority of encyclopaedias and sources refer to them in this way). Again, 3030:
Ofcourse there is a nation now that call itself "Macedonian". Wheather or not it is the right name for it, that nation had been formed, and exists. I guess you didn't understand what I wrote.
12407:
41) Peter Heylin,English geographer writes under the word "Servia": Principal towns hereof : 1.Nissa 2.Vidina (by the Turks called Kiratow) 3.Cratova........9.Scopi,by Ptolemy called Scupi.
6515:
Izahar is just stating the obvious here. What's sad with wikipedia is that the chauvinist editors who are caught red-handed semi-vandalising articles, is something that just goes unpunished.
1780:
hasn't it. Here's your chance. Give me one GOOD reason why what you are saying is correct (anything, just don't say look at you previous contribs). I searched your previous contribs, there's
12849:
2. They were swallowed by the more advanced and sophisticated Greek culture, adopting it, thus becoming the real Greeks in a very short period of time, during Philip's and Alexander's rule.
2889:
It's true that you can use alot of slavic in Florina. But estimations of 100.000-200.000 speakers sound redicilus to anyone living in Greece and having a personal experience from Makedonia.
1468:
If the Macedonian users and the administrators on the English Knowledge could hear what MATIA is saying about them (on the Greek WP, where he unloads his grievences), their ears would burn.
6091: 474:
About 2 million people are a part of the modern Macedonian nation. Also, 90% of the world sources identify us with this term, including most of the relevant institutions and encyclopedias.
8595:
times so far, I will do it one last time for the sake of good will. You must finally realize that you don't own that article, and you don't have the right to be saying whatever you want.
6928:
Of course there are Slavophones in Greece who recognize themselves as "Macedonian Slavs". They also vote every four years in the elections of their own political party (all five of them).
4782:
Could you imagine what was happening to my ancestors, a village people occupied by the harsh Ottoman rule and denied by propaganda from 3 sides, all of whom wanted the Macedonian teritory.
2859:
No wonder the Macedonians in Greece supported the communist party during the civil war there. They were the only power in Greece in the last 100 years who was recognizing their existance.
10155:
around the poor Macedonian Slavs". That the most irrational logic I've ever heard. In a carricature, it's like saying "we shouldn't be kicking around the poor nazis for claiming to be an
9035:
or whatever the last name was (well, more people could live with that then the other options). I'd reccommend you move it back, as it may start up another move war here. Also, PLEASE use
7803:
Miskin, your claims are becoming unbelieveable. You are going to fascinate every single scientist with your propy-thesis. Ah, till where can the human brain go and be manipulated! Sadly!
5990: 2071:
is his answer to the realistic poor (or even non-existant) human rights of the minorities in Greece, including the Macedonian minority. There is no human rights organization that support
1707:
tell us what the Greek Knowledge says about the modern Macedonians? I would really like some of the administrators to see what kind of POV push and national-shovinism is happening there.
986:
in the cathegory of "The fasted formation of a self-aware nation"? If you deny and assimilate us, you can at least do this for us, so there can be at least one proof that we ever existed.
13234:
harassment by the Greek public and authorities has caused a substantial percentage of Greece's ethnic Macedonian identifying minority to be reluctant to publicly identify itself as such
10821:
to have their way with the article, they would probably state that Macedonian Slavs are the actual reincarnation of the ancient Macedonians. Have a look at the vandalism that goes on in
5772: 13307:, please stop adding "unrelated" to the disambig header; it is just going to annoy some of our editors and readers can figure out what disambiguation pages are used for by themselves. 12342:
31) Archbishop of Ohrid Avram in 1634 arrived in Russia with escort.When asked,they said they were Greeks from the Serbian land of Ohrid (Grechane Serpskie zemli iz Ahridona Goroda) .
4282:
Yes, it was a matter of policy for me as well, not being a member of any of the ethnicities involved or even residing anywhere near the countries involved. By the way, I don't know why
2739:
Also, this is only acceptable if the difference between the modern Greeks and the Antique Macedonians is as clear as the one between the modern Macedonians and the Antique Macedonians.
1421: 10215:
as an ethnic group, claimed they spoke the same language as Dacians, and claimed direct descent; and to make it better, if they currently lived north of most of the territory known as
6566:
Phoenician genes/DNA probably survived among the Maltese because of the relative genetic isolation on the island. Phoenician genes are barely found among the modern populations of the
3839:
easily backed with sources, and do not require complex interpretations. So is anybody, except Macedonian and REX (who have stated their support before), interested in this approach? --
3356:
Too old and tired to opose sources and acts? Even i you are 20 yearl old hiper active kid, it will be very diicult or you because o one simple act... you are missing relevant sources.
1425: 8628:
The term "Macedonians" is already in use by the Greeks to refer to the Greek population that has historically inhabited the northern-most region of the Greek peninsula, also known as
4611:
Damn. This offends me, but I give you a complete support on this matter. No wonder many people reffer to this area as the asshole of the world. We completely deserve that "nickname".
3511:- regarded the Macedonians as non-Greek barbarians. On the other hand Macedonian kings regarded themselves as Greek. All inscriptions in ancient tombs and relics are in Greek related 12597:
punishment. Serbian priests were maltreated; permission was refused to open Serbian schools and those that were already in existence were closed; Serbian monasteries were destroyed.
2480:. Just don't go about talking about NPOV and human rights (not you, I mean Sterbinski, what the hell does this have to do with anything) and avoid to recognize that there are simply 1273:
before writing here. What was called Macedonia was changing troughout history. Not to mention the argument that ancient Macedonians were not Greek, but that is not very important. --
1066:
An ethnicity/nation can not be formed overnight. Maybe that is only your wish, so you can support your nationalist POV. But, in reality it is clear that can not happen just because.
10028:(the distinction I made above was between later citizens of the Roman Empire, who could be simply Romanized indigenous peoples who were Romanized by the colonists; vis-a-vis direct 9079:
is more specific, disambiguates and doesn't cross over into the whole tension of regional identities in the area (Macedonian Greeks, Macedonian Bulgarians). Try moving the article
8634:" This only describes what the Greeks think now and thought back then, when they regarded that Slavic population as Bulgarian. I'm sourcing everything I just said from Britannica: " 6734:, and in absence of references neither my version nor the previous version (which was both pseudo-scientific and unsourced) is acceptable. What annoyed me here extremely is the way 5505: 4379:
is rejecting the idea of mediation for the reason that he is too mighty for something like that speaking on equal terms to an underage Albanian like myself is a horrifying prospect.
11937:
Second - Basil II was called Bulgar-Slayer caus' he was from that-time Byzantinum thema Macedonia. If he was called Macedon-Slayer, he would have been a slayer for his own people.
2522:
Also, "Macedonians (Slavic)" is completely wrong, hence the modern Macedonians have origin from several other ethnicities that lived in the region through the history. Same as any
12525:
60) Catholic Archbishop of Skoplje Matija Masarek, an Albanian, reported that the city as inhabited with "Grece, scismatici Serviani, Ebrei et Armeni" in a report written c.1770.
9418:- The official UN name is FYROM, and the name of the ethnic group is generally disambiguated as "Macedonian Slavic", even in Britannica articles. This article should move back to 8728:
of the term "Macedonian" that FYROM politicians try to achieve, and it's the same type of monopoly you're trying to pass in wikipedia. For crying out loud, you don't even want to
8031:
world, Paionia was nothing but a barbaric tribe, definitely not Macedonian. In 334 BC Northern India was also part of Alexander's Empire too. But it wasn't Macedonia... So sorry.
6000: 5228:
Ethnic-Macedonians hides the real naming of these people and gives an impresion of re-naming. The parenteses "()" clearly show that Knowledge is not trying to rename these people.
4536:
We all have things to do in our private lives, don't we? As you can see, I am posting my edits at the middle of the night. If you want something, you will find a way how to do it.
1238:
I have to agree with Bomac. Or this is written by some 10 year old kid who just started learning history, or by a blind nationalist. In both cases, not good enought for Knowledge.
10400:. You had the faintest clue what you were talking about, and yet you attempted to pontificate. I already knew all that stuff I discussed, I provided the links for others to read. 10090:. Nothing really wrong with that until it becomes ingrained national mythology, and we know what national mythology can lead to. As far as the name of the article goes, I prefer 7690:
I don't see how that gives you the right to pretend that you're an opressed ethnic Macedonian Slav from Greece like you implied earlier. There used to be ethnic Greeks living in
6100: 8733:
ancient Macedonian ethnicity ends in the 4th century BD. Macedonians have been ethnic Greek ever since, despite their prior cutlrure, so deal with it and go on with your life.
8700:
So if you have a problem with this, don't tell me and don't go changing the article, tell the Human Rights Watch what ever you want and tell them to change their article first.
7114:
that the number of Macedonians is much higher. In the absence of credible official data from the Albanian government, I don't see a particular reason why we shouldn't put their
6958:
Shame on those dirty Greeks, poking their noses on every public paper. Wouldn't you like to burn them all one day? You know just like this one German guy tried to do with Jews.
6738:
focused on my edits, but ignored the blatant and more extreme (IMO) pseudoscience in the previous version. I suppose the use of the terms "gene" and "genetic" got him riled up.
631:
For all the racist hate speech and allegations of heinous human rights abuses directed against Greece by various contributors to this talk page, the reality is rather ruthless.
9239:
Although this might be much ado about nothing. The distinctions are somewhat slim, but I think Macedonian people works just fine. Also, consistency at wikipedia would be good.
2108:
would use any method he can to turn the attention away from the issue and keep hidding all the sceletons in the closets, when concerning the issue between Macedonia and Greece.
12846:
1. the Ancient Macedonians were half-barbaric people very close to the Ancient Greeks (like Russians and Poles or Ukrainians, for instance), belonging to the Hellenic family
10702:, Macedon and Paeonia (FYROM) were well into those Hellenized territories. It's delusional to be speaking of a Latinization. Either that or you're just scared to say "Greek". 6808:
is right to say that the ethnic origins shouldn't have a detailed description in the opening paragraph. Also, I am a bit worried that nobody seem to care about the claim that
6286:
Maybe by using genetic terminology (which is not pseudoscience), you guys can finally realize what the previous claims implied. They weren't talking about spiritual ancestry.
6110:
Will you please stop playing with words and cite some sources. Trying to find a balance between POVs is not going to help - find reliable sources, forget your agendas PLEASE.
2473: 12928:
Copying and summarizing info from this, same, page (section: The situation today), I added the following sentence in the section Major Populations of Macedonians by country:
10698:
There was never a "Romanization" in that part of the Empire. In fact during Roman occupation Hellenization in the East continued at the same rate as before. According to the
2334:
If the sockpuppetry is a rather immature practice, why you keep using it? Why you keep using all the dishonest methids, just to take the attention away from the real issues?
12616:"Licno ime Srbin u krajevima danasnje BJRM ("male name Srbin in the areas of todays FYROM") ",pp.41-44 in: Jovan F. Trifunoski "Makedoniziranje Juzne Srbije", Beograd, 1995 2680:
Of course I will revert that kind of edits. All you want to do with this edits is to erase any possible connection bewteen the Antient and modern Macedonians (ethnic group).
1800:
etc. Also, about that Biris book, I have read it. Isn't it a hard-back pale green book with a pencil drawing on the cover? If it is, I've read it, nd there's NOTHING there.
7928:
region which Greeks regard as the real Macedonia. Most of FYROM was known in antiquity as Paionia. It was basically the Ottoman administration that expanded it as north as
7149:
I think the two sections are related very much, but I also think that the "Major Populations of Macedonians by country" section is nice and I'm not sure about the merging.
6917:
international, neutral, reliable, non-Macedonian sources that prove there are Macedonians in Greece (although an effective one is a publication from the Human Rights Watch
5159:
Talking about the Macedonian Greeks and Macedonian Bulgarians... that is a pure lie. Non of those people register themselves as something different than Greek or Bulgarian.
3502:
inaccurate as Macedonia is in fact inhabited by a number of different peoples, none of whom has a historically exclusive claim to the term with the exception of the native
2086:
in the country. Theathenae clearly knows that since 2001st, Macedonia has one of the best laws in whole Europe on this issue, providing all the rights to the nationalities.
12180:
9) In 1395 Mihael Paleologos and his wife Helena established estate to Helena's father,Master of Serbia,Konstantin Dejanovich.Konstantin's state was around river Struma.
11896: 11673:. What you quoted ironically proves the opposite of what you and the other nationalists want to believe. That the "Macedonians" prior to the 20th century BC, were not the 11663: 11023:
were already assimilated by the Greeks), therefore I don't even know what you're talking about. MacSlavs are not using cultural assimilation as an argument, they're using
8057:
And mabey you should try out a real history book writen by an American or German instead of pro Greek writers for a change. It will explain more then what Greeks imagine.
5581:== 1944 secretary of state assertion that the yugoslav post ww2 proposal of a "Macedonian " Fatherland, conscience and ethnicity had no political or historical reality == 4001:)? Again, countless reasons have been put forward why they should be called Macedonians and you couldn't give a single reason why they should be called Macedonian Slavs. 2979:
as an idea is a product of 18th and 19th centuries. Taking that into account, one may say that no nation existed before that period, including Greek, German and Chinese.--
9656: 8488:
During the years between World Wars I and II, Greece followed a policy of assimilating the Macedonian minority and Hellenizing the Macedonian region in northern Greece.
6162:
implies, which was a word in the article for months now? Spiritual ancestry? Blood? Ancestry implies genes. I did not introduce genetics, it was introduced when the word
11969: 11894: 11661: 10755: 10739: 9325: 4166: 3930:
applies until you find a goot reason why this case should be treates as an exception. Why should it be an exception, Theathenae? Macedonian Slavs never got 60% support.
1887:
is already resolved and that policy shall be in force until a good reason is found why this case should be treated as an exception. All other disputed areas can be seen
1180:
Anyone who knows even little history should know that noone can be a direct descendant of the Antient Macedonians. Not Macedonians, not Greeks, not Bulgarians... no one.
12792:
Thrace. According Turkish hronist Siljahdar there was riots in Sofia and Plovdiv (before 24.09.1689) and after them many of these rebelions joined to Austrian forces: "
10271:
and spoke a Latin language, and due to some other facts of the time, were thus Romans (if the Hungarians are right and Romanians come from Roman provinces south of the
7786:
in the region? You can keep FYROM, that's not really part of Macedonia anyway, it's the Ottomans who chose to include it as such. Greek Macedonia on the other hand has
7511:
additions sometimes really annoy me, I can't see nothing particularly wrong with the current version of the disambiguation. Of course, a more accurate version would be
3627: 12796:". Karposh was mortolosbashi (chief of christian auxiliary forces) in the region between Sofia and Kjustendil (Kjustendil, Sirishtnik and Radomir) in present Bulgaria. 12457:
49) In 1685 Catholic Archbishop of Skoplje Petar Bogdani wrote to Cardinal Cibo saying that Turks had thrown him into exile from entire Serbia (da tutta la Servia) .
11902:
That's no news to me. The point is that he was a Greek "national", so were his descendants who were also crowned as "Macedonian". What's most important is that he was
10574:
Aldux, the ancient Macedonians are an indigenious population. You have a source (Kanchov, Weigand), that claim that it is possible that they have mixed with the Slavs.
9684: 7973:, but mabey this information corresponds better with your intelligence and preferences, mabey I should have put this instead of that "trash" I presented to you above: 5923: 5913: 5244: 5141: 13090:
It should be noted that language and ethnicity are not coterminous, and only a small minority of Slav-speakers in Greece proclaim a (non-Greek) "Macedonian" identity
9527: 8875:? Change it back the way it was on your own. You have still to prove that Lerin was in official use over Florina. All official records I have refer to the villaet of 5861: 5647:
for you to educate yourself. Maybe it will come as a shock for you, but there are sources confirming existance of a Macedonian ethnicity far before the 20th century.
5474:
They can, they are just choosing not to. That way they pretend that Greece is an ethnically homogenous society with no ethnic minorities, only one minority of Muslim
5429:
Not only the EU and UN are sources that call the Macedonians under their natural and historical name. 90% of the reliable sources in the world do this. I repeat, 90%.
1292:
I can't really understand why the page was locked after the article was in an altogether satisfavctory shape after the edits if REX??? ] 22:12, 29 October 2005 (UTC)
11489: 9675: 8773:
group. Where were those "Macedonian Slavs" of yours when Bulgaria, Greece and Serbia were fighting the Ottoman Empire and dividing your land?? Please answer me that.
8484:
The government changed place names and personal names from Macedonian to Greek, ordered religious services to be performed in Greek, and altered religious icons.
6045:. Otherwise, WP will give more prominence to the idea that the Slavs mixed with Greeks, not ancient Macedonians (who would no longer be ancient in Byzantine times). 5880: 3582: 10858:
do. You ask me to demostrate how the Slavs are more biased than the Greeks. What do you think of the following facts (which I can source individually if demanded):
10706: 10607: 10556:
Bien. I was wondering where have you dissapeared, et voila - here you are with a brand new identity. I knew that your name was Alexander, but I wasn't 100% sure. --
8209:
You don't really know what "sourcing" means, do you? Please don't revert again until you have really done so. In the meantime, I would advise you to have a look at
8081:. Every time unverified information is added, I'll be removing it until it gets verified. Adding back unverified information while it has been questioned, violates 5347:
Do you really think that i I became Macedonian just some 50-100 years ago, I wouldn't know about it? Or maybe that is what they teached you at your primary school?
5017:
also banned to leave his flat. I never have read so much nationalistic ignorance like the one this guy promotes. This is not a personal attack... just my oppinion.
3744: 1966: 13268:
Macedonians are also native inhabitants of Aegean Macedonia (northern Greece), Pirin Macedonia (sowthwestern Bulgaria), as well as the eastern villages of Albania.
12931:"A real and recent number, which can allow readers to estimate an order of magnitude, is the people voting for a slavic macedonian political party in 2004: 6,176 ( 12214:
14) Sometime at the end of 15th century Hungarian historian Bonfini wrote about "Macedonia,which is now called Serbia" ("Macedoniam quam Serbua nunc appelant") .
10551: 10498: 10451: 10404: 10359: 9324:
makes me feel sick. If those neutral sources can call them "Macedonians", then so can Knowledge. If you search Yahoo! for "Macedonian Slavs", you get 11,700 sites
6804:
I do not plan to engage the historical disputes, not until the more tangible disputes are resolved. I've noticed some activities concerning the opening paragraph.
6327: 6304:, then fine. You can say that they are the descendents of these people. Genes are relevant to what they inherited from their ancestors, not their ancestry itself. 5945:
I think you are aware that this was happening. Of course, it was not strong as the Bulgarian and Greek represion against the Macedonians, but it was still reality.
4491:
So you weren't objecting to mediation? I notice that you have cunningly avoided answering my question above. If I were to request mediation, would you support it?
4259:
policy is not a matter for debate or polls; it's one of Knowledge's most fundamental policies. The naming conflict policy is merely NPOV applied to disputed names.
4052:
Seriously, this is not a good support of your position. It actually is one more reason against the term "Macedonians Slavs" beeing used for the moder Macedonians.
3010:
Another thing... why you only talk about the past? You live in a time when the Macedonians are recognized internationaly by any relevant source as separate nation.
648: 11981: 11971: 11681: 10000: 9503: 7376:
I'm beginning to see what Bomac is getting at - he's trying to disambiguate the "RoM Macedonians" from Greeks and Bulgarians based on ethnicity. He is saying the
1984: 12130:
Episcopal Center gives ground to the thesis that it had large Serbian population. Around year 1200 this city is mentioned as Servochoria (Serbian Habitation) .
11945: 10727:. If there were early Romance speakers in the province, no reason to suppose they spoke a Proto-Romanian dialect (Vulgar Latin in the Balkans developed into the 5182: 1930:
even back to 15th century, when actually the ethnicity took more attention by the historians. There are several issues, but we have to work on them, one by one.
1211: 9243: 9225: 8964:
A few issues I have is that the article states "often referred to as Macedonian Slavs". Where? Only on Knowledge by pseudo-Athenian propagandists. Most (if not
8240:
Greeks have officially every right to perform changes in placenames, especially after the Greco-Turkish population exchange of 1922 that repopulated the region.
3843: 3788: 2535: 2408: 1728:
If I'm wikistalking you, how do you explain that I had an account at the Greek wikipedia before you did. Can I see into the future and know that you would too?
1128: 664:]. This is not the first case that Greece loses and it certainly will not be the last one, having on mind that several other similar cases are still on a trial. 12011: 11966: 11891: 11658: 10560: 10519: 9864: 9854: 9827: 9797: 9775: 9749: 9723: 9705: 9695: 9466: 9444: 9426: 9222: 8969: 3062:, what has been published by a reputable publisher shall be used in the article regardless whether Mik (which means "friend" in Arvanitic) believes it or not. 2809:
just redicilous to anyone having even the smalest personal experience with Greece. Anyone interested in seeing why I say that may have a look in my comment in
2283: 1784:. Page moves should be done with consensus, not at the whims of you and Theathenae. A suitable consensus will be found. If you want to learn WP policies, read 11927: 10473: 10426: 10377: 10340: 10253: 10231: 10141: 10106: 9976: 9958: 9484: 9091: 8400:. Obviously someone tried to pass it as some sort of factual evidence that needs to be added in the article, and obviously he was made a fool out of himself. 6663: 5937: 5162:
Should I remind you that just some 20 years ago the term "Macedonian" was completely forbiten to be used in Greece? People were sent to jainl because of that.
4709:
You suggested on my talk page that I could supervise a step-by-step discussion of the issues. I think that's a useful idea - Ed Poor did something similar on
13001: 12586:
70) On the basis of the Priviligies by Rudolph II many thousands Serbian familes emigrated from Bosnia and Macedonia under the Dukes Vukovich and Pjasonich.
11201: 11190: 10944: 9915:, but this is for the sake of expedience) in a sizable part from such citizens, as well as (no historian that I know of challenges this) in part from direct 9571: 9261: 5395:
blocked - I have seen it happen. Ther title must contain the name "Macedonians" acording to Knowledge policy as I have already explained to you. Please find
4786:
nationalistic propaganda more than 50 years ago and left it behind, in the past. The truth about their propaganda came out, but that also stayed in the past.
2343: 2272: 2201: 2131: 1096: 756:
Article is locked, and I reverted way back to 14 October: not because I like that version, but because it's just a random version before the latest edit war.
703: 686: 677: 618: 239:
are forming the Macedonian nation. Any relevant factor or source in the world reffers to them as Macedonians, except very few others that use another names.
12601:
Slavs are considered to be Bulgars, which is quite incorrect. On the contrary, the Slavs in Macedonia are incapable of understanding a Bulgar from Jantra.
12263:"Rumeli und Bosna,Geographisch beschrieben von Mustapha Ben Abdalaih Hadschi Chalfa aus dem turkischen ubersetzt von J. von Hammer" Wien 1812 pp.80; pp.97 11990: 11144: 11116: 10972: 10326: 10127: 9608: 9599: 6752:
I made some new edits and added the "fact" template after two different sentences. I don't expect these edits to be unchallenged, but they seem reasonable.
6627: 6614: 6574: 6561: 6470: 6439: 6424: 6315: 6170: 6131: 6083: 5967: 4671: 4552: 4476:
I was trying to use the same characterization that someone (Zocky? I don't remember if it was this or another admin) had used for the big (June-July) poll.
3860: 3815: 13055: 12903:
happy? In Greece, they were happy, but not that much. The language of the Christian liberators was different, and it promised many problems in the future.
11569: 11448: 10736: 10548: 10495: 10448: 10401: 10356: 10323: 10228: 10124: 10103: 9955: 9851: 9824: 9772: 9720: 9692: 9605: 9596: 9524: 9371: 9355: 9109: 9088: 7144: 6805: 6771: 6753: 6739: 6660: 6624: 6589: 6571: 6558: 6467: 6436: 6421: 6324: 6287: 6278: 6167: 6141:
in an attempt to "compromise". Suddenly genetics came onto the scene - why? If it's true, OK. You must have some sources; quote then and leave it at that.
6128: 6080: 6046: 5744: 5713: 5703: 5285: 5099: 4443: 4340: 4296: 4061: 3673: 3487: 2868: 2613: 2590: 2551: 2493: 2382: 2078:
Republic of Macedonia, the country where I live in, has an open field for nationality where you can put ANYTHING you want. In the last census we even had "
2006: 1716: 1241:
I identify myself (nationaly, ethnicaly, regionaly and in every other possible way) as Macedonian. You and your lies inside your posts can not change that.
1093: 913:
3) Do you really think that one day we decided to gather and decide about our name? Do you think we choose the name over night? How ridiculous this sounds?
12989: 12099:
distinct Macedonian people. As for Stefan Dusan's title there's something wrong here: I know for certain (via Ostrogorsky) that his diplomatic title was "
11219: 10799: 9882: 8413:, it would have been Sterbinski (or his team) :o)) I actually think this is quite good, possibly even better than the Albano-Phoenician inscription hoax. 7533: 7524:
I was really trying not to point out that the article name looks to me like Macedonians Macedonians, but I couldn't help it when I read your last phrase.
7158: 6886: 6872: 6847: 5309: 5221: 3767: 3552:. And, BTW, this text is a try to make difference between the modern Macedonians and the Antique Macedonians, a try that turned into a serious POV pusher. 2782:
There is an old Greek proverb which says: "όποιος μπλέκεται με τα άχυρα τον τρώνε οι κότες". In other words, "keep out of things that don't concern you".
1021: 787: 215: 7135: 5982: 4981: 4798: 4762: 4748: 4299: 3656:). This is a thing that has to be a part of the text. It is enought of the anti-Macedonians nationalistic claims that Tito was the one who "invented" us. 3572: 3144:
I'm afraid that Greeks afraid to do that. They are scared about it because they want their country to be ethnically clear, which is impossible nowadays.
2705: 2496: 2430: 12967: 12085:
My point is that it is not as simple as Bulgarians like to be. Macedonians are product of various mixes, having been periphery of different countries.--
11032: 10351:
For myself? Sure buddie. I don't want to make a personal attack, but on many, many points you barely knew what you were talking about; and yes, you got
10306:
basic facts for someone seeking to pontificate in this field (to quote: "Romanians, even they though they aren't really of Roman ancestry", interesting
9112: 8426: 5656: 4945: 4724: 4620: 3643: 2883::) Actualy I have traveled to Florina more than 50 times and I have spent there more than two years of my life. That's because I am partialy from there. 2385: 1956: 1390: 1254: 1070: 1049: 11050: 10847: 10829: 10682: 10655: 10628: 10185: 10163: 10015: 7519: 7481: 7394: 7122: 7088: 6392: 6127:
It is possible... Many historians... Yes. Rather vague. Go ahead and find some references. Or better yet Izehar, why don't you rewrite the damn thing.
6069: 6065:
There is a confusing conflation of language groups, self-identification, descent and political boundaries going on in this constellation of articles.
5690:
In my oppinion, this paragraph was set up here only for spreading anti-Macedonian ideas. Actually, the paragraph did not include anything that was not
4834: 4386: 4309:: if we analyse all the comments on the poll, the renaming of this page (I've mentioned before that I don't know which name should be used, please see 4005:
applies until a good reason is found why this case should be treated as an exception. That policy/guideline applies until a clear consensus is formed.
3712:
make a proposal on where it should be and justify it with sources etc... Who knows, it may even be accepted. Any thoughts you have, please bring them.
3365: 3205: 3129: 3107: 3023: 2944: 1173: 13155: 13134: 12956: 9650: 7502: 7455: 7367: 5570: 5539: 5412: 5326: 5026: 4873: 4155: 4014: 3980: 3943: 3094:
once for all times. Instead of living like brothers, we keep frustrating each other and fear each other. Not a good thing and I am sure you know that.
2748: 2569: 2327: 2256: 2164: 2154: 1939: 1832: 1572: 13333: 13319: 12107: 12059: 11868: 11380: 11341: 8803: 8584: 7410: 6975: 6533: 6266: 6049: 6029: 4918: 4529: 2837: 2048: 1920: 982:
If you decide that the Macedonian nation was formed overnight, by Tito, I would like to ask you only one thing... Can you please nominate us for the
626: 13171: 13072: 12756: 11783: 11754: 11725: 11692: 11261: 8939: 8926: 8908: 8287: 8140: 8131: 7959: 7807: 7442: 7427: 7315: 7225: 5082: 4964: 4852: 4604: 4589: 4500: 4466: 4098: 4024:
REX can you explain why the Macedonian Slav (sic) politicians and the Macedonian Slav (sic) historians (search with google the .mk domain) use that
3699: 3604:
Somewhere in the body of the article, we should explain WHY some people do or do accept the idea that modern and ancient "Macedonians" are related:
3451: 2519:
You can not change the names of the articles just because you do not like it. There is a world outside your own dorm, a world which also has rights.
2454: 1771: 1696: 1675: 12782:
How many people represent OMO-Ilinden if we accept that it represents all of those who declared them as Macedonians in Bulgaria in the last census?
12089: 11959: 9515:
is the choice in this situation. It's very specific, and it is the least problematic solution for Knowledge. It's simply not the same situation as
9062: 9049: 5934: 5739: 5682: 4454:
It's not really a personal attack, it's an inference that you no longer support the idea of mediation (if you ever did support it). OK, new start;
3721: 765: 10922:
who might claim that other peoples have split off from a parent group (and are thus not a "legitimate" people in their own right) almost endless?
10494:
to take it to personal attacks (I don't prefer to engage in personal attacks and such), but it was extremely difficult not to. Have a peachy day.
8624:
Ethnic Greeks and other ethnic groups residing in Greek Macedonia also refer to themselves as Macedonians but mostly in a strictly regional sense.
7622: 6290: 6281: 5379: 4682: 4456:
imagine that I am going to request mediation tomorrow, would you support it, or would you oppose it like Miskin, Theathenae and Chronographos did?
4273: 3993:: more sources call these people Macedonians than Macedonian Slavs and Macedonian Slavs is offensive. Or does the offensive become policy only in 3148: 2791: 13245: 13189: 13111: 12772: 12476:
52) Austrian Emperor Leopold proclaimed Jovan Monastirlija from Bitolj a Vojvoda (Military chieftain) of the Serbian nation in Austria in 1691.
12348:
32) Addressing the Russian Emperor Mihail in 1641, Mitropolit of Skoplje said that he is from Serbian land (Serbskie zemli Semion mitropolit) .
10912: 10881:
their misfortunes. I think that this is fairly blatant by the edits of most MacSlav editors here (Flavrsavr excluded). Afew days ago somebody in
8799:" - I've been saying it all along, it's you who never cared to understand what my argument was about and preferred to blindly revert me instead. 8265:
Prove that such a national minority has pre-existed prior to the Balkan Wars, in order to justify your criticism on the Greek government as NPOV.
5489: 5467: 5387: 5383: 3325: 3280: 3038: 2983: 2900: 2630: 1659: 12914:
That's my point - trying to be as objective as possible, being the Serbian citizen from Macedonian, Bulgarian, Serbian and Aromanian origin....
8763:). It doesn't prove nor imply the existence of a separate "Macedonian Slavic" nation. I've seen POV-pushing which tried to present the medieval 6221: 6059: 3601:
Say, rather, that Group A claims to see a relationship and that Group B denies the existence of such a relationship. That's good for the intro.
3409: 3347: 3239: 1036:
The identity which is strongly disputed as regards pre-1944 history. As regards quick "nation-forming", you can look at a similar example - the
853: 13237: 13221: 13181: 13147: 13103: 13069: 13040: 12986: 12915: 12671: 12030: 11169: 10788: 8972: 8695:
all this time you were denying the use of the term "Macedonian" in my examples? The source I gave that was from the Human Rights Watch states:
8044:
Exactly! Barbaric! Just like how all ancient Greeks regarded all Anceient Macedonians including Alexander the Great! Like non-Greek Barbarians!
6012: 5997: 5979: 4169: 4089:. I have said, that as far as I am concerned, those guidelines apply until you find a good reason for this case to be treated as an exception. 1757: 1359: 1104:
I don't think it can happen over night. If they accepted the Russian (so called) propaganda, it clearly means that they did not oppose it much.
670:
Also, there are 100s of links concerning the poor human rights of the minorities that live in Greece. Check google and pick any link you want:.
12630:
Dozon,A. "L' Europee Serbe, chants popularies heroiques (Serbie, Bosnie et Herzegovine, Croatie, Dalmatie, Montenegro", Paris, 1888, pp.15-16
9404: 8883:, so in order to be fair, we have to point out that MacSlavs or Bulgarians (your call) changed Greek toponyms into Slavic. What do you think? 7073: 7035: 2305: 2238: 1809: 1614: 1277: 1231: 13058: 12413:
42) In 1666 Mitropolit Ananije of Cratovo wrote to Russian Emperor, mentioning "Mihailo,Mitropolit of Serbs" (Mihaila Mitropolita Srbian) .
11995:
Most of the people on the pictures' nationalities are disputed, while some have explicitly emphasized on their Bulgarian origin, such as the
10116: 9586: 9459: 9441: 8951: 8465: 7463: 7386: 7294: 7279: 7196: 7003: 6735: 6592: 6530: 6501: 6451: 6400: 6368: 6306: 6207: 6190: 6143: 6112: 6015: 5928: 4961: 4759: 4732: 4721: 4586: 4270: 3969: 3484: 3471: 599: 10897: 9327:, whereas if you search for "Macedonians", but exclude the words: Greece, Greek, Bulgaria, Bulgarian Ancient and Alexander, you get 225,000 9058:
The words "ethnic group" and "people" are the same thing... Also, "Macedonians" = "Macedonian people". I don't seee what the big deal is. --
9025: 8792:
at the time. You brought up sources on the fact that changes in toponyms did take place, something which I never removed in the first place.
1737: 1119:
until 1945th. Why the Macedonians joined his forces against the Bulgarians, if they were Bulgarians? Sorry, but it does not have any sence.
12487:
Eparchy (of the) Krachevite city Serb Dmitrei Petrov": "Serbskie zemli Arhidonskija Eparhi Krachevskogo goroda Serbjanin Dmitrei Petrov".
11257:
But MELAS said so. It's not my problem he did that. Unbelievable - territorial-claims by editing the article? Miskin, don't make me laugh.
10291:, older identifications having vanished; nor does the ethnonym involve a claim of Italic descent, any more than Greeks calling themselves " 7829: 7657: 7020: 6962: 6946: 6932: 6910: 6519: 6510: 6460: 6409: 6377: 5248: 5145: 1532: 7795: 5852: 4434:
Matia, it is a fact that all of the Greek side refused mediation. Whatever the reason, that is not a constructive way to solve a dispute.
3000:
actually use the word "Makedonski", which is the only refference to this term on our Macedonian language. There is no other name for this.
1873:
So, do you agree with this approach? (note: I'm in a busy period, I might not be able to discuss thouroughly until the end of the week) --
1372: 1302: 923:
quite poor and our only hope is EU and NATO. How come we risk our only hope because of some identity, if that identity is not all we have?
13275: 12567:
they inhabit Bosnia, Herzegovina, Old Macedonia.Montenegrins and Dalmatians, although not subjected by the Turks, are of Serbian tribe"
12299:
27) A part of Matija Masarek's report based on a visit throughout the Serbian dioceze in 1623-1624 ,reflecting the ethnicity of Kratovo.
12154:
5) Despot Ugljesha in the 1366 letter written and confirmed in Skoplje stated that he is the master of Serbian land,Greece and Pomorje.
11795:"Wake up and smell the roses Tanevski, all those medieval and pre-20th century references to "Macedonians" are actually referring to the 11175:
I apologize for diverging from the main topic of your original thread here, Flave. My comments, as you can see, were not really meant to
7052:, regardless whether is true or not - Knowledge is not here to determine the "objective truth" - it is here to describe the disputes the 5843: 5264: 5165:
The "Macedonian Greeks" and "Macedonian Bulgarians" appeared in last few years, just in order to deffent your POV pushing on this issue.
4843:
will be taken into consideration. Naming these people against their will cannot be allowed, and any neutral person can clearly see that.
4172: 4078: 3344: 3182: 3126: 3080: 3035: 2980: 2897: 2846: 2812: 2776: 2670: 2179:
want to hide the final decisions of the European Court for human rights against Greece and in favor of the Macedonian minority in Greece?
1429: 11669:
Wake up and smell the roses Tanevski, all those medieval and pre-20th century references to "Macedonians" are actually referring to the
11439:
part of the section I've been removing, therefore you still don't have a reason to promote your nationalist propaganda and land-claims.
8410: 8351: 8308: 8273: 8251: 8097: 8035: 7941: 7777: 7703: 7666: 5637:
Also, I already said how and why is this motivated... starting from the anti-communist feeling, ending with the great Greek loby in USA.
4689: 2821: 2263:
And I am talking to Pres. Bush now (who happened to be afriend of mine), on ICQ. He promised he will ask CIA to check your claim. :))))
1619:
couldn't help wondering about that. My opinions are already recorded in English Knowledge. It's very interesting that REX escalated his
1160:
are more closely related, in all senses, to the Ancient Britons. That doesn't stop the all people of the UK calling themselves British.
1017:'s happiness. It is about the identity of 2 million people, the only identity they know. Would you dare to try to take it away from us? 577: 13043: 12724:
And again wikipedia feels the need to tell us that Macedonians had not political or national identity until the 20th cenurty...thanks.
12648:
76) "Serbs are in the south of Dalmatia, in the Kingdom of Croatia and Slavonia, at the south of the Kingdom of Hungary,in Macedonia"
12522:"Le Voyager francois, ou la connoissance de l' ancien et du noveau monde mis au jour par M. l' Abbe Delaporte", tome XXIII, Paris,1777 9551: 6832: 6799: 5446: 5364: 1877: 1463: 97: 13298: 13285: 12543:
wenig. Ragusiner, Macedonier, Bosnien sind doch Serben". Jagich, V. "Briefwechsel zwischen Dobrowsky und Kopitar" Berlin, 1885 pp.34
12528:
In 1790 he mentioned in his report that Turks are suspicious of Greeks and Serbs of Skoplje because they have sent letters to Russia.
12470:
51) In 1690 Catholic Bishop of Cotor, Marin Drago,reports that "Skoplje is inhabited with Turks, Serbs of Greek Rite and Catholics",
11443: 11300: 11251: 10782:
In Bulgaria, and to some extent in Greece, the question of whether the Macedonians constitute a distinct ethnic group is controversial
9480:- It can generate confusion between those that have a Macedonian national identity and those that have a Macedonian regional identity 9176: 6137:
It's not my job to write this article, I know nothing about Macedonia - what I do know is that more and more weasel phrases have been
5501:
Should I start with 1000s of reports of any relevant human rights organization that criticised Greece for its treatment of minorities:
4912: 4703: 4652: 2767: 2725: 1609: 1547: 13033: 12367:
35) in 1651 Mitropolit of Kratovo wrote to Russian Emperor "My forefathers and ancestors are lords of the Serbian land of Kratovo".
12160:
6) Patriarch of Constantinople mentioned master of Serbia,Ugljesha in a letter from 1371. Ugljesha's state was around Lower Struma.
11965:
Are you reffering to my post? If so, which "Macedonians on top" are you interested in? I could provide you with some external links.
11417:
mixture, argues that "Macedonian" is the correct term for this language, which the Bulgarians, he says, misleadingly call "Bulgarian"
11325:
some decades earlier. That doesn't mean that they weren't considered Greek territories. They were all conquered territories from the
9767:
Hellenized. The Macedonian identity among them was secondary (probably regional identity), they probably spoke no XMK, and they were
8495:
We can attribute the view to the Helsinki Watch, however, there is absolutely no excuse for deleting the source. Also, the addition "
6789: 6774: 6756: 5644: 5351: 5204:
do you know which call themselves Macedonians. In fact, I prefered Ethnic-Macedonians to be used at all times, but everyone prefered
3912: 3653: 1868: 1859:(not in the real world). I have a proposal - since the naming dispute is more or less resolved on WP, I propose to resolve the other 1472: 1445: 523: 194: 89: 84: 72: 67: 59: 7350: 6216: 6199: 6152: 6121: 4585:
You might as well unprotect it, as there's no realistic prospect of the participants in this dispute agreeing on a compromise... --
4392: 4376: 4369: 846:
Don't say that Knowledge should settle these questions. We can only report what the various major sides SAY about these questions.
12387:
38) Catholic missionaries in Serbia (Servia) are mentioned and among them mr.Stefan Kratovian (In Cratovo d.Stefano da Cratovo) .
11063:
Try to parallell this debate with comparable situations elsewhere. Naturally, I too am aware that this is not just about names and
4485: 4424: 4322: 4114: 4038: 2825: 1152:). The vast majority of people in Britain have in fact Germanic roots, both linguistically and probably via descent. The people of 638: 145: 130: 126: 122: 118: 12663:
Bulgarian Exarchate was registered in the Turkish population records as "bulgari-milet" and to the world as large was a Bulgar".
12327:
30) Archbishop Bianki mentiones an epidemic of plague in Serbia and the newly appeared disease in Skoplje, Janjevo and Novo Brdo.
10711:
According to sources I checked (such as Orbitus Latinus), the Jirecek Line extends into the northernmost parts of what is now the
9585:
How long is this poll going to last - when does it close? The usual is five days, but sometimes they are left running for a week.
8950:
I've unprotected the page - page protection gets in the way of non edit warriors, so the 3RR violators have been blocked instead.
8506: 7561: 7466: 7302: 7287: 7238: 7204: 6742: 6525:
We're not into "punishment" around here and "semi-vandalism" (by which you mean POV editing) isn't something that's caught by the
5046: 4921: 4579: 4310: 4287: 12721:"During the Turkish rule, the Macedonians had little or no political and national identity of their own until the 20th century." 12397:"Chtenija v imperatorskom' obshtesvja istorii i drevnosti Rossiiskih pri Moskovskom univerziteta" Moskva 1896 II 5th part pp.4a 11242:, hence the Greeks admit that they have conquered Macedonian territory". You have to cite Mr X's credible, neutral, and unbiased 8954: 8897: 8391: 7332: 6262:
The line "it is possible... but there is no way at present to verify this" appearing unreferenced in an article is troublesome.
5889:
note for the number of Macedonians in Albania, Bulgaria, and and perhaps for Serbia and Montenegro. This would be done, because:
5825: 3754:
In my opinion, the best thing to do first, would be to review all possible titles and make a list of pros and cons for each one.
1477: 1056:
I aint no looking for anyones pitty. I just express my frustration from the Knowledge's vulnerability to nationalists as you are.
12201:
Kratovo,because Congregational Church in Ohrid did not had that book in Serbian language (po eziku srbskom) but only in Greek.
9589: 9031:
There has been a lot of controversy about the page name here. After a lot of time and discussion people more of less settled on
6649: 5121: 5090:
time. Look at all the support they got from the west on this issue, just in order to keep a good position against the Ottomans.
5008: 4903: 4230: 4216: 3619:
policy recommends against trying to use Knowledge to settle controversies. As encyclopedia contributors, we should be trying to
641:, alongside Belgium and Germany and above such countries as Canada, Britain, France, Australia and the United States of America. 12918: 12674: 12501:
Cornelius,G.V.D. "Historische nachricht von der Rom. Kayser.Gross-Botschaft nacht Konstantinopol" Nurnberg 1723 pp.84; pp.102
12033: 9639: 8887: 8813: 8659:
Macedonians because is already in use by the Greeks to refer to the Greek population that has historically inhabited Macedonia"
8644: 8532: 8468: 8461: 4146:
of the other side wanted to cooperate, it is clear that they do not have how to deffend their possition in front of a cometee.
3343:
people are so eager to make Knowledge unreliable let them do it. It seems so important for them. I am out of these discusions--
1199: 12819: 12745: 12266:
22) Mitropolit Jeremiah from the City of "Pelagon" (Bitolj) went to Russia in 1603 saying that he arrived from Serbian land.
10649: 8404: 7947:
Sorry Macedonia, but your numbers are wrong and are not those ot the Ottoman census; also you should have noted that somebody
7044:. Somebody erased my remark that "Macedonian communities in Albania claim numbers as high as 150,000". What these communities 4917:
This discussion would move a bit forward if claims of affinity ("potential" or otherwise) to Ancient Macedonia are dropped. --
4409: 4293: 4290: 4202: 4184: 4132: 13063: 12768:
decide to look at both angles and decide for themselves instead of force feeding them this bullshit....please and thank you.
12699:
we all know the reason.Why dont you go into detail about the extent of Slavonic settlement in Greece even to the Pelopenese?
10767:
political and historic circumstances, the Macedonians have come to consider themselves a separate people from the Bulgarians.
10443:
Ha ha. Well, most readers will see your incompetence exposed on numerous points, whether you see it or not. You didn't prove
8681:. The Macedonian ethnic group wasn't created in the 1940's, it was officially recognized in the Yugoslav state in the 1940's. 8639: 8543:
Miskin repetedly took out Hellenization, and the examples that I gave. After claiming it was an "unsourced POV" , I added in
7338: 7192: 6728: 5727: 5670: 1888: 1847:
Could anybody please explain me what points of the article are the subject of the dispute, specifically? There's no point in
865:, but I do not think that you realise how deep is this issue. Not just for me, as a Macedonia. For all the region as a whole. 728: 721: 13077: 7741:
and was it not the Greeks who plublished a whole page in the New York Times saying that Macedonia been Greek for 4000 years.
7084:
that he is Albanian, even if a respectable number of Albanians seem to think it. I hope you understand my position. Bye :-)
6271: 1511: 1409: 1351:
The Macedonian question is a clear example why many people use the phrase "the asshole of the whole world" to reffer to the
13220:
With all this you are telling me that you can't see why Macedonians identify themselves as Greek? You got to be kidding me
12923: 11941:
threatening their political and territorial interests in Macedonia? Certainly Tito did not pushed this book to be printed.
11333:, stop hiding behind your fingers. As the data reveals, they've been the majority of the population, even in the vilaet of 7835:
What's ironic is a person who claims to be from a "alpha", doesn't even know the basic history of it. What is today called
5871:
01:22, 1 December 2005 (UTC) I've gathered most of the links representing the ethnic structure of a given country from the
5454: 5434: 5240: 5137: 4175:, "Macedonians" shall be used until MATIA and/or Theathenae can give a valid reason why "Macedonian Slavs" should be used. 3763: 3185: 3083: 2815: 1325:
Adding: "...it is very high, and here are to be found many monasteries of Christian monks, of whom some are Greeks, others
1169: 9911:
descend (yes, I know that the more exact way to say this is to consider individual lineages rather than that of an entire
8809:
Ok, check my latest compromise edits. You have no valid reason to deny them, except your illusion of owning this article.
5255:
Wrong, the poll was a tie - there was no consensus. I want to reach a mutually acceptable compromise. We cannot call them
3071: 12246:
19) ) Martin Crusius in his book mentions"Vscopia, or Scopia, a great and populous City of Turkey in the K. of Servia".
9814:
I don't know, that might be okay. The most I have found for the claims of the Macedonians (ethnic group) is a quote from
6491:
is a patrilineal descendent of Alexander the Great (which in theory could be done), genes cannot be used to that effect.
5723: 5664: 5558: 5509: 3295: 2014: 12279:
24) In 1609,in the archive of Vatican,catholic church in Skoplje Serbia is mentioned (La chiesa di Scopia in Servia) .
8497:....the Greek population that has historically inhabited the northern-most region of the Greek peninsula, also known as 8136:
Once the accuracy of an edit has been officially question, the act of adding it back is a violation of official policy.
6674:
There may have been errors in my recent edits, but let me underscore the pseudoscience in the earlier version, namely:
3483:
and will integrate it into this article when it's been unprotected. I'll remove it from the talk page when I'm done. --
2649:
I'm stating in public the changes I'll be making to this article for the sake of wikipedia's last traces of neutrality.
831:
And there's the ultimately tough question: what right does a group of people have to declare that they are of a certain
13281:
and Southern Vardar (vilaet of Monastir), long before the Asian Greeks arrived. Deal with it and go on with your life.
12802:
SIMIN that fact that OMO-ILINDEN exists is proof to me that not all the Macedonians in Bulgaria have been brainwashed.
12302:"Cratovo, dove saranno 40 fouchi di Catolici....habitata da Turchi di qualita, Serviani , et 160 anime piu Catoliche" 12240:
18) In Kraljevo (Romania) ,priest John has written in 1580 that he is a Serb from Kratovo (Srbin od mjasta Kratova) .
10006:
What criteria for Greekness? Language is usually what most academics use. The other 'claims' are just that claims. The
6659:. But it's not "so what" to the Macedonian (ethnic group)/Macedonian Slavs. It is their claims we are addressing here. 6420:
especially is used in these contexts. When I wrote "a Macedonian" I intended "a random Macedonian individual" chosen.
6340:- nevertheless, in the absence of a source, such claims could be rendered POV. Especially considering the DIY phrasing 5557:
Concerning the repressions towards the Rainbow party... even the European Court for Human rights confirmed it with its
4221:
MATIA and Theathenae have given no good reason to leave it at "Macedonian Slavs". Give us a valid reason, if you can .
2996:
Come on, you know by yourself that no modern Greek ever says that he is "Macedonian". Also, a suprise for you: we, the
2252:, but has neither the time nor the propensity to get actively involved. I am chatting to him on MSN as we speak... ;)-- 1683:: I would laugh but I can't. As for the edits... I have 1797 here and 1468 in greek WP (both are since my registration 11721:? And what about Pavlos Melas anyway? Oh, I know, they were all Slavs not Greek. There's some homework for you to do. 10723:, not just to any Vulgar Latin or early Balkan Romance speakers. Vlachs much more likely came from lands north of the 10373:
iota of original thought behind it is hardly going to school me. Whatever boosts that self-esteem though for ya kid.
8231:
there's no remote hint that those names where in fact "Macedonian Slavic" (and not Bulgarian or Serbian for instance).
6079:
is what is intended here. Feel free to find resolution in the opening paragraph, but Miskin's deletion seems extreme.
5073:
ChrisO, I try to treat everything as pseudoscience (get dates and facts and then analyse majority and minority view).
3989:. There was no consensus for Macedonian Slavs and Macedonians plain was and is more in favour. This all comes down to 2772:
And as an old Japanese proverb says: "If you throw a stone at a stray dog, it will never take food from you again"...
2736:
Talking about the difference, YES it should be clear. But, the possibility of they to be connected can not be ignored.
2182:
Should I remind you to these posts, where we can clearly see how Greece acts towards the Macedonians that live there:
1972: 1088:
Moldovans: the Moldovans in Romania who maintained their Romanian identity, and the Moldovans across the river in the
11950: 10719:
were a pre-Slavic population of Macedonia. Vlachs in English usage refers to speakers of languages that descend from
7566: 3960:
did the move here, which is why it should have stayed where it was, according to Knowledge policy. I remind you that
868:
As a mediator, your beggining position seems to me quite one sided. FYROM, hijacked, aspirations, a name they choose?
797: 7061:. Personally I believe the number of 150,000 Macedonians in Albania is a bit far fetched, but that won't change the 6706:
The problem with considering any ethnic group as one unit when considering ancestry is illustrated by these quotes (
5763: 2856:
So, which Greek census we can use, when Greece is ignoring and assimilating the Macedonians for more than 100 years?
2034: 1227:
Certainly, this is your personal research, or your source is extreme pro-Bulgarian or pro-Greek or pro-Serbian etc.
828:
Can we describe the aspirations of former Yugoslavians to have national homeland with a name of their own choosing?
211:
themselves as Macedonians (again ethnicity, not regionality)? Did maybe John F. Kennedy make them proclaim as such?
11361: 11106: 9257:- Yes, I agree this article to be a standard one, just like all others (English people etc., as mentioned before). 6300:
in this context. It is an inappropriate word. If you're going to discuss the prevalence of Chron's disease amongst
6035: 5263:
because quite simply they don't identify as such. They identify as Macedonians, therefore according to the rule in
996:
the name, the history, the culture, the language, the origin... but only untill your own are not questioned. Right?
611:
Maybe you tought that by outnumbering us you will win the poll, but fortunately there are many neutral people here.
6582: 5955:
Definitly, this is an example that should be followed by any other Balkan nations that have problems and disputes.
1270: 13311:, please stop adding that line about Macedonians being "native" to some region or other. Instead, please find a 12775:, Thank you about qualifing of my words like bullshit. Thus you save my trouble to embark in theorethical themes. 8269:
I'm removing all disputed information until credible sources have been presented for each and every one of them.
6971:, I'd like to take this opportunity to thank you for beginning to use Talk pages to discuss editing the article. 5498:
It is not just about the Macedonians in Greece. What about the enormous Albanian population? What about the Roma?
4825:
I think that we need a fair (describing not prescribing) naming policy, equilavent to others that already exist.
4632:
While I agree with the above points, could anyone please explain what specific disputes are we discussing about?
4142:
Matia, when mediation was asked, everyone of the Greek side withdraw. So, now you have no reason to complain. If
3934:
there has always been more support for Macedonians and at last Knowledge policy has been implemented. Oh Joy :-)
2101:
lists even the nationalities with less than 100 "members": . Even the Ruthenian with 11 people are in this table.
1148:
refer to themselves as British - that is what the people who lived there in ancient times called themselves (see
47: 17: 11528:
I remember the great subordination under which the Turk holds the emperor in Constantinople and all the Greeks,
10865:
the Slavs want to persuade the world that 'Macedonians' and 'Macedonian' has never had a connection with Greeks.
3559:
and you will see that a there are documents that mention separate Macedonian ethnicity even in the 15th century.
2921:
All I learned about this issue is from international sources and archives (at least the ones available on-line).
2311:
I have no reason to lie. He happened to be online when we were in the midst of our usual edit war, but I am not
2064:
was already banned from the Swedish Knowledge for using this kind of tacktics for pushing his nationalistic POV.
2027: 2024: 1437:
there. This whole thing was sending us on a wild goose chase to find something in the previous discussions that
167:, others call them Skopjians. I can't even keep track. All this fussing and fighting isn't getting us anywhere. 10760: 9275:- There is no reason why Macedonians should not be labelled as people, Macedonian people makes more sense then 8511:
I'm glad this page got protected. Have a look at the comments I've made above. I said that I never denied that
6005: 5754: 1896: 1092:
who "discovered" that they were "not Romanians" sometime after the Soviet propaganda took hold. It can happen.
10299:, if you can. Really, only an imbecile can believe that Romanians have absolutely no Roman (not talking about 9164:... Have I made my point across? I mean, "Macedonians" and "Macedonian people" are interchangeable, just like 9013:... Have I made my point across? I mean, "Macedonians" and "Macedonian people" are interchangeable, just like 8797:
and now you're telling me that all this time you were denying the use of the term "Macedonian" in my examples?
7865:
And of course you can guess where does the word "Bulgars" refer to. The region was repopulated by Greeks from
4382: 4365:
all rejected the idea of mediation after FlavrSavr, I and literally everyone else was begging them to accept:
2118:
He shouldn't be allowed to make us waste time on this senceless and ridiculous claims, instead on reall issue.
1952:
Of course Tito did not create the Macedonians. It is foolish to think that one man can create a whole nation.
11234:
Bomac you asked me to explain to you what credible sources mean. Very well then. First of all have a look at
8610: 7025: 6896: 6398:
I don't know enough about this to know whether it's POV or not. I know that saying "inherit genes" is wrong.
5595:
U.S STATE DEPARTMENT Foreign Relations Vol. VIII Washington D.C. Circular Airgram (868.014/26 Dec. 1944)
2019:
The above user's melodramatic pap about "human rights" all rings rather hollow when one considers his purely
1329:, Vlachs and even Italians, as well other nations, who live the lives of saints" - Angiolelo about Mt. Athos 1310: 12440:
46) Around 1680 Urban Cerri mentioned in his report to Pope Inocentius XI archbiscop of Skoplje in Serbia.
10983:
One guy claiming that the Spaniards were predominantly a Germanic people, derived from Visigoths and Vandals
6956: 6366:, but that's about it. Every person's genes are unique (except twins and clones). You cannot inherit genes. 5622:
The Department would appreciate any information pertinent to this subject which may come to your attention.
3690:
applies until a good reason is found why this case should be treated as an exception. Got any good reasons?
1762:
You don't understand WP policies and perhaps I don't either. We'll have them explained to us, but not here.
591:
to the article, as per the official results of the last poll on this talk page. This can only be changed by
11549:
The above quote from the 1400s distinctly mentions the Macedonians and Bulgarians are two separate people.
10314:
element is admitted by quite a many historians, though Italic stock is not the issue nor the criterion for
9313: 8977: 8457: 7341:
the related table entry to "Slavs". As for modern, what are the rest Macedonians (those unrelated to RoM)?
6138: 4082: 3985:
Which policy is that? Which policy says that it should stay where it was? If you want to know policy, read
3523:
adding another factor as to how they were regarded, since only Greeks were permitted to participate in the
3267:) was in the so called "untied countries" (nor the west, nor the east). Greece took the place to enter the 2975:
nations do not exist, before some people start believeing that the belong to a specific nation. After all,
2653:
Restore the article's first paragraph which states the difference between modern Macedonian Slavic and the
2160:
Arvanítis, he wasn't banned last time I checked. He made a contribution as recently as today, in fact. ;)--
519:
Remember, Knowledge cannot "settle" any of these points, but only describe the disputes about them fairly.
8619:, what I denied were your silly examples, generalizations, and anachronistic use of the term "Macedonian". 6543: 5605:
The following is for your information and general guidance, but not for any positive action at this time.
3686:. You're implying that it was not an honourable move, but a sneaky and dishonest one. As far as I can see 633: 186:
describing the naming dispute over what these people have been called, are called, and ought to be called.
11431:, and that no 'Macedonian Slavic' ethnicity is mentioned at the time. You'd also need to add this in the 10724: 10208: 9302: 8438: 7324:
And the readers are not blind to see the huge heading of the article in front of their eyes: Macedonians
6042: 3512: 3176:
PS. Some refear to NGO's or other sources and consider them always neutral. Why? Do or don't people like
2644: 2367: 1864:
point in trying to solve complex historical debates, without first solving the more tangible disputes. --
614:
So, please stop changing the facts in your own convinience. The pull did not support any of the options.
582: 13258: 12702:"The Macedonians had little or no political and national identity of their own until the 20th century." 12354:
33) In 1644 a Serb,Dimitrije Nikolajev (Serbjanin' Dmitrei Nikolaev) from Kastoria, arrived in Russia.
9172:. What's the point of having "(ethnic group)" in the title when you can just say "Macedonian people"? -- 9021:. What's the point of having "(ethnic group)" in the title when you can just say "Macedonian people"? -- 6708:
Introduction to Physical Anthropology, 9th Ed., Jurmaine, Kilgore, Trevathan, Nelson, 2003, pgs. 397-398
3539:
Slav inhabitants of both the Republic of Macedonia and of northern Greece. Muslim Bulgarians are called
1454: 1322:, Albanians, Esclavoni, Razici, Serbians..." - Bertradon de la Broquier, The 15th century travel-writer 11365: 10882: 10822: 10220: 10120: 10091: 9892: 9512: 9218: 9125: 9032: 8558: 8063: 7628: 5275: 5205: 5197: 3919: 3894:
discretion of an administrator. The time for discussion may be extended if a consensus has not emerged.
3800: 3592: 2997: 2371: 1908: 1398: 682:
Give it up. Your hatred of Greece is counter-productive and will only cause you pain in the long run.--
236: 141: 38: 12974:
Your argument is reasonable and so is mine. I did not claim there are 6,176 macedonian slavs. I wrote
12885:
regional identity among Slavs. It was once again the seed of the new name for the Slavs in Macedonia.
12539:
Slijepchevich, Dj. "The Macedonian Question",The American Institute For Balkan Affairs, Chicago,1958
11627:
five boys and seven girls. I learnt the Slav alphabet from my father Makedonski, who calls himself so
9671:
for the modern Macedonians to have anything in common with the ancient Macedonians - that is a sin! --
9580: 8445:
that has been taking place here. Please discuss your changes on the talk pages rather than reverting;
8281:
Those that inhabited northeastern Greece were forcibly exchanged with Greeks from Bulgaria and Serbia.
8172:
Those that inhabited northeastern Greece were forcibly exchanged with Greeks from Bulgaria and Serbia.
4207:
Also, the vas majority of editors on this talk page think that the name "Macedonians" should be used.
1457:. I sincerely hope that you will mend your ways. All I want is to find a reasonably neutral compromise 12666:
Karl Oestreich "Die Bevolkerung von Makedonien",Geographische Zeitschrift,Vol. XI, No.1,1905,pp.291
12126:
Constantin Porphyrogenitos "De Administrando Imperio" cap.32, pp.152 ed.Bonn "Starine" 14,1882 pp.16
10732: 9331: 9105: 8605:, Atanasoski becoming Atanopoulos). This was a government sponsered process known as "Hellenization". 4840: 4696: 4518: 4251: 4190: 4165:
A Yahoo! search for "Macedonians", but excluding the words Greece and Bulgaria gives 362,000 results
4086: 4002: 3961: 3927: 3687: 2023:
attempt to extinguish any reference to the Bulgarian and Greek minorities in the Republic of Skopje:
1884: 1318:
Adding: "And there are .... many Christians who perforce serve the Turk, such as Greeks, Bulgarians,
163:
Knowledge is not really concerned with what the "true name" of this people is. Some people call them
12907:
is now (surprise!) official! The people are the creatures of opportunity, that's it. No big ideas.
9210:- I believe that the article should be "Macedonians" or "Macedonian people" ... and naturally, that 9039:
for controversial moves. The answer to your question is the whole debate of this version versus the
8157:
Those that stayed in northwestern Greece were regarded as a potentially disloyal "Slavophone Greeks"
2907:
OK, this new edit of yous seems more NPOV and I can tell you that I have better oppinion of you now.
1823:, please provide some neutral source. Not a nationalistic pro-Greek page such as www.macedonia.com. 662:
just issued a case close against Greece in favor of the party of the Macedonian minority in Greece:
13014: 11750:) nowadays. It is a totally strange name for them to be identified with. That's what I've thought. 11229: 8959: 6096:
I mean, good god people! The Macedonians exist after all nowadays. HELLO!!! Anybody??? Cheers from
5054:
REX ask clarifications for our NPA parole. I don't think you should continue your statements about
3759: 3556: 2925: 1687:
last june and I 've never used any other account). I'll gather all your calumnies, you are boring.
1332:
2) . No wonder they were one of the first that recognized Macedonia under its constitutional name.
1287: 1165: 983: 8788:
to Greek, like your edits in the article implied. I provided proof that those names were regarded
8750:) that have been listed earlier in this page, and they mean nothing. Take a look at the hoax that 8051:
Maybe you should try out a real history book for a change. It will explain more than you imagine.
6635: 6545:. Even National Geographic makes use of such formulations as "modern populations on the island of 6495:
is a significant problem in this area. From generation to generation genes change, that is called
2248:
happens to be a good friend of mine who was outraged when informed of your Albanian chauvinism on
884:(not just the mediator or any other single user) here to answer me simply few questions of my own: 343:
million Bulgarians and Greeks combined) and push their POV. Same thing that happens on Knowledge.
12627:
Dalmatia, with Dubrovnik, southern parts of Hungary (Bachka, Srem, Baranja) , Slavonia, Croatia"
12008: 11912: 11565:
Please, let do not forget thet the border between propaganda and science is very thin. Regards,--
10750: 10720: 8397: 8362: 6770:
article just has the bare contemporary facts in the opening paragraph, as these articles should.
5717: 5280: 1892: 13092:
due to the ongoing discrimination and harrasment that Macedonians face from the Greek government
12234:
17) Jakov Soranzzo from Venice arrives in Skoplje,in the province of Serbia, in the year 1575.
10889:) was trying to convince me that Greece is in the EU because of the supposedly "stolen" land of 10515:
Umm... This is getting nowhere. (also, Alex, are you the artist formerly known as Decius? :)) --
10025: 3079:
Mik=friend in Arvanitika? Funny:) Actualy I am not Arvanitis and Mik comes from my first name.--
2082:" written as nationality. Also, my Mexican wife is also registered as Mexican, no matter she is 1748:. You caused a dispute, now a poll shall resolve the dispute with a consensus once and for all. 695:
time you talked face to face with a Macedonian (ethnic group)? Shake his hand, buy him a dinner?
11908: 11864:
So, in your humble opinion, does that isolated quote utterly cover all Macedonian Slav claims?
11645:"I asked him what language they spoke, and my Greek interpreter carelessly rendered the answer 11356: 10930: 9120: 8904:
blindly (as I've said black and white) believe in your countries romantic nationalistic myths.
8449: 7699:
Bulgaria and FYROM, it's done, it's over, deal with it, stop hating and get on with your life.
7577: 6105: 5789: 4250:
Obviously I can't speak for Ed, but I agree with his action for three main reasons. First, the
1904: 1789: 158: 13215:
since Stohos (Greek newspaper) printed the names of people who had crossed from the republic.
12551:
Joseph Muller, “Albanien,Rumelien und die Osterreichisch-Montenegrinische Grenze”,Prague,1844
11746:. But, admit it, there are no Greeks who describe themselves as "Macedonians" (something like 10988:
I don't see where's the national myth in that. This is actually a historically attested fact,
6939:
Two-thirds of the population are Slavic Macedonians, and about one-fifth are ethnic Albanians.
5798: 5669:
I've restored some, there was also a section named "Origin of the name" that disappeared too,
3922:, you would see that "Macedonians" got more actual votes. Was there a consensus to keep it at 3876: 3729:
Knowledge:Templates_for_deletion/Log/Deleted/September_2005#Template:Macedonian_naming_dispute
13130:
facts. If there aren't any, say only that and resist the temptation to speculate about it.
11771:? Byzantium was referred to the West as "Empire of the Greeks" or "Greece", read the article 11481:
Excuse me, but this is very strange for me. What is this anonymous Hungarian chronicler from
10862:
the Slavs want to monopolise the name 'Macedonia', the Greek want to share it - disambiguate.
10712: 9896: 9628: 9401: 9306: 8868: 8676:
Macedonians. So here are some " record of official existence prior to 1948 " that you wanted
8226:
By the way, I never said that Slavic names places were never changed for Greek ones. However:
7176: 5390:
you will find that even they have called them "Macedonians". Therefore, given that all these
4564: 4385:
is tactfully rejecting a premature Med. What I don't understand is how is it premature. The
3260: 12589:
Czoernig, von Carl "Ethnographie der oesterrichischem Monarchie", Wien, 1885, Vol II pp.169
12508:
Archivum Sacrae Congregationis de Propaganda Fide."Congregazioni Particolari"Vol.106.Fol.1
10594:
way around. Same thing goes for the Romans. It would obviously be much more rational if the
6669: 5816: 2323:. Sockpuppetry is a rather immature practice - you really should reconsider your approach.-- 2036:. Selective denial of the mere existence of ethnic minorities in his country, thinly-veiled 207:
occupation (during which time the people who accepted the islam were released from any tax)?
190:
I want to help you guys - all of you - but this is the best I can think of right now, okay?
12623:
Jastrebov,I.S. "Obichai i Pesni tureckih serbov v Prizren,Ipek,Morava i Dibra",1886,pp.1-2
12139:
ethnically Serbian enclave,situated much more southerly than political borders of Serbia.
11001:
nation that calls itself "Macedonian", in the same way that nobody raises an eyebrow on an
10642: 9932: 9338:
name to be used. Greek nationalism does not override our naming conventions. If we can say
8368: 8185:- prove that this type of project has ever existed officially under that name (as implied). 7170: 6779: 5807: 5730:
for the changes. Perhaps few of that editor's lines could be usable, so I leave this note.
4699:
policy, under which, it is clear that we should use "Macedonians" for this ethnic group? --
4573:
PS someone should really archive some of this talk page, its rather long to say the least.
2477: 1842: 339:
distinctions of a Macedonian ethnicity can be made since the beggining of the 20th century.
12638:
Anton Tuma von Waldkampf "Griechland,Makedonien und Sudalbanien",Leipzig, 1897 pp-214-215
12608:
Alexander von Heksch "Die Donau von ihrem Ursprung bis an die Mundung",Leipzig,1885,pp.63
5267:, the article title must contain the word "Macedonians". There is a wide range of choices: 4642:
with no realistic prospect of the participants in this dispute agreeing on a compromise...
2142: 335:
national feeling could be punished as separatism. But, most of the sources agree that the
8: 13100: 11776: 11584:(from the "Letter of Protection From the Emperor Leopold I to the Macedonian People") - " 11432: 11373: 10292: 10087: 9843: 9498: 8945: 8785: 8606: 8479: 8453: 8418: 8383: 8175: 8120: 8104: 8086: 7643:
An meneis ontos stin Ellada apodeikse to mou milontas apokleisteika romaiika. YS: Malaka.
7600: 7128: 7081: 6918: 6526: 6446: 6177: 6025:
And a technical note: you should leave your messages at the end of the talk page. Cheers
4539:
And, of course Miskin will not care much. His national identity was never into question.
3796: 3755: 3439: 3301: 3051: 2513: 2438: 2375: 2363: 1161: 1089: 904:
maybe Tito gave more attention to "changing" our nationality than to the comunism itself?
12065: 8755:"Macedonians" That fits very well to the disambiguation pages that we already have (see 8460:. If you have reached agreement or want the page unprotecting, please post a request on 8370:, but it is really a nice episode to illustrate how (a) this battle is really fought on 6982: 5067: 4286:
has become the scapegoat here, when these three links clearly show who was responsible:
3293:
Saying that Greece is advanced is a bit POV. If Greece were advanced would se have been
1997:
to vote or tell their oppinion. You are calling them to attack the Macedonian position.
1344:
6) . So, not all the Greek sources were denying the existance of a Macedonian ethicity.
1194:
Long story... Might discuss it with you if you register and put signature on your posts.
1059:
As I can see, you (and anyone else) obviously did not answer any of the questions above.
491:
And how does that relate to (or contrast with) what other people call these same people?
427:
One big point that we may or may not be able to address - after the above are answered:
13315:
that discusses the development of the modern Macedonian language and ethnic identity.
12975: 12652:
Henry, Rene "Questions d' Autriche-Hongrie et Question d' Orient" Paris, 1905, pp.207
12005: 11996: 11920: 11796: 11714: 11670: 11369: 11330: 10795:
explaining its usage and nor will it cater to Greek nationalism to set them apart etc.
10745: 10728: 10094:(not to curb any national mythology, but because it seems to work fine) and would like 9321: 8860: 8721:
identify themselves as "Macedonian Slavs", nobody would have been against it. It's the
8717: 8629: 8498: 8446: 8442: 8192: 7925: 7526: 7474: 7343: 7154: 6999: 6990: 6882: 6843: 6488: 6388: 5735: 5678: 5078: 4830: 4598:
OK done it, I think your above comment could apply to anything to do with the Balkans.
4510: 4481: 4420: 4362: 4318: 4110: 4034: 4029:
disambiguation purposes in texts were more than one Macedonian-something-people exist.
3639: 3480: 3473: 3447: 3047: 2833: 2565: 2450: 2030: 1980: 1767: 1692: 1655: 715: 9043:
macedonian people as it were and if they really are a people, or something like that.
8608: 3493:
They consider themselves to be a distinct ethnic group, a claim controversial as many
12899:
16. The idea after WWII was to "De-Serbianize" Macedonia, not to "De-Bulgarize" it.
12861:
including the major part of today's Serbia, but it does not make Serbs Bulgarians...
12659:
Karl Oestreich "Makedonien" Geographische Zeitschrift, Vol.X, No.1, 1904,pp 198-199
11293: 10307: 10224: 10086:; Romanians are not "wanna be Italics". However many Macedonians do seem to wanna-be 9632: 9343: 9129: 8432: 8260: 5958:
I would be glad to discuss this issue on my talk. If interested, please write to me.
5834: 5463:
travels, the Greeks can't count down the number of Macedonians in their own country.
5130: 4240: 3524: 2359: 1851:
discussions (there are forums for that), we are here to discuss how disputes will be
840: 811: 11883:
his parents were Armenian peasants who migrated to the Hellenic region of Macedonia.
9991:
Macedonians (the real ones). There was no concept of "ethnic Italian" in Antiquity (
8748: 8679: 2688:
then? Do you know how much the demographic profile of the region changed since then?
1298:
I also agree that several version during day or two before the lock were more NPOV.
761:
We need to describe the naming dispute, not settle it. Get that through your heads!
170:
Knowledge is not going to settle this dispute. We are just going to think up a good
13290:
Oh, and by the way, the only name Greeks have ever known for "Macedonian Slavs" is
13025: 12023: 11772: 11718: 11187: 11113: 10959: 10941: 10890: 10392:
Your "original thought" was best left undiscussed. I have nothing to prove to you,
10095: 9768: 9568: 9419: 8562: 8356: 8082: 8074: 8070: 7933: 7390: 7298: 7283: 7200: 6857: 6747: 6506: 6456: 6405: 6373: 6311: 6212: 6195: 6148: 6117: 4074: 3994: 3953: 3897: 3223: 2845:
because I use Macedonian more than English any time I go in Florina (Lerin). Maybe
2355: 1529: 1494: 667:
Also, here is a link for you, saying what Amnesty International thinks of Greece: .
642: 105: 10868:
the newly formed Republic of Macedonia published currency with the White Tower of
8832:
Georgos Natsulis, thirty-nine, a worker in the fur business in Kastoria,
7920:
Because in your edit summary, you were insolent enough to refer to this region as
4789:
Why now, 50 years latter the other 2 keep doing the same as 100 or 150 years ago?
2097:
For any case, here is a link where you can clearly see that the national censuses
12998: 12953: 11978: 11956: 11313:
He described it as newly-conquered territory, because that's what it was. It was
10275:
in the Balkans, this is a certainty, by the way); if the Romanization occured in
10159:". Let's just agree to it. Please, let's keep the discussion to a serious level. 9604:
Also, as usual, only accounts with enough edits should have their votes counted.
9368: 8864: 8521: 8210: 8127:
constitutes any kind of vandalism. It may not be polite, but it's not vandalism.
7836: 7610: 7603:, and would need some expert help. If and when you are willing, give me a chime. 7058: 6383:
What about the phrase that Alexander007 tried to change? Do you find it POV too?
6355: 5959: 5695: 5648: 5562: 5531: 5438: 5356: 5318: 5174: 5091: 5018: 4995: 4973: 4937: 4865: 4790: 4740: 4663: 4612: 4544: 4435: 4350: 4332: 4147: 4053: 3977: 3909: 3908:, as the last recorded support for such a move was well below the 60% required.-- 3852: 3807: 3665: 3564: 3535:
for more information.) The term is often used by Slavs of the region to mean the
3528: 3357: 3197: 3099: 3015: 2936: 2880: 2860: 2800: 2740: 2697: 2582: 2527: 2400: 2335: 2324: 2316: 2312: 2264: 2253: 2245: 2218: 2193: 2176: 2161: 2123: 2105: 2091: 2072: 2068: 2061: 2057: 2045: 1998: 1931: 1824: 1708: 1564: 1382: 1356: 1299: 1246: 1203: 1120: 1067: 1018: 1006: 784: 700: 683: 674: 645: 615: 596: 569: 532: 506: 475: 449: 432: 414: 374: 369:
have direct origin from the Antique Macedonians (same as the Greeks do not have).
344: 309: 282: 240: 212: 171: 12460:
Horvat,K. "Glasnik zemaljskog muzeja u Bosni i Hercegovini" XXI, 1909, pp. 403
10699: 9842:
As a final note, I recommend that everybody here calms down a bit regarding the
9320:. Using this humiliating form just to appease Greek nationalists in the face of 9298: 9297:
I think that humiliating titles for nationalities is wrong. In fact, Britannica
8366: 8237:
No Greek would argue about changes in placenames - that's a straightforward lie.
7080:
scholarship. To do an example, this is the reason we don't write in the article
5897:
number of ethnic Macedonians in Albania at this moment, (as it is in Greece) is
5640:
BTW, should I remind you the present official possitions of USA about Macedonia?
5634:
We all have already seen this 1 million times. Is this the only source you have?
5169:
source mentions this thing. Why you claim something that you have no sources of?
3905: 3877: 3652:
Evidence for separate Macedonian ethnicity can be found since the 15th century (
2461:
But does Britannica dispute that it is Slavic? I don't think so. 'Slavic' is an
1063:
clearly know the story of my people. And I am sure that you don't fancy it much.
751:- but that is not the sort of thing which an encyclopedia is supposed to settle. 273:
even the province of "Macedonia" in Greece got that name somewhere in the 1980s.
46:
If you wish to start a new discussion or revive an old one, please do so on the
13308: 13272: 13253: 13225: 13127: 13123: 13078: 13009: 12157:
Novakovich,S. "Zakonski spomenici Srpskih drzhava srednjeg veka", 1912, pp.509
11987: 11764: 11710: 11566: 11486: 11421: 11326: 11278: 11198: 11166: 11092: 10955: 10934: 10909: 10818: 10810: 10785: 10777: 10557: 10516: 9919:
colonists as well as indigenous groups, Slavs, Cumans, etc. etc., and the name
9861: 9794: 9746: 9702: 9681: 9672: 9595:
We should set a time-limit ASAP. No more than a week seems like a good choice.
9548: 9516: 9493: 9309: 9283: 9192:
followed by an optional one sentence explanation, then sign your vote with ~~~~
9161: 9157: 9153: 9149: 9133: 9010: 9006: 9002: 8998: 8982: 8853: 8751: 8701: 8566: 8548: 8503: 8414: 8379: 8218: 8203: 8058: 8046: 8019: 7826: 7755: 7685: 7654: 7638: 7619: 7584: 7516: 7141: 7132: 7119: 7070: 7053: 7032: 7010: 6968: 6951:
You know, it's the damnedest thing, Britannica also says something like that: "
6923: 6869: 6829: 6796: 6786: 6599: 6227: 5920: 5910: 5877: 5868: 5523: 5421: 5396: 4957: 4909: 4700: 4686: 4649: 4645: 4526: 4256: 3926:. If there was, do point it out. As I have said before, in such circumstances, 3840: 3806:
Othervise, that would be a direct support of the denials towards these people.
3785: 3616: 3548:
This text is a complete POV push and anti-Macedonian. It needs to be worked on
2379: 1900: 1874: 1865: 1647: 1585: 1145: 7571:
Why is everyone trying to deny the actual numbers of Macedonians? People like
7451:
For me, the current situation of the paragraph is "disambigual" quite enough.
6431:
Izehar, are you sure you can't inherit genes? I may be misreading the article
6238:"...but it is possible that the genetic make-up of a Macedonian includes some 5530:. The human rights is important issue anywhere in the world. But, not Greece. 4755: 3611:
evidence showing that the relationship was invented by politician C or party D
13119: 11235: 11216: 11141: 11047: 10969: 10844: 10796: 10679: 10625: 10470: 10423: 10374: 10337: 10250: 10182: 10138: 10012: 9973: 9879: 9647: 9520: 9396: 9339: 9240: 9173: 9169: 9141: 9059: 9022: 9018: 8990: 8525: 8298: 8163:
Greece regarded its Slavic minority as "Slavophone Greeks" rather than plain
7818:
If Macedonia was really Greek, Greece would not have any thing to worry about
7675: 7604: 7572: 7530: 7478: 7347: 7188: 7184: 7150: 6995: 6986: 6878: 6865: 6839: 6646: 6607: 6384: 6359: 6185: 6056: 5731: 5674: 5513: 5074: 4826: 4710: 4477: 4416: 4358: 4314: 4243:
on this question, so I'll repost them here so that they will be more visible:
4106: 4030: 3635: 3588: 3520: 3516: 3443: 2829: 2606: 2561: 2446: 2226: 1976: 1891:. Let's work on them one by one taking into consideration Knowledge policies 1820: 1793: 1763: 1704: 1688: 1651: 1643: 1593: 1478: 1405: 1010: 12151:
Novakovich,S. "Zakonik Stefana Dushana Cara Srpskog 1349-1354" Beograd 1898
11391:
Miskin, I don't know where you're getting at, I simply said its a fact that
6838:
Are your people related to Greek people? Would you write it in the article?
6822:
and other Turkic tribes also mixed with the Slavonic-speakers in the region.
5378:
Encyclopaedia and Ethnologue call these people "Macedonians". If you search
2094:, because she alone is extremely sick of these kind of nationalistic claims. 1183:
On the other hand, all of them can claim partial connection to those people.
13312: 12437:
Horvat,K. "Glasnik Zemaljskog Muzeja Bosne i Hercegovine" XXI,1909,pp.393
11392: 10869: 10674: 10581: 10319: 10315: 10268: 10067: 10038: 10029: 9987: 9951: 9916: 9912: 9904: 9900: 9145: 9137: 9080: 9076: 9036: 8994: 8986: 8713: 8336:
In the vilaet of Thessaloniki: 521 Greek schools with 32,534 students, 319
8073:. For every single edit that I make, I'll keep linking to a section of the 7839:
had always been predominantly Greek in population. This is verified by the
7760:
I was talking about the destruction of Smyrna and the Greek migration from
7273:
This article is about the Modern Macedonian Slavic-speaking ethnic group...
5391: 5201: 4685:., and could we please stop engaging in cheap mud throwing, again? (UTC) -- 4237: 3990: 3884: 3732: 3624: 3305: 3177: 2222: 1797: 1597: 1560: 850: 762: 549: 520: 191: 12952:
Attention: No opinion is presented, just data. Therefore, I will revert.--
11337:(Bitola). That is something which needs to be pointed out in the article. 8745: 8677: 5963: 5699: 5652: 5566: 5535: 5442: 5360: 5322: 5178: 5095: 5022: 4977: 4941: 4869: 4794: 4744: 4667: 4616: 4548: 4439: 4336: 4171:. Therefore, as "Macedonians" is the most common name, in accordance with 4151: 4057: 3856: 3811: 3669: 3568: 3361: 3201: 3103: 3019: 2940: 2864: 2744: 2701: 2586: 2531: 2404: 2339: 2268: 2197: 2127: 2002: 1935: 1828: 1712: 1568: 1386: 1250: 1207: 1124: 573: 536: 510: 479: 453: 418: 378: 348: 313: 286: 244: 13330: 13316: 13304: 13295: 13282: 13263: 13131: 12816: 12742: 12416:
Dimitrijevich,S. "Spomenica Srpske kraljevske akademije",38,1900 pp.64b
11924: 11865: 11780: 11722: 11678: 11526:(from the work “Voyage Across the Sea” by Bertrandon de la Brocuiere) - " 11440: 11377: 11338: 11297: 11248: 11029: 11019: 10894: 10826: 10703: 10652: 10604: 10590: 10536:
Oui. And as once stated on zee talk page of my friend Decius, Decius was
10160: 9997: 9463: 9423: 9211: 8923: 8894: 8884: 8810: 8800: 8760: 8641: 8581: 8529: 8401: 8348: 8305: 8270: 8248: 8214: 8191:
Hey, this was already confirmed by everyone including Greek users in the
8137: 8094: 8078: 8052: 8032: 7938: 7792: 7774: 7700: 7663: 7634: 7558: 7498:. It looks like someone is hiding that term or doesn't want to be there. 7407: 7235: 7101:
the view by saying that the Macedonian community claims 150,000. It is a
7017: 6972: 6959: 6943: 6929: 6907: 6611: 6603: 6550: 6516: 6263: 6231: 6066: 5063: 4354: 3986: 3682:
MATIA, that one night consensus you keep on talking about qualifies as a
3508: 3503: 3059: 2773: 2667: 2037: 1785: 832: 13294:. Same goes for the rest of the word outside of Yugoslavia before 1948. 12467:
Dimitrijevich,S. "Glasnik Srpske Kraljevske Akademije" 60, 1901 pp.154
12384:
Stanojevich,Lj "Stari Srpski zapisi i natpisi", I,1902.No 1547,No 1562
11080: 10279:, then stock from Roman colonists is also certain, though the amount of 7731: 7195:
aren't that many anyway. Can't you discuss it here according to policy?
720:
Look everyone, this revert war has to stop; it's ridiculous. Check this
13291: 13168: 13030: 12964: 12942: 12753: 12269:
Archive of the Russian Ministry For Foreign Affairs, Year 7112,Dec.19
12104: 12086: 12056: 11942: 11751: 11689: 11428: 11258: 11100: 11088: 11072: 10886: 10814: 10599: 10397: 10156: 9636: 9615: 9481: 9258: 8936: 8919: 8905: 8784:
or just Slavic. I wanted sourcing for the name changes from the Slavic
8325:
In the vilaet of Monastir: 447 Greek schools with 27,106 students, 242
8284: 8164: 8149: 8128: 7956: 7866: 7823:
Open your eyes, smell the air, put it together, and it all makes sense.
7804: 7761: 7710:
Yet you don't see Greek people bitching all over the internet about it.
7695: 7499: 7452: 7439: 7424: 7364: 7329: 7312: 7259: 7222: 7175:
Can you two please stop this ridiculous edit war? You're cluttering up
7085: 6301: 6097: 6026: 5464: 4775:
propaganda against this nation, a propaganda launched by these 2 sides.
4599: 4574: 3494: 3277: 3264: 3145: 2610: 2548: 2418: 2214: 2040:
against a neighbouring country, and an obsession with using a disputed
2020: 1953: 1745: 1369: 1274: 1228: 1046: 1014: 807: 12692:
In the section labelled "Origins and identities" somebody wrote......
12490:
Archive of the Russian Ministry For Foreign Affairs,Year 1706, No. 7
12423:
Vitkovich,G "Glasnik Srpskog uchenog drushtva",67,1887,pp.128;pp.131
12282:
Horvat,K. "Glasnik zemaljskog muzeja u Bosni i Hercegovini" XXI,1909
12228:
Adrianopol,in der Stadt Ochrida,in der Grantzen Epiri und Servien) .
7662:
Why don't you ask Makedon35, after all he's a Slavophone from Greece.
6158:
Suddenly genetics? What are you talking about? What do you think that
4960:
policy does require that we mention the existence of those claims. --
1580:
If that kind of think is allowed, maybe we could get support from the
12857:
were simply Slavs divided into some tribes (Brsjaci, Strumjani etc.)
12217:
Ant.Bonfini "Rerum Hungarii Indec." II lib IX,Viennae, 1774 pp.248a
12197:
Bogdan,J. "Archiv fur Slavische philologie" 13, 1891,pp.481; pp.493
11427:
that source, then you need to explicitely mention that it applies to
10923: 10539: 10099: 10083: 10059: 10051: 10047: 9908: 9623: 9391:"Macedonians" and "Macedonian people" are interchangeable, just like 8789: 8781: 8764: 8756: 8337: 8326: 6767: 6762: 6694: 6690: 6686: 6496: 6477: 6445:
In some circumstances, genes can be inherited (see a famous example:
6251: 6247: 6243: 3998: 3536: 3256: 3249: 2557: 2463: 2249: 2229:
and therefore cannot be used. Am I not saying it right or something?
2044:
and national flag to identify himself. Who is the nationalist here?--
1149: 1041: 1037: 836: 748: 13252:
reliable to figure out the total number of Macedonians in Greece. -
12896:
15. The Bulgarians in Macedonia? Only immigrants. Not autochtonous.
12612:
On the subject of appearance of the male name "Srbin" (a Serb) ,see:
12479:
Trifunoski,F.J. "Makedoniziranje Juzhne Srbije" Beograd 1995 pp.24
12443:
Theiner,A." Vetera. Monum. Slav. Mer. Histor. Ill." II, 1875,pp 213
12351:
Dimitrijevich.S. "Spom. Srp. Kralj. Akad." 38, 1908 pp.60a, pp 60b
12345:
Archive of the Russian Ministry Of Foreign Affairs, Year 7142,No 8
11853:
is really about the "Macedonian Greeks" why would it mention Greeks
11831:"... to serve the Turk, such as Greeks, Bulgarians, Macedonians ..." 11084: 10696:
there were strong waves of Hellenization and later on, Romanization.
7721: 5600:
The Secretary of State to Certain Diplomatic and Consular Officers*
4662:
I also wonder what we need to discuss about? Which precise moments?
1202:
about this issue. I think that might help you understand the truth.
183:
countries (probably around the same numbers, but how would I know?)?
12256:
Fermendzhin,E. "Acta Bosniae" "Monum. Slav. Mer. XXIII 1892 pp.39
12001: 11916: 11334: 11096: 11076: 11068: 10620: 10595: 10284: 9347: 8876: 8725: 7736: 7691: 7653:
means. Will someone be kind enough to translate it into English? --
6860:
is the perfect example of the absurdity of striving for a national
6819: 6492: 6277:
ancient peoples---again, by genes. Not keratin or calcium content.
5694:. It simply does not deserve to see the daylight. Pure propaganda. 5481: 5402: 5299: 5211: 5131:
http://en.wikipedia.org/Wikipedia:Naming_conflict#Overlapping_names
5113: 5038: 5000: 4895: 4844: 4492: 4458: 4401: 4283: 4222: 4208: 4194: 4176: 4124: 4090: 4006: 3949: 3935: 3888: 3736: 3713: 3691: 3399: 3315: 3229: 3063: 2783: 2759: 2717: 2622: 2422: 2297: 2287: 2230: 2146: 2041: 1912: 1801: 1749: 1729: 1667: 1601: 1539: 1469: 1460: 1442: 1153: 943:
the human rights was not important to anyone who was not concerned?
725: 12370:
Dimitrijevich,S. "Glasnik Srpske kraljevske akademije", 58,1900.
12224:
Novakovich.S. "Glasnik Srpskog uchenog drushtva" 21,1867, pp.154
12163:
Mikloshich,F & Muller,J. "Acta et diplomata" I, 1860, pp.571
11590:, Marko Kraida born in Kosana and Dimitri Georgi Popovic, born in 9351: 7870:
think you helped me make a point to all the readers of this page.
7278:
If both versions are accurate, then this should also be accurate.
7040:
Also, please do not erase the numbers that Macedonian communities
5485: 5408: 5305: 5217: 5117: 5042: 5004: 4899: 4848: 4496: 4462: 4405: 4226: 4212: 4198: 4180: 4128: 4094: 4010: 3939: 3740: 3717: 3695: 3608:
evidence they give which hints at / proves there is a relationship
3405: 3321: 3235: 3067: 2787: 2763: 2721: 2626: 2472:
descriptive titles, or by adding terms in brackets. We could have
2426: 2421:
in fact, calls it Macedonian language and the poeple Macedonians.
2301: 2291: 2234: 2150: 1916: 1805: 1753: 1733: 1671: 1605: 1543: 1527:. Their currency like everything else is part of their propaganda. 13085:
User Macedonia is inserting the following text into the article:
12211:
Novakovich,S, "Glasnik Srpskog uchenog drushtva" 22,1867,pp.287
12183:
Mikloshich,F. & Joseph,M. "Acta et dipolomata",1862, pp.260
12169:
Jorga,N. "Geschiste des Osmanischen Reiches" Vol.I, cap IV,pp241
11878: 11768: 11706: 11064: 10212: 10204: 10055: 9819: 9392: 9165: 9045: 9014: 8844: 8709: 8602: 8553: 8517: 8341: 8330: 8119:
I can't see how that is relevant here. There is no indication at
7840: 6811: 6698: 6598:
Anything that is unreferenced does not belong on Knowledge. See
6255: 5527: 5196:
Any potential ambiguities have been solved by naming the article
4683:
Knowledge:Talk_page_guidelines#What_may_talk_pages_be_used_for.3F
3532: 2893:
what you are told in FYROM schools, that's a fact, face with it.
2320: 862: 821:
Can we address the outrage of Greeks at finding the ancient name
595:, and not by arbitrary page moves by individual administrators.-- 388:
Points that should be in this article - or in a related article:
12934: 12296:
Acta. S. Congr. Vol.3. Fol.24 A D Congr. diie 20 decembris 1622
11399:. So here is the source, Mr X's credible, neutral, and unbiased 10396:
boy. Knowledge is about Academic information. For the rest, see
10283:
stock is unknown, nor does it change the fact that the peoples'
8183:
as part of a government-sponsored process called "Hellenization"
7716: 6685:
ancestry includes an element of autochthonic groups such as the
4956:
We don't have to endorse or reject such claims, but Knowledge's
2758:
This has nothing to do with me, I am not Macedonian, nor Greek.
178:
I suggest that we concentrate our mental efforts on two things:
12571:
Ruestow, W "Der Krieg in der Tuerkey 1875-1876", Zurich, 1876
12357:
Archive of the Russian Ministry For Foreign Affairs,Year 7156
12243:
Stojanovich,Lj."Stari Srpski zapisi i natpisi" I,1902 ,pp.752
11514:... the Macedonians formed the basic majority of the population 11318: 11136: 10998: 10989: 10919: 10771:
This is what the NPOV policy calls "undue weight". There is no
10716: 10646: 10616: 10584:'s quotation of a 3rd c. BC Macedonian embassador to Aetolia (" 10352: 10311: 10301: 10280: 10272: 10075: 10071: 10033: 10007: 9992: 9619: 9084: 8880: 8396:
Yeah this hoax has been previously discussed and discovered in
8125:
adding back unverified information while it has been questioned
7929: 6815: 6567: 6362:). Therefore, saying "some" genes is inaccurate. You could say 5554:
only ones living inside their borders. Science fiction story...
3498: 3218: 3055: 2976: 2609:
is a nationalist. That you can CLEARLY see from his user page.
2523: 2378:
a disambiguation page? That's the only NPOV way, cope with it.
1352: 1157: 871:
This clearly describes us as the "mistaken side". Is that fair?
12794:
Among these most eminent abuse men was damn unbeliever Karposh
12532:"Scritture rif. nei congressi - Servia. Vol. III", marzo 1790 12473:"Scritture riferite nei congressi - Servia.Vol. I, Fol. 120" 11395:
called the Slavonic language spoken by locals in Macedonia as
11005:
nation that calls itself Egyptian (with a much better reason).
10641:
Tombseye what are you talking about? The specimen used by the
6864:, which, in recent history turned some people into some quite 6482:...genetic make-up of a Macedonian includes some genes from... 4771:
I wish this could happen. It is enought with double standards.
12377:"Filologicheskaja nabljudenija A.H. Vostokova".1865, pp.184 11674: 11641:
Another interesting quote, from Allen Upward (1907-1908) ...
11474:" clearly differentiating the Bulgarians and the Macedonians. 10276: 10216: 9944: 8872: 8259:
Even today, the Greek government denies their existence as a
7722:"An online review of Macedonian affairs, history and culture" 7097:
Well, we won't furnish false information in that way. We are
6903: 6546: 6417: 6343: 6239: 6092:
Come on people, let the other people (Macedonians) breathe...
5872: 5476: 5460: 5265:
Knowledge:Naming conflict#Dealing with self-identifying terms
4168:, whereas a search for Macedonian Slavs gives 15,900 results 3540: 2556:
You didn't have that problem when you supported REX labeling
1559:
for this organization of POV push. I know that the mediator (
1524: 1430:
Knowledge:Naming conflict#Dealing with self-identifying terms
815: 12645:
P.Draganov "Makedonsko-Slavjanskii Sbornik" pp.VIII (n.d.)
12336:...Giorgio Bjanchi, Arciv d' Antivari et Primate di Servia. 11461:
Evidence of the Existence of Macedonians Throughout the Ages
9860:
what indigenous populations they were actually referring. --
7726: 6499:. Even your Y chromosome is not identical to your father's. 5991:
The Bulgarian repression in Macedonia (1914-1918, 1941-1945)
5948:
Anyway, the important thing is that is left far back in the
5459:
Unknown... Yeah... In today's time of high technologies and
3519:
language. By 5th century BC Macedonians participated in the
2911:
So, many of the new generations know the language much less.
1623:, but as I told him before he could have read the poll. And 1592:. I'm sure that many people would help us NPOV push against 1455:
naming these people against their will and against the facts
13266:
has countinually been reverting my edits from the article.
12730:
AHHHHH but there was no PRO MACEDONIAN FACTION to be sure.
12041:
Surname endings changes since 1913 in the ex-Turkish Empire
11857:
Macedonians, unless they were considered a separate people?
11002: 10993: 10393: 10082:
was simply passed down because the Balkan inhabitants were
10042: 9680:
Also, it would be good thing to add the Greeks, as well. --
8317: 6731: 6432: 6296: 6181: 4395:
is rejecting it for a reason that I haven't understood yet.
3598:
It would be better to leave this as an unsettled question.
1413: 803: 398:
Tito's role in the formation and/or break-up of Yugloslavia
140:
The renaming poll of June 2005 (now closed) is archived at
11615:- A note by teacher Gjorgija Makedonski about his origins. 11455:
Medieval sources traditionally describe them as Bulgarians
9923:
developed naturally from such old traditional concepts as
7843:
demographic census on the area which is summarised below:
7782:
What's with the "go away greeks" thing? Weren't the Slavs
7250:
is a expression I always use. I don't know about you, but
6230:
I am cutting the disputed paragraph to this Talk page for
5919:
So, what is your comment on this, brave Wikipedians? :) --
3587:
I don't think Knowledge should endorse the point of view (
2971:
The above is ofcourse not restricted to Slavomacedonians.
2488:. You are free to use the word, but that doesn't mean you 839:
and to call themselves by a name which shows their chosen
739:
I did a little digging, and I've discovered that there is
11277:. So there was no reason to take that part out Miskin. - 10964: 8027:
Ok, that's your opinion which I respect, but back in the
6554: 6337: 3918:
Would you like to have another poll? Also, I you look at
2516:
page, the Slavic origin of the language is clearly shown.
2366:
and stop haggling, this is a disgrace. If we can specify
1589: 1581: 1486: 10645:
as representative of Alexander's armies was from modern
8361:
not to pour oil in the fire or anything (hoho), but has
7850:
Vilaeti of Thessaloniki Greeks: 373,227 Bulgars: 207,317
7768:
of them like that, right? There must have been at least
6184:(in this context at least) are relevant to the realm of 3731:
a one night consensus? That is how pages are moved (see
296:
Briefly describe the history of "the Macedonian nation".
12963:
can be made for nearly all ethnic or regional parties.
12289:"Snoshenia Rossii po djelam cerkovnim" II, 1860 pp.29 11238:. You don't have the right to claim "Pavlos Melas said 8178:
was in fact forcibly instigated by Greece (as implied).
3595:" are completely unrelated to the ancient Makedonians. 3268: 1005:
This issue is not about someones wish. It is not about
9389:- If I recall recent history it's not correct to say: 8452:
aren't that productive either. I urge you to consider
7732:"Macedonia, The Historical Profile of Northern Greece" 7268:
Can't you merge both versions or something? Like say:
6730:. Now, I acknowledge that I may have misused the term 6435:, but it seems to affirm that genes can be inherited. 4236:
Theathenae might have missed the comments I posted to
1971:
How nice that you all agree, again. Almost as nice as
734:
Rex is right - about the title of the article, anyway.
465:
Who else (outside of Knowledge) feels the same as you?
7855:
Vilaeti of Monastiri Greeks: 261,283 Bulgars: 178,412
5350:
Maybe this will get as a shock to you, but here is a
2029:. He even disputes the fact that 51% of geographical 325:
Who is promoting their history and culture as theirs?
12712:
These are the ignorant foreigners i was speaing of.
12410:Heylin,P. "Cosmographie in four books" London,1666 11779:. Check the definition of "Romaic" in a dictionary. 11544:, Albanians, Esclavinians, Rasians and Serbians ..." 9891:
Uh, okay, but aren't you the same guy who said that
7438:
Thank you for the understanding, Izehar :-) Cheers,
5512:
against Greece for represion against the members of
2849:
should try to travel a little through those regions.
2417:
Because no one calls it Slavic Macedonian language.
404:
Where they came from, what language they spoke, etc.
13206:
activists--being followed, threatened and harassed.
12249:Crusius, M. "Turcogreciae libri octo", 1584, pp.5 12237:Matkovich.P."Rad. Jugosl. Akad." 124,1895, pp.131 10954:Yes, those are all valid points. When I edited the 6487:wrong though. Unless, you are trying to prove that 3799:is talking about the titles inside the text of the 3784:
So, the title of the article is disputed, again? --
11911:at the time. You "Macedonian Slav" national hero, 8528:before making edits, but he obviously ignored me. 8378:marker to prove anything you want, in genetics :) 7860:Santzaki of Scopje Greeks: 13,452 Bulgars: 172,735 6902:who were being punished for their siding with the 3308:economy that Greece is still struggling to match. 2476:, that would be unproblematic. We could also have 1635:on the poll should be checked by the Med's. And I 365:saw that there is no need to fear from each other. 12579:Veselinovich,V.M. "Brsjachka Buna" Beograd 1905 9850:book again myself and also look for its sources. 9614:Macedonian regional identity... Those people are 6342:...genetic make-up of a Macedonian includes some 4908:Duplicate article... that might help, as well. -- 3583:Modern and ancient Macedonian culture / ethnicity 2111:This is not the first time he uses these methods. 1418:el:Συζήτηση χρήστη:Kalogeropoulos#θερμή παράκληση 1412:and I noticed that people have been "plotting" a 12718:Very nice oversimplification of the situation:) 12430:Fermendzhin E., "Starine" 25, 1892. pp. 195-196 12276:"Snoshenia Rossii po djelam cerkovnim" ,I,1858 9330:that's more than twice as many. Anyway, we have 6466:So why did you say, "You cannot inherit genes"? 6234:. References, and re-wording, are both needed. 783:If you agree, I will be more than glad to help. 413:Also, several more articles has to be included. 12498:part of its inhabitants are Serbs (Raitzen) . 12231:Gerlach,S. "Tage-Buch",Frankfurt,1674, pp.64a 9899:(see above)? And as long as you brought it up: 7599:Also, Makedon45, I wish to start improving the 7246:Miskin, you are really flattering to yourself. 2484:things known by the same name, which calls for 1366:There weren't Macedonians due to the 20 century 894:Ottomans didn't managed to do during 500 years? 13099:He is backing it up with the following source 10872:, and promoted land-claims in Northern Greece. 8340:schools with 9,544 Bulgarian students, and 21 8329:schools with 8,767 Bulgarian students, and 37 5519:Why is the world playing blind on these issue? 4638:unless we specify what is the disputed content 2319:is not I. I am not even Thracian; I'm a proud 12843:My point is exactly as Krste Misirkov said, 12116:Ciao, Aldux! Let me quote them, just in case. 11470:- The anonymous Hungarian chronicler writes " 10813:'s page to get the hint. Basically if we let 10098:to possibly weigh in on this problem and how 9823:of the Greek Ministry of Culture and Science. 9745:mention Thracians, Vlach and Illyrians? :-)-- 8922:, and nobody would care enough to remove it. 7951:is missing from your list (BTW, a vilayet is 7712:Please, I couldn't have laughed any harder. 7179:. Bomac, if you revert one more time, you'll 4373:name Macedonia and is only used unofficially. 4085:. Also, i cannot see any reason not to apply 3803:page. Not about the title of the page itself. 3248:In many countries north of Greece, there was 3004:"Macedonia". That won't happen, deal with it. 2244:English is clearly not your native language. 1271:Macedonia (region)#Boundaries and definitions 435:, mean when you refer to "Macedonian" people? 12324:"Arch. S. Congr. Visitte.Vol 16. Fol. 239. 11449:Existence of Macedonians Throughout the Ages 8279:I don't understand your objection regarding 8152:to provide sources for the following edits: 7674:Yea, Miskin, try to act a little bit nicer. 6623:I agree. I have not reverted you or Izehar. 5745:Populations of ethnic Macedonians by country 4193:requires the name "Macedonians" to be used. 3896:In that sense, the overnight page move from 2221:). Very dishonest, tut tut! Ethnologue is a 747:of group these "Macedonians" are, is a real 531:I know. And, that is all I want. Fair game. 9635:, so there would be no confusions. Cheers, 8174:" - Please prove to me that such a factual 8077:. For example my latest edits are based on 7140:BTW, what about the merging proposal? :) -- 4173:Knowledge:Naming conventions (common names) 4079:Knowledge:Naming conventions (common names) 2879:Don't worry about my traveling experiences 2141:contributions. POV pushing! You Swedish ID 963:forces and only NATO member on the Balkan). 12515:Milutinovich,S."Istorija Crne Gore",1835 12390:Fermendzhin,E. "Starine" 25,1892, pp.194 12364:Fermendzhin,E. "Starine" 25,1892, pp.172 12204:Kachanovski,V. "Starine" 12,1880 ,pp.255 11629:because we are Macedonians, and not Greeks 10615:Genetic testing revealed that most of the 8867:? Would you like me to go around changing 8441:this page to deal with the mind-boggling 7932:. The demography I provided was data from 7423:And you will be the main character in it. 6476:An innoccent mistake, you can't inherit a 5909:in Bulgaria (the both POVs, of course). -- 1967:will we have a second one-night-consensus? 1627:the poll cannot be interpreted as binary. 1491:Talk:Former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia 587:I have restored the original nomenclature 148:for many comments arising from this poll.) 10119:summed up the argument for keeping it at 3050:says that there are 180,180 speakers of " 2282:Ha ha ha ha ha! Don't make me laugh! OK, 2213:Hmm, how did he make a contribution? Via 627:Annual Worldwide Press Freedom Index 2005 10784:. This is called attributing the view.-- 9422:, not to an even more inaccurrate name. 8599:I have removed the following paragraph: 5036:Please tell us what you are disputing!!! 3479:I've moved the following content out of 3007:Maybe you should read what nation means. 2692:matter the Bulgarians are mostly Slavic. 2145:has been BANNED for that kind of thing. 11775:to get a clue. Byzantine == Greek, see 11536:... to serve the Turk, such as Greeks, 7187:. Miskin, you're nearly there as well. 2968:Greeks or Serbs a nation didn't exist. 691:I do not hate Greece. I hate unjustice. 14: 12221:prishel jesi k' Gradou Sardaskomu) . 10041:means citizens of the city of ancient 9316:. It can't be that wrong to call them 8462:Knowledge:Requests for page protection 8316:Instituto Geografico de Argostini" of 7551:additions sometimes really annoy me... 7191:edit summaries don't help either. The 6937:To quote Britannica as you requested: 6856:Yes, I believe they are! In fact, the 6553:", though more specifically they mean 6242:from autochthonous groups such as the 5200:and not "Macedonians" plain. How many 2824:it was discussed and analysed and the 1040:who became a separate nation from the 223:Can you explain any of the following? 44:Do not edit the contents of this page. 12190:Ljubich,S. "Listine" 4,1874, pp.437 9312:them "Macedonians" well, as does the 7846:Ethnic census of Hilmi Pasha (1904): 5929:Sources for serb repression in 1930s? 1422:el:Συζήτηση χρήστη:Matia.gr#Arvanites 11410:published by Routledge (UK), called 10587:reasons that change from day to day. 10026:I know what Roman colonists includes 6570:, where one may have expected them. 1355:. And, I don't blame them at all... 113:Previous discussion is available at 25: 11586:This is to inform you that the two 9903:was a matter of citizenship in the 9318:by the name they use for themselves 8464:or ask me on my talk page. Thanks. 7751:"Go away Greeks, we don't want you" 5470:Can't even fix a cup of tea... :-) 1588:is an administrator there) and the 660:The European Court for Human rights 23: 12404:Fermendzhin,E. "Starine" 25 ,pp18 10744:Not moved per lack of consensus. — 9657:"Possibly the ancient Macedonians" 8739:The name "Anatanasoski is made up" 8686:And about the Hellenization part, 8622:I removed the following sentence: 7880:326,426 Slavs (mostly Macedonians) 7579:. So the total will add upto some 4049:that setled here 15 centuries ago. 2286:is a good friend of mine, too :-) 24: 13347: 12333:....Prisren, il di 29 ottobre... 12305:Visite e Colllegi, Vo.1 f66r-82r 12039:Hi Zikicam :-) Let's start from " 11412:Dialogos: Hellenic Studies Review 9301:the people "Macedonians" and the 8159:- Please prove to me that around 7183:be really close to violating the 5516:, the Macedonian party in Greece? 5480:. Talk about living in denial... 4331:nationalism too. From all sides. 13224:. Please dont revert any more. - 12006:→ Тодор Божинов / Todor Bozhinov 12000: 11598:... and way the above-mentioned 11502:Beginning of the 13th century AD 11403:that you said you wanted above. 11362:Bulgarian Archbishopric of Ohrid 9350: 8478:reference for that. So to quote 7490:In that sentence, there is only 5962: 5712:I've reverted the last edits by 5698: 5651: 5565: 5534: 5484: 5441: 5407: 5359: 5321: 5304: 5216: 5177: 5116: 5094: 5041: 5021: 5003: 4976: 4940: 4898: 4868: 4847: 4793: 4743: 4666: 4615: 4547: 4495: 4461: 4438: 4404: 4335: 4225: 4211: 4197: 4179: 4150: 4127: 4093: 4056: 4009: 3938: 3855: 3810: 3739: 3716: 3694: 3668: 3654:link towards some of the sources 3567: 3404: 3360: 3320: 3234: 3200: 3102: 3066: 3018: 2939: 2863: 2786: 2762: 2743: 2720: 2700: 2657:ancient Macedonian civilization. 2625: 2585: 2530: 2425: 2403: 2338: 2300: 2290: 2267: 2233: 2196: 2149: 2126: 2001: 1934: 1915: 1883:I agree with this approach. The 1827: 1804: 1752: 1732: 1711: 1670: 1639:what kind of thinking is allowed 1604: 1596:'s dishonest tactics. Let's ask 1567: 1542: 1385: 1249: 1206: 1123: 572: 535: 509: 478: 452: 417: 395:Tax relief for converts to Islam 377: 347: 312: 285: 243: 227:What is "the Macedonian nation"? 29: 13146:Easier said than done... :-( -- 13049:"Strong resistance" during WW2? 10058:, or whatever) and began using 10032:colonists, but not necessarily 8615:place, which is something that 8148:In that respect, I demand from 7611:UCLA Language Materials Project 7513:Macedonian speaking Macedonians 6222:Paragraph cut here for citation 5506:European court for human rights 5380:The Council of Europe's website 18:Talk:Macedonians (ethnic group) 12945:, without any justification. 12941:This sentence was reverted by 11815:by Bertrandon de la Brocuiere; 11071:and group labels derived from 10918:Hear, hear. Isn't the list of 8716:is called the co-capital, and 8374:fronts, and (b) you will find 8234:Slavic placenames still exist. 7363:sense. Is this OK :-) Cheers, 6994:13:19, 13 December 2005 (UTC) 5860:2.300 (2003 est Macédonienne)( 4994:oops, doesn't that sound like 3438:Yet another treatment without 1897:Knowledge:No original research 1650:doesn't apply on my comments. 973:hosting server (www.150m.com)? 637:ranks Greece 18 in its annual 13: 1: 13064:The Matter would solve itself 12494:- Albania. Vol. V, Fol. 175" 11317:. The question is from whom? 10310:there; in actuality, even an 8973:13:57, 31 December 2005 (UTC) 8955:19:10, 28 December 2005 (UTC) 8940:20:46, 30 December 2005 (UTC) 8927:20:40, 30 December 2005 (UTC) 8909:10:55, 30 December 2005 (UTC) 8898:01:55, 30 December 2005 (UTC) 8888:01:55, 30 December 2005 (UTC) 8814:21:35, 29 December 2005 (UTC) 8804:20:49, 29 December 2005 (UTC) 8744:You just linked to websites ( 8645:16:47, 29 December 2005 (UTC) 8585:16:45, 29 December 2005 (UTC) 8533:15:28, 28 December 2005 (UTC) 8507:15:04, 28 December 2005 (UTC) 8469:12:03, 28 December 2005 (UTC) 8427:12:15, 30 December 2005 (UTC) 8405:00:36, 28 December 2005 (UTC) 8392:18:04, 27 December 2005 (UTC) 8352:03:04, 28 December 2005 (UTC) 8309:18:39, 26 December 2005 (UTC) 8288:18:23, 26 December 2005 (UTC) 8274:17:39, 26 December 2005 (UTC) 8252:02:45, 28 December 2005 (UTC) 8141:17:39, 26 December 2005 (UTC) 8132:10:56, 26 December 2005 (UTC) 8098:03:28, 26 December 2005 (UTC) 8036:00:08, 28 December 2005 (UTC) 7960:18:28, 27 December 2005 (UTC) 7942:18:32, 26 December 2005 (UTC) 7830:15:10, 23 December 2005 (UTC) 7808:15:04, 23 December 2005 (UTC) 7796:12:18, 23 December 2005 (UTC) 7778:12:18, 23 December 2005 (UTC) 7704:03:26, 23 December 2005 (UTC) 7667:16:02, 21 December 2005 (UTC) 7658:15:43, 21 December 2005 (UTC) 7623:20:45, 20 December 2005 (UTC) 7562:15:57, 21 December 2005 (UTC) 7534:01:33, 20 December 2005 (UTC) 7520:01:29, 20 December 2005 (UTC) 7503:22:58, 19 December 2005 (UTC) 7482:19:58, 19 December 2005 (UTC) 7467:19:47, 19 December 2005 (UTC) 7456:18:02, 19 December 2005 (UTC) 7443:17:58, 19 December 2005 (UTC) 7428:16:28, 21 December 2005 (UTC) 7411:15:53, 21 December 2005 (UTC) 7395:17:46, 19 December 2005 (UTC) 7368:17:38, 19 December 2005 (UTC) 7351:17:31, 19 December 2005 (UTC) 7333:17:27, 19 December 2005 (UTC) 7316:17:24, 19 December 2005 (UTC) 7303:17:21, 19 December 2005 (UTC) 7288:17:17, 19 December 2005 (UTC) 7239:15:48, 21 December 2005 (UTC) 7226:17:13, 19 December 2005 (UTC) 7205:17:05, 19 December 2005 (UTC) 7159:00:07, 14 December 2005 (UTC) 7145:23:17, 13 December 2005 (UTC) 7136:23:17, 13 December 2005 (UTC) 7123:23:17, 13 December 2005 (UTC) 7089:17:38, 13 December 2005 (UTC) 7074:16:53, 13 December 2005 (UTC) 7036:16:38, 13 December 2005 (UTC) 7021:15:23, 21 December 2005 (UTC) 7004:13:19, 13 December 2005 (UTC) 6976:02:41, 13 December 2005 (UTC) 6963:15:37, 21 December 2005 (UTC) 6947:15:34, 21 December 2005 (UTC) 6933:15:26, 21 December 2005 (UTC) 6911:19:46, 12 December 2005 (UTC) 6824:, that is laid there without 6575:06:09, 29 December 2005 (UTC) 6562:04:38, 29 December 2005 (UTC) 6336:I think you're talking about 5740:11:05, 29 November 2005 (UTC) 5683:02:10, 27 November 2005 (UTC) 5540:05:38, 19 November 2005 (UTC) 5490:15:35, 16 November 2005 (UTC) 5468:15:32, 16 November 2005 (UTC) 5413:11:33, 20 November 2005 (UTC) 5365:15:12, 24 November 2005 (UTC) 5327:05:57, 19 November 2005 (UTC) 5310:00:13, 19 November 2005 (UTC) 5249:00:06, 19 November 2005 (UTC) 5222:23:30, 18 November 2005 (UTC) 5183:05:57, 19 November 2005 (UTC) 5146:23:25, 18 November 2005 (UTC) 5122:19:15, 14 November 2005 (UTC) 5100:05:32, 19 November 2005 (UTC) 5083:19:04, 14 November 2005 (UTC) 5047:18:54, 14 November 2005 (UTC) 5027:05:32, 19 November 2005 (UTC) 5009:18:54, 14 November 2005 (UTC) 4982:05:32, 19 November 2005 (UTC) 4965:18:47, 14 November 2005 (UTC) 4946:05:17, 19 November 2005 (UTC) 4922:18:07, 14 November 2005 (UTC) 4913:02:57, 13 November 2005 (UTC) 4904:00:19, 13 November 2005 (UTC) 4874:05:32, 19 November 2005 (UTC) 4853:19:44, 14 November 2005 (UTC) 4835:19:35, 14 November 2005 (UTC) 4799:05:17, 19 November 2005 (UTC) 4763:19:19, 14 November 2005 (UTC) 4749:08:56, 13 November 2005 (UTC) 4725:00:13, 13 November 2005 (UTC) 4704:23:06, 12 November 2005 (UTC) 4690:23:37, 12 November 2005 (UTC) 4672:08:56, 13 November 2005 (UTC) 4653:23:37, 12 November 2005 (UTC) 4621:08:56, 13 November 2005 (UTC) 4605:22:34, 12 November 2005 (UTC) 4590:22:14, 12 November 2005 (UTC) 4580:22:02, 12 November 2005 (UTC) 4553:08:47, 13 November 2005 (UTC) 4530:14:17, 12 November 2005 (UTC) 4501:23:13, 11 November 2005 (UTC) 4486:21:06, 11 November 2005 (UTC) 4467:20:48, 11 November 2005 (UTC) 4444:08:47, 13 November 2005 (UTC) 4425:20:39, 11 November 2005 (UTC) 4410:19:21, 11 November 2005 (UTC) 4341:08:47, 13 November 2005 (UTC) 4323:18:59, 11 November 2005 (UTC) 4300:18:45, 11 November 2005 (UTC) 4274:01:03, 10 November 2005 (UTC) 4231:17:10, 11 November 2005 (UTC) 4217:17:10, 11 November 2005 (UTC) 4203:17:10, 11 November 2005 (UTC) 4185:17:05, 11 November 2005 (UTC) 4156:08:47, 13 November 2005 (UTC) 4133:16:52, 11 November 2005 (UTC) 4115:15:24, 11 November 2005 (UTC) 4099:15:09, 11 November 2005 (UTC) 4062:08:47, 13 November 2005 (UTC) 4039:14:55, 11 November 2005 (UTC) 4015:13:36, 11 November 2005 (UTC) 3981:13:20, 11 November 2005 (UTC) 3944:13:06, 11 November 2005 (UTC) 3913:12:41, 11 November 2005 (UTC) 3861:08:24, 13 November 2005 (UTC) 3844:01:52, 11 November 2005 (UTC) 3816:08:24, 13 November 2005 (UTC) 3789:00:18, 11 November 2005 (UTC) 3768:22:40, 10 November 2005 (UTC) 3745:21:51, 10 November 2005 (UTC) 3722:21:48, 10 November 2005 (UTC) 3700:21:48, 10 November 2005 (UTC) 3674:08:24, 13 November 2005 (UTC) 3644:21:31, 10 November 2005 (UTC) 3628:21:11, 10 November 2005 (UTC) 3452:15:15, 24 November 2005 (UTC) 3410:22:35, 20 November 2005 (UTC) 3366:15:04, 24 November 2005 (UTC) 3348:22:29, 20 November 2005 (UTC) 3326:19:47, 19 November 2005 (UTC) 3281:19:39, 19 November 2005 (UTC) 3240:18:53, 19 November 2005 (UTC) 3206:15:04, 24 November 2005 (UTC) 3186:18:17, 19 November 2005 (UTC) 3149:12:47, 19 November 2005 (UTC) 3130:08:01, 19 November 2005 (UTC) 3108:05:46, 19 November 2005 (UTC) 3084:20:53, 15 November 2005 (UTC) 3072:20:19, 14 November 2005 (UTC) 3039:20:12, 14 November 2005 (UTC) 3024:08:10, 13 November 2005 (UTC) 2122:has control over the region. 1278:13:40, 10 December 2005 (UTC) 810:and the desire to create an " 639:Worldwide Press Freedom Index 13334:05:00, 9 February 2006 (UTC) 13320:04:53, 9 February 2006 (UTC) 13299:04:36, 9 February 2006 (UTC) 13286:04:35, 9 February 2006 (UTC) 13276:21:54, 8 February 2006 (UTC) 13246:22:43, 6 February 2006 (UTC) 13190:22:32, 6 February 2006 (UTC) 13172:22:29, 6 February 2006 (UTC) 13156:22:22, 6 February 2006 (UTC) 13135:22:14, 6 February 2006 (UTC) 13112:21:48, 6 February 2006 (UTC) 13073:19:19, 1 February 2006 (UTC) 13059:03:16, 1 February 2006 (UTC) 13044:23:28, 24 January 2006 (UTC) 13034:17:40, 24 January 2006 (UTC) 13002:23:04, 21 January 2006 (UTC) 12990:17:22, 31 January 2006 (UTC) 12968:21:03, 21 January 2006 (UTC) 12957:19:13, 21 January 2006 (UTC) 12924:Slavic macedonians in Greece 12919:20:08, 23 January 2006 (UTC) 12820:17:35, 22 January 2006 (UTC) 12757:18:30, 19 January 2006 (UTC) 12746:17:59, 19 January 2006 (UTC) 12675:23:20, 17 January 2006 (UTC) 12450:Theiner,A. ibidem, pp. 220 12108:22:49, 17 January 2006 (UTC) 12090:21:31, 17 January 2006 (UTC) 12060:18:58, 17 January 2006 (UTC) 12034:00:29, 17 January 2006 (UTC) 12012:10:32, 16 January 2006 (UTC) 11946:17:53, 1 February 2006 (UTC) 11928:16:56, 1 February 2006 (UTC) 11869:16:56, 1 February 2006 (UTC) 11784:16:56, 1 February 2006 (UTC) 11321:and central Greece was also 11184:irrelevant or out of place. 9701:reference for Thracians? -- 9305:Macedonian. Guess what, the 8879:and never to the villaet of 8698:and altered religious icons. 8333:schools with 1,142 students. 7258:to me. REGARDS, Miskin from 6887:01:05, 9 December 2005 (UTC) 6873:00:32, 9 December 2005 (UTC) 6848:12:15, 8 December 2005 (UTC) 6833:10:20, 8 December 2005 (UTC) 6800:10:20, 8 December 2005 (UTC) 6790:10:20, 8 December 2005 (UTC) 6775:09:33, 6 December 2005 (UTC) 6757:07:37, 6 December 2005 (UTC) 6743:06:49, 6 December 2005 (UTC) 6664:21:10, 5 December 2005 (UTC) 6650:21:07, 5 December 2005 (UTC) 6628:21:16, 5 December 2005 (UTC) 6615:21:14, 5 December 2005 (UTC) 6593:21:06, 5 December 2005 (UTC) 6534:23:11, 8 December 2005 (UTC) 6529:policy - and rightly so. -- 6520:19:50, 8 December 2005 (UTC) 6511:21:10, 5 December 2005 (UTC) 6471:20:59, 5 December 2005 (UTC) 6461:20:55, 5 December 2005 (UTC) 6440:20:46, 5 December 2005 (UTC) 6425:20:32, 5 December 2005 (UTC) 6410:20:27, 5 December 2005 (UTC) 6393:20:22, 5 December 2005 (UTC) 6378:20:19, 5 December 2005 (UTC) 6328:20:01, 5 December 2005 (UTC) 6316:19:59, 5 December 2005 (UTC) 6291:19:54, 5 December 2005 (UTC) 6282:19:52, 5 December 2005 (UTC) 6267:19:46, 5 December 2005 (UTC) 6217:19:43, 5 December 2005 (UTC) 6200:19:40, 5 December 2005 (UTC) 6171:19:37, 5 December 2005 (UTC) 6153:19:30, 5 December 2005 (UTC) 6132:19:16, 5 December 2005 (UTC) 6122:19:10, 5 December 2005 (UTC) 6101:18:03, 5 December 2005 (UTC) 6084:18:00, 5 December 2005 (UTC) 6070:17:55, 5 December 2005 (UTC) 6060:17:51, 5 December 2005 (UTC) 6050:16:33, 5 December 2005 (UTC) 6030:23:55, 16 January 2006 (UTC) 6016:21:53, 15 January 2006 (UTC) 6001:00:43, 15 January 2006 (UTC) 5983:21:23, 15 January 2006 (UTC) 5968:00:57, 4 December 2005 (UTC) 5938:13:56, 1 December 2005 (UTC) 5924:01:22, 1 December 2005 (UTC) 5914:01:22, 1 December 2005 (UTC) 5881:01:22, 1 December 2005 (UTC) 5704:00:49, 4 December 2005 (UTC) 5657:00:46, 4 December 2005 (UTC) 5571:00:46, 4 December 2005 (UTC) 5455:No. of Macedonians in Greece 5447:00:33, 4 December 2005 (UTC) 5384:The European Union's website 4083:Knowledge:Naming conventions 3976:official Knowledge policy.-- 3887:, so helpfully linked to by 3708:Here's a thought, why don't 3573:04:22, 7 November 2005 (UTC) 3488:14:44, 6 November 2005 (UTC) 2984:19:41, 9 November 2005 (UTC) 2945:05:03, 9 November 2005 (UTC) 2901:21:08, 7 November 2005 (UTC) 2869:04:10, 7 November 2005 (UTC) 2838:13:20, 6 November 2005 (UTC) 2816:12:03, 6 November 2005 (UTC) 2792:08:44, 3 November 2005 (UTC) 2777:08:30, 3 November 2005 (UTC) 2768:14:17, 2 November 2005 (UTC) 2749:04:34, 4 November 2005 (UTC) 2726:13:04, 2 November 2005 (UTC) 2706:04:34, 4 November 2005 (UTC) 2671:12:56, 2 November 2005 (UTC) 2631:23:36, 1 November 2005 (UTC) 2614:16:11, 2 November 2005 (UTC) 2591:04:51, 2 November 2005 (UTC) 2570:23:28, 1 November 2005 (UTC) 2552:23:03, 1 November 2005 (UTC) 2536:04:51, 2 November 2005 (UTC) 2497:22:57, 1 November 2005 (UTC) 2474:Macedonian language (Slavic) 2455:23:27, 1 November 2005 (UTC) 2431:22:47, 1 November 2005 (UTC) 2409:04:51, 2 November 2005 (UTC) 2386:22:43, 1 November 2005 (UTC) 2344:04:51, 2 November 2005 (UTC) 2328:16:38, 1 November 2005 (UTC) 2306:16:34, 1 November 2005 (UTC) 2273:04:51, 2 November 2005 (UTC) 2257:16:30, 1 November 2005 (UTC) 2239:16:26, 1 November 2005 (UTC) 2202:04:51, 2 November 2005 (UTC) 2165:16:20, 1 November 2005 (UTC) 2155:16:10, 1 November 2005 (UTC) 2132:04:51, 2 November 2005 (UTC) 2049:15:59, 1 November 2005 (UTC) 2007:05:07, 2 November 2005 (UTC) 1985:18:51, 1 November 2005 (UTC) 1957:08:12, 31 October 2005 (UTC) 1940:01:43, 31 October 2005 (UTC) 1921:21:51, 30 October 2005 (UTC) 1878:20:55, 30 October 2005 (UTC) 1869:20:55, 30 October 2005 (UTC) 1833:05:00, 2 November 2005 (UTC) 1810:18:57, 1 November 2005 (UTC) 1772:18:44, 1 November 2005 (UTC) 1758:18:01, 1 November 2005 (UTC) 1738:18:57, 1 November 2005 (UTC) 1717:05:00, 2 November 2005 (UTC) 1697:18:36, 1 November 2005 (UTC) 1676:17:54, 1 November 2005 (UTC) 1660:17:38, 1 November 2005 (UTC) 1637:don't expect REX to dictate 1610:09:17, 31 October 2005 (UTC) 1573:01:32, 31 October 2005 (UTC) 1548:22:09, 30 October 2005 (UTC) 1473:15:27, 30 October 2005 (UTC) 1464:14:46, 30 October 2005 (UTC) 1450:A message from me to MATIA: 1446:14:46, 30 October 2005 (UTC) 1391:01:47, 31 October 2005 (UTC) 1373:13:16, 30 October 2005 (UTC) 1360:23:20, 29 October 2005 (UTC) 1303:22:24, 29 October 2005 (UTC) 1255:01:15, 4 December 2005 (UTC) 1232:13:56, 2 December 2005 (UTC) 1212:01:15, 4 December 2005 (UTC) 1174:12:28, 2 December 2005 (UTC) 1129:00:01, 30 October 2005 (UTC) 1097:22:43, 29 October 2005 (UTC) 1071:22:31, 29 October 2005 (UTC) 1050:22:12, 29 October 2005 (UTC) 1022:03:45, 29 October 2005 (UTC) 854:01:50, 29 October 2005 (UTC) 788:03:02, 29 October 2005 (UTC) 766:01:44, 29 October 2005 (UTC) 729:10:13, 28 October 2005 (UTC) 704:02:54, 29 October 2005 (UTC) 687:05:53, 28 October 2005 (UTC) 678:03:55, 28 October 2005 (UTC) 649:16:58, 27 October 2005 (UTC) 619:03:38, 28 October 2005 (UTC) 600:10:13, 27 October 2005 (UTC) 578:02:51, 1 November 2005 (UTC) 524:17:03, 31 October 2005 (UTC) 216:03:44, 27 October 2005 (UTC) 195:17:27, 26 October 2005 (UTC) 7: 12316:Lettere, vol. 7, f.36v-37r 11991:18:33, 7 January 2006 (UTC) 11982:17:39, 7 January 2006 (UTC) 11972:05:55, 7 January 2006 (UTC) 11960:02:46, 7 January 2006 (UTC) 11897:10:19, 9 January 2006 (UTC) 11755:13:04, 7 January 2006 (UTC) 11726:12:21, 7 January 2006 (UTC) 11693:10:56, 7 January 2006 (UTC) 11682:05:57, 7 January 2006 (UTC) 11664:13:47, 6 January 2006 (UTC) 11649:. The man himself had said 11570:16:35, 9 January 2006 (UTC) 11490:16:35, 9 January 2006 (UTC) 11472:Cives Bulgarom et Macedonum 11444:23:11, 6 January 2006 (UTC) 11381:20:47, 5 January 2006 (UTC) 11342:20:26, 5 January 2006 (UTC) 11301:20:35, 5 January 2006 (UTC) 11262:22:41, 4 January 2006 (UTC) 11252:20:45, 4 January 2006 (UTC) 11240:Newly conquered territories 11220:06:11, 6 January 2006 (UTC) 11202:18:14, 5 January 2006 (UTC) 11191:16:27, 5 January 2006 (UTC) 11170:11:51, 5 January 2006 (UTC) 11145:04:48, 5 January 2006 (UTC) 11117:00:51, 5 January 2006 (UTC) 11051:23:33, 4 January 2006 (UTC) 11033:22:09, 4 January 2006 (UTC) 10973:21:09, 4 January 2006 (UTC) 10945:17:29, 4 January 2006 (UTC) 10913:16:36, 4 January 2006 (UTC) 10898:21:41, 4 January 2006 (UTC) 10848:20:53, 4 January 2006 (UTC) 10830:20:30, 4 January 2006 (UTC) 10800:18:41, 4 January 2006 (UTC) 10789:16:36, 4 January 2006 (UTC) 10756:20:22, 9 January 2006 (UTC) 10740:06:42, 6 January 2006 (UTC) 10725:Roman province of Macedonia 10707:17:40, 4 January 2006 (UTC) 10683:06:01, 6 January 2006 (UTC) 10656:21:16, 5 January 2006 (UTC) 10629:18:36, 4 January 2006 (UTC) 10608:17:40, 4 January 2006 (UTC) 10561:22:54, 5 January 2006 (UTC) 10552:20:23, 5 January 2006 (UTC) 10520:11:41, 5 January 2006 (UTC) 10499:05:04, 5 January 2006 (UTC) 10474:04:50, 5 January 2006 (UTC) 10452:04:47, 5 January 2006 (UTC) 10427:04:42, 5 January 2006 (UTC) 10405:04:36, 5 January 2006 (UTC) 10378:04:32, 5 January 2006 (UTC) 10360:04:22, 5 January 2006 (UTC) 10341:18:30, 4 January 2006 (UTC) 10327:09:58, 4 January 2006 (UTC) 10254:18:20, 4 January 2006 (UTC) 10232:08:30, 4 January 2006 (UTC) 10209:Ancient Macedonian language 10186:18:03, 4 January 2006 (UTC) 10164:17:40, 4 January 2006 (UTC) 10142:08:06, 4 January 2006 (UTC) 10128:06:59, 4 January 2006 (UTC) 10123:well when he voted oppose. 10107:05:13, 4 January 2006 (UTC) 10016:18:08, 4 January 2006 (UTC) 10001:17:40, 4 January 2006 (UTC) 9977:04:55, 4 January 2006 (UTC) 9959:02:50, 4 January 2006 (UTC) 9883:02:31, 4 January 2006 (UTC) 9865:16:16, 4 January 2006 (UTC) 9855:01:40, 4 January 2006 (UTC) 9828:23:58, 3 January 2006 (UTC) 9798:23:55, 3 January 2006 (UTC) 9776:23:45, 3 January 2006 (UTC) 9750:23:35, 3 January 2006 (UTC) 9724:23:10, 3 January 2006 (UTC) 9706:23:06, 3 January 2006 (UTC) 9696:23:01, 3 January 2006 (UTC) 9685:22:58, 3 January 2006 (UTC) 9676:22:58, 3 January 2006 (UTC) 9651:19:36, 2 January 2006 (UTC) 9640:18:47, 2 January 2006 (UTC) 9609:23:40, 5 January 2006 (UTC) 9600:01:48, 3 January 2006 (UTC) 9590:18:29, 2 January 2006 (UTC) 9572:14:38, 3 January 2006 (UTC) 9552:20:52, 2 January 2006 (UTC) 9528:01:48, 3 January 2006 (UTC) 9504:21:35, 2 January 2006 (UTC) 9485:18:35, 2 January 2006 (UTC) 9467:18:25, 2 January 2006 (UTC) 9445:18:17, 2 January 2006 (UTC) 9427:15:52, 2 January 2006 (UTC) 9405:09:36, 2 January 2006 (UTC) 9372:23:24, 5 January 2006 (UTC) 9356:12:53, 3 January 2006 (UTC) 9262:13:35, 2 January 2006 (UTC) 9244:09:36, 2 January 2006 (UTC) 9226:09:06, 2 January 2006 (UTC) 9177:08:34, 2 January 2006 (UTC) 9113:08:14, 2 January 2006 (UTC) 9092:07:56, 2 January 2006 (UTC) 9063:07:53, 2 January 2006 (UTC) 9050:07:36, 2 January 2006 (UTC) 9026:07:30, 2 January 2006 (UTC) 7717:"The truth about Macedonia" 7555:sometimes really annoys you 6043:Ancient Macedonian language 5833:25.847 (2002, Mazedonier)( 5762:13.696 (2001, Mazedonien) ( 5665:paragraphs that disappeared 3513:Ancient Macedonian language 2924:I would like to ask you to 2370:, why shouldn't we specify 2368:Ancient Macedonian language 1408:also has a Greek identity, 548:I have a question for you, 401:Migration of "Macedonians" 10: 13352: 12339:SOCG, Vol 60f. 176r-177v. 11847:pre-20th century reference 11763:I don't know, why was the 11366:Macedonian Orthodox Church 11014:" - You said it yourself: 10883:Talk:Republic of Macedonia 10823:Macedonian Orthodox Church 10287:was long ago derived from 10221:Macedonians (ethnic group) 10121:Macedonians (ethnic group) 10092:Macedonians (ethnic group) 9893:Macedonians (ethnic group) 9513:Macedonians (ethnic group) 9219:Macedonia (disambiguation) 9126:Macedonians (ethnic group) 9033:Macedonians (ethnic group) 8559:Macedonian Orthodox Church 8344:schools with 532 students. 5885:I also propose to use the 5806:61.000 (2001, Mazedonier)( 5522:Greece would never get in 5276:Macedonians (ethnic group) 5206:Macedonians (ethnic group) 5198:Macedonians (ethnic group) 4779:source around the world... 4648:23:06, 12 November 2005 -- 3956:never got 60% support but 3920:Talk:Macedonian Slavs/Poll 3801:Macedonians (ethnic group) 3593:Macedonians (ethnic group) 2998:Macedonians (ethnic group) 2560:as Albanians, or did you? 2372:Slavic Macedonian language 2296:Uncle Ed keep telling us. 2225:, you figures emerge from 1909:Knowledge:Reliable sources 1514:21:25, 18 Ιουν. 2005 (UTC) 1245:freedom and independance. 237:Macedonians (ethnic group) 142:Talk:Macedonian Slavs/Poll 12853:Hellenic, but Thracians. 12752:not a trouble. Thanks! -- 11951:Who are the four persons? 11767:in fact an empire of the 11734:Basil the Macedonian was 10733:Eastern Romance languages 9106:Knowledge:Requested moves 8580:you're having delusions. 8109:Official policy vandalism 8091:Official policy vandalism 8069:quoting the protocols of 8013:8,100 others (all greeks) 7904:3,291 Christain Albanians 7567:Population of Macedonians 7515:, but that sounds odd. -- 6810:Later groups such as the 6679:"...but it is likely that 6655:I agree. To me it's also 6549:" having "genes from the 5851:6.415 (2000, Macédonien)( 5824:1.595 (1991, Mazedonier)( 5753:3.972 (2002, Makedonci) ( 4841:Knowledge:Naming conflict 4697:Knowledge:Naming conflict 4519:Knowledge:Naming conflict 4389:was made a month earlier! 4252:Knowledge:Naming conflict 4191:Knowledge:Naming conflict 4087:Knowledge:Naming conflict 4003:Knowledge:Naming conflict 3962:Knowledge:Naming conflict 3928:Knowledge:Naming conflict 3904:a "sneaky and dishonest" 3688:Knowledge:Naming conflict 2507:That is why you have the 1615:where are the admins now? 1533:21:25, 18 June 2005 (UTC) 798:Background of the dispute 634:Reporters sans frontières 11594:, have told us that the 11360:some Macedonian Empire, 11107:Country name etymologies 10780:way of putting this is: 9816:The Search for Alexander 7992:240,019 Christian greeks 7895:240,019 Christian Greeks 7727:"Pan-Macedonian Network" 6036:Explanation of new edits 4731:I would be glad if you ( 3621:describe the controversy 2104:But, anyway, as I said, 984:Guinness Book of Records 11913:Tsar Samuil of Bulgaria 11453:The article states ... 8737:You just admitted that 8480:the Human Rights report 8398:Talk:Macedonia (region) 7907:45,457 Christain Vlachs 7633:This is a message from 7581:2.1 million Macedonians 7378:Macedonian ethnic group 5771:42.812 (2002 estimate)( 5526:without those powerful 5388:United Nation's website 5281:Macedonians (ethnicity) 4349:That's a load of bull! 4123:really want to know... 1893:Knowledge:Verifiability 1497:confidently claims the 13008:agricultural terms. - 11909:First Bulgarian Empire 11602:... not to attack the 11357:First Bulgarian Empire 11290:"Secrets of the Swamp" 11275:Makedonikiti Dialektos 10931:Cultural appropriation 10761:Origins and identities 9986:Italian claims on the 9075:They're not the same. 8601:"(e.g. Lerin becoming 8320:(1905), which records: 7737:"Macedonia On The Web" 6866:unvegetarian behaviour 6006:Surname endings change 5822:Bosnia and Herzegovina 3263:(in that time part of 1905:Knowledge:Cite sources 1555:I think that Matia.gr 11813:Voyage Across the Sea 11016:Cultural assimilation 10713:Republic of Macedonia 9897:Bulgarian Macedonians 9895:can well be moved to 9629:Bulgarian Macedonians 9307:Columbia Encyclopedia 8869:Republic of Macedonia 7901:5584 Muslim Albanians 7889:4,240 Christian Turks 7383:in an neutral fashion 7026:A proposal on merging 6897:Slavophones in Greece 6272:Saying the same thing 5831:Serbia and Montenegro 5504:Should I mention the 4958:neutral point of view 3531:; see the article on 1424:and of course at the 1311:Documents as evidence 825:hijacked by "Slavs"? 42:of past discussions. 12313:Roma, 25 marzo 1628 11879:Basil the Macedonian 11707:Basil the Macedonian 10920:contemporary peoples 10297:academic as possible 10074:descent rather than 9933:Etymology of Romania 9848:Search for Alexander 8978:Reason for page move 8712:part of the reason. 8089:it is considered as 8010:29,803 greek Gypsies 7995:13,753 Muslim greeks 7980:40,921 Muslim greeks 7971:your right as always 7898:13,753 Muslim Greeks 5815:10.000 (Mazedonier)( 5584:this has been added 4472:When I have written 3948:You're quite right, 3304:did and developed a 3196:change the reality. 3058:. Therefore, as per 2581:nationalistic POVs. 2478:Macedonians (Slavic) 2284:User:Rexhep Bojaxhiu 1582:Macedonian Knowledge 13068:One way or another 12120:author John Zonara. 11777:Names of the Greeks 11592:Macedonian Salonika 11463:” by Risto Stefov. 11433:Macedonian language 11374:Macedonian language 11323:conquered territory 10088:Ancient Macedonians 9844:Ancient Macedonians 9458:- more or less per 9104:I agree with Ryan: 8834:told the mission: 8786:Macedonian language 8456:or another form of 8437:I have temporarily 8176:population exchange 8121:Knowledge:Vandalism 8105:Knowledge:Vandalism 7977:326,426 pure greeks 7924:. That is only the 7913:29,803 Roma Gypsies 7910:3,500 Muslim Vlachs 7883:40,921 Muslim Slavs 7601:list of Macedonians 7129:Alexander the Great 7082:Alexander the Great 6761:I like the way the 6699:Ancient Macedonians 6527:Knowledge:Vandalism 6447:Y-chromosomal Aaron 6256:Ancient Macedonians 6178:kinship and descent 4695:matter, namely the 3591:) that the modern " 3472:Content moved from 3302:Republic of Ireland 2645:Stating the obvious 2514:Macedonian language 2439:Macedonian language 2376:Macedonian language 2364:Ancient Macedonians 1857:text of the article 1410:el:Χρήστης:Matia.gr 1090:Republic of Moldova 673:Is it clearer now? 583:Arbitrary page move 12976:order of magnitude 11997:Miladinov Brothers 11921:Macedonian dynasty 11915:, was defeated by 11715:Macedonian dynasty 11701:So I guess you've 11370:Bulgarian language 11331:Macedonia (Greece) 10729:Dalmatian language 10102:should handle it. 9342:, then we can say 9332:Naming conventions 9322:self-determination 9314:CIA World Factbook 8861:Macedonia (Greece) 8718:Macedonia (Greece) 8630:Macedonia (Greece) 8499:Macedonia (Greece) 8458:dispute resolution 8193:Macedonia (Greece) 8064:Requesting sources 8004:45,457 pure greeks 7926:Macedonia (Greece) 7922:occupied territory 7629:Translation needed 7262:the Macedonian :-) 6542:Izehar, read this: 6489:Branko Crvenkovski 5627:Secretary of State 5286:Ethnic-Macedonians 5068:Talk:Çamë#Disgrace 4525:adopted policy. -- 3555:Please check this 3481:Macedonia (region) 3474:Macedonia (region) 3226:have got to stop. 1681:Followed you there 1590:Albanian Knowledge 1557:should be reported 1399:Tactics and tricks 802:Can we talk about 743:about whether the 392:Ottoman occupation 256:Who is denying it? 13120:original research 11797:Macedonian Greeks 11713:. What about the 11671:Macedonian Greeks 11604:Macedonian people 11600:Macedonian people 11596:Macedonian people 11294:original research 10992:'s armies sacked 10643:Oxford University 10572:Flavrsavr said: " 10308:Original research 10225:Macedonian people 10080:Romanian/Rumanian 9633:Greek Macedonians 9501: 9344:Macedonian people 9334:that require the 9130:Macedonian people 9048: 8425: 8390: 8261:national minority 8085:and according to 7892:2,112 Circassians 7529: 7477: 7346: 7311:another. Cheers, 7254:didn't looked so 7157: 7002: 6993: 6885: 6846: 6391: 6335: 5738: 5681: 5251: 5148: 5081: 5060:greek nationalism 4833: 4636:cannot be solved 4484: 4423: 4321: 4113: 4037: 3642: 3623:, not settle it. 3525:Panhellenic Games 3450: 3046:I'm sorry, dear. 2836: 2568: 2453: 2360:Macedonian Greeks 2227:original research 2175:Or, do you maybe 2143:sv:User:Arvanítis 2033:belongs to Greece 2015:User:"Macedonian" 1983: 1861:specific disputes 1770: 1695: 1658: 103: 102: 54: 53: 48:current talk page 13343: 13259:Miskin's reverts 13026:Western Outlands 13015:To Aldux (contd) 12004: 11811:An excerpt from 11773:Byzantine Empire 11719:Byzantine Empire 11582:April 26th, 1690 11230:Credible Sources 10960:Sinhalese people 10891:Aegean Macedonia 10885:(I think it was 10748: 10694:Flavrsavr said: 10490:Well, I did not 10096:User:Jimbo Wales 9769:Byzantine Greeks 9618:Macedonians and 9499: 9496: 9420:Macedonian Slavs 9402:Francis Schonken 9354: 9336:self-identifying 9044: 8960:Macedonian Slavs 8563:Manakis brothers 8417: 8382: 8303: 8297: 7955:a municipality) 7934:Aegean Macedonia 7649:means, and what 7545:FlavrSavr said: 7525: 7473: 7342: 7153: 6998: 6989: 6983:this news report 6881: 6858:Macedonian salad 6842: 6583:How to handle it 6387: 6333: 6166:was introduced. 5966: 5734: 5702: 5677: 5655: 5569: 5538: 5488: 5445: 5411: 5392:reliable sources 5363: 5325: 5308: 5261:Slav Macedonians 5257:Macedonian Slavs 5247:); post left at 5238: 5220: 5181: 5144:); post left at 5135: 5120: 5098: 5077: 5045: 5025: 5007: 4980: 4944: 4902: 4872: 4862:present identity 4851: 4829: 4797: 4747: 4670: 4619: 4602: 4577: 4551: 4499: 4480: 4465: 4442: 4419: 4408: 4339: 4317: 4229: 4215: 4201: 4183: 4154: 4131: 4109: 4097: 4075:Double standards 4060: 4033: 4013: 3954:Macedonian Slavs 3942: 3924:Macedonian Slavs 3898:Macedonian Slavs 3859: 3814: 3743: 3720: 3698: 3672: 3638: 3571: 3446: 3408: 3392:Στο καλό και να 3364: 3324: 3238: 3224:double standards 3204: 3106: 3070: 3060:Knowledge policy 3022: 2943: 2867: 2832: 2790: 2766: 2747: 2724: 2704: 2629: 2589: 2564: 2534: 2467:, by calling it 2449: 2429: 2407: 2356:Macedonian Slavs 2342: 2304: 2294: 2271: 2237: 2200: 2153: 2130: 2005: 1979: 1938: 1919: 1831: 1808: 1766: 1756: 1736: 1715: 1691: 1674: 1654: 1608: 1600:what he thinks. 1571: 1546: 1389: 1288:Being bewildered 1253: 1210: 1127: 589:Macedonian Slavs 576: 539: 513: 482: 456: 421: 381: 351: 316: 289: 281:truth about us. 247: 81: 56: 55: 33: 32: 26: 13351: 13350: 13346: 13345: 13344: 13342: 13341: 13340: 13313:reliable source 13261: 13083: 13066: 13017: 12926: 12026: 11967:Daniel Tanevski 11953: 11892:Daniel Tanevski 11877:The article on 11659:Daniel Tanevski 11524:15th century AD 11516:". (D. Angelov) 11451: 11232: 10763: 10746: 10731:as well as the 10543:of a man named 9925:Ţara Romaneasca 9659: 9583: 9536:Neutral/Abstain 9494: 9223:Daniel tanevski 9123: 8980: 8970:Daniel tanevski 8962: 8948: 8865:Greek Macedonia 8545:3 sourced links 8435: 8359: 8301: 8295: 8066: 7967:Im sorry Miskin 7837:Greek Macedonia 7631: 7569: 7492:Slavic speaking 7173: 7028: 6969:user: Makedon45 6899: 6782: 6750: 6672: 6638: 6585: 6356:Gene expression 6274: 6224: 6176:Ancestry means 6108: 6094: 6038: 6008: 5993: 5931: 5747: 5667: 5457: 4600: 4575: 4567: 3995:selective cases 3881: 3684:personal attack 3585: 3477: 3396:μας γράφεις... 2803: 2647: 2441:and search for 2317:User:Thrakiotis 2313:User:Thrakiotis 2246:User:Thrakiotis 2223:reliable source 2219:User:Thrakiotis 2106:User:Theathenae 2092:User:Theathenae 2069:User:Theathenae 2062:User:Theathenae 2017: 1969: 1845: 1790:WP:Cite sources 1617: 1487:Greek Knowledge 1483: 1401: 1313: 1290: 1007:User:Theathenae 849:Your Mediator, 800: 718: 629: 585: 433:User:Macedonian 161: 108: 77: 30: 22: 21: 20: 12: 11: 5: 13349: 13339: 13338: 13337: 13336: 13323: 13322: 13309:User:Macedonia 13260: 13257: 13249: 13248: 13193: 13177: 13176: 13175: 13174: 13161: 13160: 13159: 13158: 13140: 13138: 13137: 13097: 13096: 13082: 13079:User:Macedonia 13076: 13065: 13062: 13016: 13013: 13005: 13004: 12993: 12992: 12981: 12980: 12971: 12970: 12925: 12922: 12837: 12836: 12835: 12834: 12833: 12832: 12823: 12822: 12800: 12799: 12798: 12797: 12786: 12785: 12784: 12783: 12777: 12776: 12762: 12760: 12759: 12689: 12682: 12679: 12651: 12637: 12614: 12613: 12578: 12570: 12550: 12531: 12319: 12308: 12176: 12142: 12133: 12124: 12123: 12122: 12121: 12117: 12111: 12110: 12095: 12094: 12093: 12092: 12080: 12079: 12078: 12077: 12070: 12069: 12068: 12067: 12051: 12050: 12045: 12044: 12025: 12022: 12021: 12020: 12019: 12018: 12017: 12016: 12015: 12014: 11952: 11949: 11931: 11930: 11888: 11887: 11886: 11885: 11872: 11871: 11861: 11860: 11859: 11858: 11840: 11839: 11838: 11837: 11836: 11835: 11834: 11833: 11821: 11820: 11819: 11818: 11817: 11816: 11804: 11803: 11802: 11801: 11789: 11788: 11787: 11786: 11765:British Empire 11758: 11757: 11731: 11730: 11729: 11728: 11711:Constantinople 11696: 11695: 11668: 11655: 11654: 11639: 11638: 11637: 11636: 11635: 11634: 11617: 11616: 11609: 11608: 11577: 11575: 11574: 11573: 11572: 11560: 11559: 11558: 11557: 11547: 11546: 11520: 11519: 11518: 11517: 11506: 11505: 11497: 11495: 11494: 11493: 11492: 11483:9th century AD 11476: 11475: 11468:9th century AD 11450: 11447: 11390: 11388: 11387: 11386: 11385: 11384: 11383: 11347: 11346: 11345: 11344: 11327:Ottoman Empire 11308: 11307: 11306: 11305: 11304: 11303: 11288:I've read the 11267: 11265: 11264: 11231: 11228: 11227: 11226: 11225: 11224: 11223: 11222: 11207: 11206: 11205: 11204: 11158: 11156: 11154: 11153: 11152: 11151: 11150: 11149: 11148: 11147: 11125: 11124: 11123: 11122: 11121: 11120: 11056: 11055: 11054: 11053: 11043: 11036: 11035: 11007: 11006: 10986: 10978: 10977: 10976: 10975: 10956:Spanish people 10949: 10948: 10935:Language shift 10902: 10874: 10873: 10866: 10863: 10855: 10854: 10853: 10852: 10851: 10850: 10835: 10834: 10833: 10832: 10819:User:Macedonia 10811:User:Macedonia 10803: 10802: 10762: 10759: 10721:Proto-Romanian 10692: 10691: 10690: 10689: 10688: 10687: 10686: 10685: 10663: 10662: 10661: 10660: 10659: 10658: 10634: 10633: 10632: 10631: 10570: 10569: 10568: 10567: 10566: 10565: 10564: 10563: 10529: 10528: 10527: 10526: 10525: 10524: 10523: 10522: 10506: 10505: 10504: 10503: 10502: 10501: 10483: 10482: 10481: 10480: 10479: 10478: 10477: 10476: 10459: 10458: 10457: 10456: 10455: 10454: 10436: 10435: 10434: 10433: 10432: 10431: 10430: 10429: 10412: 10411: 10410: 10409: 10408: 10407: 10385: 10384: 10383: 10382: 10381: 10380: 10365: 10364: 10363: 10362: 10346: 10345: 10344: 10343: 10330: 10329: 10263: 10262: 10261: 10260: 10259: 10258: 10257: 10256: 10239: 10238: 10237: 10236: 10235: 10234: 10195: 10194: 10193: 10192: 10191: 10190: 10189: 10188: 10171: 10170: 10169: 10168: 10167: 10166: 10147: 10146: 10145: 10144: 10131: 10130: 10112: 10111: 10110: 10109: 10019: 10018: 9984: 9983: 9982: 9981: 9980: 9979: 9964: 9963: 9962: 9961: 9943:deriving from 9929:Ţara Rumanesca 9886: 9885: 9874: 9873: 9872: 9871: 9870: 9869: 9868: 9867: 9835: 9834: 9833: 9832: 9831: 9830: 9807: 9806: 9805: 9804: 9803: 9802: 9801: 9800: 9783: 9782: 9781: 9780: 9779: 9778: 9759: 9758: 9757: 9756: 9755: 9754: 9753: 9752: 9731: 9730: 9729: 9728: 9727: 9726: 9711: 9710: 9709: 9708: 9658: 9655: 9654: 9653: 9612: 9611: 9602: 9582: 9579: 9578: 9577: 9576: 9575: 9557: 9556: 9555: 9554: 9533: 9532: 9531: 9530: 9517:English people 9506: 9487: 9472: 9471: 9470: 9469: 9450: 9449: 9448: 9447: 9432: 9431: 9430: 9429: 9410: 9409: 9408: 9407: 9375: 9374: 9361: 9360: 9359: 9358: 9295:Strong Support 9289: 9288: 9287: 9286: 9280:(ethnic group) 9267: 9266: 9265: 9264: 9249: 9248: 9247: 9246: 9231: 9230: 9229: 9228: 9197: 9195: 9194: 9180: 9162:Chechen people 9158:Tibetan people 9154:Kurdish people 9150:Turkish people 9134:English people 9122: 9121:Requested Move 9119: 9118: 9117: 9116: 9115: 9099: 9098: 9097: 9096: 9095: 9094: 9068: 9067: 9066: 9065: 9053: 9052: 9011:Chechen people 9007:Tibetan people 9003:Kurdish people 8999:Turkish people 8983:English people 8979: 8976: 8961: 8958: 8947: 8944: 8943: 8942: 8932: 8931: 8930: 8929: 8912: 8911: 8829: 8828: 8827: 8826: 8818: 8807: 8806: 8793: 8774: 8752:User:Dbachmann 8742: 8706: 8692: 8691: 8683: 8682: 8672: 8671: 8666: 8665: 8664: 8663: 8650: 8648: 8647: 8620: 8617:I never denied 8592: 8591: 8590: 8589: 8588: 8587: 8572: 8571: 8570: 8569: 8537: 8450:edit summaries 8434: 8431: 8430: 8429: 8358: 8355: 8346: 8345: 8334: 8291: 8290: 8267: 8266: 8246: 8245: 8241: 8238: 8235: 8232: 8228: 8227: 8223: 8222: 8189: 8187: 8186: 8179: 8168: 8146: 8145: 8144: 8143: 8117: 8065: 8062: 8041: 8040: 8039: 8038: 8015: 8014: 8011: 8008: 8005: 8002: 7999: 7996: 7993: 7990: 7987: 7984: 7983:289,973 greeks 7981: 7978: 7965: 7963: 7962: 7918: 7917: 7914: 7911: 7908: 7905: 7902: 7899: 7896: 7893: 7890: 7887: 7884: 7881: 7864: 7862: 7861: 7857: 7856: 7852: 7851: 7834: 7813: 7812: 7811: 7810: 7743: 7742: 7739: 7734: 7729: 7724: 7719: 7681: 7680: 7679: 7678: 7639:User:Makedon45 7630: 7627: 7626: 7625: 7597: 7596: 7595: 7594: 7573:user: Antidote 7568: 7565: 7543: 7542: 7541: 7540: 7539: 7538: 7537: 7536: 7494:. There is no 7485: 7484: 7459: 7458: 7448: 7447: 7446: 7445: 7433: 7432: 7431: 7430: 7418: 7417: 7416: 7415: 7414: 7413: 7398: 7397: 7373: 7372: 7371: 7370: 7326:(ethnic group) 7322: 7321: 7320: 7319: 7276: 7275: 7266: 7265: 7264: 7263: 7231: 7230: 7229: 7228: 7215:Slavic peoples 7177:Recent Changes 7172: 7169: 7168: 7167: 7166: 7165: 7164: 7163: 7162: 7161: 7125: 7092: 7091: 7027: 7024: 6979: 6978: 6915: 6898: 6895: 6894: 6893: 6892: 6891: 6890: 6889: 6851: 6850: 6781: 6778: 6749: 6746: 6725: 6724: 6718: 6717: 6704: 6703: 6671: 6668: 6667: 6666: 6637: 6634: 6633: 6632: 6631: 6630: 6618: 6617: 6584: 6581: 6580: 6579: 6578: 6577: 6564: 6537: 6536: 6474: 6473: 6443: 6442: 6428: 6427: 6396: 6395: 6331: 6330: 6319: 6318: 6273: 6270: 6260: 6259: 6223: 6220: 6174: 6173: 6135: 6134: 6107: 6106:Weasel and POV 6104: 6093: 6090: 6089: 6088: 6087: 6086: 6073: 6072: 6037: 6034: 6033: 6032: 6023: 6007: 6004: 5992: 5989: 5988: 5987: 5986: 5985: 5973: 5972: 5971: 5970: 5956: 5953: 5946: 5930: 5927: 5917: 5916: 5902: 5865: 5864: 5855: 5846: 5837: 5828: 5819: 5810: 5801: 5792: 5788:81.899 (2001)( 5783: 5780:31.265 (2001)( 5775: 5766: 5757: 5746: 5743: 5711: 5709: 5708: 5707: 5706: 5666: 5663: 5662: 5661: 5660: 5659: 5641: 5638: 5635: 5591: 5578: 5576: 5575: 5574: 5573: 5555: 5545: 5544: 5543: 5542: 5524:European Union 5520: 5517: 5502: 5499: 5493: 5492: 5456: 5453: 5452: 5451: 5450: 5449: 5430: 5422:User talk:KRBN 5418: 5416: 5415: 5374: 5373: 5372: 5371: 5370: 5369: 5368: 5367: 5348: 5334: 5333: 5332: 5331: 5330: 5329: 5292: 5291: 5288: 5283: 5278: 5273: 5269: 5268: 5241:195.14.132.242 5234: 5233: 5232: 5231: 5230: 5229: 5192: 5190: 5189: 5188: 5187: 5186: 5185: 5170: 5163: 5160: 5157: 5138:195.14.132.242 5109: 5108: 5107: 5106: 5105: 5104: 5103: 5102: 5071: 5034: 5032: 5031: 5030: 5029: 4989: 4988: 4987: 4986: 4985: 4984: 4953: 4952: 4951: 4950: 4949: 4948: 4933: 4891: 4890: 4889: 4888: 4887: 4886: 4885: 4884: 4883: 4882: 4881: 4880: 4879: 4878: 4877: 4876: 4814: 4813: 4812: 4811: 4810: 4809: 4808: 4807: 4806: 4805: 4804: 4803: 4802: 4801: 4787: 4783: 4780: 4776: 4772: 4736: 4716: 4715: 4679: 4678: 4677: 4676: 4675: 4674: 4630: 4629: 4628: 4627: 4626: 4625: 4624: 4623: 4593: 4592: 4566: 4563: 4562: 4561: 4560: 4559: 4558: 4557: 4556: 4555: 4537: 4504: 4503: 4470: 4469: 4451: 4450: 4449: 4448: 4447: 4446: 4397: 4396: 4390: 4380: 4374: 4348: 4346: 4345: 4344: 4343: 4303: 4302: 4279: 4278: 4277: 4276: 4263: 4262: 4261: 4260: 4245: 4244: 4163: 4162: 4161: 4160: 4159: 4158: 4102: 4101: 4069: 4068: 4067: 4066: 4065: 4064: 4050: 4022: 4021: 4020: 4019: 4018: 4017: 3880: 3875: 3874: 3873: 3872: 3871: 3870: 3869: 3868: 3867: 3866: 3865: 3864: 3863: 3829: 3828: 3827: 3826: 3825: 3824: 3823: 3822: 3821: 3820: 3819: 3818: 3804: 3797:GrandfatherJoe 3775: 3774: 3773: 3772: 3771: 3770: 3756:GrandfatherJoe 3725: 3724: 3705: 3704: 3703: 3702: 3680: 3679: 3678: 3677: 3676: 3664:of Macedonia. 3661: 3657: 3617:Knowledge:NPOV 3615:Remember, the 3613: 3612: 3609: 3584: 3581: 3580: 3579: 3578: 3577: 3576: 3575: 3560: 3553: 3476: 3470: 3469: 3468: 3467: 3466: 3465: 3464: 3463: 3462: 3461: 3460: 3459: 3458: 3457: 3456: 3455: 3454: 3421: 3420: 3419: 3418: 3417: 3416: 3415: 3414: 3413: 3412: 3381: 3380: 3379: 3378: 3377: 3376: 3375: 3374: 3373: 3372: 3371: 3370: 3369: 3368: 3333: 3332: 3331: 3330: 3329: 3328: 3286: 3285: 3284: 3283: 3259:). By the way 3243: 3242: 3213: 3212: 3211: 3210: 3209: 3208: 3174: 3173: 3172: 3171: 3170: 3169: 3168: 3167: 3154: 3153: 3152: 3151: 3139: 3138: 3137: 3136: 3135: 3134: 3133: 3132: 3115: 3114: 3113: 3112: 3111: 3110: 3095: 3078: 3044: 3043: 3042: 3041: 3027: 3026: 3011: 3008: 3005: 3001: 2993: 2992: 2991: 2990: 2989: 2988: 2987: 2986: 2956: 2955: 2954: 2953: 2952: 2951: 2950: 2949: 2948: 2947: 2932: 2927:check this out 2922: 2919: 2916: 2912: 2908: 2886: 2885: 2884: 2876: 2875: 2874: 2873: 2872: 2871: 2857: 2854: 2850: 2822:The first time 2807: 2802: 2799: 2797: 2795: 2794: 2756: 2755: 2754: 2753: 2752: 2751: 2737: 2713: 2712: 2711: 2710: 2709: 2708: 2693: 2689: 2685: 2681: 2663: 2662: 2658: 2646: 2643: 2642: 2641: 2640: 2639: 2638: 2637: 2636: 2635: 2634: 2633: 2603: 2602: 2601: 2600: 2599: 2598: 2597: 2596: 2595: 2594: 2593: 2544: 2543: 2542: 2541: 2540: 2539: 2538: 2526:ethnic group. 2520: 2517: 2509:disambiguation 2486:disambiguation 2459: 2458: 2457: 2415: 2414: 2413: 2412: 2411: 2396: 2351: 2350: 2349: 2348: 2347: 2346: 2280: 2279: 2278: 2277: 2276: 2275: 2211: 2210: 2209: 2208: 2207: 2206: 2205: 2204: 2189: 2180: 2173: 2137: 2136: 2135: 2134: 2119: 2116: 2112: 2109: 2102: 2095: 2087: 2076: 2067:This claim of 2065: 2056:I only revert 2016: 2013: 2012: 2011: 2010: 2009: 1968: 1965: 1964: 1963: 1962: 1961: 1960: 1959: 1945: 1944: 1943: 1942: 1924: 1923: 1903:and of course 1901:Knowledge:NPOV 1885:naming dispute 1844: 1841: 1840: 1839: 1838: 1837: 1836: 1835: 1777: 1776: 1775: 1774: 1726: 1725: 1724: 1723: 1722: 1721: 1720: 1719: 1648:Circular logic 1616: 1613: 1578: 1577: 1576: 1575: 1528: 1517: 1516: 1508: 1482: 1481:'s perspective 1476: 1400: 1397: 1396: 1395: 1394: 1393: 1364:The sentence: 1312: 1309: 1308: 1307: 1306: 1305: 1289: 1286: 1281: 1280: 1262: 1261: 1260: 1259: 1258: 1257: 1242: 1239: 1221: 1219: 1218: 1217: 1216: 1215: 1214: 1195: 1192: 1188: 1184: 1181: 1162:GrandfatherJoe 1146:United Kingdom 1136: 1135: 1134: 1133: 1132: 1131: 1116: 1112: 1108: 1105: 1084: 1083: 1082: 1081: 1080: 1079: 1078: 1077: 1076: 1075: 1074: 1073: 1064: 1060: 1057: 1027: 1026: 1025: 1024: 1000: 999: 998: 997: 990: 989: 988: 987: 977: 976: 975: 974: 967: 966: 965: 964: 957: 956: 955: 954: 947: 946: 945: 944: 937: 936: 935: 934: 927: 926: 925: 924: 917: 916: 915: 914: 908: 907: 906: 905: 898: 897: 896: 895: 888: 887: 886: 885: 880:I want to ask 875: 874: 873: 872: 869: 866: 799: 796: 795: 794: 793: 792: 791: 790: 781: 778: 769: 768: 758: 757: 753: 752: 736: 735: 717: 714: 713: 712: 711: 710: 709: 708: 707: 706: 696: 692: 671: 668: 665: 657: 628: 625: 624: 623: 622: 621: 612: 609: 584: 581: 545: 543: 542: 541: 540: 517: 516: 515: 514: 502: 495: 494: 493: 492: 486: 485: 484: 483: 469: 468: 467: 466: 460: 459: 458: 457: 437: 436: 425: 424: 423: 422: 408: 407: 406: 405: 399: 396: 393: 387: 385: 384: 383: 382: 373:us is a fake. 370: 366: 355: 354: 353: 352: 340: 329: 328: 327: 326: 320: 319: 318: 317: 305: 298: 297: 293: 292: 291: 290: 278: 274: 270: 267: 260: 259: 258: 257: 251: 250: 249: 248: 229: 228: 221: 220: 219: 218: 208: 204: 188: 187: 184: 160: 159:Article titles 157: 152: 151: 136: 107: 104: 101: 100: 95: 92: 87: 82: 75: 70: 65: 62: 52: 51: 34: 15: 9: 6: 4: 3: 2: 13348: 13335: 13332: 13327: 13326: 13325: 13324: 13321: 13318: 13314: 13310: 13306: 13303: 13302: 13301: 13300: 13297: 13293: 13288: 13287: 13284: 13278: 13277: 13274: 13269: 13265: 13256: 13255: 13247: 13243: 13239: 13235: 13230: 13229: 13228: 13227: 13223: 13218: 13217: 13216: 13209: 13208: 13207: 13200: 13197: 13192: 13191: 13187: 13183: 13173: 13170: 13165: 13164: 13163: 13162: 13157: 13153: 13149: 13145: 13144: 13143: 13142: 13141: 13136: 13133: 13129: 13125: 13121: 13116: 13115: 13114: 13113: 13109: 13105: 13101: 13095: 13093: 13088: 13087: 13086: 13080: 13075: 13074: 13071: 13061: 13060: 13057: 13056:85.187.180.19 13051: 13050: 13046: 13045: 13042: 13036: 13035: 13032: 13027: 13021: 13012: 13011: 13003: 13000: 12995: 12994: 12991: 12988: 12983: 12982: 12977: 12973: 12972: 12969: 12966: 12961: 12960: 12959: 12958: 12955: 12950: 12946: 12944: 12939: 12937: 12936: 12929: 12921: 12920: 12917: 12912: 12908: 12904: 12900: 12897: 12894: 12890: 12886: 12882: 12878: 12874: 12870: 12866: 12862: 12858: 12854: 12850: 12847: 12844: 12841: 12829: 12828: 12827: 12826: 12825: 12824: 12821: 12818: 12813: 12812: 12811: 12807: 12803: 12795: 12790: 12789: 12788: 12787: 12781: 12780: 12779: 12778: 12774: 12773:24.57.117.176 12771: 12770: 12769: 12765: 12758: 12755: 12750: 12749: 12748: 12747: 12744: 12738: 12734: 12731: 12728: 12725: 12722: 12719: 12716: 12713: 12710: 12707: 12703: 12700: 12696: 12693: 12690: 12687: 12683: 12680: 12677: 12676: 12673: 12667: 12664: 12660: 12657: 12653: 12649: 12646: 12643: 12639: 12635: 12631: 12628: 12624: 12621: 12617: 12611: 12610: 12609: 12606: 12605:Macedonia." 12602: 12598: 12594: 12590: 12587: 12584: 12580: 12576: 12572: 12568: 12564: 12560: 12556: 12552: 12548: 12544: 12540: 12537: 12533: 12529: 12526: 12523: 12520: 12516: 12513: 12509: 12506: 12502: 12499: 12495: 12491: 12488: 12484: 12480: 12477: 12474: 12471: 12468: 12465: 12461: 12458: 12455: 12451: 12448: 12444: 12441: 12438: 12435: 12431: 12428: 12424: 12421: 12417: 12414: 12411: 12408: 12405: 12402: 12398: 12395: 12391: 12388: 12385: 12382: 12378: 12375: 12371: 12368: 12365: 12362: 12358: 12355: 12352: 12349: 12346: 12343: 12340: 12337: 12334: 12331: 12328: 12325: 12322: 12317: 12314: 12311: 12306: 12303: 12300: 12297: 12294: 12290: 12287: 12283: 12280: 12277: 12274: 12270: 12267: 12264: 12261: 12257: 12254: 12250: 12247: 12244: 12241: 12238: 12235: 12232: 12229: 12225: 12222: 12218: 12215: 12212: 12209: 12205: 12202: 12198: 12195: 12191: 12188: 12184: 12181: 12178: 12174: 12170: 12167: 12164: 12161: 12158: 12155: 12152: 12149: 12145: 12140: 12136: 12131: 12127: 12118: 12115: 12114: 12113: 12112: 12109: 12106: 12102: 12097: 12096: 12091: 12088: 12084: 12083: 12082: 12081: 12074: 12073: 12072: 12071: 12066: 12063: 12062: 12061: 12058: 12053: 12052: 12047: 12046: 12042: 12038: 12037: 12036: 12035: 12032: 12013: 12010: 12007: 12003: 11998: 11994: 11993: 11992: 11989: 11985: 11984: 11983: 11980: 11975: 11974: 11973: 11970: 11968: 11964: 11963: 11962: 11961: 11958: 11948: 11947: 11944: 11938: 11935: 11929: 11926: 11922: 11918: 11914: 11910: 11905: 11901: 11900: 11899: 11898: 11895: 11893: 11884: 11880: 11876: 11875: 11874: 11873: 11870: 11867: 11863: 11862: 11856: 11852: 11848: 11844: 11843: 11842: 11841: 11832: 11829: 11828: 11827: 11826: 11825: 11824: 11823: 11822: 11814: 11810: 11809: 11808: 11807: 11806: 11805: 11800: 11798: 11793: 11792: 11791: 11790: 11785: 11782: 11778: 11774: 11770: 11766: 11762: 11761: 11760: 11759: 11756: 11753: 11749: 11745: 11741: 11737: 11733: 11732: 11727: 11724: 11720: 11716: 11712: 11708: 11704: 11700: 11699: 11698: 11697: 11694: 11691: 11686: 11685: 11684: 11683: 11680: 11676: 11672: 11666: 11665: 11662: 11660: 11652: 11648: 11644: 11643: 11642: 11632: 11630: 11623: 11622: 11621: 11620: 11619: 11618: 11614: 11611: 11610: 11607: 11605: 11601: 11597: 11593: 11589: 11583: 11580: 11579: 11578: 11571: 11568: 11564: 11563: 11562: 11561: 11554: 11553: 11552: 11551: 11550: 11545: 11543: 11539: 11535: 11531: 11525: 11522: 11521: 11515: 11510: 11509: 11508: 11507: 11503: 11500: 11499: 11498: 11491: 11488: 11484: 11480: 11479: 11478: 11477: 11473: 11469: 11466: 11465: 11464: 11462: 11457: 11456: 11446: 11445: 11442: 11438: 11434: 11430: 11424: 11423: 11418: 11413: 11409: 11405: 11402: 11398: 11394: 11382: 11379: 11375: 11371: 11367: 11363: 11358: 11353: 11352: 11351: 11350: 11349: 11348: 11343: 11340: 11336: 11332: 11328: 11324: 11320: 11316: 11312: 11311: 11310: 11309: 11302: 11299: 11295: 11291: 11287: 11286: 11285: 11284: 11283: 11282: 11281: 11280: 11276: 11272: 11263: 11260: 11256: 11255: 11254: 11253: 11250: 11245: 11241: 11237: 11221: 11218: 11213: 11212: 11211: 11210: 11209: 11208: 11203: 11200: 11195: 11194: 11193: 11192: 11189: 11183: 11178: 11174: 11173: 11172: 11171: 11168: 11164: 11157: 11146: 11143: 11138: 11133: 11132: 11131: 11130: 11129: 11128: 11127: 11126: 11119: 11118: 11115: 11109: 11108: 11102: 11098: 11094: 11090: 11086: 11082: 11078: 11074: 11070: 11066: 11062: 11061: 11060: 11059: 11058: 11057: 11052: 11049: 11044: 11040: 11039: 11038: 11037: 11034: 11031: 11026: 11021: 11017: 11013: 11009: 11008: 11004: 11000: 10995: 10991: 10987: 10984: 10980: 10979: 10974: 10971: 10966: 10961: 10958:page and the 10957: 10953: 10952: 10951: 10950: 10947: 10946: 10943: 10937: 10936: 10932: 10925: 10921: 10917: 10916: 10915: 10914: 10911: 10907: 10900: 10899: 10896: 10892: 10888: 10884: 10880: 10871: 10867: 10864: 10861: 10860: 10859: 10849: 10846: 10841: 10840: 10839: 10838: 10837: 10836: 10831: 10828: 10824: 10820: 10816: 10812: 10807: 10806: 10805: 10804: 10801: 10798: 10793: 10792: 10791: 10790: 10787: 10783: 10779: 10774: 10769: 10768: 10758: 10757: 10754: 10753: 10749: 10747:Nightstallion 10742: 10741: 10738: 10737:Alexander 007 10734: 10730: 10726: 10722: 10718: 10714: 10709: 10708: 10705: 10701: 10697: 10684: 10681: 10676: 10671: 10670: 10669: 10668: 10667: 10666: 10665: 10664: 10657: 10654: 10650: 10648: 10644: 10640: 10639: 10638: 10637: 10636: 10635: 10630: 10627: 10622: 10618: 10614: 10613: 10612: 10611: 10610: 10609: 10606: 10601: 10597: 10592: 10588: 10583: 10579: 10575: 10562: 10559: 10555: 10554: 10553: 10550: 10549:Alexander 007 10546: 10542: 10541: 10535: 10534: 10533: 10532: 10531: 10530: 10521: 10518: 10514: 10513: 10512: 10511: 10510: 10509: 10508: 10507: 10500: 10497: 10496:Alexander 007 10493: 10489: 10488: 10487: 10486: 10485: 10484: 10475: 10472: 10467: 10466: 10465: 10464: 10463: 10462: 10461: 10460: 10453: 10450: 10449:Alexander 007 10446: 10442: 10441: 10440: 10439: 10438: 10437: 10428: 10425: 10420: 10419: 10418: 10417: 10416: 10415: 10414: 10413: 10406: 10403: 10402:Alexander 007 10399: 10395: 10391: 10390: 10389: 10388: 10387: 10386: 10379: 10376: 10371: 10370: 10369: 10368: 10367: 10366: 10361: 10358: 10357:Alexander 007 10354: 10350: 10349: 10348: 10347: 10342: 10339: 10334: 10333: 10332: 10331: 10328: 10325: 10324:Alexander 007 10321: 10317: 10313: 10309: 10304: 10303: 10298: 10294: 10290: 10286: 10282: 10278: 10274: 10270: 10265: 10264: 10255: 10252: 10247: 10246: 10245: 10244: 10243: 10242: 10241: 10240: 10233: 10230: 10229:Alexander 007 10226: 10222: 10218: 10214: 10210: 10206: 10201: 10200: 10199: 10198: 10197: 10196: 10187: 10184: 10179: 10178: 10177: 10176: 10175: 10174: 10173: 10172: 10165: 10162: 10158: 10153: 10152: 10151: 10150: 10149: 10148: 10143: 10140: 10135: 10134: 10133: 10132: 10129: 10126: 10125:Alexander 007 10122: 10118: 10114: 10113: 10108: 10105: 10104:Alexander 007 10101: 10097: 10093: 10089: 10085: 10081: 10077: 10073: 10069: 10065: 10062:derived from 10061: 10057: 10053: 10049: 10044: 10040: 10035: 10031: 10027: 10023: 10022: 10021: 10020: 10017: 10014: 10009: 10005: 10004: 10003: 10002: 9999: 9994: 9989: 9978: 9975: 9970: 9969: 9968: 9967: 9966: 9965: 9960: 9957: 9956:Alexander 007 9953: 9949: 9946: 9942: 9938: 9934: 9930: 9926: 9922: 9918: 9914: 9910: 9906: 9902: 9898: 9894: 9890: 9889: 9888: 9887: 9884: 9881: 9876: 9875: 9866: 9863: 9858: 9857: 9856: 9853: 9852:Alexander 007 9849: 9845: 9841: 9840: 9839: 9838: 9837: 9836: 9829: 9826: 9825:Alexander 007 9821: 9818:, 1980, that 9817: 9813: 9812: 9811: 9810: 9809: 9808: 9799: 9796: 9791: 9790: 9789: 9788: 9787: 9786: 9785: 9784: 9777: 9774: 9773:Alexander 007 9770: 9765: 9764: 9763: 9762: 9761: 9760: 9751: 9748: 9744: 9739: 9738: 9737: 9736: 9735: 9734: 9733: 9732: 9725: 9722: 9721:Alexander 007 9717: 9716: 9715: 9714: 9713: 9712: 9707: 9704: 9699: 9698: 9697: 9694: 9693:Alexander 007 9689: 9688: 9687: 9686: 9683: 9678: 9677: 9674: 9670: 9665: 9652: 9649: 9644: 9643: 9642: 9641: 9638: 9634: 9630: 9625: 9622:Macedonians. 9621: 9617: 9610: 9607: 9606:Alexander 007 9603: 9601: 9598: 9597:Alexander 007 9594: 9593: 9592: 9591: 9588: 9574: 9573: 9570: 9564: 9561: 9560: 9559: 9558: 9553: 9550: 9546: 9543: 9542: 9541: 9540: 9539: 9537: 9529: 9526: 9525:Alexander 007 9522: 9521:German people 9518: 9514: 9510: 9507: 9505: 9502: 9497: 9491: 9488: 9486: 9483: 9479: 9476: 9475: 9474: 9473: 9468: 9465: 9461: 9457: 9454: 9453: 9452: 9451: 9446: 9443: 9439: 9436: 9435: 9434: 9433: 9428: 9425: 9421: 9417: 9414: 9413: 9412: 9411: 9406: 9403: 9399: 9398: 9397:German people 9394: 9388: 9385: 9384: 9383: 9382: 9381: 9379: 9373: 9370: 9366: 9363: 9362: 9357: 9353: 9349: 9345: 9341: 9340:French people 9337: 9333: 9329: 9326: 9323: 9319: 9315: 9311: 9308: 9304: 9300: 9296: 9293: 9292: 9291: 9290: 9285: 9281: 9278: 9274: 9271: 9270: 9269: 9268: 9263: 9260: 9256: 9253: 9252: 9251: 9250: 9245: 9242: 9238: 9235: 9234: 9233: 9232: 9227: 9224: 9220: 9216: 9213: 9209: 9206: 9205: 9204: 9203: 9202: 9200: 9193: 9191: 9187: 9182: 9181: 9179: 9178: 9175: 9171: 9170:German people 9167: 9163: 9159: 9155: 9151: 9147: 9143: 9142:French people 9139: 9135: 9131: 9127: 9114: 9111: 9110:Alexander 007 9107: 9103: 9102: 9101: 9100: 9093: 9090: 9089:Alexander 007 9086: 9082: 9078: 9074: 9073: 9072: 9071: 9070: 9069: 9064: 9061: 9057: 9056: 9055: 9054: 9051: 9047: 9042: 9038: 9034: 9030: 9029: 9028: 9027: 9024: 9020: 9019:German people 9016: 9012: 9008: 9004: 9000: 8996: 8992: 8991:French people 8988: 8984: 8975: 8974: 8971: 8967: 8957: 8956: 8953: 8941: 8938: 8934: 8933: 8928: 8925: 8921: 8916: 8915: 8914: 8913: 8910: 8907: 8902: 8901: 8900: 8899: 8896: 8890: 8889: 8886: 8882: 8878: 8874: 8870: 8866: 8862: 8856: 8855: 8849: 8846: 8840: 8839: 8835: 8833: 8823: 8822: 8821: 8820: 8819: 8816: 8815: 8812: 8805: 8802: 8798: 8794: 8791: 8787: 8783: 8779: 8775: 8771: 8766: 8762: 8758: 8753: 8749: 8746: 8743: 8740: 8736: 8735: 8734: 8731: 8727: 8724: 8719: 8715: 8711: 8704: 8703: 8699: 8690: 8689:"Macedonian". 8685: 8684: 8680: 8678: 8674: 8673: 8668: 8667: 8660: 8655: 8654: 8653: 8652: 8651: 8646: 8643: 8640: 8637: 8633: 8631: 8625: 8621: 8618: 8613: 8611: 8609: 8607: 8604: 8598: 8597: 8596: 8586: 8583: 8578: 8577: 8576: 8575: 8574: 8573: 8568: 8564: 8560: 8555: 8550: 8546: 8542: 8541: 8540: 8539: 8538: 8535: 8534: 8531: 8527: 8523: 8519: 8514: 8509: 8508: 8505: 8501: 8500: 8494: 8489: 8485: 8481: 8477: 8471: 8470: 8467: 8463: 8459: 8455: 8451: 8448: 8444: 8440: 8428: 8424: 8422: 8416: 8412: 8409: 8408: 8407: 8406: 8403: 8399: 8394: 8393: 8389: 8387: 8381: 8377: 8373: 8369: 8367: 8364: 8354: 8353: 8350: 8343: 8339: 8335: 8332: 8328: 8324: 8323: 8322: 8321: 8319: 8311: 8310: 8307: 8300: 8289: 8286: 8282: 8278: 8277: 8276: 8275: 8272: 8264: 8262: 8256: 8255: 8254: 8253: 8250: 8244:declarations. 8242: 8239: 8236: 8233: 8230: 8229: 8225: 8224: 8220: 8216: 8212: 8208: 8207: 8206: 8205: 8202: 8198: 8197: 8194: 8184: 8180: 8177: 8173: 8169: 8166: 8162: 8158: 8155: 8154: 8153: 8151: 8142: 8139: 8135: 8134: 8133: 8130: 8126: 8122: 8118: 8115: 8110: 8106: 8102: 8101: 8100: 8099: 8096: 8092: 8088: 8084: 8080: 8076: 8072: 8061: 8060: 8055: 8054: 8049: 8048: 8045: 8037: 8034: 8030: 8026: 8025: 8024: 8023: 8022: 8021: 8012: 8009: 8006: 8003: 8000: 7997: 7994: 7991: 7988: 7985: 7982: 7979: 7976: 7975: 7974: 7972: 7968: 7961: 7958: 7954: 7950: 7946: 7945: 7944: 7943: 7940: 7935: 7931: 7927: 7923: 7916:8,100 others. 7915: 7912: 7909: 7906: 7903: 7900: 7897: 7894: 7891: 7888: 7886:289,973 Turks 7885: 7882: 7879: 7878: 7877: 7876: 7871: 7868: 7859: 7858: 7854: 7853: 7849: 7848: 7847: 7844: 7842: 7838: 7832: 7831: 7828: 7824: 7819: 7809: 7806: 7802: 7801: 7800: 7799: 7798: 7797: 7794: 7789: 7785: 7780: 7779: 7776: 7771: 7767: 7763: 7758: 7757: 7752: 7746: 7740: 7738: 7735: 7733: 7730: 7728: 7725: 7723: 7720: 7718: 7715: 7714: 7713: 7711: 7706: 7705: 7702: 7697: 7693: 7688: 7687: 7677: 7673: 7672: 7671: 7670: 7669: 7668: 7665: 7660: 7659: 7656: 7652: 7648: 7644: 7640: 7636: 7624: 7621: 7617: 7612: 7609: 7608: 7607: 7606: 7602: 7591: 7590: 7589: 7588: 7587: 7586: 7582: 7578: 7574: 7564: 7563: 7560: 7556: 7552: 7550: 7535: 7532: 7528: 7523: 7522: 7521: 7518: 7514: 7510: 7506: 7505: 7504: 7501: 7497: 7493: 7489: 7488: 7487: 7486: 7483: 7480: 7476: 7471: 7470: 7469: 7468: 7465: 7457: 7454: 7450: 7449: 7444: 7441: 7437: 7436: 7435: 7434: 7429: 7426: 7422: 7421: 7420: 7419: 7412: 7409: 7404: 7403: 7402: 7401: 7400: 7399: 7396: 7392: 7388: 7384: 7379: 7375: 7374: 7369: 7366: 7362: 7357: 7356: 7355: 7354: 7353: 7352: 7349: 7345: 7340: 7335: 7334: 7331: 7327: 7317: 7314: 7309: 7308: 7307: 7306: 7305: 7304: 7300: 7296: 7290: 7289: 7285: 7281: 7274: 7271: 7270: 7269: 7261: 7257: 7253: 7249: 7245: 7244: 7243: 7242: 7241: 7240: 7237: 7227: 7224: 7220: 7216: 7211: 7210: 7209: 7208: 7207: 7206: 7202: 7198: 7194: 7190: 7186: 7182: 7181:have violated 7178: 7160: 7156: 7152: 7148: 7147: 7146: 7143: 7139: 7138: 7137: 7134: 7130: 7126: 7124: 7121: 7117: 7113: 7108: 7107:they do claim 7104: 7100: 7096: 7095: 7094: 7093: 7090: 7087: 7083: 7078: 7077: 7076: 7075: 7072: 7068: 7064: 7060: 7055: 7051: 7047: 7043: 7038: 7037: 7034: 7023: 7022: 7019: 7013: 7012: 7006: 7005: 7001: 6997: 6992: 6988: 6984: 6977: 6974: 6970: 6967: 6966: 6965: 6964: 6961: 6957: 6954: 6949: 6948: 6945: 6940: 6935: 6934: 6931: 6926: 6925: 6921: 6919: 6913: 6912: 6909: 6905: 6888: 6884: 6880: 6877:That's nice. 6876: 6875: 6874: 6871: 6867: 6863: 6859: 6855: 6854: 6853: 6852: 6849: 6845: 6841: 6837: 6836: 6835: 6834: 6831: 6827: 6823: 6821: 6817: 6813: 6807: 6806:Alexander 007 6802: 6801: 6798: 6792: 6791: 6788: 6785:arbitrary. -- 6777: 6776: 6773: 6772:Alexander 007 6769: 6764: 6759: 6758: 6755: 6754:Alexander 007 6745: 6744: 6741: 6740:Alexander 007 6737: 6733: 6729: 6723: 6720: 6719: 6716: 6713: 6712: 6711: 6709: 6702: 6700: 6696: 6692: 6688: 6683: 6680: 6677: 6676: 6675: 6665: 6662: 6661:Alexander 007 6658: 6654: 6653: 6652: 6651: 6648: 6644: 6629: 6626: 6625:Alexander 007 6622: 6621: 6620: 6619: 6616: 6613: 6609: 6605: 6601: 6597: 6596: 6595: 6594: 6591: 6590:Alexander 007 6576: 6573: 6572:Alexander 007 6569: 6565: 6563: 6560: 6559:Alexander 007 6556: 6552: 6548: 6544: 6541: 6540: 6539: 6538: 6535: 6532: 6528: 6524: 6523: 6522: 6521: 6518: 6513: 6512: 6508: 6504: 6503: 6498: 6494: 6490: 6486: 6483: 6479: 6472: 6469: 6468:Alexander 007 6465: 6464: 6463: 6462: 6458: 6454: 6453: 6448: 6441: 6438: 6437:Alexander 007 6434: 6430: 6429: 6426: 6423: 6422:Alexander 007 6419: 6414: 6413: 6412: 6411: 6407: 6403: 6402: 6394: 6390: 6386: 6382: 6381: 6380: 6379: 6375: 6371: 6370: 6365: 6364:inherited DNA 6361: 6360:Gregor Mendel 6357: 6352: 6347: 6345: 6339: 6329: 6326: 6325:Alexander 007 6321: 6320: 6317: 6313: 6309: 6308: 6303: 6298: 6295: 6294: 6293: 6292: 6289: 6288:Alexander 007 6284: 6283: 6280: 6279:Alexander 007 6269: 6268: 6265: 6257: 6253: 6249: 6245: 6241: 6237: 6236: 6235: 6233: 6229: 6219: 6218: 6214: 6210: 6209: 6202: 6201: 6197: 6193: 6192: 6187: 6186:pseudoscience 6183: 6179: 6172: 6169: 6168:Alexander 007 6165: 6161: 6157: 6156: 6155: 6154: 6150: 6146: 6145: 6140: 6133: 6130: 6129:Alexander 007 6126: 6125: 6124: 6123: 6119: 6115: 6114: 6103: 6102: 6099: 6085: 6082: 6081:Alexander 007 6077: 6076: 6075: 6074: 6071: 6068: 6064: 6063: 6062: 6061: 6058: 6052: 6051: 6048: 6047:Alexander 007 6044: 6031: 6028: 6024: 6020: 6019: 6018: 6017: 6014: 6003: 6002: 5999: 5984: 5981: 5977: 5976: 5975: 5974: 5969: 5965: 5961: 5957: 5954: 5951: 5947: 5944: 5943: 5942: 5941: 5940: 5939: 5936: 5926: 5925: 5922: 5915: 5912: 5907: 5903: 5900: 5896: 5892: 5891: 5890: 5888: 5883: 5882: 5879: 5876:Sweden etc)-- 5874: 5870: 5862: 5859: 5856: 5853: 5850: 5847: 5844: 5841: 5838: 5835: 5832: 5829: 5826: 5823: 5820: 5817: 5814: 5811: 5808: 5805: 5802: 5799: 5797:4.270 (2001)( 5796: 5793: 5790: 5787: 5784: 5781: 5779: 5776: 5773: 5770: 5769:United States 5767: 5764: 5761: 5758: 5755: 5752: 5749: 5748: 5742: 5741: 5737: 5733: 5729: 5725: 5722: 5719: 5715: 5714:203.63.57.218 5705: 5701: 5697: 5693: 5689: 5688: 5687: 5686: 5685: 5684: 5680: 5676: 5672: 5658: 5654: 5650: 5646: 5642: 5639: 5636: 5633: 5632: 5631: 5630: 5629: 5628: 5624: 5623: 5619: 5618: 5613: 5612: 5607: 5606: 5602: 5601: 5597: 5596: 5592: 5589: 5585: 5582: 5579: 5572: 5568: 5564: 5560: 5556: 5552: 5551: 5550: 5549: 5548: 5541: 5537: 5533: 5529: 5525: 5521: 5518: 5515: 5511: 5507: 5503: 5500: 5497: 5496: 5495: 5494: 5491: 5487: 5483: 5479: 5478: 5473: 5472: 5471: 5469: 5466: 5462: 5448: 5444: 5440: 5436: 5431: 5428: 5427: 5426: 5425: 5424: 5423: 5414: 5410: 5406: 5405: 5404: 5398: 5393: 5389: 5386:and even the 5385: 5381: 5376: 5375: 5366: 5362: 5358: 5353: 5349: 5346: 5345: 5344: 5343: 5342: 5341: 5340: 5339: 5338: 5328: 5324: 5320: 5315: 5314: 5313: 5312: 5311: 5307: 5303: 5302: 5301: 5294: 5293: 5289: 5287: 5284: 5282: 5279: 5277: 5274: 5272:"Macedonians" 5271: 5270: 5266: 5262: 5258: 5254: 5253: 5252: 5250: 5246: 5242: 5227: 5226: 5225: 5224: 5223: 5219: 5215: 5214: 5213: 5207: 5203: 5202:ethnic groups 5199: 5195: 5194: 5193: 5184: 5180: 5176: 5171: 5168: 5164: 5161: 5158: 5155: 5154: 5153: 5152: 5151: 5150: 5149: 5147: 5143: 5139: 5133: 5132: 5128: 5124: 5123: 5119: 5115: 5101: 5097: 5093: 5088: 5087: 5086: 5085: 5084: 5080: 5076: 5072: 5069: 5065: 5061: 5057: 5053: 5052: 5051: 5050: 5049: 5048: 5044: 5040: 5037: 5028: 5024: 5020: 5015: 5014: 5013: 5012: 5011: 5010: 5006: 5002: 4999: 4997: 4983: 4979: 4975: 4970: 4969: 4968: 4967: 4966: 4963: 4959: 4955: 4954: 4947: 4943: 4939: 4934: 4930: 4929: 4928: 4927: 4926: 4925: 4924: 4923: 4920: 4915: 4914: 4911: 4906: 4905: 4901: 4897: 4875: 4871: 4867: 4863: 4858: 4857: 4856: 4855: 4854: 4850: 4846: 4842: 4838: 4837: 4836: 4832: 4828: 4824: 4823: 4822: 4821: 4820: 4819: 4818: 4817: 4816: 4815: 4800: 4796: 4792: 4788: 4784: 4781: 4777: 4773: 4770: 4769: 4768: 4767: 4766: 4765: 4764: 4761: 4757: 4752: 4751: 4750: 4746: 4742: 4737: 4734: 4730: 4729: 4728: 4727: 4726: 4723: 4718: 4717: 4712: 4711:Terri Schiavo 4708: 4707: 4706: 4705: 4702: 4698: 4692: 4691: 4688: 4684: 4673: 4669: 4665: 4661: 4660: 4659: 4658: 4657: 4656: 4655: 4654: 4651: 4647: 4643: 4639: 4635: 4622: 4618: 4614: 4610: 4609: 4608: 4607: 4606: 4603: 4597: 4596: 4595: 4594: 4591: 4588: 4584: 4583: 4582: 4581: 4578: 4571: 4565:Unprotection? 4554: 4550: 4546: 4542: 4538: 4535: 4534: 4533: 4532: 4531: 4528: 4524: 4520: 4515: 4512: 4511:Chronographos 4508: 4507: 4506: 4505: 4502: 4498: 4494: 4490: 4489: 4488: 4487: 4483: 4479: 4475: 4474:premature Med 4468: 4464: 4460: 4457: 4453: 4452: 4445: 4441: 4437: 4433: 4432: 4431: 4430: 4429: 4428: 4427: 4426: 4422: 4418: 4412: 4411: 4407: 4403: 4394: 4393:Chronographos 4391: 4388: 4384: 4381: 4378: 4375: 4371: 4368: 4367: 4366: 4364: 4363:Chronographos 4360: 4356: 4352: 4342: 4338: 4334: 4329: 4328: 4327: 4326: 4325: 4324: 4320: 4316: 4312: 4308: 4301: 4298: 4297:Alexander 007 4294: 4291: 4288: 4285: 4281: 4280: 4275: 4272: 4267: 4266: 4265: 4264: 4258: 4253: 4249: 4248: 4247: 4246: 4242: 4239: 4235: 4234: 4233: 4232: 4228: 4224: 4219: 4218: 4214: 4210: 4205: 4204: 4200: 4196: 4192: 4187: 4186: 4182: 4178: 4174: 4170: 4167: 4157: 4153: 4149: 4145: 4141: 4140: 4139: 4138: 4137: 4136: 4135: 4134: 4130: 4126: 4121: 4117: 4116: 4112: 4108: 4100: 4096: 4092: 4088: 4084: 4080: 4076: 4071: 4070: 4063: 4059: 4055: 4051: 4047: 4046: 4045: 4044: 4043: 4042: 4041: 4040: 4036: 4032: 4027: 4016: 4012: 4008: 4004: 4000: 3996: 3992: 3988: 3984: 3983: 3982: 3979: 3975: 3971: 3968:published by 3967: 3963: 3959: 3955: 3951: 3947: 3946: 3945: 3941: 3937: 3933: 3929: 3925: 3921: 3917: 3916: 3915: 3914: 3911: 3907: 3903: 3899: 3895: 3890: 3886: 3883:According to 3879: 3862: 3858: 3854: 3849: 3848: 3847: 3846: 3845: 3842: 3837: 3836: 3835: 3834: 3833: 3832: 3831: 3830: 3817: 3813: 3809: 3805: 3802: 3798: 3794: 3793: 3792: 3791: 3790: 3787: 3783: 3782: 3781: 3780: 3779: 3778: 3777: 3776: 3769: 3765: 3761: 3757: 3753: 3752: 3751: 3750: 3749: 3748: 3747: 3746: 3742: 3738: 3734: 3730: 3723: 3719: 3715: 3711: 3707: 3706: 3701: 3697: 3693: 3689: 3685: 3681: 3675: 3671: 3667: 3662: 3658: 3655: 3651: 3650: 3649: 3648: 3647: 3646: 3645: 3641: 3637: 3632: 3631: 3630: 3629: 3626: 3622: 3618: 3610: 3607: 3606: 3605: 3602: 3599: 3596: 3594: 3590: 3589:Knowledge:POV 3574: 3570: 3566: 3561: 3558: 3554: 3551: 3547: 3546: 3545: 3544: 3542: 3538: 3534: 3530: 3526: 3522: 3521:Olympic games 3518: 3517:ancient Greek 3514: 3510: 3505: 3500: 3496: 3492: 3491: 3490: 3489: 3486: 3482: 3475: 3453: 3449: 3445: 3441: 3437: 3436: 3435: 3434: 3433: 3432: 3431: 3430: 3429: 3428: 3427: 3426: 3425: 3424: 3423: 3422: 3411: 3407: 3403: 3402: 3401: 3395: 3391: 3390: 3389: 3388: 3387: 3386: 3385: 3384: 3383: 3382: 3367: 3363: 3359: 3355: 3354: 3353: 3352: 3351: 3350: 3349: 3346: 3341: 3340: 3339: 3338: 3337: 3336: 3335: 3334: 3327: 3323: 3319: 3318: 3317: 3311: 3307: 3303: 3298: 3297: 3292: 3291: 3290: 3289: 3288: 3287: 3282: 3279: 3275: 3270: 3266: 3262: 3258: 3255: 3251: 3247: 3246: 3245: 3244: 3241: 3237: 3233: 3232: 3231: 3225: 3220: 3215: 3214: 3207: 3203: 3199: 3194: 3193: 3192: 3191: 3190: 3189: 3188: 3187: 3184: 3179: 3164: 3163: 3160: 3159: 3158: 3157: 3156: 3155: 3150: 3147: 3143: 3142: 3141: 3140: 3131: 3128: 3123: 3122: 3121: 3120: 3119: 3118: 3117: 3116: 3109: 3105: 3101: 3096: 3092: 3091: 3090: 3089: 3088: 3087: 3086: 3085: 3082: 3074: 3073: 3069: 3065: 3061: 3057: 3053: 3049: 3040: 3037: 3032: 3031: 3029: 3028: 3025: 3021: 3017: 3012: 3009: 3006: 3002: 2999: 2995: 2994: 2985: 2982: 2978: 2974: 2970: 2969: 2966: 2965: 2962: 2961: 2958: 2957: 2946: 2942: 2938: 2933: 2929: 2928: 2923: 2920: 2917: 2913: 2909: 2906: 2905: 2904: 2903: 2902: 2899: 2895: 2894: 2891: 2890: 2888: 2887: 2882: 2878: 2877: 2870: 2866: 2862: 2858: 2855: 2851: 2848: 2843: 2842: 2841: 2840: 2839: 2835: 2831: 2827: 2823: 2820: 2819: 2818: 2817: 2814: 2810: 2798: 2793: 2789: 2785: 2781: 2780: 2779: 2778: 2775: 2770: 2769: 2765: 2761: 2750: 2746: 2742: 2738: 2735: 2734: 2733: 2732: 2731: 2730: 2729: 2728: 2727: 2723: 2719: 2707: 2703: 2699: 2694: 2690: 2686: 2682: 2679: 2678: 2677: 2676: 2675: 2674: 2673: 2672: 2669: 2659: 2656: 2652: 2651: 2650: 2632: 2628: 2624: 2619: 2618: 2617: 2616: 2615: 2612: 2608: 2604: 2592: 2588: 2584: 2579: 2578: 2577: 2576: 2575: 2574: 2573: 2572: 2571: 2567: 2563: 2559: 2555: 2554: 2553: 2550: 2545: 2537: 2533: 2529: 2525: 2521: 2518: 2515: 2510: 2506: 2505: 2504: 2503: 2502: 2501: 2500: 2499: 2498: 2495: 2494:83.79.181.171 2491: 2487: 2483: 2479: 2475: 2470: 2466: 2465: 2460: 2456: 2452: 2448: 2444: 2440: 2436: 2435: 2434: 2433: 2432: 2428: 2424: 2420: 2416: 2410: 2406: 2402: 2397: 2394: 2393: 2392: 2391: 2390: 2389: 2388: 2387: 2384: 2383:83.79.181.171 2381: 2377: 2373: 2369: 2365: 2361: 2357: 2345: 2341: 2337: 2333: 2332: 2331: 2330: 2329: 2326: 2322: 2318: 2314: 2310: 2309: 2308: 2307: 2303: 2299: 2293: 2289: 2285: 2274: 2270: 2266: 2262: 2261: 2260: 2259: 2258: 2255: 2251: 2247: 2243: 2242: 2241: 2240: 2236: 2232: 2228: 2224: 2220: 2216: 2203: 2199: 2195: 2190: 2187: 2185: 2183: 2181: 2178: 2174: 2170: 2169: 2168: 2167: 2166: 2163: 2158: 2157: 2156: 2152: 2148: 2144: 2139: 2138: 2133: 2129: 2125: 2120: 2117: 2113: 2110: 2107: 2103: 2100: 2096: 2093: 2088: 2085: 2081: 2077: 2074: 2070: 2066: 2063: 2059: 2055: 2054: 2053: 2052: 2051: 2050: 2047: 2043: 2039: 2035: 2032: 2028: 2025: 2022: 2008: 2004: 2000: 1996: 1991: 1990: 1989: 1988: 1987: 1986: 1982: 1978: 1974: 1958: 1955: 1951: 1950: 1949: 1948: 1947: 1946: 1941: 1937: 1933: 1928: 1927: 1926: 1925: 1922: 1918: 1914: 1910: 1906: 1902: 1898: 1894: 1890: 1886: 1882: 1881: 1880: 1879: 1876: 1871: 1870: 1867: 1862: 1858: 1854: 1850: 1834: 1830: 1826: 1822: 1818: 1817: 1816: 1815: 1814: 1813: 1812: 1811: 1807: 1803: 1799: 1795: 1791: 1787: 1783: 1782:nothing there 1773: 1769: 1765: 1761: 1760: 1759: 1755: 1751: 1747: 1742: 1741: 1740: 1739: 1735: 1731: 1718: 1714: 1710: 1706: 1702: 1701: 1700: 1699: 1698: 1694: 1690: 1686: 1685:following you 1682: 1679: 1678: 1677: 1673: 1669: 1664: 1663: 1662: 1661: 1657: 1653: 1649: 1645: 1644:Boolean logic 1641: 1640: 1634: 1630: 1626: 1622: 1621:wiki-stalking 1612: 1611: 1607: 1603: 1599: 1595: 1591: 1587: 1583: 1574: 1570: 1566: 1562: 1558: 1554: 1553: 1552: 1551: 1550: 1549: 1545: 1541: 1535: 1534: 1531: 1526: 1521: 1515: 1513: 1509: 1507: 1504: 1503: 1502: 1500: 1496: 1492: 1488: 1480: 1475: 1474: 1471: 1466: 1465: 1462: 1458: 1456: 1448: 1447: 1444: 1440: 1439:doesn't exist 1436: 1431: 1427: 1423: 1419: 1415: 1411: 1407: 1406:User:Matia.gr 1392: 1388: 1384: 1379: 1378: 1377: 1376: 1375: 1374: 1371: 1367: 1362: 1361: 1358: 1354: 1349: 1345: 1342: 1339: 1336: 1333: 1330: 1328: 1323: 1321: 1316: 1304: 1301: 1297: 1296: 1295: 1294: 1293: 1285: 1279: 1276: 1272: 1268: 1267: 1266: 1256: 1252: 1248: 1243: 1240: 1237: 1236: 1235: 1234: 1233: 1230: 1226: 1225: 1224: 1213: 1209: 1205: 1201: 1196: 1193: 1189: 1185: 1182: 1179: 1178: 1177: 1176: 1175: 1171: 1167: 1163: 1159: 1155: 1151: 1147: 1142: 1141: 1140: 1130: 1126: 1122: 1117: 1113: 1109: 1106: 1103: 1102: 1101: 1100: 1098: 1095: 1094:Alexander 007 1091: 1086: 1085: 1072: 1069: 1065: 1061: 1058: 1055: 1054: 1053: 1052: 1051: 1048: 1043: 1039: 1035: 1034: 1033: 1032: 1031: 1030: 1029: 1028: 1023: 1020: 1016: 1012: 1011:User:Matia.gr 1008: 1004: 1003: 1002: 1001: 994: 993: 992: 991: 985: 981: 980: 979: 978: 971: 970: 969: 968: 961: 960: 959: 958: 951: 950: 949: 948: 941: 940: 939: 938: 931: 930: 929: 928: 921: 920: 919: 918: 912: 911: 910: 909: 902: 901: 900: 899: 892: 891: 890: 889: 883: 879: 878: 877: 876: 870: 867: 864: 860: 859: 858: 857: 856: 855: 852: 847: 844: 842: 838: 834: 829: 826: 824: 819: 817: 813: 809: 805: 789: 786: 782: 779: 775: 774: 773: 772: 771: 770: 767: 764: 760: 759: 755: 754: 750: 746: 742: 741:some question 738: 737: 733: 732: 731: 730: 727: 723: 705: 702: 697: 693: 690: 689: 688: 685: 681: 680: 679: 676: 672: 669: 666: 663: 661: 658: 655: 654: 653: 652: 651: 650: 647: 643: 640: 636: 635: 620: 617: 613: 610: 606: 605: 604: 603: 602: 601: 598: 594: 590: 580: 579: 575: 571: 565: 561: 557: 553: 551: 546: 538: 534: 530: 529: 528: 527: 526: 525: 522: 512: 508: 503: 499: 498: 497: 496: 490: 489: 488: 487: 481: 477: 473: 472: 471: 470: 464: 463: 462: 461: 455: 451: 446: 441: 440: 439: 438: 434: 431:What do you, 430: 429: 428: 420: 416: 412: 411: 410: 409: 403: 402: 400: 397: 394: 391: 390: 389: 380: 376: 371: 367: 363: 362: 361: 360: 359: 350: 346: 341: 338: 333: 332: 331: 330: 324: 323: 322: 321: 315: 311: 306: 302: 301: 300: 299: 295: 294: 288: 284: 279: 275: 271: 268: 264: 263: 262: 261: 255: 254: 253: 252: 246: 242: 238: 233: 232: 231: 230: 226: 225: 224: 217: 214: 209: 205: 201: 200: 199: 198: 197: 196: 193: 185: 181: 180: 179: 176: 173: 168: 166: 156: 155: 150: 149: 147: 143: 137: 135: 134: 132: 128: 124: 120: 116: 110: 109: 99: 96: 93: 91: 88: 86: 83: 80: 76: 74: 71: 69: 66: 63: 61: 58: 57: 49: 45: 41: 40: 35: 28: 27: 19: 13289: 13279: 13267: 13262: 13250: 13233: 13219: 13213: 13212: 13210: 13204: 13203: 13201: 13198: 13194: 13178: 13139: 13126:. Instead, 13098: 13091: 13089: 13084: 13081:'s additions 13067: 13052: 13048: 13047: 13037: 13022: 13018: 13006: 12997:the truth.-- 12951: 12947: 12940: 12933:See details 12932: 12930: 12927: 12913: 12909: 12905: 12901: 12898: 12895: 12891: 12887: 12883: 12879: 12875: 12871: 12867: 12863: 12859: 12855: 12851: 12848: 12845: 12842: 12838: 12808: 12804: 12801: 12793: 12766: 12761: 12739: 12735: 12732: 12729: 12726: 12723: 12720: 12717: 12714: 12711: 12708: 12704: 12701: 12697: 12694: 12691: 12688: 12684: 12681: 12678: 12668: 12665: 12661: 12658: 12654: 12650: 12647: 12644: 12640: 12636: 12632: 12629: 12625: 12622: 12618: 12615: 12607: 12603: 12599: 12595: 12591: 12588: 12585: 12581: 12577: 12573: 12569: 12565: 12561: 12557: 12553: 12549: 12545: 12541: 12538: 12534: 12530: 12527: 12524: 12521: 12517: 12514: 12510: 12507: 12503: 12500: 12496: 12492: 12489: 12485: 12481: 12478: 12475: 12472: 12469: 12466: 12462: 12459: 12456: 12452: 12449: 12445: 12442: 12439: 12436: 12432: 12429: 12425: 12422: 12418: 12415: 12412: 12409: 12406: 12403: 12399: 12396: 12392: 12389: 12386: 12383: 12379: 12376: 12372: 12369: 12366: 12363: 12359: 12356: 12353: 12350: 12347: 12344: 12341: 12338: 12335: 12332: 12329: 12326: 12323: 12318: 12315: 12312: 12307: 12304: 12301: 12298: 12295: 12291: 12288: 12284: 12281: 12278: 12275: 12271: 12268: 12265: 12262: 12258: 12255: 12251: 12248: 12245: 12242: 12239: 12236: 12233: 12230: 12226: 12223: 12219: 12216: 12213: 12210: 12206: 12203: 12199: 12196: 12192: 12189: 12185: 12182: 12179: 12175: 12171: 12168: 12165: 12162: 12159: 12156: 12153: 12150: 12146: 12141: 12137: 12132: 12128: 12125: 12100: 12040: 12027: 11954: 11939: 11936: 11932: 11903: 11889: 11882: 11854: 11850: 11846: 11830: 11812: 11794: 11747: 11743: 11739: 11735: 11702: 11667: 11656: 11650: 11646: 11640: 11628: 11625: 11612: 11603: 11599: 11595: 11591: 11587: 11585: 11581: 11576: 11548: 11541: 11537: 11533: 11529: 11527: 11523: 11513: 11501: 11496: 11482: 11471: 11467: 11460: 11458: 11454: 11452: 11436: 11425: 11415: 11411: 11407: 11401:publications 11400: 11396: 11393:Pavlos Melas 11389: 11322: 11314: 11289: 11274: 11270: 11266: 11244:publications 11243: 11239: 11233: 11185: 11181: 11176: 11162: 11159: 11155: 11111: 11104: 11024: 11015: 11011: 10982: 10939: 10928: 10904: 10901: 10878: 10875: 10870:Thessaloniki 10856: 10781: 10772: 10770: 10765: 10764: 10751: 10743: 10710: 10700:Jireček Line 10695: 10693: 10675:Anna Comnena 10585: 10577: 10573: 10571: 10544: 10537: 10491: 10444: 10320:Roman Empire 10300: 10296: 10288: 10269:Roman Empire 10079: 10063: 10046:identities ( 9985: 9947: 9940: 9936: 9928: 9924: 9920: 9913:ethnic group 9905:Roman Empire 9847: 9815: 9743:specifically 9742: 9679: 9668: 9663: 9660: 9613: 9584: 9566: 9562: 9544: 9535: 9534: 9508: 9489: 9477: 9455: 9437: 9415: 9390: 9386: 9377: 9376: 9364: 9335: 9317: 9294: 9279: 9276: 9272: 9254: 9236: 9214: 9207: 9198: 9196: 9189: 9185: 9183: 9146:Dutch people 9138:Irish people 9124: 9081:Ethnic group 9077:Ethnic group 9040: 8995:Dutch people 8987:Irish people 8981: 8965: 8963: 8949: 8891: 8857: 8850: 8841: 8838: 8836: 8831: 8830: 8817: 8808: 8796: 8776: 8770:contemporary 8769: 8738: 8729: 8722: 8714:Thessaloniki 8705: 8696: 8693: 8687: 8658: 8649: 8635: 8627: 8623: 8616: 8600: 8593: 8544: 8536: 8512: 8510: 8496: 8491: 8490:And again: 8487: 8483: 8475: 8472: 8443:edit warring 8436: 8420: 8395: 8385: 8375: 8371: 8360: 8347: 8315: 8312: 8292: 8280: 8268: 8258: 8247: 8200: 8199: 8190: 8188: 8182: 8171: 8160: 8156: 8147: 8124: 8112: 8108: 8090: 8087:WP:Vandalism 8067: 8056: 8050: 8043: 8042: 8028: 8016: 8007:3,500 greeks 8001:3,291 greeks 7989:2,112 greeks 7986:4,240 greeks 7970: 7966: 7964: 7952: 7948: 7921: 7919: 7873: 7872: 7863: 7845: 7833: 7822: 7817: 7814: 7787: 7783: 7781: 7769: 7765: 7759: 7750: 7747: 7744: 7709: 7707: 7689: 7682: 7661: 7650: 7646: 7645:I know what 7642: 7632: 7614: 7598: 7580: 7570: 7554: 7548: 7546: 7544: 7512: 7508: 7495: 7491: 7460: 7382: 7377: 7360: 7336: 7325: 7323: 7291: 7277: 7272: 7267: 7255: 7251: 7247: 7232: 7218: 7214: 7180: 7174: 7171:Edit-warring 7115: 7111: 7106: 7102: 7098: 7066: 7062: 7049: 7045: 7041: 7039: 7029: 7014: 7007: 6980: 6952: 6950: 6938: 6936: 6927: 6922: 6914: 6900: 6861: 6825: 6809: 6803: 6793: 6783: 6780:Latest edits 6760: 6751: 6726: 6721: 6714: 6707: 6705: 6684: 6681: 6678: 6673: 6656: 6642: 6639: 6586: 6514: 6500: 6484: 6481: 6475: 6450: 6444: 6399: 6397: 6367: 6363: 6351:ethnic links 6350: 6341: 6332: 6305: 6285: 6275: 6261: 6232:verification 6225: 6206: 6203: 6189: 6175: 6163: 6159: 6142: 6136: 6111: 6109: 6095: 6053: 6039: 6009: 5994: 5949: 5932: 5918: 5905: 5898: 5894: 5886: 5884: 5866: 5857: 5848: 5839: 5830: 5821: 5812: 5803: 5794: 5785: 5777: 5768: 5759: 5750: 5720: 5710: 5692:already said 5691: 5668: 5626: 5625: 5621: 5620: 5615: 5614: 5609: 5608: 5604: 5603: 5599: 5598: 5594: 5593: 5590: 5586: 5583: 5580: 5577: 5546: 5475: 5458: 5417: 5401: 5400: 5335: 5298: 5297: 5260: 5256: 5239:unsigned by 5235: 5210: 5209: 5191: 5167:Not even one 5166: 5136:unsigned by 5134: 5129: 5125: 5110: 5059: 5055: 5035: 5033: 4993: 4990: 4916: 4907: 4892: 4861: 4693: 4680: 4641: 4637: 4633: 4631: 4572: 4568: 4540: 4523:consensually 4522: 4513: 4509:To be fair, 4473: 4471: 4455: 4413: 4398: 4347: 4306: 4304: 4220: 4206: 4188: 4164: 4143: 4119: 4118: 4103: 4025: 4023: 3973: 3965: 3957: 3932:Au contraire 3931: 3923: 3901: 3892: 3882: 3726: 3709: 3683: 3620: 3614: 3603: 3600: 3597: 3586: 3550:really a lot 3549: 3515:or in plain 3478: 3398: 3397: 3393: 3314: 3313: 3309: 3306:Celtic Tiger 3294: 3273: 3253: 3228: 3227: 3178:George Soros 3175: 3075: 3045: 3034:Knowledge.-- 2972: 2926: 2826:"n-1"th time 2804: 2796: 2771: 2757: 2715: 2714: 2664: 2654: 2648: 2508: 2489: 2485: 2481: 2468: 2462: 2442: 2352: 2281: 2215:sockpuppetry 2212: 2099:since 1953rd 2098: 2084:the only one 2083: 2079: 2021:chauvinistic 2018: 1994: 1970: 1872: 1860: 1856: 1852: 1848: 1846: 1843:Step by step 1781: 1778: 1727: 1684: 1680: 1638: 1636: 1632: 1628: 1624: 1620: 1618: 1579: 1561:User:Ed Poor 1556: 1536: 1520:Translation: 1519: 1518: 1510: 1505: 1484: 1467: 1451: 1449: 1438: 1434: 1426:Village Pump 1402: 1365: 1363: 1350: 1346: 1343: 1340: 1337: 1334: 1331: 1326: 1324: 1319: 1317: 1314: 1291: 1282: 1269:Please read 1263: 1220: 1137: 1111:nationality? 881: 861:With all my 848: 845: 830: 827: 822: 820: 801: 744: 740: 719: 659: 632: 630: 592: 588: 586: 566: 562: 558: 554: 547: 544: 518: 444: 426: 386: 356: 336: 222: 189: 177: 169: 164: 162: 154: 153: 144:. (See also 139: 138: 112: 111: 78: 43: 37: 13305:User:Miskin 11851:Macedonians 11738:. He was a 11588:Macedonians 11542:Macedonians 11530:Macedonians 11188:Big Adamsky 11114:Big Adamsky 11073:place names 11020:nationalism 10942:Big Adamsky 10591:nationality 10078:; the name 9820:Macedonians 9569:Big Adamsky 9460:User:ChrisO 9277:Macedonians 9212:Macedonians 8946:Unprotected 8761:Macedonians 7998:5584 greeks 7553:So now it " 7547:While that 7507:While that 7219:South Slavs 7193:differences 7099:attributing 6826:any sources 6551:Phoenicians 5849:Switzerland 5842:456 (2001)( 5840:New Zealand 5064:Talk:Epirus 4756:Talk:Gdańsk 4754:the top of 4634:The Dispute 3970:User:ChrisO 3906:coup d'état 3878:Coup d'état 3660:teritories. 3509:Demosthenes 3504:Macedonians 3181:reliable?-- 2038:irredentism 1327:Macedonians 1320:Macedonians 833:nationality 165:Macedonians 36:This is an 13292:Bulgarians 13242:talk (el:) 13186:talk (el:) 13152:talk (el:) 13108:talk (el:) 12999:FocalPoint 12954:FocalPoint 12943:user:Aldux 11979:Mukadderat 11957:Mukadderat 11881:says that 11651:Makedonski 11538:Bulgarians 11534:Bulgarians 11429:Bulgarians 11397:Macedonian 11271:Makedoniki 11093:the French 11089:Bulgarians 10924:Peoplehood 10887:User:Bomac 10815:User:Bomac 10600:Pakistanis 10540:pseudonyme 10398:The Finger 10157:Aryan race 9941:Rumaneasca 9937:Romaneasca 9581:Discussion 9495:Bonaparte 9369:LuiKhuntek 9217:direct to 9046:WhiteNight 8920:Aryan race 8670:with that. 8196:vandalism. 8165:Bulgarians 8150:User:Aldux 7875:refugees). 7867:Asia Minor 7762:Asia Minor 7696:Asia Minor 7496:macedonian 7065:that they 6302:Ashkenazim 5960:Macedonian 5696:Macedonian 5671:check this 5649:Macedonian 5563:Macedonian 5532:Macedonian 5508:and their 5439:Macedonian 5357:Macedonian 5319:Macedonian 5175:Macedonian 5092:Macedonian 5019:Macedonian 4974:Macedonian 4938:Macedonian 4866:Macedonian 4839:Of course 4791:Macedonian 4741:Macedonian 4664:Macedonian 4613:Macedonian 4545:Macedonian 4436:Macedonian 4370:Theathenae 4351:Theathenae 4333:Macedonian 4148:Macedonian 4054:Macedonian 3978:Theathenae 3910:Theathenae 3853:Macedonian 3808:Macedonian 3727:Also, was 3666:Macedonian 3565:Macedonian 3495:Bulgarians 3440:wikiquette 3358:Macedonian 3265:Yugoslavia 3198:Macedonian 3100:Macedonian 3048:Ethnologue 3016:Macedonian 2937:Macedonian 2881:Macedonian 2861:Macedonian 2806:ethnicity. 2741:Macedonian 2698:Macedonian 2605:Of course 2583:Macedonian 2547:language. 2528:Macedonian 2419:Britannica 2401:Macedonian 2336:Macedonian 2325:Theathenae 2265:Macedonian 2254:Theathenae 2194:Macedonian 2177:Theathenae 2162:Theathenae 2124:Macedonian 2073:Theathenae 2058:Theathenae 2046:Theathenae 1999:Macedonian 1932:Macedonian 1825:Macedonian 1746:Arvanitika 1709:Macedonian 1565:Macedonian 1383:Macedonian 1357:Macedonian 1300:Macedonian 1247:Macedonian 1204:Macedonian 1121:Macedonian 1068:Macedonian 1019:Macedonian 1015:User:VMORO 814:" for the 808:Yugoslavia 785:Macedonian 716:Revert war 701:Macedonian 684:Theathenae 675:Macedonian 646:Theathenae 616:Macedonian 597:Theathenae 570:Macedonian 533:Macedonian 507:Macedonian 476:Macedonian 450:Macedonian 415:Macedonian 375:Macedonian 345:Macedonian 310:Macedonian 283:Macedonian 241:Macedonian 213:Macedonian 98:Archive 10 13273:Macedonia 13254:Macedonia 13226:Macedonia 13010:Macedonia 12706:decades. 11988:FlavrSavr 11748:Makedonas 11740:Byzantine 11736:not Greek 11705:heard of 11567:AKeckarov 11487:AKeckarov 11422:Macedonia 11315:conquered 11279:Macedonia 11199:FlavrSavr 11167:FlavrSavr 11105:See also 11101:Egyptians 11081:Ghanaians 11077:Hawaiians 11069:ethnonyms 10929:See also 10910:FlavrSavr 10786:FlavrSavr 10558:FlavrSavr 10545:Alexandre 10517:FlavrSavr 10445:jack shit 10100:Knowledge 10084:Romanized 10060:ethnonyms 10052:Illyrians 10048:Thracians 9909:Romanians 9862:FlavrSavr 9795:FlavrSavr 9747:FlavrSavr 9703:FlavrSavr 9682:FlavrSavr 9673:FlavrSavr 9624:Ethnicity 9616:Bulgarian 9549:FlavrSavr 9284:Macedonia 8854:Macedonia 8790:Bulgarian 8782:Bulgarian 8765:Bulgarian 8757:Macedonia 8702:Macedonia 8567:Macedonia 8549:FlavrSavr 8504:FlavrSavr 8454:Mediation 8439:protected 8433:Protected 8411:of course 8338:Bulgarian 8327:Bulgarian 8204:Macedonia 8114:vandalism 8103:Hmmm.... 8083:WP:POLICY 8075:WP:POLICY 8071:WP:POLICY 8059:Macedonia 8047:Macedonia 8020:Macedonia 7949:important 7827:Makedon45 7784:invanders 7756:Makedon45 7686:Makedon45 7655:FlavrSavr 7620:FlavrSavr 7585:Makedon45 7517:FlavrSavr 7361:ethnicity 7256:regarding 7142:FlavrSavr 7133:FlavrSavr 7120:FlavrSavr 7071:FlavrSavr 7033:FlavrSavr 7011:Makedon45 6924:Makedon45 6870:FlavrSavr 6830:FlavrSavr 6797:FlavrSavr 6787:FlavrSavr 6768:Albanians 6763:Albanians 6695:Paionians 6691:Illyrians 6687:Thracians 6497:evolution 6478:phenotype 6252:Paionians 6248:Illyrians 6244:Thracians 6139:appearing 5935:estavisti 5921:FlavrSavr 5911:FlavrSavr 5887:see below 5878:FlavrSavr 5869:FlavrSavr 5786:Australia 5645:something 5559:judgement 5510:judgement 5056:companies 4910:FlavrSavr 4701:FlavrSavr 4687:FlavrSavr 4681:See also: 4650:FlavrSavr 4646:FlavrSavr 4527:FlavrSavr 4241:talk page 4026:offensive 3999:Arvanites 3966:guideline 3841:FlavrSavr 3786:FlavrSavr 3537:Christian 3296:convicted 3261:Macedonia 3257:communism 3250:socialism 2655:unrelated 2558:Arvanites 2464:adjective 2374:and make 2250:Arvanites 2031:Macedonia 1875:FlavrSavr 1866:FlavrSavr 1853:described 1703:Can you, 1586:FlavrSavr 1499:following 1150:Brythonic 1042:Romanians 1038:Moldovans 837:ethnicity 823:Makedonia 749:ethnicity 593:consensus 146:Archive 2 131:Archive 5 127:Archive 4 123:Archive 3 119:Archive 2 115:Archive 1 90:Archive 8 85:Archive 7 79:Archive 6 73:Archive 5 68:Archive 4 60:Archive 1 13202:pg 58 12101:basileus 12076:Emperor. 12024:To Aldux 11986:Done. -- 11917:Basil II 11845:If this 11335:Monastir 11217:Tombseye 11182:entirely 11163:the text 11142:Tombseye 11097:Latvians 11048:Tombseye 10970:Tombseye 10845:Tombseye 10797:Tombseye 10680:Tombseye 10626:Tombseye 10621:Pashtuns 10596:Iranians 10471:Tombseye 10424:Tombseye 10375:Tombseye 10353:schooled 10338:Tombseye 10285:ethnonym 10251:Tombseye 10183:Tombseye 10139:Tombseye 10115:I think 10013:Tombseye 9974:Tombseye 9880:Tombseye 9669:possible 9648:Tombseye 9303:language 9241:Tombseye 9174:Khoikhoi 9060:Khoikhoi 9023:Khoikhoi 8877:Monastir 8726:monopoly 8522:WP:RULES 8476:specific 8357:genetics 8211:WP:RULES 8107:defines 7692:Monastir 7676:Antidote 7605:Antidote 7217:and the 7112:believes 7050:relevant 6820:Pecheneg 6748:New edit 6657:So what? 6647:Macrakis 6643:So what? 6636:Ancestry 6493:Mutation 6164:ancestry 6160:ancestry 6057:Macrakis 5933:Well? -- 5906:official 5895:official 5751:Slovenia 5726:) - see 5724:contribs 5643:Here is 5528:sponsors 4996:trolling 4541:Mine was 3950:User:REX 3889:User:REX 3795:I think 3764:contribs 3625:Uncle Ed 3310:Advanced 2115:"angel". 2042:ethnonym 1633:comments 1598:Uncle Ed 1170:contribs 1154:Brittany 851:Uncle Ed 841:identity 812:identity 763:Uncle Ed 550:Uncle Ed 521:Uncle Ed 445:at least 192:Uncle Ed 106:Untitled 13238:Latinus 13222:Latinus 13182:Latinus 13148:Latinus 13128:WP:CITE 13124:WP:NPOV 13104:Latinus 13070:Reefus2 13041:Zikicam 12987:Reefus2 12916:Zikicam 12672:Zikicam 12031:Zikicam 11919:of the 11769:English 11717:of the 11647:Bulgare 11177:resolve 11085:Syrians 11065:emblems 10906:Czechs. 10773:general 10598:or the 10578:obvious 10289:Romanus 10213:Dacians 10205:Macedon 10064:Romanus 10056:Dacians 9948:Romanus 9921:Romania 9563:Neutral 9545:Abstain 9393:Germans 9365:Support 9273:Support 9255:Support 9237:Support 9208:Support 9199:Support 9186:Support 9166:Germans 9015:Germans 8845:Florina 8730:mention 8710:ancient 8603:Florina 8554:Florina 8518:Florina 8447:uncivil 8342:Serbian 8331:Serbian 8219:WP:CITE 7841:Ottoman 7527:talk to 7475:talk to 7344:talk to 7339:changed 7248:Regards 7189:Abusive 7127:As for 6812:Bulgars 6600:WP:CITE 6346:from... 6228:WP:CITE 6013:Zikicam 5998:Zikicam 5980:Zikicam 5899:unknown 5813:Albania 5804:Germany 5795:Croatia 5760:Austria 5514:Rainbow 5397:sources 4257:WP:NPOV 3991:sources 3958:neither 3533:Macedon 3529:Olympia 3125:ha!!)-- 2801:180,180 1855:in the 1849:general 1485:On the 1435:nothing 1013:'s and 863:respect 608:origin. 39:archive 13331:Miskin 13317:Jkelly 13296:Miskin 13283:Miskin 13264:Miskin 13211:pg 58 13132:Jkelly 12979:Scots. 12817:JSimin 12743:JSimin 12009:→ Talk 11925:Miskin 11866:Miskin 11781:Miskin 11723:Miskin 11679:Miskin 11441:Miskin 11406:Its a 11378:Miskin 11364:-: --> 11359:-: --> 11339:Miskin 11319:Athens 11298:Miskin 11249:Miskin 11236:WP:NOR 11137:Azeris 11030:Miskin 11025:racial 10999:Slavic 10990:Alaric 10895:Miskin 10827:Miskin 10717:Vlachs 10704:Miskin 10653:Miskin 10647:Greeks 10617:Kalash 10605:Miskin 10318:; see 10312:Italic 10302:Italic 10293:Romioi 10281:Italic 10273:Danube 10161:Miskin 10117:ChrisO 10076:Italic 10072:Dacian 10039:Romans 10034:Italic 10024:Tomby: 10008:Kalash 9998:Miskin 9993:Italic 9988:Romans 9907:, and 9901:Romans 9587:Izehar 9523:here. 9509:Oppose 9490:Oppose 9478:Oppose 9464:Jkelly 9456:Oppose 9442:ChrisO 9438:Oppose 9424:Miskin 9416:Oppose 9387:Oppose 9378:Oppose 9190:Oppose 9132:. Ok, 9085:People 8952:Izehar 8924:Miskin 8895:Miskin 8885:Miskin 8881:Bitola 8811:Miskin 8801:Miskin 8778:above) 8723:unfair 8642:Miskin 8582:Miskin 8530:Miskin 8526:WP:POV 8493:names. 8486:Also: 8466:Izehar 8402:Miskin 8349:Miskin 8306:Miskin 8271:Miskin 8249:Miskin 8138:Miskin 8095:Miskin 8053:Miskin 8033:Miskin 7939:Miskin 7930:Skopje 7793:Miskin 7788:always 7775:Miskin 7701:Miskin 7664:Miskin 7651:Malaka 7647:Ellada 7635:Miskin 7559:Miskin 7549:Slavic 7531:+MATIA 7509:Slavic 7479:+MATIA 7472:Cool. 7464:ChrisO 7408:Miskin 7387:Izehar 7348:+MATIA 7295:Izehar 7280:Izehar 7252:malaka 7236:Miskin 7197:Izehar 7151:+MATIA 7069:so. -- 7018:Miskin 6996:+MATIA 6987:+MATIA 6973:Jkelly 6960:Miskin 6944:Miskin 6930:Miskin 6908:Miskin 6879:+MATIA 6862:purity 6840:+MATIA 6816:Kumans 6736:Izehar 6612:Jkelly 6608:WP:NOR 6568:Levant 6531:ChrisO 6517:Miskin 6502:Izehar 6452:Izehar 6401:Izehar 6385:+MATIA 6369:Izehar 6307:Izehar 6264:Jkelly 6254:, and 6208:Izehar 6191:Izehar 6188:only. 6144:Izehar 6113:Izehar 6067:Jkelly 5858:France 5778:Canada 5732:+MATIA 5675:+MATIA 5477:Greeks 5075:+MATIA 4962:ChrisO 4827:+MATIA 4760:ChrisO 4733:ChrisO 4722:ChrisO 4714:month. 4587:ChrisO 4478:+MATIA 4417:+MATIA 4377:Miskin 4355:Miskin 4315:+MATIA 4307:ChrisO 4271:ChrisO 4189:Also, 4107:+MATIA 4031:+MATIA 3902:indeed 3636:+MATIA 3541:Pomaks 3499:Greeks 3485:ChrisO 3444:+MATIA 3312:, HA! 3219:Greeks 3056:Greece 3052:Slavic 2977:nation 2830:+MATIA 2774:Miskin 2668:Miskin 2661:edits. 2607:+MATIA 2562:+MATIA 2524:Balkan 2469:Slavic 2447:+MATIA 2443:Slavic 2437:Go to 2362:, and 2321:Maniot 1977:+MATIA 1821:+MATIA 1819:Also, 1794:WP:NOR 1764:+MATIA 1705:+MATIA 1689:+MATIA 1652:+MATIA 1353:Balkan 1341:5) ]. 1200:thinks 1191:Greek. 1158:France 882:anyone 266:years. 203:about. 13169:Aldux 13031:Cigor 12965:Aldux 12935:below 12754:Cigor 12105:Aldux 12087:Cigor 12057:Aldux 11943:Bomac 11752:Bomac 11744:Greek 11703:never 11690:Bomac 11675:Slavs 11273:, or 11259:Bomac 10355:son. 10316:Roman 10277:Dacia 10217:Dacia 10068:Roman 10030:Roman 9952:Roman 9945:Latin 9931:(see 9917:Roman 9637:Bomac 9620:Greek 9482:Aldux 9310:calls 9299:calls 9259:Bomac 9184:Add * 9041:other 9037:WP:RM 8937:Bomac 8906:Bomac 8873:FYROM 8304:tag. 8285:Aldux 8129:Zocky 8123:that 7957:Aldux 7805:Bomac 7500:Bomac 7453:Bomac 7440:Bomac 7425:Bomac 7365:Bomac 7330:Bomac 7313:Bomac 7260:Bomac 7223:Bomac 7116:claim 7105:that 7086:Aldux 7067:claim 7046:claim 7042:claim 6904:Nazis 6682:their 6670:Their 6547:Malta 6418:mtDNA 6344:genes 6334:Sigh, 6297:Genes 6240:genes 6182:genes 6098:Bomac 6027:Aldux 5873:Serbs 5465:Bomac 5461:Space 4919:Simos 4758:. -- 4601:G-Man 4576:G-Man 4521:is a 4383:MATIA 4359:MATIA 3964:is a 3885:WP:RM 3733:WP:RM 3278:Bomac 3146:Bomac 3054:" in 2853:that. 2611:Bomac 2549:Bomac 2482:other 2080:a can 1954:Bomac 1798:WP:RC 1594:MATIA 1530:Matia 1525:halva 1512:Ματιά 1495:MATIA 1479:MATIA 1370:Bomac 1338:4) . 1335:3) . 1315:1) . 1275:Cigor 1229:Bomac 1198:Foss 1187:them. 1115:Tito. 1047:VMORO 953:them? 816:FYROM 337:clear 172:title 16:< 13236:. -- 12938:)." 11613:1846 11606:..." 11532:and 11408:book 11099:and 11003:Arab 10994:Rome 10933:and 10817:and 10778:NPOV 10619:and 10582:Livy 10492:want 10394:Tomb 10207:and 10043:Rome 9939:and 9631:and 9500:talk 9395:and 9221:. -- 9188:or * 9168:and 9017:and 8561:and 8524:and 8513:some 8376:some 8363:this 8318:Rome 8299:NPOV 8215:WP:V 8161:1913 8079:WP:V 8029:real 7708:HA! 7391:talk 7299:talk 7284:talk 7201:talk 7103:fact 7063:fact 7059:link 7054:NPOV 6868:. -- 6732:gene 6701:..." 6606:and 6604:WP:V 6507:talk 6457:talk 6433:gene 6406:talk 6374:talk 6312:talk 6226:Per 6213:talk 6196:talk 6149:talk 6118:talk 5950:past 5904:The 5893:The 5728:here 5718:talk 5435:link 5352:link 5245:talk 5142:talk 5066:and 5058:and 4932:too. 4644:. -- 4361:and 4311:this 4238:Ed's 4120:Lie! 3987:WP:V 3900:was 3760:talk 3557:link 3497:and 3345:Mik2 3274:fact 3183:Mik2 3127:Mik2 3081:Mik2 3036:Mik2 2981:Mik2 2898:Mik2 2847:Mik2 2813:Mik2 2811:].-- 2492:it. 2315:and 2217:(ie 1973:this 1907:and 1889:here 1786:WP:V 1631:the 1629:Alll 1414:coup 1166:talk 1009:'s, 933:etc? 806:and 804:Tito 745:type 722:diff 129:and 11904:not 11855:and 11849:to 11709:of 11437:one 11110:). 11103:. ( 10965:Hui 10938:). 10879:all 10752:(?) 10538:le 10322:). 9935:), 9927:or 9664:any 9519:or 9511:--- 9462:. 9348:Rex 9215:not 9083:to 8966:all 8871:to 8863:to 8415:dab 8380:dab 8372:all 8111:as 7953:not 7770:one 7766:all 7637:to 7185:3RR 7048:is 6710:): 6610:. 6555:DNA 6338:PCR 5482:Rex 5403:Rex 5300:Rex 5290:... 5259:or 5212:Rex 5114:Rex 5039:Rex 5001:Rex 4896:Rex 4845:Rex 4514:did 4493:Rex 4459:Rex 4402:Rex 4387:RFC 4305:To 4284:REX 4223:Rex 4209:Rex 4195:Rex 4177:Rex 4144:non 4125:Rex 4091:Rex 4007:Rex 3974:not 3936:Rex 3737:Rex 3735:). 3714:Rex 3710:you 3692:Rex 3527:at 3400:Rex 3316:Rex 3254:not 3230:Rex 3064:Rex 2973:All 2784:Rex 2760:Rex 2718:Rex 2623:Rex 2490:own 2423:Rex 2380:dab 2298:Rex 2288:Rex 2231:Rex 2186:], 2184:], 2147:Rex 1995:Not 1913:Rex 1802:Rex 1750:Rex 1730:Rex 1668:Rex 1646:or 1602:Rex 1540:Rex 1489:on 1470:REX 1461:REX 1443:REX 1156:in 835:or 777:it. 726:REX 13244:) 13188:) 13180:-- 13154:) 13110:) 13054:-- 11890:-- 11799:." 11677:. 11657:-- 11540:, 11372:~ 11368:, 11186:// 11112:// 11095:, 11091:, 11087:, 11083:, 11079:, 11075:: 10940:// 10908:-- 10547:. 10447:. 10066:(= 10054:, 10050:, 9950:, 9793:-- 9567:// 9538:: 9492:- 9380:: 9367:. 9346:. 9282:. 9201:: 9160:, 9156:, 9152:, 9148:, 9144:, 9140:, 9136:, 9128:→ 9108:. 9087:. 9009:, 9005:, 9001:, 8997:, 8993:, 8989:, 8985:, 8759:, 8747:, 8612:." 8482:: 8302:}} 8296:{{ 8217:, 8213:, 8093:. 7969:, 7641:: 7618:-- 7613:: 7393:) 7385:. 7328:. 7301:) 7286:) 7203:) 6985:. 6818:, 6814:, 6795:-- 6697:, 6693:, 6689:, 6645:-- 6602:, 6509:) 6485:is 6459:) 6408:) 6376:) 6314:) 6250:, 6246:, 6215:) 6198:) 6180:- 6151:) 6120:) 5867:-- 5782:]) 5673:. 5561:. 5437:. 5382:, 5208:. 5070:). 4864:. 4543:. 4357:, 4353:, 4295:. 4292:, 4289:, 3972:, 3952:. 3891:: 3766:) 3762:• 3543:. 3442:. 3394:μη 3276:. 3269:EU 2828:. 2445:. 2358:, 2188:]. 2026:, 1975:. 1911:. 1899:, 1895:, 1796:, 1792:, 1788:, 1642:. 1625:no 1501:: 1493:, 1459:. 1441:. 1420:, 1416:: 1172:) 1168:• 843:? 818:? 644:-- 125:, 121:, 117:, 94:→ 64:← 13240:( 13184:( 13150:( 13106:( 13094:. 11653:. 11633:” 11624:“ 11512:" 11010:" 10985:" 10981:" 10927:( 10223:/ 8795:" 8638:" 8632:. 8423:) 8421:ᛏ 8419:( 8388:) 8386:ᛏ 8384:( 8263:. 8257:" 8221:. 8181:" 8170:" 8167:. 8116:. 7825:- 7389:( 7318:. 7297:( 7282:( 7199:( 7155:☎ 7000:☎ 6991:☎ 6955:" 6883:☎ 6844:☎ 6505:( 6455:( 6404:( 6389:☎ 6372:( 6310:( 6211:( 6194:( 6147:( 6116:( 5863:) 5854:) 5845:) 5836:) 5827:) 5818:) 5809:) 5800:) 5791:) 5774:) 5765:) 5756:) 5736:☎ 5721:· 5716:( 5679:☎ 5243:( 5140:( 5079:☎ 5062:( 4998:? 4831:☎ 4482:☎ 4421:☎ 4319:☎ 4111:☎ 4035:☎ 3997:( 3758:( 3640:☎ 3448:☎ 3252:( 2834:☎ 2566:☎ 2451:☎ 1981:☎ 1768:☎ 1693:☎ 1656:☎ 1584:( 1164:( 133:. 50:.

Index

Talk:Macedonians (ethnic group)
archive
current talk page
Archive 1
Archive 4
Archive 5
Archive 6
Archive 7
Archive 8
Archive 10
Archive 1
Archive 2
Archive 3
Archive 4
Archive 5
Talk:Macedonian Slavs/Poll
Archive 2
title
Uncle Ed
17:27, 26 October 2005 (UTC)
Macedonian
03:44, 27 October 2005 (UTC)
Macedonians (ethnic group)
Macedonian

Macedonian

Macedonian

Macedonian

Text is available under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License. Additional terms may apply.