27:
884:
273:
237:. Such arguments can be refuted by showing that the disjunctive premise — the "horns of the dilemma" — does not in fact hold, because it presents a false dichotomy. You are asked to accept "A or B", but counter by showing that is not all. Successfully undermining that premise is called "escaping through the horns of the dilemma".
363:
144:
A dilemma is often phrased as "you must accept either A, or B", where A and B are propositions each leading to some further conclusion. In the case where this is true, it can be called a "dichotomy", but when it is not true, the dilemma constitutes a
583:, Rhetorica: A Journal of the History of Rhetoric Vol. 28, No. 4 (Autumn 2010), pp. 363–383, at p. 364. Published by: University of California Press on behalf of the International Society for the History of Rhetoric. DOI: 10.1525/rh.2010.28.4.363
856:, Oxford University Press, p. 15, 72. See also Michael Bohlander, ‘Of Shipwrecked Sailors, Unborn Children, Conjoined Twins and Hijacked Airplanes—Taking Human Life and the Defence of Necessity’ (2006) 70 The Journal of Criminal Law 147.
355:, whether a government official could intentionally kill innocent civilians by shooting down a hijacked airplane that would otherwise have crashed into a football stadium, killing tens of thousands.
320:, as did casuistry itself. Another approach, with legal roots, is to lay emphasis on particular features present in a given case: in other words, the exact framing of the dilemma.
866:
853:
332:, to describe a situation where a legal subject is confronted with two or more legal norms that the legal subject cannot simultaneously comply with.
839:
Leibniz, Gottfried
Wilhelm, "Inaugural Dissertation on Perplexing Cases in the Law" in Alberto Artosi, Bernardo Pieri, and Giovanni Sartor (eds.),
298:
appear to be inconsistent, an actor confronts a dilemma in terms of which principle to follow. This kind of moral case study is attributed to
253:
philosopher whose works survive in fragmentary form, making the origins of the technique in philosophy imponderable. It was established with
34:
in a dilemma: If he climbs to escape the guard dog he will face the man's wrath, but if he drops to avoid the man, the dog will attack him.
335:
Examples include contradictory contracts where one clause directly negates another clause, or conflicts between fundamental (e.g.
50:
71:
offering two possibilities, neither of which is unambiguously acceptable or preferable. The possibilities are termed the
313:
665:
811:
757:
692:
611:
564:
510:
485:
460:
435:
367:
347:(Perplexing Cases) is an early study of contradictory legal conditions. In domestic law, it has been argued that the
418:
114:. He also concluded that Valla had reintroduced to the Latin West a type of argument that had fallen into disuse.
784:
638:
366:. It was faced with the question whether, in an extreme circumstance of self-defence, it is a state's right to
359:
603:
Logic and Its
Applications: 7th Indian Conference, ICLA 2017, Kanpur, India, January 5-7, 2017, Proceedings
348:
914:
229:, which are in themselves valid rather than fallacious. They each have three premises, and include the
888:
340:
351:
confronted a legal dilemma when determining, in connection with proceedings relating to the German
20:
828:
Valentin
Jeutner: Irresolvable Norm Conflicts in International Law: The Concept of a Legal Dilemma
533:
423:
31:
556:
43:
774:
655:
628:
601:
427:
801:
747:
682:
352:
79:
usage, but distinguishing the dilemma from other kinds of predicament as a matter of usage.
230:
190:
8:
234:
218:
111:
588:
527:
329:
909:
584:
549:
336:
226:
92:
919:
904:
807:
780:
753:
709:
688:
661:
634:
607:
560:
506:
481:
456:
431:
328:
In law, Valentin
Jeutner has argued that the term "legal dilemma" could be used as a
276:
246:
186:
121:
did not immediately take hold, preference being given to the established Latin term
413:
295:
289:
254:
206:
146:
134:
68:
867:
Irresolvable Norm
Conflicts in International Law: The Concept of a Legal Dilemma
854:
Irresolvable Norm
Conflicts in International Law: The Concept of a Legal Dilemma
728:
371:
166:
153:. Traditional usage distinguished the dilemma as a "horned syllogism" from the
99:
in the 15th century, in later versions of his logic text traditionally called
26:
898:
96:
64:
389:
258:
198:
110:. Nuchelmans argued that his probable source was a logic text of c.1433 of
503:
Dilemmatic arguments : towards a history of their logic and rhetoric
478:
Dilemmatic arguments : towards a history of their logic and rhetoric
453:
Dilemmatic arguments : towards a history of their logic and rhetoric
304:
250:
133:
applied to the upsetting of dilemmatic reasoning. With the support of
309:
262:
118:
56:
103:. Valla claimed that it was the appropriate Latin equivalent of the
76:
383:
16:
Problem requiring a choice between equally undesirable alternatives
154:
150:
279:
of sounding (or not sounding) an alarm for a possible earthquake
272:
883:
317:
299:
126:
104:
312:, an approach to abstract ranking of principles introduced by
283:
266:
265:
in dilemma form, but that may have been to conform with what
830:, 28 (2017) European Journal of International Law 1415-1428.
189:. Its isolation as textbook material has been attributed to
316:
in the 16th century became tainted with the accusation of
800:
Jonsen, Albert R.; Toulmin, Stephen
Edelston (1988).
746:
Jonsen, Albert R.; Toulmin, Stephen
Edelston (1988).
358:
In international law, it has been suggested that the
803:
The Abuse of
Casuistry: A History of Moral Reasoning
749:
The Abuse of
Casuistry: A History of Moral Reasoning
394:
Pages displaying wikidata descriptions as a fallback
141:was widely applied by the end of the 16th century.
548:
896:
841:Leibniz: Logico-Philosophical Puzzles in the Law
735:. Metaphysics Research Lab, Stanford University.
716:. Metaphysics Research Lab, Stanford University.
806:. University of California Press. p. 54.
752:. University of California Press. p. 75.
370:or international law's general prohibition of
799:
745:
245:Dilemmatic reasoning has been attributed to
779:. Princeton University Press. p. 154.
599:
386: – Difficult choice from three options
687:. Cambridge University Press. p. 44.
500:
475:
450:
284:Moral dilemmas along with ethical dilemmas
532:. Moore, Wilstach & Baldwin. p.
680:
525:
271:
25:
733:The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
714:The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
600:Ghosh, Sujata; Prasad, Sanjiva (2016).
555:. University of Toronto Press. p.
546:
529:The Logic of Sir William Hamilton, Bart
362:confronted a legal dilemma in its 1996
180:
897:
772:
726:
707:
653:
626:
581:Rhetorical use of dilemmatic arguments
412:
869:, Oxford University Press, p. 10-11.
257:(died c. 284 BCE). The paradoxes of
185:The dilemma is sometimes used as a
13:
630:Introduction to Mathematical Logic
173:, translating from the Latin term
165:in English has been attributed to
14:
931:
876:
505:. North-Holland. pp. 102–6.
882:
606:. Springer. p. 177 note 5.
364:Nuclear Weapons Advisory Opinion
308:. In the Christian tradition of
240:
859:
846:
833:
820:
793:
766:
739:
720:
701:
674:
647:
161:. The original use of the word
633:. Princeton University Press.
620:
593:
573:
540:
526:Hamilton, Sir William (1863).
519:
494:
469:
444:
419:Garner’s Modern American Usage
406:
360:International Court of Justice
157:that attracted the Latin name
82:
1:
657:A Practical Study of Argument
480:. North-Holland. p. 94.
455:. North-Holland. p. 89.
399:
547:Erasmus, Desiderius (2003).
501:Nuchelmans, Gabriel (1991).
476:Nuchelmans, Gabriel (1991).
451:Nuchelmans, Gabriel (1991).
7:
773:Peters, Francis E. (2003).
684:Melissus and Eleatic Monism
681:Harriman, Benjamin (2018).
377:
374:that should take priority.
349:German Constitutional Court
343:1666 doctoral dissertation
212:
205:as any argument relying on
10:
936:
865:Jeutner, Valentin (2017),
852:Jeutner, Valentin (2017),
579:Lucia Calboli Montefusco,
287:
49:
18:
776:The words and will of God
323:
269:said about Zeno's style.
225:is applied to a group of
589:10.1525/rh.2010.28.4.363
551:Paraphrase on Luke 11-24
21:Dilemma (disambiguation)
627:Church, Alonzo (1996).
424:Oxford University Press
392: – English proverb
32:William Ewart Gladstone
826:Birkenkötter, Hannah,
708:Sedley, David (2018).
654:Govier, Trudy (2009).
280:
35:
727:Palmer, John (2017).
353:Aviation Security Act
302:, in book III of his
275:
201:gave a definition of
149:, which is a logical
29:
891:at Wikimedia Commons
660:. Cengage Learning.
345:De casibus perplexis
231:constructive dilemma
191:Hermogenes of Tarsus
181:Dilemmatic arguments
175:cornuta interrogatio
19:For other uses, see
314:Bartolomé de Medina
294:In cases where two
235:destructive dilemma
219:propositional logic
203:dilemmatic argument
112:George of Trebizond
281:
227:rules of inference
93:Gabriel Nuchelmans
75:of the dilemma, a
36:
915:Concepts in logic
887:Media related to
710:"Diodorus Cronus"
277:Contingency table
261:were reported by
247:Melissus of Samos
187:rhetorical device
169:in his 1548 book
91:is attributed by
927:
886:
870:
863:
857:
850:
844:
843:(Springer 2013).
837:
831:
824:
818:
817:
797:
791:
790:
770:
764:
763:
743:
737:
736:
724:
718:
717:
705:
699:
698:
678:
672:
671:
651:
645:
644:
624:
618:
617:
597:
591:
577:
571:
570:
554:
544:
538:
537:
523:
517:
516:
498:
492:
491:
473:
467:
466:
448:
442:
441:
410:
395:
296:moral principles
60:
53:
30:Cartoon showing
935:
934:
930:
929:
928:
926:
925:
924:
895:
894:
879:
874:
873:
864:
860:
851:
847:
838:
834:
825:
821:
814:
798:
794:
787:
771:
767:
760:
744:
740:
725:
721:
706:
702:
695:
679:
675:
668:
652:
648:
641:
625:
621:
614:
598:
594:
578:
574:
567:
545:
541:
524:
520:
513:
499:
495:
488:
474:
470:
463:
449:
445:
438:
411:
407:
402:
393:
380:
372:nuclear weapons
339:) legal norms.
326:
292:
290:ethical dilemma
286:
255:Diodorus Cronus
243:
215:
207:excluded middle
183:
147:false dichotomy
135:Juan Luis Vives
85:
24:
17:
12:
11:
5:
933:
923:
922:
917:
912:
907:
893:
892:
878:
877:External links
875:
872:
871:
858:
845:
832:
819:
812:
792:
785:
765:
758:
738:
729:"Zeno of Elea"
719:
700:
693:
673:
667:978-0495603405
666:
646:
639:
619:
612:
592:
572:
565:
539:
518:
511:
493:
486:
468:
461:
443:
436:
404:
403:
401:
398:
397:
396:
387:
379:
376:
337:constitutional
325:
322:
288:Main article:
285:
282:
242:
239:
214:
211:
182:
179:
167:Nicholas Udall
84:
81:
63: 'double
15:
9:
6:
4:
3:
2:
932:
921:
918:
916:
913:
911:
908:
906:
903:
902:
900:
890:
885:
881:
880:
868:
862:
855:
849:
842:
836:
829:
823:
815:
813:9780520060630
809:
805:
804:
796:
788:
782:
778:
777:
769:
761:
759:9780520060630
755:
751:
750:
742:
734:
730:
723:
715:
711:
704:
696:
694:9781108416337
690:
686:
685:
677:
669:
663:
659:
658:
650:
642:
636:
632:
631:
623:
615:
613:9783662540695
609:
605:
604:
596:
590:
586:
582:
576:
568:
566:9780802036537
562:
558:
553:
552:
543:
535:
531:
530:
522:
514:
512:0-444-85730-3
508:
504:
497:
489:
487:0-444-85730-3
483:
479:
472:
464:
462:0-444-85730-3
458:
454:
447:
439:
437:9780199888771
433:
429:
425:
421:
420:
415:
414:Garner, Bryan
409:
405:
391:
388:
385:
382:
381:
375:
373:
369:
365:
361:
356:
354:
350:
346:
342:
338:
333:
331:
321:
319:
315:
311:
307:
306:
301:
297:
291:
278:
274:
270:
268:
264:
260:
256:
252:
248:
241:In philosophy
238:
236:
232:
228:
224:
220:
210:
208:
204:
200:
196:
192:
188:
178:
176:
172:
168:
164:
160:
156:
152:
148:
142:
140:
136:
132:
128:
124:
120:
115:
113:
109:
106:
102:
98:
97:Lorenzo Valla
94:
90:
80:
78:
74:
70:
66:
62:
59:
52:
48:
45:
44:Ancient Greek
41:
33:
28:
22:
861:
848:
840:
835:
827:
822:
802:
795:
775:
768:
748:
741:
732:
722:
713:
703:
683:
676:
656:
649:
629:
622:
602:
595:
580:
575:
550:
542:
528:
521:
502:
496:
477:
471:
452:
446:
417:
408:
390:At Dulcarnon
368:self-defence
357:
344:
334:
327:
303:
293:
259:Zeno of Elea
244:
222:
216:
202:
199:C. S. Peirce
195:On Invention
194:
193:in his work
184:
174:
170:
162:
158:
143:
138:
130:
122:
116:
107:
100:
88:
86:
72:
57:
54:
47:
39:
37:
330:term-of-art
305:De Officiis
251:Presocratic
171:Paraphrases
137:, however,
83:Terminology
65:proposition
899:Categories
786:0691114617
640:0691029067
426:. p.
400:References
125:, used by
108:dilemmaton
101:Dialectica
42:(from
910:Arguments
341:Leibniz's
310:casuistry
263:Aristotle
131:conversio
123:complexio
119:neologism
87:The term
920:Rhetoric
905:Dilemmas
889:Dilemmas
416:(2009).
384:Trilemma
378:See also
213:In logic
159:cornutus
117:Valla's
67:') is a
223:dilemma
155:sophism
151:fallacy
139:dilemma
129:, with
89:dilemma
77:clichéd
69:problem
58:dílēmma
51:δίλημμα
40:dilemma
810:
783:
756:
691:
664:
637:
610:
587:
563:
509:
484:
459:
434:
324:In law
318:laxism
300:Cicero
127:Cicero
585:JSTOR
267:Plato
163:horns
105:Greek
73:horns
46:
808:ISBN
781:ISBN
754:ISBN
689:ISBN
662:ISBN
635:ISBN
608:ISBN
561:ISBN
507:ISBN
482:ISBN
457:ISBN
432:ISBN
249:, a
233:and
557:158
534:185
428:257
217:In
95:to
901::
731:.
712:.
559:.
430:.
422:.
221:,
209:.
197:.
177:.
38:A
816:.
789:.
762:.
697:.
670:.
643:.
616:.
569:.
536:.
515:.
490:.
465:.
440:.
61:)
55:(
23:.
Text is available under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License. Additional terms may apply.
.jpg)