193:
723:
245:
224:
172:
142:
649:
regarding the title colour of set-index articles, which are still being displayed in the same green colour as disambiguation pages. For those not familiar with the gadget, it can be enabled at
Preferences... Gadgets... Appearance... "Display an assessment of an article's quality in its page header".
511:
I would like to propose that if an article doesn't meet any of these criteria, it should be treated as a DAB. i.e. if the article would be a valid DAB page without any content changes, it's a DAB, not a SIA. By this standard, all three of the examples above would be DABs (whose entries all happen to
554:
type (perhaps the guidance should be clearer on this). A dab page doesn't/shouldn't specify a type so it wouldn't always be clearcut whether the entries are all "one type" or not - e.g. if a dab page has 2 entries, one an insect and one a mammal, are they "one type" because they are both animals?
523:
If we say that such articles should instead be classified as SIAs, the natural consequence of this would be that all disambiguation pages that happen to only list items of a common type would have to be recategorized as SIAs, which I think would be a disaster. See for example
335:. All are currently classified as dab pages, but since they all list things of the same type I'd say they meet the SIA criteria. I'm just a bit reluctant to make any changes though as I'm not convinced I'd be doing the right thing.
605:
They feature disagreement on the core question of "Is a DAB page where all the linked topics are of a common type actually a SIA?" (and feature many of the same editors as in this thread - small world!). Hike395 says yes:
394:). The main advantage is that any inlinks are more likely to be fixed (because of DPLbot, dabfixers etc). There's also then no need to convert it (back) to a dab if a book/film etc of that name is found.
734:
517:
693:
614:
is intending to refer to a specific hospital, not the set of hospitals that share that name - getting the benefit of bot warnings when linking to that name seems really important.
726:
715:
542:
Even if a dab page happens to (currently) have items that are all of one type it's still a dab page (any inlinks from article text should be fixed). By contrast, a SIA (e.g.
133:
469:
Yes, the difference can be nebulous, but importantly SIAs can have redlinks, extra information, references, etc, all of which are inappropriate on a disambiguation page.
713:
451:
is bringing up a long-running issue with SIAs. The distinction is clear, but some editors are concerned about the side-effects of SIAs. I tried to resolve these issues
588:
748:
598:
350:
I would say all three of these articles areSIAs -- they're all a list of articles about the same type of item (settlement, park, mountain) with the same name. —
525:
610:, DexDor says no, and others are just confused. I personally find DexDor's argument about avoiding mistargeted links very convincing. Any editor who links to
50:
528:. The vast majority of these thousands of pages meet the "only one type" criterion just by virtue of having a name like "X Tower", or "X Airport".
593:
478:
299:
561:
634:
537:
464:
377:
359:
426:
400:
759:
625:). I won't be surprised or upset if it gets reverted, I just thought I'd give it a shot before resorting to starting an RfC or whatever.
129:
646:
85:
543:
578:
823:
785:
289:
91:
818:
141:
828:
804:
681:
740:
730:
344:
17:
323:
I've been sorting through some articles and need a bit of guidance with regard to SIAs. Take these three for example:
265:
417:
Hmmm, then I'd suggest that the distinction is somewhat nebulous. Perhaps there needs to be a clearer guideline?
663:
31:
650:
I believe "List purple" might be a preferable colour as I'm not sure whether the Set-index lilac (per SIA at
80:
708:
789:
651:
204:
35:
608:
If something looks like a disambiguation page, but contains only plants, it is indeed a set index article
261:
257:
252:
229:
178:
71:
779:
124:
774:
669:
I agree to use the same colour as List-class, because that is what they are most similar to — Martin
694:
Knowledge talk:Content assessment#Pages rated as
Disambig-class which are not disambiguation pages
585:
I stumbled on a few discussions old discussions related to DAB vs. SIA which may be of interest:
503:
SIAs can have red links, or even list entries that are presumed non-notable (i.e. no link at all)
474:
744:
622:
611:
210:
109:
8:
618:
494:
318:
61:
156:
470:
391:
101:
76:
659:
630:
533:
460:
355:
57:
497:
makes the point that SIAs are not DABs because they differ in the following ways:
799:
769:
703:
676:
573:
422:
373:
340:
328:
152:
812:
687:
640:
655:
626:
621:
is clear on the answer to this question. I boldly added a line about this (
529:
456:
390:
Pages like those are better as dabs (there are thousands of such dabs e.g.
351:
589:
Template talk:Set index article/Archive 1 § Promotion and use in
Knowledge
599:
Knowledge talk:Disambiguation/Archive 42 § disambiguation vs. set indexes
557:
448:
396:
332:
157:
692:
Editors watching this page might be interested to join a discussion at
795:
765:
699:
672:
569:
418:
369:
336:
154:
244:
223:
792:
scheme. If anyone has an opinion, please comment there — Martin
452:
753:
654:) would be too pale to show up against a white background. --
324:
158:
500:
A SIA "is meant to provide information as well as navigation"
264:, where you can join the project and/or contribute to the
594:
Knowledge talk:Disambiguation/Archive 42 § Orange
Emperor
493:
I'd like to return to this question of DAB/SIA overlap.
526:
Category:Buildings and structures disambiguation pages
760:
Knowledge talk:Content assessment#Request for comment
368:
Cheers, helpful to know that I'm on the right track!
647:
MediaWiki talk:Gadget-metadata.js#Set-index articles
26:
788:to automatically assess SIAs as List-class on the
733:. You are invited to comment on the discussion at
617:One way or the other, I think it's important that
810:
566:I agree with this excellent suggestion — Martin
177:Threads older than 365 days may be archived by
786:Module talk:WikiProject banner#More page types
736:the entry on the Templates for discussion page
256:, an attempt to structure and organize all
544:List of buildings named Flatiron Building
516:wants to make a set index article called
203:does not require a rating on Knowledge's
260:. If you wish to help, please visit the
14:
811:
455:, but the discussion never took off. —
192:
190:
186:
166:
209:It is of interest to the following
34:for discussing improvements to the
24:
518:List of parks named Champions Park
25:
840:
250:This page is within the scope of
721:
243:
222:
191:
170:
140:
51:Click here to start a new topic.
13:
1:
824:High-importance List articles
805:09:02, 27 February 2024 (UTC)
749:04:52, 15 December 2023 (UTC)
727:Template:Double soft redirect
716:Template:Double soft redirect
635:22:21, 12 November 2019 (UTC)
48:Put new text under old text.
709:15:25, 6 December 2023 (UTC)
682:15:30, 6 December 2023 (UTC)
664:15:36, 16 January 2023 (UTC)
652:Category:Articles by quality
579:15:28, 6 December 2023 (UTC)
562:07:59, 6 November 2019 (UTC)
538:20:44, 5 November 2019 (UTC)
512:be of one type). If someone
294:This page has been rated as
7:
819:Project-Class List articles
775:18:06, 1 January 2024 (UTC)
714:Nomination for deletion of
479:19:33, 20 August 2019 (UTC)
465:12:55, 20 August 2019 (UTC)
427:20:07, 19 August 2019 (UTC)
401:16:04, 18 August 2019 (UTC)
378:14:06, 18 August 2019 (UTC)
360:01:06, 18 August 2019 (UTC)
345:00:43, 18 August 2019 (UTC)
274:Knowledge:WikiProject Lists
56:New to Knowledge? Welcome!
10:
845:
829:WikiProject Lists articles
645:I've raised a question at
300:project's importance scale
277:Template:WikiProject Lists
99:
293:
238:
217:
86:Be welcoming to newcomers
506:SIAs can have references
784:There is a proposal at
780:Auto assessment of SIAs
258:list pages on Knowledge
731:nominated for deletion
612:Western State Hospital
179:Lowercase sigmabot III
81:avoid personal attacks
520:, more power to them.
134:Auto-archiving period
790:content assessment
392:1st arrondissement
205:content assessment
92:dispute resolution
53:
36:Set index articles
18:Knowledge talk:SIA
803:
773:
707:
680:
577:
314:
313:
310:
309:
306:
305:
253:WikiProject Lists
185:
184:
165:
164:
72:Assume good faith
49:
16:(Redirected from
836:
793:
763:
725:
724:
697:
670:
567:
550:to items of one
282:
281:
278:
275:
272:
247:
240:
239:
234:
226:
219:
218:
196:
195:
194:
187:
174:
173:
167:
159:
145:
144:
135:
112:
27:
21:
844:
843:
839:
838:
837:
835:
834:
833:
809:
808:
782:
756:
722:
719:
690:
643:
321:
296:High-importance
279:
276:
273:
270:
269:
233:High‑importance
232:
171:
161:
160:
155:
132:
118:
117:
116:
115:
108:
104:
97:
67:
23:
22:
15:
12:
11:
5:
842:
832:
831:
826:
821:
781:
778:
755:
752:
718:
712:
689:
686:
685:
684:
642:
639:
638:
637:
615:
603:
602:
601:
596:
591:
583:
582:
581:
564:
521:
509:
508:
507:
504:
501:
490:
489:
488:
487:
486:
485:
484:
483:
482:
481:
467:
436:
435:
434:
433:
432:
431:
430:
429:
408:
407:
406:
405:
404:
403:
383:
382:
381:
380:
363:
362:
329:Champions Park
320:
317:
312:
311:
308:
307:
304:
303:
292:
286:
285:
283:
248:
236:
235:
227:
215:
214:
208:
197:
183:
182:
175:
163:
162:
153:
151:
150:
147:
146:
120:
119:
114:
113:
105:
100:
98:
96:
95:
88:
83:
74:
68:
66:
65:
54:
45:
44:
41:
40:
39:
9:
6:
4:
3:
2:
841:
830:
827:
825:
822:
820:
817:
816:
814:
807:
806:
801:
797:
791:
787:
777:
776:
771:
767:
761:
751:
750:
746:
742:
738:
737:
732:
728:
717:
711:
710:
705:
701:
695:
683:
678:
674:
668:
667:
666:
665:
661:
657:
653:
648:
636:
632:
628:
624:
620:
616:
613:
609:
604:
600:
597:
595:
592:
590:
587:
586:
584:
580:
575:
571:
565:
563:
560:
559:
553:
549:
545:
541:
540:
539:
535:
531:
527:
522:
519:
515:
510:
505:
502:
499:
498:
496:
492:
491:
480:
476:
472:
471:Shhhnotsoloud
468:
466:
462:
458:
454:
450:
446:
445:
444:
443:
442:
441:
440:
439:
438:
437:
428:
424:
420:
416:
415:
414:
413:
412:
411:
410:
409:
402:
399:
398:
393:
389:
388:
387:
386:
385:
384:
379:
375:
371:
367:
366:
365:
364:
361:
357:
353:
349:
348:
347:
346:
342:
338:
334:
330:
326:
316:
301:
297:
291:
288:
287:
284:
280:List articles
267:
263:
259:
255:
254:
249:
246:
242:
241:
237:
231:
228:
225:
221:
220:
216:
212:
206:
202:
198:
189:
188:
180:
176:
169:
168:
149:
148:
143:
139:
131:
128:
126:
122:
121:
111:
107:
106:
103:
93:
89:
87:
84:
82:
78:
75:
73:
70:
69:
63:
59:
58:Learn to edit
55:
52:
47:
46:
43:
42:
37:
33:
29:
28:
19:
783:
757:
741:65.92.247.90
735:
720:
691:
644:
619:WP:SIANOTDAB
607:
556:
551:
547:
513:
495:WP:SIANOTDAB
395:
322:
315:
295:
262:project page
251:
211:WikiProjects
201:project page
200:
137:
123:
30:This is the
758:Please see
333:Cheongoksan
319:SIA or Dab?
813:Categories
688:Discussion
641:Assessment
266:discussion
762:— Martin
729:has been
696:— Martin
552:specified
94:if needed
77:Be polite
32:talk page
447:I think
138:365Â days
125:Archives
102:Shortcut
62:get help
656:Jameboy
627:Colin M
548:limited
530:Colin M
457:hike395
352:hike395
298:on the
558:DexDor
449:DexDor
397:DexDor
325:Buk-gu
207:scale.
110:WT:SIA
739:. --
546:) is
453:above
271:Lists
230:Lists
199:This
90:Seek
38:page.
800:talk
796:MSGJ
770:talk
766:MSGJ
745:talk
704:talk
700:MSGJ
677:talk
673:MSGJ
660:talk
631:talk
623:diff
574:talk
570:MSGJ
534:talk
514:also
475:talk
461:talk
423:talk
419:PC78
374:talk
370:PC78
356:talk
341:talk
337:PC78
290:High
79:and
754:RfC
815::
798:·
768:·
747:)
702:·
675:·
662:)
633:)
572:·
536:)
477:)
463:)
425:)
376:)
358:)
343:)
331:,
327:,
136::
60:;
802:)
794:(
772:)
764:(
743:(
706:)
698:(
679:)
671:(
658:(
629:(
576:)
568:(
532:(
473:(
459:(
421:(
372:(
354:(
339:(
302:.
268:.
213::
181:.
130:1
127::
64:.
20:)
Text is available under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License. Additional terms may apply.
